- Email: [email protected]
Comparative Study on Life Cycle CO2 Emissions from the Production of Electric and Conventional Vehicles in China
Available online at www.sciencedirect.com
ScienceDirect Energy Procedia 105 (2017) 3584 – 3595
! " # $ !"$
" % & ' #" "( # & # " ) " * &* +,+-&.& / +,+/ ' & +,+% & & 0 +1 1 +,2
!
" #$ !
) )+ 3 & "( + # " + & 3 .& # , & 1 + , # ) , #& + & $ # , #) " + & "( # & & # ! " ,& ) !")+ & " & "( # & # ) # 4 45 +678 8 # !")+ 7 ' 9 , & ) : + ## &, ## , ,& $ &# & .& #' 9 , & + & & #"( # )3 "
© 2017 The Authors. Published by Elsevier Ltd. This is an open access article under the CC BY-NC-ND license ; $& &, , ' (http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-nc-nd/4.0/). % 9 & , #!"$ Peer-review under responsibility of the scientific committee of the 8th International Conference on Applied Energy.
% < & =' 9 , = # = &
$ 3 + ) ) #& &+ " $
" + && & & #) 6 + &, 6>? #
#
# # "( >?+ & & + &# & + ,+& + + + @
& # & # # ## % #& ' # " ! '"! # ) & , 2" & <A 95754=# 3<A 95754 &' ( B & &
1876-6102 © 2017 The Authors. Published by Elsevier Ltd. This is an open access article under the CC BY-NC-ND license (http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-nc-nd/4.0/). Peer-review under responsibility of the scientific committee of the 8th International Conference on Applied Energy. doi:10.1016/j.egypro.2017.03.827
Qinyu Qiao et al. / Energy Procedia 105 (2017) 3584 – 3595
& >C? ' & # # & #
, & >4? ( 9 9 & # ## ## + & " >6? $ D $E
& ' # " $ '"$ # %4
+ & # ## , >? @ & & # &
& # : 1 +
"( # & # ! " ,& ) !") ,&
, & 8 #& # "( + & #
>5? $ & + # )+ "( # &
& # + F & &,:
& # & & & #& & ( +"( # & ## &# & .& $ & 3 & # & + # # & .& ! &,: + & # & "( # & " + & 3 .& # , & > ?- & + & # # G # & + & # G
"( +G
-
# +G9"(@0
@@
# +G
@-
# #&+@0
H
& #
# 2 $
,
I
,
I$
,
I"
,
-
#&
%"
.* * 2
3585
3586
Qinyu Qiao et al. / Energy Procedia 105 (2017) 3584 – 3595
& 9 9 + & & # + ,
&# & + &# & +, &# &
, $ - + # , + #& &
#& & & & F #
"( + & 3 + ,& ,& +&
& & F "( # & $ "(
& , & &3 +& +
& ,
- ) & , & #
.*.*3#'2# # !") ) ,: &
& #& &!6+ 4 & " + , & C & # @ + # + )+ , & # !")>7? ! + & & , + & G 9 F
, I9"
" # , # ) !") % # # " & + & & & # & + & $& % " @ $%"@ , ( G H J ' , >?+ 6 E & E + H& + K @ EH 96>?+ $ 3$ , -& + #
#, + #& $ 3$ ,( 9 , , !") )+ , ) ' 9 , , - +' -(4 '- ,
& , & 68 # " L , G 6+ ' J " @( J"@ ,
& # C78>? # & '- J"@ ,
Qinyu Qiao et al. / Energy Procedia 105 (2017) 3584 – 3595
,: M + # 9 F
, # !") ) - + G # #& & + & + , G#& #& + + #& .*4*5 .& 4 , # "( # &
I" %" I - H @@ @- - I$ I $ @- - C I$ $ I"A %" 4 M +
I" %" I - "( # & # ,
, #& G9"( = I$ "( # , G9"( = $ "( # ,+# , , G9"( = "( # & G9"( # # #& & #
& , # # & , , ,' # "( # # #& #&
"( # 6&!7.+586&!7.+69
D &
"
74
>C?
C46
>4?+>6?
J &
C6
>C?
" G
67
>?+>5?
H &
7C
>C?
E
>C?
D
577
>C?
I #&
>?
