Advances in Molecular Relaxation and Interaction Processes, 13 (1978) 287-298
287
0 Elsevier Scientific Publishing Company, Amsterdam - Printed in The Netherlands
DIELECTRIC
ABSORPTION
A. LAKSHMI, Department
S. WALKER,
N.A. WEIR,
IN A FEW POLYMER
Lakehead
University,
of Salford,
Lancashire,
England
22 February
MATRICES
and J.H. CALDERWOOD*
of Chemistry,
*University (Received
OF POLAR MOLECULES
Thunder
Bay, Ontario,
Canada,
P7B 5El
1978)
ABSTRACT A detailed
study has been made of benzaldehyde
Eyring parameters lar (AHE=
have been obtained
kJ mol-1)
a polyethylene
relaxation
matrix.
been investigated
processes.
(AHE=
Benzaldehyde
in polyethylene,
polypropylene,
and polystyrene
Within
the experimental
little
influence
for group relaxation accuracy
on the enthalpy
observed
is to be contrasted
are virtually
with
hyde in polyethylene,
of activation
the molecular
polystyrene,
reported
carboxaldehyde matrices.
the medium
have
In a
and polypropylene
is
and
error,
for 2-fluorene
which
re-
has
group relaxation,
of the order of the experimental process
in
to that of benzaldehyde.
here,
for aldehyde
relaxation
and molecu-
for both group and molecular
was very similar
for the systems
and the
has also been examined
and 2-fluorene
have been obtained
matrix,
kJ mol-')
carboxaldehyde
the AHE value
the variations
for both the group
4-Biphenyl
few cases the Eyring parameters laxation;
in a polystyrene
definitely
This
carboxaldedependent
on the medium.
INTRODUCTION Dielectric
measurements
that dipolar molecules medium
of Frank et al [l] and Davies
dissolved
of very high viscosity.
loss factor occurs solution,
Further,
be more pronounced
in a polystyrene The frequency
is then considerably
at which
behave
somewhat
the maximum
as if in a
value of dielectric
lower than that in the case of a liquid
this effect of viscosity for molecular
matrix
et al [2,3] have indicated
rotation,
on relaxation
which
time may be expected
invo1ve.s the motion
to
of a species
of
288
than for the rotation
large volume,
of much smaller
substituent
groups within
the
molecule. The group rotational Ill01
-1
rotational
microwave
barrier,
and i.r. respectively,
while Grindley
siderably,
ranging between
and thus further
concentrations of directly tion.
to examine
equation
to dielectric
respectively
may be gained.
of the weight
(p1/n2)2 = (cot 0)
although
2
the weight
providing
2
=l.
the relaxation
-1
[6], and
differs
from the molecular
the value
our temperature
the process
should be good.
relaxa-
the Eyring
rate
if any, of the medium
Cl and C2 for molecular
subtends
magnitude
itself
from dipole moment with
and group re-
of the two processes data from the
the long axis of the molecule.
~1 = n cos 0, n2 = u sin 0, and Cl/C2 =
is greater
aldehydes
Mountain Thus,
than that for the
and in such circumstances
for the group and molecular
range,
exists
for the energy barrier
by applying
the latter is far from negligible,
within
con-
at low
the possibility
0 to be 38', and hence Cl is 0.62 for benzaldehyde.
appreciably
for
from an i.r. study,
From data on a few aromatic
time values
from
The energy barrier
where
contribution
factor for the molecularprocess
process,
for the
aldehydes.
of the molecule,
andCl+C
[ll] deduced
intramolecular
polymers
Both Cl and C2 may be estimated
If n is the dipole moment
[7], 28.1
and some related molecules
of the relative
dipole moment
-1
[9] gave 27.7 kJ mol-1
-1 .
the influence,
factors
an appreciation
24.8
to 20 kJ mol
as deduced
data and to examine
angle that the molecular
and Walker
in benzaldehyde
[6] kJ mol
by these procedures
to establish
and a few other aromatic
From consideration laxation
of this paper
group rotation
on benzaldehyde
of non-polar
[4] is 33 kJ
is merited.
benzaldehyde
the group relaxation
It is the purpose
for aldehyde
estimated
of this molecule
in solid matrices
separating
[5] and 19.6
a value of 34 kJ mol
34 kJ mol-l by n.m.r,
examination
It seemed of interest
20.6
An -ab initio MO calculation
in benzaldehyde
studies
also has given estimates
and in the liquid phase,
et al [lo] reported
group rotation
from n.m.r.
spectroscopy
in the gas phase,
[8] from i.r. studies.
aldehyde
for benzaldehyde
Vibrational
in vinyl chloride.
