Available online at www.sciencedirect.com
ScienceDirect Procedia Engineering 105 (2015) 628 – 637
*" +,- . /( !" ./! 0
+($1 # #$ #% " 2 2$ 3$%& - # 4)565 - 7 8$5 - - 9 9"
!"#$%&
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© 2015 The Authors. Published by Elsevier Ltd. This is an open access article under the CC BY-NC-ND license $ %& ( ) ( " *" +,- . /( !" (http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-nc-nd/4.0/). ./! 0 Peer-review under responsibility of organizing committee of the 6th BSME International Conference on Thermal Engineering (ICTE 2014) ' ()+($A 2$ &A # 2$A 747 A 2 2$A ' /% A / & 8 $
6 / $" !1 B*0C<*C*<0A * )+ ,-+ +
1877-7058 © 2015 The Authors. Published by Elsevier Ltd. This is an open access article under the CC BY-NC-ND license
(http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-nc-nd/4.0/). Peer-review under responsibility of organizing committee of the 6th BSME International Conference on Thermal Engineering (ICTE 2014)
doi:10.1016/j.proeng.2015.05.041
M.A. Hazrat et al. / Procedia Engineering 105 (2015) 628 – 637
629
,$% %($ %$ " $% $ ( ( !"& & ( " % & # 5 %$ = ( " ($ $ %$ %& $ ($ ? %5 %"5 $ ($5 " #$ DE F ( $ &5 #$ $ ? " % ( ( $ $ %$ "( " " DE5 " $%& ( $& " D<*E 2 $ " " $ $ $& " & ( #$ ( &
< " " & $ $ $& " G ($ $& % DE!" 5 "$ ( @ ( " %& ( ( $ " ($ DE
2 3$%& ( #$ 2$ ,$& /" DE
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
%" ( % (? ( $ (5 ) & " %& $ " 747
630
M.A. Hazrat et al. / Procedia Engineering 105 (2015) 628 – 637
DE ! $ % ($ $& ? " ( 747 $5 $% & ( %($ ? !" " ($ " ;$ ( (( & (? " G ( ($ ( & $ $ +($ " % ($ " "" % " $& " %& $ ( ($ $ " ( $ " !" ( %($ % $& " $& (& " %& $ ( ( ($5 747 5 $& 5 $$ 5 $ "? ( ($ $ ( ($ $& $ " %& #$ ? ,$" $ % %( ( " $ "" $ $ " ( ($ ( " # " % D0E5 <5 $ ( $ 5 <-' F ($ $ $ $ 0 = " > %$ <= ( $ $5 "5 " $& @ = ( $ $ DE / $ ($ C= ( ;$ ($ %$ <0= ( & $ D05
$ %& %$ * = % <= ( " & D0E !% ! ($ ( #$ % < ( & /$ L " (& $ K
-'
#$ -'
F -'
! $ -'
! $ -'
! $ $ -'
.
@
.
$
.
$
<
CC
*0
<*<
*
*
*
*
<
C0C0
0<C
<*
<
0C
*<
*0*
**
<*
C*C*
*
**0
<0
<C
0 C
- ( " #$ $ "5 5 && $($ @5 "( " " $ " " " $ D0E # " " / + ( >" #$ $ ( = ( #$ $ $ - ( " %$& @ $ " ? ( @ ( &5 " @& # ? " %& $ ( " "5 ( $ ,$%;$&5 " $&G >" >" & & ( ( ;$ ($ $ ( $!" $ ( $ ( & " % ( #$ $ ($ " " 5 ((5 ( # ( . & = ( " & $ $ "" " ( +$ <= DE!"$ " " ( $ %$ "( ( " ($ $5 " $ % " (& $ # ( ( ($ % ( . " % & "$ " ( $ " " $%& ( ($ $& & " % & %& & #$ -5 ( (& $ %& 5 #$ % ( " & ($ (5 ;$ $ ( & ( 0= #& ($" ( (& & ($" " ( ( $ $ ( !" ( ( ( #$ ( " ;$ ($ 5 ( $ ? ( ( ( (5 ( (& %&$ "" & & ( " " $5 " & ( ( " $ . " &5 " G C" & $ $&5 #$ & ( ( $ ? (5 ;$ ($ ? ( &
631
M.A. Hazrat et al. / Procedia Engineering 105 (2015) 628 – 637
& & %& < "$ " " ( ? % $& " & " % " " ( ( " & ? $%& D5 *5 5 E !"(5 & $ " ( $& ? :$ $ $ ( $%& $ ($ " " & # " ( %5 " & % " " $ ( !" $ % " " " ? ( ($ ( " ( $ #$ " % & ( C & ;$ ($ ( " & ;$ $ $ D"J 3 ( & ( 7 G (& $ $ DE J" " & ( $ $ 5 " " & "$ & $ " ? $$ !" & $%& " $&G $ !" ( " " " $ $ " " & " " ? $ !" $%& ( ( % " #5 ( $ "" & " @ ( $5 (% )5 ( " " $ " $ $ ? " " 5 " 5 7;$5 /;$5 %5 "" && $ ( 45 " #$ 7 "$ ? ( " " ($ $ & ? 5 ( & " $ !% " " $ $ ( ($ ? #$ #$ " ? ( $ $ ( C & " ( $ & ? " " " % ( ( ($ -5 " . & # & . # " : " " & @ " & ;$ %$ <= ( & & %& <5 "5 #$ ;$ ($ $ *< 7' %$ = " " ( < " $ & $ ($ $&D*5 E # ( ;$ &5 C= $ % %& ( ($ = %& " % & " $ & #$ & ? !% H $ ? #$ ( " ( &D*5 E !
