Psychoanalytic evaluations for the courts: A handbook for mental health professionals and lawyers

w7-2352/w Copynghc

CURRENT PUBLICATIONS

Ann

John

disputes

Christopher

G.

Poythress.

validity tic

and

is disputed.

Guilford

Press

New York,

(X0

New York

Park

Avcnuc

IoW3).

input

51

I pp..

hardcover-$50.00

play

health

professionals

an important

legal

role

proceedings.

many , however. criticism health

of

in a wide

Kcliancc has

both

on

cntailcd

the courts

profession.

To

and the

the

some cxtcnt

clinicians

can provide

training

Another

sions.

Moreover,

to assist ways

the issues

health

when

clinicians

in legal matters,

specified

accustomed

their

precisely.

to functioning

their

has been used sometimes

of

morality

The

and

social

fusion

involved

The One,

reduced,

both

of moral

questions

and to eliminate

reliance

proceedings to halt

with

on a scicncc

ophies

ones whose

do psychoand lawyers

scrviccs.

to address.

and

It

is a

of

These

competency

civil

injuries, basic

such

of

its

taken

in each area, workings,

on clinical

arc made for

procedures

as cus-

approach

of the law

research

guardjuvenile

issues

The

in-

dctcrmina-

commitment,

and family

book ‘Gcncral

and

and legal improving

and the use of

The

is divided

of

into

first.

“Law An

the differences the two of

five

Considerations,”

Professions:

1the issue 65

com-

infor-

by the courts.

examines

the con-

scientific

who

USC thcsc

Suggestions

Health

be

a

two of

to bc used hy both

for the courts

examination

chapters.

that the USC of mental

in legal

system.

an outline

mation in

a statcwidc

and neglect.

evaluation

questions

dcvclop

evaluating

issues.

testi-

also has pre-

policy

sentencing,

a critical

decisionmaking.

professionals

substantially

expert

tions,

discussion

to the lim-

the fundamental

It has been suggested health

way

insanity

involves

arc un-

The

from

evaluation

clinicians

clude

tody

grew

guide to major issues the courts

delinquency,

in the adversarial

its of

courtroom

also

asked

in the

role.

in which

professionals

who

ianship,

arc asked

sensitive

mony

vented confronting

not

dcci-

task is not al-

They

arena and are not always expertise.

does

evaluations

have

legal

legal

logical

their

volume

is dcsigncd

health

comprehcnsivc

is that

field

underlying

book

mental

and judges

is due

however,

hclpod

health

is to improve

for participating

in Virginia,

outpatient

The

assessments

to make binding issue,

in the mental

encompass

this

program

legal

adequately

in mental

approach

prcscnt

for

ol

mental

experts

idea

munity

tcsti-

fram

less dras-

many

with

not to eliminate

the authors

widcsprcad

to USC: of the type of probabilistic judgments.

variety their

.cm

of the pres-

that

be dealt

preparation

to

have come

believe

Icgal process. training

Mental

authors

take a much

the proper

clinicians’

South,

1987.

They

cannot

without

Slobogin.

The

however,

position.

and that The

+

Press plc

Munster

ent volume.

Norman

53 00 Prrpamm

ABSTRACTS

Psychoanalytic Evaluations for the Courts: A Handbook for Mental Health Professionals and Lawyers by Gary B. Melton. Petrila.

,C IYXY

Part three

and

the

Mental

Uneasy

Alliance,”

between

the philos-

disciplines

whether

parts.

contains

clinicians

and confronts can provide

66

Current

the

kind

of data for

looked to them. answer.

Two.

System:

System,

-An

Sources

Adjudicative authors

the stages

proceedings.

section,

sures rcnsic The

trial.

