Nuclear Physics AS66 (1994) 69c-76c North-Holland, Amsterdam
Electromagnetic Sourendu
NUCLEAR PHYSICS A
Signals and Backgrounds in Heavy-Ion Collisions
Gupta a
“HLRZ, c/o KFA Jiilich, D-5170 Jiilich, Germany Aspects of the dilepton spectrum in heavy-ion collisions are discussed, with special emphasis on using lattice computa.tions to guide the phenomenology of finite temperature hadronic matter. The background rates for continuum dileptons expected in fort~~coming experiments are summa,rised. Properly augmented by data from ongoing measurements at HERA, these rates will serve as a calibrating background for QGP searches. Recent results on the temperature dependence of the hadronic spectrum obtained in lattice computations below t,he deconfinement transition are summarised. Light vector meson masses are strongly temperature dependent. Accurate measurements of a. resolved p-peak in dimuon spectra in present experiments are thus of f~~ndamental import#ance.
1. Introduction Electromagnetic probes of t,he quark gluon plasma have been surveyed extensively in the last few years. I will not repeat the material covered by these excellent reviews [I]. Since there has not been much development in the theory of photon signals since the last Quark Matter meeting, therefore, in t,he rest of this talk I will concentrate on dilepton signals and backgrounds. Recall t,hat mass spectra for opposite sign dilept,ons form a, continuum with conspicuous resonances sitting over it, The cross sect,ion is very closely related to a theorist,‘s favourite quantity-. the spectral density of a vector correlation function. All observed resonances correspond to flavour singlet vector mesons. With sufficient mass resolution in the spectra the fate of each such meson can be seen in the dense a,nd. possibly, t.hernlalised hot matter formed as a result of heavy ion collisions. The ease with which individual resonances can be isolated and studied by well-designed experiments makes the dilepton signal a tool which is neglected only by the most foolha.rdy physicist. The continuum itself may be interesting for various reasons, many of which have been reviewed before. I shall spend most of my allotted pages on scenarios which are built for matter in, or not far from, thermal eqL~iIibri~~~~.The ma,in reason for this emphasis is t,he ease with which theorists can do these computations; but, as reported in this meeting 12, 31, t,here arc model computations now which indicat,e a fairly short thermalisation times in heavy-ion collisions. Nevertheless, it is necessary to keep in mind that t,he dense systems formed may spend a significant fraction of their lifetimes t,rying to come t,o a state of equilibrium. If they succeed, they will be doing muc.h better than most people. Uptil now very little work has been done with non-e[~~lilibriu~~ scena,rios. It should be mentioned t,hat Shuryak’s t,wo-step thermalisation model [4] is an attempt at. constructing a toy model of non-equilibrium phenomena. Other such attempts are hydrodynamical shock waves and burning walls [5], Swiss-cheese inst,ahilities [6], etc. All these dynamical
0375-9474~4/$07.~
0 1994 - Elscvier Science B.V. All rights reserved.
7oc
S. Gupta I Electromagnetic
modes
can
siblc
be married
signals
However
it is known
densities
This
feature
heavy-ion
importa.nt
The
which
To turn selected
in models
Latt,ice
‘rhese
I sha.ll divide
and
a peak
in spcc-
system
[‘il.
may not, be seen in
experiments heavy-ion
peaks
of the should
Non-equilibrium
to guide
theory.
keep
statistical
watch physics
experiments
irlto two major
talk
regions;
mass
ca.n make
part,s.
elcnlrnts
l’he
work st,a.rtcd
I shall
point
in QCD
The
t)hc second
in t,hc next, two scct,ions. phenomenolog>T.
matrix Such
any
in various
are discussed
t,ool to compute
dilept~oils n~ay Ix ilsrflil as a probe t.o date
computations
therefore,
QCD
ma.trix
will be available
I shall
speak
region.
I shall
This
is the
a year
ago [8]
for thcrIria1
ma.ttcr.
thr
t,he latt,ice
a.rc usually and
will
a few
empha.sise
is that
which
first
with
is
obtained
is being
pursued
2.1.
Low
titative
attempts
cially
Dalitz
to extend
of a ferlni. quite
recent
A first
crucially,
High
mass
can
at tempcrat lat,tice
ures
est.imatcs
is now being
clone;
the
low
mass
GcV)
(MS1
mass
region
wit,h M~lO
GcV
a.nd the intermediate
is bounded
by the p and J/c’,
as t.hr very-high
mass
region.
continuum
bremsstrahlung to heavy-ion
There
collisions
[lo].
