STUDIES ON THE ROLE OF CATECHOLAMINS OF THE Dads PA’JXERN OF ~C
IN THE REGULATION AROMATASE
Jacob A. &nick,” Stuart A. Tobet,b Michael J. Baum,f Dennis E. Vaccaro, Kenneth J. Ryan: Susan E. L.eeman,C and Thomas 0. Foxb Dqxutment of Pathology, Brown University, Women & Infants Hospital, Providence, RI 0290.5’; The E.K. Shriver Center, 200 Trapelo Road, Waltham, MA 02~254~;Depaiment of Biology, Boston University, Boston, MA 02219; Department of Obstetrics and Gynecology, Harvard Medical School, Boston, MA 0X15? Lkpartment of Physiology, University of Massachusetts School of Medicine, Worcester. MA 01605, USAe
ABSTRACT
Experiments were conducted to study the regulation of the developmental pattern of aromatase in the forebrain of the perinatal rat. Two experimental designs were used: aromatase measured in primary cultures of fetal hypothalamic cells and in cell-free preparations of forebrain tissue excised at varying ages. In cultured cells, aromatase decreased logarithmically at a slow rate (t1/2 = 7.8 days). Norepinephrine caused a pronounced dose (4 x IWM) and time-dependent (2-6 days) drop in aromatase without affecting the levels of Sa-reductase or substance P. In isolated tissue, ~omatase activity was compared with the concentrations of norepinephrine and dopamine in the forebrain of males vs females at different perinatal ages and in discrete forebrain areas at postnatal day 4. In no case was a sex difference in catecholamines seen. An overall developmental decline in aromatase was associated with developmental increases in catecholamine levels. Acute treatment with the beta-agonist, isoproterenol, had no effect on brain aromatase activity. INTRODUCTION Androgen metabolism in specific brain regions most likely plays an integral role in the process of sexual differentiation
of the male rat brain (1,2). Aromatization,
in particular,
may be essential for the defeminizadon of behavior and gonado~opin control and important for behavioral
masculinization
(3,4). Very little is known about the regulation
developmental
pattern of the aromatase enzyme in the brain during the period of sexual
differentiation,
although it is clear that aromatase activity in the preoptic area and temporal
lobe tissues is highest during the perinatal
period in mammals
and declines
of the
during
development (4-6). Throughout development, aromatase is somewhat higher in males than
STEROIDS 50 / 4-6 1987
510
Canick et al.
in females, synthesis
presumably
of aromatase
The possible effecters Since neural pathways concentrations serotonin
are increasing
beta-adrenergic
are forming
in the brain throughout
measurable
conducted
regulatory
factors,
decreased
marker, substance
hypothalami
decreased
administering
of neonatally
subsequently
effecters
may influence
and compared
examining
we attempted
into the nuclear an indirect
which
we have
have easily
of various
potential
androgen
metabolic
and another important
concentration
of a neuronal
was measured
with levels of norepinephrine
a potent beta-agonist,
hypothalamic
that apparent
aromatization,
in the presence
to manipulate
In fact,
treated female rats
of fetal rat hypothalamus,
with the cellular
and
(13).
P. In the other model, the activity of aromatase
(-)isoproterenol,
suggested
the uptake of [3Hjestradiol
(14,1.5), were grown
were compared
In addition,
dopamine,
of neonatal rats given [3H]-testosterone,
how possible
levels
of the rat forebrain
the same regions.
the
and since the
would include these compounds.
androgenization
and the levels of aromatase
Sex-reductase,
induce
are not yet known.
development
by Raum and his colleagues
In one, cell cultures
aromatase
which
such as norepinephrine,
of a possible effect on in vivo brain aromatization
used two models.
regions
androgens,
decline of brain aromatase
(9-l l), likely candidates
To study more precisely
enzyme,
circulating
neurotransmitters
such stimulation
of homogenized
indication
of the developmental
stimulation
(12). Additionally,
of higher
in males (7,8).
of putative
a series of experiments
fraction
because
beta-adrenergic
in discrete
and dopamine stimulation
in by
to neonatal male and female rats and
aromatase activity.