" G
444
>?
J < " G+ , #& G & & G & & & , & # ## +, + #& @
D &
I + #&
D &
%
> ?+>7?+>?
'-, <
>5?
!
> ?
'-, <
> ?
3587
3588
Qinyu Qiao et al. / Energy Procedia 105 (2017) 3584 – 3595 " & &
> ?+>?
J"@, <
>5?
M & & &
> ?+>?
J"@, <
> ?
" ,
>?+>C?
> ?+>7?
E
>4?
-&
>?+>C?+>6?
H&,,
>6?+>?
$
> ?+>C?+>4?
@ &
>6?
J < @ # & # ,
& & & # " - + & # &
& # 8 " >C?+ & & " -& + & G # & " + & # , & , , ,'&>C?+ >C?9>CC? %& >C? 4* *7 % , C "( # & ! "(
, & 4 ) J"@ , + 678 # !")+ , & 7 $ &, # ) '-, + , & 45 +8 # !") ,C"( # & "( G
" I "
% "
I
$,
!")
)9J"@
)9'-
I < & , 9 9 + +3 +
557
4C7C6
4C7C6
" & ,
45
66
66
76
46
46
54
466
466
57
57
' 9 ,
46
6
6
' 9 ,
5
-&
C
7 C
7 C
55
55
55
' 9 , ,
4
5
5
74
' 9 I ,
46
46
) ,
4
4
4
756
446
454
#"( # - !
,# & "( # ' 9 , &
& # , G # )+ , & 788# ) J"@'-, @ + "( & # # ) # !")
3589
Qinyu Qiao et al. / Energy Procedia 105 (2017) 3584 – 3595
- D #"( , ##
4*.*# ' ' 9 , :& , ) # # & # & "( # , & 3 # & , , # , &# & " + & & $ +"( # & #& , # , '- J"@ , - C "( # & # , , & , & + & # 4C6 C44G9"( J"@, 67C C 6G9"( '-, + .& #
& , G & , # &
- CK #"( # , &
3590
Qinyu Qiao et al. / Energy Procedia 105 (2017) 3584 – 3595
* *! 2 ' ' % && , G #"( # & # !")
)EH 96 & #
& + + K%+ "( # & # !") , & 4 # ) J"@'-, , & 4 >?+ & " ' 9 , & .& & - # +1 G "( # & # @ $9" !") ) J"@'- , & , & , # ) J"@'- & , & C4 "(9.+ & #!") & +6 "(9.>5? ! + & , ## & & ## &# & .&+ + ) &
& & "( *.*: #' @& "( & # & # ) !")# # " , , G # & ,
& , + "( # & # ) 678 # !")+
& , M + & # !") & "( & ## 1 + 3 ) G "( # & # )C8 # !")-& +
,# & & #,
+ & #& + & C 4 "( ) J"@'- , # !") & "( # ' 9 , & - + "( & # ) , & ' 9 , , *4*!7. # 2 ' $ & +) # & & " 1 + & ,3 < &# & .& #' 9 , " $ + & & # + ' 9 , +& J"@ '-, + & K% & "( > ?+ # " # & & .& " " !")+ & & & )+ #
"( 1 + &
,## ,& # - + , + # & " 8+ 58 K% 68 K>C?+ & & ! & + # "( # & # 9 F ) !") " # # + & "( # & # ) J"@'-, , & 445 +6788 #
Qinyu Qiao et al. / Energy Procedia 105 (2017) 3584 – 3595
!")+ 7 ' 9 , &
) : + ## &, ## , ,& ## @ + & # "( # ) & F & M #, &# & .&+ + "( # ' 9 , &
, & K%+ , & # " $ + & & & ) !")+ & &
, # # & & & D & , & +#&
& $ & + #
# & " + & $ &# & #, , , " + L
3591
3592
Qinyu Qiao et al. / Energy Procedia 105 (2017) 3584 – 3595
!" & , J J & % - & # " 54C4+ I : J & % - & 7 & & G G & # # >? " % " & % J ) D 9 $ < < FG957 N57C >?"I &+01 #+10$ &+$DD& +$% # # & #& & <' # , # G 22' +6+65< 59
C
>C?"% + O @ ' # # & # &9 , <
