Gene, 146(1994)297-301 0 1994 Elsevier Science B.V. All rights reserved.
297
0378-l 119/94/$07.00
GENE 08072
Gene expression, purification and characterization neutrophil collagenase
of recombinant human
MMP-8; recombinant DNA; prokaryotic expression; inclusion bodies)
(Metalloprotease;
Thau F. Hoa, M. Walid Qoronfleha, Robert C. Wahlb, Tricia A. Pulvinob, Karen J. Vavra”, Joe Falvoc, Tracey M. Banksa, Patricia G. Brakea and Richard B. Ciccarelli” Departments ofaMolecular Biology, and bEnzymology, Sterling Winthrop Pharmaceuticals Research Division, Collegeville, PA 19426-0900, USA. Tel. (I -610) 983-7146; and ‘Eastman Kodak Company, Rochester, NY 14650-2158, USA. Tel. ( l-71 6) 588-0735 Received by G.P. Livi: 21 September
1993; Revised/Accepted:
22 March/l
April 1994; Received at publishers:
5 May 1994
SUMMARY
Human neutrophil collagenase (HNC) is a member of a family of matrix metalloproteinases (MMP). HNC is capable of cleaving all three a-chains of types I, II and III collagens. In rheumatoid and osteo-arthritis, MMP members have been implicated in the pathology associated with these diseases due to the accelerated breakdown of the extracellular matrix of articular cartilage. A cDNA coding for the HNC catalytic domain (lacking both the propeptide and C-terminal fragments) was sub-cloned into the pETlla prokaryotic expression vector. The cloned fragment encodes a protein that extends from amino acids (aa) Met”’ through Gly 262of the full-length proenzyme, which as a result, would not require proteolytic or chemical activation. The HNC construct was expressed in Escherichia coli and recombinant mature, truncated neutrophil collagenase (re-mNC-t) was produced at high levels (approx. 30% of total bacterial protein). The re-mNC-t protein was extracted from inclusion bodies by solubilization in 6 M urea, followed by ion-exchange chromatography. The protein was refolded to an active conformation in the presence of Ca2+ and Zn2+. A final purification step on size-exclusion chromatography yielded 30 mg per liter of active re-mNC-t with minor autodegradative products. Alternatively, hydroxamate affinity chromatography was used to obtain pure, non-degraded re-mNC-t (20-25 mg per liter). The catalytic activity of re-mNC-t was abolished by known MMP inhibitors and the Ki measurement against actinonin was similar to that of HNC prepared from human blood.
INTRODUCTION
Enzymes in the matrix metalloproteinase (MMP) family are secreted as zymogens, are inhibited by tissue inhibitor of metalloproteinases (TIMP), require Zn2+ for Correspondence
to: Dr. M.W.
Qoronfleh,
Department
of Molecular
Biology, Sterling Winthrop Pharmaceuticals Research Division, P.O. Box 5000, Collegeville, PA 19426-0900, USA. Tel. (l-610) 983-5620; Fax (I-610) 983-5293. Abbreviations: A, absorbance (1 cm); aa, amino acid(s); BCIP, 5-bromo-4-chloro-3-indolyl phosphate; bp, base glutathione S-transferase; HFC, human fibroblast HNC, human NC; Ig, immunoglobulin; IPTG, thiogalactopyranoside; kb, kilobase or 1000 bp; LB, SSDI 0378-l
119( 94)00283-X
Ap, ampicillin; pair(s); GST, collagenase; isopropyl-fl-oLuria-Bertani
catalysis and need Ca 2c for stability. In addition to their high primary sequence homology, they are structurally conserved and most are arranged into three functional domains. These domains consist of a propeptide region with a cysteine residue responsible for maintaining lat(medium);
MMP, matrix metalloproteinase;
M9, minimal
salts medium;
NBT, nitro blue tetrazolium chloride; NC, neutrophil collagenase; NC-t, NC C-terminal-truncated; oligo, oligodeoxyribonucleotide; PAGE, polyacrylamide-gel electrophoresis; PCMB, p-chloromercuribenzoate; PCR, polymerase chain reaction; proHNC, full-length HNC proenzyme (latent); proNC-t, NC-t proenzyme (latent); PUMP, putative matrix proteinase (matrilysin); re, recombinant; re-mNC-t, recombinant mature NC-t; sepragel, SDS-PAGE; SDS, sodium dodecyl sulfate; TIMP, tissue inhibitor of MMP; vvm, volume of air per volume of medium per min.
