Report on Therapy Experience with “Cardioversion” Atria1 Fibrillation JAMES J. MORRIS,
JR.,
of
and Flutter*
M.D.,t YIHONG KONG, M.D., WILLIAM C. NORTH, M.D. and HENRY D. MCINTOSH, M.D. Durham,
North
T
HE introduction of direct current countershock by Lown et al.‘-cardioversion-requires that a new chapter be written in the treatment of cardiac arrhythmias. This technic consists of delivering an electrical impulse of high energy level through the*intact chest wall, producing a synchronized depolarization of all myocardial cells, and the subsequent spontaneous resumption of a more orderly impulse propagation. This report describes our experience with the technic in 70 patients with atria1 fibrillation or flutter. The clinical status and etiologic classification of these patients are discussed, as well as the success of attaining and maintaining normal sinus rhythm during the follow-up period of 1 to 9 months.
Carolina
been taking anticoagulants were continued on such therapy. The nature of the procedure was carefully explained to the patient. Nothing by mouth was allowed for 12 hours before anesthesia. No premeditation was employed. The anterior chest wall was shaved when indicated to insure adequate contact of the electrodes. Intravenous thiobarbiturates were employed as the anesthetic agent. The electrocardiogram was continuously monitored during the procedure. Following the procedure, the patient was observed until stable (15 to 30 min.) and then returned to the ward for two to three hours of bed rest. Thereafter, the patients were allowed activity as dictated by their basic condition and were kept under observation for two to eight days in the hospital. A Lown D.C. cardioverter (American Optical Co.) was programed to discharge a synchronized D.C. countershock during the downstroke of the R wave. In the initial 26 patients external electrodes three and a half inches in diameter were used. The electrodes were positioned at the apex and base of the heart (Fig. 1, A and B). In the remaining patients the larger electrodes,1 five inches in diameter, were employed and positioned on the anterior and posterior chest wall. The initial countershock was usually begun at 50 w.-sec. and advanced 50 or 100 w.-sec. with each attempt until the patient reverted to regular sinus rhythm or the. reversion was not accomplished with an energy level of 400 w.-sec. Intravenous thiobarbiturates, either sodium methohexital (BrevitaP) or sodium thiamylal (Surital@), were employed in all patients for induction of light
METHODS External D.C. cardioversion was attempted in 70 patients with atria1 fibrillation or flutter. The onset of the arrhythmia was determined by a reliable history from the patient or the earliest documentation from the referring physician or hospital records. In the patients with paroxysmal arrhythmias only the duration of the rhythm disturbance that was treated by cardioversion is reported. All patients were hospitalized. Digitalis was used for adequate control of the ventricular rate, and other therapeutic measures were employed to obtain the best clinical status and optimal cardiac compensation. Anticoagulation was not specifically instituted for this procedure. However, 4 patients who had
$ Designed by Dr. Bernard Lown and supplied American Optical Company, Buffalo, N. Y.
by
* From the Cardiovascular Laboratory, Department of Medicine and the Department of Anesthesiology, Duke University Medical Center, Durham, N. C. This study was supported in part by Research Grant HE-07563-02 of the National Heart Institute of the National Institutes of Health, U. S. Public Health Service and by a grant-in-aid from the North Carolina Heart Association and the Wynn Pharmacal Corporation, Philadelphia, Pa. t Work completed during tenure of U. S. Public Health Service Postdoctoral Research Fellowships. 94
THE
AMERICAN
JOURNAL
OF CARDIOLOGY
“Cardioversion”
of Atria1 Fibrillation
and Flutter MATERIAL
FIN. 1. version
The types of external are shown,
electrodes used in cardio-
as well as their manner
In a and b, the conventional
of application.
3.5 in. electrodes are shown.
