From war to peace Arab-Israeli relations 1973–1993

Book reviews

264 meetings makes

and

the

UNCED

the subtitle

less, this volume UNCED

contains

process

politics

which

literature

process.

somewhat and

useful

useful

section

Nonethe-

critiques

of global

offer

of the

place

the present

to the

Sadat’s much

predicament.

Department of Geography, Carleton University, B-349 Loeh Building, 1125 Colonel L3yDrive,

that

all,

Shamir,

Dalby

change

here

that

started

with

1970s.

There

the

One

that

policy

From War to Peace Araklsraeli 19Z+1993 Barry Rubin, Joseph Moshe

Ma’oz

Brighton,

(eds),

Sussex

Relations Ginat

and

Academic

and

Oslo

odization

Press,

volume,

a conference mixed

held by

While some

peace

some

highly

respectable

from

reflecting

sized

volume

short

and

debate. new

too

Indeed,

here,

some variety

and

of the many

peace

is divided

into

first of which

claims

of the

political

1973 war.

This

three

big figures-Ezer

and

Yossi

Barry

of

a

of the

learn

rhetoric belief

necessarily

perceptive,

if too

reflection

introduction

bias

of

the

the best solution it addresses

can and do

chapter

prede-

is a rather and

a solution, of justice

restrain

that

genuine

continued

for

national

succinct

of obstacles

survey

this

can

book

criticism’,

be

pursue

One

the same

is no oil under provides

a in

on Russia and the (and

more

space).

that, for the most part,

represents

a

Behind

a facade

there

the

ill-informed

to disarmament

attention

no doubt

or

instead

rights.

Titorenko

while the chapters deserve

perceptions.

and

that Israel has not suffered there

It

con-

to observe

blindly

because

and

occupation

through

Vladimir

There

European

build-up

Palestinian

Asher

to whine.

failure

Europeans

fate as Iraq simply

it is

by

a the

on Europe

be said

the West Bank.

USA both

or

only

diaand

on

is provided chapter

of their oil supplies

might argue

and

Ma’oz,

contribution

its nuclear

complains

the

possible-regardissues

by Moshe

Minerbi’s

for

throughand concise

laws, to end a brutal

the region,

black-and-white policy,

to

support

provide

their

over

international

security

of subjective

(and

foreign

worth

although

Beilin

that statesmen Sisco’s

by

are

them,

and

their

for Sisco

to the Oslo

positions

in Jordan

Itzhak

Israel’s

if the LJSA defines

rights.

Susser.

cerns

section

of which for under-

at the potential

short,

dismisses

the

from

less of whether national

so far is given

incorrectly

Joseph

both

East’. An articulate

since

Weizman,

Society

reading

agreement

of Syrian-Israeli

at work

Weizman

of American that

out the Middle logue

‘looks

processes

contain

mistakes,

frightening

section

East can

is a showcase

War),

the Israel-PLO

the Middle

wrote

evidence

cessors’)

final

extending

over-

contributions

lessons

the

and

in Israel‘s

the background

a broad

for who

While

reassuring

studying

to provide

These

inevitably

parts,

Kippur

in

(Policy

process.

summary

provide

aspects

an

simply

interests.

peace

is found

Leadership)

(Changes

Yom

graduates The

or

deal that is

does

Beilin-with

Rubin.

reading they

in a

argument

four

Palestinian

serve well as required

Palestinians

volume

view

of the

and

his writing

Hassassian

the

process.

The

the

varied

Manuel

Eisenstadt

interests

the Israeli position.

Since

assessments

and

I>ynamics

of

Yair peri-

in the book

would

in a mid-

is not a great

chapters

Shmuel

are necessarily

the volume

thoughtful

the

of the

a useful

although

his role in presenting of the best work

PLO

after.

in the

as from

its origins

of substantive there

con-

Some

changes

five

and

period

provides

it suffers

as well

that many

a

in the

academics,

accurately

although

tidy

from

actors

to fit 24 chapters

means

devoid

it benefits

process,

Trying

of

in 1993, deserves

prominent

Arab-Israeli

conference.

is the end-product

in Israel

reception.

tributions

which

includes

Israeli the

of the two parties,

reflects This edited

have usefully

immediately

contribution

are

feeling

detail.

during and

of the

policies

1994, 244 pp.

interests

Hirschfeld’s

could

to analyse

negotiations

Shimon

Shemesh

of the volume

seek

is not

the section

fragmentary

The third section

Anwar

by

Moshe

finishes

to

or enlightening

chapters

chapter

so much

chapters

new

Sella and

that one substantive replaced

attempt

into the chain

of the

although

reading.

interesting

chapters

process

is really

Amnon

worth

the most

Seven

peace

initiatives

after Simon

is potentially

of the book.

of historical

environmental

contributions

on our contemporary

Part Two

All this

suspect.

very

Israeli

set

of ‘objective

is a prevailing

and

of self-

implicit

Book reuieuls assertion

throughout

was always

Arab

stumbling

block

concessions

much

that

that proved

to peace.