Ph-CHO
28.6
barrier
the chance of detection
processes
differ
and separation
of
289 EXPERIMENTAL
RESULTS
The dielectric bridge
measurements
in the frequency
circular,
parallel
range 50 to lo5 Hz.
plate
purged with dry nitrogen ture to about 400K.
have been made on a General
capacitor gas.
mounted
measurements
Q-meter
with a temperature-controlled
1.5x10'
Hz.
viously.
chamber
from liquid nitrogen
tempera-
were made using a Hewlett-Packard
two-terminal
and measurement
cell was a three-terminal,
in a temperature-controlled
The cell may be operated
Additional
The apparatus
The measuring
Radio 1615A capacitance
cell in the range 2.5~10~
techniques
have been described
4342A to
pre-
[12,13]
The polystyrene
matrix
and we have adopted the relaxation
was prepared
their procedures
both experimentally
time and distribution
tion and the enthalpy
of activation
in the way described
parameter
by Davies
and Swain
[2],
and also in the evaluation
by means of the Fuoss-Kirkwood
from the Eyring equation,
of
equa-
The atactic polystyrene
had a zw value of 2.3~10~. When isotactic was used,
polystyrene,
the same procedure
was used as a solvent Benzaldehyde,
polypropylene was adopted
in the latter
salicylaldehyde,
dehyde have each been examined are presented
in Table r.
are given in Table
equation,
to obtain
activation
in a variety
The results
values
standard
statistical
for the relaxation
or less, in agreement
cases, since
carboxaldehyde, of polymer
of the Eyring
and 4-biphenylcarboxal-
matrices,
equation
The relaxation
analyses
intervals
(see Ostle
data
of these data
of the enthalpy along with
intervals
the work of Davies
intervals
typically
For this reason,
for each of
For the ASE term,
were of the order of ?50% of the nominal
(l/T) plot.
(ASE) of
?lO% of the nominal
et al. [2,3]
this term is often a small part of the intercept,
of the In (T r) versus
to the
of these two
(AHE) and entropy
confidence
on AHE were
of temperature
[14]) have been employed
of the line and the variances
values
with
time as a function
techniques
process
The 95% confidence
these confidence
that p-xylene
II.
These data yielded
these two.
except
(low density)
two cases.
L-fluorene
the slope and intercept
parameters.
or polyethylene
to make the sample,
In the fitting of the data of relaxation Eyring
(atactic)
values
in some
(In (h/kg) - ASE/R),
an extensive
study of the matrix
290 was undertaken higher
to obtain
a larger number
of points
on the Eyring
plot extending
to
temperatures.
DISCUSSION A sample of benzaldehyde
in atactic polystyrene
plot of log rT v l/T.
One of these straight
range 102-138K,
an enthalpy
yields
pared with a slightly which
larger
a similar
enthalpy
benzaldehyde higher
of activation
falls
bromobenzene
may be attributed
of 16 k.J mol-1.
to the molecular
temperature
This low temperature relaxation
process,
172-201K
yields
to the value of 29 k.J mol-'
obtained
for the group relaxation
in atactic polystyrene
both the AHE values correct magnitude Benzaldehyde similar mol
-1
for molecular
to that for the polystyrene
of data between
this yielded
on the bridge.
the bridge
range of 4.7~10~
a.virtually
associated
with
process
the isotactic
range to that for benzaldehyde
swiftly solely
from the matrix, to molecular
centration
of the
This is similar
process
in p-OHC-C6[16]
Thus,
are of the
respectively.
polystyrene
in a temperature of activation
the work was extended
AHE=29.5
polymer.
range
of 29 kJ
kJ mol-'.
influenced
range 169-193K,
by the relative temperature
Benzaldehyde
the solute
tended
molecules
-1
and
imply order
and frequency
was also
to be exuded
the AHB value of 19 kJ mol
of benzaldehyde
frequency
These figures would
This was a similar
However,
to a higher
in the temperature
in atactic polystyrene.