EXPERIMENTAL Animals. For cell-culture experiments, pregnant Sprague-Dawley-derived rats (CD strain) were obtained on the thirteenth day of gestation and were sacrificed on the eighteenth day. For tissue experiments, adult male and virgin female Long-Evans rats were used. Both strains were purchased from Charles River Breeding Laboratories (Wilmington, MA). Cell culture. Detailed methodology for the preparation of these cultures has been described previously (16). Hypothalami were removed from pooled male and female fetuses taken at
STEROIDS
50 14-6
1987
CATECHOLAMINES
AND BRAIN AROMATASE
511
day 18 of gestation. Cultures were treated with 2 x 10-e M I-beta-arabinofuranosylcytosine at the time of plating to enhance neuronal morphology. Aromatase was determined using 19-hydroxy-[6,7-3Hlandrostenedione as substrate. Sa-Reductase was determined using [lp,2@Hftestosterone as substrate. The incubation with labeled steroids and analysis of extracts for labeled metabolites and for substance P were as described previously (15). Tissue experiments. Rats were decapitated at various ages, ranging from the eighteenth day of gestation to the eighteenth postnatal day. For all ages and for all types of tissue dissected, the basic procedure was the same as previously described (6). Tissues for aromatase assay were stored in liquid nitrogen in an enzyme-stabilizing medium (20% glycerol, 0.1 mM EDTA, 50 mM potassium phosphate, pH 7.4, with 1 mM dithiothreitol added just prior to use). Tissue samples stored frozen for several weeks exhibited no loss of aromatase activity. Tissues for catecholamine (CA) analysis were homogenized and centrifuged before storage in liquid nitrogen. CA samples were never stored for longer tham 24 h. Aromatase w. The assay for aromatase activity was exactly as described previously (6). The substrate was 19-hydroxy-[6,7-XIJandrostenedione, SA=5 Ci/mmol and the isolated product was [3H]estrone. Data were expressed as total activity (pm01 estronef animal/30 min) or specific activity (pm01 estronelmg protein/30 min). Catecholamine m. Concentrations of norepinephrine (NE) and dopamine (DA} were determined in various brain regions dissected from individual animals using high performance liquid chromatography (HPLC) with electrochemical detection. Dissected tissue was homogenized by ultrasonic disruption in 0.1 M perchloric acid to which l-3 ngf100 FL dihydroxybenzylamine had been added as an internal standard. Details of the HPLC assay are given by Menniti and Baum (17). CA and aromatase data were analyzed by 2-factor ANOVA, sex x region (repeated measure). A w comparisons between sex in each region were done by Newman-Keuls test (18). Intraventricular isoproterenol. Four-day-old rats were administered one of four treatments 3-7 h before lights on: 1) 50 pg (-)isoproterenol (ISO) in 4 PL 0.9% saline injected intraventricularly (iv) according to a method modified by Noble a d (19); 2) 4 &Lof saline injected iv; 3) 60 pg of an~osta-l,4,6,-~ene-3,17-dione (ATD) suspended in 50 PL saline injected SC; or 4) 50 FL of saiine injected SC. Three hours after injection, pups were sacrificed, the HPOAs dissected, placed in stabilizing medium, and frozen until aromatase assay. Animals injected with IS0 were more active and vocalized more than either salineor ATD-injected animals, suggesting that this dose of IS0 was active behaviorally. The data were analyzed using a 2-factor analysis of variance, sex x treatment; aposteriori comparisons were made with Newman-Keuls tests (18). RESULTS Culture experiments.
The potential of the cultures to aromatize and fja-reduce added
substrate was determined as a function of the age of the culture (Fig. 1). Both enzymes are plotted as the total qu~tity
of product formed, either estrone or DHT, over a 24-h period.
Over the first month in culture, aromatase declined logarithmically days while Scl-reductase remained essentially constant.
STEROIDS
50 /4-6
1987
with a half life of 7.8
512
Canick et al.
0.2 -
I
I
I
I
I
I
5
IO
I5
20
25
30
Age of Culture
.
(days)
Figure 1. Aromatase (PHJestrone production) and So-reductase ([XIjdihydrotestosterone production) as a function of age of the culture. For aromatase, n=2; for Sa-reductase, n=4. Arrow indicates the half-life for aromatase. Several putative neurotransmitters and 5ol-reduction.
