Journal Pre-proofs PET Image Reconstruction Using Physical and Mathematical Modelling For Time of Flight PET-MR Scanners in the STIR Library Palak Wadhwa, Kris Thielemans, Nikos Efthimiou, Kristen Wangerin, Nicholas Keat, Elise Emond, Timothy Deller, Ottavia Bertolli, Daniel Deidda, Gaspar Delso, Michel Tohme, Floris Jansen, Roger N. Gunn, William Hallett, Charalampos Tsoumpas PII: DOI: Reference:
S1046-2023(19)30193-8 https://doi.org/10.1016/j.ymeth.2020.01.005 YMETH 4847
To appear in:
Methods
Received Date: Revised Date: Accepted Date:
31 July 2019 15 November 2019 14 January 2020
Please cite this article as: P. Wadhwa, K. Thielemans, N. Efthimiou, K. Wangerin, N. Keat, E. Emond, T. Deller, O. Bertolli, D. Deidda, G. Delso, M. Tohme, F. Jansen, R.N. Gunn, W. Hallett, C. Tsoumpas, PET Image Reconstruction Using Physical and Mathematical Modelling For Time of Flight PET-MR Scanners in the STIR Library, Methods (2020), doi: https://doi.org/10.1016/j.ymeth.2020.01.005
This is a PDF file of an article that has undergone enhancements after acceptance, such as the addition of a cover page and metadata, and formatting for readability, but it is not yet the definitive version of record. This version will undergo additional copyediting, typesetting and review before it is published in its final form, but we are providing this version to give early visibility of the article. Please note that, during the production process, errors may be discovered which could affect the content, and all legal disclaimers that apply to the journal pertain.
© 2020 Published by Elsevier Inc.
S1h AK;2 _2+QMbi`m+iBQM lbBM; S?vbB+H M/ Ji?2KiB+H JQ/2HHBM; 6Q` hBK2 Q7 6HB;?i S1h@J_ a+MM2`b BM i?2 ahA_ GB#``v SHF q/?r-# - E`Bb h?B2H2KMb+ - LBFQb 17i?BKBQm/ - E`Bbi2M qM;2`BM2 - LB+?QHb E2i# - 1HBb2 1KQM/+ - hBKQi?v .2HH2`2 - PiipB "2`iQHHB+ - .MB2H .2B//-; - :bT` .2HbQ7 - JB+?2H hQ?K22 - 6HQ`Bb CMb2M2 - _Q;2` LX :mMM# - qBHHBK >HH2ii# - *?`HKTQb hbQmKTb-# "BQK2/B+H
AK;BM; a+B2M+2 .2T`iK2Mi- a+?QQH Q7 J2/B+BM2- lMBp2`bBiv Q7 G22/b- lE # AMpB+`Q- GQM/QM- lE Q7 Lm+H2` J2/B+BM2- lMBp2`bBiv *QHH2;2 GQM/QM- lE / S1h _2b2`+? *2Mi`2- 6+mHiv Q7 >2Hi? a+B2M+2b- lMBp2`bBiv Q7 >mHH- lE 2 :1 >2Hi?+`2- qmF2b?- qA- la 7 :1 >2Hi?+`2- *K#`B/;2- lE ; LiBQMH S?vbB+H G#Q`iQ`v- h2//BM;iQM- lE + AMbiBimi2
#bi`+i h?Bb rQ`F /2KQMbi`i2b ?Qr +QKTmiiBQMH M/ T?vbB+H KQ/2HHBM; Q7 i?2 TQbBi`QM 2KBbbBQM iQKQ;`T?v US1hV BK;2 +[mBbBiBQM T`Q+2bb 7Q` bii2@Q7@i?2@`i BMi2;`i2/ S1h M/ K;M2iB+ `2bQMM+2 BK;BM; US1h@J_V bvbi2K +M T`Q/m+2 BK;2b +QKT`#H2 iQ i?2 KMm7+im`2`X h?2 :1 aA:L S1hfJ_ b+MM2` Bb KMm7+im`2/ #v :2M2`H 1H2+i`B+ M/ ?b iBK2@Q7@~B;?i UhP6V +T#BHBiB2b Q7 #Qmi jNy TbX HH bQ7ir`2 /2p2HQTK2Mi iQQF TH+2 BM i?2 aQ7ir`2 7Q` hQKQ;`T?B+ AK;2 _2+QMbi`m+iBQM UahA_, ?iiT,ffbiB`Xb7XM2iV HB#``v r?B+? Bb rB/2Hv mb2/ QT2M bQm`+2 bQ7ir`2 iQ `2+QMbi`m+i /i b 2tTQ`i2/ 7`QK 2KBbbBQM iQKQ;`T?v b+MM2`bX h?2 M2r bQ7ir`2 /2p2HQTK2Mib rBHH #2 BMi2;`i2/ BMiQ ahA_ T`QpB/BM; i?2 QTTQ`imMBiv 7Q` `2b2`+?2`b rQ`H/rB/2 iQ 2bi#HBb? M/ 2tTM/ i?2B` BK;2 `2+QMbi`m+iBQM K2i?Q/bX 6m`i?2`KQ`2i?Bb rQ`F Bb Q7 T`iB+mH` bB;MB}+M+2 b Bi T`QpB/2b i?2 }`bi pHB/iBQM Q7 hP6 S1h BK;2 `2+QMbi`m+iBQM 7Q` `2H b+MM2` /ib2ib mbBM; i?2 ahA_ HB#``vX h?Bb TT2` T`2b2Mib i?2 K2i?Q/QHQ;v- MHvbBb- M/ +`BiB+H Bbbm2b 2M+QmMi2`2/ BM BKTH2K2MiBM; M BM/2T2M/2Mi `2+QMbi`m+iBQM bQ7ir`2 T+F;2X +[mB`2/ S1h /i r2`2 T`Q+2bb2/ pB b2p2`H TT`QT`Bi2 H;Q`Bi?Kb r?B+? `2 M2+2bb`v iQ T`Q/m+2 M ++m`i2 M/ T`2+Bb2 [mMiBiiBp2 BK;2X h?Bb BM+Hm/2/ Ki?2KiB+H- T?vbB+H M/ MiQKB+H KQ/2HHBM; Q7 i?2 TiB2Mi M/ bBKmHiBQM Q7 p`BQmb bT2+ib Q7 i?2 +[mBbBiBQMX h?2b2 BM+Hm/2/ KQ/2HHBM; Q7 `M/QK +QBM+B/2M+2b mbBM; ǵbBM;H2bǶ `i2b T2` +`vbiHb/2i2+iQ` 2{+B2M+B2b M/ ;2QK2i`B+ 2z2+ibX ii2MmiBQM 2z2+ib r2`2 +H+mHi2/ #v mbBM; i?2 ahA_Ƕb ii2MmiBQM +Q``2+iBQM KQ/2HX JQ/2HHBM; HH i?2b2 2z2+ib rBi?BM i?2 bvbi2K Ki`Bt HHQr2/ i?2 `2+QMbi`m+iBQM Q7 S1h BK;2b r?B+? /2KQMbi`i2b i?2 K2i#QHB+ mTiF2 Q7 i?2 /KBMBbi2`2/ `/BQT?`K+2miB+HX h?2b2 BKTH2K2MiiBQMb r2`2 pHB/i2/ mbBM; K2bm`2/ T?MiQK M/ +HBMB+H /ib2ibX h?2 /2p2HQTK2Mib `2 i2bi2/ mbBM; i?2 Q`/2`2/ bm#b2i 2tT2+iiBQM KtBKBbiBQM UPa1JV M/ i?2 KQ`2 `2+2MiHv T`QTQb2/ F2`M2HBb2/ 2tT2+iiBQM KtBKBbiBQM UE1JV H;Q`Bi?K r?B+? BM+Q`TQ`i2b MiQKB+H BM7Q`KiBQM 7`QK J_ BK;2b BMiQ S1h `2+QMbi`m+iBQMX E2vrQ`/b, SQbBi`QM 1KBbbBQM hQKQ;`T?v- ahA_- S1hfJ_- hQKQ;`T?v- AK;2 _2+QMbi`m+iBQM RX AMi`Q/m+iBQM SQbBi`QM 2KBbbBQM iQKQ;`T?v US1hV Bb M BKTQ`iMi iQKQ;`T?B+ BK;BM; KQ/HBiv rBi? T`iB+mH` /2THQvK2Mi BM +`/BQHQ;v (R)- M2m`QHQ;v (k) M/ QM+QHQ;vX h?2 bm++2bb@ 7mH miBHBiv Q7 S1h BM i?2b2 #`M+?2b Q7 K2/B+BM2 +M #2 b22M #v Bib BM+`2bBM; mb2 7Q` p`BQmb +HBMB+H BM/B+iBQMbX S1h b+Mb `2 MQM@BMpbBp2 M/ ?2HT7mH BM 2`Hv /B;MQbBb M/ KM;2K2Mi Q7 +QM/BiBQMb bm+? b BM S`FBMbQMǶb /Bb@ 2b2 (j)- /2K2MiB (9- 8)- +Q`QM`v `i2`v /Bb2b2 (e) M/ QM@ +QHQ;v (d) #v [mMiBiiBp2Hv bb2bbBM; K2i#QHB+ M/ 7mM+@ iBQMH Hi2`iBQMb (3)X S1h b+Mb `2 HbQ +HBMB+HHv mb27mH 1KBH //`2bb2b, TXr/?r!H22/bX+XmF USHF q/?rV+XibQmKTb!H22/bX+XmF U*?`HKTQb hbQmKTbV S`2T`BMi bm#KBii2/ iQ J2i?Q/b
BM KQMBiQ`BM; i?2 T`Q;`2bbBQM Q7 /Bb2b2b M/ i?2 TiB2MiǶb `2bTQMb2 iQ i?2`Tv (N)X "2BM; Q7 BMi2`2bi BM #Qi? i?2 +HBMB+H M/ `2b2`+? +QKKmMBiB2b- THi7Q`K i?i +M `2/BHv T`QpB/2 M QT2M 7`K2rQ`F iQ `2+QMbi`m+i /i Bb Q7 ?B;? bB;MB}@ +M+2X h?2 `2+QMbi`m+iBQM bQ7ir`2 mb2/ BM i?Bb rQ`F Bb M QT2M bQm`+2 HB#``v #b2/ QM Q#D2+i@Q`B2Mi2/ T`Q;`K@ KBM; +HH2/ ǵaQ7ir`2 7Q` hQKQ;`T?B+ AK;2 _2+QMbi`m+@ iBQMǶ UahA_, ?iiT,ffbiB`Xb7XM2iV (Ry)X ahA_ Bb rB/2Hv mb2/ *YY HB#``v T`QpB/BM; iQQHb iQ `2+QMbi`m+i 2KBbbBQM iQ@ KQ;`T?v BK;2b rBi? HH /i +Q``2+iBQMb bm+? b MQ`@ KHBbiBQM- ii2MmiBQM- `M/QKb M/ b+ii2` 2biBKiBQMX ahA_ HbQ HHQrb KMBTmHiBQM Q7 T`QD2+iBQM /i M/ BK@ ;2b- BK;2 MHvbBb M/ MHviB+H bBKmHiBQMbX Ai Bb CMm`v kN- kyky
