- Email: [email protected]
Effect of Inquiry based Learning Method on Students’ Motivation
Available online at www.sciencedirect.com
ScienceDirect Procedia - Social and Behavioral Sciences 106 (2013) 988 – 996
! "#
" $#%& '( # )( *+ % (, -.!'.!% /0 1+ %&-"( "(&- (2 / .!'3&-4 4 &
" #$"
!
5 6#6 #% ( $#% & ' ( # ) ( 7 $# 8#62' (6 % ( 66# #% (6 ' # ' 9 # % "# 6 : %7 5 ; ' < ' =#
; <= 6&% - (-8 ;> ?? 6 5#+&% 3%3+@!3+-A+'3 -.!+ 2( 66 ( # )( 79 # - % 66 7 B5A#7#& &%" <7 © 2013 The Authors. Published by Elsevier Ltd. 6 # 6 & % 5A -"# 5 '% 5A "5- + % Selection and peer-review under responsibility of The Association of Science, Education and Technology-TASET, Sakarya Universitesi, : -5#+%7 Turkey. %& C $#%& '-# ( -( $# &#(
< & % + 6 % (6 (% '7 #'' # &(# # #'6 6 & % <# - ?D- E - ??E 5& - ??E 8 + '- ??F7 5% & 6 6( # )( ' # '- 6# # ' # 6 % $# 6 6 $#%& & % 7 G & + $# ' ' <# - ?DE 5& 8 '- ?DHE 5& - ??E <# - 7 # & # - ( % # ' <# 5 (- ?H?E 2( - ???E ,
6 ' #7 "( C!+7& % ((I'( 7(
1877-0428 © 2013 The Authors. Published by Elsevier Ltd. Selection and peer-review under responsibility of The Association of Science, Education and Technology-TASET, Sakarya Universitesi, Turkey. doi:10.1016/j.sbspro.2013.12.112
Zeki Bayram et al. / Procedia - Social and Behavioral Sciences 106 (2013) 988 – 996
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
989
990
Zeki Bayram et al. / Procedia - Social and Behavioral Sciences 106 (2013) 988 – 996
&# '6 ( ' $#%& J6( ( + '# 6 E #J6( # )( ' #6#675#- #' '$# C A % ' & # #' $#% & ' 66 J6( '#6 # #' # '#6 6 ' - J ' - + #- ' & - % ' 6 ( - J% ( (%#T #& 6& ( #% C A %' & # ); <=6 J6( '#6 '#6T A % ' & # ) ; <= 6 6 J6( '#6T A % ' & # ) ; <= 6 6 '#6T A % ' & # ) ; <= 6 J6( '#6 '#6T + , 1 $2 5#% # $# 8#62' 9 + N -ME8 % A -7 + + 3 A H# '26 ( % ; ( "# 9 # % "# 6: %6 6 7 + - # ; ' < ' =#
; <=C 5 ; ' < ' =#
(6 % ( # )( (%#75; <= 6 &% - (- 8 ;> ?? 6 5#+ &% 3%3+@!3+- A+'3 -.!+ 2( # # %# )( K#( # ' ' ' # # %7 5 ; <= (6 ( 6 C ( - ' '7 5 ( 6 ( #& ( ' 81-J ' "81- + #5U- '& 1<-
% ' 6 ( <- J% 5A75 # ( % % 6 (( # %# )( (% CVW X--89X7DH- A89X7HH G; "AX7H75 & % 7H 81-7FHF "81-7D? 5U-7H 1<-7? <- 7FM 5A4 -7 5 & ( + ( 6 ; <= & 7
