Scientia Horticulturae 121 (2009) 353–360
Contents lists available at ScienceDirect
Scientia Horticulturae journal homepage: www.elsevier.com/locate/scihorti
Development of the female gametophyte in the sterile ecotype of the bolting Allium sativum L. K. Winiarczyk a,*, A. Kosmala b a b
Department of Plant Anatomy and Cytology, Marie Curie-Sklodowska University, Akademicka 19, 20-033 Lublin, Poland Institute of Plant Genetics, Polish Academy of Sciences, Strzeszynska 34, 60-479 Poznan, Poland
A R T I C L E I N F O
A B S T R A C T
Article history: Received 9 December 2008 Received in revised form 27 January 2009 Accepted 4 February 2009
Manifestations of female sterility were investigated in a sterile bolting ecotype of Allium sativum (garlic). Morphological studies revealed interference during the formation of integuments around the nucellus and the lack of a micropylar channel and anatomical studies revealed disorders in female gametophyte formation. As the consequence of developmental abnormalities ovule abortion was observed. Finally, significant differences were revealed between 2D protein profiles of sterile ovules of A. sativum and fertile ovules of Allium tuberosum. Further possibilities of application of modern proteomic tools to identify proteins responsible for developmental changes in sterile ovules of A. sativum are discussed. Published by Elsevier B.V.
Keywords: Ovule abortion Megasporogenesis Embryo sac Protein Garlic
1. Introduction The ovule is the site of megasporogenesis, megagametogenesis and double fertilization. The mature ovule consists of tissues from both generations of the plant life cycle, the diploid sporophyte and the haploid gemetophyte. This structure is varied very deeply started from primordia initiation, specification, morphogenesis to cellular differentiation and seed formation. The intimate association of sporophytic and gametophytic tissues in ovule allows an investigation of their cellular interactions during ovule and seed development (Angenent and Colombo, 1996). Sterile female plants do not set seeds even after pollination with compatible pollen, and disturbed development of ovules, embryo sacs or pistil constitutes the main barrier to their generative propagation. In such a case the plant using high totipotency of sporophyte fragments propagates vegetatively by runners, tendrils, rhizomes, tubers, and bulbs. Such descendants of one plant form cloned lines. Since the genotype of plants belonging to a particular clone is the same, then all variability within its area can be examined as fluctuating variability evoked by environmental factors (Kamenetsky et al., 2004). Allium sativum (garlic) is an
* Corresponding author. E-mail addresses: winiark@biotop.umcs.lublin.pl (K. Winiarczyk), akos@igr.poznan.pl (A. Kosmala). Abbreviations: DTT, dithiothreitol; IEF, isoelectrofocusing; IPG, immobilized pH gradient; PAGE, polyacrylamide gel electrophoresis; SDS, sodium dodecyl sulfate. 0304-4238/$ – see front matter . Published by Elsevier B.V. doi:10.1016/j.scienta.2009.02.014
example of a totally sterile plant propagating vegetatively. Genotype variability among A. sativum ecotypes is not a result of hybridization, but selection of spontaneous mutations of important functional characteristics desired by breeders (Volk et al., 2004). Discovery of fertile ecotypes of garlic forming seeds in Central Asia opens new possibilities for genetic and molecular research on restoring fertility to this species. Due to that particular attention is paid to the study of morphological and physiological processes accompanying garlic inflorescence (Kamenetsky and Rabinowitch, 2001, 2002; Simon and Jenderek, 2003). Nevertheless, even the proper formation of female gametophyte does not guarantee seed formation because after fertilization endosperm or ovule formation disorders may occur as a manifestation of so-called postzygotic incompatibility (Vaughton and Carthew, 1993). Current embryological knowledge is quite extensive with regard to its morphology and ovule anatomy but extremely limited as regards mechanisms controlling processes responsible for proper morphogenesis and ovule maturation (Grossniklaus and Schneitz, 1998; Robinson-Beers et al., 2004). Ovule ontogenesis comprises several stages: primordia initiation, formation and morphogenesis, and cellular differentiation. Megaspore mother cell, which differs from sporophytic cells surrounding it in high polarity, plays an important role here (Grossniklaus and Schneitz, 1998). From this diploid cell four haploid cells are formed during megasporogenesis. The three of them undergo programmed death, and the fourth one undergoes megagametophytogenesis (Drews et al., 1998). Development of female structures associated with generative propagation depends on the activity of many gametophytic genes.