Neurotransmitters
were examined for their ability to affect aromatization were added twice daily for a period of 4 days
beginning 1 day after plating. Control wells received the app~p~ate vehicle. The cells were then allowed to incubate for consecutive 24-h periods with each of the tritiated substrates. Dopamine (DA) and epinephrine treatment did not alter aromatase or 5a-reductase 2B-C) except at the highest concentrations;
at these concentrations
(Fig.
both enzyme activities
decreased and necrosis of the cultures was apparent. The addition of y-aminobutyric
acid
(Fig. 2D) in the same manner did not affect either enzyme nor was it toxic in the range of concentrations
used. Incubation of the cultures with norepinephrine
effect on enzyme activity at low concentrations high concentrations
(NE) (Fig. 2A) had no
(<10-e M) and was toxic to the cultures at
+10-s M). However, at an intermediate concentration
(4 x IO-6 M),
which did not appear to be toxic to the cells, a selective decrease in aromatization occurred, while So-reduction was essentially unaffected. When the results of seven experiments were
STEROIDS
50 / 4-6 1987
CATECHOLAMINES
I t I 5 \
AND BRAIN AROMATASE
3.0
3.0
2.0
2.0
I.o
I .o
513
3.0 3.0 2.0
2.0
1.0
% 01
1.0 1 Y 0
w” + 1.5 W
t: 1.5 5
z I.0 E 0 0.5
1.0 -g a 0.5
I.5 1.0 0.5
lO-6 Neurotransmitter
lci5 ( M1
Figure 2. Production of [3H]estrogen (aromatization) and [3H]DHT (k-reduction) in culture in response to different doses of: A) norepinephrine, B) dopamine, C) epinephrine, D) y-aminobutyric acid. The dotted lines in B,C, and D describe the decline in aromatase in response to norepinephrine as shown in A. For all points, n=3. averaged using
NE at 4 x IO-6 M, a decrease of less than 2% in 5a-reductase
was
recorded, while aromatization decreased by 73% rt: 11%. To characterize
the selective decline in aromatization
caused by NE, the following
experiments
were performed. Figure 3 describes a time-course
of incubation
with NE
a~in~stered
twice daily. A decline in aromatase was apparent after 2 days of incubation
STEROIDS
50 / 4-6 1987
514
Canick
et al.
0
2
length’ of
4 6 8 NE treatment (days)
Figure 3. [3H]Estrone production (aromatization) in cultures as a function of the length of treatment with norepinephrine (4 x 10-b M). Each data bar represents the average of two cultures. and was virtually complete by 4 days. No decrease was observed after a 24-h incubation, nor did NE directly inhibit aromatization when included with tritiated substrate (data not shown). Washing away the NE did not reverse a decline once it had occurred. Figure 4 describes the effect of varying NE doses and treatment regimens on aromatase, Sex-reductase, and substance P, a peptide present in hypothalamic neurons. Treatment twice daily for 4 days with 10-c M NE had no effect (Fig. 4B) while 4 x 10-h M NE caused a selective decrease in aromatase only (Fig. 4C). Treatment with 10-S M NE twice daily for 4 days caused a sharp decrease in aromatase, but also caused a decrease in Sa-reductase and to a lesser extent in substance P (Fig. 4D), indicating a generalized toxic effect in this case. Multiple doses of NE appear to be necessary since the higher dose (lo-5 M), given only once, had no effect when tested 4 days later (Fig. 4E). Experiments
were performed to determine whether NE receptors were involved in
mediating this effect. NE was added twice daily to cultures, as described previously, with or without up to equimolar concentrations phentolamine,
of the alpha-blockers,
phenoxybenzamine
or
or the beta-blocker, propranolol. In all cases, no inhibition of the NE effect
was observed. Higher concentrations of these blockers were toxic. When NE was replaced
STEROIDS
50 / 4-6 1987
CATECHOLAMINES
by the alpha- or beta-agonists,
AND BRAIN AROMATASE
515
clonidine or isoprotereno1, no decrease in aromatization or
So-reduction
was observed in the range of concentrations
Isoproterenol
appeared to lower ~omatization
at which NE was effective.
isoproterenol were toxic. 0
.; 1
at a dose of 10-5 M; higher doses of
1
Aromatase 51x -Reductase
1 L
P
I
a
b
c
d
e
Figure 4. A comparison of [Wlestrogen production (aromatization), [VIJDHT production (5a-reduction), and substance P content of cultures after treatment for 4 days with norepinephrine (NE). a) vehicle alone, twice daily; b) 10-6 M NE, twice daily; c) 4 x10-6 M NE, twice daily; d) 10-s M NE, twice daily; e) 10-s M NE, administered only once and then left untreated for the 4-day period. Tissue em.