The
on properties
time
out to be close
hadronic
on
of t,hermalised
at, such estimates
bc obtained
masses, in lattice
t,o bc understood etc.
dependent turns
seems
from pions
low-mass
hadronic [ll].
widt,hs and interact,ion computations,
and
Such
spe-
number-
a
computations
strengths I shall
quart-
dilepton
matter,
to t,his yea.r’s favollrite now exists
in terms
have been
at finit,e
summarise
a
section.
continuum t,imes arc short,
pre-equilibrium
processes.
Drell-Yan
at both
T and
the lowmass pairs,
[9] in the next
if t.hermalisa.tion pairs
GeV),
of the region
att,empt
input
These
computation
Even
(Mk5
this picture
ma.y be sbrongly
temperatures.
This
of
theory.
the Y resonances.
if the thermalisation
fraction
phenomena
non-perturbative
at high temperature.
the intermediate
collisions,
processes-
spectrum
to obtain
All computations
IIrc perturba.tion
continuum
In ha.dron-hadron of several
for non-pert,urbati\,e
elements
speaking,
beyond
mass
in lligh tempera1
in the Ilear fut.ure.
a.lso speak
region
performed
be int,ercsting
of the high mass Rougly
resonances.
have been
give clear evidence
It would,
for the relevant results
the
physics
dilept,ons
computa.tions
signal
t,o ?:.
need,
is that
levels
pas-
dileptoils.
Continuum
(lontinuuill
2.2.
pliysics.
or perturbation
the t,hermal
mass
such
yielding
continu1lm
[9].
The
close
of funtlamcntal
energy
whether with.
thereby
yield
give rise to narrow
can
to t,hc equilibrium
ca.nnot. yet deal
wit,h continuum
a norl~I’erturbative
dynamics
nlodcs
here.
t.o concrete
resonances.
ion processes,
.411 these
n1ora.l I wa.nt to draw
~1ew branch
of lattice
product
t,hat one wonders
theories
contributions
be concerned
further
110 relation
so generic
collisions.
tlilcpton
phenomena.
rrorl-equilihriu~~~
have
seems
is a growing
2.
that
!vliirh
for phenomena
utility
to sl.andard
of norl-cqulibrium
tral
signals and backgrounds in heavy-ion collisions
J/T,!), there
The the LHC
could
the high mass continuum
very high mass and RHIC
be subst,antial
region
energies.
is expected At LHC,
contribution
from
cross section to consist
in the mass open
bottom
consists
essentially range
of of
between
production.
71c
S. Gupta I Electromagnetic signals and backgrounds in heavy-ion collisions
This
has yet to be estimated.
A state-of-the-art in perturhative data
QCD
obtained
Drell-Yan
[13].
since
cross
the
section
functions data Tllc
HERA
main
illcreasing energies
this
increasing growt,ll
r 5 lop3
has been
in [la].
It, should
nf,
hand,
at I,HC
2.3.
that
mass that
there
mass
is around
the extrapolated turns
extrapolation t,he range
come
the most, poorly
uncrxtainty new results of a fa.ctor a.t RHIC
then
then
0..5 GeV)
not,
effect
once
scales
s&ion
the
involved
cutoffs.
gencrat,ors
is a roughly
in the QCD (&),
Thus fi
Wit 11
from the
predictions
schemes
a.t. each
.5 units.
of this
sect.ions,
Wit,h
At, RIIIC
comes
Detailed
MonteCa.rlo
values
following.
a plateau.
to about
cross
of cross
Carlo
arc
predictions
ctc,
and
their
[.)I, on the other
absolute
normalisa-
sepera.tely.
be compa.red
As a result
bvith a proper
of 6.
continuum
comes
understood
part
from
a complex
of the continuum
thermal
out, that
at M
this signal cross
source
of masses
dilepton
t,he thern1a.l
M Z-2.5
GeV.
may bc visible
above
when
region
for a brtter
of higher
show that
continuum.
in t,he cutoff
The
mixt,ure
of
spectrum.
signal. signal
If the
vanishes
initial
It
If the illit,ial below
temperature
a.bove the same
mass
signal
this large
hrlow
t,his region
which
sufTers
is in t,he parton to .r z
Structure
background
resummed
at small
!5 x 10-l.