/2bB;M2/ iQ #2 KQ/mH` M/ ?b M BM?2`BiM+2 #2ir22M +Hbb2bX h?Bb HHQrb +Hbb 2ti2MbBQM M/ i?mb +M BM+Q`TQ@ `i2 MQp2H H;Q`Bi?Kb M/ b+MM2` ;2QK2i`B2b +QMp2MB2MiHv rBi?Qmi i?2 M22/ iQ `2@BKTH2K2Mi 2tBbiBM; ii`B#mi2b M/ 7mM+iBQMbX h?Bb bi`m+im`2 T`QpB/2b THi7Q`K iQ i?2 S1h `2b2`+? +QKKmMBiv r?2`2 i?2 HB#``v Bb 2tTM/#H2 iQ dz}i i?2 M22/bǴ Q7 M2r mb2`b b i?2 }2H/ T`Q;`2bb2b #v /2`Bp@ BM; M2r +Hbb2b 7`QK #bB+ #mBH/BM; #HQ+FbX 6Q` BMbiM+2iQ BKTH2K2Mi MQp2H Bi2`iBp2 `2+QMbi`m+iBQM H;Q`Bi?Kb- M 2tBbiBM; `2+QMbi`m+iBQM #b2 +Hbb bm+? b P`/2`2/ am#b2i JtBKmK SQbi2`BQ`B PM2 ai2T Gi2 +M #2 2ti2M/2/ M/ Qi?2` ahA_ 7mM+iBQMHBiB2b +M #2 `2mb2/ (RR)X _2+2Mi +QH@ H#Q`iBp2 2zQ`ib rBi?BM i?2 ahA_ /2p2HQT2`Ƕb +QKKmMBiv ?p2 H2/ iQ i?2 2ti2MbBQM Q7 i?2 HB#``v iQ MQp2H Bi2`iBp2 `2+QMbi`m+iBQM H;Q`Bi?Kb bm+? b i?2 F2`M2H 2tT2+iiBQM KtBKBxiBQM UE1JV (Rk) Q` KQ/2HHBM; iBKBM; BM7Q`KiBQM 7Q` iBK2@Q7@~B;?i UhP6V S1h (Rj)X S1h b+MM2`b K2bm`2 /i r?B+? `2 /B{+mHi iQ `2+QM@ bi`m+i- 2bT2+BHHv rBi? bm{+B2Mi ++m`+v rBi?Qmi FMQrBM; HH M2+2bb`v BM7Q`KiBQM T`QpB/2/ #v i?2 KMm7+im`2`X .2bTBi2 i?2 rB/2 `M;2 Q7 MQp2H Bi2`iBp2 `2+QMbi`m+iBQM H@ ;Q`Bi?Kb pBH#H2 rBi?BM ahA_- Bi +M #2 +?HH2M;BM; 7Q` mb2`b iQ ++m`i2Hv `2+QMbi`m+i /i K2bm`2/ 7`QK +HBMB+H Q` T`2+HBMB+H S1h b+MM2`bX PM2 M22/b iQ +`27mHHv BKTH2@ K2Mi T`QT`B2i`v b+MM2` /i 7Q`Kib ++m`i2Hv rBi?BM ahA_ b Bi +m``2MiHv bmTTQ`ib QMHv *hA 1*he- 1*hd M/ aB2K2Mb "BQ;`T? KJ_ }H2 7Q`KibX
2.8 KKVX 6m`i?2`- i?2`2 `2 4 #HQ+Fb T2` mMBi M/ 2+? #HQ+F ?b 4 × 9 +`vbiHbX 1+? #HQ+F 7m`i?2` ?b 3 × 6 ``v Q7 aBSJbX h?2 b+MM2` Bb +QM};m`2/ #v /2i2+iQ` KQ/mH2b TH+2/ M2ti iQ 2+? Qi?2` 7Q`KBM; +vHBM/`B+H #Q`2 rBi? /2i2+iQ` mMBib HQM; i?2 tBH /B`2+iBQMX h?mbi?2 b+MM2` ?b 45 /2i2+iQ` +`vbiHb HQM; i?2 tBH /B`2+@ iBQM M/ 448 /2i2+iQ`b `QmM/ i?2 b+MM2` KFBM; iQiH Q7 ky-Rey /2i2+iQ`bX h?2 KQ/mH2b `2 TH+2/ rBi? KQ/mH2 0 +2Mi2`2/ #Qp2 i?2 BbQ+2Mi2` Q7 i?2 b+MM2` r?B+? BK@ THB2b i?i +`vbiH 0 Bb MQi p2`iB+HHv #Qp2 i?2 +2Mi2` Q7 i?2 b+MM2`X *`vbiH y Bb HQ+i2/ i M Qzb2i Q7 −5.23◦ 7`QK i?2 p2`iB+H +2Mi2` r?2M pB2rBM; 7`QK i?2 #+F Q7 i?2 b+MM2`X h?2 GuaP +`vbiHb `2 5.3 KK HQM; i?2 tBH /B`2+iBQM3.95 KK HQM; i?2 i`MbtBH /B`2+iBQM M/ 25 KK /22TX qBi? i?2 7bi /2i2+iBQM 2H2+i`QMB+b Q7 i?2 b+MM2`- Bib iBK@ BM; `2bQHmiBQM Bb 390 TbX h?2 b+MM2` ?b +QBM+B/2M+2 iBKBM; rBM/Qr Q7 4.57 Mb M/ iBKBM; H2bi bB;MB}+Mi #Bi Q7 13.02 Tb /m`iBQM r?B+? H2/b iQ 351 iBKBM; #BMbX h?2 b+MM2` bp2b i?2b2 b bB;M2/ iBKBM; #BMb UBX2X MmK#2`2/ 7`QK @Rd8 iQ YRd8 #BMbV r?B+? i?2 bQ7ir`2 +QK#BM2b BM ;`QmTb Q7 13 iBKBM; #BMb- T`Q/m+BM; 27 bBMQ;`K iBKBM; #BMbX h?2 +QBM+B/2M+2 2p2Mib `2 biQ`2/ BM bBMQ;`K Q7 /BK2MbBQMb 224 × 1981 × 27 × 357- r?2`2 224 +Q``2bTQM/b iQ i?2 iQiH MmK#2` Q7 pB2rb- 1981 +Q``2bTQM/b iQ i?2 iQiH MmK#2` Q7 tBH TQbBiBQMb- 27 +Q``2bTQM/b iQ i?2 MmK#2` Q7 dzKb?2/Ǵ iBKBM; #BMb M/ 357 +Q``2bTQM/b iQ i?2 MmK@ #2` Q7 iM;2MiBH TQbBiBQMbX h?2 MmK#2` Q7 pB2rb `272`b iQ QM2@?H7 Q7 i?2 iQiH MmK#2` Q7 /2i2+iQ`b HQM; i?2 `BM; #v +QMp2MiBQMX h?2 b+MM2` T`K2i2`b `2 BM+Hm/2/ BM i?2 b+MM2` i2K@ THi2 +Hbb Ǵa+MM2`X+ttǴ (Rd)X h?Bb +Hbb biQ`2b i?2 `2H2@ pMi ;2QK2i`B+ BM7Q`KiBQM 7Q` S1h b+MM2`bX
RXRX P#D2+iBp2b h?2 BKb Q7 i?Bb rQ`F `2, RX JQ/2HHBM; Q7 i?2 :1 aA:L S1hfJ_ b+MM2`Ƕb +@ [mBbBiBQM T`Q+2bbX kX 1tTM/ ahA_ HB#``v iQ :1 7Q`KibX jX oHB/iBQM Q7 i?2 BK;2b `2+QMbi`m+i2/ #v ahA_ M/ i?2 p2M/Q`Ƕb bQ7ir`2X 9X .2KQMbi`iBQM Q7 `2+QMbi`m+iBQM mbBM; E1JX 8X .2KQMbi`iBQM Q7 hP6 `2+QMbi`m+iBQM mbBM; ahA_ HB@ #``v 7Q` K2bm`2/ /iX
kXkX a+MM2` JQ/2H h?2 `/BQ+iBp2 /Bbi`B#miBQM Q7 i?2 Q#D2+i TH+2/ rBi?BM i?2 b+MM2` Bb Ki?2KiB+HHv KQ/2HH2/ b 7QHHQrb, y = Ax + b,
URV
r?2`2 y `2T`2b2Mib i?2 +[mB`2/ bBMQ;`K K2bm`2K2MiA `2T`2b2Mib i?2 bvbi2K Ki`Bt r?2`2 A = [a pm ] - x `2T@ `2b2Mib i?2 BK;2 Q7 i?2 `/BQ+iBpBiv /Bbi`B#miBQM Q7 i?2 Q#D2+i M/ b `2T`2b2Mib i?2 #+F;`QmM/ +QBM+B/2M+2b U2X;X `M/QKb M/ b+ii2`VX h?2 bvbi2K Ki`Bt KQ/2Hb i?2 b2M@ bBiBpBiv i 2+? pQt2H m Q7 i?2 b+MM2` #v KQ/2HHBM; i?2 T`Q##BHBiv Q7 TQbBi`QM MMB?BHi2/ BM pQt2H m M/ #2BM; /2i2+i2/ b T?QiQM@TB` +QBM+B/2M+2 #v i?2 /2i2+iQ` TB` pX h?2 b2MbBiBpBiv Q7 2+? pQt2H m +QK#BM2b i?2 /2i2+iQ` 2{+B2M+v- ;2QK2i`B+ M/ ii2MmiBQM 2z2+ibX aT2+B}+HHv- i?2 hP6 BM7Q`KiBQM 7Q` i?2 K2bm`2/ bBMQ@ ;`K /i Bb KQ/2HH2/ rBi?BM i?2 7Q`r`/ KQ/2H b,
kX J2i?Q/b M/ Ji2`BHb kXRX :1 aA:L S1hfJ_ a+MM2` AM ahA_ :1 aA:L hP6 S1hfJ_ b+MM2` BMbiHH2/ i AMpB+`QAKT2`BH *QHH2;2 GQM/QM- >KK2`bKBi? >QbTBiH- GQM@ /QM- lE- rb mb2/ BM i?Bb bim/vX Ai Bb jh J_ b+MM2` i?i ?b M BMi2;`i2/ J_@+QKTiB#H2 S1h b+MM2` (R9)X h?2 S1h b+MM2` ?b }2H/ Q7 pB2r Q7 60 +K M/ 25 +K BM i`MbtBH M/ tBH /B`2+iBQMb- `2bT2+iBp2HvX Ai Bb +QK@ TQb2/ Q7 Hmi2iBmK@vii`BmK QtvQ`i?QbBHB+i2 UGuaPV +`vb@ iHb- bBHB+QM T?QiQKmHiBTHB2`b UaBSJV M/ Qi?2` T`Q+2bbBM; 2H2+i`QMB+b (R8)X h?2 aBSJ iQ;2i?2` rBi? i?2 GuaP +`vb@ iHb HHQr 7Q` hP6 BK;BM; (Re)X h?2 S1h +QKTQM2Mi Q7 :1 aA:L +QKT`Bb2b Q7 28 /2i2+iQ` KQ/mH2b M/ 2+? /2@ i2+iQ` KQ/mH2 ?b 5 /2i2+iQ` mMBib U2+? /2i2+iQ` mMBib `2 b2T`i2/ 7`QK i?2 M2ti mMBi #v +`vbiH@7`22 ;T Q7 bBx2
yt = Σm a ptm x + bt ,
UkV
r?2`2 yt `2T`2b2Mib i?2 iBK2 Q7 ~B;?i T`QD2+iBQM /i K2bm`2/ #v i?2 b+MM2` M/ i?2 bvbi2K Ki`Bt a ptm KQ/2Hb i?2 T`Q##BHBiv Q7 2p2Mi 2KBii2/ BM pQt2H m iQ #2 k
/2i2+i2/ #v /2i2+iQ` TB` p rBi?BM i?2 bB;M2/ iBKBM; #BM MmK#2`- tX
r?2`2 klm `2T`2b2Mib i?2 J_ F2`M2H BK;2X h?2 }MH λ BK;2 r?B+? +QMiBMb i?2 BM7Q`KiBQM Q7 BM@ i2`2bi UBX2X i?2 `/BQ+iBpBiv /Bbi`B#miBQMV Bb Q#iBM2/ #v TTHvBM; 2[miBQM U9V 7i2` i?2 Hbi Bi2`iBQM Q7 2[miBQM U8VX