In c and d, the larger anterior-posterior electrodes with their proper positioning are demonstrated. In actual use, with both types of paddles, the patient is in the supine position; the patient is erect in this illustration only to show the application.
anesthesia. Maintenance of the desired level of anesthesia was accomplished with nitrous oxide and occasionally with supplemental doses of thiobarbiturates. A nasopharyngeal airway was used in all cases. Succinylcholine was also used in the initial 22 patients. To evaluate the influence of succinylcholine, the anesthetic records of the first 38 patients were reviewed in detail. There were no differences in the anesthetic time or complicatio IS nor adequacy of the anesthesia with either sodium methohexital or sodium thiamylal. When succinylcholine was employed in addition to thiobarbiturates, there was no significant change in the adequacy of the anesthesia nor a significant decrease in the degree of muscular activity associated with the electrical discharge. The only discernible difference was a significant prolongation of the time of anesthesia from an average of 22 to 39 minutes. With further experience, in the remaining 32 patients, the anesthetic time with a thiobarbiturate alone was reduced to less than 15 minutes. In the initial 50 patients maintenance quinidine gluconate (Quinaglute@) was not instituted until the patient had reverted to regular sinus rhythm, except for the test dose administered for one to two days before the procedure to determine if the drug could be employed for maintenance therapy. In the last 20 patients quinidine gluconate, 0.33 gm. every eight hours, was begun three days prior to cardioversion. In one instance in which the patient was allergic to quinidine, procaine amide, 0.5 gm. every eight hours, was employed. Serum quinidine levels were determined fluorometrically.* After discharge, all patients were seen by one of the authors at periodic outpatient visits, the last being at least within one month of preparing this paper.
JULY
1964
Reversion of atria1 fibrillation or flutter to regular sinus rhythm with direct current countershock was attempted 94 times in 70 patients. Atria1 flutter was present in 7 and the remaining 63 had atria1 fibrillation. Twenty-seven of these patients had had cardiac surgery. Except in one case, cardioversion was not attempted until at least six weeks postoperatively. The age of the patients ranged from 19 to 79; 36 per cent were over 50 years old. The arrhythmia was due to a number of causes. Forty-six patients (66%) had rheumatic heart disease, 14 had ischemic heart disease and 3, hypertensive cardiovascular disease; 7 formed a miscellaneous group. Half of the patients had atria1 fibrillation one year or longer. Sixty-four per cent of the patients were included in the New York Heart Association functional classes I and II, 36 per cent in class III and 10 per cent in class IV. The first 25 patients had failed to revert to regular sinus rhythm during an adequate trial of quinidine therapy which required that the drug be administered in this hospital until the appearance of electrocardiographic signs of toxicity, severe hypotension, nausea, vomiting or diarrhea. Only 16 of the last 45 patients had undergone previous attempts at reversion with quinidine. RESULTS Fifty-nine tion
and
reverted current
ber
of
varied
patients
all patients
cessfully direct
of 63
with to
used
energy
from
50 to 400 w.-sec.
posterior the
level
placed
at
(Table
I).
during
the For
for
With with
apex
and
the the
example,
The
by num-
cardioversion of three.
reversion the large
less energy
than
suc-
rhythm
an average
needed
electrodes,
reversion
sinus
fibrillawere
(94%).
one to five with
The
atria1 flutter
regular
countershock
discharges from
with atria1
was
needed
small base
ranged anteriorfor
electrodes of the
at an energy
heart
level
of
TABLE I Energy
Level for Successful
WattSec.
With Small BaseApex Electrode No. of Cardioversions
50 or less 75 100 150 200 250 300 350 400 Total
Reversion
1 3 4 I1 6 3 2 0 1 31
Cumulative Frequency ($&J 3 13 26 61 80 90 97 97 100
of Arrhythmias With Large Anterior-Posterior Electrode
No. of Cardioversions 13 5 19 0 5 1 0 2 4 49
Cumulative Frequency (%I 26 37 75 75 86 88 88 92 100
Morris, ‘f-ABLE
Kong,
North
11
Follow-up of 70 Patients After Cardioversion No. of Patients
outcome
‘;/is .~-
Remained in RSR* Remained in RSR after initial reversion Required repeated reversion to maintain RSR Reverted to AFt following successful cardioversion Failed to revert to RSR
74
52
Totals
45
64
7
10
14 4
20 6
70
100
* RSR = regular sinus rhythm. t AF = atria1 fibrillation. TABLE
III
Follow-up of Patients Remaining in Regular Sinus Rhythm Maintenance of RSR in Follow-Up Period (mo.)
