Available online at www.sciencedirect.com
ScienceDirect Procedia Chemistry 16 (2015) 149 – 154
>D5B>1D9?>1<*I=@?C9E=?>@@<95485=9CDBI *
6653D?6HDB13D9?>$5D8?4?>+?D1<<1F?>?94+?D1<'85>?<93 ?>D5>D>D9?H941>D1>4>D9213D5B91< 3D9F9DI ?6 '+%' #.'/ ,$$'!'+)# )89J?=5 )9>1>4B9I1>91+85<=1 E491D91*B9'E4:9B181BD91
1+!0',+),,"/'2'/',+#/#.!&#+0#.$,.*'/0.5+",+#/'++/0'010#,$!'#+!#/1/-'-0#(#.-,+% +",+#/'
+89CB5C51B3819=CD?3?=@1B525DG55>453?3D11>4=135B1D9?>=5D8?4EC9>7G1D5B1>45D81>?<1C1C?D?>D?D1< 6<1F?>?94D?D1<@85>?<933?>D5>D1>D9?H941>D1>4 1>D9213D5B91<13D9F9DI ?6 '+%' #.,$$'!'+)# B8IJ?=5 5HDB13D +85)8IJ?=5G1C 4BI542I?F5>=5D8?4 ?>6?B 8?EBC1>48?EBC +?D1<6<1F?>?94D?D1<@85>?<933?>D5>D1>41>D9?H941>D13D9F9DIG5B5 1CC1I2IC@53DB?@8?D?=5DB93=5D8?4 +85 1>D9213D5B91< 13D9F9DIG1C45D5B=9>542I496ECC9?>171B=5D8?41719>CD !'))1//1 0')'/ C1>4 /!.'!&'!,))' >13 D81>?<5HDB13D6B?=4B954 B8IJ?=5@B?35CC54 6?B 8?EBC ) 9>4931D54 D8525CD B5CE?94D?D1<@85>?<93 3?>D5>D1>41>D9?H941>D13D9F9DI +85I95<4?6D?D1<6<1F?>?946?B ) G1C 7 =# +85I95<4?6 D?D1<@85>?<933?>D5>D 6?B) G1C 7 =#1>4 D85I95<4?6 1>D9?H941>D13D9F9DI 6?B) G1C 7 =# +855HDB13DC8?E<4 1>D9213D5B91< 13D9F9DI 1719>DCC G9D89>8929D9?> 491=5D5B ?6 1>4 ?6C1=@<5C3?>35>DB1D9?>1B5 1>4 == B5C@53D9F5G89<5+859>8929D9?>491=5D5BB5CECD3 6?B 1>4 ?6C1=@<5C3?>35>DB1D9?>1B5 1>4 == B5C@53D9F545BB5C@?>C929<9DI?6)5C51B385>D5B6?B85=9CDBI >4?>5C91> >CD9DED5?6*395>35C Peer-review under responsibility of Research Center for Chemistry, Indonesian Institute of Sciences #53,."/ D?D1<6<1F1>?94D?D1<@85>?<933?>D5>D1>D9?H941>D 1>D9213D5B91< '+%' #.,$$'!'+)# B8IJ?=5
?BB5C@?>49>71ED8?B +5< 61H *')"".#// B9>1<9@9 7? 94
1876-6196 © 2015 Published by Elsevier B.V. This is an open access article under the CC BY-NC-ND license (http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-nc-nd/4.0/). Peer-review under responsibility of Research Center for Chemistry, Indonesian Institute of Sciences doi:10.1016/j.proche.2015.12.023
150
Rina Andriyani et al. / Procedia Chemistry 16 (2015) 149 – 154