AM i?Bb TT2`- i?2 r2HH FMQrM Q`/2`2/ bm#b2i 2tT2+@ iiBQM KtBKBbiBQM UPa1JV (R3) Bi2`iBp2 BK;2 `2+QM@ bi`m+iBQM H;Q`Bi?K Bb 2ti2M/2/ iQ BM+Hm/2 iBKBM; BM7Q`K@ iBQM UBX2X hP6@Pa1JV M/ J_ BM7Q`KiBQM UBX2X hP6@ E1JVX h?2b2 H;Q`Bi?Kb `2 mb2/ iQ `2+QMbi`m+i i?2 K2@ bm`2/ bBMQ;`K yt b K2bm`2/ #v i?2 b+MM2`X *m``2MiHv QMHv bBMQ;`K@#b2/ `2+QMbi`m+iBQMb `2 /2KQMbi`i2/X
kXjX :1 aA:L S1hfJ_ a+MM2` +[mBbBiBQM .i BM ahA_ AK;2 `2+QMbi`m+iBQM Q7 /i +[mB`2/ rBi? i?2 :1 b+M@ M2` mbBM; ahA_ HB#``v `2[mB`2b i?2 BM+Q`TQ`iBQM Q7 BMTmi M/ QmiTmi BM7Q`KiBQM i?i +QMp2`i i?2 /i BMiQ M +@ +2bbB#H2 /i 7Q`KiX aT2+B}+HHv- i?2 QmiTmi }H2b bp2/ #v i?2 b+MM2` +QMbQH2 i i?2 2M/ Q7 S1h b+M BM+Hm/2,
kXkXRX hP6@Pa1J H;Q`Bi?K h?2 hP6@Pa1J H;Q`Bi?K rb /2b+`B#2/ BM (Rj)X H@ i?Qm;? i?2 hP6 2tTMbBQM Q7 i?2 ahA_ HB#``v rb `2@ +2MiHv BKTH2K2Mi2/ M/ pHB/i2/ QM bBKmHi2/ /ib2ib (Rj)- i?Bb Bb i?2 }`bi iBK2 i?i i?2 BKTH2K2MiiBQM Bb i2bi2/ QM +[mB`2/ /ib2ibX h?2 hP6@Pa1J H;Q`Bi?K Bb /2b+`B#2/ b 7QHHQrb, xmj+1 =
xmj s∈S j
a sm
s∈S j
a st;m
y st j k a st;k xk + b st
,
RX GBbiKQ/2 UGJV M/ bBMQ;`K `r /i }H2b U_.6V +QKT`2bb2/ rBi? i?2 :1 T`QT`B2i`v +QKT`2bbBQM H@ ;Q`Bi?K kX _r /i +HB#`iBQM }H2b BM+Hm/BM; MQ`KHBbiBQM- ;2@ QK2i`B+ M/ r2HH +QmMi2` +HB#`iBQM 7+iQ`b jX S1h AK;2b 6Q` ii2MmiBQM USA6V }H2b UBX2X T`Q@ +2bb2/ S1h ii2MmiBQM +Q``2+iBQM U*V BK;2b Q#@ iBM2/ #v +QMp2`iBM; J_ BK;2b +[mB`2/ mbBM; J_ b2[m2M+2b BM+Hm/BM; x2`Q 2+?Q iBK2 M/ .BtQMV 9X _2+QMbi`m+i2/ S1h BK;2b rBi? `2+QMbi`m+iBQM b2i@ iBM;b b2H2+i2/ i i?2 iBK2 Q7 b+M
UjV
r?2`2 xmj `2T`2b2Mib i?2 BMi2MbBiv Q7 mth pQt2H BM BK;2 mT/i2/ Qp2` i?2 bm#@Bi2`iBQM j- y st `2T`2b2Mib i?2 bm#b2i s Q7 hP6 T`QD2+iBQM /i 7Q` hP6 #BM t- a st;m `2T`2b2Mib i?2 T`Q##BHBiv Q7 M 2p2Mi Q++m``BM; BM pQt2H K #2BM; /2i2+i2/ #v /2i2+iQ` TB` s rBi?BM i?2 iBKBM; #BM t- b st `2T`2b2Mib i?2 +Q``2+iBQM i2`K iQ ++QmMi 7Q` i?2 bmK Q7 `M/QKb M/ b+ii2` 2p2Mib UQ` b rBHH #2 `272``2/ iQ #+F;`QmM/ i2`KV 7Q` bm#b2i s M/ iBKBM; #BM t M/ S j `2T`2b2Mib i?2 bm#b2i Q7 /2i2+iQ` TB`bX LQi2 i?i QM2 7mHH Bi2`iBQM- Q` bBKTHv K2MiBQM2/ b Bi2`iBQM- +Q``2bTQM/b iQ 7mHH +v+H2 Q7 bm#@Bi2`iBQMb +`Qbb HH bm#b2ib UBX2X Bi2`iBQMb 4 bm#@ Bi2`iBQMbfbm#b2ibVX
HH i?2 QmiTmi `r /i }H2b `2 BM :1 T`QT`B2i`v /i 7Q`Ki M/ +M #2 T`Q+2bb2/ Q|BM2 bQH2Hv rBi? i?2 :1Ƕb T`QT`B2i`v `2+QMbi`m+iBQM bQ7ir`2X :1 biQ`2b /i M/ ?2/2` BM7Q`KiBQM BM >B2``+?B+H .i 6Q`Ki 8 U>.68V }H2 7Q`KiX >.68 }H2b BM+Hm/2, RX aBMQ;`K _.6 ;2M2`HHv +HH2/ Ƕ`/7XRXRǶ kX GJ }H2 ;2M2`HHv +HH2/ ǶGAahyyyyX"G6Ƕ jX LQ`KHBbiBQM /i }H2- ǶMQ`Kj/Ƕ- M/ ;2QK2i`B+ +Q`@ `2+iBQM /i }H2- Ƕ;2Qj/Ƕ
kXkXkX hP6@E1J H;Q`Bi?K h?2 E1J H;Q`Bi?K rb }`bi T`QTQb2/ #v qM; 2i HX (RN) M/ rb /2p2HQT2/ BM ahA_ HB#``v #v .2B// 2i HX(Rk- ky)X h?Bb ?b #22M MQr 2ti2M/2/ 7m`i?2` iQ ++QK@ KQ/i2 hP6 /i b r2HHX h?2 H;Q`Bi?K bbmK2b i?i M BK;2 Bb /2b+`B#2/ #v i?2 bmK Q7 MmK#2` Q7 r2B;?i2/ F2`M2Hb- M/ Bi i`B2b iQ `2+QMbi`m+i i?2 r2B;?i Q7 2+? F2`@ M2H #v bbmKBM; Bi FMQrb i?2 F2`M2H 7`QK MQi?2` bQm`+2 Q7 BM7Q`KiBQM U2X;X J_AV, xm =
Nm
h?2b2 }H2b `2 mb2/ b BMTmi iQ pHB/i2 i?2 BKTH2K2Mi@ iBQM Q7 i?2 +[mBbBiBQM KQ/2H 7Q` i?Bb b+MM2` BM ahA_X >Qr2p2`- ahA_ ?b Bib QrM MiBp2 bBMQ;`K /i 7Q`@ Ki- mb2/ b BMTmi 7Q` i?2 Bi2`iBp2 M/ MHviB+H `2+QM@ bi`m+iBQM H;Q`Bi?KbX h?mb- HH i?2 >.68 }H2b M22/ iQ #2 +QMp2`i2/ BMiQ ahA_ MiBp2 BMi2`}H2 7Q`Ki (Rd)X r`T@ T2` +Hbb rb +`2i2/ iQ BKTQ`i i?2 >.68 }H2b /m`BM; i?Bb rQ`FX >.68r`TT2` +Hbb ?b 7mM+iBQMb BKTH2K2Mi2/ iQ ++2bb M/ `2/ i?2 `2[mB`2/ BM7Q`KiBQM r?B+? Bb 7m`i?2` KQ/2HH2/ rBi?BM i?2 bvbi2K Ki`Bt b /Bb+mbb2/ BM b2+iBQM kX9X
U9V
λ f k f m,
f =1
r?2`2 pHm2 i pQt2H m Q7 BK;2 xm `2T`2b2Mib i?2 HBM2` +QK#BMiBQM Q7 i?2 F2`M2H Ki`Bt Uk f m `2T`2b2Mib Bib f mth 2H2K2MibV- Nm `2T`2b2Mib i?2 MmK#2` Q7 72im`2 p2+iQ`b M/ F2`M2H r2B;?ib λX h?2 F2`M2H r2B;?ib `2 `2+QMbi`m+i2/ b 7QHHQrb, λmj+1 =
λmj
l klm
s∈S j
a st;m
l
klm
s∈S j
a st;m
l
a st;l
kX9X AKTH2K2MiiBQM Q7 i?2 +[mBbBiBQM KQ/2H BM ahA_ kX9XRX hP6 +[mBbBiBQM .i BM ahA_ hP6 BM7Q`KiBQM Bb BKTH2K2Mi2/ BM ahA_ rBi?BM i?2 bvbi2K Ki`Bt b,
y st f
, k f l λ jf + b st U8V
a pt;m = a pm T ptm . j
UeV
h?Bb 2[miBQM KQ/2Hb i?2 hP6 BM7Q`KiBQM b iBK2 bT`2/ 7mM+iBQM- T ptm 7Q` 2+? iBK2 #BM t M/ b2T`i2b Bi 7`QK i?2 b2MbBiBpBiv BM7Q`KiBQM- a pm X h?2 BKTH2K2M@ iiBQM ?b #22M `2+2MiHv T`2b2Mi2/ M/ pHB/i2/ BM bBKm@ Hi2/ /i (Rj)- #mi MQi v2i 7Q` +[mB`2/ /iX h?2 b+MM2` bp2b i?2 /2i2+iQ` TB` M/ iBKBM; BM7Q`@ KiBQM BM GJ M/ bBMQ;`K _.6bX h?2 /i bp2/ BM i?2 GJ >.68 }H2 Bb ++2bbB#H2 #v MpB;iBM; iQ i?2 }2H/ +HH2/ ǵfGBbi.ifGBbi.iǶ (kR- Rd)X GJ }H2b biQ`2 2+? 2p2Mi Q7 M +[mBbBiBQM b 6 #vi2 bi`m+im`2X h?Bb BM@ +Hm/2b BM7Q`KiBQM bm+? b i?2 +`vbiH B/2MiB}2`b UA.bV r?B+? `2;Bbi2`2/ i?2 +QBM+B/2Mi T?QiQMb M/ i?2 iBKBM; #BMX h?2 /2i2+iQ` TB` TQbBiBQMb `2 ?M/H2/ b tBH M/ i`MbtBH +QQ`/BMi2b rBi?BM i?2 dz*GBbiJQ/2.i:1a@ A:LǴ +Hbb Q7 ahA_X h?2 bB;M2/ hP6 #BM Bb ?M/H2/ rBi?BM i?2 dz*GBbi_2+Q`/:1aA:LǴ +HbbX h?Bb Bb /QM2 #v `2/BM; i?2 hP6 BM7Q`KiBQM HQM; rBi? i?2 hP6 ǴKb?@ BM;Ǵ BM7Q`KiBQM M/ mb2 hP6 T`QD2+iBQM /i- yt rBi?BM i?2 `2+QMbi`m+iBQM 7`K2rQ`FX AM i?2 +m``2Mi BKTH2K2M@ iiBQM- hP6 #BMb +M #2 Kb?2/ iQ;2i?2` iQ ;2i MQM@hP6 /iX h?2 /i Bb `2``M;2/ iQ #2 ++m`i2Hv `2/ BM ahA_ #v TTHvBM; i`Mb7Q`KiBQMb 7`QK b+MM2` bT+2 iQ ahA_ bT+2X h?2 M2ti bi2T iQ `2+QMbi`m+i S1h BK;2b rBi? ahA_ `2[mB`2b i?2 +H+mHiBQM Q7 i?2 b2MbBiBpBiv BK;2X h?Bb BM@ +Hm/2b KQ/2HHBM; Q7 /2i2+iQ` 2{+B2M+v- ;2QK2i`B+ M/ i@ i2MmiBQM 7+iQ`bX h?2 b2MbBiBpBiv BK;2b /2KQMbi`i2 i?2 bTiBH p`BiBQM Q7 2tT2+i2/ +QBM+B/2M+2b T2` mMBi +iBpBiv +QM+2Mi`iBQMX
