- Email: [email protected]
CNGS neutrino beam systematics for θ13
Nuclear Physics B (Proc. Suppl.) 145 (2005) 93–97 www.elsevierphysics.com
%
'
*
,
-
/
9
0
L
2
M
3
3
G
5
3
P
8
9
:
-
/
Q
;
;
<
2
U
=
2
?
V
8
2
?
]
_
8 Z
Z
<
Z
b
5
[
8
b
U
5
?
2
C
Q
S
P
8
2
S
C
A
\
E
H
W
/
8
Z
G
[
/
2
3
H
?
5
5
?
U
5
J
\
/
,
8
0
8
_
8
f
5
P
<
f
?
2
5
3
2
5
U
\
j
2
l
Z
/
b
m
E
n
o
_
8
f
_
Q
V
8
5
p
5
3
[
b
?
b
r
Q
E
,
J
]
_
Z
8
Z
<
Z
b
P
5
[
8
b
U
5
?
2
\
8
0
8
8 _
f
5
P
<
f
?
2
5
3
2
Q
V
8
5
L
2
?
b
3
8
5
Q
p
w
y
{
}
~
}
}
¡
¡
~
}
~
{
{
}
{
}
}
~
{
}
{
ª
~
}
~
~
}
}
}
{
}
{
¤
{
}
¥
~
}
}
y
}
S
x
,
}
³
´
µ
¶
·
¸
¹
º
»
¶
¼
¸
5
{
5
l
²
~
}
?
U
b
Q
]
Z
5
?
o
5
\
b
V
5
Q
]
Z
5
?
o
/
,
/
,
8
s
}
f
~
b
Z
}
_
8
ª
U
}
U
{
§
y
Ü
~
¯
2
U
_
S µ
}
}
_
8
Z
{
8
V
°
8
Z
}
}
~
}
o
8
¨
_
2
}
¾
~
~
l
2
~
f
{
Z
~
{
}
\
}
±
2
}
m
3
{
b
{
~
¤
A
Z
n
2
î Ý
Þ
_
V ½
2
3
Z
n
2
U
2
¾
Z
¿
V
2
o
2
5
3
_
Z
n
2
l
3
2
_
2
U
Z
=
2
U
2
3
5
Z
8
b
o
m
b
_
f
8
?
?
5
Z
8
b
U
2
¾
l
2
3
8
A
2
U
Z
_
5
Z
5
f
f
2
?
2
3
5
Z
b
3
_
W
Z
2
8
Z
3
b
U
=
Ä
Å
5
_
2
?
8
U
2
Æ
Ç
Å
2
5
A
_
Q
É
É
5
Z
É
M
É
Ì
Q
S
H ½
5
Z
P
Ð
p
]
Å
2
5
A
b
m
0
Z
8
f
_
b
m
Z
n
2
í Æ
#
Ç Æ
3
5
Z
8
b
Q
5
U
\
8
U
l
5
3
Z
8
f
<
?
5
8
Z
_
U
b
3
A
5
?
8
[
5
Z
8
b
U
2
3
3
b
3
3
/
n
p
]
n
2
L
P
;
H
Å
2
5
A
Ä
?
8
U
2
\
2
_
8
=
U
W
5
_
5
f
f
b
A
l
?
8
_
n
2
\
Ä
Í
b
P
5
A
÷
b ?
A
U
m
b
_
P
-
Ñ
Ì
5
S
U
\
]
L
-
G
Ð
U
Z
n
2
Å
5
_
8
_
b
m
Z
n
2
l
2 3
V
8
b
<
_
%
-
P
0
Æ
Ç
Å
2
5
A
2
¾
Ä
H
Í
l
2
3
8
2
U
f
2
5
Z
L
M
G
P
H
E
H
Ì
'
m
b
3
L
ï
G ½
Ð
H
5
U
\
P
Ä ½
Í
5
U
\
E ½
M
G
-
Ì
5
,
Z
L
P
;
H
L
M
G
P
Z
b
;
3
5
U
H
5
_
_
b
Í
p
-
j
2
¾
l
2
3
8
A
2
U
Z
_
Ì
r
W
n
8
f
n
5
?
?
b
W
2
\
m
b
3
5
l
b
W
2
3
Ä
Í
U
2
Z <
3
8
U
b
Å
2
5
A
_
Ì
Õ
8
_
2
¾
l
2
f
Z
2
\
Z
b
f
b
U
¿
3
A
Z
n
2
Í
m
Ç Æ
Ù Æ
Ú
Z
3
5
U
_
8
Z
8
b
U
_
b
Å
_
2
3
V
2
\
8
U
Z
n
2
5
Z
A
b
_
l
n
2
3
8
<
?
5
U
\
A
2
5
_
<
3
2
_
8
U
5 Ü
S
U
\
ß
à
ß á
W
8
Z
n
8
Ü
Ü
5
f
f
<
3
5
f
o
8
m
ß
à
ß á
ã
2
U
Ü
P
H ½
5
3
2
?
b
b
ç
8
U
o
A
2
5
_
<
3
8
U
=
Z
n
ä
å
/
Þ
É
<
U
f
Z
E ½
8
M
b
U
G
b
-
m
U
W
8
?
2
?
<
_
Z
2
m
b
3
U
Ç Æ
3
5
8
3
U
f
_
b
2
n
É
5
U
U
f
b
U
M
V
V
2
2
U
Z
U
8
U
b
U
b
5
Z
?
2
Æ
m
¾
Ç
l
b
Å
?
8
2
<
U
<
3
2
3
2
f
8
2
U
2
<
Z
3
8
U
b
Å
2
5
A
l
3
A
5
P
5
3
;
Z
3
8
U
b
\
8
_
5
l
l
2
5
3
5
U
f
2
Z
3
8
ç
f
m
<
?
b
5
3
f
3
m
b
b
U
V
3
2
Z
U
n
Z
8
2
b
U
L
5
P
?
U
;
2
H
<
/
Z
]
5
3
f
n
2
_
Z
n
2
_
2
2
¾
l
V
3
2
5
Z
2
8
3
8
\
8
U
U
H
Å
2
5
A
_
o
_
Z
2
A
5
Z
8
f
_
b
U
U
=
b
Z
í Æ
#
8
V
5
?
l
3
b
Å
5
Å
8
?
8
Z
o
5
_
2
3
=
V
o
8
W
\
2
n
U
f
8
2
?
2
b
]
m
L
Æ
-
Ú
8
G
U
Ð
Z
2
H
3
5
_
Z
3
b
U
=
Å
n
2
_ 8
5
_
A
2
_
U
_
5
U
2
\
Z
n
Ç Æ
3
5
Z
8
b
f
5
U
2
Å
f
Z
U
8
?
A
_
o
V
2
\
5
U
\
l
3
2
\
8
f
Z
2
\
m
3
b
A
Z
n
2
l
3
3
8
l
2
V
8
b
<
_
A
2
5
_
<
2
3
2
2
U
Z
_
5
U
\
_
Z
<
\
8
_ 2
l
2
3
m
b
3
A
2
\
W
8
Z
n
Z
n
2
%
-
P
0
Ä
/
\
b
_ U
³
,
.
0
2
4
6
7
8
:
»
:
=
0
¸
?
=
¶
º
¹
A
/
b
A
2
5
5
5
8
Z
8
A
8
[
2
\
m
b
3
Æ
Ù Ç
Æ
í
U
Z
n
2
%
-
P
0
Ç Æ
m
5
f
8
?