B55 B14931< 1C G5 ;>?G 1C 1 ?>5 ?6 613D?B 3?E<4 @B?=?D54 =1>I 49C51C5C 1>4 1>D9?H941>D 9C 1> 9>D5B5CD9>7 29?13D9F9DI4E5D?9=@B?F5?EB851D9?H941>D 13D9F9DI31>251>17C5F5B1<=5D8?49 5 +)'+ &) +&* )' ?<<9>9?31?<93 CC1I 1>4 '' '' ?B 49@85>I< @9BI<8I4B1I< 9C 1 CD12<5 B1491< D 3?==?>F5CD971D9?> ?6 1>D9?H941>D @B?@5BDI +85 381B13D5B9CD93 ?6 ?H941>D B54E3D9?> G1C =51CEB54 2I EC5 C@53DB?@8?D?=5D5B 1D P >= I EC5 '' 1C 1>D9?H941>D 1CC1I D85 B54E3D9?>6?B=?6''B14931<2531=5''E>45B5<53DB?>DB1>C6?B=1D9?>=5381>9C=31>25=?>9D?B54 9>75B '+%' #. ,$$'!'+)# # )?C3 1C 1 619B37 1C C@935C 5CC5>D91< ?935>DB1D5C ?B 1C 1 4BE7 *9>35 D85 69BCD 79>75B 9C EC54 1C 1 =54939>5 ?B 85B2C 1>4 1 F1B95DI ?6 ?D85B @EB@?C5C 9>75B 31> CD9=E<1D5 D85 4975CD9F5 7<1>4 59D85B D? 1B?EC5 D85 1@@5D9D5 1>4 4975CD9?> 9>75B 9C EC54 1C C51C?>9>7 5C@5391<3B51C51@@5D9D5 CDB5>7D85> D85CD?=138 1>4 9=@B?F5C4975CD9?> +89C9C @?CC92<52531EC5 D85 =E3?EC =5=2B1>5 ?6 D85 CD?=138 1>4 9>D5CD9>5C CD9=E<1D54 2I 5CC5>D91< ?975B B8IJ?=5 9CCE54 +B149D9?>1<5CC 9CD? DB51DB85E=1D9349C51C5C 1CD8=1 CDB?;5 D??D81385 49125D5C=EC3<5@19> D8B?1D 3B1=@C 8I@5BD5>C9?> >1EC51 65F5B 1>4 9>653D9?> 1C54 ?> D85 C81@5 3?4 C9J5 ?6 D85 B8IJ?=5 D85B5 1B5 D8B55 ;9>4C?6 79>75B 1B5;>?G> >1=575B 79>75B B89>? G89D5 79>75B 1>4 79>75B 5=@B9D C=1<< ?B CE>D9 ?B B54 79>75B 5>5B1<75B CD1B38 5CC5>D91< ?9DC ?6 @B?D59> F9D1=9>C =9>5B14 5>JI=5C 31<<54 @B?D5?79219> +85=19> 3?=@?>5>D ?6 6B5C8 79>75B 9C 13?=@?E>4 ?6 8?=?7?EC @85>?<93 ;5D?>5 ;>?G> 1C 79>75B?< 9>75B?< F5BI E>CD12<5 9> D85 @B5C5>35 ?6 851D 1>4 8978 D5=@5B1DEB5C G9<< DEB> 9>D? C8?71?< *8?71?< =?B5 C@93I D81> 79>75B?< 9C D85 =19> 3?=@?>5>D ?6 4BI 79>75B >F5CD971D9>7 D85 25CD 3?>49D9?> 9> D5B=C ?6 =1D5B91< C9J5 C?D DI@5 D9=5 1>4 D5=@5B1DEB5 ?6 D85 5HDB13D9?> @B?35CCCD?@B?4E35?<5?B5C9> D8525CDB5CE?<5?B5C9>3?>D5>D?6 1>41F?<1D9<5?9<3?>35>DB1D9?>?6 1>4 D85EC175?65D81>?<C?D6?BD8B558?EBC1D1D5=@5B1DEB5?6 ?I95<454D8525CD79>75B?<5?B5C9> +855HDB13D3?>D19>54
