- Email: [email protected]
The Relationship between Corporate Governance and Expropriation of Minority Shareholders’ Interests
Available online at www.sciencedirect.com
ScienceDirect Procedia Economics and Finance 35 (2016) 99 – 106
" - . '$
/ + 0 ) 1 " . " 2%
!" 3 " % 0 4 5 ) / & 6"" 7 - / " #%$ 8 191 - : ; + ! +%1 < = + ;" #
! " $ %
! "
!" $& & 5 " " % + 5 ) & "" 7 /& ) * + ) > " ) " /& 1 " $& $ $ &
"" & "" 7 %& + " & !" $ ) " $& " " $ $ " $ " $ + + & ' 1 & $++ " ) 0 2 0" % + " %& )) - " & 1 " $& ) + % $" % ? 0 27 0" 7 ) 5 - $ &1 & ) " $ ) " $& @ + " 1 "%& "& % ) % " ) & © 2016 The Authors. Published by Elsevier B.V. This is an open access article under the CC BY-NC-ND license !" #$" $% " %& '( (http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-nc-nd/4.0/). $ %& ) * ! + , Peer-reviewed under responsibility of Universiti Tenaga Nasional &"' (0 + A 5 A / & "" A ' "
2 " & 1 + " $" " - " ) "1 + ) 5 & 0
1 - " & 1 $ @ 1 )& "
9 0 + $" !B C D E A )5B C D E %) ( "F$ $ &
2212-5671 © 2016 The Authors. Published by Elsevier B.V. This is an open access article under the CC BY-NC-ND license (http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-nc-nd/4.0/).
Peer-reviewed under responsibility of Universiti Tenaga Nasional doi:10.1016/S2212-5671(16)00014-9
100
Masdiah Abdul Hamid et al. / Procedia Economics and Finance 35 (2016) 99 – 106
:0 " *6 " " $ 1 %$ ) "+"+" " ) + + & + $ @ & $ % @ 1 "" $ 5 )
"1 > G$ " . $? H )$" " ? " % +
& $ " ) $ + "" )$ "$+" I$ % 1 & " & "" 7 # + 8 D1 + " "
$$ "" ) " ) "" $ "$+" + ) " )) $" & " $ " ) " $ ) " @" # " 1 & $ $ + /& " % " ) + % " ) ) " @ - /& 1 " )) " + ) $% " % DD> - & DD1 " ) % $ % + & )$" " ? %& " /& 6$ 0
81 ) " 0 DD 1 $ " +% I$ "" " $ +$ )) + "" 7 !" /& 0 ) 0 4 /004 ) & $ /" 1 "" " ? "
%& ) $ ) 2 % ) "" 7 " $ + ++ %& " $ # + 3& . ! H1 ) + $ ) ) "+" ) " & " " + "" 5 % ) ) " & "" - " 1 $ +
" " + "" ) & & % ) %& + $% & & )
" & $ " $ $ 8 1 " "" ) " $% & $)) "
) " "$+" # " " $ % " + & + " " " $ ) +$ ) " & $$ ) $ $% &
" & ) ) ))$ "$+" & !" " ) " &
"" $ " $% & " $)) $ $ + " %$
1 " " % +& 5 + " " % 04 5 ) & ""7 "
$ #"$+" " $ I$ " /& 51 5
$ %$ & )) " & "" 7 !" & "" 1 " " " & " ) " &1 "$ " " " J&
"" 5 + " +" !" +" $ @ + ) 1 + @ +
# . 3" 1 D 81 "&
" +" 1 %$ "& % % 6@$ + . 6" $+ $ " " ) ) $ % " $$ ) $ /& %%& " "& "" @ + " 6"" " " " " $ $ " " & + " " %& " + !" " "$ ) + " $1 %& 5 + " ) I$& " /& 5 5 " " % + 5 ) & ""7 ' " % $