kX9XjX SA6@#b2/ ii2MmiBQM *Q``2+iBQM ii2MmiBQM +Q``2+iBQM rb +``B2/ Qmi mbBM; b+MM2` 2ti`+i2/ SA6 BK;2bX h?Bb rb +?B2p2/ #v +`2iBM; +mbiQK b+`BTib i?i BKTQ`i2/ i?2 SA6 BK;2b rBi?BM i?2 ahA_ `2+QMbi`m+iBQM 7`K2rQ`F (Rd)X 6m`i?2`KQ`2- #+F;`QmM/ i2`K M22/b iQ #2 +H+mHi2/ iQ +Q``2+i 7Q` b+ii2` M/ `M/QK 2p2MibX kX9X9X AKTH2K2MiiBQM Q7 _M/QKb *Q``2+iBQM lbBM; aBM@ ;H2b _M/QKb `2 2biBKi2/ 7`QK bBM;H2b T2` +`vbiH 7Q` i?2 :1 aA:L (k9- k8), RXY = 2τS X S Y /T,
r?2`2 RXY Bb i?2 MmK#2` Q7 `M/QK 2p2Mib UQ` +QmMibV /2@ i2+i2/ #v i?2 /2i2+iQ` TB` X M/ Y- τ `2T`2b2Mib i?2 +QBM+B@ /2M+2 iBK2 rBM/Qr U4.57 Mb 7Q` i?Bb b+MM2`V- T `2T`2b2Mib i?2 iQiH +[mBbBiBQM iBK2- S X M/ S Y `2T`2b2Mi i?2 bBM;H2 2p2Mib /2i2+i2/ #v +`vbiH X M/ Y- `2bT2+iBp2HvX aBM;H2 `i2b 7Q` 2+? +`vbiH `2 2tTQ`i2/ 7`QK i?2 GJ >.68 }H2 M/ +QMp2`i2/ BMiQ `M/QK `i2b mbBM; i?2 ahA_ miBHBiv ǵ+QMbi`m+in`M/QKbn7`QKn:1bBM;H2bǶ BKTH2K2Mi2/ /m`@ BM; i?Bb rQ`FX aBM;H2b T2` b2+QM/ `2 /2i2+i2/ 7Q` 2p2`v +`vbiH M/ i?2M biQ`2/ b /ib2i rBi? /BK2MbBQMb 45 × 448 BM GJ >.68 }H2X 1+? +2HH Q7 i?2 /ib2i +Q``2bTQM/b iQ i?2 MmK#2` Q7 bBM;H2b /2i2+i2/ #v i?2 +`vbiH MmK#2` (X, Y) r?2`2 X +Q``2bTQM/b iQ i?2 `BM; MmK#2` M/ Y +Q``2bTQM/b iQ i?2 i`MbtBH +`vbiH MmK#2`X 6Q` M +[mBbBiBQM Q7 iBK2 Q7 N b2+QM/b- i?2`2 Bb HBbi Q7 N + 1 bKTH2bX h?2`2 `2 N + 1 bKTH2b b i?2 T2`BQ/B+ /i `2 bvM+?`QMQmb rBi? i?2 bi`i Q7 S1h b+M r?B+? M22/b iQ #2 iF2M BMiQ ++QmMi /m`BM; /i +H+mHiBQM #v r2B;?iBM; i?2 }`bi M/ Hbi bKTH2b Q7 i?2 T2`BQ/B+ /i TT`QT`Bi2HvX 1[miBQM U3V +H+mHi2b i?2 `M/QKb +Q``2+iBQM bBMQ;`K- r?B+? Bb Hi2` mb2/ 7Q` 2p2`v hP6 #BM 7i2` /BpB/BM; Bi rBi? i?2 iQiH MmK#2` Q7 iBKBM; #BMbX AM i?2 +m``2Mi ahA_ BKTH2@ K2MiiBQM- /2/@iBK2 M/ BbQiQT2 /2+v KQ/2HHBM; `2 MQi +QMbB/2`2/ rBi?BM `M/QKb +Q``2+iBQMX
kX9XkX AKTH2K2MiBM; LQ`KHBbiBQM *Q``2+iBQM 7Q` :1 aA:L BM ahA_ h?2 ;2QK2i`B+ M/ /2i2+iQ` 2{+B2M+v 7+iQ`b `2 KmH@ iBTHB2/ iQ ;2i i?2 MQ`KHBbiBQM +Q``2+iBQM 7+iQ`b T2` /2@ i2+iQ` #BM b #2HQr(kk- kj), nXY =
X Y , gXY
U3V
UdV
kX9X8X a+ii2` *Q``2+iBQM LQM@hP6 b+ii2` +Q``2+iBQM bBMQ;`K rb 2ti`+i2/ 7`QK i?2 p2M/Q`Ƕb `2+QMbi`m+iBQM iQQH#Qt 7Q` b+ii2` +Q`@ `2+iBQMX hP6@b+ii2` Bb +m``2MiHv MQi BKTH2K2Mi2/- r?2`2b MQM@ hP6 b+ii2` +Q``2+iBQM bBMQ;`Kb r2`2 TT`QtBKi2/ iQ hP6 T`QD2+iBQM /i rBi? TT`QT`Bi2 b+HBM; 7+iQ`b 7Q` 2+? hP6 #BMbX h?2 b+HBM; 7+iQ`b r2`2 2ti`+i2/ mbBM; i?2 2KBbbBQM T`QD2+iBQM /i #v +H+mHiBM; i?2 7`+iBQM Q7 +QmMib BM 2+? hP6 #BM rBi? `2bT2+i iQ iQiH MmK#2` Q7 +QmMibX h?2 `M/QKb M/ b+ii2` +Q``2+iBQM hP6 T`QD2+iBQM /i r2`2 //2/ iQ +H+mHi2 i?2 #+F;`QmM/ i2`K- bt X
r?2`2 nXY `2T`2b2Mib i?2 MQ`KHBbiBQM +Q``2+iBQM 7+iQ` 7Q` i?2 /2i2+iQ` TB`- j r?B+? Bb +QKT`Bb2/ Q7 /2i2+iQ` A.b X M/ Y- X M/ Y `2T`2b2Mib i?2 +`vbiH 2{+B2M+v 7+iQ`bM/ gXY `2T`2b2Mib i?2 ;2QK2i`B+ +Q``2+iBQM 7+iQ`bX h?2 b+MM2` 2tTQ`ib >.68 }H2b- r?B+? `2 i?2M mb2/ b BMTmib 7Q` +H+mHiBM; i?2 MQ`KHBbiBQM 7+iQ`b (Rd)X *`vb@ iH 2{+B2M+v 7+iQ`b `2 biQ`2/ BM ǵMQ`Kj/Ƕ M/ ;2QK2i@ `B+ 7+iQ`b `2 biQ`2/ BM ǵ;2Qj/ǶX h?2 MQ`Kj/ >.68 }H2 biQ`2b +`vbiH 2{+B2M+v 7+iQ`b r?B+? `2 `2/ b M ``v Q7 448 × 45 BM ahA_X h?2 j. ;2QK2i`B+ +Q``2+iBQM 7+iQ`b `2 biQ`2/ b T`i Q7 i?2 T`QD2+iBQM /i M/ QMHv 16 pB2rb `2 biQ`2/ BX2X 7Q` QM2 KQ/mH2X h?2b2 pB2r /ib2ib `2 Q7 /BK2MbBQMb 1981 × 357X h?2 2tTQ`i2/ ;2QK2i`B+ 7+iQ`b `2 `2T2i2/ 14 iBK2b rBi?BM ahA_ iQ ;2i 7mHH ;2@ QK2i`B+ +Q``2+iBQM T`QD2+iBQM /iX .2/@iBK2 +Q``2+iBQM ?b MQi #22M BKTH2K2Mi2/ BM i?Bb bim/vX
kX8X .i +[mBbBiBQM- AK;2 _2+QMbi`m+iBQM M/ MHvbBb kX8XRX S?MiQK +[mBbBiBQM h?2 7QHHQrBM; irQ T?MiQKb r2`2 b+MM2/, 9
TQ`i2/ SA6 BK;2b b /2KQMbi`i2/ BM };m`2 RX _M@ /QKb +Q``2+iBQM bBMQ;`K rb +H+mHi2/ mbBM; ǵ+QM@ bi`m+in`M/QKbn7`QKn:1bBM;H2bǶ miBHBivX a+ii2` +Q``2+@ iBQM rb /QM2 mbBM; i?2 bBMQ;`K 2ti`+i2/ 7`QK i?2 p2M@ /Q`Ƕb `2+QMbi`m+iBQM iQQH#QtX 6Q` hP6 BK;2 `2+QMbi`m+@ iBQMb- i?2 hP6 T`QD2+iBQM /i r2`2 ?BbiQ;`K@ K2/ mbBM; i?2 GJ }H2X _M/QKb M/ b+ii2` +Q``2+iBQM bBMQ;`Kb r2`2 i`MbHi2/ BMiQ hP6 T`QD2+iBQM /i #v /2p2HQTBM; +mbiQK miBHBiB2b M/ TT`QT`Bi2 b+HBM; Q7 /i b /2@ b+`B#2/ #Qp2 BM b2+iBQMb kX9X9 M/ kX9X8X ii2MmiBQM M/ MQ`KHBbiBQM bBMQ;`Kb r2`2 mMB7Q`K BM iBKBM; #BMb M/ r2`2 KmHiBTHB2/ rBi? i?2 #+F;`QmM/ i2`K iQ +`2i2 //B@ iBp2 bBMQ;`Kb 7Q` ahA_ BKTH2K2MiiBQMbX AK;2 `2+QM@ bi`m+iBQMb r2`2 +``B2/ Qmi mbBM; Pa1J M/ hP6@Pa1J H;Q`Bi?Kb rBi? M/ rBi?Qmi TQBMi bT`2/ 7mM+iBQM USa6V KQ/2HHBM;X hP6@E1J `2+QMbi`m+iBQMb r2`2 HbQ +``B2/ Qmi 7Q` i?2 TiB2Mi /ib2iX h?2 J_ BK;2 b?QrM BM };@ m`2 R rb mb2/ b iQ /2`Bp2 i?2 F2`M2HbX HH `2+QMbi`m+iBQMb r2`2 +``B2/ Qmi rBi? k3 bm#b2ibX
6B;m`2 R, SiB2Mi .ib2i, h`Mbp2`b2 M/ +Q`QMH bHB+2b Q7 i?2 2t@ TQ`i2/ `2bKTH2/ SA6 BK;2 U#QiiQK `QrV 7`QK J_* UiQT `QrV mbBM; +mbiQK b+`BTib b ahA_ BMi2`}H2X J_* BK;2 mb2/ b M MiQKB+H T`BQ` 7Q` F2`M2H Ki`Bt 2biBKiBQM 7Q` hP6@E1J BK;2 `2+QMbi`m+iBQMbX SA6 BK;2 mb2/ 7Q` *X
kX8X9X AK;2 _2+QMbi`m+iBQM rBi? o2M/Q`Ƕb _2+QMbi`m+@ iBQM hQQH#Qt :1 T`QT`B2i`v `2+QMbi`m+iBQM H;Q`Bi?Kb BM+Hm/BM; ol1 SQBMi >. UQ` 7mHHv j. Bi2`iBp2 `2+QMbi`m+iBQM r?B+? Bb 7m`i?2` `272``2/ iQ Pa1J@:1V- ol1 SQBMi 6s UQ` 7mHHv j. hP6 Bi2`iBp2 `2+QMbi`m+iBQM r?B+? Bb 7m`i?2` `272``2/ iQ hP6@Pa1J@:1V- ol1 TQBMi >. a?`TA_ UQ` Sa6@ Pa1J@:1V M/ ol1 TQBMi 6s a?`TA_ UQ` Sa6@hP6@ Pa1J@:1V r2`2 mb2/ iQ `2+QMbi`m+i oZ*- >QzKM M/ TiB2Mi /ib2ib rBi? 28 bm#b2ib (kN- jy)X
RX oQHmK2i`B+ ZmHBiv *QMi`QH UoZ*V S?MiQK, *QK@ T`Bb2/ Q7 }p2 0.7 J"[ 68 :2 bT?2`2b Q7 RN KK BM /B@ K2i2` rBi? R9 KK +iBp2 /BK2i2` UrBi? ?H7 KK iQH2`M+2V 2M+b2/ rBi?BM J_@pBbB#H2 im#2b K/2 Q7 LB*H2 X h?2 2MiB`2 +QM};m`iBQM Bb 2M+b2/ rBi?BM 7QK +m#2X h?2 T?MiQK rb b+MM2/ 7Q` 10 KBM K/ 5 × 106 T`QKTib r2`2 `2;Bbi2`2/X kX >QzKM S?MiQK, a+MM2/ 7Q` 20 KBM M/ 1.5 × 108 T`QKTib r2`2 `2;Bbi2`2/ (ke)X