New physics
measurements rrgion.
pcrt,llrbative
uncertainty t,hermal
still
yields
signal
The
an uncertainty
to t,hc intermediate a much
now
A second
corrections.
I estimate
t.urns olrt t,o have thr
two mail1
of this
cont,rol.
results
from
luminosities
function
understanding
are under
Drell-Yan
thermal
Hence
order
these
into
corresponds
of kinematics.
extrapolating
energies.
scct,ions
of uncertaint,y of interest,
is in the import,ance of three
account
are the
develops
100 GcV.
a.re fitted
it. turns
section
will be crucial
mentioned and I,HC
do
of structure
have possible
into
A consequence
for the continuum
cross
in this
at, HERA
t,han the Drell-Yan than
region
strongest
int,o play
done
Monte
of Drell-Yan
.r.
being
these
(?(a:)
continuum
1 GeV,
The
may
beelr
full
[ 171.
ambiguities. At LHC,
region
These
section
in moment,um
of the dilepton
250 MeV,
out to be about
The
are no mass
at all relevant
Drell-Yan
even for M FZ .5 GeV
[16].
pairs
Ihr fiz.50
quantjil.ies
these
region
is also the most, important tempera.turc
occurs
paramet,ers
and data
is probably
well wit,11 have
measurements
the widt,h increases
Approximate
This
the
in Ihe l>,-integrated
are predictions.
int,ermediate
sources.
energies
on &?
Intermediate
The
cross
of Drell-Yan
normalisations
estima.te
is theoretical&
and must, be taken
absolute
it is necessary
Drell-Yan
There
In the high mass
tail in the p> .-distribution.
t.ions and ot,her such dimensional of this,
GcV
computed
extremely
[14].
performed
Thus
various
One
[15].
i\gcu.
contain
640
in the Aachen
cross sections agree
is experimental-
energies;
the increase
be remembered
dependence
sections <
of t,hc Drrll-Yan
of (~2,) wit,11 S which
from
advance
distribution
of tbc perturbative
given
fi
made.
have now been
features
at fixed
cross
U(oz,)
analysed.
is 3 unitjs wide;
growth
<
were
at LHC
the ra.pidity
&?,
linear
apart
second
sections
kinematic
&,
19.J
has now been computed
in the range
from
to say, these
estimates
The
of cross
for LHC and R.HIC was presented
of energies
last
the old estimates.
on estimates
of rates
were hased on exponentiated
Needless
in t,he range
two advances affect
computation
in 1990 [12]. These
Workshop
mass
range
steeper
slope
a small
dominat,es
error over
(less t,his
12c
S. Gupta I Electromagnetic signals and backgrounds in heavy-ion collisions
It should be remembered lhat the Drell-Yan process is only one of the rna,ny ba.ckgroimds in the dilepton channel in the intermediate mass region. At the higher end of this region deca.ys of heavy-flavour quarks give rise t,o a large tliiepton rate. Such a contribution ha,cl been pointed out by Shor long ha,ck. A minijet c~rrl~~llta~ion [19] for the process A $ N --f jet.5 -+ c(b) + lep%orzs,
(1)
shows &at one should expect, a large number of single leptons per event. These combine into r? large diiepton background. This is relative/y innocuous, since the rate for unlike sign is the same a.s for like sign pairs, and thus can be subtracted. A detailed Monte Carlo study is reportedly in progress [ZO]. M ore problematic is the background from the cascade decay of hott,om into strange with unlike sign pairs. This background also needs t.o be computed. At the lower end of the intermediate mass range the situation is even more complicated. The processes which contribute in heavy-ion collisions have probably not, been completely enumerat~cd yet,. NA3G has some new data which they will discuss in t,his meeting [31]. 2.4. The deconfined phase The continuum dimuon cross section in t,he deconfinctl pha,se is the signal for which the processes discussed in the previous subsections xe the ba.ckground. It is customary to comput,e this cross section in ~ligh-t,emperaturc perturbation theory. The Ja,tticc can furnish cross checks on this procedure. In recent years several studies of lattice QCD [22, S] 1iave furnished evidence that. the high t5empernture phase really c0nsist.s of &confined quarks. Thus the primary condition for perturbation theory seems LO bc valid&xt,he degrees of beedom are correctly idcnt~ified. However, t,here a.re indicat,ions that these clua.rks, under certain circuinstances, ha.ve A study [S] has clnrihrd this situation. For ma.ss scales fairly strong self-interactions. below the Debye screening mass, one could write an effective theory for t,he quarks in t,hc form