8
Z
o
Õ
;
s
2
V
Q
]
_
b
\
*
8
n
S Ü
A
m
Z
Þ
=
2
n
l
\
Å
f
U
L
]
m
Þ
2
x Ü
p
b o
Þ
Ü
m
\
â
8
b
<
U
x
Ý
Z
f
Å
Æ
_
U
Z
_
f
5
U
2
¾
l
?
b
3
2
_
8
U
2
å
C
f
l
3
b
Z
b
U
_
x
Ü
S
Ý
î
W
2
3
2
2
¾
Z
3
5
f
Z
2
\
Å
o
Z
n
2
H
E
H
5
\ U
_
2
U
Z
8
U
Z
b
5
_
2
=
Ä
Þ
b
f _
8
?
?
5
Z
8
b
U
l
5
3
5
A
2
Z
2
3
Å
2
o
b
U
\
Z
n
2
L
ï ½
½
? ð
8
A
8
Z
A
2
U
Z
2
\
Z
5
3
=
2
Z
f
b
A
l
b
_
2
\
Å
o
2
3
b
\
_
Q
f
E
Ì
/
s
]
U
l
5
3
Z
8
f
<
?
5
3
]
L
-
G
Ð
H
5
U
\
E ½
M
G
-
Ì
f
Í
,
5
A
b
m
x
U
Í
?
2
U
=
Z
n
5
U
\
A
A
\
8
5
A
2
Z
2
3
2
5
f
n
/
÷
n
2
l
3
b
\
<
f
2
\
,
3
2
5
f
n
5
f
b
A
Å
8
U
2
\
_
2
U
_
8
Z
8
V
8
Z
o
b
U
8 _
U
L Ü
S
Ý
E
V
8
Ä
î
l
Þ
b
_
8
Z
8
V
2
U
2
=
5
8 Z
V
2
ó
A
2
_
b
U
_
Q
2
_
_
2
U
Z
8
5
?
?
o
F
5
U
\
H
Q
ñ
ñ
b
?
5
Z
8
b
U
5
U
\
A
5
Z
Z
2
3
2
ò
2
f
Z
_
U
b
Z
5
f
f
b
<
U
Z
2
\
m
b
3
ó
5
W
2
3
2
m
b
f
<
_
2
\
\
2
m
b
f
<
_
2
\
ó
Å
o
Z
W
b
l
<
?
_
2
\
A
5
=
U
2
Z
8
f
ñ
m
5
f
Z
b
3
õ
Å
2
Z
Z
2
3
Z
n
5
U
L
ï ½
½
8 ð
U
Z
n
2
5
?
?
b
W
2
\
s
?
2
U
_
2
_
n
b
3
U
5
U
\
3
2
J
2
f
Z
b
3
ó
8
U
Z
b
5
V A
S
L
5
f
<
<
A
x
ñ
l
5
3
5
A
2
Z
2
3
3
2
=
8
U b
b
m
5
Z
A
b
_
l
n
2
3
8
f
U
2
<
Z
3
8
U
b
b
_
f
8
?
?
5
Ä
\
Z
8
b
U
_
m
b
3
¿
V
2
o
2
5
3
_
2
¾
l
b
_
<
3
2
Z
b
Z
n
2
L
P
;
H
Å
2
5
2
f
5
o
Z
<
U
U
2
?
W
2
3
2
U
2
<
Z
3
8
U
b
_
W
2
3
2
l
3
b
\
<
f
2
\
/
÷
n
2
A
3
2
_
<
?
Z
8
U
=
Ç Æ
Å
2
5
A
8
U
P
p ½
-
j
5
Z
r
Õ
A
m
3
b
A
Z
n
2
x
5
Z
U
b
A
8
U
5
?
8
U
Z
2
U
_
8
Z
o
Ì
/
w
÷
n
2
Ç Æ
Ù
í Æ
b
_
f
? 8
?
5
Z
8
b
U
_
Í
2
Z
5
3
=
2
Z
Q
W
5
_
f
n
5
3
5
f
Z
3 2
8
[
2
\
Å
o
5
U
2
U
2
3
=
o
õ
Õ
8
?
?
Å
2
_
2
5
3
f
n
2
\
m
b
3
5
_
í Æ
f
n
5
3
=
2
f
<
3
3
2
U
Z
2
V
2
U
Z
_
2
¾
2
å
5
U
\
5
f
b
U
Z
5
A
8
U
5
Z
8
b
U
b
m
õ
M
r
Q
w
f
2
_
_
b
V
2
3
Z
n
2
í Æ
f
b
U
Z
5
A
8
U
5
Z
8
b
U
b
m
Z
n
2
Å
2
5
A
ø
Z
n
M
o
8
_
_
<
2
W
8
? ?
Å
2
Z
n
2
ç
U
b
W
?
2
\
=
2
b
m
Z
n
2
U
2
<
Z
3
8
U
2
5
A
f
b
A
l
b
_
8
Z
8
b
U
5
U
\
_
l
2
f
Z
3
<
A
/
-
_
Z
3
b
U
=
8
A
5
U
\
â
b
,
Ç Æ
m
Q
í Æ
5
U
\
í Æ
3
2
_
l
2
f
Z
8
V
2
?
o
/
0
b
<
3
A
5
8
U
â
b
l
Å
õ
â
2
x
2
,
Ä
;
ç
M
S E
W
3
b
f
2
_
_
2
_
5
_
_
b
<
3
f
2
_
b
m
U
2
<
Z
3
8
U
b
_
W
2
3
2
3
2
f
b
=
U
8
[
2
\
ø
Ä
Õ
;
s
2
å
C
f
l
3
b
Z
b
U
8
U
Z
2
3
5
f
Z
8
b
U
_
8
U
Z
n
2
2
x
E
N
Z
ú
û
ü
ý
þ
ÿ
þ
ÿ
þ
ü
þ
þ
ý
ÿ
ü
0920-5632/$ – see front matter © 2005 Elsevier B.V. All rights reserved. doi:10.1016/j.nuclphysbps.2005.03.042
5
3
=
2
Z
W
n
8
f
n
l
3
b
\
<
f
2
F
Q
Q
H
Q
Q
H
S
Q
/
/
/
b
3
8
=
8
Ä
94
A. Ferrari et al. / Nuclear Physics B (Proc. Suppl.) 145 (2005) 93–97
$
%
&
%
!
#
)
$
%
+
%
2
%
&
+
+
%
%
2
x 10 2
9
%
9
A
A
2
+
$
B
9
%
<
<
2
9
+
<
F
%
&
H
<
<
&
$
νµCC
1500 1000
F
+
+
&
H
$
A
)
2
9
+
P
A
)
W
%
X
Z
2
[
+
\
<
F
)
0.9
$
%
&
2
$
<
%
<
&
<
&
$
%
$
)
%
A
+
<
2
100
150
0.8
200
0
50
A
+
%
<
P
W
<
+
[
<
2
%
)
−
νµCC
4000
%
2
A
+
%
%
200
2000
−
νµCC
1.4 1.2 1 0.8 0.6
0
50
100
150
0
200
50
2
+
A
F
&
H
A
100
150
200
Visible energy (GeV)
Visible energy (GeV)
150
0
$
100
Visible energy (GeV)
50
Visible energy (GeV)
0
V
1
500
Events / 8 GeV
νµCC
1.1
B
0 &
1.2
Data / MC
Data / MC
Events / 8 GeV
2
W
X
<
2
+
<
2
b
<
[
F
W
e
b
&
$
1.5
1.5
1
1
[
−
f
νeCC
400
2
Data / MC
a
Events / 16 GeV
200
−
νeCC
1.5 1 0.5
0
0
50
100
0
150
0
50
0.5
0.5
100
150
Visible energy (GeV)
Visible energy (GeV) g
%
f
%
%
)
+
$
2
%
A
\
%
V
<
0
0
100
200
0
300 p (GeV/c)
0
100
200
300 p (GeV/c)
$
+
9
+
+
2
A
%
%
%
F
%
+
\
<
V
%
A
+
%
&
\
%
B
<
V
1.5
1.5
1
1
0.5
0.5
[
%
\
%
2
+
!