No. of Patients
%
Frequency ( % )
2 3 9 11 19 8
4 6 17 21 37 15
4 10 37 48 85 100
>8 7-8 5-6 3-4 >2 >1 Total
100 w.-sec. or less, could be reverted electrodes, whereas reverted with the ference was further
Cumulative
52
75 per cent of the patients with the anterior-posterior only 26 per cent could be This difsmall electrodes. demonstrated in 5 patients
and McIntosh
in whom both types of electrodes were used successfully on two different occasions; the large anterior-posterior electrodes required only one-half to one-quarter the energy needed with the small electrodes. The result of follow-up of these 70 patients is shown in Table II. Fifty-two patients (74%) were in regular sinus rhythm at the last followup visit. Forty-five of this group have been continuously in regular sinus rhythm since the initial cardioversion. The follow-up period (Table III) varies from one to nine months, depending upon the time of the cardioversion, but about half of this group have maintained regular sinus rhythm longer than three months. Two patients not placed on maintenance quinidine gluconate therapy were still in regular sinus rhythm at the last follow-up visit, five and nine months, respectively, after reversion. Seven other patients of this group had reverted to atria1 fibrillation once and 1 patient, twice; but as they had maintained sinus rhythm for at least one month, a second or third cardioversion was performed. At the last follow-up visits, they continued in sinus rhythm. The reversions of these 7 patients from regular sinus rhythm to atria1 fibrillation were all coincident with a reduced dose of quinidine gluconate or a low serum quinidine level. Of the original 70 patients reverted to sinus rhythm on one occasion, 14 (200/,) were in atria1 fibrillation at the time of the last fohow-up; 11 reverted to atria1 fibrillation within four weeks. Nine of these 14 patients underwent multiple attempts at maintenance of sinus rhythm with from two to six successful cardioversions; however, sinus rhythm could not be maintained despite maximally tolerated doses of quinidine, and in some cases, multiple drug
TABLE 1" Etiology of Atria1 Fibrillation or Flutter and Its Influence on the Maintenance
No. of Patients Rheumatic heart disease Mitral stenosis Mitral insufficiency Mitral stenosis and insufficiency Combined valvular lesions Ischemic heart disease Hypertensive vascular disease Congenital heart disease Miscellaneous Total
46
%
14 3 1 6 70
No. of Patients Remaining in RSR
66 19 8 5 14
of Regular Sinus Rhythm
34 27 12 7 20
% of Success 74
16 5 4 9
20 4 1 9
84 63 80 64
11 2 1 4 52
THE
AMERICAN
79 67 100 67
JOURNAL
OF CARDIOLOGY
“Cardioversion”
of Atria1 Fibrillation
combinations. Five patients had single successful cardioversions followed by recurrence of atria1 fibrillation. Cardioversion was not attempted a second time for a number of reasons in this group. Two patients reverted to atria1 fibrillation while taking the maximally tolerated dose of quinidine, and further attempts were not felt justified. In 1 patient urticaria developed after he was placed on quinidine maintenance, and when the drug was discontinued, he reverted to atria1 fibrillation. Another patient reverted to atria1 fibrillation at a low level of maintenance quinidine (serum quinidine 2.0 to 2.8 mg./L.); however, he was lost to followup, and another attempt with higher maintenance levels has not been tried. The remaining patient reverted despite adequate quinidine therapy (3.8 mg./L.). Another attempt is anticipated in the near future after maintaining a higher quinidine level. Failures: There were 4 patients (6%) who failed to revert to regular sinus rhythm, even when the maximal energy level of 400 w.-sec. was applied. These patients all had rheumatic heart disease with atria1 fibrillation for more than one year and were in functional classes III and IV. All but 1 had had a previous mitral valvulotomy. The age of the patients and the cause of the atria1 fibrillation seemed to have no significant influence on the immediate success of reversion or the maintenance of the regular sinus rhythm after reversion. However, patients with pure mitral stenosis or mitral stenosis with mitral insufficiency seemed to have a better rate of success in maintaining regular sinus rhythm after reversion than those with pure mitral insufficiency or multiple valvular lesions (Table IV). The patients in functional classes I and II could be more easily maintained in regular sinus rhythm than those in classes III and IV (Table v). The influence of the duration of atria1 is fibrillation upon successful maintenance shown in Table VI. In most patients mild eryComjdications: thema developed at the sites of electrode application. This was transient, 24 to 96 hours, and asymptomatic. Mild residual upper chest discomfort and muscle soreness occurred in about 50 per cent of the patients. The discomfort lasted 1 to 6 hours and was rapidly relieved by mild analgesics. Both the erythema and the chest soreness were related to the number and energy level of the discharge and were less apparent when the large anterior-posterior elecJULY 1964