# '##;# ' + +47<C59C5 >4?$@' +0"O+E$O ) ' #
<' #" E1E H& # D ) 22' +4++C9 >6?-( +@@& +@H
+" , +EH FF $& 9 9 9 # ## < & +"( + 22' ++7<7597 >?D $E' #" #
# %41, @ 9IF% & +E <D $E+ 7 >5? H 1 G + I % + E @ : &9I F+ $ 1 % " # #
8 ' $ '# ' +C+5<6C94 > ? ( ! " & & P$& , (!"$ E , ) & $ < <
>7?@ #! & !# 6Q & # & , & $ < < 4 64C6C64C66C656 6C656 7 4C5 >? % D $ " $ # $ I 9 9M @ # $ ) ##',2 +4+965C >?$I& K #
EH 9 < ' + >?" $& ! & $ ' 2 ! ' ' 2 %
+ >C? R % " $ & #
,# # & & &, &, D $
D += +4+494 >4?"@ +%' +*EE & # # # " " ###+4+ C6<69 >6? J I& & # % # " JI%" $& $
< < .& S T" >?! " " !""!""& # & $
< <
9 : &, >5?J D H# " JDH""
, # # & 4$
< <. F 4C 4C N4 5 > ? $ J ' , $J' E & E + H& + K @ 6$
< < >7?U1MH , & ,3 # & & & #
G " 5'' #'# #5+74+9 >?H0 +0"" +)'E +O%M +!@"' " # &
& # & " 8 ' !' , # +4+ C<695
Qinyu Qiao et al. / Energy Procedia 105 (2017) 3584 – 3595
>?11 +RE+ M1 E1E # & & & " <
22' ++<495 >? E R /+ 0 U R + U ' % + I ' &
, # &
, '"$!2 2' # ++4<496 >C? 0 ' %& + $ I& + @ M 9 &
, 9 # &# & < ' + >4?EO +%@ +HO +$- +0@ ' # & # EH < ' + >6?$I& + @M +RM&D
#EH 599 ) 9" @
< ' + >?1'I ' '2 # - +! +77 >5?*M " # & , , # @% $
D + ! # ' ++C69C > ?0ID&+'E +@I +@M +0%& @ # & + ,+
9 #9 # # & &9 , # < ' + >7?DR +'0 &+R0 3 +JD " , - $ #H # " !8 ' , 2' " # +4<4+94 >C? 0 M&,,G+ 1 "
& # " " # ! "##'+4+ 5<95 >C?*'&+-M&+M U % + U"M +I/ + " M ' # # , + 5 '##> +< 45+4C94 >C? % + % O + 0 " + H E& " F # & < , 7 #! ++4C<7C9 >CC?% +% O +0" +HE& ' # # 8 ' ! # ' +<5476<695
$ "% D1 1 D #$& + & K 1 & +
+ 3 #
%% & '%# ,M , 3 & , +#& "
!")<" @ 6
)<" @ 6
CC
C768 + 8
+58
& &+78 , + 7C8 +8&,,
68 +68 , +768
C8 +C8
+C8 & & &+68 +68&,,
4
66 68 + 78 , +8 & & &+8 + 48
3593
3594
Qinyu Qiao et al. / Energy Procedia 105 (2017) 3584 – 3595 CC
C8 +C8
& &+5 8
, 77
" & ,
68 +478
& &+ 8
, +C58&,,+C 8 +48
C7
4
48 +78
+8
& &+8 , + 8 +448&,,+8
I < & , 9 9 + + 3
65
747
C8 +58 & & &+78 , +68 + 8
+68&,,+48
,M & # #, + #& I + #&
!")<" @ 6
)<" @ 6
C
' 9 ,
8 +78 +578&#& +8# , +48 + 8
H
C
'-,
448 +68
, +8, +48
+C8 & & &+ 8' -+5 8
, + 5 8
, +78 +C8 +C8 +68 + C8 & +8 + 8
5
J"@,
-&
8 + C8
, +48, +48
+758 & & &+78 ' -+648
, +648
, +58 +C8 +8 +48 + 48 & +8 + C8
7
7
58&,,+CCC8
58&,,+CCC8
C7
C C7
, G
7
7
C
#&
7
4
5
C
#&
5
5
7
3595
Qinyu Qiao et al. / Energy Procedia 105 (2017) 3584 – 3595
C
C
ScienceDirect Energy Procedia 105 (2017) 3584 – 3595
! " # $ !"$
" % & ' #" "( # & # " ) " * &* +,+-&.& / +,+/ ' & +,+% & & 0 +1 1 +,2
!