1 " "" + " ? 5 ) & "" 7 !" " %$ " + + %& ) @ + + ) 1 " $& +" " %$ " " % + " 5 ) & "" 7 6 1 "
$& ) ) " +$ + " $ +$ :" " $ ) " $&1 " +$ $ % % @ + " ) " $% 5 ) & "" 7 !" + ) " $& + ) 6 $ 6 > " "+& 6 E " ) + & 6 $ " 1 & )$$ $
Masdiah Abdul Hamid et al. / Procedia Economics and Finance 35 (2016) 99 – 106
101
+.+ 2 %3 "4!! 56 0 + " + ? )+$ " ) " "" 0 + "
$$ $ + " %$
)) ) " & " + %$
& $ %& " " $ %J ) ? + +
"" $1 " @ + $ " ) " " @" 0 1 DDD # + 0%$& 3 DD1 + " & %& "" !")1 + + " " & " " )$ " %$
& ) " & !" $ " " %$
& & $ " 5 " ? " %J ) " &1 "" " + %$
& $ %& '$
& % " " & + ) " $ %& % " " +" " 1 $" " % !" & " !"& " " & " "+ )+$ " ) " "" !"$ 1 + 5 $ " " ) " " ""1 " " %$ )$ ) " & $1 H !$ + + ) ) 5 !$ + ) ) ) $ ) ) "+" ) " & " " + ) ) "+" ) ) " & " % $ " + ) ) % @$ & 3& . ! 1 H 5 "
) $ + 7 5 ? ) %$ " ) & "" ) /$ ) 1 6 &1 & " ) 5 $ "" 7 "$+" ) + 3& + . !" 1 0"$ + 1 D )$ " & "" 0" $%& " $ & " " + "" $%J %" 5 "$+" $ + + ) + $ ) " - ) " $ +
" + ) &
) $ + $" 1 = . 6 + ) " " & $ + ) " $ @ + 5 + /1 '@ 1 D ) " 5 + ) & & 1 + ) & "+" +1
+ ) $ "
$ +$ " & ' 1 /$ . /" 6" D ) + ) & " ++ 5 + I$& ) & % - 1 0"$ + 1 ) " & "" 5 + ) $
" $ @ + +6 # !"$+" " ) " $ ) 5 %& " $ " 1 " 5 ) & "" +% 04
$ 8 1 " $& $ " 04 1 & % 1 $ 0 2 $& 5 " ) + " + & "" 7 6 + . ' )$ " % +& " 5 ) & "" 7 1 = # 5 0"$ + 1 " 5$ $ " + 5 $" 1 /$ ) 1 ) " ++ & $ )$ 5 ) & "" 7 +" /1 " $& )$ " " $ % ) 1 " $ ) " & $ %& " ) " " 0 " /$ ) )$ " % % & +7+ # 0 % @ " " )) " ) + "
102
Masdiah Abdul Hamid et al. / Procedia Economics and Finance 35 (2016) 99 – 106
!")1 $ " 04 " % & % ? " 7 0 27 ) 5 !" +$ " " "+" $ % ) % ) % + + $ & ) @ %
+ $ "$+" " @ + 2 " " " 1 % ))$ ) + "" 5 & "" 7 K) 1 )$ @ @ " ) " $ + @ + " $ 6 &1 #% "& 1 )$ + )
% $ + ) 5 " $ & + ) " $
# +&1 ) 5 ) 0" 0 2 ? " 5 ) & "" 7 " & $"1 $ " ) " "%& ) ) ?1 ) + $
32# & + )) 5 & "" 7 +8+*" ! # + 6 + . ' 1 "& ) " % " + " " 5 ) & "" 81 /$ ) 1 /$ ) ) % " " " & ' " ) +
" "&1 +$ " % ? 5 ) & "" " & !" %$ " %1 5$ ))$ " @ + " % !"$ 1 @ " 5$ ))$ 5 &
"" # + . L DH>1 "& 5$ % % + + % + & $ @ " $ + & % % + $ /1 "& $++ " " + "+" + ) $ " %7 ))
) + !" $& %& 0"$ + 1 1 )$ " $ " % " & + 5 ' " $
$ " "&1 +$ " 5 % " ) " $ " 5 ) & "" 7 !" %$ " " $ 1 " %$ " % !" @ 5$ + "" ))$ 5 & "" 0 2 $& ) " "" " ) " " 0 2 " %& !" " " %" ) " " 5
$ " ) !" ) + ) )) + + %&1 %$ $" + 1 ++ ) $& 5 1 )$$ $ & " ' " ) + + & "&1 +$ " " ) 0 2 $& 5 ) & "" " !" %$ "$ " "@ % 1 ))$ " " 0 2 $& !"$ 1 " 5 ) & "" 7 ' " % $