354
K. Winiarczyk, A. Kosmala / Scientia Horticulturae 121 (2009) 353–360
They control fundamental stages of female gametophyte development, such as nucleus migration, cell polarity, their vacuolization, and most of all coordination of all developmental sequences (Drews et al., 1998; Rudall and Bateman, 2007). Authors studying these processes emphasize that knowledge of this area is incomplete and often presented in the form of hypotheses (Grossniklaus and Schneitz, 1998; Siddiqi et al., 2000; Cnudde and Gerats, 2005; Dhar et al., 2006). Studying manifestations of sterility in female gametes is difficult because this phenomenon is often affected by pleiotropic genes, which may undergo expression at different stages of developmental processes (Kaul, 1988). The effect of fs recessive gene on ovule development and megasporogenesis was described in sterile female species, such as Agropyron glaucum (Orlova, 1991) and Trifolium pratense (Kazimierski and Kazimierska, 1995). Sterility in T. pratense is evoked by a pleiotropic gene, which is responsible also for shortening the perianth tube and style as well as meiosis disorders. In another economically important plant, Medicago sativa, after incomplete meiosis embryo sacs are not formed in ovules, and in sterile nucellus large accumulation of callose was observed. The consequence of such deep developmental changes is ovule abortion (Rosellini et al., 2003). Flowering plant ovules can die at various stages, at the beginning of their ontogenetic development or after fertilization and zygote formation. After egg cell fertilization non-balanced endosperm and embryo genotypes are often formed. A classical example of such reactions are interspecific hybrids, such as Lycopersicon esculentum with Lycopersicon pennelli and Lycopersicon chilense (Karihaloo et al., 1996). The aim of the studies was to compare 2D protein profiles obtained for ovules of sterile (A. sativum) and fertile plants (Allium tuberosum) to find the probable associations between ovule developmental disorders and changes in plant proteome. 2. Materials and methods 2.1. Plant materials The plants of A. sativum (bolting garlic) used for the study originated from natural habitats in the Botanical Garden of the University of Maria Curie-Sklodowska in Lublin. Vegetatively propagated A. sativum in the gardens collection were used for our purposes. Since there are no fertile ecotypes of A. sativum in the natural environment in Europe A. tuberosum were used as a fertile plant for comparison of protein content in their ovules. Plant material for the investigation of meiotic processes in female generative propagation organs of A. sativum were ovaries fixed from the beginning of June to mid-August. Anatomical studies were carried out on flower bud preparations fixed in paraffin or epoxy resin. Morphological observations were based on SEM images. 2.2. Light and SEM microscopy Cytological observations were conducted on fresh material A. sativum and samples fixed for evaluations in the light and the electron scanning microscope. Paraffin preparations were stained in the PAS reaction and in fast green and safranine O according to routine procedures. For observation in the scanning electron microscope, flower buds were fixed in a mixture of 2.5% paraformaldehyde and 2.5% glutaraldehyde in 0.1 M phosphate buffer (pH 6.9) for 24 h at room temperature. After two times rinsing in the same buffer the material was dehydrated in a graded acetone series (30%, 60%, 70%, 100%) and pure acetone. Immediately thereafter material was dried using liquid CO2 in a critical point dryer Polaron 7501 (Quorum Technologies Ltd.). Samples