/$ (& (? &
#$ 7 &
# 7 &
#$ F &
-&5 0
*
*
<
#5 0
<
<
-"5 0
*
C
2%$&5 0
0
0
M$&5 0
<
C
0
C
<
C
C
C
0
J" " @ " & #$5 $ "
= & # % "& % %
= % ( $ ( ( ($ . ( ) " ( & %" " $ $ ;$& " " $ $ " $& " $%& !"(5 " " " ( $ " & #5 " & " ( . # % %( ( #$ " & $& $ ( $ ( ($ DCE # $5 $ @ $) ( ( ($ ( & $& "$ ( $ 5 " & % 747 $ % " %& !"(5 " $ ( . # % (( " ;$ " $ % /H
632
M.A. Hazrat et al. / Procedia Engineering 105 (2015) 628 – 637
( $ = %& ( " $ DE !"$ " $ % ( % $ 747 DE #$ $ 747 %& * = %& 9& DCE -5 % & 5 $ * = ( & @ ( #$ D*E # " ( " & $ #$ $ %$ ! ( $ $ & $ (( " @ % $ -5 $ ( " $ ( & $ " ? " C=
C ( $ & $ " ( ($$ D*E !" & % & $ 5 5 $ 5 "&5 "5 " 5 % &5 "" % " $& & $ $ # ($ ? %($ % %$& $ " $& ( $ !" $ " /H $ %& " ( ($ $ D E !" ( $ (( " " %& ( $ $& ) %($ $G # " ? %" % $& " & & $ ($ % $ & ($$ $% DE #$ 7 " ? ( " $ ( %($ 2 5 $ + = % % " = " % " " % ( $ " #$ ($ D5 E 2$" " (( $& " & " %($ $ !" #$ %($ ? $& " " " ( " " & " $& D
$ ( %($ %" % #$ $ % $ ( $ " & $ ;$ ( ( 5 ( &5 " ;$& ( " & +($ $ #$ " %
< 0 " ( $ & %$ " ( G ($ $ ($$ "+3+7 . #$5 5 = " % " $ $ $ % & % $ (& !"(5 " & ( " $ %& <= %$ @ (& ( 0 D0E # % " $ " ( ($ ( $ ( " " $ ( $ " "& $% % " 747 (($ $ # " ( +($ # ( #$ DE5 $ & ( " %$ 00 -' 00 7' $ -&5 " 8 , "$ -'5 J ," <
-' - ( $ %&$ * -' " (? %$ " " $ . " % " " ( & % 7' C 7' < D*E 45 " ;$ ( " $ ( " %& ( " $ ( $ ( ($ % " $ ? #& " $ ( (? % ($ " " " ;$& ( (? " ;$& ( " " $ " % ;$& F$ %$ ( $ %&5 #$ " $ ;$ % " " $ % (? (( " ( $$ !" $ ( " " " ( " $ $%& ($ @ $& ,$" (& "$ % " $& # $ ( %($ $ ( " #$ " % $ $ D & #$ & " " $ ($$5 " & " $ "" " & ($ $ ( " " " ( ($ 5
633
M.A. Hazrat et al. / Procedia Engineering 105 (2015) 628 – 637
$& $%& $%& +" I,# +) % " ( $ %" ( 5 $ $ 5 "$ ? (($ !% < DE " $ ( " I,# " % $% "
< DE !" $ " @ " *= ( " $ !"& " " " " ( " $ " " $ ( " $ ( " DCE !% < " $ 3$ /$ DE J 2$ " $ %& /$& 8 (
<- 7 /$&
C
<
I,#
*
C< C
C<
<C
<<
<<
+)
C
*0
*
*C0
<0
**
$
<
<<*
0
**0
C
<
*C*
/"