1 " "& " )B 8B !" $ % ) 5$ " % $ " 5 ) &
"" 7 8B !" $ % ) 5$ " $ $ " 5 ) & "" 7 8>B 0 2 $& $ " 5 ) & "" 7 7+.+4 !" $ " $& " $%& /& 1 $& " ) % @ ? 6 "& & " +" ) /& 1 @ + "" " & "" 7 " + 81 " ) $ ) & > !" ) A
Masdiah Abdul Hamid et al. / Procedia Economics and Finance 35 (2016) 99 – 106
103
#"$+" " $ $ " $& % ) " '$ /& % 1 "" %1 $ % 5 I$ ) ) " 7 $ " ) D % K $
+ & "" 7 /& 1 /6:4 "$ % " )$ ! 5 " $ % ) /6:4 + " $&1 " )$& " % ) " /6:4 % K$ " )) $ ) %$
)) +$& + 1 ) " % @ + $ $ !")1 " D ) & % ) " & $ 7+ +9# !" % $ 5 ) & "" 7 /6-1 "" 5 %& " $ ) 8) " 5 $ + " "" + 8- " & 3! !" ) $ " ) & " " %& " > "" " " ) ) & " & " $ + /$ )1 1 " " " $ ) & $ %&
& < 1 1 . M$ +1 !" "+" " $ ) " /6- 1 " "+" " 5 ) & "" 7 $ % # $
1 5 " ) + + &
"" 7 0 + " 1 $& " " % 1 @ $ " + % " $&1 + "" $ % '2-,1 $ #0-,1 0 2 $& 0K*# '2-, $ " ) $ % ) /$ )1 1 " #0-, $ " ) " $ #% "&1 8 1 ; +1 . ; " 1 > !" " %1 0K*#1 $ & % " I$ ) " 0 2 " 0" " %& )) 1 ? " ; . ," 1 > ' % + ) )) ) 7 " 1 $ " 5 ) + " B % ? '6-G 0" 7 0 27 ) 5 00 '6-G $ " $ +" ) ; . ," 1 >1 " 00 $ & % " I$ ) " 0" " 0 2 ) 5 K 1 8 1 . 8$1 # ) ) " % 1 @ ) ? 6-G " $ +" )
A ) + = ( " ) %
A $
32# " ) + %) 5
7+7+: ! $ "& " 1 & " ) + +
/6- 1 NO CO '2-, 1 CO 0-, 1 CO > K*# 1 CO E '6-G 1 CO 00 1
CO 6-G CO = ( CO 32# CP
:"A ; " ) / / 1 & 1 " $
1
1
H
1
8+.+ 4 !% " ) " % $ " $& !" $ " " "
" + E ) % !" + ) " $ $" "+" " " % 1 ) "" " "
104
Masdiah Abdul Hamid et al. / Procedia Economics and Finance 35 (2016) 99 – 106
I$ /& 2 ) " ) " /& 0 0 4 " Q" % $ J& ) " " " ) " % R # H ) " " & ) " ) 0 2 0" !" $ % ) " % %$ D " $ ++ # " + ) + " > ) " 0 2 0" " $&
) 5 3+ + ) " 1 ) " "
) " %$ /M3 % 1 " 5 & E % 2 +1 " @ + ) ) %$ $ "
!% K 6 ) - (%
/
6 K
/ $
'2-, #0-, '6-G 6-G = ( 32#
EH D H ED E E I$ &
D E D
0K*# 00
/
/5 $
ED H H >>> D H >H H EED D +
H H
> >H
HE >
E >
8+ + " !% " & + " % $ " $& 2) " " + % 1 & ) + & + ) )) /6- +& + ) & " #0-,1 %$ '2-, 0K*# /6- + ) & " " % 81 " $ ) " "$ % "$+")$& )) ) ) " !% 0 0))
/6- '2-, '2-, E #0-, HH9 99 EH99 0K*# '6-G > 999 00 H E 6-G E> DD999 = ( H > 32#
#0-, 99 >D E E
0K*#
'6-G
99 999 9 H D
00
D999 D 99
6-G
E >9 D
= (
>999 ED 999
>
2" )) )$ % " !" "+" $ " % 32# 6-G ) ED ! $ " $ & % 1 "@ ) ) (- 0 &1 " $ ) " (- " # $"1 $ & %
$ ) " +
& ) " $& 8+7+: " !" $ ) " %$ I$ !% > : J$ ) 8$% !& - . 1 $ + %$ '2-, & 5 ) & "" 7 1 %$ " $ " " + ) ; N 1 $ N 81 ) " #0-, ; N E1 $ N >> 0K*# ;> N > 1 $ N + ) & +& /6- !" $ " " ) & " $