were then mounted on SEM stubs with double-sided tape, sputtercoated with about 10 nm of gold and palladium alloy in a Polaron SC7620 (Halbritter, 1998), and studied in LEO 1430VP (Zeiss) with an accelerating potential of 15 kV. 2.3. Protein extraction and two-dimensional electrophoresis Protein extraction was performed as described by Hurkman and Tanaka (1986) and the proteins were finally solubilizated in 100 ml of the sample solution (7 M urea, 2 M thiourea, 2% NP-40, 2% IPG buffer pH range 4–7, 40 mM DTT). The protein concentration was determined by the using of 2D Quant Kit (GE Healthcare). Aliquots of proteins were mixed with rehydratation solution (7 M urea, 2 M thiourea, 2% NP-40, 0.5% IPG buffer pH range 4–7, 0.002% bromophenol blue, 18 mM DTT) to the final volume of 450 ml and used for two-dimensional gel electrophoresis that was performed according to Hochstrasser et al. (1988). In the first dimension, isoelectrofocusing (IEF), 24 cm Immobiline DryStrip gels with linear pH range 4–7 were used. Rehydratation and focusing was carried out in Ettan IPGphor II (GE Healthcare) at 50 mA per strip at 20 8C, applying the following program: 12 h of rehydratation at 0 and 9 h of focusing at: 1 h/500 V, 2 h/1000 V, 6 h/8000 V. After IEF, the strips were equilibrated for 15 min in SDS equilibration buffer solution (6 M urea, 75 mM Tris–HCl pH 8.8, 29.3% glycerol, 2% SDS, 0.002% bromophenol blue, 65 mM DTT), followed for 15 min with the same buffer but containing 135 mM iodoacetamide instead of DTT. After equilibration, the proteins were separated in the second dimension (SDS-PAGE) using 12.5% polyacrylamide gels (1.0 mm 255 mm 196 mm) at 2 W/gel for 30 min and then at 17 W/gel for 4 h. After electrophoresis, the gels were stained with colloidal Coomassie Brilliant Blue G-250 using the modified method of Neuhoff et al. (1988). Total separated protein spots on the gels were scanned by ImageScanner III (GE Healthcare) and subjected to LabScan 6.0 program (GE Healthcare) processing. Spot detection and image analyses (background subtraction, normalization, spot matching), were performed by the using of Image Master 2D Elite software (GE Healthcare). 3. Results Mature syncarpous ovary developed from three carpels that grew together and contained three locules, with two ovules developing in each of them (Fig. 1a). The flower bud after becoming fully developed remained still closed and anthesis never occurred. The style developed to reach the apex of the closed perianth, which was also reached by long, filamentous barren structures; at that time diameter of a mature ovary section was around 564 mm. All, both generative and vegetative, flower elements grew close to one another, remaining tightly compressed at all times by the surrounding perygonium (Fig. 1b). In a three-locule superior ovary of A. sativum usually two ovules of axile placentation developed. Young ovules were orthotropous, surrounded by two integuments. During ovule maturation the position of nucellus with respect to micropylar-chalazal axis to the position of campylotropous ovule changed (Fig. 1c). Each ovary locule usually contained two ovules but some anomalies were also observed. After examination of 120 flower selected at random, it was discovered that 67% of analysed ovaries contained six ovules, 16% ovaries contained eight ovules, and 17% ovaries contained from two to four ovules. The style developed very slowly and reached only inferior parts of anthers. Near receptacle edges, usually at the foot of the filament, there were long, barren elements growing. The style formed a regular column, covered by elongated epidermal cells. Its apex remained unvaried for a long time, and only when the pistil reached half of the anthers, the stigma began to develop. Average
K. Winiarczyk, A. Kosmala / Scientia Horticulturae 121 (2009) 353–360
355
Fig. 1. Preparations of material collected from 7 to 14 July. (a) SEM of the mature syncarpous ovary. (b) The longitudinal section of mature pistil. (c) The campylotropous ovule in locule of the ovary. (d) SEM of the dry sigma on the top of the mature pistil. Bars 10 mm.
