Ammonia-based carbon dioxide capture technology: Issues and solutions

Ammonia-based carbon dioxide capture technology: Issues and solutions

 Available online at www.sciencedirect.com       Energy Procedia 4 (2011) 1459–1470      www.e...

321KB Sizes 0 Downloads 71 Views



Available online at www.sciencedirect.com

   

 

Energy Procedia 4 (2011) 1459–1470

   

 www.elsevier.com/locate/procedia    



 !

"  !#  #  $  %& '  (

&  &   )&*'&+, '   +- *' .& /           ,    '0   '0 %  '



' #1   2 '  %%    #   '   ' %   %2   2 '   !#  /3 %&  '     2 '    &' '&#   '  %,&  #  &     '   2   !# /3 %& 2  &  & %      #    '   &    %'    4&  %'   +     & # #  % %    '  #  % & &2&     '  %% #   2 '  '   "    %   ' '  # ' '  2&   2 # %    ' /3  2  / 4&+'  % 4&  5& '  &#   2  &# # +  ' # # & # %     '    & 2   3' +       4&     # #  4&   &  '   # & +      /3    %   ' % &    267  &   ' 28 784& +  /3   % 

2 &#   % ' 2 '   /3 %&  '    '  &  9  %  2 # %     # &  26:/37 ' 6:/375%  /367   ' ;  ' # #  &  ' &  # 

       < 67  %   '  2&    ' %&  /3   -  %&  '   # %    ' ' %&    %2# 2 

#  #/3 %&%2     67 '# #

 c= - " '  ⃝ 2011 Published by Elsevier Ltd.

 (+' &+//>+  +% ! #&  #  $  %&+/3+'  +  & # +   &# # + '  % +   %+# #+  #+ %%+   &## 

 

/ %  &'  (?!@7!A:7!ABB02$(?!@7!AA!A77; !(4<'&C   

doi:10.1016/j.egypro.2011.02.012

1460 

Q. Zhuang et al. / Energy Procedia 4 (2011) 1459–1470 "# $ %&&'(&&)&&&*&&&

    D ' # % &  ' ' %    ' &       1  2   2   '    #   EF D   + $      '    # &   ' ' 24& + 22    ' &' &'    ' 2  2  +     %  EF

  '  +'G      / %'"'#  # &  ' ' % 2 & /3  E7FD 9 '2  2& #&  '  &  2/3   D'%    $  ''#2 &  % ! #& /3 %&2 2   2&%  %E:F D  &  & + /3  %&   %  2     # '   %'  # %  % " /3 %& '     2'%  2 ' % !# '  ' & &  &    '4& %   2# # ' '/3 %  # # 

      & 0       %%   ' ' ' /3!     &  2     '   %&/3"' &''  '  '#& 2&%%   %  %&/3 &  %& 2  + % & 2   %+ '   %& 2  +   & !2   #

 2&  /3 %&+ %%   !  !2      >   '#  '   $%   #  "   #    # >3+ 63$+ % &   $   %%   /3 %& '    !2  #

+>3 63$    '2&&# &   #  %%E;F+ 22 & $%   &H&' +  &##  &%  '' ' D     ' '    2   &## +  !# /3 %& '  '# % %  -#  # ' /3# %  ''#    & '%E@FD %   '  /3# %  '  +  !#  /3  % ' & ' ' '   % &+ >3+ 63$   $  3  + '  &  # & '2 2 '   '   %  "      # '%' "   >% &   &%  !  EB+IF +' 2&%  # '  &  '%2   2'  '  4&   %    '# &' ' '   &  9 ' #1   2' %%    % ''     2 '  &'   #  /6,J'  &     '   '67!3!/3&  & %     ' 2  

#    &          + $ & /3    %  % & 4&  67   + 67  %+ %  # #  '+   & # #  & 2     +      4&  '& 2'%   ' %%       

    