Masdiah Abdul Hamid et al. / Procedia Economics and Finance 35 (2016) 99 – 106
105
" )$ + ) + " % " $&1 " "+" " $ % ) " $ 1 " " ) 5 ) &
"" 7 $ % # ) 0K*#1 % " "$ " " 0 2 0" % + " %& )) %$ " & $ " $ ) 5 ) & "" 7 # " + %
+ ) :" '6-G )$ % + ;E N >1 $ N D1 " )) ) 00 ; N 1 $ N > - " 1 & & % + " 0 2 0" " ) 5 "& @ " $ + 21 " $ $ " + " + + & "" 7 !% > 3%$ = 6I$ 3 $ 2 3 $ (% 0)) $ - H>99 '2-, #0-, E99 >> 0K*# > 999 '6-G >9 D 00 9 > 6-G > = ( >99 >E 32# EE99 D #J$ 3 3 I$ >D 999 , B 91 991 999 + ) " S1 S1 S 1 &
! " !" " " % + 5 ) &
"" 7 ) " /& $% % @ ? ) " ) D !" ) + ) " + " + ) & + + &
"" 7 @ ? ) /& $% !" $
$++ " " "+" " $ % ) " $ $ " ) 5 ) & "" 7 /1 " $ " $ " $ + ) 5 ) & "" 7 !" " ) ) 1 " $& +" " %$ " " % + " 5 ) & "" 7 6 1 " $& ) ) " +$ + " $ +$ :" " $ ) " $&1 " +$ $ % % @ + " ) " 5 ) & "" 7 81 $& $ + " + " + ) ) " $ ) !" $& " " " & @ " @ ) + "$ ) ) + +% # ) " 1 & ) + 5 % $ " $& !")1 $ $ " "
%& " $ $ +" % )$ %& % 8 1 + ? ) " ) + ) " " /& % $$ $ & 5 + + % "" $ @ " $ + 3 ) " $& " )) $" + @ + @ 1 )
)
$ % " )$)$ &1 )$"
$ %& $ + $ )) ) %
106
Masdiah Abdul Hamid et al. / Procedia Economics and Finance 35 (2016) 99 – 106
# #% "&1 L =1 8 1 K1 ; +1 !1 ; " 1 4 ( > #$ ) 5 ) & + ) # #$ +1 D1 B " B5+ J # 1 31 3" 1 3 # D !" ) & "" "+ +$ " ) ) + ) /& # # & ) / + L$ ) #$ + 1 1 D '@ 1 81 01 3 #1 $1 = L D 5 "$+" +$ B ) 0" L$ ) ' @ + . 1 >>1 E 0%$& 3 DD " B++ $ %$& ) 0"$ +1 M ;1 L +1 =1 =$1 !1 3$1 31 6$ 1 # D !$ + + $ B & ) & %& 0" ) ' L$ 1 1 > >D> 0"$ +1 M =1 3$1 31 6$ 1 # !$ +1 +1 5 B ) & 8 + ; + L$ ) 1 H1 >E> >H 0
1 61 KJ @1 61 1 L 1 = +1 = 8 K + + " " )) ) + "" + !" L$ ) 1 1 E K 1 / =1 8 1 3 ,1 8$1 T K " @ $ ) 5 $ ) % ) U L$ ) $ + "1 > D> "1 L > K &1 + " + " "& " B & L$ ) '$
. #$ +1 >D1 > D 0 0 4 0041 %$& DDD 3 + " B & +" $ "$ + ) 5 ) # & + # $ +1 + $ +1 8 1 G D 0 + B - - 3 ) '$
3 " 1 1 D> ;1 4 01 ," 1 4 L > ' ) B " " #$ 5 ) + " ) + 0 4 B # - 31 >1 HD =1 # 0 81 6 + / 0 ) $B ) 0" #)) ) ' L$ 1 D1 E ED /$ 1 61 /" 6"1 , D 3 & 1 ) & " + I$&B $& ) /& ) E * $% " $ /$ )1 , 81 ' ) 5 ) & "" V +" $ L$ ) 6 ) 3 "1 >E1 > D /$ )1 , 81 #%$ =)1 31 !& +1 6 / 5 ) & "" 7 +" B ) /& - L$ ) '$
6 6 1 >1 $1 0 8 H 0 + $$ " ) ) /& $% - 3 ) '$
3 " 1 E1 > < 1 /1 1 81 M$ +1 ' 5 ) & "" & ) 663, :@ + 6 3& 1 M 1 ! 1 = # H !$ + +B J$ ) ) & " L$ ) ' @ + . 1 >1 H H 3& +1 /1 !" 1 6 3 & B " + " )) L$ ) =$1 * $% " $ 6 +1 /1 ' 1 0 L 2 " $$ & +" B = # L$ ) '$