kX8X8X AK;2 MHvbBb 1KBbbBQM M/ /i +Q``2+iBQM bBMQ;`Kb 2tTQ`i2/ 7`QK i?2 b+MM2` `2 +H+mHi2/ mbBM; i?2 BKTH2K2MiiBQMb K/2 BM i?2 ahA_ M/ i?2M +QKT`2/ mbBM; pQt2HrBb2 bm#i`+@ iBQMX hP6@Pa1J `2+QMbi`m+iBQMb rBi? ahA_ M/ i?2 p2M@ /Q`Ƕb `2+QMbi`m+iBQM iQQH#Qt UQ` ǵ:1Ƕ b rBHH #2 MQr `2@ 72``2/ iQ BM i?Bb /Q+mK2MiV 7Q` i?2 oZ* T?MiQK r2`2 mb2/ iQ +QKT`2 i?2 7mHH@rB/i?@?H7@KtBKmK U6q>JV (jR)X 6q>J rb +H+mHi2/ mbBM; ahA_ miBHBiv +HH2/ ǵ}M/n7r?KnBMnBK;2Ƕ- 7Q` HH }p2 bT?2`2b 7Q` p2M/Q`Ƕb `2@ +QMbi`m+iBQM iQQH#Qt M/ ahA_ #b2/ `2+QMbi`m+iBQMX h?2 6q>J 7Q` HH bT?2`2b BM HH i?`22 /BK2MbBQMb r2`2 p@ 2`;2/ M/ biM/`/ 2``Q` rb +H+mHi2/ b i?2 iQH2`M+2 rBM/QrX hP6@Pa1J `2+QMbi`m+iBQMb rBi? ahA_ M/ p2M@ /Q`Ƕb `2+QMbi`m+iBQM iQQH#Qt 7Q` i?2 >QzKM T?MiQK M/ i?2 TiB2Mi /ib2i r2`2 +QKT`2/ mbBM; biM/`/Bx2/ mT@ iF2 pHm2 `iBQ Ualo_V M/ +Q2{+B2Mi Q7 p`BiBQM U*QoVX alo_ Bb +H+mHi2/ b i?2 `iBQ Q7 i?2 alo Q7 i`;2i M/ `272`2M+2 `2;BQMbX AM i?Bb bim/v- `2;BQM Q7 BMi2`2bi U_PAV /`rM rBi?BM i?2 HBp2` M/ bTH22M r2`2 mb2/ b i?2 i`;2i M/ MQi?2` _PA Q7 bK2 pQHmK2 rBi?BM i?2 HmM; rb mb2/ b i?2 `272`2M+2X *Qo Bb +H+mHi2/ b i?2 W Q7 biM/`/ /2pBiBQM Qp2` i?2 K2MX ahA_ `2+QMbi`m+iBQMb r2`2 HbQ +QKT`2/ rBi? i?2 p2M/Q`Ƕb `2+QMbi`m+iBQMb mbBM; bi`m+@ im`H bBKBH`Biv BM/2t UaaAJV b /2b+`B#2/ BM (jk)X h?2 ;HQ#H aaAJ pHm2b `2 `2TQ`i2/ b i?2 bBKBH`Biv K2bm`2
kX8XkX *HBMB+H +[mBbBiBQM TiB2Mi rBi? `/BQi?2`Tv BM/m+2/ TmHKQM`v }#`Q@ bBb (kd- k3)- BMD2+i2/ rBi? 40.62 J"[ Q7 18 6 2tT2`BK2M@ iH `/BQi`+2` rb b+MM2/X h?2 `/BQi`+2` rb BMD2+i2/ 90KBM T`BQ` iQ i?2 b+M- Q7 r?B+? ?/ /m`iBQM Q7 13KBMX 3.8 × 107 T`QKTib r2`2 `2;Bbi2`2/X J_* BK;2b- SA6 BK;2b- mM+QKT`2bb2/ S1h GJ M/ _.6 }H2b r2`2 2tTQ`i2/ 7`QK i?2 b+MM2` 7Q` HH #Qp2 T?MiQK M/ +HBMB+H +[mBbBiBQMbX kX8XjX AK;2 _2+QMbi`m+iBQM h?2 b+MM2` +[mB`2/ mM+QKT`2bb2/ GJ /i r?B+? r2`2 ?BbiQ;`KK2/ BMiQ hP6 ahA_ bBMQ;`Kb mbBM; i?2 2tBbiBM; ǵHKniQnT`QD/iǶ miBHBivX h?Bb Bb TQbbB#H2 /m2 iQ i?2 BK@ TH2K2MiiBQM /2b+`B#2/ BM kX9XRX .i +Q``2+iBQM bBMQ;`Kb r2`2 +H+mHi2/ mbBM; +mb@ iQK miBHBiB2b M/ T`K2i2` +Hbb2b rBi? ahA_ 7Q` i?Bb b+MM2`X LQ`KHBbiBQM +Q``2+iBQMb r2`2 +H+mHi2/ mb@ BM; i?2 ǵ+Q``2+inT`QD/iǶ miBHBiv rBi? T`K2i2`b b2i iQ `2/ /i 7`QK ǵMQ`Kj/Ƕ }H2 2tTQ`i2/ 7`QK i?2 b+M@ M2`X ii2MmiBQM +Q``2+iBQM rb +``B2/ Qmi mbBM; i?2 2t@ 8
h#H2 R, 6q>J *QKT`BbQMb, oZ* S?MiQK
6B;m`2 k, h?2 };m`2 b?Qrb i?2 hP6 bBMQ;`Kb 7Q` hP6 #BM 0 UiQT `QrV M/ 5 U#QiiQK `QrV 2tTQ`i2/ 7`QK p2M/Q`Ƕb `2+QMbi`m+iBQM iQQH@ #Qt UQ` Ƕ:1Ƕ b rBHH #2 /2b+`B#2/ BM HH i?2 };m`2 +TiBQMb M/ i#H2b ?2`27i2`V M/ ahA_ 7Q` i?2 oZ* T?MiQK /ib2iX HH i?2 /2KQM@ bi`i2/ bBMQ;`Kb `2 7Q` b2;K2Mi y M/ tBH TQbBiBQM R3X
Ai2`iBQM R k j
:1 R9XR±yX9 R9X9±yXj R9Xj±yXj
ahA_ RjX8±yX9 RjXe±yX9 RjX9±yX9
Sa6@Pa1J
R k j
RjXR±yX8 RjXR±yX9 R9Xj±yXj
RjXe±yX9 RjXR±yX9 RkXj±yX8
hP6@Pa1J
R k j
R9Xd±yXk R9X8±yXk R9X9±yXk
RjXN±yX9 RjXN±yX9 RjXe±yXj
Sa6@hP6@Pa1J
R k j
RjXy±yX8 RjXR±yX9 RkXd±yX8
RjXe±yX9 RjXd±yX9 RjXN±yX9
h#H2 k, alo_UHBp2`fHmM;V *QKT`BbQMb, SiB2Mi .ib2i
H;Q`Bi?K Pa1J Sa6@Pa1J hP6@Pa1J Sa6@hP6@Pa1J hP6@E1J@ahA_ Sa6@hP6@E1J@ahA_
#2ir22M ahA_ M/ :1 `2+QMbi`m+i2/ BK;2b M/ `2 +H@ +mHi2/ b, S S I M(x, y) = [l(x, y)][c(x, y)][s(x, y)],
H;Q`Bi?K Pa1J
UNV
r?2`2 l(x, y) Bb i?2 HmKBMM+2 i2`K- c(x, y) Bb i?2 +QMi`bi i2`K M/ s(x, y) Bb i?2 bi`m+im`H i2`KX AM i?2 #Qp2 2[miBQM- x M/ y `2 i?2 `272`2M+2 M/ /BbiQ`i2/ BK@ ;2bX h?2 bBKBH`Biv K2bm`2 2pHmi2b i?2 BK;2 [mH@ Biv Q7 i?2 /BbiQ`i2/ BK;2 rBi? `2bT2+i iQ i?2 `272`2M+2 BK;2X h?2 ;HQ#H aaAJ pHm2b `2 +H+mHi2/ 7Q` hP6@ Pa1J@ahA_ p2`bmb hP6@Pa1J@:1- hP6@E1J@ahA_ p2`bmb hP6@Pa1J@:1- Sa6@hP6@Pa1J@ahA_ p2`bmb Sa6@hP6@Pa1J@:1 M/ Sa6@hP6@E1J@ahA_ p2`bmb Sa6@hP6@Pa1J@:1- r?2`2 ahA_ BK;2b `2 +QMbB/2`2/ b /BbiQ`i2/ BK;2b M/ :1 BK;2b `2 +QMbB/2`2/ b `27@ 2`2M+2 BK;2bX h?2 +QKT`BbQMb `2 +``B2/ Qmi 7Q` `2+QM@ bi`m+i2/ BK;2b Qp2` }`bi e Bi2`iBQMbX
:1 kRX3 kkXe k8X8 k8Xd @ @
ahA_ kRX3 kyX8 R3X8 RdXR R3X3 RdXj
`2 Pa1J- Sa6@Pa1J- hP6@Pa1J- Sa6@hP6@Pa1JhP6@E1J M/ Sa6@hP6@E1JX 6B;m`2 k +QKT`2b i?2 /B`2+i `BM; bBMQ;`Kb 7`QK ahA_ M/ p2M/Q`Ƕb `2+QMbi`m+iBQM iQQH#Qt 7Q` b2;K2Mi yX h?2 +QKT`BbQM Bb K/2 mbBM; i?2 mM+QKT`2bb2/ HBbiKQ/2 }H2 7Q` HH i?2 p`BQmb T?MiQK M/ +HBMB+H /ib2ib #mi QMHv /2KQMbi`i2/ 7Q` oZ* T?MiQK ?2`2X h?2 mMHBbi2/ bBMQ@ ;`K mbBM; ahA_ miBHBiv M/ p2M/Q`Ƕb `2+QMbi`m+iBQM iQQH@ #Qt Bb /2KQMbi`i2/ ?2`2 7Q` hP6 #BM 0 M/ 2- b2;K2Mi y M/ tBH TQbBiBQM R3X 6B;m`2 j +QKT`2b i?2 MQM@hP6 bBMQ;`Kb 7`QK ahA_ M/ p2M/Q`Ƕb `2+QMbi`m+iBQM iQQH#QtX h?2 +QKT`BbQMb r2`2 K/2 7Q` 2KBbbBQM- MQ`KHBbiBQM M/ `M/QKb bBMQ@ ;`KbX h?2 `2HiBp2 /Bz2`2M+2 ?b #22M /2KQMbi`i2/ #v T2`7Q`KBM; pQt2HrBb2 bm#i`+iBQMbX 6B;m`2 9 M/ 8 /2KQMbi`i2b i?2 MQM@hP6 `2+QMbi`m+@ iBQM rBi? Pa1J M/ Sa6@Pa1J `2bT2+iBp2Hv- 7Q` 28 bm#@ b2ib M/ 3 Bi2`iBQMb 7Q` >QzKM T?MiQKX 6B;m`2 e M/ d /2KQMbi`i2b i?2 MQM@hP6 `2+QMbi`m+iBQM rBi? Pa1J M/ Sa6@Pa1J `2bT2+iBp2Hv- 7Q` 28 bm#b2ib M/ 3 Bi2`@ iBQMb 7Q` +HBMB+H /ib2iX h?2 /2KQMbi`iBQM +QKT`2b i?2 `2+QMbi`m+iBQMb #2ir22M ahA_ M/ p2M/Q`Ƕb `2+QMbi`m+iBQM bQ7ir`2 pBbmHHvX 6B;m`2 3 /2KQMbi`i2b hP6@Pa1J@:1 UTQbi@}Hi2`2/ rBi? :mbbBM Q7 9KK 6q>JV- hP6@Pa1J@ahA_ UTQbi@ }Hi2`2/ rBi? :mbbBM Q7 9KK 6q>JV M/ hP6@E1J@ ahA_ `2+QMbi`m+iBQMbX h?2 +QKT`BbQMb `2 K/2 7Q`
jX _2bmHib h#H2 R /2KQMbi`i2b i?2 p2`;2 Q7 6q>J 7Q` HH }p2 68 :2 bT?2`2b BM HH /BK2MbBQMb 7Q` i?2 oZ* T?M@ iQKX h?2 +QKT`BbQMb `2 /2KQMbi`i2/ 7Q` BK;2b `2@ +QMbi`m+i2/ rBi? Pa1J- Sa6@Pa1J- hP6@Pa1J M/ Sa6@hP6@Pa1J H;Q`Bi?Kb rBi? p2M/Q`Ƕb `2+QMbi`m+iBQM iQQH#Qt M/ ahA_ Qp2` k3 bm#b2ib M/ j bm#b2[m2Mi Bi2`@ iBQMbX h#H2b k M/ j /2KQMbi`i2 i?2 alo_ +QKT`BbQMb 7Q` HBp2` M/ bTH22M _PAb `2bT2+iBp2Hv- +QKT`2/ rBi? HmM; _PAX h?2 +QKT`BbQMb `2 K/2 7Q` BK;2 `2+QMbi`m+i2/ rBi? TiB2Mi /i@ b2iX Ai2`iBp2 H;Q`Bi?Kb +QKT`2/ e