#
<
u
%
2
%
%
+
$
<
%
+
f
X
v
w
V
0
0
100
200
0
300 p (GeV/c)
1.5
0
100
200
300 p (GeV/c)
1.5 %
1
1
0.5
0.5
A
%
q
A
2
2
&
+
%
&
+
+
+
F
+
&
A
2
A
2
A
[
f
<
$
%
<
2
#
)
e
!
2
$
%
+
9
%
$
%
%
&
<
F
)
!
F b
0
0
100
200
0
300 p (GeV/c)
A
A
b b
F
%
u
<
F
)
n
o
A
A
F
%
w
0
100
200
300 p (GeV/c)
Events / 8 GeV
1.4 1.2 1 0.8 0.6
800
νeCC
700 600
0.4
500 0.2 0
g
0
50
%
f
100
g
i
k
l
150
!
n
o
200
B
!
&
X
p
2
2
+
400
300 350 p (GeV/c)
$
%
<
2
300 H
b
%
%
250
%
q
2
+
%
+
+
%
+
2
A
+
r
&
&
9
&
+
200 f
100 r
<
+
9
<
9
%
2
%
)
F
%
+
\
9
0 V
2
&
F
$
A
)
&
A
2
+
u
0
f
X
v
20
40
60
80
100
120
140
160
180
200
w
Visible energy (GeV) g
%
f
%
)
+
$
2
%
&
%
&
+
%
<
v
x
%
<
%
$
%
<
2
%
)
+
$
2
%
B
+
)
<
2
&
$
+
F
&
+
<
P
9
A
<
[
%
2
+
$
+
9
+
+
2
A
%
%
%
V
F
&
+
$
%
<
2
%
+
%
%
<
f
x
%
+
\
<
%
A
H
V
!
#
u
<
X
f
<
2
2
%
<
+
2
%
$
<
v
w
+
%
&
\
H
95
A. Ferrari et al. / Nuclear Physics B (Proc. Suppl.) 145 (2005) 93–97
6
7
8
#
-
;
9
<
>
!
#
#
%
!
#
%
%
B
#
0
*
*
,
-
#
0
0
0
#
4
# F
0
n
*
*
0
O
#
G
G
0
!
J
0
J
4
!
F
8
# G
%
J
#
0
0
#
0
G
%
#
G
#
0
O
#
F
!
#
0
0
J
O
#
J
#
0
0
J
#
0
#
J
G
0
G
R
!
#
0
0
#
#
G
F
u
0
J
#
0
O
#
#
0
4
G
O
#
O
#
G
F
j
t
#
0
G
G
X
4
G
0
4
]
0
#
0
#
0
X
#
G
O
#
0
J
0
0
!
O
J
#
0
G
0
J
J
]
G
%
#
0
J
]
c
d
e
> J
O
0
J
0
#
0
J
4
]
0
0
J
i
G
0
J
#
0
#
J
6
]
7
G
J
0
J
!
7
O
#
J
G
J
G
#
0
#
R
0
#
-
8
m
O
J
#
#
0
%
h
#
0
4
F
7
#
G
8
<
J
G
O
8
]
0
-
#
0
7
G
8
4
<
0
0
#
0
#
#
0
4
G
G
O
#
0
G
q
%
#
G
J
0
#
0
n
G
]
m
6
#
0
#
%
i
#
J
O
J
!
#
G
4
0
!
z
0
j
#
#
0
G
#
G
#
%
n
0
J
F
n
G
F
m
G
q
#
]
0
G
G
#
#
0
0
0
O
G
]
0
0
%
0
0
G
#
G
0
#
n
0
n
0
F
9
! J
R
J
n
#
G
#
%
%
G
O
#
#
0
J
0
0
J
0
#
0
O
#
n
#
m
G
6
!
F
J
O
0
J
0
j
7
0
X
#
F
9
0
!
0
J
j
i
O
;
8
8
7
i
i
9
j
F
t
G
G
G
u
G
G
#
0
J
#
!
G
O
!
%
#
0
F
#
0
#
4
>
#
O
0
#
0
#
!
O
G
#
G
0
#
0
%
G
$
&
(
)
+
-
/
(
2
(
5
7
G
n
4
]
G
O
F
0
*
,
-
0
0
#
4
%
!
u
t
%
#
J
4
!
4
0
G
#
0
%
#
O
!
O
#
#
0
G
-
8
O
#
,
B y
>
z
J
#
0
J
0
<
#
%
#
0
8
]
0
#
0
0
0
G
!
#
%
<
O
;
:
7
#
!
O
#
F
8
t
c
d
e
>
0
#
]
%
#
#
0
G
#
G
#
0
O
#
J
#
0
4
G
J
#
0
G
J
J
#
0
G
4
]
0
O
J
J
0
J
G
J
G
4
G
J
#
O
#
#
J
0
X
G
]
0
%
0
#
0
G
]
#
0
G
u
q
]
4
m
J
*
,
¡
0
J
G
0
#
4
#
0
q
0
O
#
J
G
#
%
7
!
F
%
0
7
0
q
8
0
J
#
%
;
J
q
G
G
O
J
4
!
F
>
J
G
%
0
#
0
#
%
G
#
0
#
0
F
4
!
0
0
O
O
#
J
#
0
#
R
J
#
%
0
O
0
0
J
0
J
0
!
#
O
R
#
G
?
>
,
0
0
#
4
F
0
7
G
#
0
0
J
#
]
#
]
%
#
G
0
#
8
J
%
#
G
0
u
#
%
O
#
G
R
0
0
G
O
#
0
!
G
%
0
#
0
#
%
O
#
J
R
u
J
G
#
0
F
t t
F
J
G
0
#
h
#
0
J
!
0
0
]
0
7
#
0
0
#
0
4
F
0
X
]
F
0
]
G
#
4
0
J
%
#
#
G
O
#
0
J
0
%
#
0
G
0
F
#
0
0
#
J
]
#
7
;
%
0
0
!
6
0
,
B y
n
0
0
J
#
0
#
0
4
J
O
]
G
O
J #
4
G
#
4
J
>
G
J
F
J
#
0
G
0
J
#
0
4
F
0
>
O
F
9
0
]
G
J
n
0
#
0
>
z
]
G
%
]
O
0
R
0
#
0
]
G
J
R
#
J
#
R
%
#
0
F
G
j
G
O
7
X
0
0
0
#
%
O
#
#
0
4
G
O
#
0
u
i
0
J
#
J
G
]
G
O
#
G
G
4
0
!
#
%
t
]
G
!
G
0
#
#
0
#
#
%
h
j
0
4
0
0
#
J
#
m
96
7
7
νe / 5 GeV / 10 p.o.t.
νµ / 2 GeV / 10 p.o.t.
