- Email: [email protected]
PRIMITIVE PATIENTS.
403 virulent and giving rise to of septicaemia usually develops in association with other micro-organisms, especially Two forms of tetragenus the tubercle bacillus. septicaemia have been described-viz., a mild form
primitive thought. In allowing himself to be treated by a foreigner, a man with other and distant gods. other " medicine," other habitat, totem, and tribal connexions, he as a good native of the districts ncrth of the Orange River, with his own gods (ancestors). characterised by fever, gastro-intestinal disturbance, medicine, habitat, totem, and tribalism, had taken and transient pleuro-pulmonary symptoms lasting immense risks, and, though cured, ncw found himself from three or four days to about a week, and a a kind of lost soul in limbo, a man cut off from hi malignant form, characterised by multiple lesions, own ancestral and tribal environment. He now deep-seated and subcutaneous suppuration, intense clung to his benefactor, who had beccme his " white toxaemia, prolonged duration, and frequent relapses. man." And the least that the new white man, now The diagnosis of tetragenus septicaemia is impossible responsible for him in this world and the next, could apart from an epidemic, but considerable diagnostic do was to give him a trifling present, the first of many importance is to be attached to the hectic character to come. Sometimes the primitive dodges these vast of the fever, the multiplicity of the lesions, the risks. He lends himself for a specified pericd to the absence of any important symptoms such as enlarge- dangerous alien influences. Thus a powerful Seuth Sea ment of the spleen, when the condition simulates Island potentate allowed his young wife to become typhoid fever, or of laryngo-bronchial catarrh in a Christian while undergoing a cure, but with the cases resembling influenza, and the frequency of proviso that she was to return to her native gcds after remissions and relapses. An exact diagnosis, how- the treatment, as she would have to be strangled on She was at least to die in ever, can only be established by direct examinationI the day of his death. of the pus, blood cultures, and serum agglutination. spiritual safety. The immediate prognosis is relatively good, even in We read between the lines in the pages of Prof. the severest forms, but the remote prognosis should Levy-Bruhl, and are constantly reminded of parallels be guarded owing to the frequency with which tuber- between the mental attitude of natives and the culosis develops. The use of auto-vaccines is the primitives to be found in many out-patient rocms and best method of treatment. A bibliography of recent poor practices. It is common for hospital patients literature is appended to the thesis. to believe that by allowing themselves to be treated they confer a favour upon the physician or surgeon. In its crudest form the belief involves the assumption PRIMITIVE PATIENTS. that the doctors should b3 glad of an opportunity to WHAT a mean fellow you are ! " said a Congo practise, but the attitude of a show patient " often chief to the Rev. W. H. Bentley, who had cured the indicates a sense of mutual obligation which, if we native of an illness and had come to inquire after his search our hearts, is not without foundation. Pride health. *’ What a fuss you made ! I had to eat in a good job well done, apart frcm a welcome a fowl and feed well; what strange things you white enhancement of reputation, may stimulate a feeling men are ! Why did not you give me a present when of gratitude towards the patient who has provided
capable of becoming septicaemia. This form
I
"
"
This the occasion. That the situation may be recognised you left ? What a mean fellow you are!" " Primitive by the patient was shown by a wounded soldier who. passage is cited from Prof Levy-Bruhl’s Mentality," a work of which one of the most interesting told that the attempt to save his leg had failed. chapters is headed The Primitive’s Attitude to replied to the surgeon, "Well, sir, I’ve wanted it off European Remedies. Here are set down numerous for a long time, but you seemed so interested that instances of the curious demeanour of Central I didn’t like to say so." In this sentiment, put forward Africans, natives of New Guinea, Battaks, Basutos, respectfully and with good intent, is expressed the Melanesians, and South American Indians towards idea of a favour conferred. The medical missicnary. the medical men, lay and missionary, who have like the surgeon in this case, is keen to exercise his helped them. When cured of a large and loathsome art, and the intuitive savage may be trusted to ulcer, for instance, they expect a solatium from their recognise this keenness. From this is a short step to Nor can they understand why the the belief that benefactors. any obligation is on the side of the demand of a present appears illogical to the white healer and this process may account for scme of tlw doctors. Prof. Levy-Bruhl explains the attitude of examples that would not be covered by Prof. the native in a manner at once surprising and Levy-Bruhl’s ingenious generalisaticn. The fear of convincing. The native, in the first place, is not the " doctor," the contempt of him, followed by aware