diameter of stigmas of 15 pistils was around 101 mm. Mature stigma did not change its shape, and only glandular surface with slightly larger papillae was varied; the papillae were never covered by any secretion, so this was a dry stigma (Fig. 1d). In a young ovule integuments were gradually becoming larger, and in the nucellus an archesporial cell varied subepidermally (Fig. 2a). Initially the cell was isodiametric (Fig. 2b), then it gradually elongated along a micropylar-chalazal axis (Fig. 2c). There was neither specific pattern organelle accumulation nor substantial callose deposition in megasporocyte cytoplasme. Only in young ovules there appeared starch grains as PAS-positive globules. But there were few of them located mainly in somatic cells of the ovule at the foot of integuments (Fig. 2a). Cytochemical tests for the presence of reserves such as polysaccharides and fats showed that in A. sativum ovules there were few of them, apart from the ones in the integument area as mentioned above. In the apical part of the young nucellus small amounts of insoluble polysaccharides were discovered (Fig. 2b and c). Similarly colour reactions using Sudan IV did not reveal the presence of fats either
in young or older ovules. The size of mature A. sativum ovules was in the range 300–350 mm. Morphological observations in SEM showed asymmetric development of integuments. Internal integuments reached two-thirds of nucellus height, and the external ones were of similar length or slightly longer. During maturation ovules were gradually bending until they became anatropous. Integuments never reached the nucellus apex and never formed a typical micropylar channel. In A. sativum the embryo sac varied according to the bisporous type. In an elongated megasporocyte of tenuinucellate ovule there occurred meiotic divisions. After the first heterotypic division of megasporocyte a megaspore dyad was formed. A micropylar dyad cell soon degenerated, and a chalaza developed into an embryo sac. Apart from megasporocytes in this period the following was also identified: binucleate (Fig. 2d), tetranucleate stages, and developmentally advanced polarized embryo sacs which did not undergo cellularization (Fig. 2e). In older embryo sacs nuclei with strongly stained nucleoli were visible, but they always remained in coenocytic state (Fig. 2f).
356
K. Winiarczyk, A. Kosmala / Scientia Horticulturae 121 (2009) 353–360
Fig. 2. Preparations of material collected from 15 July to 15 August. (a) Longitudinal section of ovule with megasporocyte polarized along micropylar-chalazal axis. In cell cytoplasm lying at the foot of integuments stained starch globules are visible. PAS staining. (b) Tenuinucellate ovule of Allium sativum with visible megasporocyte in meiotic prophase at a bunch stage. PAS staining. (c) In the young nucellus polarized meiocyte at diplotene stage is visible. PAS staining. (d) Binucleate embryo sac of A. sativum. In the apical part of nucellus stained epidermal cell walls are visible. PAS staining. (e) On the micropylar pole of an embryo sac two nuclei are visible. The embryo sac is surrounded by shrunk ovule epidermal cells. PAS staining. (f) Micropylar part of an embryo sac with two nuclei with large nucleoli visible. Safranine and fast green staining. Bars 10 mm. (For interpretation of the references to colour in this figure legend, the reader is referred to the web version of the article.)
