A Retrospective Review of 26 Cases of Dysthyroid Optic Neuropathy

A Retrospective Review of 26 Cases of Dysthyroid Optic Neuropathy

A R E T R O S P E C T I V E R E V I E W O F 26 CASES O F DYSTHYROID OPTIC NEUROPATHY GREGORY J. PANZO, M.D., AND ROBERT L. TOMSAK, M.D. Chveland, Ohio...

545KB Sizes 42 Downloads 89 Views

A R E T R O S P E C T I V E R E V I E W O F 26 CASES O F DYSTHYROID OPTIC NEUROPATHY GREGORY J. PANZO, M.D., AND ROBERT L. TOMSAK, M.D. Chveland, Ohio

Sixteen patients (14 women and two men) with dysthyroid optic neuropathy (26 involved eyes) were treated with either oral corticosteroids, orbital irradiation, surgical orbital decompression, combined corticosteroids and irradiation, or combined corticosteroids and surgi­ cal decompression. Thirteen of 16 eyes responded favorably to corticosteroid therapy but eight of the 13 relapsed upon discontinuation of treatment. Two of four eyes responded to irradiation initially but later relapsed. The response to orbital decompression was almost uniformly beneficial (eight of nine eyes responded) and lasting in all. Combined modes of therapy offered no additional advantage. Accepted treatments for dysthyroid optic neuropathy include systemic corti­ costeroids, orbital irradiation, and surgi­ cal decompression of the orbit. We retro­ spectively analyzed cases of dysthyroid optic neuropathy treated here between 1972 and 1982. SUBJECTS AND METHODS

The study included 16 patients (26 eyes) affected by dysthyroid optic neu­ ropathy. All the involved eyes demon­ strated optic nerve dysfunction and the characteristic external signs of ocular dysthyroidism. Optic nerve dysfunction was documented by examination of visual acuity, visual fields, pupils, and color vision. We excluded patients with other conditions that might have accounted for visual impairment (opaque media, maculopathy, and the like). The patients ranged in age from 26 to

Accepted for publication May 11, 1983. From the Department of Ophthalmology, Cleve­ land Clinic Foundation, Cleveland, Ohio. Reprint requests to Robert L. Tomsak, M.D., Department of Ophthalmology, 9500 Euclid Ave., Cleveland, OH 44106. 190

69 years (mean age, 51 years). Fourteen of the 16 patients were female. At the time dysthyroid optic neuropathy was diagnosed, 11 patients were euthyroid, four were hyperthyroid, and one was hypothyroid. All eyes were exophthal­ mic, 24 had soft tissue changes, and 21 demonstrated extraocular muscle in­ volvement. Mild, optically insignificant corneal changes were noted in 13 eyes. By Werner's 1 classification, four eyes had severe ophthalmopathy and the remain­ ing 22 demonstrated mild to moderate ophthalmopathy. All affected eyes had decreased central visual acuities or visual field defects, or both. Central scotomas, inferior altitudinal and arcuate defects, generalized con­ striction, and paracentral scotomas were demonstrated by Goldmann perimetry. Ten eyes had afferent pupillary defects. Abnormal color vision was demonstrated by AOH-R-R pseudoisochromatic plates in nine of 15 tested eyes. Sixteen of 26 eyes had ophthalmoscopically normal optic disks. All patients were treated. Treatment consisted of oral prednisone, orbital irra­ diation, surgical decompression, concur-

© AMERICAN JOURNAL OF OPHTHALMOLOGY 96:190-194, 1983

VOL. 96, NO. 2

DYSTHYROID OPTIC NEUROPATHY

rent corticosteroids and irradiation, or concurrent corticosteroids and orbital de­ compression. Response to therapy was evaluated for each form of treatment as well as for the entire group. We defined a successful response as improvement of two or more lines of visual acuity or a visual acuity of 20/20 with improvement of visual fields to normal within eight weeks of therapy. RESULTS

Corticosteroids—Sixteen eyes (11 pa­ tients) were treated with high doses of oral prednisone (Fig. 1). The patients' ages ranged from 29 to 60 years (mean age, 52 years). Dosage was 80 to 100 mg daily. The patients received a maximum dosage for a mean of 11 days after which the dosage was gradually decreased. Total days of corticosteroid therapy ranged from 14 to 51 days with a mean of 32 days. Thirteen eyes (nine patients) initially improved with treatment (Table 1). Three eyes remained unchanged. There was no instance of deterioration during therapy.

VISION BEFORE TREATMENT

Fig. 1 (Panro and Tomsak). Dysthyroid optic neu­ ropathy response to oral prednisone therapy.