1 D1 E> EE 6@$ + 1 1 6" $+ 1 ' !" I$ ) $$ "" /& L$ ) # / + #$ + 3 "1 E1 E G$ "1 61 $? 1 / , H K 1 " $$ % + ) $B ) /& ) 1 /& #$ + 3 1 1 D
ScienceDirect Procedia Economics and Finance 35 (2016) 99 – 106
" - . '$
/ + 0 ) 1 " . " 2%
!" 3 " % 0 4 5 ) / & 6"" 7 - / " #%$ 8 191 - : ; + ! +%1 < = + ;" #
! " $ %
! "
!" $& & 5 " " % + 5 ) & "" 7 /& ) * + ) > " ) " /& 1 " $& $ $ &
"" & "" 7 %& + " & !" $ ) " $& " " $ $ " $ " $ + + & ' 1 & $++ " ) 0 2 0" % + " %& )) - " & 1 " $& ) + % $" % ? 0 27 0" 7 ) 5 - $ &1 & ) " $ ) " $& @ + " 1 "%& "& % ) % " ) & © 2016 The Authors. Published by Elsevier B.V. This is an open access article under the CC BY-NC-ND license !" #$" $% " %& '( (http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-nc-nd/4.0/). $ %& ) * ! + , Peer-reviewed under responsibility of Universiti Tenaga Nasional &"' (0 + A 5 A / & "" A ' "
2 " & 1 + " $" " - " ) "1 + ) 5 & 0
1 - " & 1 $ @ 1 )& "
9 0 + $" !B C D E A )5B C D E %) ( "F$ $ &
2212-5671 © 2016 The Authors. Published by Elsevier B.V. This is an open access article under the CC BY-NC-ND license (http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-nc-nd/4.0/).
Peer-reviewed under responsibility of Universiti Tenaga Nasional doi:10.1016/S2212-5671(16)00014-9
100
Masdiah Abdul Hamid et al. / Procedia Economics and Finance 35 (2016) 99 – 106
:0 " *6 " " $ 1 %$ ) "+"+" " ) + + & + $ @ & $ % @ 1 "" $ 5 )
"1 > G$ " . $? H )$" " ? " % +
& $ " ) $ + "" )$ "$+" I$ % 1 & " & "" 7 # + 8 D1 + " "
$$ "" ) " ) "" $ "$+" + ) " )) $" & " $ " ) " $ ) " @" # " 1 & $ $ + /& " % " ) + % " ) ) " @ - /& 1 " )) " + ) $% " % DD> - & DD1 " ) % $ % + & )$" " ? %& " /& 6$ 0
81 ) " 0 DD 1 $ " +% I$ "" " $ +$ )) + "" 7 !" /& 0 ) 0 4 /004 ) & $ /" 1 "" " ? "
%& ) $ ) 2 % ) "" 7 " $ + ++ %& " $ # + 3& . ! H1 ) + $ ) ) "+" ) " & " " + "" 5 % ) ) " & "" - " 1 $ +
" " + "" ) & & % ) %& + $% & & )
" & $ " $ $ 8 1 " "" ) " $% & $)) "
) " "$+" # " " $ % " + & + " " " $ ) +$ ) " & $$ ) $ $% &
" & ) ) ))$ "$+" & !" " ) " &
"" $ " $% & " $)) $ $ + " %$
1 " " % +& 5 + " " % 04 5 ) & ""7 "
$ #"$+" " $ I$ " /& 51 5
$ %$ & )) " & "" 7 !" & "" 1 " " " & " ) " &1 "$ " " " J&
"" 5 + " +" !" +" $ @ + ) 1 + @ +
# . 3" 1 D 81 "&
" +" 1 %$ "& % % 6@$ + . 6" $+ $ " " ) ) $ % " $$ ) $ /& %%& " "& "" @ + " 6"" " " " " $ $ " " & + " " %& " + !" " "$ ) + " $1 %& 5 + " ) I$& " /& 5 5 " " % + 5 ) & ""7 ' " % $
1 " "" + " ? 5 ) & "" 7 !" " %$ " + + %& ) @ + + ) 1 " $& +" " %$ " " % + " 5 ) & "" 7 6 1 "