where I’ denotes a. direct. product, of spin a,nd flavour matrices, a.nd the sum is over t,hc whole set of such products. ‘I’hc ellipsis denote ncglcctrd terms of higher mass dimcnsiou. From lattice measurements ii, has been found IS] that, a~t,llo~lgll t.hc effect,ivc rouplings 9 in the scalar and pseudo-x&r channels are large, t,hose in the vector and pseudo-v&or channels are rather small alreatly a.t temperatures close to T,. Thus, t,his observat,ion implies that perturbative computations of dilepton and photon product,ion rates may he reliable quite close to the phase transition tempera.t.ure. A similiar compntat~iori iu unquenched QCD is now in progress. For 7’ < 1 .2T,, however, perturbation theory does break down. ‘I’his is reflected in the growth of all the effective couplings as one approxlirs 7: frorrr above. It may be possible to use lattice mea.surement.s to ofhili Lhe matrix elcirtent relevant t.o pltof.on or dilcpt~on cross sections. Such studies are planned.
73c
S. Guptu J Electromagnetic signals and backgrounds in heavy-ion collisions
3. The Resonances Beavy-quark resonances have been the subject of concerted study for the last five years. The situation is slowly being clarified; there is new and exciting data this year from the NR38 collaboration [‘23]. Lighter resonances have been studied in models for many years now, There is exciting news on these from recent lattice co~~l~utations. 3.1. Charmonium Based on lattice studies of the static inter-quark potenti& heavy-qua,rkonia have been suggested as a signal for screening. Sc.reening sets in at the QCD phase t~ransition and the screening length decreases with increasing T. Consequently, different resonances are suppressed to different extent under the same physical circumstances. This year’s result from NA38 [Z] s hows a strong ET-dependence t,o the relative suppression between the $’ and the J/g. The data is compat,ible with estimates given in 1241 as well as in 1251.
0.12
0
0.5
1
1.5
2
--
5.6
2.5
5.7
5.8
5.9
6
T/L
6.1
6.2
6.3 P
Figure 1. The temperature dependence of ($$), for quenched simulations with N, = 4 (filled circles) and S (squares) and from a 4-Aavour simulation with N, = 8 (open circles).
Figure 2. The temperature dependence of fT. Data for T = 0 (open circles) and at finit,e temperatures (filled circles) 7’ = 0.757:: (a = 5.9) and T w 0.9T, (a = 5.95).
3.2. The p meson Two recent studies of quenched lattice QCD have concentrated on hadronic properties for 0 < T < T,. One of these [S] wa.s done on N, ..- ? l., ” ices on very large spatial volumes, in progress [9] extends these computations to extending to (8/T)3, at OAT,. Work il.8 T,. In both these studies the values N, = 8 on spatial volumes of (4/T)3 of the quark condensate, ($$), p ion decay constant, fX, and t,he pion and p masses have been studied. The temperature dependence of these quantities is obtained by compa.rison with T = 0 mea,surements at the same lattice spacing. It is known that the quark condensate goes to zero with a discontinuit~y at T, in both the quenched [8, 91 and 4-flavour [ZS] theories. In Figure 1 we show the measured temperature dependence of ($$)(T)/($$)(O) (the T = 0 values are taken from [27]). Two features bear comment. First, note that the discontlrui,;; :I Z/ similiar ;n the two cases. Second, (~~}
seems to be relatively temperature
independent
up to T M 0.9TC-.
S. Gupta I Electromagnetic signals and backgrounds in heavy-ion collisions
74c
A non-vanishing The
physica.
ma =
quark
pion mass
condensate is obta.ined
implies
a vanishing
pion
mass
in the
chiral
limit.
from the relation
A,m,.
(3)
Here mq is the quark the temperature compared
mass.
to the values
to these
two facts,
T = 0.9T,. of [28].