and Flutter TABLE v
Functional Classification and Its Influence on Maintenance of Regular Sinus Rhythm Functional Classification I ,I III
Patients No. % 14 24 25
IV
% of Success
12 19 16 5 52
86 79 64 71
20 34 36 10 100
7
Total
Remained in RSR
70
TABLE VI Duration of Arrhythmia and Its Influence on Maintenance of Regular Sinus Rhythm Duration of Arrhythmia O-6 mo. 7-12 mo. l-2 yr. 3-5 yr. >5 yr. Total
Patients No. % 24 11 18 9 8 70
Remained in RSR
% of Success
21 10 13 5 3 52
88 90 72 56 38
34 16 26 13 11 100
trodes were used. Transient electrocardiographic changes-occasional premature ventricular contractions and premature atria1 and nodal beats-were noted in about 50 per cent of the patients during the first few minutes of the immediate postconversion period ; on occasion, the atria1 premature beats persisted for as long as 24 hours. Three patients developed mild laryngospasm during the anesthesia. There were five complications noted during these 94 cardioversions and in the follow-up period (50/,). One patient experienced a mild TABLE WI Comparison of Quinidine and Cardioversion Reverting Supraventricular Arrhythmias Criterion
Quinidine
Effective Safe (mortality) Speed Patient discomfort Myocardial depression Peripheral effect Physician’s time required Duration of hospitalization
45-80% l-4% l-7 days Moderate Yes Yes Days 4-10 days
* Can be safely done for outpatient.
in
Cardioversion 90-95 % 0% Minutes Minimal No No Hours 2-3 days*
Morris,
98
!Lic/lq, North and McIntosh
febrile illness with cough, leukocytosis, fe\.er and a slight pneumonitis probably related to Ventricular fibrillation was inanesthesia. duced in 1 patient coincident with an unexpected capacitor discharge, which fell during the upstroke of the T wave. This event was triggered by an artificial upward displacement of the electrocardiographic baseline due to a sudden movement of the patient. The arrhythmia persisted for approximately 15 seconds and was promptly terminated by a second electrical discharge with restoration of regular sinus no residual effects were noted. Sysrhythm; temic embolization occurred in 3 patients, an incidence of 3.3 per cent (3 of 90 successful cardioversions). One patient sustained an immediate cerebral embolism at the time of cardioversion. In the other 2 patients cerebral embolization occurred on the third and the tenth days after cardioversion. All were transient and left no residual neurological deficit. Two of these 3 patients had a previous history of embolization, which had occurred at least one year prior to cardioversion. None of these Eighteen patients were on anticoagulants. other patients with a past history of systemic embolization experienced no difficulty following cardioversion. DISCUSSION From our data and those reported by other groups, 3,4 it appears that over 90 per cent of all patients with atria1 fibrillation or flutter can safely and effectively be reverted to regular sinus rhythm by this method. Table VII compares the advantages of cardioversion with The successful maintequinidine reversion. nance of regular sinus rhythm after reversion depends mainly on quinidine or procaine amide. In the present study, we have attempted to maintain the patients on quinidine gluconate with a quinidine blood level of approximately 4 mg./L. (dosage has generally been between 0.33 to 0.50 gm. of quinidine gluconate every six to eight hours).j Fifty-two of 66 patients reverted to regular sinus rhythm (79%) have been successfully maintained with this regimen from one to nine months. In the first 50 patients quinidine was not employed before reversion, the drug being started In the immediately following the procedure. last 20 patients we have instituted quinidine therapy two to three days prior to the procedure with no untoward effect noted at cardioversion. Such therapy appears to avoid early recurrence