and whether
relaxation
Analysis
for
In order to check this result and the continuity
is not greatly
medium.
process
in polystyrene
and an enthalpy
Hz on the Q-meter
identical
in a polyethylene
matrix,
and Q-meter
to 5.2~10~
that the intramolecular
studied
in isotactic
[15]
range and has
may be observed.
for benzaldehyde
and group relaxation
was also examined
was obtained
a AHB of 27 kJ mol-'.
when only group relaxation
of 13 and 27 kJ mol-'
This is to be com-
in atactic polystyrene
betweeen
H4-CHO
lines from a
in the temperature
of 13 kJ mol-'.
range also falls in a similar
of activation
temperature
two straight
lines, which
rigid molecule,
for the given frequency
yielded
quite
may be attributed
dispersed
in very low con-
is not established.
In order to ensure
that the two AHB values
styrene had been assigned molecule,which
is somewhat
correctly, bigger
for benzaldehyde
we also examined
than benzaldehyde,
in isotactic
salicylaldehyde. a chelated
poly-
In this
ring is formed held
291 together
by a very strong
McClellan
[17]).
intramolecular
If group relaxation
AHK (e.g., ~40 kJ mol
-1
Hence,
).
may look upon this molecule atactic
polystyrene,
the molecular somewhat
smaller
process
molecule.
lower AHK of benzaldehyde
-1
absorption
in these media
process
In
polystyrene, was similar.
the molecular
relaxa-
[18] has more recently
of benzotrichloride
de-
in
, and this again sets an upper limit for
of benzaldehyde
in polystyrene
All these data thus support
in isotactic
by a high
of comparison.
and in isotactic
a co-worker
relaxation
[17] to be 21 kJ mol
relaxation
for the purposes -1
and
region of the bridge we
range of dielectric
Further,
the AHg for the molecular
atactic polystyrene
a
-1 ,
(see Pimentel
it would be accompanied
a AHK of 23 kJ mol
that for benzaldehyde
tion AHK is less than 24 kJ mol
bond 0-H"'OCH
in the low temperature
the temperature
We may, in fact, conclude
termined
occurred,
as a rigid molecule
we obtained
In both,
24 kJ mol-1.
hydrogen
polystyrene
since benzaldehyde
the interpretation
is
of the
in terms of the molecular
relaxa-
tion process. For dielectric is abundant variation
absorption
evidence
volume
to demonstrate
in relaxation
change in viscosity
or molecular
such as relaxation
changes
for a solute
variations
aldehyde
such behaviour
-4
a AHE=
kJ mol
laxation
times and the enthalpies
being
the process
in polymer
and a relaxation
responsible
higher
rigid molecule,
for the higher
where
the
4-biphenyl
Both 4-biphenyl
temperature
processes
carbox-
with
and have identical
of activation
relaxa-
are of the same
4-nitrobiphenyl
[15], which has
Thus, both the re-
favour a molecular
temperature
of such
In order to
we examined
time at 300K of 4.6x10 -4 s. of activation
to the effective
independent
matrices,
respectively
These enthalpies
considerable
(owing to substantial
in a few media,
yielded
there
that an intramolecular
could be considerable,
of 72 and 76 kJ mol-'
s at 300K.
also reveal
solvents
exhibits
of a non polar solvent.
carboxaldehyde
order as that of the similar-sized -1
process
group is reasonably
is paralleled
carboxaldehyde
of activation
tion times of 1.7x10
solution
viscosity
and 2-fluorene
and Z-fluorene
enthalpies
in non polar
and is also sensitive
such studies
of an aldehyde
in a dilute
in macroscopic
carboxaldehyde
that a molecular
interaction)
However,
process
whether
of polar molecules
time by a change in local environment
of the molecule.
determine
studies
absorption.
relaxation It can
as
292 thus be seen
(Table II) that there is a reasonable
for the high temperature molecule,
process
Such behaviour
from a group relaxation. AHS values
differ
volume
parameter
29 kJ mol
-1
4-biphenyl
,
from that of the high
styrene
which
and group processes
matrices,
which
factor is enormously
for 4-biphenylcarboxaldehyde
larger
as molecular
time and
since the corresoccurs,
has been achieved
the relaxation
is
for
to identify
times for
lo6 in the poly-
than is usually
relaxation
as distinct
In fact, it may be noted
rod-shaped,
seem reasonable
process
only group relaxation
carboxaldehyde.