6B;m`2 j, h?2 };m`2 b?Qrb i?2 MQM@hP6 2KBbbBQM- MQ`KHBbiBQM M/ `M/QKb bBMQ;`Kb 7Q` oZ* T?MiQK /ib2ib 2tTQ`i2/ 7`QK p2M/Q`Ƕb `2+QMbi`m+iBQM iQQH#Qt M/ ahA_X h?2 /Bz2`2M+2 bBMQ;`K Bb HbQ /2TB+i2/ BM i?Bb };m`2X
UV M/ U#V +QKT`2 i?2 *Qo BM _PA TH+2/ rBi?BM bTH22M M/ HBp2` `2bT2+iBp2Hv- 7Q` hP6@Pa1J@ahA_- hP6@E1J@ ahA_ M/ hP6@Pa1J@:1 H;Q`Bi?KbX :`T?b U+V M/ U/V +QKT`2 i?2 *Qo BM _PA TH+2/ rBi?BM bTH22M M/ HBp2` `2bT2+iBp2Hv- 7Q` Sa6@hP6@Pa1J@ahA_- Sa6@hP6@ E1J@ahA_ M/ Sa6@hP6@Pa1J@:1 H;Q`Bi?KbX
h#H2 j, alo_UbTH22MfHmM;V *QKT`BbQMb, SiB2Mi .ib2i
H;Q`Bi?K Pa1J Sa6@Pa1J hP6@Pa1J Sa6@hP6@Pa1J hP6@E1J@ahA_ Sa6@hP6@E1J@ahA_
:1 k3Xy k3XN j9Xy j8Xy @ @
ahA_ j9Xy k3XN kNXj k8X8 kNX9 k8X9
9X .Bb+mbbBQM h?2 hP6 2KBbbBQM T`QD2+iBQM /i 2ti`+i2/ rBi? ahA_ 7Q` HH T?MiQK M/ +HBMB+H /ib2ib BM i?2 /2b+`B#2/ BK@ TH2K2MiiBQMb Bb B/2MiB+H iQ i?2 +[mB`2/ 2KBbbBQM /iX h?2 MQM@hP6 2KBbbBQM bBMQ;`Kb 2ti`+i2/ 7`QK ahA_ M/ p2M/Q`Ƕb `2+QMbi`m+iBQM iQQH#Qt 7Q` i?2 oZ* T?M@ iQK /ib2i- b +M #2 b22M BM };m`2 j- `2 B/2MiB+Hr?2`2b i?2`2 `2 bKHH /Bz2`2M+2b 7Q` i?2 MQ`KHBbiBQM M/ `M/QKb bBMQ;`Kb Q7 ahA_ BKTH2K2MiiBQM M/ +QK@ T`2/ rBi? i?2 p2M/Q`Ƕb `2+QMbi`m+iBQM iQQH#QtX h?2 `2H@ iBp2 /Bz2`2M+2 BM i?2 MQ`KHBbiBQM +Q``2+iBQM bBMQ;`K Bb ±1.6 × 10−7 X h?2 `2HiBp2 /Bz2`2M+2 7Q` i?2 `M/QKb bBMQ@ ;`K Bb 0.6% iQ 1.1%X h?2 /Bz2`2M+2b #2ir22M i?2 `M@ /QKb M/ MQ`KHBbiBQM bBMQ;`Kb `2 /m2 iQ i?2 7+i i?i MQ /2/@iBK2 KQ/2HHBM; ?b #22M BKTH2K2Mi2/ BM i?2 +m`@ `2Mi ahA_ p2`bBQMX HH i?2 /i +[mBbBiBQMb i?i `2 mb2/
BK;2b `2+QMbi`m+i2/ rBi? 28 bm#b2i M/ 7Q` 2nd Bi2`@ iBQMX h?2 `2+QMbi`m+i2/ BK;2b rBi? +HBMB+H /ib2ib `2 /2KQMbi`i2/ 7Q` +QKT`BbQMX 6B;m`2 N /2KQMbi`i2b Sa6@hP6@Pa1J@:1 UTQbi@ }Hi2`2/ rBi? :mbbBM Q7 9KK 6q>JV- Sa6@hP6@ Pa1J@ahA_ UTQbi@}Hi2`2/ rBi? :mbbBM Q7 9KK 6q>JV M/ Sa6@hP6@E1J@ahA_ `2+QMbi`m+iBQMbX h?2 +QKT`BbQMb `2 K/2 7Q` BK;2b `2+QMbi`m+i2/ rBi? 28 bm#b2i M/ 7Q` 2nd Bi2`iBQMX PMHv bBMQ;`K@#b2/ `2+QM@ bi`m+iBQMb r2`2 +``B2/ Qmi M/ `2 /2KQMbi`i2/ BM i?Bb TT2`X 6B;m`2 Ry b?Qrb *Qo +QKT`BbQMb 7Q` _PA TH+2/ rBi?BM i?2 bTH22M M/ HBp2` Q7 i?2 TiB2Mi /ib2iX :`T?b d
6B;m`2 9, >QzKM S?MiQK, h`Mbp2`b2 M/ +Q`QMH bHB+2 +QKT`@ BbQMb 7Q` UV Pa1J@ahA_ M/ U#V Pa1J@:1X *QKT`BbQMb `2 K/2 7Q` BK;2b `2+QMbi`m+i2/ rBi? k3 bm#b2ib M/ j Bi2`iBQMbX
6B;m`2 8, >QzKM S?MiQK, h`Mbp2`b2 M/ +Q`QMH bHB+2 +QKT`@ BbQMb 7Q` UV Sa6@Pa1J@ahA_ M/ U#V Sa6@Pa1J@:1X *QKT`@ BbQMb `2 K/2 7Q` BK;2b `2+QMbi`m+i2/ rBi? k3 bm#b2ib M/ j Bi2`@ iBQMbX
BM i?Bb bim/v ?p2 `2HiBp2Hv HQr +iBpBiB2b b +QKT`2/ iQ +HBMB+H bBimiBQMbX h?Bb BKTHB2b i?i i?2 /2/@iBK2 +Q`@ `2+iBQM Bb p2`v bKHHX HbQ- i?2 `M/QKb +Q``2+iBQM BKTH2@ K2Mi2/ BM ahA_ Bb MQi B/2MiB+H iQ i?i BM i?2 p2M/Q`Ƕb `2+QMbi`m+iBQM iQQH#Qt +H+mHiBQM (k9- jj)X 6q>J +QKT`BbQMb 7Q` i?2 oZ* T?MiQK /ib2i- b /2KQMbi`i2/ BM h#H2 R- b?Qrb i?i i?2 ahA_ `2+QMbi`m+@ iBQMb ?p2 bBKBH` `2bQHmiBQM rBi? i?2 p2M/Q`Ƕb `2+QMbi`m+@ iBQM iQQH#QtX h?2`2 Bb `2HiBp2 /Bz2`2M+2 Q7 8W iQ RjW BM i?2 K2bm`2K2Mib rBi? ahA_ b +QKT`2/ iQ p2M/Q`Ƕb `2+QMbi`m+iBQM bQ7ir`2X >QzKM M/ TiB2Mi /ib2ib `2+QMbi`m+i2/ rBi? i?2 Pa1J H;Q`Bi?K rBi? ahA_ M/ i?2 p2M/Q`Ƕb `2+QMbi`m+@ iBQM bQ7ir`2- b b?QrM BM };m`2 9 M/ e- b?Qrb pBbmH /Bz2`2M+2b r?B+? `2 +QMb2[m2M+2 Q7 #b2Mi /2i2+iQ` ;T KQ/2HHBM; rBi?BM i?2 bvbi2K Ki`Bt BM ahA_ M/ H+F Q7 /2/iBK2 KQ/2HHBM; BM `M/QKbX h?2 /2i2+iQ` ;Tb `2 MQi iF2M BMiQ ++QmMi b ahA_ +m``2MiHv bmTTQ`ib QMHv i?2 +vHBM/`B+H b+MM2` ;2QK2i`B2b M/ rBi?Qmi Mv ;TbX h?2`2 `2 HbQ KBMQ` /Bz2`2M+2b i?i `Bb2 7`QK i?2 Qz@ b2ib #2ir22M i?2 S1h M/ J_ ;Mi`vX :1 +QMp2`ib i?2 S1h `2+QMbi`m+iBQMb BM J_ bT+2 r?B+? Bb MQi +m``2MiHv miQKi2/ rBi?BM ahA_X Hi?Qm;?- i?2b2 Qzb2ib `2 KM@ mHHv iF2M BMiQ ++QmMi /m`BM; i?Bb rQ`FX alo_ +QK@ T`BbQMb 7Q` Pa1J@ahA_ M/ Sa6@Pa1J@ahA_ 7Q` T@ iB2Mi /ib2ib `2 BM ;QQ/ ;`22K2Mi rBi? i?2 p2M/Q`Ƕb `2@ +QMbi`m+iBQM bQ7ir`2 +QmMi2`T`ib 7Q` HBp2`fHmM; +QKT`@ BbQMb- b +M #2 b22M BM i#H2 kX 6Q` i?2 HBp2`fHmM;- i?2`2 Bb KtBKmK Q7 jW `2HiBp2 /Bz2`2M+2 BM i?2 alo_ pHm2bX 6Q` bTH22MfHmM; +QKT`BbQMb i?2`2 Bb ;`2i2` `2HiBp2 /B7@ 72`2M+2 Q7 kRW 7Q` Pa1J /m2 iQ /Bz2`2M+2b BM T`QD2+iQ`b M/ `M/QK KQ/2HHBM;X aBKBH` Tii2`Mb `2 Q#b2`p2/ BM i?2 >QzKM T?MiQK /ib2iX
h?2 TiB2Mi BK;2b `2+QMbi`m+i2/ rBi? i?2 irQ bQ7ir`2 T+F;2b rBi? hP6@Pa1J H;Q`Bi?Kb TT2` iQ ?p2 /B7@ 72`2M+2b /m2 iQ i?2 `2bQMb 7Q`2K2MiBQM2/X hP6 BK;2b ?/ /Bz2`2M+2b BM MQBb2 r?B+? Bb /m2 iQ i?2 H+F Q7 BKTH2@ K2MiiBQM Q7 hP6 b+ii2` bBKmHiBQM BM i?2 +m``2Mi p2`@ bBQM Q7 i?2 ahA_ HB#``vX alo_ +QKT`BbQMb 7Q` hP6 `2+QMbi`m+iBQMb 7m`i?2` b?Qrb i?2 2z2+i Q7 H+F Q7 hP6 b+ii2` BKTH2K2MiiBQM b i?2`2 `2 ;`2i2` /Bz2`2M+2b #2@ ir22M ahA_ M/ p2M/Q`Ƕb `2+QMbi`m+iBQM bQ7ir`2 [mM@ iB}+iBQMbX hP6@E1J alo_ +QKT`BbQMb /BbTHv p2`v bHB;?i BKT`Qp2K2Mi BM i2`Kb Q7 i?2 [mMiB}+iBQMX Ai +M #2 b22M BM };m`2 Ry i?i Sa6@hP6@E1J ?b i?2 #2bi mMB7Q`KBiv 7Q` bTH22M M/ hP6@E1J ?b i?2 #2bi mMB@ 7Q`KBiv 7Q` HBp2`X h?Bb b?Qrb i?2 2z2+i Q7 i?2 J_ MiQK@ B+H BM7Q`KiBQM BM S1h `2+QMbi`m+iBQMbX hP6@E1J *Qo pHm2b BKT`Qp2b b i?2 MmK#2` Q7 Bi2`iBQMb BM+`2K2MibX h?2 ;HQ#H aaAJ pHm2 Bb #2ir22M yX39@yX38 7Q` HH +QK@ T`BbQMb T2`7Q`K2/ QM `2+QMbi`m+i2/ BK;2b Qp2` e Bi2`@ iBQMbX h?Bb b?Qrb ?B;? bi`m+im`H bBKBH`Biv #2ir22M ahA_ M/ :1 `2+QMbi`m+i2/ BK;2bX h?2 /Bz2`2M+2 #2@ ir22M irQ BK;2b Bb KDQ`Hv /m2 iQ BMi2MbBiv /Bz2`2M+2 #2ir22M i?2 irQ BK;2bX h?Bb bim/v /Q2b MQi iF2 BMiQ ++QmMi hP6 b+ii2` +Q``2+iBQM r?B+? ;Bp2b `Bb2 iQ /B7@ 72`2M+2b BM MQBb2 T`QT2`iB2b #2ir22M ahA_ M/ :1 `2@ +QMbi`m+iBQMbX h?2 `M/QKb +Q``2+iBQM KQ/2HHBM; BKTH2@ K2Mi2/ BM ahA_ Bb MQi B/2MiB+H iQ i?i BM :1 iQQH#QtX :1 `2+QMbi`m+iBQMb `2 b+H2/ #v ;HQ#H M/ +HB#`@ iBQM 7+iQ` i?i Bb MQi +m``2MiHv iF2M BMiQ ++QmMi rBi?BM i?2 ahA_ `2+QMbi`m+iBQMbX 3