?<5?B5C9> F?<1D9<5?9<3?>D5>D1>4 C?DB5=19>C G9D81 45F91D9?>9>45H 9>75B ?9< 3?>D19>C 79>75B?< DI@931< 1B?=1D93 79>75B 56693139?ECD?@B5F5>D 1>4 DB51D >1EC51 1>4 F?=9D9>7CE38 1C =?D9?> C93;>5CC ?B 9> G?=5> G8? 1B5 @B57>1>D D 17D85>C D85 9>D5CD9>1< =EC3<5C 85<@B5=?F5 9>D5CD9>1< 71C 1>4 85<@D85851BD6E>3D9?> > DB149D9?>1< C91> =54939>5 79>75B 9C EC54 D?DB51D3?<4C 3?E78C 491BB851 1>4 9>6<1==1D?BI49C51C5C?6 D85:?9>DC CE381C 1BD8B9D9C 9>75B9C19>7 ?6D852?4I D8B?E78CG51D *5F5B1<385=931<3?=@?>5>DC?679>75BCE381C79>75B?<C8?71?< 1>4 J9>75B?>5 31> @B?F945 @81B=13?7931< 1>4 @8IC9?7931< 56653DC CE38 1C 1>D9?H941>DC 1>D99=6<1==1C9 1>1<75C93 1>D931B39>?75>93 >?>D?H93 1>4 >?>=ED175>93 5F5> D8?E78 1D 8978 3?>35>DB1D9?>C +85 ?9< 5HDB13D 3?>D19>9>7C5C;E9D5B@5>5C@5391<7925B5>=?>?D5B@5>5C1>4?H949J54D5B@5>5C +85 3?>D5>D ?6 C53?>41BI =5D12?<9D5C 9> @<1>DC 79>75BC 5C@5391<?94C @85>??94C 1>4 5CC5>D91< ?941BI =5D12?<9D5C @B?4E354 2I @<1>DC 09>7925B13515 75>5B1< 9>8929D D85 7B?GD8 ?6 @1D8?75>C D81D 81B= 8E=1> <965 9>37 213D5B91 /!.'!&' !,)' !'))1/ /1 0')'/ 0-&5),!,!!1/ 1.#1/6E>79%5EB?C@?B1C@)89J?@ECC@ 1>4'5>939<<9E=C@ &EB@1@5B@B5C5>D5456653D?65HDB13D9?>=5D8?4?> D?D1< 6<1F?>?94 D?D1< @85>?<93 3?>D5>D 1>D9?H941>D 1>4 1>D9213D5B91< 13D9F9DI ?6 '+%' #. ,$$'!'+)# B8IJ?=5 +85 G1D5B1>45D81>?<G5B5EC541C1C?D
'<1>D=1D5B9145HDB13D9?>=5D8?4C +85 '+%' #. ,$$'!'+)# B8IJ?=5 G1C 3?<<53D54 6B?= ?>5 ?6 DB149D9?>1< =1B;5D 9> 1>4E>7 .5CD !1F1 +85 C1=@<5G1C?F5>4B9541DL256?B55HDB13D9?>E>D9<81C1G1D5B3?>D5>D2512<5 DG? ;9>4 ?6 C1=@<5C +8?C5 1B5 C1=@<5C G9D8 1>4 8?EBC 4B954 @B?35CCC 2?ED 7 4B954 B8IJ?=5 G1C 5HDB13D54 2I =# 5D81>?< 1C 1 C?D 9> 5138 41IC +85 =135B1D9?> =5D8?4 G1C 4?>5 6?B H 8?EBC $51>G89<5 6?B D85 ?D85B C1=@<5 5HDB13D9?> G1C EC54 2I 453?3D1 =5D8?4C EC9>7 1AE145CD 1C 1 C?D +85> D85 C?D?>D852?D8?6D85@B?35CC5CG1C5F1@?B1D542IF13E=B?D1F?B1D?B +85>?=5>3<1DEB56?BC1=@<5C1B5C1=@<5 5D81>?<5HDB13D6B?= 8?EBC4B954@B?35CCC1=@<5 5D81>?<5HDB13D6B?=8?EBC4B954 @B?35CCC1=@<5 G1D5B5HDB13D6B?= 8?EBC4B954@B?35CC1>4C1=@<5G1D5B5HDB13D6B?= 8?EBC4B954@B?35CC
Rina Andriyani et al. / Procedia Chemistry 16 (2015) 149 – 154
CC1I=5D8?4C +0',4'"+0//5 >D9?H941>D1CC1IG1C141@D546B?=*1B1F1>1;E=1B5D 1<
>D9?H941>D13D9F9DIG1C45D5B=9>54EC9>7 ''=5D8?4G9D81C3?B2931394*97=11C@?C9D9F53?>DB?4G1D5B1C12<1>; ?B1>D9?H941>D13D9F9DID5CD1 #C1=@<5 #''=7''9> =#5D81>?<@ 1G5B5144549>5138G5<<?61G5<<@<1D5 6D5B =9>D8512C?B21>35?6D85=9HDEB51C=51CEB541D >= +859>8929D?BI13D9F9DIG1C45D5B=9>542I,--9C *@53DB?@8?D?=5DB93=5D8?4 ,0)$)2,+,'"//5 +?D1<6<1F?>?941CC1IG1C141@D546B?=*1B1F1>1;E=1B5D 1<