are roughly
to 2-fluorene
one, and its
differ by a factor of approximately
Thus, it would
phase studies.
temperature
of the two processes
and 2-fluorene
of the
the relaxation
group relaxation
[16] where
Thus, a clear separation
that in these two aldehydes, molecular
to aldehyde
for terephthaldehyde
carboxaldehyde
from a molecular process
AHS values
volume
from benzaldehyde
would be expected
AH=27 kJ mol-1 is to be attributed ponding
increasing
For the low temperature
appreciably
between
(atactic PS) and the effective
both AHP and molecular
carboxaldehyde.
correlation
found in liquid
the longer
and the shorter
relaxation one as group
relaxation. In polyethylene observed
in 4-biphenyl
considerably
carboxaldehyde,
measurements
of the matrices.
similar
In all three atactic polymer
polypropylene parameters
reflect
environments. sequentially transition
falling
bound bulky phenyl temperatures).
relaxation
parameters
in the various
is probably
to a rigid chain
in in
These polymeric
the result of the (at sub-glass
these effects would be less noticeable
there is a considerably
of the degree of random branching
in this
was observed
and polystyrene.
relaxation
attached
in which
Under
of the large scale deformation
the activation
for polystyrene
On the other hand,
in the low density polyethylene, on account
also molecular
of molecular
groups
at temperatures
of these polymers.
those in polyethylene
AHE value
it occurs
was not
parameters.
above room temperature,
the difficulty
process
group rotation was observed
activation
media
in between
The higher
because
temperatures
aldehyde
In all three media,
carboxaldehyde
relaxation
cannot be made on account
near 200K, yielding
2-fluorene
possibly
above the glass transition
such conditions
aldehyde
the molecular
and polypropylene,
of the chains.
higher
free volume
In polystyrene
and
293 polypropylene,
aldehyde
group rotation
with AHK of 27 and 30 kJ mol molecular
peaks overlap
respectively.
and extend
rendering
group rotation,
-1
was also observed
in this molecule
In polyethylene,
out into the absorption
a clear cut determination
near ZOOK,
the tail of the
peaks owing to aldehyde
of AHK for the group process
not
feasible.
CONCLUSIOHS Altogether
our experimental
the molecular
and group processes
In 2-fluorene molecular
carboxaldehyde
and group processes
now been detected carboxaldehyde
absorption
peaksextends
ing it not feasible
aldehyde
to the chemical
that free volumes required
listed
when
A change in medium
fluorene tion. shown
has caused
whilst
absorption
is small.
However,
In contrast
tion time when
of the aldehyde.
considerable relaxation
matrix
occurs,
render-
for the latter process. -1
appears
indicative
AHK value being
Further, is varied,
polymers
of the
relatively
this value does not possibly
considerably
studies
on polar
process,
indicating
exceed
the variation
the volume
is changed
is much
time acti-
as seen in the case of Zfor aldehyde
in non polar
to macroscopic
in enthalpy
studies
in the relaxation
change
solutes
is sensitive
the variation
the matrix
the polymer
variation
causing very little
relaxation
for small molecules
Debye equation,
parameters
in atactic polystyrene,
the various
for a molecular
that the molecular
although
with
the group process
group rotation.
carboxaldehyde,
Dielectric
nature
has been
the tail of the molecular
II a AHK ~30 k.J mol
the type of polymer
associated
for aldehyde
vation parameters
in Table
have
For 4-biphenyl
only the group process
out into the region where
both
and both processes
in polypropylene,
in polyethylene,
the relaxation
of both
in polystyrene,
observed,
and polyethylene,
group relaxation
alter significantly
carboxaldehyde
carboxaldehyde
carboxaldehyde
of activation
in atactic polystyrene.
have been previously
to measure
For the molecules
insensitive
and 4-biphenyl
in polypropylene
In 2-fluorene
enthalpies
for benzaldehyde
for 2-fluorene
detected.
aromatic
data have yielded
group
solvents
viscosity
reveal vast changes
and the molecular
by the
for such systems
in molecular
enthalpy
have
changes
less than that predicted of activation
relaxa-
relaxa-
of activation
alters
294
appreciably. This difference in behaviour of the molecular and small relaxing segment of a molecule is the very basis on which separation of the group and molecular motions may be achieved in the matrix and eliminates the complicationswhich can sometimes ensue with a Budo analysis of the dielectric data of polar solutions in the liquid phase. [19] Clearly, much more work is necessary on the dielectric absorption of flexible molecules in various types of polymer matrices where, from that reported here, it follows that one polymer matrix may better facilitate the separation of particular molecular and intramolecularprocesses more readily than another.