298 ency, a catalytic
domain
site and a C-terminal pexin (Docherty genase (HNC:
with a conserved
portion
Lint-binding
with resemblance
et al., 1992). Human
to hemo-
neutrophil
colla-
encoding
proteinase
which
glutathione-S-transferase
EC 3.4.24.34) is a neutral
belongs to the MMP enzyme family. The MMP members are capable varying
of degrading
specificities
et al., 1993). The MMPs role
native
collagen
remodelling.
stems from their ability
The
to destroy
This
interest
matrix.
destruction
diverse pathological
occurs
states such as inflammation,
tis, metastasis
and peridiontal
disease (Henderson
1990). Several
pharmaceutical
companies
a number
of the MMPs
for diseases principal
for the development
where loss of connective-tissue
and generates (GST)
arthriet al.,
have targeted
with the desired 1988) domain
authentic lacks
genase (MMP-1)
eliminated.
HNC with these proteins
neutrophil is activated to exocytosis (Hasty et al., 1990; Sorsa et al., 1992). The synovial fluid in rheumatoid and osteo-arthritis is characterized by the presence of abundant neutrophils. The local release of neutrophil type MM P-8 collagenase and its effect on type II collagen found in articular cartilage is thought to contribute to the progressive destruction of joint tissues (Sorsa et al.,
Stromelysin
Therefore, strategy
we due
to
(MMP-3) colla-
adopted
the
homology
of
and chose the T7 polymerase-
directed expression system (pET1 la vector. Studier ct al.. 1990) to generate authentic HNC protein. DNA encoding C-terminally truncated forms of HNC (proNC-t and mNC-t) were PCR-amplified from pGEX-2T/hnc and sub-cloned into pET1 la (see legend to Fig. 1A). The plasmids were designated pWQlO0 and pWQll0, respectively: the proNC-t-encoding clone clone with begins with Phe”‘, the mNC-t-encoding Met”‘. Both clones end with GlyZh’ (a naturally autolytic site exists between Gly”’ and Leu’“” marking the approx. border between the catalytic domain and hemopexin-like
1992; Henderson et al., 1990). This suggests that HNC is a reasonable target molecule for therapeutic intervention
domain).
in diseases accompanied with accelerated breakdown of the extracellular matrix of articular cartilage. The aim of the present study was the cloning, expression in E. di, purification and characterization of two HNC forms. We succeeded in producing a form of the protein, re-mNC-t, which contains only the catalytic domain, thereby obviating the need for proteolytic or organomercurial compound activation and also removing an autolytic site near the C terminus (for detailed discussion on activation and autocatalysis of MMPs the reader is referred to VanWart and Birkedal-Hansen,
(b) Expression of proNC-t and mNC-t Expression of re-proNC-t and re-mNC-t
1990). The 18-kDa recombinant mature, truncated neutrophil collagenase (re-mNC-t) protein produced is pure, active, and suitable for studies of catalysis and inhibition. In addition, a homogeneous affinity-purified preparation of the truncated protein was used for the X-ray craystallographic studies recently reported by Stams et al. (1994).
et al..
hemopexin-like
(Lowry et al., 1992) are active with this
C-terminally-truncated
secreted
( Muller
MMP-7) C-terminal
and is an active enzyme.
integrity
is a
the
for biophysical
(Ye et al., 1992; Marcy et al., 1991) and fibroblast domain
glycoprotein which is synthesized as a latent proenzyme during the myelocyte stage of neutrophil development. It is stored in the secondary or specific granules until the
EXPERIMENTAL
with
a source of active. re-HNC N terminus
( PUMP;
Matrilysin naturally
of inhibitors
is a 75kDa
protein
fused to the N terminus
(a) PCR cloning of proNC-t and mNC-t forms of HNC
studies. in
feature.
HNC, also referred to as MMP-8,
a fusion
of Ynlc pcptidc-
region ( Phc” ).
of the propeptide
Our aim was to generate in
components
of the extracellular
sequence
Dr. N. Berliner lacks the signal
with
et al., 1991; Hirose
are believed to play a significant
in connective-tissue
MMPs
interstitial
(Netezel-Arnett
pGEX-2T:hnc clone from University. This construct
was carried
out in the E. coli lysogen BL21 (DE3). Cultures were grown at 37 C either in terrific broth for small-scale preparations or in LB + M9 medium for 10 liter fermentations. in the presence of 100 pg Ap per ml, to .4600=0.7p1 .O or 1.3-1.5, respectively, and induced with 0.5 mM IPTG. Aliquots were collected at different time points. The harvested samples were normalized and analyzed on precast IO--20% gradient sepragel. An example of a typical fermentation/expression experiment is presented in Fig. 1A. Routinely, the 18-kDa re-mNC-t accumulated at high levels (approx. 30% of total bacterial protein) after l-3 h induction (Fig. 1A, lanes 2--4). Western blot analysis (Fig. IB, lane 4) using a polyclonal antibody raised against human fibroblast collagenase ( HFC) (BirkedalHansen et al., 1988) showed that re-mNC-t is apparently related to HFC despite the low homology between HNC and HFC (Hasty et al., 1990; Devarajan et al.. 1991 ).
AND DISCUSSION
The cDNA cloning of HNC has been previously scribed (Devara_jan et al., 1991). We obtained
dethe
(c) Purification of re-proNC-t and re-mNC-t Methods for purifying truncated MMPs have been detailed elsewhere (Ye et al., 1992; Schnierer et al.. 1993).