Zeki Bayram et al. / Procedia - Social and Behavioral Sciences 106 (2013) 988 – 996
!,4 $ $ "& 2 ( 256 U # "J6 % A
9 ' "J ' 5 + # % '& 5 J%
"J6 < )& &#(6 + < )&  ( < )) +
3%3+@!3+-A+'3 -2( -L.!+ - + 7
5 & %!#';
N %: N J ' G +57 + 8 ( 5 ( $# &#( J6( $#%7 5 ( J6( 6 & % & # ' & > 9 # 7 J6( -'#6 # (- '#6  7 ' 6 C 5 J6( W& 7 5 C 6 ' 6 6& (7 5 6# # - ( # + # # > Y9 - #&75# +&6 ( # '7 G# C +& # 7 ( ( &#( $# &#(# 7 5% '##' $#% # ( $# &#(7 7( # # $#%C # 6+ ' 6 7 5 C6( # -## $#%-' ( 75 +# ( +(( & +& # & - #'C 66 T 7( # # (# #' (6 ( ) C5 C' # 6 - # (6 ( & 6+ ' # 7 5# (( & 71 '#6((& ' &(6 &%'#675'#6 +6 % 75
&#( $# &#( ( &% 7 ( $# &#(( %7 5 + $# C N 66 ( 9 # # T %#6 7 7 %6! 'C '( 6& (-'#6 # (%675 C 6 (# ' 6& (- (# ' %6- ' ' & 7 5 # ' %6 66 9 # (J#7 (%%6 -# & '-7 F75# %6J6( -& -$#
-#( -7 5 C 6( # #' ( + # (# %- ( + # % (6 7 (( $#% 7 -# # + ' + '%67
991
992
Zeki Bayram et al. / Procedia - Social and Behavioral Sciences 106 (2013) 988 – 996
M7 5 ' %6C 5 %6 ( ( J6( - & - $#
-#( 75 C& ''( #( 66 % ( $#% 7 & (9 # (J# #C + & # & 7 # $# 7 5 ' (6 $# 7 9 # # T-77777 H75# & -% 6 5 C 6 6 '# 75 & ' !75'#66 (6 7 D7 " %6 %C # %6 - % ' & + 6 7 5 C # ' 6 $#%7 %6 C 6 ' #66 ( ' % 7 (( 66 # 7 5 + ' & &% - #7 !+42 )9$ )
81
5U
1<
<
5A
H-
DH-F
?-
M?-F
MM-F
MD-
N J N
M-
FD-F
-
-F
FM-F
FD-
-
-FF
-D
-M
-H
-?
-
-
-?M
-D?
-?H
-
-
-?M
-D?
-?
*
"81
;
N %:
A%(67 '7
- "J '7Z,
- '[ 7 7 &78#6 'U & C8#6
A ';
N %: # - ' '#6 & 6 J ' :XDH-F-6\7F7 & ' & 6 # 6]7F !-4N J ' G +5G# *
81 "81 5U 1< < 5A
81 "81 5U 1< < 5A
-
-DF
A%(67 '7
-H - 7 ' +7 &7 6 +7 7N J ' G +5
-F
-
-D
-H&
-
-DDM
-M
-
Zeki Bayram et al. / Procedia - Social and Behavioral Sciences 106 (2013) 988 – 996
A 'N J ' G +5# - ' 6 & J ' !X -DF- 6\7F 6 6 # J6( '#67 & ' & 6 6 # 6]7F # 0 $ $
$ $ $#%& < ' " ! $" $ !) " J '
!74N J ' G +5G#
81 "81 5U 1< < 5A
81 "81 5U 1< < 5A
-MMH
*
-
A%(67 '7
-?M -?D 7 ' +7 &7 6 +7 7N J ' G +5
-FH
-DDH&
-?
-MF&
-M
-HF
-?F
-
A 'N J ' G +5# - ' 6 & J%!X -MF-6\7F6 6 # '#67 & ' & 6 6 # 6]7F !842 )9$ ) 1
81
"81
;
N %:
FF-F
H-
D-
N J N
M-F
DD-
-H
-M?
*
A%(67 '7
-MF "J '7Z,
-M '[ 7 7 &78#6 'U & C8#6
5U
1<
<
5A
M?-F
FD-F
D-
??-
F?-F
D-F
?D-
-
-M
-D
-?H
-??
-?
-?M
-H
-F
-F
-??