K. Winiarczyk, A. Kosmala / Scientia Horticulturae 121 (2009) 353–360
Anatomical preparations made from material fixed during clove formation showed early meiotic stages from young meiocyte (Fig. 3a), through dyad (Fig. 3b and c), and vacuolated binucleate embryo sacs (Fig. 3d) were visible. Finally, very few ovules had complete embryo sacs, and in flower ovaries collected in that period ovules were most often aborted. Degeneration began with cells located at the foot of integuments, and in consequence a large free space under the nucellus was formed. In degenerating ovules dead integuments and epidermal cells covering the nucellus were visible. At the foot of the ovule, when abscission layer is normally formed, cells were shrinking, which caused anatomical isolation of degenerating ovules from the parent plant (Fig. 3b and d). The analysis of anatomical preparations enabled the preparation of results in the form of numbers. For the studies on the course of megasporogenesis 86 ovules, sampled for fixing after 15 August, when the formation of an embryo sac should be completed, were
357
examined. Only such microscopic images which enabled identification of development stages were analysed and it was ascertained that in A. sativum for the whole study period the most common stage were meiocytes, which constituted 62.4% of all analysed female meiotic cells. The least common were megasporocytes during meiotic divisions, among which the cells in telophase were predominant—4.3%. Also other stages of a developing embryo sac were identified on paraffin preparations— 11.6%. Although it was the lying nuclei that were observed on micropylar and chalaza poles, no cellularization occurred in those embryo sacs. They remained in cenocyte state at all times and their further development was inhibited until ovule abortion. But it should be emphasized that also at earlier stages of garlic megasporogenesis the death of 21% ovules was observed. Megasporogenesis disorders, lack of a properly developed embryo sac and ovule abortion makes generative propagation
Fig. 3. Preparations of material collected in the period of spathe withering. Paraffin preparations stained with safranine and fast green. (a) In the degenerated ovule of A. sativum a well-preserved meiotic cell is visible, all nucellus cells, integuments, and funicle are shrunk. Large free space formed under the nucellus. (b) Degenerated ovule with withered integuments visible, well-preserved megasporocyte at telophase stage. (c) Anatomical image of megasporocyte during first meiotic telophase. (d) In the degenerated nucellus a binucleate embryo sac is visible, with large centrally located vacuole. Bars 10 mm. (For interpretation of the references to colour in this figure legend, the reader is referred to the web version of the article.)
358
K. Winiarczyk, A. Kosmala / Scientia Horticulturae 121 (2009) 353–360
Fig. 4. The 2D protein profiles for Allium tuberosum (a) and A. sativum (b). The common spots (matched spots) for both gels were numbered from 1 to 38. The protein spots without numbers are specific for A. tuberosum (a) and for A. sativum (b).
impossible. Since the disorders observed were very drastic, studies on the determination of protein profiles of sterile ecotype of A. sativum and their comparison with protein profiles of fertile species of A. tuberosum propagating generatively were initiated. All the 2D patterns within pH 4–7 range were highly repeatable and the obtained 2DE gels presented well-resolved protein maps for each species. Eighty two protein spots were identified for A. tuberosum (Fig. 4a) and only 45 for A. sativum (Fig. 4b). Thirty eight spots were easily matched between the gels and they represented the common proteins for both species. The protein extract of A. tuberosum contained 44 protein spots which were specific for that species as those spots were absent within the extract of A. sativum (Fig. 4a). The extract of A. sativum contains only 7 specific protein spots (Fig. 4b).
4. Discussion According to classification suggested by Heslop-Harrison and Shivana (1977) stigma in Allium is dry with developed papillae. This receptive part of the pistil is responsible for proper recognition of male gametophyte and initial reactions associated with pollen grain germination. Stigma receptiveness period is one of the most important factors determining effective fertilization. The structure of the stigma surface adapted for pollination vector and shape of pollen grains deposited (Yi et al., 2006) is particularly important. In the studies on sterile ecotype of A. sativum it was observed that the pistil stigma never became physiologically mature, which constitutes a serious obstacle for generative propagation. Stigma cells differ morphologically from other style cells but they never become typical receptive cells prepared for the deposition of pollen grains. The pistil in fertile garlic clones described by Simon and Jenderek (2003) was completely different. The style of these plants is longer than their stamens and perianth, and most important it is topped with a typical stigma, which is receptive for 1–2 days. In addition, the fact that the inflorescence of fertile ecotypes contains a lot more flowers contributes to the lengthening of anthesis from 5 to 20 days, which considerably increases the chances for the plant to be fertilized.