that the medical man has taken any real ingratitude or a demand for money, are not unkncwll trouble in his case. His attendances, often laboriously to-many a surgical dresser in the east ends of large undertaken, his prescriptions, soup, rest, bandages, towns. Motives of policy have doubtless restrained and so forth are to the native so much hocus-pocus, our author from emphasising parallels, a large treatise the kind of thing a medicine-man must " keep up " which might yet be written. upon in order to maintain his mysterious prestige. Any good medicine-man, as every primitive knows, has such virtue within him that he could cure a man right THE INFLUENCE OF ATMOSPHERIC PRESSURE If, therefore, the nativee away by his mere touch. ON AN ARTIFICIAL PNEUMOTHORAX. submits to a long and tiresome treatment he does so has been known for many years that patients IT with his eyes open and as one playing into the hands of a conjurer. He hunours the white healer just as undergoing treatment by artificial pneumothorax he would humour a native wizard. But he expects to may experience some discomfort on going frcm a low " be paid in kind for his complaisance. I have to a high altitude, but few exact observations have played into your hands, my good sir," he saysin been made, such as those recorded by Dr. C’. Mantoux effect, and I deserve a reivard-a yard or two of in Revue de la Tuberculose (1923, vol. iv., -No. IS). ‘C1 cloth, or a pocket-knife. Better still, I deserveto be patient on whcm the observations were made was kept by you in future, fed, clothed, and all." The given a refill of 310 c.cm. of nitrogen in the right Rev. J. Mackenzie had cared for and cured a native pleural cavity on Sept. 19th at 1.50 P.JI.. when whose face had been terribly lacerated by a tiger. the barometer at Chamonix registered 712 mm. cf Aly mouth is not exactly where it used to be," said mercury. The initial pressure of -li was raised to the nativecondescendingly, "...but the wound is +9 by the injection. the pneumothorax being complete. quite whole. Everybody said I should die, but your At 2.25 he left Chamonix. which is 1050 metres above herbs cured me. Y’ou are now my white man ; please the sea. and lie arrived at Montenvers. which i,... to give me a knife." After some further pour-parlers 1914 metres above the ea. at 3.1.i. experitncinn the medical missionary gave the man up as a very a sensation of fullness in the c1 a en the way. and wonderful specimen of jumbled ideas." But the man slight pain over the base of the left lung en his 11’3i-Vill was less oblique than his mouth. He was following, at Montenvers. 3 pleural rub, which had not betii as Prof. Iz-v-I3rulxl clearly shows, a definite line of heard earlier in the day, was now dtmonstrabJe over "
.
"
primitive thought. In allowing himself to be treated by a foreigner, a man with other and distant gods. other " medicine," other habitat, totem, and tribal connexions, he as a good native of the districts ncrth of the Orange River, with his own gods (ancestors). characterised by fever, gastro-intestinal disturbance, medicine, habitat, totem, and tribalism, had taken and transient pleuro-pulmonary symptoms lasting immense risks, and, though cured, ncw found himself from three or four days to about a week, and a a kind of lost soul in limbo, a man cut off from hi malignant form, characterised by multiple lesions, own ancestral and tribal environment. He now deep-seated and subcutaneous suppuration, intense clung to his benefactor, who had beccme his " white toxaemia, prolonged duration, and frequent relapses. man." And the least that the new white man, now The diagnosis of tetragenus septicaemia is impossible responsible for him in this world and the next, could apart from an epidemic, but considerable diagnostic do was to give him a trifling present, the first of many importance is to be attached to the hectic character to come. Sometimes the primitive dodges these vast of the fever, the multiplicity of the lesions, the risks. He lends himself for a specified pericd to the absence of any important symptoms such as enlarge- dangerous alien influences. Thus a powerful Seuth Sea ment of the spleen, when the condition simulates Island potentate allowed his young wife to become typhoid fever, or of laryngo-bronchial catarrh in a Christian while undergoing a cure, but with the cases resembling influenza, and the frequency of proviso that she was to return to her native gcds after remissions and relapses. An exact diagnosis, how- the treatment, as she would have to be strangled on She was at least to die in ever, can only be established by direct examinationI the day of his death. of the pus, blood cultures, and serum agglutination. spiritual safety. The immediate prognosis is relatively good, even in We read between the lines in the pages of Prof. the severest forms, but the remote prognosis should Levy-Bruhl, and are constantly reminded of parallels be guarded owing to the frequency with which tuber- between the mental attitude of natives and the culosis develops. The use of auto-vaccines is the primitives to be found in many out-patient rocms and best method of treatment. A bibliography of recent poor practices. It is common for hospital patients literature is appended to