-?M
-HH
-FH
A ';
N %: # - ' & 6 # J6( '#66]7F A ' # - # # ) J ' 6 66 7 "J ' # ' # ) ( (6 ' '' - '' 6 ( - (-8 -L;> -??75 ' #66 ' ' & # # ' $#% & 6( # ) ( - E &+ > - E ; J 7- E 5# 7- FE; -7 ( -8& - ( -N 9+ # $#%& # # ) '6 # '7
993
994
Zeki Bayram et al. / Procedia - Social and Behavioral Sciences 106 (2013) 988 – 996
#( 7- ??E " (- E <66- N - ;#(( 8# - ??E ( - $#%& (' # )( # % '# ( ( + '-6( 66# %# '# + 6 6K % 5# 7- F7 # - # ' # )( #& ( J ' ( 6 J6( 67 N # 6& ( + % &# # ) ( ' # '7 $#% & J6( & ( %%6( +# ( 75 $#% & J6( ( % & (6 ( # # %- # 66 6E 6 & ( + '6 &# ' & ( 7 A ' # # # #- ( % & # ( 75 -( + ' $#%& J6( $# 6 # 6 & (' # & 7 66 #- ( %%6 & ( %&(( 7
A& " > +- 97-#O #- 7- 2# - G7- <( - 787- ; ( + ( - G7- - A7- !- ;7- 5 '#- 27 5# - 7<7 7 $#% # C 667 ?H ?7 A%S#- 7 "' - .7 D7 9 5+ K +# 0 + 0 % + + @S & ( 3/ & + 7 0 : " 0
;*-F M7 +#-<7F7A% #6#7 $ $ <+H-F FD7 3%3+@!3+- 47- A+'3 - .7 "7- 2( - 97 .!+ - .7 7 833 ( .S ( K . /S) 53+/ (# # '/ +'3 +/ 0^( 07% " 0" : " " 7-H ?7 -7A77"(& ' $#%C 7= 1 $ $ 0-<?- ?M ?H7 2->7;7F7 # 6 ' ' $#% & &7= #$" +-HD D7 2( -27 7???7A & % # % 7= #$" < -F FH7 9 + - O7G7 N - 7"7 M7 & 0 $ M 77 P+C ;8 + (6 %7 8 - 7O7 + '- ;7N7 ??F7 G # ' (% &C A & % & ' 7 $ = -7,-M7 8 %- <7 G7 A - 7 7 1 $4 # "
M 77 " ' - OC 7 8& - 7<7 - 7 7 < '# (6 $#% & 6' ( ( # ) # 7 -M? HF7 #%-27??7 $ 0 $ 0$ > 7"G 2#( G6# 7"2F?D7 -27??7A + 6 + ' 7$ 1 &<,-7
Zeki Bayram et al. / Procedia - Social and Behavioral Sciences 106 (2013) 988 – 996 -A7 <# U7 775 & % # C9# % #%7 -D F7 -A7- -G7 >6 -;77 '' (%# 66# 6 '+ $#%
%6 & %CA #%7? = + -H M7 -A7 <# -U7 7?D75 & % 'C ' 6 71 & 1 $8+-H7 -A7 <# U7 775 & % # C9# % #%7 -D F7 -A7 <# -U7 775 & % # C9# % _ #%7 - DF7 - A7- #( 57 <7 G7 7 A( < ' " ( $#% 5%6 < & ' (%75 0 " 1 $7-? H7 &+- O7 > - O7 <77 ' 6( $#% & (7 $ ? # $5 0 H7 O - ;7"7-8- G7 O ( - G7 7 ' 6 +% ' ## #( 7 1 $ ,7- H7 <-57 1+ ! +-57M7; ' ( $#% & # & %7" 0 $ M- F7 <# -U7 75 (-7?H?7; ' & '' 7 $ $ 7 F- 7 ; ->7G77 $ > )! " "
$ 0$ $ ! 0
"7 ; 5-; : %-!( -; 7 ; J-G7N7- #( - 7 7-> K+-O7 7-9( -7- %-"7- 8-G7G -57577 $#% & ( ' CA( ' #& %( (7= 1 $ $ 07,-M D7 ; %- 7<7- 8 - ;797-L>+7 G7 M7 # ' (% & %C A( # '7 = #$" -F-D7 ;- 7- (- 27 * - :7 H7 #6 % ' 6( ' + ' + C A + '71 $ -<-FM?7 %- U7 G7-L 7 7 G 7 7 $ & "@ $" $ 0 0 "4 @" " > )! 07A ""W"""9 "# -G 7 - 7G7- (- 27A797- 8 - 57 ;> - N7O7 ??7 A ( # # ( ' ' $#