ACKNOWLEDGEMENTS We are grateful to the National Research Council of Canada for support and to Mr. B. K. Morgan for invaluable technical help.
TABLE I Fuoss-Kirkwood Analysis Parameters for Four Solutes in Polymer Matrices (Solute Concentrations are in parenthesis)
T (0
106,(s)
103c"max
Bensaldehvde in atactic uolvstvrene (0.232Mj 102
107 113 118 123 128 133 138
362 173 92.6 44.6 25.9 14.3 8.3 5.3
0.17 0.16 0.17 0.17 0.18 0.17 0.16 0.17
9.65 10.20 10.70 11,oo 11.30 11.60 11.80 12.00
2.64 2.63 2.63 2.62 2.62 2.60 2.60 2.59
Benzaldehyde in atactic polystyrene (0.655Ml 172 178 184 193 201
1.03 0.44 0.33 0.20 0.04
0.24 0.23 0.22 0.21 0.18
18.82 14.59 15.12 15.70 16.81
Benzaldehvde in isotactic uolvstvrene (0.633M 139.1 141.2 143.9
96.3 65.9
49.3
0.15 0.17 0.15
0.19 0.19 0.20
2.62 2.62 2.62
295
T(K)
10%(6) Benzaldehyde in isotactic polystyrene (0.633M) can't
145.8 148.2 151.7 178 182.9 188.2 193
38.0 23.3 12.9 0.527 0.277 0.185 0.0724
0.15 0.16 0.15 0.20 0.21 0.22 0.49
0.20 0.20 0.21 0.17 0.17 0.18 0.19
2.62 2.62 2.62 2.62 2.62 2.62 2.62
Benzaldehyde in polyethylene (0.897M) 214.6 224.9 235.1 254.1 273.4 297.3
259 185 108 53.8 27.0 9.99
0.39 0.34 0.32 0.27 0.24 0.22
53.57 54.51 54.31 51.85 46.34 35.58
2.88 2.85 2.83 2.78 2.74 2.67
Salicylaldehydein polystyrene (0.52lM) 114.2 118.8 125.4 128.8 132.5 140.8
363 129 50.2 22.1 11.7 3.05
0.14 0.14 0.13 0.13 0.14 0.14
16.35 17.28 18.46 19.16 19.81 21.48
2.68 2.68 2.66 2.66 2.66 2.64
Salicylaldehydein isotactic polystyrene (0.63M) 122.5 124.9 129.2 133.3 138.4 142.3 145.2
174 165 46.2 24.1 11.7 6.02 4.38
0.14 0.12 0.14 0.15 0.14 0.14 0.14
14.25 14.58 15.31 16.02 16.86 17.56 18.12
2.66 2.64 2.65 2.65 2.64 2.64 2.64
4-Biuhenvlcarboxaldehydein polyethylene (0.296Ml 181.6 190.1 198.8 207.5 216.5 249.2
389 154 72.5 54.3 28.7 0.4
0.39 0.36 0.35 0.28 0.31 0.36
6.14 6.47 6.99 8.00 4.44 51.2
2.36 2.36 2.36 2.36 2.37
4-Biphenyl carboxaldehyde in polypropylene (0.254M) 185.4 192.7 197.5
202 207.6 212.7 217.8 224
390 149 93.8 42.0 31.0 19.7 12.5 9.5
0.39 0.42 0.43 0.42 0.42 0.41 0.39 0.36
6.94 7.33 7.49
7.84 7.86 8.25 8.83 9.88
2.26 2.25 2.25 2.24 2.24 2.27 2.23 2.23
296
T(K)
10%(s)
B
103Pmax
EC.2
2-Fluorene carboxaldehyde in,polystYrene (0.33M) 294.7 303.4 311.9 317.3 322 326.7
1126 446 293 231 178 LO9
0.57 0.60 0.58 0.57 0.55 0.57
38.03 37.78 34.76 33.79 32.86 31.00
2.57 2.56 2.55 2.53 2.51 2.49
2-Fluorene carboxaldehyde in polypropylene (0.216M) 295.2 306 310.7 314.9 320.9 325.4 330
1766 500 414 281 208 143 120
0.49 0.53 0.52 0.53 0.51 0.52 0.50
71.65 73.09 75.04 75.39 74.76 75.03 74.87
2.52 2.51 2.51 2.51 2.50 2.49 2.49
2-Fluorene carboxaldehvde in polv~ro~vlene (0.216M) 202.4 206.7 210.6 213 217.5 220.6 223.9 230.5