HiBQM (j9) M/ iQ BMi2;`i2 Bi rBi? i?2 M2ti `2H2b2 Q7 aA_6 UavM2`;BbiB+ AK;2 _2+QMbi`m+iBQM 6`K2rQ`FV (j8)X eX +FMQrH2/;2K2Mib SX q/?r Bb 7mM/2/ #v J2/B+H _2b2`+? *QmM@ +BH AM/mbi`BH *a1 S?. a+?QH`b?BT UJ_fJyRd9esfRVX .` hbQmKTb Bb bTQMbQ`2/ #v _QvH aQ+B2iv AM/mbi`v 62HHQrb?BT UA6RdyyRRVX h?2 T`QD2+i ?b #22M T`iBHHv bmTTQ`i2/ #v i?2 1Sa_* *QHH#Q`iBp2 *QKTmiiBQMH S`QD2+i U1SfJykk83dfRV M/ Bib ~;b?BT `2b2`+? ;`Mi U1SfSykkkyyfRVX q2 rQmH/ HBF2 iQ i?MF S`Q7X ai27M oM/2M#2`;?2- S`Q7X JB+?2H EQQH2 M/ Jb 1bi2` .Ƕ>Q2 7Q` i?2B` BMBiBH bmTTQ`i M/ /i 7Q` i?Bb rQ`FX q2 rQmH/ HbQ HBF2 iQ i?MF S`Q7X .pB/ "m+FH2v 7Q` ?Bb bm#biMiBH bmTTQ`i 7Q` i?2 2MiB`2 +Qm`b2 Q7 i?Bb rQ`FX 1i?B+b MmK@ #2` RdfqJfyy39 rBi? T2`KBbbBQM 7`QK +HBMB+H bim/v T2`7Q`K2/ i AMpB+`QX
(a)
(b) 6B;m`2 e, SiB2Mi .ib2i, h`Mbp2`b2 M/ +Q`QMH bHB+2 +QKT`BbQMb 7Q` UV Pa1J@ahA_ M/ U#V Pa1J@:1X *QKT`BbQMb `2 K/2 7Q` BK;2b `2+QMbi`m+i2/ rBi? k3 bm#b2ib M/ j Bi2`iBQMbX
(R) SX JX _Q#bQM- .X .2v- .X 1X L2r#v- .X "2`KM- .X GB- wX X 6v/- JX _X .r2+F- J_fS1h AK;BM; Q7 i?2 *`/BQpb+mH` avbi2K- C**X *`/BQpb+mH` AK;BM; Ry URy S`i V UkyRdV RRe8ĜRRdNX l_G ?iiTb,ff/QBXQ`;fRyXRyRefDXD+K;XkyRdXydXyy3X (k) _X LX :mMM- JX aHB7bi2BM- :X 1X a2`H2- CX *X S`B+2- ZmMiBi@ iBp2 BK;BM; Q7 T`Qi2BM i`;2ib BM i?2 ?mKM #`BM rBi? S1hS?vbB+b BM J2/B+BM2 "BQHQ;v ey UkkV UkyR8V _jejX (j) wX qHF2`- 6X :M/QH7Q- aX P`BMB- oX :`B#QiiQ- 6X ;Qbi- CX `@ #Bxm- 6X "QmrKM- X .`x2x;- SX L2biQ`- JX "Q++`/B- .X H@ iQK`2- *X 62bi`B- 6X LQ#BHB- *HBMB+H miBHBiv Q7 6.: S1h BM S`FBMbQMǶb /Bb2b2 M/ ivTB+H T`FBMbQMBbK bbQ+Bi2/ rBi? /2K2MiB- 1m`QT2M DQm`MH Q7 Mm+H2` K2/B+BM2 M/ KQH2+mH` BK;BM; 98 UNV UkyR3V R8j9ĜR898X (9) >X JQi`- hX PHmbQ;- :X _mbb2HH- aX CKB2bQM- aX ?K2/LX "`BM/H2- X SBHHB- X 6X a+`b#`QQF- *X LX Si2H6X lX *?Qr/?m`v- *HBMB+H BKT+i M/ /B;MQbiB+ ++m`+v Q7 k@(R36)@~mQ`Q@k@/2Qtv@/@;Hm+Qb2 TQbBi`QM@2KBbbBQM iQKQ;`@ T?vf+QKTmi2/ iQKQ;`T?v US1hf*hV #`BM BK;BM; BM T@ iB2Mib rBi? +Q;MBiBp2 BKTB`K2Mi, i2`iB`v +2Mi`2 2tT2`B2M+2 BM i?2 lE- *HBMB+H `/BQHQ;v dk URV UkyRdV ejĜdjX l_G ?iiTb,ff/QBXQ`;fRyXRyRefDX+`/XkyReXy3XyyjX (8) sX uX w?M;- wX GX uM;- :X JX Gm- :X 6X uM;- GX CX w?M;S1hfJ_ AK;BM;, L2r 6`QMiB2` BM Hx?2BK2`Ƕb .Bb2b2 M/ Pi?2` .2K2MiBb- 6`QMiB2`b BM JQH2+mH` L2m`Qb+B2M+2 RyX l_G ?iiTb,ff/QBXQ`;fRyXjj3Nf7MKQHXkyRdXyyj9jX (e) LX HB2- JX 1H/B#- wX X 6v/- oX JMB- AM~KKiBQMi?2`Qb+H2`QbBb- M/ *Q`QM`v `i2`v .Bb2b2, S1hf*h 7Q` i?2 1pHmiBQM Q7 i?2`Qb+H2`QbBb M/ AM~KKiBQM- *HBMB+H J2/B+BM2 AMbB;?ib, *`/BQHQ;v 3 UkyR9V *J*ĜaRdyejX l_G ?iiTb,ff/QBXQ`;fRyX9Rjdf*J*XaRdyejX (d) SX JX S`B+2- JX JX :`22M- SQbBi`QM 2KBbbBQM iQKQ;`T?v BK;@ BM; TT`Q+?2b 7Q` 2ti2`MH #2K `/BiBQM i?2`TB2b, +m``2Mi biimb M/ 7mim`2 /2p2HQTK2Mib- h?2 "`BiBb? DQm`MH Q7 `/BQH@ Q;v 39 UbT2+BHnBbbm2nRV UkyRRV aRNĜaj9X l_G ?iiTb,ff/QBXQ`;fRyXRk8Nf#D`fkRkejyR9X (3) aX oB/vMi?M- *X Si2H- X a+`b#`QQF- 6X *?Qr/?m`v- 6.: S1hf*h BM BM72+iBQM M/ BM~KKiBQMĜ+m``2Mi M/ 2K2`;BM; +HBMB+H TTHB+iBQMb- *HBMB+H `/BQHQ;v dy UdV UkyR8V d3dĜ3yyX l_G ?iiTb,ff/QBXQ`;fRyXRyRefDX+`/XkyR8XyjXyRyX (N) CX :`m2M2Bb2M- "X JX a+?`b+?KB/i- X .2KB`+BQ;HmJX *?Q/vH- PX J`iBM- aX "2`i`K- X q2ii2`- aX "m2`- qX SX 62M/H2`- GX SQ/H2bF- JX 6Q`biBM;- EX >2``KMM- GX lKmiHmR36@6.: S1hfJ_A 7Q` h?2`Tv _2bTQMb2 bb2bbK2Mi Q7 AbQ@ Hi2/ GBK# S2`7mbBQM BM SiB2Mib rBi? aQ7i@hBbbm2 a`+QKbCQm`MH Q7 Lm+H2` J2/B+BM2 ey UkyRNV R8jdĜR89kX (Ry) EX h?B2H2KMb- *X hbQmKTb- aX Jmbi7QpB+- hX "2Bb2HSX ;mB`- LX .BFBQb- JX qX C+Q#bQM- ahA_, bQ7ir`2 7Q` iQ@
6B;m`2 d, SiB2Mi .ib2i, h`Mbp2`b2 M/ +Q`QMH bHB+2 +QKT`BbQMb 7Q` UV Sa6@Pa1J@ahA_ M/ U#V Sa6@Pa1J@:1X *QKT`BbQMb `2 K/2 7Q` BK;2b `2+QMbi`m+i2/ rBi? k3 bm#b2ib M/ j Bi2`iBQMbX
8X *QM+HmbBQM AM i?Bb bim/v- i?2 +[mBbBiBQM T`Q+2bb 7Q` :1 aA:L S1hfJ_ b+MM2` Bb KQ/2HH2/ rBi?BM i?2 QT2M bQm`+2 HB@ #``v- ahA_X HH pHB/iBQMb r2`2 K/2 #v +QKT`BM; BK;2b `2+QMbi`m+i2/ rBi? Bi2`iBp2 `2+QMbi`m+iBQM H;Q@ `Bi?Kb pBH#H2 BM i?2 HB#``v 7Q` +[mB`2/ T?MiQK M/ +HBMB+H /ib2ibX _2+QMbi`m+i2/ BK;2b TT2` iQ #2 i +QKT`#H2 H2p2H rBi? i?2 QM2b T`QpB/2/ #v i?2 KMm7+@ im`2`X .2/@iBK2 +Q``2+iBQM- #b2M+2 Q7 /2i2+iQ` ;T KQ/@ 2HHBM; M/ hP6 b+ii2` +Q``2+iBQM ?p2 MQi #22M KQ/2HH2/ BM i?Bb rQ`F- M/ Kv ++QmMi 7Q` i?2 Q#b2`p2/ /Bb+`2T@ M+B2bX h?2 KBM /pMi;2 Q7 KQ/2HHBM; i?2 +[mBbBiBQM T`Q+2bb2b Q7 i?Bb b+MM2` BM i?2 ahA_ HB#``v Bb i?i i?2 b+B2MiB}+ +QKKmMBiv +M T2`7Q`K i?2B` `2b2`+? BM BK;2 `2+QMbi`m+iBQM rBi? +QKTH2i2 +QMi`QH Q7 ?Qr i?2 /i Bb KMBTmHi2/X h?Bb rBHH ?2HT iQ Tp2 i?2 rv 7Q` ?`KQMB@ biBQM Q7 K2i?Q/QHQ;v +`Qbb p`BQmb S1h b+MM2`b mb2/ BM i?2 +HBMB+X 6mim`2 rQ`F rBHH HbQ BM+Hm/2 +H+mHiBM; b+ii2` +Q``2+iBQM rBi? ahA_ mbBM; bBM;H2 *QKTiQM b+ii2` bBKm@ N
(RR)
(Rk)
(Rj)
(R9)
(R8)
(Re)
(Rd)
(R3)
(RN) (ky)
(kR)
(kk) (kj)
(k9)
KQ;`T?B+ BK;2 `2+QMbi`m+iBQM `2H2b2 k- S?vbB+b BM J2/B+BM2 "BQHQ;v 8d UkyRkV 3edĜ33jX oX "2iiBM`/B- 1X S;MB- JX :BH`/B- aX H2MBmb- EX h?B2H2@ KMb- JX h2`b- 6X 6xBQ- AKTH2K2MiiBQM M/ 2pHmiBQM Q7 j. QM2@bi2T Hi2 `2+QMbi`m+iBQM H;Q`Bi?K 7Q` j. TQbBi`QM 2KBb@ bBQM iQKQ;`T?v #`BM bim/B2b mbBM; K2/BM `QQi T`BQ`- 1m`Q@ T2M CQm`MH Q7 Lm+H2` J2/B+BM2 M/ JQH2+mH` AK;BM; kN URV UkyykV dĜR3X l_G ?iiTb,ff/QBXQ`;fRyXRyydfbyyk8NyRyye8RX .X .2B//- LX X E`FibMBb- SX JX _Q#bQM- uX@CX hbBLX 17i?BKBQm- EX h?B2H2KMb- wX X 6v/- _X :X vF`Qv/*X hbQmKTb- >v#`B/ S1h@J_ HBbi@KQ/2 F2`M2HBx2/ 2tT2+@ iiBQM KtBKBxiBQM `2+QMbi`m+iBQM- AMp2`b2 S`Q#H2Kb j8 U9V UkyRNV y99yyRX l_G ?iiTb,ff/QBXQ`;fRyXRy33fRjeR@e9kyf#yRj7X LX 17i?BKBQm- 1X 1KQM/- SX q/?r- *X *ri?Q`M2*X hbQmKTb- EX h?B2H2KMb- AKTH2K2MiiBQM M/ pHB/iBQM Q7 iBK2@Q7@~B;?i S1h BK;2 `2+QMbi`m+iBQM KQ/mH2 7Q` HBbiKQ/2 M/ bBMQ;`K T`QD2+iBQM /i BM i?2 ahA_ HB#``v- S?vbB+b BM J2/B+BM2 "BQHQ;v e9 UkyR3V yj8yy9X l_G ?iiTb,ff/QBXQ`;fRyXRy33fRjeR@e8eyf7N#NX X JX :`Mi- hX qX .2HH2`- JX JX E?HB;?B- aX >X J`K`Dm:X .2HbQ- *X aX G2pBM- L1J Ll k@kyRk T2`7Q`KM+2 bim/B2b 7Q` i?2 aBSJ@#b2/ hQ6@S1h +QKTQM2Mi Q7 i?2 :1 aA:L S1hfJ_ bvbi2K- J2/B+H S?vbB+b 9j U8V UkyReV kjj9Ĝkj9jX l_G ?iiTb,ff/QBXQ`;fRyXRRR3fRX9N989ReX aX oM/2M#2`;?2- 1X JBF?vHQp- 1X .