Lack of sterile ecotypes for the onset of progamic phase, i.e. lack of stigma receptive surface and anthesis, constitutes a serious barrier to successful propagation of A. sativum, and even makes generative propagation completely impossible. Synchronization of developmental cycles of female and male gametes is a fundamental condition of plant generative propagation (Weberling, 1992). In A. sativum already in the early morphogenesis large delay in ovule development and asynchronous development of integuments surrounding nucellus and lack of micropylar channel were observed. With a model plant Arabidopsis as an example, a close coordination during formation and growth of both integuments in ovules was demonstrated (Skinner et al., 2004). The greatest developmental disorders were observed in the organization of an embryo sac, which included in particular the blocking of its cellularization. On the basis of analysis of microscopic preparations of A. sativum ovules it can be said that the development of female gametophyte in garlic was inhibited at the stage of bi- or tetranucleate embryo sac. The presence of a heptanucleate gametophyte was rarely observed, and octanucleate embryo sac was never observed because no cellularization occurred. As a result of such crucial developmental disorders in both sporophytic ovule parts and gametophyte all A. sativum ovules were aborted, but at different stages. In the garlic ecotype studied no properly developed heptacellular and octanucleate female gametophyte typical for the representative of family Alliaceae was observed (Davis, 1966). During studies carried out in five vegetative seasons no seeds were obtained, and in microscopic preparations no fertilization signs were observed. Hence the conclusion that disorders observed in developing female meiotic cells of the studied A. sativum ecotype are so serious that they practically exclude fertilization. Inhibition of female gametophyte development during the first miotic division was described in Arabidopsis mutant marked hdd (Grossniklaus and Schneitz, 1998). Similar disorders were described in Arabidopsis ant-72F5 mutant in which no integuments developed or their initiation was much delayed (Moore et al., 1998). In another Arabidopsis sap mutant no embryo sac was formed, and in the sterile nucellus large deposits of callose were observed where an embryo sac should be present (Byzova et al., 1999).
K. Winiarczyk, A. Kosmala / Scientia Horticulturae 121 (2009) 353–360
Developmental disorders of female gametophyte were observed in Arabidopsis in salt stress conditions. Meiosis in these plants was normal with megaspore formation, but further gametophyte development was inhibited. Such a blockade was usually present in a binucleate embryo sac, and sometimes in a tetranucleate one, and consisted in that cells were shrinking and nuclei disintegrated (Sun et al., 2004). In sterile genotypes of M. sativa meiosis in megasporocytes was inhibited at zygotene stage with large cytoplasm hypervacuolization visible. In sterile nucellus large amounts of callose accumulated, and pistil development was inhibited, and at the final stage ovules were aborted. Flowers with sterile ovules had lighter perianths, which according to authors is correlated with physiological disorders of sterile female plants (Rosellini et al., 2003). One of the first visible signs of ovule abortion is callose synthesis in nucellus, around developing embryo sac. Ovule callose acts as a molecular filter and inhibits saccharide transport to dying ovules (Taylor et al., 1997). In sterile ovules of A. sativum no callose was observed probably because degenerative processes occurred very early and were so drastic that not even slight cytological changes could be observed on microscopic preparations. Callose synthesis during meiotic division of female generative cells occurs in an early prophase of heterotypic division. Its distribution around young megasporocyte corresponds to later location of functional megaspore in megaspore tetrad. The presence of callose wall around meiotic cells is very dynamic and its deposition changes quickly both in external and crosswise walls (Gabara, 1977). Callose envelope is nondurable and at the end of prophase it disappears on one of the apexes of polarized meiocyte. This is a pole index on which functional megaspore and then an embryo sac are formed. During megasporogenesis in megaspore tetrad callose or non-callose internal and external walls appear, which is one of the features differentiating the formation of female gametophyte in various plant species. After the end of meiosis, callose remains around degenerating megaspores and this is probably associated with apoptosis occurring in these cells (Rogers, 2006). The proteome is the entire complement of proteins expressed by a genome. More specifically, it is the set of expressed proteins at a given time under defined conditions. Proteomes are not only ‘‘genome-dependent’’ but they are also ‘‘environment-dependent’’ and they will vary with time and distinct requirements, or stresses, that a cell or organism undergoes. Two-dimensional electrophoresis (2DE) is a highly resolving technique for arraying proteins by isoelectric point and molecular mass (O’Farrell, 1975; Go¨rg et al., 2000). One of the main disadvantages of 2DE is that entire proteomes can not be visualized in a single gel. Cellular protein populations have diversity with respect of function, sequence, physical properties, and relative abundance, making it difficult to obtain the entire proteome. The method of protein extract preparation according to Hurkman and Tanaka (1986), used in the current paper, was shown earlier to be one of the most efficient way to obtain high quality 2D gels with low background staining. In the 2D analyses the composition of proteins in ovules of fertile A. tuberosum and sterile A. sativum plants was revealed. As two different species of the same genera were analysed some of the detected differences in the protein profiles could be the result of the presence/absence of species-specific proteins in the particular proteomes and not all the differences observed within 2D protein profiles between the species were simply associated with the ovule developmental disorders in A. sativum. Perfectly, the sterile and fertile (unfortunately unavailable) samples of bolting garlic should have been used for proteomic work. Moreover, the plant material availability was also a huge limitation of the current research, especially in the case of A.