/3 %&# 4& # #2  2 &  & % '# %%  2      K&+  # %    # #     %      #+     %%  %   '% "   /32   '# #2 '#  ' '# %   4&    &    '# #2 ' %D& ' & &2  +/32 '  # #   ' 4& # #+' '#  ' /3 '/3! '# # 4&    ' % 2'  %  "!#

'#   2'  #'&%' /3! '# # '  %  <% 2' %   '# # /3  "&+'% &  /3 2 &% D    ''&% 2  % & /3+ /3 ' 2   4&  # #   #  $ '  #2 ' % &6 +'# #   # 9  ' %  2'# # # #/3D%  2 & '$ '2'2 ' # #   '  ' # #  ' # %   '   # '   %'  %   %  4& +% %  2'    D   '  '2#'   4& %'+% 9   ' & 2 # ''# # ' EAF "4& &    ' #      # # 2  #  !  /3 %&  D '  '  # %  % +   & # #  "./     & #  "/  2   &%  /3 # % "% %  2  '2   !# /3 %&2 %  2& '   !" "% %  #" +2& # '   %&#L/ L/EBF"' % 2 # ''# # '  #'   %    &    %

1461

Q. Zhuang et al. / Energy Procedia 4 (2011) 1459–1470 

"# $ %&&'(&&)&&&*&&&

             

7

      

  +) ,-  

.

*

 #  

+! ! 

! ! ) !

  "

)/ 

  $

( !



)!  &'

#

$

*

% -

!"   # H   2'  !# /3 %&% 

$%   " ' %2   2 '   !#  /3 %& %   &  &   &   (  '  #     &  %&+%&    & %     # '  4&  %',  4&  #   & & H >M 2EF '  '  'H >M #& +' '  %     #   ' '     '      '% & < # (     6 :   /3 74 /3    3  6 : /3 74   6 7   3  6 :



/3    3  /3 7

/3 7 



4



4



3



4



4

4 

/3 7

  3  

3  4 





















7

4 











:













;

4







4

  ' %N%  O && +' '     #'  D2 % %    %& +% &  ''    #  #' 9   2&  "# % !#  2    # # ' ' #%  %EF >     % 2 ' %  ' # %   ' EF  P& #   # 22  ' #$ ' &  22  '   #    &   & "'  %  $%   +'# & &  2' #  &  %   '  #  2 '#  & '  # ' "&# 2 2   &2&' %

(   "# #   Q4& 678 # # 4&   "# #/3'  Q/38 # # 4&   /3   % Q' 22  /3'  # '   /367    # #  4&  Q    0   #   $%   '     + 67/3  , '# #Q'# #2/3# %   -# #Q'# #2   /2&Q2&2/3'## # 2    "/Q  & # +6:/37

1462

Q. Zhuang et al. / Energy Procedia 4 (2011) 1459–1470

:

"# $ %&&'(&&)&&&*&&& 

"./Q  &# # +6:/37

&'      +,,(-.

5& 8   

5& %&   

8   

R' 2&        ' 4& &     & + /3   # # #    '  &  2     & # #    #   '    + $      4& &  &  &  ' $ & &#    ' .  ' %

+    &# #    & #   % %  & 2' & D'/3!67!3+ /3+67 3$  '%' '   &   #'% 2     2'    90""13"  0$"13"  0$13" *0$"13"   0""13" 40""13"   *0$"13" %0$"13"   $0""13" 0""13"   0$"13" 0$"13"   "0""12"" "0""12""  0"" 0" 0%" 04" 0." 0"" (  ) 5& 6 . 7  !"  %'%&&67/3 # # & I7G+E67FQB8

H &' '& 2/3# %  B84& &67 & I7G   %'D' & &2  +'  H  %   '   ' % 2' # #' 2&%'/3  '# # # # 4&    '  '  H  %   '#   2'# #'2&%'/3 ' '2     '# #$ '# #" '67/3  H +'%'/3 67  4&  # & '' &  '/3     !2  2& % # &7 8E7F+ ' '& 67/3  2# &7& ' &   H K    +' 67% & ' '  %  ' 2& & H  !"  &+   # 2  '  '  ' # # '   2 '    %  /3   67