0*
C
0
0
0*
/
<
<
C
<**<
0*<
00C
<
# !$
# !$
%# &$
## $!
&' $
' $$
#
8 ( J
C
<*<
C
* C
*
J
<<
*0<
<
<< C
0 0 C
<0<
! $" ? %&5 " $% $ ( 7 ( CC
* NC % ? " " " $ @$ +& " " %" %" ? ($ $ " & ( @$ ( " $ ? " & " 7G ( "" $ N % < F " $ % % ( " 0 " $& $? D< E ,
5 I,# " % $ " = ( ( ( ($ " $ ( %($ " ( & ;$ 2 !" (( ( $ ( & " " " :% ( 5 %$ " 7F " "$" H " " "5 #$5 ( % ( " & $ $5 " ($$ %" ($(( %($ ? !" " " % " ( "$ " " " " " ($((& /" " & ;$ $ ( ($((& ( %" ( ($ $ . ( %" $ #$ % ;$ %$ C7' ( %" $ ,5 " %$ & ? %& I,# & $ $ ( #$ % ($ ? %& < ( & (( ($$ % &
2 2$ $& " ( I,# DE
634
M.A. Hazrat et al. / Procedia Engineering 105 (2015) 628 – 637
"+%+7 + & @$ ( "& "& ( (& "" % "$ " " ( ( % ( % & ( " D< <E !" ? % ($ " % $ & " !" ($ ( % " ($ ( " #,!- F* C % % " & D
= % $( $ $ " ( % ($ " ($ D0E +$ $ % % % $ "" " ( ( " ($ #$ & ;$ ($ $ . #$5 = % ( % " ($ + " % % $ "$ & & % D0<5 00E J" " 5 = ( ($ $ $ % %& C 7' ( % < !" ;$ " " ( $ +$ " $ $ & :$ $(( $& " $ ( % " ? D5 *5 0E -5 " ( 8 9 /,.8H " " " +* ( " $ ;$& D0
( % % ( $ % (? " ($ ( (? " " $ ( 4 " " (? ? 1
9:5 %$& ( 5 $5 / P$ 5 & $ : : % & #$ & " " $ ( ( % $ !" ;$ ( $ & ( $ " ( " (? % $ ( % $ F$ @ ( ($ ? ( & $&5 %" 7 ( & % ($ ? % -5 ( % (& " % "$ $ $ ( ($ ? !" (? ;$& $ ( !"(5 ( (? ? " %$ (% %& $& ($ " ($ $& &
M.A. Hazrat et al. / Procedia Engineering 105 (2015) 628 – 637
635
% ( # F% ;$ ( < D0E5 % ( " 9 * ! H /F $5 #$ 7 ( ( $ ($ ($ & " $ !" %$ = ( " ($ " " @ $ $5 ( 5 " ( ( " " % ( " $G . " 5 -@ I,# 7 <* & #$ $& !" ($ & $" " @ !"$ " " $ ( " $& & " ;$5 %$ " ($ & " " %" " & $5 ( %$ ($$ ( & DG & & % @ ( ? % :% !" " $ $% $ " & ( $ !" :$ " " $ $ ($" !" " ( @ ($ & #$ 45 :$ "$ " & ( " $& $ " @ ($(( ($ ? # $& "$ ($ $& " & & ( ? " $ ( $ (( " " ( $ 2 5 " %($ & I,# % ( " $ " $ ? $ " $& " " " ($ !" " " I,# ( " $% ( ( ($ & ( @ ( < " $ % % ( $ $%& ( $ .( #$ 7 %($ ++ %& % %& " %" $ $& ?5 " % ( $ %$ 07' % C7' %" $ " ( ($ %& < = %& < # 5 & 7' $ ( <* 7' % $ & % ( $ ( ( (? H " " % %$ (& " , ( % %($ (?5 ( %$ & 5 $ % $ " " :$ 5 $ ( @" 5 ? ( ($$5 ( ( " % %($ #$ ($ @ D5 E /$ @ $& % $ < M$5 & & %$ " " ( 747 #IF % " "
636
M.A. Hazrat et al. / Procedia Engineering 105 (2015) 628 – 637