; <=7A
A&-;C G (6 %5 ' < '-5: % ;' 7 = '-*7-O '-87 P -N77( '6 ) + '+ &% $#% & ( J6( 7( $ +-F?HM7 1 %- ;7-A - 27 # - N797 # - O7 L- A7 7 " ' ( C 5 '
# 7= #$" ,-D7 1 %- ;7-LA -27 F7 A# # ' ( 7 = #$" +M-??7 G#& - 7??M7 ")
$ $! " !0 0 0 7 27-5(6 : %7
995
996
Zeki Bayram et al. / Procedia - Social and Behavioral Sciences 106 (2013) 988 – 996 ( - 57A7- N- 7P7 9+ - O7G7 7 # ) ' ' $#% + (_ & 7? = -M7 %( +%-O7- '-<7-LN -87??7A ( $#% & ## M) # 6 ( 7= 1 $ $ 0+<-H7 (- 27 ??M7 ")
" !! $ $ 0 > " "$ 0727-5(6 : %7 4 - 47 7 % " : A " " A B: " " " CBDE " B: !A F F "
P3++< 5!7A + C 6` 9 ( " 337 5 - 7-L >##- ;7 M7 5 $#% & ' 66 # ( ( 7 G : " E 0
-,-H FD7 5& ->7??7G & % C 6## &$# (6 '7$ 2$" ; D7 5& ->7 8 '-O7O7?DH7N 66 ' (T= # " ,;M-F? FM7 5# - 7<- - 7 7-5 - 7 7 '- 797F7 ' ' $#% # ( '% # 7? = 2$" --F FMM7
ScienceDirect Procedia - Social and Behavioral Sciences 106 (2013) 988 – 996
! "#
" $#%& '( # )( *+ % (, -.!'.!% /0 1+ %&-"( "(&- (2 / .!'3&-4 4 &
" #$"
!
5 6#6 #% ( $#% & ' ( # ) ( 7 $# 8#62' (6 % ( 66# #% (6 ' # ' 9 # % "# 6 : %7 5 ; ' < ' =#
; <= 6&% - (-8 ;> ?? 6 5#+&% 3%3+@!3+-A+'3 -.!+ 2( 66 ( # )( 79 # - % 66 7 B5A#7#& &%" <7 © 2013 The Authors. Published by Elsevier Ltd. 6 # 6 & % 5A -"# 5 '% 5A "5- + % Selection and peer-review under responsibility of The Association of Science, Education and Technology-TASET, Sakarya Universitesi, : -5#+%7 Turkey. %& C $#%& '-# ( -( $# &#(
< & % + 6 % (6 (% '7 #'' # &(# # #'6 6 & % <# - ?D- E - ??E 5& - ??E 8 + '- ??F7 5% & 6 6( # )( ' # '- 6# # ' # 6 % $# 6 6 $#%& & % 7 G & + $# ' ' <# - ?DE 5& 8 '- ?DHE 5& - ??E <# - 7 # & # - ( % # ' <# 5 (- ?H?E 2( - ???E ,
6 ' #7 "( C!+7& % ((I'( 7(
1877-0428 © 2013 The Authors. Published by Elsevier Ltd. Selection and peer-review under responsibility of The Association of Science, Education and Technology-TASET, Sakarya Universitesi, Turkey. doi:10.1016/j.sbspro.2013.12.112
Zeki Bayram et al. / Procedia - Social and Behavioral Sciences 106 (2013) 988 – 996