191

Maximum response occurred within 14 to 40 days (mean, 24 days). A lasting remission was achieved in five eyes (three patients) with follow-up peri­ ods of five to 12 months. Clinical relapse occurred in eight eyes (six patients) with­ in four to 72 days (mean, 33 days) of discontinuation of therapy (Table 1). Two relapsing eyes (one patient) responded to four separate courses of corticosteroids (three relapses) before achieving a lasting remission for a follow-up period of three years. All of the remaining eyes that relapsed later underwent surgical decom­ pression. Irradiation—Four eyes (three patients) were treated with orbital irradiation (Fig. 2). Their ages ranged from 45 to 54 years (mean age, 50 years). Treatment consisted of 1,600 to 2,000 rads in eight to ten daily divided doses (200 rads/dose) through lateral ports to the orbital apices. Two eyes (two patients) remained un­ changed. One patient with bilateral dys­ thyroid optic neuropathy responded suc­ cessfully within 27 days of beginning therapy, but both eyes relapsed on the 38th day after the final radiation treat­ ment (Table 1). Orbital decompression—Nine eyes (seven patients) underwent surgical de­ compression transantrally in the manner described by Ogura and Lacente 2 (Fig. 3). Their ages ranged from 35 to 58 years (mean age, 52 years). Two eyes had decompression as the primary treatment. Four had relapsed after responding to corticosteroid therapy. Three had failed to respond to either corticosteroids or irradiation. Eight of the nine eyes im­ proved. There were no relapses during an average follow-up period of 14 months (Table 1). Oral corticosteroids with irradiation— Three eyes (two patients) were treated with concurrent corticosteroids and irra­ diation (Table 2). Their ages were 35 and 55 years. All eyes initially responded, but

192

AMERICAN JOURNAL OF OPHTHALMOLOGY

AUGUST, 1983

TABLE 1 RESPONSE TO SINGLE METHOD OF TREATMENT

Response

Corticosteroids

Treatment Irradiation

Decompression

No. of eyes Improved Unchanged Worsened Relapse after initial response No. responding No. relapsing Time to relapse (days) Mean Range

16 13 3 0

4 2 2 0

9 8 1 0

13 8

2 2

8 0

33 4 to 72

38 38

— —

later relapsed and underwent surgical decompression. Oral corticosteroids with orbital decompression—Four eyes (three pa­ tients) were treated with concurrent cor­ ticosteroids and surgical decompression (Table 2). Their ages ranged from 43 to 69 years (mean age, 57 years). Three orbits were decompressed transantrally, and one orbit was decompressed by a Kronlein procedure. Two of the four eyes improved. Both of these were done by the transantral approach. One eye re­ lapsed. The one eye decompressed by a Kronlein procedure showed no change. Vision deteriorated in one patient who underwent transantral decompression.

20/100 or worse, six had final visual acui­ ties of counting fingers to no light percep­ tion. In our series, four of 26 eyes had final visual acuities of 20/100 or less and none had a final visual acuity worse than 20/400. Twenty of 26 eyes had final visual acuities of 20/40 or better. Trobe, Glaser, and Laflamme 7 found that only two of 29 eyes had final visual

DISCUSSION

The natural course of untreated dysthyroid optic neuropathy has been evalu­ ated in a combined total of 29 affected eyes.3"6 Of the untreated eyes in these studies, 18 had final visual acuities of 20/40 or better but nine had final visual acuities of 20/100 or worse. This suggest­ ed that although spontaneous remission and a favorable outcome are common, nearly one fourth of the described pa­ tients were severely visually impaired. Of the nine patients with visual acuities of

VISION BEFORE TREATMENT

Fig. 2 (Eanzo and Tomsak). Dysthyroid optic neu­ ropathy response to orbital irradiation.

VOL. 96, NO. 2

I

DYSTHYROID OPTIC NEUROPATHY

O 8 O O 8

£

S § | àà

M

a ~ BEFORE TREATMENT VISION

Fig. 3 (Panzo and Tomsak). Dysthyroid optic neu­ ropathy response to surgical orbital decompression.

acuities of 20/100 or worse with therapy. Therefore, therapeutic intervention does appear to exert a beneficial effect by reducing the ultimate severity of visual loss. Oral systemic corticosteroid therapy led to a beneficial response in ten of ten patients studied by Day and Carrol.8 Six of eight patients described by Brown and associates9 and ten of 21 eyes described by Trobe, Glaser, and Laflamme7 also

TABLE 2 RESPONSE TO COMBINED THERAPY

Response No. of eyes Improved Unchanged Worsened Relapsed

Treatment Corticosteroids Corticosteroids and and Irradiation Decompression 3 3 0 0 3

Transantral decompression. t Kronlein procedure.