It is assumed

it

to be tangible

Israel

required

is

only

positional

changes.

Oslo

years

two

conceded

the

to

the

is that

reality

that

lesbian

hope

a great

of

offers and

well

only

the

always

the book

reflects

with a

linguistic

manipulation

of Israeli,

Arab and western

language

moderacy

of

equates

question

for human the

evident

the

current

the process,

may

albeit

or

argue

for

they

functional

and realistic

than

agreed

and

supplirs.

control

those

ates’ in the Palestinian Oslo

are now

tionistx

who

easily

of

call

a

for

water

‘moder-

were cause

national

may

of Israeli

Palestinian who

as radical

rejec-

to

demonized

for

be

questioning

whether

has resulted

from the Washington

the peace

truly the heir to the principles

process

which

Agreement

which

is

it claimed

C. Murphy

He

turous

spirit of individualistic is that Irish emigration

been.

a social

cesses

at the

processes

response level

that

British

whole.

tion.

claiming

about

the

analysis

about Edited

various

aspects

Irish Times columnist aims

of contemporary

by the well-known to

overviews

provide

Fintan accessible

of key issues

Ireland.

Irish intellectual O’Toole, and

and

the series so

to sustain

on the

this al-j+-

the evidence he omits)

Thus he seems decades

f;lils

reluctant

have seen a

of Irish emigratoo soon

to talk

or gentrification

is presented

capitalist

development

emigration,

of

first

‘emigrant

of capital

to show

the last century.

to North America

alone of

in the period

Ireland

if somewhat

and 20thcentury

the

After

the

emigrated to

1925; 6.5

in 1901. Equally

less massive, migrations

of the British

and

from

xvere the

to Britain.

by the 1860s Irish labour a tenth

Ireland for

LIP

halved

in 1841 to 3.2 million

fact already

how

accumulation-Britain

the

significant,

and

Ireland.

nursery’

of the 1840s. 4 million

population

the rela-

colonialism

ideas from Marx, Grdmsci

theory

an

a largely

with

in 19th.century

employs

became

through

starting

and worlcl-systems

for nearly

provocative

such as (to list those

in Europe. and,

arise when

treatment,

between

19th

power

it is much

tionship

million

via

economics

Hews.

America-in

books

pro-

economy-

themselves

in the nature

that

Famine

of short

world

modernization

Great

series

to restructuring

that recent

change

North

028 0

His has

an energetic

the thesis.

Press, Cork, 1994 (‘Undercurrents’

88 pp.

young

attempt

to acknowledge

new-wave

adults.

is, and always

(let alone that which

LIP to

qualitative

of the adven-

transatlantic

A few problems

he describes

(post-

economic

makes

successful

ment.

recent

of ‘newwave’

expressed

rule,

of em-

about

of the

have

colonial

MacLaughlin

causes

scathing

thesis

atheor-

for they fail to

as an expression

centres

is a useful

its

since pre-

of factual,

structural

interpretations

Ireland: i%e Emipaut Nunely and the World Economy: Jim MacLaughlin, Cork University

‘Ilndercurrents

if not in

as an impor-

accounts,

is equally

MacLaughlin

&I.95 pbk ISBN 1 85918

is very

consistent

emigration

the underlying

gration.

chronological

series),

and Jim

which

of Irish society

etical and cost-benefit

The

to uphold Emma

perva-

provoking,

times. He is dismissive

to live

before

dismissed

deserve

regards

and, most recently,

arrange-

or they

the future

over

In any case,

inter-

radicals.

economic

over

of

in place may

in Paris,

raise concerns

settlements

with

thought and

1980) emigration

Those

over concerns

democracy

ment simply

MacLaughlin

behavioural

process,

are labelled

more

In

of the spirit

compliance

authoritarianism, was

peace

the fulfilment

Accord.

Arafat’s

alike.

and

for at least 150 years,

an analysis

balanced

define

in the speeches

politicians

legal requirements

They

trend in

with Arab compliance.

rights,

Oslo

national

written

of infor-

case for treatment’,

tant diagnostic feature

long-term

a worrying

a ‘suitable

funds,

freedom

arguments.

on the other

their

and

an established

is clearly

not

unemployment,

EU structural

of Irish society

MacLaughlin

famine

In places

who

Emigration,

of

aspirations.

the

mation.

has

series)

and gay politics,

or

deal more

gaining

the

feminism,

verbal

of occupation,

have conceded

in

crime,

sive feature

while

Israel

The Palestinians,

published

divorce,

evidence

make

Indeed, later

form that it takes. receding

and substantive,

far

the

on the part of the Arab states or the

PLO have

hand,

of the book

intransigence

265

workforce,

this excl~~clccl the tens of thousands

In

accounted ancl

of seasonal