?BD?D1<6<1F?>?94D5CD #C1=@<5 14454 D? D5CD DE25 ?>D9>E54 G9D8 # 1AE145CD # %1%& 9> 1AE145CD <5D CD1>4 6?B =9>ED5C ?>D9>E54G9D8 #<< 9>5D81>?< #%1& $1>4 #1AE145CD +8512C?B21>?6D85=9HDEB5 1C=51CEB541D >= )ED9>(E5B35D9>BED9>?C9458I4B1D5*97=19CEC541C@?C9D9F53?>DB?< ,0)-+,)//5 +?D1< @85>?< 1CC1I G1C 141@D54 6B?= *1B1F1>1;E=1B 5D 1<
*1=@<5 14454 D? D5CD DE25 1C # ?>D9>E54G9D8 #6?<<9> 9>1AE145CD%1 & 9>1AE145CD +85=9HDEB5 9>3E21D9?>1DL6?B =9>ED5C 1>4D85>D8512C?B21>?6D85=9HDEB51C=51CEB541D>= 1<9313949CEC541C1@?C9D9F53?>DB?< +0' !0#.') !0'2'05//5 >D9213D5B91<13D9F9DI G1C141@D546B?=*1B1F1>1;E=1B5D 1<
>D9213D5B91<13D9F9DI1719>CD !'))1/ /1 0')'/ C1>4 /!.'!&'!,))' >13 ?>35>DB1D9?>6B?=5138C1=@<5C1B5 1>4 9>1AE145CD CD5B9<<5 B956EDB95>171B & +85=549E=G1CCD5B9<9J549>1ED?3<1F5 +?5138 @5DB9 49C814454 #9>?3E 1D>=1>4 =#>EDB95>D171B=549E= >C5BD #5138C1=@<5?>D?@1@5B49C8== +85>@<1359D9>D?>EDB95>D171B3?>D19>C1213D5B91 0#.!,+0#+0//5 .1D5B3?>D5>D6B?=4B954B8IJ?=5 ?> 45D5B=9>542I851D9>7@B?35CCC1D LEC9>77B1F9=5DBI=5D8?4
'#)"+"30#.!,+0#+0,$".'#" %'+%#. BI9>7 9C 3?>C945B54 1C 1 3B9D931< 613D?B 6?B D85 @?CD81BF5CD =1>175=5>D 1>4 D85 =5B381>D129<9DI ?6 85B2C '+%' #.,$$'!'+)# B8IJ?=5G1D5B3?>D19>C>?D=?B5D81> +854BI9>7?685B2C9>8929DC=93B?291<7B?GD81>4 6?B5CD1<75C2ED1DD85C1=5D9=59D31>79F5B9C5D??D85B381>75CD81D16653DD8585B2AE1<9DI +85381>75C9>1@@51B1>351>41B?=11B531EC542IF?<1D9<5C?BD856?B=1D9?>?6>5GF?<1D9<5C1C1B5CE ?B 5CD5B96931D9?> B513D9?>C > 1449D9?> D85 4BI9>7 ?6 85B2C 9C ?6D5> 133?=@1>954 G9D8 D85 4CG8938=1I@?CC5CC1>D9?H941>D13D9F9DI1>4?D85B8517@B?@5BD95C 9B4BI9>79C 1DB149D9?>1< @B?35CCG9D8 9AE5 +?@B5F5>D29?13D9F9DI6B?=453<9>9>7D85D5=@5B1DEB5@B?35CC9C>?D =?B5 6B?= 5C945 D? @B?D53DC 6B?= 457B141D9?> ?6 D85 13D9F5 3?>CD9DE5>DC EC9>7 6B?= 7 ?6 D851B?=1D93@<1>DC1>4CE2C5AE5>DD5>DB5CE?EBCDE4I+125< C8?G54 D81D6?B 8?EBC 4BI9>7@B?35CCD85I95<49C G9D8CD1>41B45F91D9?> .89<516D5B8?EBCG1D5B3?>D5>D?6D85B8IJ?=5 9CD85?D85B@B?35CC 5HDB13D9?>D81D G54?>5?>D89CB5C51B38 +85I95<416D5B 8?EBC4B954@B?35CC9C G9D8CD1>41B45F91D9?> <<G?B;C4?>5DB9@<931D54 .51CCE=5D81DD854B954B8IJ?=5G893881F5G1D5B 3?>D5>D 9C >?D =?B5 D81> 9D 9>4931D5 D81D B8IJ?=5 81C >?D 1 =93B??B71>9C= 3?>D1=9>1D9?> 4EB9>7 1 CD?B175