4 2* lf

1* 1*

193

improved with corticosteroids alone. In our series, 13 of 16 eyes responded favor­ ably to oral prednisone. Although successful response to corti­ costeroid therapy occurred frequently in our patients, eight of the 13 corticosteroid-responsive eyes relapsed. This was a much higher incidence than that reported by Trobe, Glaser, and Laflamme7 (three of ten eyes) and was more consistent with the relapse fre­ quencies (42%9 and 100%10 reported by others treating congestive ophthalmopathy. Two of our patients responded to repeated courses of corticosteroids, and one patient achieved a lasting remission in both eyes only after a fourth separate course of therapy. This suggested that alternative treatments may not be abso­ lutely necessary after corticosteroid re­ lapse. A repeat course of corticosteroids should be considered. Two of four eyes receiving orbital irra­ diation alone responded transiently to therapy. This was consistent with data published by Trobe, Glaser, and Laflamme7 (six of 12 eyes responded) and less favorable than that reported by Ravin, Sisson, and Knapp.11 All three eyes in patients who received concurrent oral corticosteroids and orbit­ al irradiation responded successfully, but all suffered relapses. Although our num­ bers were small, irradiation did not seem to be highly effective or lasting. The response to surgical decompres­ sion in our series was almost uniformly beneficial. Eight of nine eyes responded favorably to transantral decompression and none relapsed. This was somewhat more favorable than results published by Trobe, Glaser, and Laflamme7 (six of nine responded) and was consistent with re­ ports of successful decompression by Gorman and associates12 (17 of 18 eyes responded) and by Linberg and Ander­ son13 (six of seven eyes responded). All but two eyes in the series of Trobe,

194

AMERICAN JOURNAL OF OPHTHALMOLOGY

Glaser, and Laflamme7 were decom­ pressed by Kronlein procedures with or without orbital floor fracture. Gorman and associates12 treated one half of their cases transantrally and the other half transfrontally. Linberg and Anderson13 used transorbital decompression, which combines decompression of the medial wall and floor through a lateral orbital approach. Interestingly, Riley14 reported that only 50% of eyes decompressed with Kronlein procedures for dysthyroid optic neuropathy had a successful response. Decompression by Kronlein methods may be less favorable than transantral, transfrontal, or transorbital decompres­ sion. Of those who responded to therapy in our series, all did so maximally within one month of the onset of treatment. There were no clinical differences in the degree of ophthalmopathy between responders and nonresponders. The mean number of lines of improvement in visual acuity was similar in all treatment groups. A relapse was common after discontin­ uation of therapy in the corticosteroidtreated and irradiation-treated groups within one month of completion of therapy. There was a slight variation in duration of therapy within the corticosteroid-treated group, but no significant dif­ ference existed between eyes with and without relapses.

AUGUST, 1983

REFERENCES 1. Werner, S. C : Classification of eye changes of Graves' disease. Am. J. Ophthalmol. 68:646, 1969. 2. Ogura, J. H., and Lacente, F. E.: Surgical results of orbital decompression for malignant exoph­ thalmos. Laryngoscope 84:637, 1974. 3. Ingersheimer, J. : Visual changes in progressive exophthalmos. Arch. Ophthalmol. 53:94, 1955. 4. Hedges, T. R., and Scheie, H. G.: Visual field defects in exophthalmos associated with thyroid dis­ ease. Arch. Ophthalmol. 54:885, 1955. 5. Henderson, J. W.: Optic neuropathy of exoph­ thalmic goiter (Graves' disease). Arch. Ophthalmol. 59:471, 1958. 6. Day, R. M., and Carrol, F. D.: Optic nerve involvement associated with thyroid dysfunction. Arch. Ophthalmol. 67:289, 1962. 7. Trobe, J. D., Glaser, J. S., and Laflamme, P.: Dysthyroid optic neuropathy. Arch. Ophthalmol. 96:1199, 1978. 8. Day, R. M., and Carrol, F. D.: Corticosteroids in the treatment of optic nerve involvement associat­ ed with thyroid dysfunction. Arch. Ophthalmol. 79:279, 1968. 9. Brown, J., Coburn, J. W., Wigod, R. A., Hiss, J. M., Jr., and Dowling, J. T.: Adrenal steroid thera­ py of severe infiltrative ophthalmopathy of Graves' disease. Am. J. Med. 34:786, 1963. 10. Medical Research Council Panel: Cortisone in exophthalmos. Report on a therapeutic trial of corti­ sone and corticotrophin (ACTH) in exophthalmos and exophthalmic ophthalmoplegia. Lancet 1:6, 1955. 11. Ravin, J. G., Sisson, J. C , and Knapp, W. T.: Orbital radiation for the ocular changes of Graves' disease. Am. J. Ophthalmol. 79:285, 1975. 12. Gorman, C A . , Desanto, L. W., MacCarty, C. S., and Riley, F. C : Optic neuropathy of Graves' disease. Treatment by transantral or transfrontal orbital decompression. N. Engl. J. Med. 290:70, 1974. 13. Linberg, J. V., and Anderson, R. L.: Transor­ bital decompression. Indications and results. Arch. Ophthalmol. 99:113, 1981. 14. Riley, F. C : Surgical management of ophthal­ mopathy in Graves' disease. Mayo Clin. Proc. 47:986, 1972.