of atria1 fibrillation in the immediate postcardioversion period. In this study, digitalization was employed for optimal control of rapid ventricular rates prior to cardioversion. However, it is not necessary if restoration of normal sinus rhythm is immediately indicated for other reasons. After the patient was reverted to regular sinus rhythm, maintenance digitalization was continued in the eventuality of recurrence of atria1 fibrillation (21 y0 in this series). The anticipated gains from the restoration of normal sinus rhythm are: (1) a lessening of the incidence of systemic embolization; (2) control of inappropriate response of the ventricular rate to exercise;6 (3) improvement in cardiac function;’ and (4) removal of subjective awareness of palpitation. The last point needs no clarification. That embolization might be decreased is suggested by the statistical difference in embolic episodes occurring in patients with regular sinus rhythm and those in atria1 fibriI1ation.s The change of cardiac function rests on the well known clinical observation of improvement of cardiac compensation following restoration of sinus rhythm in some patients and a 26 per cent increase in cardiac output observed in this laboratory in a small series of patients after cardioversion.g Selection of patients for cardioversion is a problem which will require experience to define correctly. Some of the former criteria for selecting patients for restorationsa’0 and maintenance of sinus rhythm are no longer applicable. In this series there are patients with long term fibrillation (over 15 yr.), severe cardiac decompensation (class IV), and severe valvular disease (aortic and mitral) who were restored to and maintained in sinus rhythm. A previous history of quinidine failure in reversion of arrhythmias is not a contraindication for cardioversion. As demonstrated in this study, 38 of 41 quinidine failures (93%) were successfully reverted to regular sinus rhythm, and 26 (649i’,) have been maintained in regular sinus rhythm after reversion. These observations demonstrated that the ability of quinidine to maintain regular sinus rhythm, once it is established, does not appear to be related to its ability to revert the arrhythmia. Several situations do not appear to indicate the immediate use of cardioversion. Atria1 fibrillation occurring in the course of acute myocardial infarction tends to be self-limiting and, unless there are other considerations, cardioTHE AMERICAN JOURNALOF CARDIOLOGY
“Cardioversion”
of Atria1
version is not indicated in the first several weeks. Because of the danger of dislodging an atria1 avoided cardioversion thromhus, we have within eight weeks of a known episode of embolization. Atria1 fibrillation occurring in the course of digitalis intoxication is treated by removal of the drug. However, if the rapid rate is contributing to decompensation, cardioversion does not appear contraindicated. In patients with thyrotoxicosis the ventricular rate is controlled with digitalis and antithyroid medication until the patient is euthyroid. When surgical intervention is anticipated in the immediate future for patients with mitral stenosis, cardioversion is deferred until at least six weeks after surgery. Some patients with ischemic heart disease are actually benefited by atria1 fibrillation because of the slow ventricular rate associated with it which cannot be obtained when they are in sinus rhythm. Emergency Indications: Cardioversion for atria1 arrhythmias is helpful in three emergency First, supraventricular tachycardia situations. associated with acute myocardial infarction may not always be controlled with digitalization and other supportive measures; in this case cardioversion may reverse the worsening clinical situation. We have encountered two such occasions. In both instances cardioversion successfully and promptly restored the cardiac rhythm and blood pressure to normal with dramatic improvement of the clinical status. Secondly, when the electrocardiographic differentiation of supraventricular versus ventricular tachycardia is difficult or impossible, cardioversion instead of drug therapy can be employed with safety, since it is effective in either rhythm disturbance. Third, during the treatment of supraventricular tachycardia, when the difficulty arises of determining if the patient is or overdigitalized, cardioversion can underbe used, and the error of further intoxicating an already overdigitalized patient can be avoided. The serious complications encountered have been small in number. One of the major risks is that due to anesthesia. We attribute the infrequent complications to adhering to periods of brief and light anesthesia. With experience we have found it possible to use even lighter anesthesia (analgesia) of brief duration (less than 5 min.). The second major danger is that of embolization. The 3 per cent incidence in this series is comparable to or higher than that encountered with quinidine conversion of atria1 fibrillation.lo The value of anticoagulaJULY
1964
Fibrillation
and Flutter