359
sativum. It influenced the efficiency of protein extraction and finally the number of protein spots detected. The results presented herein could be the good initial steps for the complex research to identify the ‘‘differentially expressed’’ proteins within the proteomes of A. tuberosum and A. sativum by the use of the extended 2D analyses combined with mass spectrometry approach.
References Angenent, G.C., Colombo, L., 1996. Molecular control of ovule development. Trends Plant Sci. 1, 228–232. Byzova, M.V., Franken, J., Aarts, M.G.M., de Almeida-Engler, J., Engler, G., Mariani, C., van Lookeren Campagne, M.M., Angenent, G.C., 1999. Arabidopsis STERILE APETALA, a multifunctional gene regulating inflorescence, flower, and ovule development. Gen. Dev. 8, 1002–1014. Davis, G.L., 1966. Systematic Embryology of the Angiosperms. John Wiley & Sons Inc., New York/London/Sydney. Dhar, R., Sharma, N., Sharma, B., 2006. Ovule abortion in relation to breeding system in four Trifolium species. Curr. Sci. 91 (4), 482–485. Drews, G.N., Lee, D., Christensen, C.A., 1998. Genetic analysis of female gametophyte development and function. Plant Cell 10, 5–15. Gabara, B., 1977. Kaloza w komo´rkach ros´linnych w s´wietle nowych badan´. Poste˛py Biol. Kom. 4/3, 279–302. Go¨rg, A., Obermaier, C., Boguth, G., Harder, A., Scheibe, B., Wildgruber, R., Weiss, W., 2000. The current state of two-dimensional electrophoresis with immobilized pH gradients. Electrophoresis 21, 1037–1053. Grossniklaus, U., Schneitz, K., 1998. The molecular and genetic basis of ovule and megagametophyte development. Semin. Cell Dev. Biol. 9, 227–238. Halbritter, H., 1998. Preparing living pollen material for scanning electron microscopy using 2,2-dimethoxypropane (DMP) and critical-point drying. Biotechnol. Histochem. 73, 137–143. Heslop-Harrison, Y., Shivana, K.R., 1977. The receptive surface of the angiosperm stigma. Ann. Bot. 41, 1233–1258. Hochstrasser, D.F., Harrrington, M.G., Hochstrasser, A.C., Miller, M.J., Meril, C.R., 1988. Methods for increasing the resolution of two-dimensional protein electrophoresis. Anal. Biochem. 73, 424–435. Hurkman, W.J., Tanaka, C.K., 1986. Solublization of plant membrane proteins for analysis by two-dimensional gel electrophoresis. Plant Physiol. 81, 802–806. Kamenetsky, R., Rabinowitch, H.D., 2001. Floral development in bolting garlic. Sex Plant Reprod. 4, 235–241. Kamenetsky, R., Rabinowitch, H.D., 2002. Florogenesis. In: Rabinowtich, H.D., Currah, L. (Eds.), Allium Crop Science: Recent Advances. CABI Publishing, Wallingford, UK, pp. 31–58. Kamenetsky, R., Shafir, I.L., Zemah, H., Barzilay, H.D., Rabinowitch, 2004. Environmental control of garlic growth and florogenesis. J. Am. Soc. Hortic. Sci. 129, 144–151. Karihaloo, J.L., Chitralekha, P., Tikoo, S.K., 1996. Seed development in cross of Lycopersicon esculentum Mill. with L. pennelli (Corr) D’Arcy and L. chilense Dunn. Phytomorphology 46, 31–44. Kaul, M.L.H., 1988. Male Sterility in Higher