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
989
990
Zeki Bayram et al. / Procedia - Social and Behavioral Sciences 106 (2013) 988 – 996
&# '6 ( ' $#%& J6( ( + '# 6 E #J6( # )( ' #6#675#- #' '$# C A % ' & # #' $#% & ' 66 J6( '#6 # #' # '#6 6 ' - J ' - + #- ' & - % ' 6 ( - J% ( (%#T #& 6& ( #% C A %' & # ); <=6 J6( '#6 '#6T A % ' & # ) ; <= 6 6 J6( '#6T A % ' & # ) ; <= 6 6 '#6T A % ' & # ) ; <= 6 J6( '#6 '#6T + , 1 $2 5#% # $# 8#62' 9 + N -ME8 % A -7 + + 3 A H# '26 ( % ; ( "# 9 # % "# 6: %6 6 7 + - # ; ' < ' =#
; <=C 5 ; ' < ' =#
(6 % ( # )( (%#75; <= 6 &% - (- 8 ;> ?? 6 5#+ &% 3%3+@!3+- A+'3 -.!+ 2( # # %# )( K#( # ' ' ' # # %7 5 ; <= (6 ( 6 C ( - ' '7 5 ( 6 ( #& ( ' 81-J ' "81- + #5U- '& 1<-
% ' 6 ( <- J% 5A75 # ( % % 6 (( # %# )( (% CVW X--89X7DH- A89X7HH G; "AX7H75 & % 7H 81-7FHF "81-7D? 5U-7H 1<-7? <- 7FM 5A4 -7 5 & ( + ( 6 ; <= & 7
Zeki Bayram et al. / Procedia - Social and Behavioral Sciences 106 (2013) 988 – 996
!,4 $ $ "& 2 ( 256 U # "J6 % A
9 ' "J ' 5 + # % '& 5 J%
"J6 < )& &#(6 + < )&  ( < )) +
3%3+@!3+-A+'3 -2( -L.!+ - + 7
5 & %!#';
N %: N J ' G +57 + 8 ( 5 ( $# &#( J6( $#%7 5 ( J6( 6 & % & # ' & > 9 # 7 J6( -'#6 # (- '#6  7 ' 6 C 5 J6( W& 7 5 C 6 ' 6 6& (7 5 6# # - ( # + # # > Y9 - #&75# +&6 ( # '7 G# C +& # 7 ( ( &#( $# &#(# 7 5% '##' $#% # ( $# &#(7 7( # # $#%C # 6+ ' 6 7 5 C6( # -## $#%-' ( 75 +# ( +(( & +& # & - #'C 66 T 7( # # (# #' (6 ( ) C5 C' # 6 - # (6 ( & 6+ ' # 7 5# (( & 71 '#6((& ' &(6 &%'#675'#6 +6 % 75
&#( $# &#( ( &% 7 ( $# &#(( %7 5 + $# C N 66 ( 9 # # T %#6 7 7 %6! 'C '( 6& (-'#6 # (%675 C 6 (# ' 6& (- (# ' %6- ' ' & 7 5 # ' %6 66 9 # (J#7 (%%6 -# & '-7 F75# %6J6( -& -$#
-#( -7 5 C 6( # #' ( + # (# %- ( + # % (6 7 (( $#% 7 -# # + ' + '%67
991
992
Zeki Bayram et al. / Procedia - Social and Behavioral Sciences 106 (2013) 988 – 996
M7 5 ' %6C 5 %6 ( ( J6( - & - $#
-#( 75 C& ''( #( 66 % ( $#% 7 & (9 # (J# #C + & # & 7 # $# 7 5 ' (6 $# 7 9 # # T-77777 H75# & -% 6 5 C 6 6 '# 75 & ' !75'#66 (6 7 D7 " %6 %C # %6 - % ' & + 6 7 5 C # ' 6 $#%7 %6 C 6 ' #66 ( ' % 7 (( 66 # 7 5 + ' & &% - #7 !+42 )9$ )
81
5U
1<
<
5A
H-
DH-F
?-
M?-F
MM-F
MD-
N J N
M-
FD-F
-
-F
FM-F
FD-
-
-FF
-D
-M
-H
-?