-5 " % $) & ? $5 $ ($ %$ % & $$ $& " & ( " $ > % %($ (? $ " $$ % ( , " ( ($ " % 5 " ( " & % %($ & " ( $ %& < " " DE .( " " $ " % ? % ($ ;$& " $ %& " + " $ %" ( %($ % & $ #$5 " % "&% % " & 3$ ($ ? 7!' 7';$5 /!' /';$5 ' 7 ;$( $ 75 '>7 ;$( >$ 75 ($5 " & " ( ($ " " ? % " %& < !"(5 ( ($ & " ( " $ " $%& ( ( ($ #$ -5 ( & $ ( ? ? " $ ($ @ " & % %$ " $& . ( " (& %& $ & ;$ " " $ ( " $ $ % # ) !" ( ( ($ " (& %& $ % " " ( $ ;$ $ !"(5 7 $ ? " " " " ( ,($((& " " $ ? " % $ ( $ " $%& $ & ($ " $ ( % @ "$ ( - $ ( ( ($ % % ( " 747 !"(5 " %" % & %$ %$ = " = & ( " ;$ ($ " & +" " $) " % % % ($ ( $ 747 " $%& !" ($ $& " & "$ ( " % #$ $ ( ( ($ " $ %& $ " " ( " ($((& %($ $ $) ( " ($ $& ($$ ( I,# +) . " % " " % (? % $$ ( " & ( $ ) ($ $ ( " $& # " ;$ ( " & ) " ( & ( $ "$ " ($ & " :$ ( $ " %" ( (( ( " $& !" (( " ? " % $ ( 5 5 & % $% !"$5 & ( %($ $& & & % " ( ($ $%& " $& * + !" $" $ ? ? " " $ ( ," ( L !" & ( / P$ I& DE F8 ! , 2? ( # ! 2$ /%1 F ( 8$5 & !$ F8 !A DE ,& # #$ & : 0C /%1 +$$ ( 8$ & +8
A D
D0E +8
#$ $ , /%1 /" ( #$A 0 < DE +?%$ M #$S ';$ 2$ ,$& # ( >8-# - L , 0 D*E +?%$ M #$G ';$ 2$ ,$& # 8 ( >8-# - , < DE +8
#$ $ , -& 0 /%5 #/!1 #$ 7A 0
M.A. Hazrat et al. / Procedia Engineering 105 (2015) 628 – 637
637
DE F8 ! & J" #$G & ( /% #/!1 F ( 8$5 & !$ F8 !A DCE F8
> & ,$& # /%5 #/!1 /" ( #$A D E 2 + ' % ( #$ - A<1 DE #"" > $ + ( #$ > >$ , 8$ .$ 8" F /A < DE #. - $& $& %& ( ;$ ($ #$ /%1 #$ .$ ( $A < 0 D
#$ & 8$ # /%5 #/!1 7 #$A < DE & 9 #$ /$& 8 .1 9$ ,5 #& & , # 8 M?1 8.#A C DE . # !" & 81 +($ ( ! 21 !" . & # & . #A DCE 4$ !5 M5 J" # #$ +($ 2? 8 31 /,.8HA
D E /%$ #$S 7"$ 7 /% >$A DE /@ +($ /@ #$A 0 DE HG/ /5 +?& F5 9& M5 7 - +($ !?( " - +5 #/!
D
< 8% 2$ # 82#A 0 DE 82# " .$& H$? 8% 2$ # 82#A < < DCE 82# ? 7$ " 0 D< E 82# " .$& H$? 8% 2$ # 82#A 0 0 D<E #%%)" #5 7"% +5 H?"" -85 >:( 7 /$ % $ " 1 # & / - A*<1<0 D<E #%$? #,5 M" #5 H $ MH5 F5 #(% #, $ /") ( +($ ( > % H1 # # & ,$ F D<? ,> H) ( ?&) ( ( ( $ ( % +$ !" &
*AC1? ,> !( ( ?: %& % & $ M$ ( ' , !" &
*A 1<CC D<E -" '/5 3& , F5 >? ,> !" ( % $ %& (U 8% ,$%
& 8
*A 10* D
A<<1<< D0 E -(:$ -5 -:$? 445 9 -#5 #% # 5 ,""%$ -5 " ,-5 (( ( % ( $ (? %$ "5 $%& %&1 # 8% ,$% & 8 $ + ( #$ > >$ , /PI& #$A D0E - 25 4 -# + $1 +$ !" & CCCA 1 D0
D00E !?( + 8 ( " +($ !?( " - #$ 7A
D0E +## + $ +($ # ( #$A < D0*E .# 4 $" % @ $ %& %$ ($V 1 I, & .( #A < D0E J #/5 4 3, 2$$ +($ ( #$.$ $ ( ( $ +5 #/!1 8$ .$ 8" F / 8.8F/A
D0E + F5 HS/ F +($ #$ , & 8$ .$ F / 88F/A