A. Ferrari et al. / Nuclear Physics B (Proc. Suppl.) 145 (2005) 93–97
10 3
10
10 2
1 10
0
25
50
75
0
100
25
50
$
&
+
75
100
Neutrino energy (GeV)
Neutrino energy (GeV)
-
&
&
$
-
4
6
$
$
$
-
:
-
4
6
$
$
$
6
<
n
E
<
-
d
<
>
+
$
&
>
$
B
B
+
-
>
M
-
O
D
P
E
<
4
>
6
H
B
+
B
$
S
i
-
H
>
&
]
D
$
+
=
$
-
D
E
4
6
-
H
B
B
=
<
-
B
&
H
B
$
Z
^
$
:
&
H
B
$
&
-
&
\
Z
&
H
B
$
-
&
$
c $
Z
B
$
Z
&
n
&
Z
+
S
Z
]
`
-
Z
4
f e
d
6
]
$ $
D
D
S
Z
:
&
-
-
$
u
$
B
B
$
i
-
$
-
&
H
B
H
$
$
-
$
Z
-
B
d
&
H
$
H
$
-
n
$
q
]
i
H
Z
B
&
$
$
H
u
\
Z
p
f e
-
B
$
n
$
:
$
$
-
:
>
i
B
>
+
-
$
Z
$
B
-
$
Z
>
{ e
?
f e
p
:
4
6
$
$
r
4
H
w
-
y
4
s
z
w
{ e
]
\
p
]
>
]
H
$
u
-
>
B
H
-
<
>
E
H
-
B
Z
&
$
&
Z
p
c
:
-
&
]
`
i
-
e
f
e
{
B
&
H
+
d
$
&
u
Z
i
-
e
$
u
p
&
]
-
d
H
$
$
$
<
B
s
>
y
p
p
B
H
&
>
H
-
e
f
e
{
+
-
y
+
H
H
+
\
&
&
:
]
&
+
>
f
e
e
>
Z
$
B
$
+
-
H
-
D
<
O
6
y
<
$
-
P
-
H
-
$
\
Z
B
>
H
$
$
\
n
-
$
<
>
Z
E
n
B
+
H
-
-
$
&
Z
+
B
>
-
&
H
B
>
B
-
$
-
$
>
+
>
B
{
B
&
Z
$
+
>
&
&
-
-
-
&
$
-
$
&
Z
&
H
S
&
$
-
i
H
B
B
#
Z
&
$
(
*
+
-
/
1
2
4
6
8
6
4 1
2
-
-
-
&
u
$
$
-
B
$
>
$
-
-
<
!
E
#
H
B
p
-
$
H
$
&
-
H
B
+
-
-
S
>
&
H
B
B
H
$
n
-
d
$
B
$
B
-
B
&
$
B
$
s
-
-
-
>
$
B
H
>
$
f e
H
n
{ e
Z
:
{ e
Z
&
:
$
>
n
+
-
B
C
Z
$
H
H
#
+
>
e
-
>
{
-
B
$
-
$
B
$
B
H
$
$
$
D
>
$
n
-
-
B
f e
Z
e
f
6
p
-
<
E
M
O
P
<
Z
n
$
-
e
? {
e
f
i
H
H
&
'
d
-
B
B
B
]
e
d
\
p
&
u
i
-
>
-
B
s
97
A. Ferrari et al. / Nuclear Physics B (Proc. Suppl.) 145 (2005) 93–97
"
%
(
*
2
"
7
%
:
:
%
7
"
,
/
+
0
2
B
B
B
"
%
E
D
2
(
H
(
D
G
G
,
.
"
G
"
r
D
c
c
H
B
%
r
c
c
,
B
B
s
"
u
c
v
f
w
m
/
D .
+
H
2
J
B
H
M
"
| /
"
J
(
B
H
k
"
D
H
*
D
E
*
0.2 0.18 0.16 0.14 0.12 0.1 0.08 0.06 0.04 0.02 0
Uncertainty
0
25
50
75
100 E (GeV)
/
0
2
H
$
%
%
$
B
H
%
B
/
"
~
/
% (
/
%
&
/
v
2
*
(
/
M
y
2
/
f
G
/
/
,
+
D
+
/
D
/
,
0
2
D
Q
B
(
%
h
J
u
k
J
M
Q
h
v
h
J
u
:
D
E
M
+
S
h
,
J
(
+
.
U
/
v
%
(
(
/
M
Q
h
v
y
:
0
M
/
.
+
u
,
J
B
/
"
2
/
v
+
+
+
D
/
,
,
D
D
0
25
50
75
100 E (GeV)
/
0
2
u
v c
f
w
m
c
(
(
/
M
h
J
(
/
u
J
B
/
"
+
2
/
v
E
S
Uncertainty
0.2 0.18 0.16 0.14 0.12 0.1 0.08 0.06 0.04 0.02 0
Uncertainty
0.2 0.18 0.16 0.14 0.12 0.1 0.08 0.06 0.04 0.02 0
#
S
,
D
E
,
+
.
c
U
f
h
:
m
y
m
c
:
D
D
D
0
M
m
y
m
c
:
y
:
M
D
+
D
+
D
/
D
0
2
y x
U
f
v
c
(
(
/
M
c
U
f
h
:
y m
m
c
:
y
:
+
h
k
m
:
y
:
.
D
2
/
E
D
,
¦
B
J
"
(
/
M
M
,
2
:
+
D
/
D
E
/
k
/
v
J
(
/
M
c
U
f
h
:
:
M
+
u
h
Q
h
v
U
:
+
,
+
.
c
U
f
h
:
m
D
:
+
+
+
E
u
M
u
h
Q
h
v
U
:
+
+
v
+
"
"
"
J
B
/
0
20
40
60
80
100 E (GeV) /
/
v
(
(
(
/
M
U
J
/
y
2
/
8
/
c
0
D D
M
+
/
+
Q
7
J
/
U
7
"
"
J
H
+
,
S
/
/
¦
B
J
(
/
M
8
/
y
2
/
k
D S
+
D
E
E
/
+
+
"
J
J
"
H
2
/
0
/
/
c
7
"
(
/
M
c
U
f
h
:
+
/
0
2
c
~
f x
w
m
c
(
(
/
M
y
2
/
M
S
/
S
,
/
+
E
+
S
0
:
+
D
,
[
\
]
^
`
a
\
]
M
"
0
2
h
c
U
f
h
k
m
c
h
k
m
J
x
v
E
2
H
2
E
0
,
+
c
(
(
/
M
h
J
(
/
u
/
"
2
/
v
/
+
+
S
/
~
/
/
v
2
(
/
M
c
U
f
h
:
:
+
%
B
H
r
s
(
(
2
t
/
,
u
c
v
f
w
m
"
y x
U
f
v
"
(
7
(
%
M 0
,
/
+
2
|
k
/
v
B
%
(
/
M
U
J
/
y
2
/
8
/
c
,
,
+
+
+
/
S
H
2
v
h
Q
t
2
c
~
f x
w
m
"
h
: x
/
,
v
B
v
/
2
J
J
%
"
"
k
m
7
B
2
B
<
t
J
*
M
2
M
(
/
/
M
0
v
G
/
¦
M
y
(
/
7
M
Q
M
/
"
/
M
>
@
M
B
C
D
/
D
E
G
H
t
:
h
0
Q
,
/
J
K
M
N
P
D
R
B
N
L
D
U
W
@
Y
B
[
\
\
\
U
B
M
J
D
@
D
C
J
D
J
.
m
7
:
(
7
M
(
M
:
t
(
(
%
t
t
2
*
B
(
D
/
,
+
+
,
.
/
,
"
E
+
7
"
"
M
%
k
/
c
E
2
J
"
%
u
c
v
f
w
m
"
y x
U
f
v
M
%
(
2
H
r
(
(
(
7
(
(
/
M
h
J
(
/
u
/
"
2
/
v
%
D
y
/
"
2
S
+
v
~ c
x
x
(
B
D
N
W
Y
b
M
h
J
(
/
u
/
"
2
/
v
,
/
+
/
/
+
J
D
/
2
D
7
,
(
E
+
(
D
.
v
~
t
G
2
G
%
2
r
s
/
k
J
7
(
(
B
r
(
(
2
(
B
(
(
"
B
+
D
:
"
%
2
/
u
H
c
h
k
m
/
/
"
"
M
E
(
G
(
x
y
%
U
f
v
H
7
,
M
,
"
u
c
v
f
w
m
D
"
S
,
c s
c
D
/
B
u
:
:
"
k
/
c
(
(
J
(
M
u
h
Q
h
v
U
:
/
+
y
f
"
(
/
M
c
U
f
h
:
v
:
:
:
x
E
,
"
Q
/
E
D
:
D
D
%
'
*
,
-
/
9
0
L
2
M
3
3
G
5
3
P
8
9
:
-
/
Q
;
;
<
2
U
=
2
?