   %  ' &     "./ ' &#   2  &# #  2  K  '    +"./  2 67/3  2# &B; # R'/3 2&'# #    ' # #  4& + "./     &   % %  & 2 ' # #  &  D2 ' # %  %  %&   G' '+' &#   2"./    '   #  % %  67/3  2# &@'  !" $D' 4& ' ' ' "./% %  + '67% &'    &#/ 4&+'  ! 22#"./  2    67% & % 

Q. Zhuang et al. / Energy Procedia 4 (2011) 1459–1470

5&%&   

0*$13" 8   

 0$"13"   0$13"   0""13"   *0$"13"  $0""13"   0$"13"  "0""12""  0"  ) 

"# $ %&&'(&&)&&&*&&& 0*$13"

;

0$"13"

5& 8   



1463

0$13" 0""13" *0$"13" $0""13" 0$"13"

"0""12"" 0 "

0$"

0*"

09"

5& 6 . 7

0" (

!"  $%'%&&67/3 # # & A7G+E67FQB8



5& 8   

5&%&   

8   

'    ' 2 22     % 9     & ' ' ' '   '      D2    % % +  & # '    % 9    ''$ '2 ' % 2  &  3         2      &   67     ' # #  &   &  ' E:F   !" & '  ' & 2    67      D  #  '    67    2:;8+"./ 2 ''67/3  '# # &  '7K  '    +'/3   %  2'# # 

  #%  " % 9 & &  ' % & #&  ''"./% %  & #'  #' !2  # #  4&  #   4& &9"% % 9    #   % /6,J H '# &  #'2# % '   4&    & 67% & ' 2&" +    '%  #/3   % +'67     & & #

   "./  2   &

# '2 +'"./& ' '# #' #%    '    0""13" 40$13"   04"13" $0""13"   0*$13" 0"13"  .0""13" 0$"13"   0$13" %0""13"   "0""12"" "0""12""  0"" 0" 0%" 04" 0." 0"" 0" 0%" ( )  5& 6 . 7  !"  & %'%&&67/3 # # & I7G+E67FQ:;8

1464 @

Q. Zhuang et al. / Energy Procedia 4 (2011) 1459–1470 "# $ %&&'(&&)&&&*&&&

+,(,--$

  

'   !# /3 %&%    & & % "2/3 # #  '# #+ ' /3   # #  4&  2    '    + ' /3      '  ' # #      '# 9 '# # ' '    &  '  '   +7 : '%&/3'  2  %   4&  ,   ' %  ''4&     %   ##



 '#   2' !" (' '  &  ' & #  %& '2'   2'2 &' ' & '      '#   2' + ''# # 4&  ' &%##

 ' # #'   2 # 9 '# # ' ''   '2 & '      ' % 2' + ' '# # 4& '  '/3$ D'  & +G%& 22 2 '#   ' % & D2 +'%&% 2  2'  4& %' '      # 22  ' & '     &   %% $    '      2 ' &     0""    "0." 5&  &  "04"    "0%"   "0"   "0"" "0%" "0%$ "0$" "0$$ "04" "04$ "0*"   65&  . 7  !"  ( # , & # %&+   "./   Q;A8 

D  #  2  !" ( ' ' /3 %&   2  ' #     '  % 2 '    ' 67 % &' ' %%   "  &   '/3& '''% #    ' ' '  4& %'R'/3  2 ' 4& + 67'%'"'  !" ()  '/3' % 2' '67% &  

' '+   ''  2'/3 D'# # 4& '#  +2'  +'/367   +'  ' '# #  D2'# # 2&'   /3+'# # &  '

' '67% & '  2 # 9 ' % 2'# # & 67 %  ' 2& , & %&'#% %      & 67% &%& /3EB+F D  &+ %       && %  &  ' ' %&   ' ' ' ' &'%&  #  < + &   ' ' 22  +  4& % 2