151
152
Rina Andriyani et al. / Procedia Chemistry 16 (2015) 149 – 154
9783?>D5>D?6G1D5B31EC9>789789C=7B?GD8 &>?EB CDE4IG51CCE=5D81D D8525CDD9=56?B4BI9>7@B?35CC6?B79>75BB8IJ?=59C8?EBC +125< /95<41>4G1D5B3?>D5>D BI9>7+9=5 /95<4 .1D5B?>D5>D 8?EBC
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
+9=5?64BI9>76?B 4B95479>75B8?EBC
+?D1<<1F?>?94 7 =#
+?D1<'85>?< 7 =#
>D9?H941>D 7 =#
D81>?< 5HDB13D
M
M
D81>?< 5HDB13D
M
M
.1D5B5HDB13D
M
M
.1D5B5HDB13D
M
M
+0' !0#.') !0'2'05,$30#.+"#0&+,)#40.!0 ,$%'+%#.#40.!0 +12<5 C8?G54 1>D9213D5B91< 13D9F9DI 6B?= 5HDB13D G8938 49665B5>D =5D8?4C +85 DI@5 ?6 C?D 1>4 D9=5 ?6 4BI9>7@B?35CC79F5149665B5>DB5CE 1>D9213D5B91< 1CC1I $135B1D9?>=5D8?4C8?G54D81D5D81>?<5HDB13D6B?= 8?EBC 4B954 B8IJ?=5 @B?35CC 81C 8978D9213D5B91< 13D9F9DI D81> 8?EBC 4B954 @B?35CC ?6 B8IJ?=5 6?B 5D81>?< 5HDB13D .51CCE=5 D85B59C@?CC929<9DI31EC9>76B?=851DG85>4BI9>7@B?35CC6?BB8IJ?=5453B51C9>7 1>D9213D5B91< 13D9F9DI D? D89C 5HDB13D $51>G89<5 6?B 453?3D1 =5D8?4 C8?G54 D81D G1D5B 5HDB13D 6B?= 8?EBC 4B954 B8IJ?=5
153
Rina Andriyani et al. / Procedia Chemistry 16 (2015) 149 – 154
@B?35CC 9C =?B5 8978 D81> 8?EBC 6?B 5138 3?>35>DB1D9?> 53?3D1 @B?35CCC 9>F?7 D85 5HDB13D9?> +851449D9?>1< 851D@B?35CC9>453?3D131EC9>7@?CC929<9DID?9>3B51C5 1>D9213D5B91< 13D9F9DI +125< >D9213D5B91< 13D9F9DI >8929D?BI0?>5== C
HDB13D>1=5 D81>?< 5HDB13D 6B?= 8?EBC @B?35CC?679>75B D81>?< 5HDB13D 6B?= 8?EBC @B?35CC?679>75B .1D5B 5HDB13D 6B?= 8?EBC @B?35CC?679>75B .1D5B 5HDB13D 6B?= 8?EBC @B?35CC?679>75B
3
M
M
M
M
M
M
M
M
4BI9>7
M
M
M
M
4BI9>7
M
M
M
M
4BI9>7 4BI9>7