-
-
-?M
-D?
-?H
-
-
-?M
-D?
-?
*
"81
;
N %:
A%(67 '7
- "J '7Z,
- '[ 7 7 &78#6 'U & C8#6
A ';
N %: # - ' '#6 & 6 J ' :XDH-F-6\7F7 & ' & 6 # 6]7F !-4N J ' G +5G# *
81 "81 5U 1< < 5A
81 "81 5U 1< < 5A
-
-DF
A%(67 '7
-H - 7 ' +7 &7 6 +7 7N J ' G +5
-F
-
-D
-H&
-
-DDM
-M
-
Zeki Bayram et al. / Procedia - Social and Behavioral Sciences 106 (2013) 988 – 996
A 'N J ' G +5# - ' 6 & J ' !X -DF- 6\7F 6 6 # J6( '#67 & ' & 6 6 # 6]7F # 0 $ $
$ $ $#%& < ' " ! $" $ !) " J '
!74N J ' G +5G#
81 "81 5U 1< < 5A
81 "81 5U 1< < 5A
-MMH
*
-
A%(67 '7
-?M -?D 7 ' +7 &7 6 +7 7N J ' G +5
-FH
-DDH&
-?
-MF&
-M
-HF
-?F
-
A 'N J ' G +5# - ' 6 & J%!X -MF-6\7F6 6 # '#67 & ' & 6 6 # 6]7F !842 )9$ ) 1
81
"81
;
N %:
FF-F
H-
D-
N J N
M-F
DD-
-H
-M?
*
A%(67 '7
-MF "J '7Z,
-M '[ 7 7 &78#6 'U & C8#6
5U
1<
<
5A
M?-F
FD-F
D-
??-
F?-F
D-F
?D-
-
-M
-D
-?H
-??
-?
-?M
-H
-F
-F
-??
-?M
-HH
-FH
A ';
N %: # - ' & 6 # J6( '#66]7F A ' # - # # ) J ' 6 66 7 "J ' # ' # ) ( (6 ' '' - '' 6 ( - (-8 -L;> -??75 ' #66 ' ' & # # ' $#% & 6( # ) ( - E &+ > - E ; J 7- E 5# 7- FE; -7 ( -8& - ( -N 9+ # $#%& # # ) '6 # '7
993
994
Zeki Bayram et al. / Procedia - Social and Behavioral Sciences 106 (2013) 988 – 996
#( 7- ??E " (- E <66- N - ;#(( 8# - ??E ( - $#%& (' # )( # % '# ( ( + '-6( 66# %# '# + 6 6K % 5# 7- F7 # - # ' # )( #& ( J ' ( 6 J6( 67 N # 6& ( + % &# # ) ( ' # '7 $#% & J6( & ( %%6( +# ( 75 $#% & J6( ( % & (6 ( # # %- # 66 6E 6 & ( + '6 &# ' & ( 7 A ' # # # #- ( % & # ( 75 -( + ' $#%& J6( $# 6 # 6 & (' # & 7 66 #- ( %%6 & ( %&(( 7
A& " > +- 97-#O #- 7- 2# - G7- <( - 787- ; ( + ( - G7- - A7- !- ;7- 5 '#- 27 5# - 7<7 7 $#% # C 667 ?H ?7 A%S#- 7 "' - .7 D7 9 5+ K +# 0 + 0 % + + @S & ( 3/ & + 7 0 : " 0
;*-F M7 +#-<7F7A% #6#7 $ $ <+H-F FD7 3%3+@!3+- 47- A+'3 - .7 "7- 2( - 97 .!+ - .7 7 833 ( .S ( K . /S) 53+/ (# # '/ +'3 +/ 0^( 07% " 0" : " " 7-H ?7 -7A77"(& ' $#%C 7= 1 $ $ 0-<?- ?M ?H7 2->7;7F7 # 6 ' ' $#% & &7= #$" +-HD D7 2( -27 7???7A & % # % 7= #$" < -F FH7 9 + - O7G7 N - 7"7 M7 & 0 $ M 77 P+C ;8 + (6 %7 8 - 7O7 + '- ;7N7 ??F7 G # ' (% &C A & % & ' 7 $ = -7,-M7 8 %- <7 G7 A - 7 7 1 $4 # "