Measurements
dependence
This
on the la.ttice,
decay
is explicitly 1 and
constant,
shown 2, mass
up to 0.9T,
&,
in Figure ra.tios
thus give information
Our mea.surements
at 7’ = 0 for tempera,tures
the pion
In Figures
of A,
of the pion mass.
shows
used
-0.01
0
3a).
with
on in A,
Consequent
temperature
upto
of [9] and the T = 0 data
the data
been
no change
(see Figure
no change
2, using
have
reveal
in order
to remove
0.01
0.03
most
lattice
effects. 0.4
-
-0.1
~
-0.01
I
I
I
/
I
I
!
0
0.01
0.02
0.03
0.04
0.05
0.06
0.02
0.04
0.05
m, Figure
3.
The
dependence
The
Measurements
a temperature
where
that
Within
there
emphasise
dependence
of the quark
condensate
sector say,
of the theory. the
of this
gluon
is usually other
so strong, information
data. This
a.ssumed.
Efforts
condensa.tes then
the
on vector
different
some
of these
to extract
the
of an universal
and pseudo-vector
spectrum the
Thus of study.
neglected.
condensates
mesons
t,heory
3b.
It is
at
sector
finite-temperatures
may not be justified.
temperature
is stronger
of at lea.st
of the glue
of,
interpretation
ha.ve strong
dependence
of
to the chiral
dependence
One which
and its
temperature
The vacuum
some invisible
the temperature
If the influence
chiral
at
at a temperature
theory. objects
often
temperature
masses
is discernible.
in Figure
a.lready
role for the glue sector
are now underway.
use
of the
models, other
a dynamical
no shift
visible
on the tem-
meson
of the hadron
condensates,
quantity,
compared
effect,.
is one of t,hc primary
phenomenological
imply
shift, occurs
models
aspects
is a secondary
is that
would
dependent
of the p meson
dependent,
in the vector in fact,
sees no temperature
by many
In most
condensate
lattice
dependence. these
is characterised
st,rongly
shift
of measurement,
chiral
(circles)
(p = 5.95).
t,o be quite
is very little
phenomenological
dependence
however,
spacing
temperature
of the theory that, most
temperature QCD,
seems
there
shift, in the mass
sector
be noted
mP on mq at, 1’ M 0.9T,
lattice
the errors
is a. large
a large
the chiral
It should
hand,
show that
of 0.75T,.
at, 0.9T,
However, interesting
at t,he same
of mp, 011 the other
value
perature.
m,
of (a) ma and (b)
at T = 0 (squares)
to data
0.06
than
a few of is indeed to obtain
S. Gupta I Electromagnetic signals and backgrounds in heavy-ion collisions
ISC
The variation of the vector meson mass with the quark mass mq is shown in Figure 3b at, a temperature T M O.QT,. For comparison the corresponding data for T = 0 at the same lattice spacing, ,!j’ = 5.95 [29], is also shown. It is seen that the magnitude of the thermal shift is dependent on mg. Thus, the maximum effect is seen for the F meson, somewhat less for the w and 4, and virtually none (a.t this temperature, at least) for any heavier meson. Of course, an accurate deterI~linat.ion of the mass shift of a state heavier than the inverse lattice spacing is difficult. It is interesting to speculate what the effect of differential shifts in the masses of the p, w and 4 mesons would be on an experiment like NA38 which cannot resolve these seperate peaks. An obvious effect would be to broaden this peak. Further phenomenology might be interesting.
4
6
8
10
12
14
16 z
4
6
0
10
12
14
16 2.
Figure 4.
Local masses for the (a) pseudoscalar and (b) vector mesons at, T M 0.9T, (/3 = 5.95) for m4 = 0.05 (filled circles), 0.025 (squares) ancl 0.01 (open circles). The estimates and errors are obtained by jack-knife. The lines a,re explained in the text.
We conclude this section with some technical remarks. The masses reported here were extracted by global fits t,o vector and pseudoscalar correlation functions constructed from local sources. The well-known oscillatory behaviour in the vector channel was suppressed by the usual stratagem of defining a correlation function on even sites G(2.z)
=
;[G(Zz
- 1) + 2G(2z) $ G(2z + l)].