Plants Monographs on Theoretical and Applied Genetics 10. Springer, Heidelberg/New York/Berlin. Kazimierski, T., Kazimierska, E.M., 1995. Cytogenetics, embryology and fertility of red clover (Trifolium pratense L.) with short flowers and anthocyanin spots on the leaves. J. Appl. Gen. 36, 353–362. Moore, J.M., Calzada, J.P.V., Gagliano, W., Grossniklaus, U., 1998. Genetic characterization of hadad, a mutant disrupting female gamatogenesis in Arabidopsis thaliana. Cold Spring Harbor. Quant. Biol. 62, 35–47. Neuhoff, V., Arold, N., Taube, D., Ehrhardt, W., 1988. Improved staining of proteins in polyacrylamide gels including isoelectric focusing gels with clear background at nanogram sensitivity using Coomassie Brilliant Blue G-250 and R-250. Electrophoresis 9, 255–262. O’Farrell, P.H., 1975. High resolution two-dimensional electrophoresis of proteins. J. Biol. Chem. 250 (10), 4007–4021. Orlova, A.M., 1991. Obtaining Agropyron forms without fs mutant alleles causing female sterility. Citogent. Asp. Genet. Selekcii Rastienij 1, 87–97. Robinson-Beers, K., Pruitt, R.E., Gasser, Ch.S., 2004. Ovule development in wild-type Arabidopsis and two female-sterile mutants. Plant Cell 4, 1237–1249. Rogers, H.J., 2006. Programmed cell death in floral organs: how and why do flowers die? Ann. Bot. 97, 309–315. Rosellini, D., Ferranti, F., Barone, P., Veronesi, F., 2003. Expression of female sterility in alfalfa (Medicago sativa L.). Sex Plant Reprod. 15, 271–279. Rudall, P.J., Bateman, R.M., 2007. Developmental bases for key innovations in the seed-plant microgametophyte. Trends Plant Sci. 12, 317–326. Siddiqi, I., Ganesh, G., Grossniklaus, U., Subbiah, V., 2000. The dyad gene is required for progression through female meiosis in Arabidopsis. Development 127, 197– 207. Simon, P.W., Jenderek, M.M., 2003. Flowering, seed production, and the genesis of garlic breeding. In: Janick (Ed.), Plant Breeding Reviews, vol. 32, Wiley & Sons, pp. 211–244. Skinner, D.J., Hill, T.A., Gasser, C.S., 2004. Regulation of ovule development. Plant Cell 16, S32–S45.
360
K. Winiarczyk, A. Kosmala / Scientia Horticulturae 121 (2009) 353–360
Sun, K., Hunt, K., Hauser, B.A., 2004. Ovule abortion in Arabidopsis triggered by stress. Plant Physiol. 135, 2358–2367. Taylor, A.A., Horsch, A., Rzepczyk, A., Hasenkampf, C.A., Riggs, C.D., 1997. Maturation and secretion of a serine proteinase is associated with events of late microsporogenesis. Plant J. 12 (6), 1261–1271. Vaughton, G., Carthew, S.M., 1993. Evidence for selective fruit abortion in Banksia spinulosa (Proteaceae). Bot. J. Linn. Soc. 50, 35–46.
Volk, G.M., Henk, A.D., Richards, Ch.M., 2004. Genetic diversity among U.S. garlic clones as detected using AFLP methods. J. Am. Soc. Hortic. Sci. 129, 559– 569. Weberling, F., 1992. Morphology of Flowers and Inflorescences. Cambridge University Press. Yi, W., Law, S.E., Mccoy, D., Wetzstein, H.Y., 2006. Stigma development and receptivity in almond (Prunus dulcis). Ann. Bot. 97, 57–63.