tion in reducing this figure is unsettled. This problem is currently under investigation. For predicting the success of maintain&< regular sinus rhythm after cardioversion, certain observations seem worthy of comment. Age of the patients, 19 years to 80 years, does not seem to be important in determining whether regular sinus rhythm may be maintained. The type of cardiac disease does not appear to be an important determinant. Successful maintenance of regular sinus rhythm is not significantly different for rheumatic heart disease (74$&,), ischemic heart disease (79oj,) and hypertensive cardiovascular disease (67%). The type of valvular disease does appear to be important. Maintenance is more successful in pure mitral stenosis (84%) than in mitral insufficiency or multiple valvular involvement (647&). The duration of atria1 fibrillation also seems to influence the results of successful maintenance of sinus rhythm. For example, when atria1 fibrillation was less than two years in duration reversion and maintenance of regular sinus rhythm was possible in 83 per cent of cases, while in those with atria1 fibrillation for more than three in years, only 47 per cent were maintained regular sinus rhythm. The most reliable sign indicating ultimate failure of maintenance of sinus rhythm has been the prompt recurrence of atria1 fibrillation in the first month following successful cardioversion despite adequate quinidine therapy. Multiple attempts at maintaining sinus rhythm are not indicated once a patient has on two occasions reverted to atria1 fibrillation in the early postconversion period. &MMARY
Synchronized direct current countershock, “cardioversion,” was used in 70 patients on 94 occasions for reversion of atria1 fibrillation or flutter. The method and anesthetic technics are described. A modification of the size and location of the electrode has decreased the incidence of minor discomfort resulting from the procedure and lowered the amount of energy necessary for successful cardioversion. In 90 of 94 episodes, or in 66 of 70 patients, the arrhythmia was restored to sinus rhythm. With a follow-up period of from 1 to 9 months, 52 of 66 patients (79%) remained in sinus rhythm. Fourteen patients (21%) reverted to atria1 fibrillation despite multiple cardioversions and maximally tolerated quinidine therapy. Certain factors appear to decrease the chances duration of of maintaining sinus rhythm:
100
Morris,
Kong,
North
fibrillation, type of valvular lesion, functional classification and previous quinidine failure. The advantages anticipated with the restoration of sinus rhythm are discussed. The emergency indication and contraindications are outlined. A broad policy of selection of patients for cardioversion is suggested. The reasons for this approach are the high degree of acute success (94%), the low incidence of complications (5ojo) and SUCCESS in maintaining sinus rhythm (79yO) for a short follow-up period. REFERENCES 1.
AMARASINGHAM,R., NEUMAN, J. and BERKOVITZ, B. U. Use of synchronized direct current countershock in treatment of cardiac arrhythmias. Presented at 54th Annual Meeting of American Society for Clinical Investigation, Atlantic City, N. J., April 30, 1962. 2. LINENTHAL,A. J., ULICK, S. and PATTERSON,L. A. Fluorometric measurement of plasma quinidine aid its coIrzlation with clinical effects in man. J. C/in. Invest., 26: 1188, 1947. 3. LOWN, B., PERLROTH, M. G., KAIDBAY, S., ABE, T. “Cardioversion” of atria1 and HARKEN, D. E. New En,&md J. Med., 269: 325, fibrillation. 1963. LOWN,
B.;
and
McIntosh
4. ( )K.AN. S.. DAVIES. J. P., WEINBKEN, I. and TAGGAR.I., P. Conversion of atria1 fibrillation to sinus rhythm by direct current shock. Lancet, 2: 159, 1963. .5. SOKOL.OM., M. and BALL, R. F. Factors influencing conversion of chronic atria1 fibrillation with special reference to serum quinidine concentration. Cwculation, 14: 568, 1956. 6. WETHERBEE,D. G., BROWN, M. G. and HOLEMAN, D. Ventricular rate response following exercise during atria1 fibrillation and after conversion to normal sinus rhythm. Am. J. M. SC., 223: 667, 1952. 7. GILBERT, R., EICH, R. H., SMULYAN,H., KEIGHLEY, J. and AUCHINCLOSS, J. H. Effect on circulation of conversion of atria1 fibrillation to sinus rhythm. Circulation, 21: 1079, 1963. 8. DALEY, R., MATTINGLY, T. W., HOLT, C. L., BLAND, E. F. and WHITE, P. D. Systemic arterial embolization in rheumatic heart disease. Am. Heart J., 42: 566, 1951. 9. MORRIS, J. J., JR., ENTMAN, M., THOMPSON, H. K., WORTH, W. C. and MCINTOSH, H. D. Cardiac output in atria1 fibrillation and sinus rhythm. Circulation, 28: 772, 1963. 10. GOLDMAN, M. J. Management of chronic atria1 fibrillation: Indications for and methods of conversion to sinus rhythm. Prog. Cardiovas. Dis., 2: 465, 1960.
THE AMERICAN JOURNAL OF CARDIOLOGY