406 226 185 127 95.4 65.7 59.4 42.2
0.41 0.45 0.42 0.43 0.44 0.43 0.40 0.41
4.62 4.88 5.05 5.26 5.34 5.79 6.02 7.07
2.39 2.39 2.39 2.39 2.39 2.39 2.38 2.38
297
TABLE II Eyring Analysis
Results
for Several Molecules
Type of Relaxation Molecule
Benzaldehyde
AHE (kJ_l al01 )
AsE (J-K-’
mol
-1
)
in Polymer
Matrices
AGElOo
AGE200
CkJ_l
(kJ_1
mol
)
mol
Temperature Range (K)
)
in
a) atactic polystyrene
mol
13
-45
18
27
102-138
group
27
31
24
18
172-201
group
29
35
26
19
163-193
c) polyethylene
mol
19
-88
27
45
215-297
a) atactic styrene
mol
23
28
20
15
114-141
mol
24
31
21
15
122-145
group
34
10
33
31
182-249
group mol
32 72
-2 67
32 65
32 52
185-224 295-330
grow
27
-19
29
33
176-223
a) atactic polystyrene
mol
76
79
68
52
296-330
b) polyethylene
mol
51
-15
53
56
295-327
c) atactic polypropylene
mol
59
8
58
57
295-330
d) atactic polystyrene*
group
27
-34
30
37
200-230
e) atactic polypropylene
group
30
-29
33
39
202-231
polystyrene b) isotactic styrene
poly-
poly-
b) isotactic styrene
poly-
4-Biphenyl carboxaldehyde in a) polyethylene b) atactic polypropylene c) atactic polystyrene 2-Fluorene carboxaldehyde in
*In process
of publication
(see ref. 16)
298
REFERENCES 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19
F.C. Frank and W. Jackson, Trans. Faraday Sot., 36(1940) 440. M. Davies and J. Swain, Trans. Faraday Sot., 67(1971) 1637. M. Davies and A. Edwards, Trans. Faraday Sot., 63(1967) 2163. F.A.L. Anet and M. Ahmad, J. Amer. Chem. Sot., 86(1964) 119. R.K. Kakar, E.A. Rinehart, C.R.Quade, and T. Kojima, J. Chem. Phys., 52(1970) 3803. W.G. Fateley, R.K. Harris, F.A. Miller and R.E. Witkowski, Spectrochim. Acta, X(1965) 231. J.H.S. Green, W. Kynaston, and H.A. Gebbie, Nature, 195(1962) 595. G.E. Campagnaro and J.L. Wood, J. Mol. Struct., 6(1970) 117. W.J. Hehre, L. Radom and J.A. Pople, J. Amer. Chem. Sot., 94(1972) 1496. T.B. Grindley, A.R. Katritzky, and R.D. Topsom, J. Chem. Sot., Perkin II, (1974) 289 P.F. Mountain and S. Walker, Canad. J. Chem., 52(1974) 3229. S.P. Tay and S. Walker, J. Chem. Phys., 63(1975) 1634. S.P. Tay, J. Kraft and S. Walker, J. Phys. Chem. 80(1976) 303. B. Ostle, "Statistics in Research", (2nd edit.), Iowa State University Press, Ames, Iowa, U.S.A., (1963). A. Kwaja, (Private communication - this laboratory). A. Lakshmi, S. Walker, N.A. Weir, and J.H. Calderwood, Chem. Sot., Trans. Faraday II (in press). G.C. Pimentel and A.L. McLellan, "The Hydrogen Bond", W.H. Freeman and Co., San Francisco, (1960). J.P. Shukla, (Private communication - this laboratory). J. Crossley, S.P. Tay and S. Walker, Adv. in Mol. Relax. Processes, 6(1974) 79.