$& ) ) " +$ + " $ +$ :" " $ ) " $&1 " +$ $ % % @ + " ) " $% 5 ) & "" 7 !" + ) " $& + ) 6 $ 6 > " "+& 6 E " ) + & 6 $ " 1 & )$$ $
Masdiah Abdul Hamid et al. / Procedia Economics and Finance 35 (2016) 99 – 106
101
+.+ 2 %3 "4!! 56 0 + " + ? )+$ " ) " "" 0 + "
$$ $ + " %$
)) ) " & " + %$
& $ %& " " $ %J ) ? + +
"" $1 " @ + $ " ) " " @" 0 1 DDD # + 0%$& 3 DD1 + " & %& "" !")1 + + " " & " " )$ " %$
& ) " & !" $ " " %$
& & $ " 5 " ? " %J ) " &1 "" " + %$
& $ %& '$
& % " " & + ) " $ %& % " " +" " 1 $" " % !" & " !"& " " & " "+ )+$ " ) " "" !"$ 1 + 5 $ " " ) " " ""1 " " %$ )$ ) " & $1 H !$ + + ) ) 5 !$ + ) ) ) $ ) ) "+" ) " & " " + ) ) "+" ) ) " & " % $ " + ) ) % @$ & 3& . ! 1 H 5 "
) $ + 7 5 ? ) %$ " ) & "" ) /$ ) 1 6 &1 & " ) 5 $ "" 7 "$+" ) + 3& + . !" 1 0"$ + 1 D )$ " & "" 0" $%& " $ & " " + "" $%J %" 5 "$+" $ + + ) + $ ) " - ) " $ +
" + ) &
) $ + $" 1 = . 6 + ) " " & $ + ) " $ @ + 5 + /1 '@ 1 D ) " 5 + ) & & 1 + ) & "+" +1
+ ) $ "
$ +$ " & ' 1 /$ . /" 6" D ) + ) & " ++ 5 + I$& ) & % - 1 0"$ + 1 ) " & "" 5 + ) $
" $ @ + +6 # !"$+" " ) " $ ) 5 %& " $ " 1 " 5 ) & "" +% 04
$ 8 1 " $& $ " 04 1 & % 1 $ 0 2 $& 5 " ) + " + & "" 7 6 + . ' )$ " % +& " 5 ) & "" 7 1 = # 5 0"$ + 1 " 5$ $ " + 5 $" 1 /$ ) 1 ) " ++ & $ )$ 5 ) & "" 7 +" /1 " $& )$ " " $ % ) 1 " $ ) " & $ %& " ) " " 0 " /$ ) )$ " % % & +7+ # 0 % @ " " )) " ) + "
102
Masdiah Abdul Hamid et al. / Procedia Economics and Finance 35 (2016) 99 – 106
!")1 $ " 04 " % & % ? " 7 0 27 ) 5 !" +$ " " "+" $ % ) % ) % + + $ & ) @ %
+ $ "$+" " @ + 2 " " " 1 % ))$ ) + "" 5 & "" 7 K) 1 )$ @ @ " ) " $ + @ + " $ 6 &1 #% "& 1 )$ + )
% $ + ) 5 " $ & + ) " $
# +&1 ) 5 ) 0" 0 2 ? " 5 ) & "" 7 " & $"1 $ " ) " "%& ) ) ?1 ) + $
32# & + )) 5 & "" 7 +8+*" ! # + 6 + . ' 1 "& ) " % " + " " 5 ) & "" 81 /$ ) 1 /$ ) ) % " " " & ' " ) +
" "&1 +$ " % ? 5 ) & "" " & !" %$ " %1 5$ ))$ " @ + " % !"$ 1 @ " 5$ ))$ 5 &
"" # + . L DH>1 "& 5$ % % + + % + & $ @ " $ + & % % + $ /1 "& $++ " " + "+" + ) $ " %7 ))
) + !" $& %& 0"$ + 1 1 )$ " $ " % " & + 5 ' " $
$ " "&1 +$ " 5 % " ) " $ " 5 ) & "" 7 !" %$ " " $ 1 " %$ " % !" @ 5$ + "" ))$ 5 & "" 0 2 $& ) " "" " ) " " 0 2 " %& !" " " %" ) " " 5
$ " ) !" ) + ) )) + + %&1 %$ $" + 1 ++ ) $& 5 1 )$$ $ & " ' " ) + + & "&1 +$ " " ) 0 2 $& 5 ) & "" " !" %$ "$ " "@ % 1 ))$ " " 0 2 $& !"$ 1 " 5 ) & "" 7 ' " % $
1 " "& " )B 8B !" $ % ) 5$ " % $ " 5 ) &