The developmental
patterns of NE, DA, and aromatase were
compared in the hypothalamus plus preoptic area (HPOA) of male and female rats from 2 days before birth to 18 days after birth (Fig. 5). Aromatase activity was consistently higher in males than females in the HPOA at all ages examined. The developmental
pattern of
aromatase activity appeared different when the data were expressed as total activity as compared to specific activity. Specific activity decreased with age, whereas total activity, especially in males, increased into the early postnatal period (days 3 and 4), fell on day 6, and rose to another apparent peak on days 9 and 10 before falling
STEROIDS
50 /4-6
1987
to the lowest
516
Canick et al.
Figure 5. Norepinephrine (NE) and dopamine (DA) concentrations and aromatase activity in the hypothalamus + preoptic area as a function of age in male and female rats. Aromatase data are displayed as the mean of the 4 determinations and are presented as pmol estrone/mg protein/30 min (specific activity) and pmol estrone/animal/30 min (total activity). NE and DA concentrations were determined in tissues from individual animals and the data are displayed as mean f SEM. levels on day 17. In contrast, from gestational catecholamine distribution
day 20 to postnatal content
of aromatase,
male and female females(p<.Ol), (p<.Ol),
there was an age-dependent
in NE and DA content
day 17. There were no significant
nor was there
a trend
for a sex difference
sex differences across
ages.
NE, and DA within the HPOA was studied in postnatal
rats (Fig. 6). evident
increase
Males had significantly
in the preoptic
but not in the anterior
area (~~01)
or posterior
more aromatase
and in the anterior
hypothalamus.
Furthermore,
STEROIDS
in The
day 4
activity
than
temporal
lobe
the greatest
50 / 4-6 1987
CATECHOLAMINES
AROA.fA JASE
AND BRAIN AROMATASE
517
5
Figure 6. Norepinephrine (NE), dopamine (DA), and aromatase activity in brain regions of male and female rats sacrificed on postnatal day 4. The number of animals in each group is given above each bar and the data are displayed as mean z!zSEM. Some of these data were reported in Tobet a d (6). Males significantly higher than females (*p<.O5,**p<.Ol). amount of activity was seen in the anterior temporal lobe followed by the preoptic area, anterior, and then posterior hypothalamus. In contrast, there were no reliable sex differences in catecholamine content in any brain region examined. There were, however, significant regional differences in catecholamine content
(~~01).
NE content
was highest
in the preoptic
area and the anterior
hypothalamus, lower in the posterior hypothalamus, and lower still in the anterior temporal lobe. DA content was greatest in the preoptic area. The anterior hypothalamus contained STEROIDS
50 / 4-6 1987
518
Canick et al.
less DA than the posterior comparable
administration
activity
subcutaneous m
The DA content of the anterior temporal lobe was
to that found in the anterior hypothalamus.
Intraventricular aromatase
hypothalamus.
in males
administration
by approximately
males had significantly
of the
beta-agonist,
or females
isoproterenol,
on postnatal
of the aromatase
day 4 (Fig.
inhibitor ATD reduced
70% in males and females.
had no effect
Regardless
on
7). In contrast,
aromatase
of pharmacologic
activity _ treatment,
more aromatase activity than females in the HPOA.
1
ATD
ControlIS0
ATD
Figure 7. Aromatase activity in the hypothalamus + preoptic area of male and female rats sacrificed on postnatal day 4, 3 h after drug or vehicle administration. The number of animals in each group is given above each bar and the data are expressed as mean + SEM. For control and IS0 groups, aromatase activity was significantly higher in males than in females (pc.01) and significantly lower in ATD-treated rats (pc.01) than in either IS0 or control animals.
DISCUSSION The experiments brain aromatase
reported
here were designed
and to study factors
to examine
which might regulate
the developmental that process.
STEROIDS
decline
in
Brain aromatase
50 / 4-6
1987
CATECHOLAMINES
519
AND BRAIN AROMATASE
was studied in two systems: primary culture of fetal rat hypothalamic cells and cell-free preparations of h~~~~c
tissue f?om rats at different times in the perinatal period.