" #$ !
) )+ 3 & "( + # " + & 3 .& # , & 1 + , # ) , #& + & $ # , #) " + & "( # & & # ! " ,& ) !")+ & " & "( # & # ) # 4 45 +678 8 # !")+ 7 ' 9 , & ) : + ## &, ## , ,& $ &# & .& #' 9 , & + & & #"( # )3 "
© 2017 The Authors. Published by Elsevier Ltd. This is an open access article under the CC BY-NC-ND license ; $& &, , ' (http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-nc-nd/4.0/). % 9 & , #!"$ Peer-review under responsibility of the scientific committee of the 8th International Conference on Applied Energy.
% < & =' 9 , = # = &
$ 3 + ) ) #& &+ " $
" + && & & #) 6 + &, 6>? #
#
# # "( >?+ & & + &# & + ,+& + + + @
& # & # # ## % #& ' # " ! '"! # ) & , 2" & <A 95754=# 3<A 95754 &' ( B & &
1876-6102 © 2017 The Authors. Published by Elsevier Ltd. This is an open access article under the CC BY-NC-ND license (http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-nc-nd/4.0/). Peer-review under responsibility of the scientific committee of the 8th International Conference on Applied Energy. doi:10.1016/j.egypro.2017.03.827
Qinyu Qiao et al. / Energy Procedia 105 (2017) 3584 – 3595
& >C? ' & # # & #
, & >4? ( 9 9 & # ## ## + & " >6? $ D $E
& ' # " $ '"$ # %4
+ & # ## , >? @ & & # &
& # : 1 +
"( # & # ! " ,& ) !") ,&
, & 8 #& # "( + & #
>5? $ & + # )+ "( # &
& # + F & &,:
& # & & & #& & ( +"( # & ## &# & .& $ & 3 & # & + # # & .& ! &,: + & # & "( # & " + & 3 .& # , & > ?- & + & # # G # & + & # G
"( +G
-
# +G9"(@0
@@
# +G
@-
# #&+@0
H
& #
# 2 $
,
I
,
I$
,
I"
,
-
#&
%"
.* * 2
3585
3586
Qinyu Qiao et al. / Energy Procedia 105 (2017) 3584 – 3595
& 9 9 + & & # + ,
&# & + &# & +, &# &
, $ - + # , + #& &
#& & & & F #
"( + & 3 + ,& ,& +&
& & F "( # & $ "(
& , & &3 +& +
& ,
- ) & , & #
.*.*3#'2# # !") ) ,: &
& #& &!6+ 4 & " + , & C & # @ + # + )+ , & # !")>7? ! + & & , + & G 9 F
, I9"
" # , # ) !") % # # " & + & & & # & + & $& % " @ $%"@ , ( G H J ' , >?+ 6 E & E + H& + K @ EH 96>?+ $ 3$ , -& + #
#, + #& $ 3$ ,( 9 , , !") )+ , ) ' 9 , , - +' -(4 '- ,
& , & 68 # " L , G 6+ ' J " @( J"@ ,
& # C78>? # & '- J"@ ,
Qinyu Qiao et al. / Energy Procedia 105 (2017) 3584 – 3595
,: M + # 9 F
, # !") ) - + G # #& & + & + , G#& #& + + #& .*4*5 .& 4 , # "( # &
I" %" I - H @@ @- - I$ I $ @- - C I$ $ I"A %" 4 M +
I" %" I - "( # & # ,
, #& G9"( = I$ "( # , G9"( = $ "( # ,+# , , G9"( = "( # & G9"( # # #& & #
& , # # & , , ,' # "( # # #& #&
"( # 6&!7.+586&!7.+69
D &
"
74
>C?
C46
>4?+>6?
J &
C6
>C?
" G
67
>?+>5?
H &
7C
>C?
E
>C?
D
577
>C?
I #&
>?
" G
444
>?