V
8
2
?
]
_
8 Z
Z
<
Z
b
5
[
8
b
U
5
?
2
C
Q
S
P
8
2
S
C
A
\
E
H
W
/
8
Z
G
[
/
2
3
H
?
5
5
?
U
5
J
\
/
,
8
0
8
_
8
f
5
P
<
f
?
2
5
3
2
5
U
\
j
2
l
Z
/
b
m
E
n
o
_
8
f
_
Q
V
8
5
p
5
3
[
b
?
b
r
Q
E
,
J
]
_
Z
8
Z
<
Z
b
P
5
[
8
b
U
5
?
2
\
8
0
8
8 _
f
5
P
<
f
?
2
5
3
2
Q
V
8
5
L
2
?
b
3
8
5
Q
p
w
y
{
}
~
}
}
¡
¡
~
}
~
{
{
}
{
}
}
~
{
}
{
ª
~
}
~
~
}
}
}
{
}
{
¤
{
}
¥
~
}
}
y
}
S
x
,
}
³
´
µ
¶
·
¸
¹
º
»
¶
¼
¸
5
{
5
l
²
~
}
?
U
b
Q
]
Z
5
?
o
5
\
b
V
5
Q
]
Z
5
?
o
/
,
/
,
8
s
}
f
~
b
Z
}
_
8
ª
U
}
U
{
§
y
Ü
~
¯
2
U
_
S µ
}
}
_
8
Z
{
8
V
°
8
Z
}
}
~
}
o
8
¨
_
2
}
¾
~
~
l
2
~
f
{
Z
~
{
}
\
}
±
2
}
m
3
{
b
{
~
¤
A
Z
n
2
î Ý
Þ
_
V ½
2
3
Z
n
2
U
2
¾
Z
¿
V
2
o
2
5
3
_
Z
n
2
l
3
2
_
2
U
Z
=
2
U
2
3
5
Z
8
b
o
m
b
_
f
8
?
?
5
Z
8
b
U
2
¾
l
2
3
8
A
2
U
Z
_
5
Z
5
f
f
2
?
2
3
5
Z
b
3
_
W
Z
2
8
Z
3
b
U
=
Ä
Å
5
_
2
?
8
U
2
Æ
Ç
Å
2
5
A
_
Q
É
É
5
Z
É
M
É
Ì
Q
S
H ½
5
Z
P
Ð
p
]
Å
2
5
A
b
m
0
Z
8
f
_
b
m
Z
n
2
í Æ
#
Ç Æ
3
5
Z
8
b
Q
5
U
\
8
U
l
5
3
Z
8
f
<
?
5
8
Z
_
U
b
3
A
5
?
8
[
5
Z
8
b
U
2
3
3
b
3
3
/
n
p
]
n
2
L
P
;
H
Å
2
5
A
Ä
?
8
U
2
\
2
_
8
=
U
W
5
_
5
f
f
b
A
l
?
8
_
n
2
\
Ä
Í
b
P
5
A
÷
b ?
A
U
m
b
_
P
-
Ñ
Ì
5
S
U
\
]
L
-
G
Ð
U
Z
n
2
Å
5
_
8
_
b
m
Z
n
2
l
2 3
V
8
b
<
_
%
-
P
0
Æ
Ç
Å
2
5
A
2
¾
Ä
H
Í
l
2
3
8
2
U
f
2
5
Z
L
M
G
P
H
E
H
Ì
'
m
b
3
L
ï
G ½
Ð
H
5
U
\
P
Ä ½
Í
5
U
\
E ½
M
G
-
Ì
5
,
Z
L
P
;
H
L
M
G
P
Z
b
;
3
5
U
H
5
_
_
b
Í
p
-
j
2
¾
l
2
3
8
A
2
U
Z
_
Ì
r
W
n
8
f
n
5
?
?
b
W
2
\
m
b
3
5
l
b
W
2
3
Ä
Í
U
2
Z <
3
8
U
b
Å
2
5
A
_
Ì
Õ
8
_
2
¾
l
2
f
Z
2
\
Z
b
f
b
U
¿
3
A
Z
n
2
Í
m
Ç Æ
Ù Æ
Ú
Z
3
5
U
_
8
Z
8
b
U
_
b
Å
_
2
3
V
2
\
8
U
Z
n
2
5
Z
A
b
_
l
n
2
3
8
<
?
5
U
\
A
2
5
_
<
3
2
_
8
U
5 Ü
S
U
\
ß
à
ß á
W
8
Z
n
8
Ü
Ü
5
f
f
<
3
5
f
o
8
m
ß
à
ß á
ã
2
U
Ü
P
H ½
5
3
2
?
b
b
ç
8
U
o
A
2
5
_
<
3
8
U
=
Z
n
ä
å
/
Þ
É
<
U
f
Z
E ½
8
M
b
U
G
b
-
m
U
W
8
?
2
?
<
_
Z
2
m
b
3
U
Ç Æ
3
5
8
3
U
f
_
b
2
n
É
5
U
U
f
b
U
M
V
V
2
2
U
Z
U
8
U
b
U
b
5
Z
?
2
Æ
m
¾
Ç
l
b
Å
?
8
2
<
U
<
3
2
3
2
f
8
2
U
2
<
Z
3
8
U
b
Å
2
5
A
l
3
A
5
P
5
3
;
Z
3
8
U
b
\
8
_
5
l
l
2
5
3
5
U
f
2
Z
3
8
ç
f
m
<
?
b
5
3
f
3
m
b
b
U
V
3
2
Z
U
n
Z
8
2
b
U
L
5
P
?
U
;
2
H
<
/
Z
]
5
3
f
n
2
_
Z
n
2
_
2
2
¾
l
V
3
2
5
Z
2
8
3
8
\
8
U
U
H
Å
2
5
A
_
o
_
Z
2
A
5
Z
8
f
_
b
U
U
=
b
Z
í Æ
#
8
V
5
?
l
3
b
Å
5
Å
8
?
8
Z
o
5
_
2
3
=
V
o
8
W
\
2
n
U
f
8
2
?
2
b
]
m
L
Æ
-
Ú
8
G
U
Ð
Z
2
H
3
5
_
Z
3
b
U
=
Å
n
2
_ 8
5
_
A
2
_
U
_
5
U
2
\
Z
n
Ç Æ
3
5
Z
8
b
f
5
U
2
Å
f
Z
U
8
?
A
_
o
V
2
\
5
U
\
l
3
2
\
8
f
Z
2
\
m
3
b
A
Z
n
2
l
3
3
8
l
2
V
8
b
<
_
A
2
5
_
<
2
3
2
2
U
Z
_
5
U
\
_
Z
<
\
8
_ 2
l
2
3
m
b
3
A
2
\
W
8
Z
n
Z
n
2
%
-
P
0
Ä
/
\
b
_ U
³
,
.
0
2
4
6
7
8
:
»
:
=
0
¸
?
=
¶
º
¹
A
/
b
A
2
5
5
5
8
Z
8
A
8
[
2
\
m
b
3
Æ
Ù Ç
Æ
í
U
Z
n
2
%
-
P
0
Ç Æ
m
5
f
8
?
8
Z
o
Õ
;
s
2
V
Q
]
_
b
\
*
8
n
S Ü
A
m
Z
Þ
=
2
n
l
\
Å
f
U
L
]
m
Þ
2
x Ü
p
b o
Þ
Ü
m
\
â
8
b
<
U
x
Ý
Z
f
Å
Æ
_
U
Z
_
f
5
U
2
¾
l
?
b
3
2
_
8
U
2
å
C
f
l
3
b
Z
b
U
_
x
Ü
S
Ý
î
W
2
3
2
2
¾
Z
3
5
f
Z
2
\
Å
o
Z
n
2
H
E
H
5
\ U
_
2
U
Z
8
U
Z
b
5
_
2
=
Ä
Þ
b
f _
8
?