"" 7 8B !" $ % ) 5$ " $ $ " 5 ) & "" 7 8>B 0 2 $& $ " 5 ) & "" 7 7+.+4 !" $ " $& " $%& /& 1 $& " ) % @ ? 6 "& & " +" ) /& 1 @ + "" " & "" 7 " + 81 " ) $ ) & > !" ) A
Masdiah Abdul Hamid et al. / Procedia Economics and Finance 35 (2016) 99 – 106
103
#"$+" " $ $ " $& % ) " '$ /& % 1 "" %1 $ % 5 I$ ) ) " 7 $ " ) D % K $
+ & "" 7 /& 1 /6:4 "$ % " )$ ! 5 " $ % ) /6:4 + " $&1 " )$& " % ) " /6:4 % K$ " )) $ ) %$
)) +$& + 1 ) " % @ + $ $ !")1 " D ) & % ) " & $ 7+ +9# !" % $ 5 ) & "" 7 /6-1 "" 5 %& " $ ) 8) " 5 $ + " "" + 8- " & 3! !" ) $ " ) & " " %& " > "" " " ) ) & " & " $ + /$ )1 1 " " " $ ) & $ %&
& < 1 1 . M$ +1 !" "+" " $ ) " /6- 1 " "+" " 5 ) & "" 7 $ % # $
1 5 " ) + + &
"" 7 0 + " 1 $& " " % 1 @ $ " + % " $&1 + "" $ % '2-,1 $ #0-,1 0 2 $& 0K*# '2-, $ " ) $ % ) /$ )1 1 " #0-, $ " ) " $ #% "&1 8 1 ; +1 . ; " 1 > !" " %1 0K*#1 $ & % " I$ ) " 0 2 " 0" " %& )) 1 ? " ; . ," 1 > ' % + ) )) ) 7 " 1 $ " 5 ) + " B % ? '6-G 0" 7 0 27 ) 5 00 '6-G $ " $ +" ) ; . ," 1 >1 " 00 $ & % " I$ ) " 0" " 0 2 ) 5 K 1 8 1 . 8$1 # ) ) " % 1 @ ) ? 6-G " $ +" )
A ) + = ( " ) %
A $
32# " ) + %) 5
7+7+: ! $ "& " 1 & " ) + +
/6- 1 NO CO '2-, 1 CO 0-, 1 CO > K*# 1 CO E '6-G 1 CO 00 1
CO 6-G CO = ( CO 32# CP
:"A ; " ) / / 1 & 1 " $
1
1
H
1
8+.+ 4 !% " ) " % $ " $& !" $ " " "
" + E ) % !" + ) " $ $" "+" " " % 1 ) "" " "
104
Masdiah Abdul Hamid et al. / Procedia Economics and Finance 35 (2016) 99 – 106
I$ /& 2 ) " ) " /& 0 0 4 " Q" % $ J& ) " " " ) " % R # H ) " " & ) " ) 0 2 0" !" $ % ) " % %$ D " $ ++ # " + ) + " > ) " 0 2 0" " $&
) 5 3+ + ) " 1 ) " "
) " %$ /M3 % 1 " 5 & E % 2 +1 " @ + ) ) %$ $ "
!% K 6 ) - (%
/
6 K
/ $
'2-, #0-, '6-G 6-G = ( 32#
EH D H ED E E I$ &
D E D
0K*# 00
/
/5 $
ED H H >>> D H >H H EED D +
H H
> >H
HE >
E >
8+ + " !% " & + " % $ " $& 2) " " + % 1 & ) + & + ) )) /6- +& + ) & " #0-,1 %$ '2-, 0K*# /6- + ) & " " % 81 " $ ) " "$ % "$+")$& )) ) ) " !% 0 0))
/6- '2-, '2-, E #0-, HH9 99 EH99 0K*# '6-G > 999 00 H E 6-G E> DD999 = ( H > 32#
#0-, 99 >D E E
0K*#
'6-G
99 999 9 H D
00
D999 D 99
6-G
E >9 D
= (
>999 ED 999
>
2" )) )$ % " !" "+" $ " % 32# 6-G ) ED ! $ " $ & % 1 "@ ) ) (- 0 &1 " $ ) " (- " # $"1 $ & %
$ ) " +
& ) " $& 8+7+: " !" $ ) " %$ I$ !% > : J$ ) 8$% !& - . 1 $ + %$ '2-, & 5 ) & "" 7 1 %$ " $ " " + ) ; N 1 $ N 81 ) " #0-, ; N E1 $ N >> 0K*# ;> N > 1 $ N + ) & +& /6- !" $ " " ) & " $
Masdiah Abdul Hamid et al. / Procedia Economics and Finance 35 (2016) 99 – 106
105