%        " '   !" *) 2       &+' %& #' ' +' 67% &  '/3 # . &' /3 # %   4&  &%   

Q. Zhuang et al. / Energy Procedia 4 (2011) 1459–1470 

"# $ %&&'(&&)&&&*&&&

1465 B

  

+ ' '%& /3 %  " '%

   '' < 2'   #& ' 2 %  & %&     "0"    40" 5&  &  0"   .0"   %0"   "0"  "0%$ "0$$ "04$ "0*$   65&  . 7    !"  * , & +   "./   Q;A8 K # %&+' & 2/3 2 ' '# # '67% &    22%& '  !" +D #'2 ;8/3'%&' & ## &7::G '67    & # %%"' '%&+' &' /3 & # +'67% &    &    4& 9 '&+'  '# #' &  # %  4& &   '1 % # 2 %  '& 2  % &

 '%' ' % &  %  '/3  ' 2&'# # # 9 '# #+

  '  & 5%    & ";8/3+  2'/3 67 '2  2   & #  '# # 4&  ' % &     % %  ' # &';8/3 

2 22   67% &    '/3/ 4&+' &/3# %    #"/ "./ ' 9 # #    &     6:?+/37! /37!% "'  !" ,+ ;8/3 '67    %% $ %%+' '  '2 2' %& # %& '   '  &%

2 ' '%&  # %& 5& ' '%&+' %&

' 2  7:G!7;G

"" ) #:

            

""""  5& 

."

."""

4"

4"""

%"

%"""

"

"""

"

5& 



" ""

"

%"

4"

."

)/ +  7

!"  +"# # # %&+E"./FQ:I8 

1466

Q. Zhuang et al. / Energy Procedia 4 (2011) 1459–1470

I

"# $ %&&'(&&)&&&*&&&





 







 $%

























$%



  !"#





 

 

 









!"  ,"# # +E"./FQ:I8

29        

    

   

)#



'(!(*"&+

            ! " !# $  $ ! " "  ! % &'      (% " !'!      $$ "     $     )    $     *+'   #  !$   ,$  !      $" !- './   #  "

# # !      0   !"  1            2'#3        " "    0! ! 0      " "  !  4                    $         ! 0  %  5!                             1!        

  !   #!           #!#    ! "   $(' (' 0    " !- '   #   #    4       *'  6  #7   ./  8       65  ! #! "      "  # $!  

  4  # " "    0 ! 65     " "   ! "     

    









$%&'(!()#

  96" "    0!    ! 0  % " "  ! 

Q. Zhuang et al. / Energy Procedia 4 (2011) 1459–1470 

      !"

1467 2

$%%/ ")# &, '(!(*-"

 4     $     " "  65    #    " "   !      ! 0       6  

65    #!1   #!# ! 0       $(' ('65 # !  $   " "  !     $- ' +-'  

   3   $ !!#                                     $%)# &,'(!(*-"-.     96# !  $65   $   " "  ! 0!" "     

#$#$%   & '()&        1 #" 0!   !  ,"   #"! !  $ !#!"    ! .:*/# !  $!      #   $ !0 ! "  0 ! !"  0!0 !  !!   0  

4" !  "  # !  $ ! ! " -( #.-/4   0   ! ;    ##    " # - #1  , #"! !!   #     !;  ""  

 

    

  1        

  # !  $        #!  62< # !  $- '     !"    " -( # = #  $     $  # !  $ #6    $     0      4   #       $" "#!   !   #     " -(#       "  0 !      ># !  $ !  #  #3,! ! # $   $ !    0 #  " #  !   # 0$ #  ", !  $          " $  "3    #  4       "    $   $     $  % ! 0 "! .:/ 1         #    !    "  " # 0      # !  !" !   # 4" $ !   #!   #"# 0   .&/

1468

Q. Zhuang et al. / Energy Procedia 4 (2011) 1459–1470

(

      !"





