Comment on “The late swing and early stance of sprinting are most hazardous for hamstring injuries” by Liu et al.

ARTICLE IN PRESS

JSHS372_proof ■ 23 February 2017 ■ 1/2

Available online at www.sciencedirect.com

H O S T E D BY

ScienceDirect

Available online at www.sciencedirect.com

ScienceDirect

Production and hosting by Elsevier

Journal of Sport and Health Science xx (2017) 1–2 www.jshs.org.cn 1 2 3 4 5 6 7

bs_bs_query

Q2

Commentary

Q3

Comment on “The late swing and early stance of sprinting are most hazardous for hamstring injuries” by Liu et al.

bs_bs_query

bs_bs_query

bs_bs_query

bs_bs_query

bs_bs_query

bs_bs_query

a

8 9 10

bs_bs_query

bs_bs_query

bs_bs_query

11 12

bs_bs_query

bs_bs_query

13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 21 22 23 24 25 26 27 28 29 30 31 32 33 34 35 36 37 38 39 40 41 42 43 44 45 46 47 48 49

Bing Yu a,*, Hui Liu b, William E. Garrett c

Q1

Center for Human Movement Science, The University of North Carolina at Chapel Hill, Chapel Hill, NC 27599, USA b Biomechanics Laboratory, Beijing Sport University, Beijing 100084, China c Duke University Sports Medicine Center, Durham, NC 27710, USA Received 8 November 2016; revised 15 November 2016; accepted 23 November 2016 Available online

bs_bs_query

bs_bs_query

bs_bs_query

bs_bs_query

bs_bs_query

bs_bs_query

bs_bs_query

bs_bs_query

bs_bs_query

bs_bs_query

bs_bs_query

bs_bs_query

bs_bs_query

bs_bs_query

bs_bs_query

bs_bs_query

bs_bs_query

bs_bs_query

bs_bs_query

bs_bs_query

bs_bs_query

bs_bs_query

bs_bs_query

bs_bs_query

bs_bs_query

bs_bs_query

bs_bs_query

bs_bs_query

bs_bs_query

bs_bs_query

bs_bs_query

bs_bs_query

bs_bs_query

We have carefully read the description of the proposed Q4 mechanisms of hamstring muscle strain injury by Liu et al.1

and noticed that they suggest that hamstring strain injuries may be associated with extensive muscle force and occur during the early stance phase of sprinting when the hamstrings are thought to work concentrically. We did not find any evidence in our extensive literature review to support this particular view. Liu et al.1 did not provide any literature showing a muscle injury mechanism with high concentric muscle contractions. The literature is full of examples demonstrating that muscle strain injuries are caused by muscle strain, instead of muscle force, that occurs in eccentrically contracting muscles. Garrett et al.2 demonstrated that muscle strain injury occurred at similar strains in eccentric contraction, independent of muscle forces. Similarly, Lieber and Friden3 found that muscle strain, not force, was the primary factor producing muscle damage due to repetitive eccentric contractions. We did not find evidence that muscle strain could occur in concentric contractions. Q5 Mann and Sprague3,4 investigated lower extremity kinetics during overground sprinting and calculated the resultant torques of the lower limb joints. They found that knee flexion and hip extension torques peaked in early stance.4 Although the variations in knee flexion and hip extension torque can be approximated as indications of the variation in hamstring muscle force, Mann and Sprague4 did not present muscle strain values. Therefore, it was impossible for them to establish an association between muscle force and strain. Their suggestion that hamstring muscles might be at risk for strain injury during early stance was a guess lacking scientific rigor and was made in the absence of studies on the mechanism of muscle strain injury.

bs_bs_query

bs_bs_query

bs_bs_query

bs_bs_query

Peer review under responsibility of Shanghai University of Sport. * E-mail address: [email protected]

It has been found that hamstring muscle force and strain are not associated in sprinting. Mann and Sprague4 showed that the peak knee flexion and hip extension torque occurred in the early stance phase in overground sprinting. However, Thelen et al.5 found that the hamstring muscles were in eccentric contraction and reached maximal muscle-tendon unit length in the late swing phase in treadmill sprinting. They also found that the hamstring muscles were contracting concentrically in the early stance phase of sprinting.4 Yu et al.6 showed similar results in overground sprinting. These results taken together clearly indicate that hamstring muscle force and strain are not associated in a linear fashion in sprinting and specifically that peak torques and hamstring forces do not occur at peak hamstring lengths. The idea that hamstring muscle strain injury may be caused by muscle force is mainly based on a recent study by Sun et al.7 However, there is little information on the possible mechanisms of hamstring muscle strain injury in sprinting in that study. Sun et al.7 decomposed the contributions to the resultant joint torques into 5 components using a sophisticated biomechanical model. However, they did not establish a convincing correlation between any of the components and hamstring muscle length or strain. Therefore, no direct evidence was shown supporting an association among hamstring injury, muscle force, and muscle strain to support their proposal. Liu et al.1 cited Uchiyama et al.8 in support of their view that muscle strain injury can occur during concentric contraction. We would argue that the study by Uchiyama et al.8 provides little support to their proposal. Uchiyama et al.8 added strain in concentric contractions to create strain injuries in rat muscles.7 Therefore, the muscle strain injuries actually occurred in an eccentric part of the contraction, which is different from the hamstrings’ continuous concentric contraction in the early stance phase of sprinting. In summary, the current literature provides overwhelming evidence that muscle strain injuries occur in eccentric contractions, or when muscles are stretched without activation, and that hamstring muscles are at risk for strain injury during the late