?
5
Z
8
b
U
l
5
3
5
A
2
Z
2
3
Å
2
o
b
U
\
Z
n
2
L
ï ½
½
? ð
8
A
8
Z
A
2
U
Z
2
\
Z
5
3
=
2
Z
f
b
A
l
b
_
2
\
Å
o
2
3
b
\
_
Q
f
E
Ì
/
s
]
U
l
5
3
Z
8
f
<
?
5
3
]
L
-
G
Ð
H
5
U
\
E ½
M
G
-
Ì
f
Í
,
5
A
b
m
x
U
Í
?
2
U
=
Z
n
5
U
\
A
A
\
8
5
A
2
Z
2
3
2
5
f
n
/
÷
n
2
l
3
b
\
<
f
2
\
,
3
2
5
f
n
5
f
b
A
Å
8
U
2
\
_
2
U
_
8
Z
8
V
8
Z
o
b
U
8 _
U
L Ü
S
Ý
E
V
8
Ä
î
l
Þ
b
_
8
Z
8
V
2
U
2
=
5
8 Z
V
2
ó
A
2
_
b
U
_
Q
2
_
_
2
U
Z
8
5
?
?
o
F
5
U
\
H
Q
ñ
ñ
b
?
5
Z
8
b
U
5
U
\
A
5
Z
Z
2
3
2
ò
2
f
Z
_
U
b
Z
5
f
f
b
<
U
Z
2
\
m
b
3
ó
5
W
2
3
2
m
b
f
<
_
2
\
\
2
m
b
f
<
_
2
\
ó
Å
o
Z
W
b
l
<
?
_
2
\
A
5
=
U
2
Z
8
f
ñ
m
5
f
Z
b
3
õ
Å
2
Z
Z
2
3
Z
n
5
U
L
ï ½
½
8 ð
U
Z
n
2
5
?
?
b
W
2
\
s
?
2
U
_
2
_
n
b
3
U
5
U
\
3
2
J
2
f
Z
b
3
ó
8
U
Z
b
5
V A
S
L
5
f
<
<
A
x
ñ
l
5
3
5
A
2
Z
2
3
3
2
=
8
U b
b
m
5
Z
A
b
_
l
n
2
3
8
f
U
2
<
Z
3
8
U
b
b
_
f
8
?
?
5
Ä
\
Z
8
b
U
_
m
b
3
¿
V
2
o
2
5
3
_
2
¾
l
b
_
<
3
2
Z
b
Z
n
2
L
P
;
H
Å
2
5
2
f
5
o
Z
<
U
U
2
?
W
2
3
2
U
2
<
Z
3
8
U
b
_
W
2
3
2
l
3
b
\
<
f
2
\
/
÷
n
2
A
3
2
_
<
?
Z
8
U
=
Ç Æ
Å
2
5
A
8
U
P
p ½
-
j
5
Z
r
Õ
A
m
3
b
A
Z
n
2
x
5
Z
U
b
A
8
U
5
?
8
U
Z
2
U
_
8
Z
o
Ì
/
w
÷
n
2
Ç Æ
Ù
í Æ
b
_
f
? 8
?
5
Z
8
b
U
_
Í
2
Z
5
3
=
2
Z
Q
W
5
_
f
n
5
3
5
f
Z
3 2
8
[
2
\
Å
o
5
U
2
U
2
3
=
o
õ
Õ
8
?
?
Å
2
_
2
5
3
f
n
2
\
m
b
3
5
_
í Æ
f
n
5
3
=
2
f
<
3
3
2
U
Z
2
V
2
U
Z
_
2
¾
2
å
5
U
\
5
f
b
U
Z
5
A
8
U
5
Z
8
b
U
b
m
õ
M
r
Q
w
f
2
_
_
b
V
2
3
Z
n
2
í Æ
f
b
U
Z
5
A
8
U
5
Z
8
b
U
b
m
Z
n
2
Å
2
5
A
ø
Z
n
M
o
8
_
_
<
2
W
8
? ?
Å
2
Z
n
2
ç
U
b
W
?
2
\
=
2
b
m
Z
n
2
U
2
<
Z
3
8
U
2
5
A
f
b
A
l
b
_
8
Z
8
b
U
5
U
\
_
l
2
f
Z
3
<
A
/
-
_
Z
3
b
U
=
8
A
5
U
\
â
b
,
Ç Æ
m
Q
í Æ
5
U
\
í Æ
3
2
_
l
2
f
Z
8
V
2
?
o
/
0
b
<
3
A
5
8
U
â
b
l
Å
õ
â
2
x
2
,
Ä
;
ç
M
S E
W
3
b
f
2
_
_
2
_
5
_
_
b
<
3
f
2
_
b
m
U
2
<
Z
3
8
U
b
_
W
2
3
2
3
2
f
b
=
U
8
[
2
\
ø
Ä
Õ
;
s
2
å
C
f
l
3
b
Z
b
U
8
U
Z
2
3
5
f
Z
8
b
U
_
8
U
Z
n
2
2
x
E
N
Z
ú
û
ü
ý
þ
ÿ
þ
ÿ
þ
ü
þ
þ
ý
ÿ
ü
0920-5632/$ – see front matter © 2005 Elsevier B.V. All rights reserved. doi:10.1016/j.nuclphysbps.2005.03.042
5
3
=
2
Z
W
n
8
f
n
l
3
b
\
<
f
2
F
Q
Q
H
Q
Q
H
S
Q
/
/
/
b
3
8
=
8
Ä
94
A. Ferrari et al. / Nuclear Physics B (Proc. Suppl.) 145 (2005) 93–97
$
%
&
%
!
#
)
$
%
+
%
2
%
&
+
+
%
%
2
x 10 2
9
%
9
A
A
2
+
$
B
9
%
<
<
2
9
+
<
F
%
&
H
<
<
&
$
νµCC
1500 1000
F
+
+
&
H
$
A
)
2
9
+
P
A
)
W
%
X
Z
2
[
+
\
<
F
)
0.9
$
%
&
2
$
<
%
<
&
<
&
$
%
$
)
%
A
+
<
2
100
150
0.8
200
0
50
A
+
%
<
P
W
<
+
[
<
2
%
)
−
νµCC
4000
%
2
A
+
%
%
200
2000
−
νµCC
1.4 1.2 1 0.8 0.6
0
50
100
150
0
200
50
2
+
A
F
&
H
A
100
150
200
Visible energy (GeV)
Visible energy (GeV)
150
0
$
100
Visible energy (GeV)
50
Visible energy (GeV)
0
V
1
500
Events / 8 GeV
νµCC
1.1
B
0 &
1.2
Data / MC
Data / MC
Events / 8 GeV
2
W
X
<
2
+
<
2
b
<
[
F
W
e
b
&
$
1.5
1.5
1
1
[
−
f
νeCC
400
2
Data / MC
a
Events / 16 GeV
200
−
νeCC
1.5 1 0.5
0
0
50
100
0
150
0
50
0.5
0.5
100
150
Visible energy (GeV)
Visible energy (GeV) g
%
f
%
%
)
+
$
2
%
A
\
%
V
<
0
0
100
200
0
300 p (GeV/c)
0
100
200
300 p (GeV/c)
$
+
9
+
+
2
A
%
%
%
F
%
+
\
<
V
%
A
+
%
&
\
%
B
<
V
1.5
1.5
1
1
0.5
0.5
[
%
\
%
2
+
!