 $%23



 

96" "   $ !  

  

 







 



 



 







04 1!0, 







  

    ?  #"  !

   

$%23



    

       











01!0, 

#$*$+     0 !! $ ! !## $!   $ $$      #!.:/4   #!     0 !  6 !  " 0   "              "   !  $ 65   6  @     " (- ! "0  "! $0 ! " #   !  ,      !  "   !  $   A        ! ! ##     ## !#"  ! 6## !#"  # ;  0 ## 4 !  ,  ! #   !  "   !       #   ! ! ##  "    !   !  " "    !

 #3  !  " "  !  "  !     ! ##   

      !   $   6$  ! 65  "!  !    " "  !   !  "  !       @! ,!$  6  "3 " "   !##   #3,!#!"   !!    "      $##   ##   ! ! ## # " !  "    #!#" "  !       $  #3,!"   !##    0 #  " # 4  #       #      ## ,"   !         ! ! ## !  !  3   " "   !  ! !##  4  0     "" "      !  $ '   ! "!     ! 0      

Q. Zhuang et al. / Energy Procedia 4 (2011) 1459–1470 

      !"

1469 

     !

 



" ##" " "





    0 !! $ ! !##  0!   



#$,$  

  

      $ 65  #    #!#

  $     #  # ! 4       !      !#        $## ,"  ! 

   $$    0

#  "        $ !# !  "  -(B8" !# !  ,$     " "    + B8#  ! 0   +&CD$   4$$ !#!"

 "$    " "  

 !  -2 B8       !#     0  #

  !     $  !#" #

# !    8 #

  "    ##  !   0

 $$    $" !-CD   



           

   



 



  





 % 



   

   

        

 





!    "





! #$

!     

  





! #$



! &'( )





 *+

% %     

%  ,&







! 



!  ,





%  -./0

!

  9  #  "  $ ## ! 

1470 

Q. Zhuang et al. / Energy Procedia 4 (2011) 1459–1470      

                                    

           

                 



      



                              

     

!     "   

 #          

         "   

 $    

  $ 

  

%   &'(       ) &" " 

           



 

                    

           

  

 

  



  $   &'(                "  

 

     

     



                

          

   

$      

   

 

 

    

     $  $       

   &'(     

         

   

 &'(                    

*       

    

              $             !+          

  &'(     $          , $  -  (, $  -   $            $

     $ 

           $     

  

!       

 

                     *                 

          $           

   ./0

            

  

   

  .0



 1  $             23* 



  $                % 4 2      % 5   !    $ 6   

   6            1  

 .0

.0

*4 ,, *4  !   5      $$$

7   !   +              8 (9, *  :, )       ,,/  ;;/

.(0 <  4   =>> >  ? > >/(,

.90 *2! @,,9A B4       

 )  C

.D0



E  E

    !   (F @;/A ::;  :D:

.;0 G  7 5   <4 5   <'  H 4   " #    $  # /;@9DA ,,D 

D((D9;

.F0 <I  J 4   ! % 2 5 5

 K  

     ,,:  9:9;

./0



%E  5

 7E K 

     @,,:A  ,F,(9

.:0



<   2G <  E

 ! L 

 % %$  #% ; @,,(A  ;(

.,0  =>>$$$   >

.0 M   N 4  5

 +        

.0 K   8   <   H  H

 2 ) 

&'()* +   )    / @,,/A  /

.(0

)  7L @2A

B  J 4$  ) C   2   * H  :/

.90  K 

 & K  

 + ,   ,  

 =>>$$$       >>J2>  ? $   >&   ?K  

.D0 "#(         4$    = 2    ! )   7 ,,(

.;0 <   K 2  5 %   <  ! <     -., # /      "  L   

L   )    / @,,/A

.F0

4   24

0% %(% /( @:,(A  ;/

./0 ' % %1% $  )     )    2    6    & $ )  H  

)  !    J   ,,F