http://dx.doi.org/10.1016/j.jshs.2017.02.003 2095-2546/© 2017 Production and hosting by Elsevier B.V. on behalf of Shanghai University of Sport. This is an open access article under the CC BY-NC-ND license (http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-nc-nd/4.0/). Please cite this article in press as: Bing Yu, Hui Liu, William E. Garrett, Comment on “The late swing and early stance of sprinting are most hazardous for hamstring injuries” by Liu et al., Journal of Sport and Health Science (2017), doi: 10.1016/j.jshs.2017.02.003

50 51 52 53 54 55 56 57 58 59 60 61 62 63 64 65 66 67 68 69 70 71 72 73 74 75 76 77 78 79 80 81 82 83 84 85 86

bs_bs_query

bs_bs_query

bs_bs_query

bs_bs_query

bs_bs_query

bs_bs_query

bs_bs_query

bs_bs_query

bs_bs_query

bs_bs_query

bs_bs_query

bs_bs_query

bs_bs_query

bs_bs_query

bs_bs_query

bs_bs_query

bs_bs_query

bs_bs_query

bs_bs_query

bs_bs_query

bs_bs_query

bs_bs_query

bs_bs_query

bs_bs_query

bs_bs_query

bs_bs_query

bs_bs_query

bs_bs_query

bs_bs_query

bs_bs_query

bs_bs_query

bs_bs_query

bs_bs_query

bs_bs_query

bs_bs_query

bs_bs_query

bs_bs_query

ARTICLE IN PRESS 2

1 87 88 89 90 91 92 93 94 95 96 97 98 99 100 101 102 103 104 105

bs_bs_query

bs_bs_query

bs_bs_query

bs_bs_query

bs_bs_query

bs_bs_query

B. Yu et al.

swing phase of sprinting in which hamstring muscles have peak strains in eccentric contraction. In an extensive literature review, we failed to find any theoretical or direct experimental evidence supporting the association between hamstring strain injury and concentric contraction during the early stance phase of sprinting.

bs_bs_query

bs_bs_query

Authors’ contributions

bs_bs_query

bs_bs_query

bs_bs_query

bs_bs_query

bs_bs_query

bs_bs_query

bs_bs_query

BY drafted the manuscript; HL performed literature searches and helped to draft and revise the manuscript; WEG helped to perform literature searches and draft and revise the manuscript. All authors have read and approved the final version of the manuscript, and agree with the order of presentation of the authors.

bs_bs_query

bs_bs_query

Competing interests

bs_bs_query

bs_bs_query

JSHS372_proof ■ 23 February 2017 ■ 2/2

None of the authors declare competing financial interests.

References

106 107 108 109 110 111 112 113 114 115 116 117 118 119 120 121 122 123 124 125 126 127 128

bs_bs_query

bs_bs_query

1. Liu Y, Sun Y, Zhu W, Yu J. The late swing and early stance of sprinting are most hazardous for the hamstring injuries. J Sport Health Sci 2017;6. 2. Garrett WE, Safran MR, Seaber AV, Glisson RR, Ribbeck BM. Biomechanical comparison of stimulated and nonstimulated skeletal muscle pulled to failure. Am J Sports Med 1987;15:448–54. 3. Lieber RL, Friden J. Muscle damage is not a function of muscle force but active muscle strain. J Appl Physiol 1993;74:520–6. 4. Mann R, Sprague P. A kinetic analysis of the ground leg during sprint running. Res Q Exerc Sport 1980;51:334–48. 5. Thelen DG, Chumanov ES, Best TM, Swanson SC, Heiderscheit BC. Simulation of biceps femoris musculotendon mechanics during the swing phase of sprinting. Med Sci Sports Exerc 2005;37:1931–8. 6. Yu B, Queen RM, Abbey AN, Liu Y, Moorman CT, Garrett WE. Hamstring muscle kinematics and activation during overground sprinting. J Biomech 2008;41:3121–6. 7. Sun Y, Wei S, Zhong Y, Fu W, Li L, Liu Y. How joint torques affect hamstring injury risk in sprinting swing-stance transition. Med Sci Sports Exerc 2015;47:373–80. 8. Uchiyama Y, Tamaki T, Fukuda H. Relationship between functional deficit and severity of experimental fast-strain injury of rat skeletal muscle. Eur J Appl Physiol 2001;85:1–9.

Please cite this article in press as: Bing Yu, Hui Liu, William E. Garrett, Comment on “The late swing and early stance of sprinting are most hazardous for hamstring injuries” by Liu et al., Journal of Sport and Health Science (2017), doi: 10.1016/j.jshs.2017.02.003

bs_bs_query

bs_bs_query

bs_bs_query

bs_bs_query

bs_bs_query

bs_bs_query

bs_bs_query

bs_bs_query

bs_bs_query

bs_bs_query

bs_bs_query

bs_bs_query

bs_bs_query

bs_bs_query

bs_bs_query

bs_bs_query

bs_bs_query

bs_bs_query

bs_bs_query

bs_bs_query

bs_bs_query