#
<
u
%
2
%
%
+
$
<
%
+
f
X
v
w
V
0
0
100
200
0
300 p (GeV/c)
1.5
0
100
200
300 p (GeV/c)
1.5 %
1
1
0.5
0.5
A
%
q
A
2
2
&
+
%
&
+
+
+
F
+
&
A
2
A
2
A
[
f
<
$
%
<
2
#
)
e
!
2
$
%
+
9
%
$
%
%
&
<
F
)
!
F b
0
0
100
200
0
300 p (GeV/c)
A
A
b b
F
%
u
<
F
)
n
o
A
A
F
%
w
0
100
200
300 p (GeV/c)
Events / 8 GeV
1.4 1.2 1 0.8 0.6
800
νeCC
700 600
0.4
500 0.2 0
g
0
50
%
f
100
g
i
k
l
150
!
n
o
200
B
!
&
X
p
2
2
+
400
300 350 p (GeV/c)
$
%
<
2
300 H
b
%
%
250
%
q
2
+
%
+
+
%
+
2
A
+
r
&
&
9
&
+
200 f
100 r
<
+
9
<
9
%
2
%
)
F
%
+
\
9
0 V
2
&
F
$
A
)
&
A
2
+
u
0
f
X
v
20
40
60
80
100
120
140
160
180
200
w
Visible energy (GeV) g
%
f
%
)
+
$
2
%
&
%
&
+
%
<
v
x
%
<
%
$
%
<
2
%
)
+
$
2
%
B
+
)
<
2
&
$
+
F
&
+
<
P
9
A
<
[
%
2
+
$
+
9
+
+
2
A
%
%
%
V
F
&
+
$
%
<
2
%
+
%
%
<
f
x
%
+
\
<
%
A
H
V
!
#
u
<
X
f
<
2
2
%
<
+
2
%
$
<
v
w
+
%
&
\
H
95
A. Ferrari et al. / Nuclear Physics B (Proc. Suppl.) 145 (2005) 93–97
6
7
8
#
-
;
9
<
>
!
#
#
%
!
#
%
%
B
#
0
*
*
,
-
#
0
0
0
#
4
# F
0
n
*
*
0
O
#
G
G
0
!
J
0
J
4
!
F
8
# G
%
J
#
0
0
#
0
G
%
#
G
#
0
O
#
F
!
#
0
0
J
O
#
J
#
0
0
J
#
0
#
J
G
0
G
R
!
#
0
0
#
#
G
F
u
0
J
#
0
O
#
#
0
4
G
O
#
O
#
G
F
j
t
#
0
G
G
X
4
G
0
4
]
0
#
0
#
0
X
#
G
O
#
0
J
0
0
!
O
J
#
0
G
0
J
J
]
G
%
#
0
J
]
c
d
e
> J
O
0
J
0
#
0
J
4
]
0
0
J
i
G
0
J
#
0
#
J
6
]
7
G
J
0
J
!
7
O
#
J
G
J
G
#
0
#
R
0
#
-
8
m
O
J
#
#
0
%
h
#
0
4
F
7
#
G
8
<
J
G
O
8
]
0
-
#
0
7
G
8
4
<
0
0
#
0
#
#
0
4
G
G
O
#
0
G
q
%
#
G
J
0
#
0
n
G
]
m
6
#
0
#
%
i
#
J
O
J
!
#
G
4
0
!
z
0
j
#
#
0
G
#
G
#
%
n
0
J
F
n
G
F
m
G
q
#
]
0
G
G
#
#
0
0
0
O
G
]
0
0
%
0
0
G
#
G
0
#
n
0
n
0
F
9
! J
R
J
n
#
G
#
%
%
G
O
#
#
0
J
0
0
J
0
#
0
O
#
n
#
m
G
6
!
F
J
O
0
J
0
j
7
0
X
#
F
9
0
!
0
J
j
i
O
;
8
8
7
i
i
9
j
F
t
G
G
G
u
G
G
#
0
J
#
!
G
O
!
%
#
0
F
#
0
#
4
>
#
O
0
#
0
#
!
O
G
#
G
0
#
0
%
G
$
&
(
)
+
-
/
(
2
(
5
7
G
n
4
]
G
O
F
0
*
,
-
0
0
#
4
%
!
u
t
%
#
J
4
!
4
0
G
#
0
%
#
O
!
O
#
#
0
G
-
8
O
#
,
B y
>
z
J
#
0
J
0
<
#
%
#
0
8
]
0
#
0
0
0
G
!
#
%
<
O
;
:
7
#
!
O
#
F
8
t
c
d
e
>
0
#
]
%
#
#
0
G
#
G
#
0
O
#
J
#
0
4
G
J
#
0
G
J
J
#
0
G
4
]
0
O
J
J
0
J
G
J
G
4
G
J
#
O
#
#
J
0
X
G
]
0
%
0
#
0
G
]
#
0
G
u
q
]
4
m
J
*
,
¡
0
J
G
0
#
4
#
0
q
0
O
#
J
G
#
%
7
!
F
%
0
7
0
q
8
0
J
#
%
;
J
q
G
G
O
J
4
!
F
>
J
G
%
0
#
0
#
%
G
#
0
#
0
F
4
!
0
0
O
O
#
J
#
0
#
R
J
#
%
0
O
0
0
J
0
J
0
!
#
O
R
#
G
?
>
,
0
0
#
4
F
0
7
G
#
0
0
J
#
]
#
]
%
#
G
0
#
8
J
%
#
G
0
u
#
%
O
#
G
R
0
0
G
O
#
0
!
G
%
0
#
0
#
%
O
#
J
R
u
J
G
#
0
F
t t
F
J
G
0
#
h
#
0
J
!
0
0
]
0
7
#
0
0
#
0
4
F
0
X
]
F
0
]
G
#
4
0
J
%
#
#
G
O
#
0
J
0
%
#
0
G
0
F
#
0
0
#
J
]
#
7
;
%
0
0
!
6
0
,
B y
n
0
0
J
#
0
#
0
4
J
O
]
G
O
J #
4
G
#
4
J
>
G
J
F
J
#
0
G
0
J
#
0
4
F
0
>
O
F
9
0
]
G
J
n
0
#
0
>
z
]
G
%
]
O
0
R
0
#
0
]
G
J
R
#
J
#
R
%
#
0
F
G
j
G
O
7
X
0
0
0
#
%
O
#
#
0
4
G
O
#
0
u
i
0
J
#
J
G
]
G
O
#
G
G
4
0
!
#
%
t
]
G
!
G
0
#
#
0
#
#
%
h
j
0
4
0
0
#
J
#
m
96
7
7
νe / 5 GeV / 10 p.o.t.
νµ / 2 GeV / 10 p.o.t.