J < " G+ , #& G & & G & & & , & # ## +, + #& @
D &
I + #&
D &
%
> ?+>7?+>?
'-, <
>5?
!
> ?
'-, <
> ?
3587
3588
Qinyu Qiao et al. / Energy Procedia 105 (2017) 3584 – 3595 " & &
> ?+>?
J"@, <
>5?
M & & &
> ?+>?
J"@, <
> ?
" ,
>?+>C?
> ?+>7?
E
>4?
-&
>?+>C?+>6?
H&,,
>6?+>?
$
> ?+>C?+>4?
@ &
>6?
J < @ # & # ,
& & & # " - + & # &
& # 8 " >C?+ & & " -& + & G # & " + & # , & , , ,'&>C?+ >C?9>CC? %& >C? 4* *7 % , C "( # & ! "(
, & 4 ) J"@ , + 678 # !")+ , & 7 $ &, # ) '-, + , & 45 +8 # !") ,C"( # & "( G
" I "
% "
I
$,
!")
)9J"@
)9'-
I < & , 9 9 + +3 +
557
4C7C6
4C7C6
" & ,
45
66
66
76
46
46
54
466
466
57
57
' 9 ,
46
6
6
' 9 ,
5
-&
C
7 C
7 C
55
55
55
' 9 , ,
4
5
5
74
' 9 I ,
46
46
) ,
4
4
4
756
446
454
#"( # - !
,# & "( # ' 9 , &
& # , G # )+ , & 788# ) J"@'-, @ + "( & # # ) # !")
3589
Qinyu Qiao et al. / Energy Procedia 105 (2017) 3584 – 3595
- D #"( , ##
4*.*# ' ' 9 , :& , ) # # & # & "( # , & 3 # & , , # , &# & " + & & $ +"( # & #& , # , '- J"@ , - C "( # & # , , & , & + & # 4C6 C44G9"( J"@, 67C C 6G9"( '-, + .& #
& , G & , # &
- CK #"( # , &
3590
Qinyu Qiao et al. / Energy Procedia 105 (2017) 3584 – 3595
* *! 2 ' ' % && , G #"( # & # !")
)EH 96 & #
& + + K%+ "( # & # !") , & 4 # ) J"@'-, , & 4 >?+ & " ' 9 , & .& & - # +1 G "( # & # @ $9" !") ) J"@'- , & , & , # ) J"@'- & , & C4 "(9.+ & #!") & +6 "(9.>5? ! + & , ## & & ## &# & .&+ + ) &
& & "( *.*: #' @& "( & # & # ) !")# # " , , G # & ,
& , + "( # & # ) 678 # !")+
& , M + & # !") & "( & ## 1 + 3 ) G "( # & # )C8 # !")-& +
,# & & #,
+ & #& + & C 4 "( ) J"@'- , # !") & "( # ' 9 , & - + "( & # ) , & ' 9 , , *4*!7. # 2 ' $ & +) # & & " 1 + & ,3 < &# & .& #' 9 , " $ + & & # + ' 9 , +& J"@ '-, + & K% & "( > ?+ # " # & & .& " " !")+ & & & )+ #
"( 1 + &
,## ,& # - + , + # & " 8+ 58 K% 68 K>C?+ & & ! & + # "( # & # 9 F ) !") " # # + & "( # & # ) J"@'-, , & 445 +6788 #
Qinyu Qiao et al. / Energy Procedia 105 (2017) 3584 – 3595
!")+ 7 ' 9 , &
) : + ## &, ## , ,& ## @ + & # "( # ) & F & M #, &# & .&+ + "( # ' 9 , &
, & K%+ , & # " $ + & & & ) !")+ & &
, # # & & & D & , & +#&
& $ & + #
# & " + & $ &# & #, , , " + L
3591
3592
Qinyu Qiao et al. / Energy Procedia 105 (2017) 3584 – 3595
!" & , J J & % - & # " 54C4+ I : J & % - & 7 & & G G & # # >? " % " & % J ) D 9 $ < < FG957 N57C >?"I &+01 #+10$ &+$DD& +$% # # & #& & <' # , # G 22' +6+65< 59