(3)
Local masses were extracted assuming that this correlation function can be described by one mass, i.e., by a single hyperbolic cosine. The global fits were made to a two-mass functional form by minimising a x2 functional which took into account the covariance An useful cross check is to use the fitt,ed of the measurements at different seperations. function to then extract ‘local masses’ to compare with the direct measurement. Such a comparison then checks the validity of the global fits. Example are given in Figure 4. Acknowledgements: I would like to thank Ii. Eskola, R. Ciavai, S. Gavin, ii\. Irback, F. Karsch, B. Petersson, V. Ruuskanen, H. Satz, K. Sridhar and R. Vogt for the discussions and/or colla,borations, the results of which are reflected in this t,alk.
S. Gupta I Electromagnetic
76C
signals and backgrounds in heavy-ion collisions
REFERENCES 1.
P. V. Ruuskanen, J. I. Kapusta.
2.
K. Kinder-Geiger,
3.
M. Gyulassy,
4.
E. Shuryak
5.
P. Huet these
Nucl.
these
A 544 (1992)
Phys.
169~;
proceedings.
these proceedings.
these proceedings. and L. Xiong,
et al., preprint
Phys.
Rev.
70 (1993)
Mt.
SLAGPUB-5943,
1992;
2241.
see also the talk by K. Kajantie
in
proceedings.
6.
G. Lana
7.
Sourendu
8.
S. Gupta,
9.
G. Boyd,
and B. Svetitsky, Gupta,
Phys.
11. F. Karsch,
F. Karsch,
K. Redlich K. Rcdlich
12. Sourendu
HLRZ
Gupta,
and D. Rein, 13. G. Altarelli.
171.
E. Laermann
a.nd H. Satz,
and H. Turko,
in Proceedings
Vol II (1990) R. K. Ellis,
and B. Petersson,
Z. Phys.
C 52 (1991)
preprint
HLRZ
work in progress.
517.
19/93.
of the ECE’A-LHCA,
rtch en Workshop,
eds G. .Jarlskog
1174.
M. C’~ICCOand G. Martinelli,
14. A. G. Cla.rk et al., Aiucl. Phys. C. Kourkoumelis
U 285 (1992) 251.
22/93.
B 2SS (1992)
Lett.
S. Gupta,
10. J. Cleymans,
Phys. Lett.,
preprint
B 142 (1978)
Nucf.
Phys.
B 246 (1984)
12.
29;
et al., Phys.
Letl. 91 B (1980) 475; Rev. D 23 (1981) 604; Badier et al., Z. Phys. C 26 (1985) 489; Betev et al.. Z. Phys. C 28 (1985) 9; Albajar et al., Phys. Mt. R 209 (1988) 397: N. Brown et al., Phys. R,ev. Lett. 63 (1989) 2637.
A. S. Ito et al., Phys. .I. B. C. C.
15. R. Hamberg,
i%‘. L. van Neerven
16. L. Jiinsson,
these
17. J. 1. Kapusta, 18. A. Shor,
and T. Matsuura.
L. McLerran
and D. K. Srivastava,
19. Sourendu
I,ett. B 233 (1989) 231. Gupta, Phys. Lett. B 248 (1990)
20. K. Eskola
and X.-N.
21. NA36
Wang,
collaboration,
343.
Phvs.
Lett.
H 283 (1992)
145.
Sourendu
G. Boyd,
Sourendu
by G. Boyd collaboration,
F. Ka.rsch
302;
hTucl. Phys.
and
B 385 (1992)
E. Laermann,
preprint
in t,hese proceedings. these proceedings.
25. S. Gavin,
these
28. R. Gupta
67 (1991)
and F. Karsch,
Gupta,
and H. Satz,
27. G. Salinas
Kev. Lett.
Gupta
24. S. Gupta
26. R. V. Gavai
453.
these proceedings.
these proceedings.
et al., Phlw.
G. Boyd,
23. NA38
Phys. B 359 (1991)
Phys.
22. K. D. Born
port.ed
Nucl.
proceedings.
Phys.
Lett.
B 283 (1992)
439.
proceedings.
et al., Phys.
Lett.
and A. Vladikas, et al., Phys.
B 241 (1990)
Phys.
Lett.
Rev. D 43 (1991) 29. K. M. Bitar et al., Nucl. Phys. B (Proc.
567.
B 249 (1990)
119.
2003.
Suppl.)
20 (1991)
362.
481; HLRZ
54/93;
rc-