" )$ + ) + " % " $&1 " "+" " $ % ) " $ 1 " " ) 5 ) &
"" 7 $ % # ) 0K*#1 % " "$ " " 0 2 0" % + " %& )) %$ " & $ " $ ) 5 ) & "" 7 # " + %
+ ) :" '6-G )$ % + ;E N >1 $ N D1 " )) ) 00 ; N 1 $ N > - " 1 & & % + " 0 2 0" " ) 5 "& @ " $ + 21 " $ $ " + " + + & "" 7 !% > 3%$ = 6I$ 3 $ 2 3 $ (% 0)) $ - H>99 '2-, #0-, E99 >> 0K*# > 999 '6-G >9 D 00 9 > 6-G > = ( >99 >E 32# EE99 D #J$ 3 3 I$ >D 999 , B 91 991 999 + ) " S1 S1 S 1 &
! " !" " " % + 5 ) &
"" 7 ) " /& $% % @ ? ) " ) D !" ) + ) " + " + ) & + + &
"" 7 @ ? ) /& $% !" $
$++ " " "+" " $ % ) " $ $ " ) 5 ) & "" 7 /1 " $ " $ " $ + ) 5 ) & "" 7 !" " ) ) 1 " $& +" " %$ " " % + " 5 ) & "" 7 6 1 " $& ) ) " +$ + " $ +$ :" " $ ) " $&1 " +$ $ % % @ + " ) " 5 ) & "" 7 81 $& $ + " + " + ) ) " $ ) !" $& " " " & @ " @ ) + "$ ) ) + +% # ) " 1 & ) + 5 % $ " $& !")1 $ $ " "
%& " $ $ +" % )$ %& % 8 1 + ? ) " ) + ) " " /& % $$ $ & 5 + + % "" $ @ " $ + 3 ) " $& " )) $" + @ + @ 1 )
)
$ % " )$)$ &1 )$"
$ %& $ + $ )) ) %
106
Masdiah Abdul Hamid et al. / Procedia Economics and Finance 35 (2016) 99 – 106
# #% "&1 L =1 8 1 K1 ; +1 !1 ; " 1 4 ( > #$ ) 5 ) & + ) # #$ +1 D1 B " B5+ J # 1 31 3" 1 3 # D !" ) & "" "+ +$ " ) ) + ) /& # # & ) / + L$ ) #$ + 1 1 D '@ 1 81 01 3 #1 $1 = L D 5 "$+" +$ B ) 0" L$ ) ' @ + . 1 >>1 E 0%$& 3 DD " B++ $ %$& ) 0"$ +1 M ;1 L +1 =1 =$1 !1 3$1 31 6$ 1 # D !$ + + $ B & ) & %& 0" ) ' L$ 1 1 > >D> 0"$ +1 M =1 3$1 31 6$ 1 # !$ +1 +1 5 B ) & 8 + ; + L$ ) 1 H1 >E> >H 0
1 61 KJ @1 61 1 L 1 = +1 = 8 K + + " " )) ) + "" + !" L$ ) 1 1 E K 1 / =1 8 1 3 ,1 8$1 T K " @ $ ) 5 $ ) % ) U L$ ) $ + "1 > D> "1 L > K &1 + " + " "& " B & L$ ) '$
. #$ +1 >D1 > D 0 0 4 0041 %$& DDD 3 + " B & +" $ "$ + ) 5 ) # & + # $ +1 + $ +1 8 1 G D 0 + B - - 3 ) '$
3 " 1 1 D> ;1 4 01 ," 1 4 L > ' ) B " " #$ 5 ) + " ) + 0 4 B # - 31 >1 HD =1 # 0 81 6 + / 0 ) $B ) 0" #)) ) ' L$ 1 D1 E ED /$ 1 61 /" 6"1 , D 3 & 1 ) & " + I$&B $& ) /& ) E * $% " $ /$ )1 , 81 ' ) 5 ) & "" V +" $ L$ ) 6 ) 3 "1 >E1 > D /$ )1 , 81 #%$ =)1 31 !& +1 6 / 5 ) & "" 7 +" B ) /& - L$ ) '$
6 6 1 >1 $1 0 8 H 0 + $$ " ) ) /& $% - 3 ) '$
3 " 1 E1 > < 1 /1 1 81 M$ +1 ' 5 ) & "" & ) 663, :@ + 6 3& 1 M 1 ! 1 = # H !$ + +B J$ ) ) & " L$ ) ' @ + . 1 >1 H H 3& +1 /1 !" 1 6 3 & B " + " )) L$ ) =$1 * $% " $ 6 +1 /1 ' 1 0 L 2 " $$ & +" B = # L$ ) '$
1 D1 E> EE 6@$ + 1 1 6" $+ 1 ' !" I$ ) $$ "" /& L$ ) # / + #$ + 3 "1 E1 E G$ "1 61 $? 1 / , H K 1 " $$ % + ) $B ) /& ) 1 /& #$ + 3 1 1 D