Ƕ>Q2- SX JQHH2i- CX aX E`T- _2+2Mi /2p2HQTK2Mib BM iBK2@Q7@~B;?i S1h- 1m`QT2M CQm`MH Q7 Lm+H2` J2/B+BM2 M/ JQH2+mH` AK;BM; S?vbB+b j URV UkyReV jX l_G ?iiTb,ff/QBXQ`;fRyXRR3efb9ye83@yRe@yRj3@jX .X 6X *X >bm- 1X AHM- qX hX S2i2`bQM- CX l`B#2- JX Gm#@ #2`BMF- *X aX G2pBM- aim/B2b Q7 L2ti@:2M2`iBQM aBHB+QM@ S?QiQKmHiBTHB2`Ĝ"b2/ hBK2@Q7@6HB;?i S1hf*h avbi2K- CQm`@ MH Q7 Lm+H2` J2/B+BM2 83 UNV UkyRdV R8RRĜR8R3X SX q/?r- EX h?B2H2KMb- LX 17i?BKBQm- PX "2`iQHHB1X 1KQM/- "X X h?QKb- JX hQ?K2- EX qM;2`BM- :X .2HbQqX >HH2ii- _X :mMM- .X "m+FH2v- *X hbQmKTb- AKTH2K2M@ iiBQM Q7 AK;2 _2+QMbi`m+iBQM 7Q` :1 aA:L S1hfJ_ S1h .i BM i?2 ahA_ GB#``v- A111 Lm+H2` a+B2M+2 avK@ TQbBmK M/ J2/B+H AK;BM; *QM72`2M+2- ULaafJA*V kyR3@ S`Q+22/BM;bX l_G ?iiTb,ff/QBXQ`;fRyXRRyNfLaaJA*XkyR3X33k9j9RX >X JX >m/bQM- _X aX G`FBM- ++2H2`i2/ BK;2 `2+QMbi`m+iBQM mbBM; Q`/2`2/ bm#b2ib Q7 T`QD2+iBQM /i- A111 h`Mb+iBQMb QM J2/B+H AK;BM; Rj U9V URNN9V eyRĜeyNX l_G ?iiTb,ff/QBXQ`;fRyXRRyNf9kXjejRy3X :X qM;- CX ZB- S1h AK;2 _2+QMbi`m+iBQM lbBM; E2`M2H J2i?Q/- A111 h`Mb+iBQMb QM J2/B+H AK;BM; j9 UkyR8V eRĜ dRX .X .2B//- LX E`FibMBb- SX JX _Q#bQM- LX 17i?BKBQm- wX X 6v/- _X :X vF`Qv/- *X hbQmKTb- 1z2+i Q7 S1h@J_ BM@ +QMbBbi2M+v BM i?2 F2`M2H BK;2 `2+QMbi`m+iBQM K2i?Q/- A111 h`Mb+iBQMb QM _/BiBQM M/ SHbK J2/B+H a+B2M+2bX PX "2`iQHHB- aX ``B/;2- *X qX ai2`Mb- aX .X qQHH2Mr2#2`"X 6X >miiQM- EX h?B2H2KMb- .i /`Bp2M `2bTB`iQ`v bB;MH /2i2+iBQM BM S1h iFBM; /pMi;2 Q7 iBK2@Q7@~B;?i /i- BM, kyRe A111 Lm+H2` a+B2M+2 avKTQbBmK- J2/B+H AK;BM; *QM@ 72`2M+2 M/ _QQK@h2KT2`im`2 a2KB+QM/m+iQ` .2i2+iQ` qQ`F@ b?QT ULaafJA*f_ha.V- A111- kyRe- TTX RĜjX l_G ?iiT,ff/tX/QBXQ`;fRyXRRyNfMbbKB+XkyReX3yeN9keX JX .27`Bb2- .X 1X hQrMb2M/- .X "BH2v- X :2Bbb#m?H2`*X JB+?2H- hX CQM2b- MQ`KHBxiBQM i2+?MB[m2 7Q` j. S1h /i- S?vbB+b BM J2/B+BM2 "BQHQ;v je URNNRV NjN Ĝ N8kX .X GX "BH2v- .X qX hQrMb2M/- SX 1X EBM?M- aX :`QQiQQMFhX CQM2b- M BMp2biB;iBQM Q7 7+iQ`b z2+iBM; /2i2+iQ` M/ ;2@ QK2i`B+ +Q``2+iBQM BM MQ`KHBxiBQM Q7 j@. S1h /i- A111 h`Mb+iBQMb QM Lm+H2` a+B2M+2 9j URNNeV jjyy Ĝ jjydX *X qX ai2`Mb- .X GX J+.MB2H- aX :X EQ?HKv2`- SX _X `mH"X SX :2Bb2`- oX a?MKm;K- _M/QK +QBM+B/2M+2 2biBKiBQM 7`QK bBM;H2 2p2Mi `i2b QM i?2 .Bb+Qp2`v ah S1hf*h b+MM2`-
(k8) (ke)
(kd) (k3)
(kN) (jy)
(jR)
(jk)
(jj) (j9)
(j8)
Ry
A111 Lm+H2` a+B2M+2 avKTQbBmK M/ J2/B+H AK;BM; *QM@ 72`2M+2 ULaafJA*V 8 UkyyjV jyed Ĝ jyeNX CX PHBp2`- JX _72+b- JQ/2HHBM; _M/QK *QBM+B/2M+2b BM SQbBi`QM 1KBbbBQM hQKQ;`T?v #v lbBM; aBM;H2b M/ S`QKTib, *QKT`BbQM aim/v- SHQa QM2 RR UkyReV 2yRekyNeX 1X CX >QzKM- SX .X *miH2`- qX JX .B;#v- CX *X JxxBQii- j@. T?MiQK iQ bBKmHi2 +2`2#`H #HQQ/ ~Qr M/ K2i#QHB+ BK;2b 7Q` S1h- A111 h`Mb+iBQMb QM Lm+H2` a+B2M+2 jd URNNyV eRe Ĝ ekyX X aH22K- uX >2HQ- :X a2`H2- 6X .2FD- CX *QQF- wX qBM_X :mMM- SX q2HHb- AK;BM; `/BQi?2`Tv BM/m+2/ TmHKQM`v }#`Q;2MB+ +?M;2b rBi? BMi2;`BM@S1h UkyRNVX X aH22K- uX >2HQ- :X a2`H2- wX qBM- CX *QQF- _X :mMMSX q2HHb- AMi2;`BM@S1h mTiF2 2pHmiBQM BM TiB2Mib `2+2BpBM; TmHKQM`v `/BQi?2`Tv- CQm`MH Q7 Lm+H2` J2/B+BM2 ey UbmT@ TH2K2Mi RV UkyRNV kN8ĜkN8X aX _Qbb- *X ai2`Mb- a?`TA_- q?Bi2 TT2`b- :1 >2Hi?+`2 UkyRyV R Ĝ 3X .X oM/2M/`B2bb+?2- CX l`B#2- >X "2`iBM- 6X .2 :22i2`- S2`@ 7Q`KM+2 +?`+i2`BbiB+b Q7 bBHB+QM T?QiQKmHiBTHB2` #b2/ R8@+K 6Po hP6 S1hf*h- 1m`QT2M CQm`MH Q7 Lm+H2` J2/B+BM2 M/ JQH2+mH` AK;BM; S?vbB+b e URV UkyRNV 3X :X .2HbQ- aX 6Ƀ`bi- "X CFQ#v- _X G/2#2+F- *X :Mi2`- aX :X L2FQHH- JX a+?rB;2`- aX AX wB2;H2`- S2`7Q`KM+2 K2bm`2K2Mib Q7 i?2 aB2K2Mb KJ_ BMi2;`i2/ r?QH2@#Q/v S1hfJ_ b+MM2`CQm`MH Q7 Lm+H2` J2/B+BM2 8k UkyRRV RNR9 Ĝ RNkkX wX qM;- X *X "QpBF- >X _X a?2BF?- 1X SX aBKQM+2HHB- 2i HX- AK@ ;2 [mHBiv bb2bbK2Mi, 7`QK 2``Q` pBbB#BHBiv iQ bi`m+im`H bBK@ BH`Biv- A111 h`Mb+iBQMb QM AK;2 S`Q+2bbBM; Rj U9V Ukyy9V eyyĜeRkX *X qX ai2`Mb- X >X GQMM- _M/QKb 7`QK bBM;H2b 2biBKiBQM 7Q` HQM; S1h b+Mb- kyRR A111 Lm+H2` a+B2M+2 avKTQbBmK *QM72`2M+2 _2+Q`/ UkyRRV jdjNĜjd9RX *X hbQmKTb- SX ;mB`- EX LBFBi- .X _Qb- EX h?B2H2KMb1pHmiBQM Q7 i?2 bBM;H2 b+ii2` bBKmHiBQM H;Q`Bi?K BKTH2@ K2Mi2/ BM i?2 ahA_ HB#``v- kyy9 A111 avKTQbBmK *QM72`2M+2 _2+Q`/ Lm+H2` a+B2M+2X e Ukyy9V jjeRĜjje8X 1X Ppi+?BMMBFQp- _X "`QrM- *X EQH#Bib+?- 1X Sb+*X / *Qbi@GmBb- X :X :BHHKM- "X X h?QKb- LX 17i?BKBQmCX Jv2`- SX q/?r- JX 1?`?`/i- aX 1HHBb- CX CǠ`;2Mb2MCX Jii?2rb- *X S`B2iQ- X CX _2/2`- *X hbQmKTb- JX hm`M2`.X iFBMbQM- EX h?B2H2KMb- aA_6, avM2`;BbiB+ AK;2 _2+QM@ bi`m+iBQM 6`K2rQ`F- *QKTmi2` S?vbB+b *QKKmMB+iBQMb , BM T`2bbX
6B;m`2 3, SiB2Mi .ib2i, h`Mbp2`b2 M/ +Q`QMH bHB+2 +QKT`BbQMb 7Q` UV hP6@Pa1J@:1- U#V hP6@Pa1J@ahA_ M/ U+V hP6@E1J@ahA_X *QKT`BbQMb `2 K/2 7Q` BK;2b `2+QMbi`m+i2/ rBi? k3 bm#b2ib M/ k Bi2`iBQMbX :mbbBM TQbi@}Hi2`BM; rBi? 6q>J Q7 9KK r2`2 TTHB2/ iQ hP6@Pa1J BK;2bX
RR
6B;m`2 N, SiB2Mi .ib2i, h`Mbp2`b2 M/ +Q`QMH bHB+2 +QKT`BbQMb 7Q` UV Sa6@hP6@Pa1J@:1- U#V Sa6@hP6@Pa1J@ahA_ M/ U+V Sa6@ hP6@E1J@ahA_X *QKT`BbQMb `2 K/2 7Q` BK;2b `2+QMbi`m+i2/ rBi? k3 bm#b2ib M/ k Bi2`iBQMbX :mbbBM TQbi@}Hi2`BM; rBi? 6q>J Q7 9KK r2`2 TTHB2/ iQ Sa6@hP6@Pa1J BK;2bX
Rk
(b)
(c)
(d)
6B;m`2 Ry, SiB2Mi .ib2i, hP6@Pa1J@ahA_- hP6@Pa1J@:1 M/ hP6@E1J@ahA_ +QKT`BbQMb 7Q` UV *Qo, aTH22Mc U#V *Qo, GBp2`c Sa6@hP6@Pa1J@ahA_- Sa6@hP6@Pa1J@:1 M/ Sa6@hP6@E1J@ahA_ +QKT`BbQMb 7Q` U+V *Qo, aTH22Mc U/V *Qo, GBp2`X
Rj