M 77 " ' - OC 7 8& - 7<7 - 7 7 < '# (6 $#% & 6' ( ( # ) # 7 -M? HF7 #%-27??7 $ 0 $ 0$ > 7"G 2#( G6# 7"2F?D7 -27??7A + 6 + ' 7$ 1 &<,-7
Zeki Bayram et al. / Procedia - Social and Behavioral Sciences 106 (2013) 988 – 996 -A7 <# U7 775 & % # C9# % #%7 -D F7 -A7- -G7 >6 -;77 '' (%# 66# 6 '+ $#%
%6 & %CA #%7? = + -H M7 -A7 <# -U7 7?D75 & % 'C ' 6 71 & 1 $8+-H7 -A7 <# U7 775 & % # C9# % #%7 -D F7 -A7 <# -U7 775 & % # C9# % _ #%7 - DF7 - A7- #( 57 <7 G7 7 A( < ' " ( $#% 5%6 < & ' (%75 0 " 1 $7-? H7 &+- O7 > - O7 <77 ' 6( $#% & (7 $ ? # $5 0 H7 O - ;7"7-8- G7 O ( - G7 7 ' 6 +% ' ## #( 7 1 $ ,7- H7 <-57 1+ ! +-57M7; ' ( $#% & # & %7" 0 $ M- F7 <# -U7 75 (-7?H?7; ' & '' 7 $ $ 7 F- 7 ; ->7G77 $ > )! " "
$ 0$ $ ! 0
"7 ; 5-; : %-!( -; 7 ; J-G7N7- #( - 7 7-> K+-O7 7-9( -7- %-"7- 8-G7G -57577 $#% & ( ' CA( ' #& %( (7= 1 $ $ 07,-M D7 ; %- 7<7- 8 - ;797-L>+7 G7 M7 # ' (% & %C A( # '7 = #$" -F-D7 ;- 7- (- 27 * - :7 H7 #6 % ' 6( ' + ' + C A + '71 $ -<-FM?7 %- U7 G7-L 7 7 G 7 7 $ & "@ $" $ 0 0 "4 @" " > )! 07A ""W"""9 "# -G 7 - 7G7- (- 27A797- 8 - 57 ;> - N7O7 ??7 A ( # # ( ' ' $#
; <=7A
A&-;C G (6 %5 ' < '-5: % ;' 7 = '-*7-O '-87 P -N77( '6 ) + '+ &% $#% & ( J6( 7( $ +-F?HM7 1 %- ;7-A - 27 # - N797 # - O7 L- A7 7 " ' ( C 5 '
# 7= #$" ,-D7 1 %- ;7-LA -27 F7 A# # ' ( 7 = #$" +M-??7 G#& - 7??M7 ")
$ $! " !0 0 0 7 27-5(6 : %7
995
996
Zeki Bayram et al. / Procedia - Social and Behavioral Sciences 106 (2013) 988 – 996 ( - 57A7- N- 7P7 9+ - O7G7 7 # ) ' ' $#% + (_ & 7? = -M7 %( +%-O7- '-<7-LN -87??7A ( $#% & ## M) # 6 ( 7= 1 $ $ 0+<-H7 (- 27 ??M7 ")
" !! $ $ 0 > " "$ 0727-5(6 : %7 4 - 47 7 % " : A " " A B: " " " CBDE " B: !A F F "
P3++< 5!7A + C 6` 9 ( " 337 5 - 7-L >##- ;7 M7 5 $#% & ' 66 # ( ( 7 G : " E 0
-,-H FD7 5& ->7??7G & % C 6## &$# (6 '7$ 2$" ; D7 5& ->7 8 '-O7O7?DH7N 66 ' (T= # " ,;M-F? FM7 5# - 7<- - 7 7-5 - 7 7 '- 797F7 ' ' $#% # ( '% # 7? = 2$" --F FMM7