The culture experiments demonstrate that norepinephrine causes a dramatic decline in the aromatization
of androgen to estrogen by hypothalamic cells. Treatment of the cells with
other putative neuro~ansmitters
causes a decline in aromatization only at concen~ations
which cause necrosis of the cells. When necrosis is observed, Sa-reductase and substance P also decrease. significantly
Only NE treatment
selectively
aromatization
altering either Sa-reductase or the intracellular concentration
and without visibly altering the mo~hology
high concentrations
without
of substance P
of the cultures. Alpha- and eta-agonists
antagonists were either ineffective in the concentration
Alternatively,
decreases
(>lO-5 M), thus masking
range tested or were cytotoxic at
a possible
it is possible that chronic administration
and
receptor-mediated
effect.
of NE is toxic to cells that contain
aromatase but not to others, perhaps in the same way that kainic acid can be toxic to some neurons
but not to most non-neuronal
cells (15,20).
Chronic
in vitro
effects of
catecholamines are not well-studied phenomena. Hypothalamic aromatase activity declines during development in vivQ (4-6) (Fig. 5) and declines during the lifetime of the cultured hypothalamic aromatization
cells (Fig. 1). The decline in
observed with age of culture appears not to be due to a general decline in
culture viability, since the levels of Sa-reductase are relatively constant throughout the first month of culture (Fig. 1) and somatostatin
and glutamine
synthetase levels have been
shown to increase during this period (21,22). Whether NE is responsible physiologically for the decreases in aromatase measured in vivo and in vitro is still to be determined. The developmental
decline in aromatase appears to correlate with a gross increase in NE
and DA within the HPOA (9-l 1) (Fig. 5). However, there are no correlations between sex or regional
increases
in aromatase
and lower NE or DA levels. With regard to sex
differences in aromatase, this well-documented
effect is not dramatic, generally ranging
from 50% to 100% higher in males than in females (4-6). The higher levels in males are
STEROIDS
50 / 4-6 1987
Canick et al.
520
most
likely
attributable
catecholamines. correlate
to induction
Regional differences
with catecholamine
lobe, the region
levels (Fig. 6). Sex or regional
not alter aromatase
in aromatase
aromatase
differences
aromatase
measured,
possible that estrogen translocation In summary, the possibility
brain and correlates perinatal
stress reduces
were not examined.
injection of isoproterenol
did
that acute beta-adrenergic
in aromatase
(13). Since they also
uptake into hypothalamic
nuclei, it is
administration.
of the catecholaminergic and dopamine.
activity (23) is particularly stimulation
temporal
catecholamine
may regulate the developmental
in norepinephrine
adrenergic
the lowest
further. The decline in aromatase
with maturation
do not appear to
the anterior
turnover
by
in vitro 3 h later (Fig. 7). This negative
is affected by beta-agonist
brain aromatase
directly related to increased
estrogen
that catecholamines
with increases
exhibits
in catecholamine
may cause a decline
should be investigated
period to adulthood coincides
although
of Raum and co-workers
as part of their assay product,
brain aromatase
activity,
activity in the HPOA measured
of the hypothalamus
than modulation
within the rat forebrain
activity, intraventricular
result does not support the conclusions stimulation
(7,8) rather
levels within those regions,
with the highest
In an attempt to manipulate
by androgens
pattern of
from the perinatal pathways
within the
The recent finding that intriguing
and may be
of the hypothalamus.
ACKNOWLEDGMENTS This work was supported by U.S. Public Health Service Grants HD 21094, HD 12337, and HD 20327 (M.J.B., J.A.C., T.O.F.), by Research Career Development Award MH 00392 (M.J.B.), and by a Mental Retardation Core Grant HD 04147 (E. K. Shriver Center).
REFERENCES 1. Baum MJ (1979). Differentiation of coital behavior in mammals: A comparative analysis. NEUROSCI BIOBEHAV REV 3:265-284. 2. MacLusky NJ and Naftolin F (1981). Sexual differentiation of the central nervous system. SCIENCE 211: 1294-1303. 3. McEwen BS, Lieberburg I, Chaptal C, and Krey LC (1977). Aromatization: Important for sexual differentiation of the neonatal rat brain. HORM BEHAV 9:249-263.