C
>C?"% + O @ ' # # & # &9 , <
# '##;# ' + +47<C59C5 >4?$@' +0"O+E$O ) ' #
<' #" E1E H& # D ) 22' +4++C9 >6?-( +@@& +@H
+" , +EH FF $& 9 9 9 # ## < & +"( + 22' ++7<7597 >?D $E' #" #
# %41, @ 9IF% & +E <D $E+ 7 >5? H 1 G + I % + E @ : &9I F+ $ 1 % " # #
8 ' $ '# ' +C+5<6C94 > ? ( ! " & & P$& , (!"$ E , ) & $ < <
>7?@ #! & !# 6Q & # & , & $ < < 4 64C6C64C66C656 6C656 7 4C5 >? % D $ " $ # $ I 9 9M @ # $ ) ##',2 +4+965C >?$I& K #
EH 9 < ' + >?" $& ! & $ ' 2 ! ' ' 2 %
+ >C? R % " $ & #
,# # & & &, &, D $
D += +4+494 >4?"@ +%' +*EE & # # # " " ###+4+ C6<69 >6? J I& & # % # " JI%" $& $
< < .& S T" >?! " " !""!""& # & $
< <
9 : &, >5?J D H# " JDH""
, # # & 4$
< <. F 4C 4C N4 5 > ? $ J ' , $J' E & E + H& + K @ 6$
< < >7?U1MH , & ,3 # & & & #
G " 5'' #'# #5+74+9 >?H0 +0"" +)'E +O%M +!@"' " # &
& # & " 8 ' !' , # +4+ C<695
Qinyu Qiao et al. / Energy Procedia 105 (2017) 3584 – 3595
>?11 +RE+ M1 E1E # & & & " <
22' ++<495 >? E R /+ 0 U R + U ' % + I ' &
, # &
, '"$!2 2' # ++4<496 >C? 0 ' %& + $ I& + @ M 9 &
, 9 # &# & < ' + >4?EO +%@ +HO +$- +0@ ' # & # EH < ' + >6?$I& + @M +RM&D
#EH 599 ) 9" @
< ' + >?1'I ' '2 # - +! +77 >5?*M " # & , , # @% $
D + ! # ' ++C69C > ?0ID&+'E +@I +@M +0%& @ # & + ,+
9 #9 # # & &9 , # < ' + >7?DR +'0 &+R0 3 +JD " , - $ #H # " !8 ' , 2' " # +4<4+94 >C? 0 M&,,G+ 1 "
& # " " # ! "##'+4+ 5<95 >C?*'&+-M&+M U % + U"M +I/ + " M ' # # , + 5 '##> +< 45+4C94 >C? % + % O + 0 " + H E& " F # & < , 7 #! ++4C<7C9 >CC?% +% O +0" +HE& ' # # 8 ' ! # ' +<5476<695
$ "% D1 1 D #$& + & K 1 & +
+ 3 #
%% & '%# ,M , 3 & , +#& "
!")<" @ 6
)<" @ 6
CC
C768 + 8
+58
& &+78 , + 7C8 +8&,,
68 +68 , +768
C8 +C8
+C8 & & &+68 +68&,,
4
66 68 + 78 , +8 & & &+8 + 48
3593
3594
Qinyu Qiao et al. / Energy Procedia 105 (2017) 3584 – 3595 CC
C8 +C8
& &+5 8
, 77
" & ,
68 +478
& &+ 8
, +C58&,,+C 8 +48
C7
4
48 +78
+8
& &+8 , + 8 +448&,,+8
I < & , 9 9 + + 3
65
747
C8 +58 & & &+78 , +68 + 8
+68&,,+48
,M & # #, + #& I + #&
!")<" @ 6
)<" @ 6
C
' 9 ,
8 +78 +578&#& +8# , +48 + 8
H
C
'-,
448 +68
, +8, +48
+C8 & & &+ 8' -+5 8
, + 5 8
, +78 +C8 +C8 +68 + C8 & +8 + 8
5
J"@,
-&
8 + C8
, +48, +48
+758 & & &+78 ' -+648
, +648
, +58 +C8 +8 +48 + 48 & +8 + C8
7
7
58&,,+CCC8
58&,,+CCC8
C7
C C7
, G
7
7
C
#&
7
4
5
C
#&
5
5
7
3595
Qinyu Qiao et al. / Energy Procedia 105 (2017) 3584 – 3595
C
C