+85851D@B?35CCC9>5HDB13D9?>=5D8?41>4@B5@1B1D9?>4BIB89IJ?=5G5B53?E<425 9>635D?D8529?13D9F9DI ?6 '+%' #.,$$'!'+)# B?=?EBCDE4ID854BI9>7@B?35CCCD?75D14B954 '+%' #. ,$$'!'+)# B8IJ?=5D81D3?>D19> G1D5B 25D9?H941>D 13D9F9DI 1>D9213D5B91< 13D9F9DI D?D1< 6<1F?>?94 1>4 D?D1< @85>?< 3?>D5>D45@5>45421C5?>5HDB13D9?>=5D8?49>37D85;9>4?6C?D1>4851D9>7@B?35CC .51CCE=5D85B59C @?CC929<9DI D81D 3?=@?E>4 ?6 457B141D9?> I95<4 79F5 1 25DD5B 13D9F9DI .5 81F5 D? 4? 1>?D85B 1>1?6457B141D9?>?6 13D9F53?=@?E>46B?= '+%' #.,$$'!'+)# B8IJ?=525DG55> 8?EBC1>48?EBC 4B954@B?35CCC1>4D?1@@B?F5?EB1CCE=5
*1B1CG1DI-95>>15D1< >D9?H941>D13D9F9DI1>4D?D1<@85>?<933?>D5>D?65>4?@8ID936E>7EC65>>5<91>9F51 %))# **% & @:2C '1;9CD1>!?EB>1<?69?7931<*395>35C
$1D5C! $ 6653D ?6 1>D9?H941>D 5>JI=5C 9> D85 =?<53E<1B 3?>DB?< ?6 B513D9F5 ?HI75> C@5395C D?H93?7I +?HI3?7I $5B=5% 5D5B=9>9>71>D9?H941>D13D9F9DI #12?B1D?BI??4+538>?< %9B=1<1 %EB81C1>18 6653D 1>D9?H941>D 9> :5<; 6B?= B54 4B17?> 6BE9D @55< 1>4 B?C5<<1 D? *&+ 1>4 *'+<5F5< !?EB>1<?6D85*395>35?6??41>47B93E
1BD<5I ! 1>4 !13?2C 6653DC ?6 4BI9>7 ?> 6<1F?EB 3?=@?E>4C 9> ECDB1<91>7B?G> 79>75B '+%' #. ,$$'!'+)# !?EB>1<?6D85*395>35?6??41>47B93E1>941>8B9CD9>1.9>1BD9 "1>4E>71>181>;D96!18541>'5=1>611D1>>I11<1=941>7 "5C581D1> *D1DEC+5;>?791C9<'5>5<9D91>!185 <9 45>$ & +1>9B141> %5==1B *?=5@8ID?385=931<@81B=13?7931<1>4D?H93?7931< @B?@5BD95C?679>75B'+%' #.,$$'!'+)#,/!,#B5F95G?6B535>DB5C51B38 ??41>485=931< +?H93?7I
Q 5>I5B - ' !13;C?> $ #?1;5C $ ) <<9C 41> /?E>4 C?<1D9?> ?6 1>D9B89>?F9B1< C5CAE9D5B@5>5C6B?=79>75B09>7925B?66939>1<5 !%1D'B?4E3DC $9C8B1 ' C?<1D9?> C@53DB?C3?@93 381B13D5B9J1D9?> 1>4 =?<53E<1B =?45<9>7 CDE495C ?6 =9HDEB5 ?6 EB3E=1 >7179>75B1>4C554C?665>E7B55; >D5B>1D9?>1<!?EB>1<?6'81B=+538)5C51B38 8?9BE<>1= ;CDB1;C9?<5?B5C9>:185'+%' #.,$$'!'+)#;1:91>41B9E;EB1>2181>@5<1BEDG1;DE 41> CE8E !EB>1<'5BD1>91>$'+ **% Q *EB8/ ! #?541>! $ #55 85=?@B5F5>D9F5@B?@5BD95C?6C?=5@E>75>D9>7B5495>DC@B5C5>D9>B54 @5@@5B1>479>75B $ED1D)5C
154
Rina Andriyani et al. / Procedia Chemistry 16 (2015) 149 – 154
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
;G5>I5, % 1>4% % <571<1= >D9213D5B91<<13D9F9DI?6 79>75B'+%' #.,$$'!'+)# )?C3?51>471B<93 ))'1* /0'21* 5HDB13DC ?> /!.'!&' !,)' 1>4 )*,+#)) 05-&' >D5B>1D9?>1< !?EB>1< ?6 $?<53E<1B $54939>51>44F1>335*395>35
*1B1F1>1;E=1B 5D < F1 ?6 1>D9213D5B91<< 13D9F9DI @85>?< 1>4 6<1F1>?94 3?>D5>D ?6 /-#/' -,-1)+# 6