the thesis. to believe that by allowing themselves to be treated they confer a favour upon the physician or surgeon. In its crudest form the belief involves the assumption PRIMITIVE PATIENTS. that the doctors should b3 glad of an opportunity to WHAT a mean fellow you are ! " said a Congo practise, but the attitude of a show patient " often chief to the Rev. W. H. Bentley, who had cured the indicates a sense of mutual obligation which, if we native of an illness and had come to inquire after his search our hearts, is not without foundation. Pride health. *’ What a fuss you made ! I had to eat in a good job well done, apart frcm a welcome a fowl and feed well; what strange things you white enhancement of reputation, may stimulate a feeling men are ! Why did not you give me a present when of gratitude towards the patient who has provided
capable of becoming septicaemia. This form
I
"
"
This the occasion. That the situation may be recognised you left ? What a mean fellow you are!" " Primitive by the patient was shown by a wounded soldier who. passage is cited from Prof Levy-Bruhl’s Mentality," a work of which one of the most interesting told that the attempt to save his leg had failed. chapters is headed The Primitive’s Attitude to replied to the surgeon, "Well, sir, I’ve wanted it off European Remedies. Here are set down numerous for a long time, but you seemed so interested that instances of the curious demeanour of Central I didn’t like to say so." In this sentiment, put forward Africans, natives of New Guinea, Battaks, Basutos, respectfully and with good intent, is expressed the Melanesians, and South American Indians towards idea of a favour conferred. The medical missicnary. the medical men, lay and missionary, who have like the surgeon in this case, is keen to exercise his helped them. When cured of a large and loathsome art, and the intuitive savage may be trusted to ulcer, for instance, they expect a solatium from their recognise this keenness. From this is a short step to Nor can they understand why the the belief that benefactors. any obligation is on the side of the demand of a present appears illogical to the white healer and this process may account for scme of tlw doctors. Prof. Levy-Bruhl explains the attitude of examples that would not be covered by Prof. the native in a manner at once surprising and Levy-Bruhl’s ingenious generalisaticn. The fear of convincing. The native, in the first place, is not the " doctor," the contempt of him, followed by aware that the medical man has taken any real ingratitude or a demand for money, are not unkncwll trouble in his case. His attendances, often laboriously to-many a surgical dresser in the east ends of large undertaken, his prescriptions, soup, rest, bandages, towns. Motives of policy have doubtless restrained and so forth are to the native so much hocus-pocus, our author from emphasising parallels, a large treatise the kind of thing a medicine-man must " keep up " which might yet be written. upon in order to maintain his mysterious prestige. Any good medicine-man, as every primitive knows, has such virtue within him that he could cure a man right THE INFLUENCE OF ATMOSPHERIC PRESSURE If, therefore, the nativee away by his mere touch. ON AN ARTIFICIAL PNEUMOTHORAX. submits to a long and tiresome treatment he does so has been known for many years that patients IT with his eyes open and as one playing into the hands of a conjurer. He hunours the white healer just as undergoing treatment by artificial pneumothorax he would humour a native wizard. But he expects to may experience some discomfort on going frcm a low " be paid in kind for his complaisance. I have to a high altitude, but few exact observations have played into your hands, my good sir," he saysin been made, such as those recorded by Dr. C’. Mantoux effect, and I deserve a reivard-a yard or two of in Revue de la Tuberculose (1923, vol. iv., -No. IS). ‘C1 cloth, or a pocket-knife. Better still, I deserveto be patient on whcm the observations were made was kept by you in future, fed, clothed, and all." The given a refill of 310 c.cm. of nitrogen in the right Rev. J. Mackenzie had cared for and cured a native pleural cavity on Sept. 19th at 1.50 P.JI.. when whose face had been terribly lacerated by a tiger. the barometer at Chamonix registered 712 mm. cf Aly mouth is not exactly where it used to be," said mercury. The initial pressure of -li was raised to the nativecondescendingly, "...but the wound is +9 by the injection. the pneumothorax being complete. quite whole. Everybody said I should die, but your At 2.25 he left Chamonix. which is 1050 metres above herbs cured me. Y’ou are now my white man ; please the sea. and lie arrived at Montenvers. which i,... to give me a knife." After some further pour-parlers 1914 metres above the ea. at 3.1.i. experitncinn the medical missionary gave the man up as a very a sensation of fullness in the c1 a en the way. and wonderful specimen of jumbled ideas." But the man slight pain over the base of the left lung en his 11’3i-Vill was less oblique than his mouth. He was following, at Montenvers. 3 pleural rub, which had not betii as Prof. Iz-v-I3rulxl clearly shows, a definite line of heard earlier in the day, was now dtmonstrabJe over "
.
"