A. Ferrari et al. / Nuclear Physics B (Proc. Suppl.) 145 (2005) 93–97
10 3
10
10 2
1 10
0
25
50
75
0
100
25
50
$
&
+
75
100
Neutrino energy (GeV)
Neutrino energy (GeV)
-
&
&
$
-
4
6
$
$
$
-
:
-
4
6
$
$
$
6
<
n
E
<
-
d
<
>
+
$
&
>
$
B
B
+
-
>
M
-
O
D
P
E
<
4
>
6
H
B
+
B
$
S
i
-
H
>
&
]
D
$
+
=
$
-
D
E
4
6
-
H
B
B
=
<
-
B
&
H
B
$
Z
^
$
:
&
H
B
$
&
-
&
\
Z
&
H
B
$
-
&
$
c $
Z
B
$
Z
&
n
&
Z
+
S
Z
]
`
-
Z
4
f e
d
6
]
$ $
D
D
S
Z
:
&
-
-
$
u
$
B
B
$
i
-
$
-
&
H
B
H
$
$
-
$
Z
-
B
d
&
H
$
H
$
-
n
$
q
]
i
H
Z
B
&
$
$
H
u
\
Z
p
f e
-
B
$
n
$
:
$
$
-
:
>
i
B
>
+
-
$
Z
$
B
-
$
Z
>
{ e
?
f e
p
:
4
6
$
$
r
4
H
w
-
y
4
s
z
w
{ e
]
\
p
]
>
]
H
$
u
-
>
B
H
-
<
>
E
H
-
B
Z
&
$
&
Z
p
c
:
-
&
]
`
i
-
e
f
e
{
B
&
H
+
d
$
&
u
Z
i
-
e
$
u
p
&
]
-
d
H
$
$
$
<
B
s
>
y
p
p
B
H
&
>
H
-
e
f
e
{
+
-
y
+
H
H
+
\
&
&
:
]
&
+
>
f
e
e
>
Z
$
B
$
+
-
H
-
D
<
O
6
y
<
$
-
P
-
H
-
$
\
Z
B
>
H
$
$
\
n
-
$
<
>
Z
E
n
B
+
H
-
-
$
&
Z
+
B
>
-
&
H
B
>
B
-
$
-
$
>
+
>
B
{
B
&
Z
$
+
>
&
&
-
-
-
&
$
-
$
&
Z
&
H
S
&
$
-
i
H
B
B
#
Z
&
$
(
*
+
-
/
1
2
4
6
8
6
4 1
2
-
-
-
&
u
$
$
-
B
$
>
$
-
-
<
!
E
#
H
B
p
-
$
H
$
&
-
H
B
+
-
-
S
>
&
H
B
B
H
$
n
-
d
$
B
$
B
-
B
&
$
B
$
s
-
-
-
>
$
B
H
>
$
f e
H
n
{ e
Z
:
{ e
Z
&
:
$
>
n
+
-
B
C
Z
$
H
H
#
+
>
e
-
>
{
-
B
$
-
$
B
$
B
H
$
$
$
D
>
$
n
-
-
B
f e
Z
e
f
6
p
-
<
E
M
O
P
<
Z
n
$
-
e
? {
e
f
i
H
H
&
'
d
-
B
B
B
]
e
d
\
p
&
u
i
-
>
-
B
s
97
A. Ferrari et al. / Nuclear Physics B (Proc. Suppl.) 145 (2005) 93–97
"
%
(
*
2
"
7
%
:
:
%
7
"
,
/
+
0
2
B
B
B
"
%
E
D
2
(
H
(
D
G
G
,
.
"
G
"
r
D
c
c
H
B
%
r
c
c
,
B
B
s
"
u
c
v
f
w
m
/
D .
+
H
2
J
B
H
M
"
| /
"
J
(
B
H
k
"
D
H
*
D
E
*
0.2 0.18 0.16 0.14 0.12 0.1 0.08 0.06 0.04 0.02 0
Uncertainty
0
25
50
75
100 E (GeV)
/
0
2
H
$
%
%
$
B
H
%
B
/
"
~
/
% (
/
%
&
/
v
2
*
(
/
M
y
2
/
f
G
/
/
,
+
D
+
/
D
/
,
0
2
D
Q
B
(
%
h
J
u
k
J
M
Q
h
v
h
J
u
:
D
E
M
+
S
h
,
J
(
+
.
U
/
v
%
(
(
/
M
Q
h
v
y
:
0
M
/
.
+
u
,
J
B
/
"
2
/
v
+
+
+
D
/
,
,
D
D
0
25
50
75
100 E (GeV)
/
0
2
u
v c
f
w
m
c
(
(
/
M
h
J
(
/
u
J
B
/
"
+
2
/
v
E
S
Uncertainty
0.2 0.18 0.16 0.14 0.12 0.1 0.08 0.06 0.04 0.02 0
Uncertainty
0.2 0.18 0.16 0.14 0.12 0.1 0.08 0.06 0.04 0.02 0
#
S
,
D
E
,
+
.
c
U
f
h
:
m
y
m
c
:
D
D
D
0
M
m
y
m
c
:
y
:
M
D
+
D
+
D
/
D
0
2
y x
U
f
v
c
(
(
/
M
c
U
f
h
:
y m
m
c
:
y
:
+
h
k
m
:
y
:
.
D
2
/
E
D
,
¦
B
J
"
(
/
M
M
,
2
:
+
D
/
D
E
/
k
/
v
J
(
/
M
c
U
f
h
:
:
M
+
u
h
Q
h
v
U
:
+
,
+
.
c
U
f
h
:
m
D
:
+
+
+
E
u
M
u
h
Q
h
v
U
:
+
+
v
+
"
"
"
J
B
/
0
20
40
60
80
100 E (GeV) /
/
v
(
(
(
/
M
U
J
/
y
2
/
8
/
c
0
D D
M
+
/
+
Q
7
J
/
U
7
"
"
J
H
+
,
S
/
/
¦
B
J
(
/
M
8
/
y
2
/
k
D S
+
D
E
E
/
+
+
"
J
J
"
H
2
/
0
/
/
c
7
"
(
/
M
c
U
f
h
:
+
/
0
2
c
~
f x
w
m
c
(
(
/
M
y
2
/
M
S
/
S
,
/
+
E
+
S
0
:
+
D
,
[
\
]
^
`
a
\
]
M
"
0
2
h
c
U
f
h
k
m
c
h
k
m
J
x
v
E
2
H
2
E
0
,
+
c
(
(
/
M
h
J
(
/
u
/
"
2
/
v
/
+
+
S
/
~
/
/
v
2
(
/
M
c
U
f
h
:
:
+
%
B
H
r
s
(
(
2
t
/
,
u
c
v
f
w
m
"
y x
U
f
v
"
(
7
(
%
M 0
,
/
+
2
|
k
/
v
B
%
(
/
M
U
J
/
y
2
/
8
/
c
,
,
+
+
+
/
S
H
2
v
h
Q
t
2
c
~
f x
w
m
"
h
: x
/
,
v
B
v
/
2
J
J
%
"
"
k
m
7
B
2
B
<
t
J
*
M
2
M
(
/
/
M
0
v
G
/
¦
M
y
(
/
7
M
Q
M
/
"
/
M
>
@
M
B
C
D
/
D
E
G
H
t
:
h
0
Q
,
/
J
K
M
N
P
D
R
B
N
L
D
U
W
@
Y
B
[
\
\
\
U
B
M
J
D
@
D
C
J
D
J
.
m
7
:
(
7
M
(
M
:
t
(
(
%
t
t
2
*
B
(
D
/
,
+
+
,
.
/
,
"
E
+
7
"
"
M
%
k
/
c
E
2
J
"
%
u
c
v
f
w
m
"
y x
U
f
v
M
%
(
2
H
r
(
(
(
7
(
(
/
M
h
J
(
/
u
/
"
2
/
v
%
D
y
/
"
2
S
+
v
~ c
x
x
(
B
D
N
W
Y
b
M
h
J
(
/
u
/
"
2
/
v
,
/
+
/
/
+
J
D
/
2
D
7
,
(
E
+
(
D
.
v
~
t
G
2
G
%
2
r
s
/
k
J
7
(
(
B
r
(
(
2
(
B
(
(
"
B
+
D
:
"
%
2
/
u
H
c
h
k
m
/
/
"
"
M
E
(
G
(
x
y
%
U
f
v
H
7
,
M
,
"
u
c
v
f
w
m
D
"
S
,
c s
c
D
/
B
u
:
:
"
k
/
c
(
(
J
(
M
u
h
Q
h
v
U
:
/
+
y
f
"
(
/
M
c
U
f
h
:
v
:
:
:
x
E
,
"
Q
/
E
D
:
D
D