STEROIDS
50 / 4-6
1987
CATECHOLAMINES
AND BRAIN AROMAJASE
521
4. Naftolin F, Ryan KJ, Davies IJ, Reddy VV, Flores F, Petro Z, Kuhn M, White RJ,
Takaoka Y, and Wolin L (1975). The formation of estrogens by central neuroendocrine tissues. RECENT PROG HORM RES 31:295-3 19. 5. George FW and Ojeda SR (1982). Changes in aromatase activity in the rat brain during embryonic, neonatal, and infantile development. ENDOCRINOLOGY 111522-529. 6. Tobet SA, Baum MJ, Tang HB, Shim JH, and Canick JA (1985). Aromatase activity in the perinatal rat forebrain: Effects of age, sex and intrauterine position. DEV BRAIN RES 23:171-178. 7. Roselli CE, Ellinwood WE, and Resko JA (1984). Regulation of brain aromatase activity in rats. E~OCRINOL~Y 114:192-200. 8. Roselli CE and Resko JA (1984). Androgens regulate brain aromatase activity in adult male rats through a receptor mechanism. ENDOCRINOLOGY 114:2183-2189. 9. Hyyppa M (1969) A histochemical study of the primary catecholamines in the hypothalamic neurons of the rat in relation to the ontogenetic and sexual differentiation. ZEITSCHR ZELLFORSCH 98550-560. 10. Hyyppa M (1971). Hypo~~~ic mono~ines and pineal dopamine during the sexual ~fferentiation of the rat brain. EXPER~E~A 27:336-337. 11. Smith GC and Simpson RW (1970). Monoamine fluorescence in the median eminence of foetal, neonatal and adult rats. ZEITSCHR ZELLFORSCH 104541-556. 12. Raum WJ and Swerdloff RS (198 1). The role of hypothalamic adrenergic receptors in preventing testosterone-induced androgenization in the female rat brain. ENDOCRINOLOGY 109:273-278. 13. Raum WJ, Marcano M, and Swerdloff RS (1984). Nuclear accumulation of estradiol derived from the aromatization of testosterone is inhibited by hypothal~ic betareceptor stimulation in the neonatal female rat. BIOL REPROD 30:388-396. 14. Canick JA, Vaccaro DE, Ryan KJ, and Leeman SE (1977). The aromatization of androgens by primary monolayer cultures of fetal rat hypothalamus. ENDOCRINOLOGY 100:250-253. 15. Canick JA, Vaccaro DE, Livingston EM, Leeman SE, Ryan KJ, and Fox TO (1986). Localization of aromatase and Set-reductase to neuronal and non-neuronal cells in the fetal rat hypo~alamus. BRAIN RES 372:277-282. 16. Vaccaro DE and Messer A (1977). Preparation of fetal rat h~oth~~ic cells in primary monolayer culture. TISSUE CULTURE ASSN MANUAL 3561-563. 17. Menniti FS and Baum MJ (1981). Differential effects of estrogen and androgen on locomotor activity induced in castrated male rats by amphetamine, a novel environment, or apomorphine. BRAIN RES 216:89-107. 18. Brunning JL and Kintz BL. Comnutational Handbook pf Statistics, Scott, Foresman, Glenview, Illinois (1977), pp. 119-121. 19. Noble EP, Wurtman RJ, and Axelrod J (1967). A simple and rapid method for injecting 3H-norepinephrine into the lateral ventricle of the rat brain. LIFE SC1 6:281291. 20. Herndon RM and Coyle JT (1977). Selective destruction of neurons by a transmitter agonist. SCIENCE 198:7 l-72. 21. Vaccaro DE, Leeman SE, and Reif-Lehrer L (1979). Glutamine synthetase activity & m and in primary cell cultures of rat hypothalamus. J NEUROCHEM 33:953-957. 22. Gamse R, Vaccaro DE, Gamse G, DiPace M, Fox TO, and Leeman SE (1980). Release of i~unoreactive somatos~tin from hypo~al~i~ cells in culture: Inhibition by raminobutyric acid. PROC NATL ACAD SC1 USA 77:5552-5556. 23. Weisz J, Brown BL, and Ward IL (1982). Maternal stress decreases steroid aromatase activity in brains of male and female rat fetuses. NEUROENDOCRINOLOGY 35:374-379.
STEROIDS
50 / 4-6 1987