Process,”

ncy.

of

the

matism.

diminished

techniques

ill

novel

*reconstructive”

and

either

system. can

mental

reports

of mental

a

state at in this

It describes

suggcst-

input

ways

focusing

both

under

in which spccifi-

book.

input

The

of clinical

from

on how

writing

points final

ters. index.

which

covered

in the on le-

made in the pertinent

chapter

and research

consists

terms.

extensive

stress

be done. evaluation

commentary

of legal terms

with

Chapter

it should sample

of the issues

area.

evaluation and gives

relevant

notes

of

two

and the other Each

in the book has its own bibliography. concludes

dynam-

the courts.

report

contains

glossaries-one

in lack

in this difficult

accompanying

gal and clinical chapters.

and family

with

on some

Custody

is the current

the focus

discusses

with

” and “Child focus

of

Dclinqucncy.”

that needs to be applied

to communication

and new

last chapter

It then discusses

shifts

Five

Fifteen

for conducting

of clinical

clinical

Part

involvc-

and it consists

of children

guidance

impairments

and the research

contribute.

and Neglect.

in utilizing

in dcwhich and the

to children’s

“Juvcnilc

A major

issue under

difficulty.

system.

chapters:

“Abuse

legal and clinical

to be awarded

is dcvotcd

Chapter

ideal and the use of dctcr-

clinicians

ought

comspecifically

the key

the grcatcst

in the legal

three

in connection

the circumstances

Four

Chap-

mechanisms

It focuses

hctwccn

detailed

the rehabilitative

ing a lack of intlucnce

those injured

of causation.

compensation Part

security.

main

of others-workman’s

and tort law.

concepts

ment

with

to social

the two

the actions

rc-

sentencing.

sentencing

describes

chap-

The

section deals with minate

ter Ten

Fourteen

evaluating

‘syndromes”

The

auto-

intoxication.

verdict.

evaluation

of offense.

covers

of

and re-

the competency

ics and the caution

It also

to treatment

deals

as it relates

Divorce.”

discus-

Competenguardianship,

segment

final

to work

of knowledge

sections

assessing

to consent

States at the Time

capacity,

and some recommendations the time

and it in-

on

A

one posing

of voluntar-

“Civil

data

danger-

to make a will.

tcrmining

to

an adversar-

and the competency

a lengthy

dcfcnsc.

with

Nine.

on the differcncc

to

recent Supreme

short-term

sections

inpro-

search,

pcnsation

to an attor-

to testify.

competencies

Eight

and presenting

of

Chapter

chapters,

of the current

the attorney

contains

the

it focuses

recommending

for compensating

in cur-

dcfcnsc,

ousness. ties,”

with

justice

to confess.

as the defense

but mentally

for

in fo-

Chapter

the right

-Mental

such

search on various

Its

in the Criminal

an insanity

insanity

concludes

predictability

evaluation

dispositions.

contains

issues

tcr

on

the possibility

of the issue

Six,

related

the guilty

and

psychological

compctcncy

the Offcnsc.”

sion

for

is on the compctcncy

to waive

Chapter

ial role

culpa-

Chapter

it criticizes

decisions,

the

three

and

on the deficiencies

this

prin-

of

proceedings.

cess. In that vein.

of pres-

the abuses

tensely

most

emphasizing

consisting

Court

process.

for the criminal

to refuse

consideration

iness. of

with

and the competency

cludcs

in

Three,

and

Process:

explore

deals

Four

covers

bc cxccutcd.

processing,

involved

Compctcncics

plcud guilty.

and

is subject.

pretrial

“Other

commitment.

as a Double

and discusses

altcmativc

Five,

civil

the kinds

It examines

proccdurcs

is on

the legal and ethical

conducted

Chapter

It

the evaluation

Part Two

system.

of the law.”

chapter

the clinician

to stand

civil

Common-Law,

next three sections

evaluations

with

Professional

evaluations

in detail.

of

last

goal is to identify to which

deals

of the Evaluation

Health

Aeent.” examines c ciples that govern primary

a

between criminal

The

Contours

Mental

is

of criminal

‘Constitutional.

Ethical

Process.-

Part

them

to treatment,

and dangerousness.

‘essentially

as

of the legal system

the distinction

rent

last.

the

clarifying

The

Court

the

confronting

frequently-amenability

Law,

the

describes

on the questions

bility.

by

the operation

tally

of the

on the ‘infrastructure’

outlines

civil

of

have

affirmative

Abstrxts

Overview

and

described primer

the courts

_givinp a qualified

Chapter

Legal

which

Publicatwns

chapter

The

book

for all chap-

case law.

and an