299
c
B kDa
M
1
2
3
kDa
4
M
1
2
3
4
kDa
Ml
234
95.0 94.0
66.0
67.0 43.0
39.0 29.0 20.4
29,o
-
mNC-t
20.4 cmNC-t
mNC-t
14.0 Fig. 1. Production of mNC-t in E coii. (A) Synthesis of re-mNC-t in E. coli. Oligos used to synthesis PCR products coding for pro and mature NC-t included: HNC-1, a 30-mer proenzyme N terminus end, HNC-2, a 27-mer mature enzyme N terminus end and HNC-3, a 36-mer truncated C terminus end. The sense primers incorporated an Ndel site at their S-end for an ATG start codon. The antisense primer possessed a BarnHI site with two TGA stop codons in tandem. HNC-1, S-CTC CAT ATG NdeI Met HNC-2, S-CTC -~ CAT ATG ~deI/M’~ HNC-3, S-CTC GGA TCC BumHI
TTT CCT GTA TCT TCT AAA GAG F2’ TTA ACC CCA GGA AAC CCC TCA TCA TCC ATA GAT GGC CTG AAT GCC __-
stop -+----+----
@?62
The resulting PCR products of a 729-bp fragment (proNC-t) and a 489-bp fragment (mNC-t) were cloned between the N&I and BamHI unique sites of pETlla (Studier et al., 1990; also see section a).The nt sequence of the catalytic domain was verified by double-stranded dideoxy DNA sequencing (Kraft et al., 1988). The growth of NC-t producing E. coli pWQll0 was scaled up to 10 liters in a 15-1Bioengineering AG fermentor. The medium used was LB + M9 and 1 ml Mazu DF204 antifoam agent was added to the medium. The cooled medium was supplemented with a filter sterilized solution consisting of glucose, MgSOd, and Ap to a final con~ntration of 0.4%, 1 mM and 100 &g/ml, respectively. A 200-ml overnight culture was used to inoculate the fermentor. The fermentation conditions were: 37”C, 500 rpm, and an aeration of 1 vvm. The culture was induced with 0.5 mM IPTG when it reached an A,, of 1.3. I-ml samples were taken, pelleted, resuspended in a 100 ~1 2 x SDS sample buffer, boiled for 5 min and centrifuged. A normalizing volume loaded to A of sample was run onto a 10-20% gradient sepragel (IS& Hyde Park, MA, USA) according to manufacturers instruction, then Coomassie blue R-250 stained (see section b). Lane M, ISS molecular mass markers in kDa; lane 1, prior to IPTG induction (0 h); lanes: 2-4 post induction (+ IPTG) at 1.3, 1.7 and 2.3 h, respectively. (B) Western blot analysis of re-mNC-t expressed in E. c&i. Cultures were grown in terrific broth and induced with 0.5 mM IPTG for 2 h. Gels were run onto precast l&20% gradient sepragel then electrotransferred to nitrocellulose paper essentially as described by Towbin et al. (1979). Western immunoblotting was carried out using a rabbit polyclonai antibody raised against HFC (Birkedal-Hansen et al., 1988). Then, the blot was treated with a secondary antibody, an alkaline phosphatase conjugate of goat anti-mouse IgG, and developed with BCIP/NBT (Mierendorf et al., 1987; also see section b). Lane M, ISS molecular mass markers in kDa; lanes 1 and 2, the host strain without the NNC gene (-/+ IPTG); lanes 3 and 4, the host strain with the HNC gene (-/+ IPTG). (C) Affinity purification of re-mNC-t. Methods: inclusion bodies were recovered, solubilized with 6 M urea. and the re-mNC-t was isolated by MonoQ chromatography. The protein was then renatured and concentrated. A Sepharose-Pro-Leu-Giy-NHGH affinity column (Moore and Spilburg, 1986) was used to purify the full length enzyme. The peptide hydroxamic acid moiety is a substrate analogue with a metal-cheIating group allowing the Zn~+-conta~njng enzyme to bind the column (see section c). A 15-mg sample was loaded onto the lo-ml column equilibrated with 20mM Tris/S mM CaCIJ0.4 M NaCI/O.02% NaN, pH 7.5 buffer at a rate of 0.7 miimin. After loading, the column was washed with 3 vols. of the above buffer to remove nonspecifically bound protein. The specifically bound protein was eluted with 4 vols. of 0.2 mM hydroxamate inhibitor dissolved in the same buffer. The eluate was then concentrated in an Amicon stirred cell with a IO-kDa cut off YMIO membrane that also get rid of minor peptide contaminants. This yielded 11mg of pure, active re-mNC-t. Shown in C) is a Coomassie blue R-250 stained lo-20% gradient sepragel. Lane M, Bio-Rad molecular mass markers in kDa; lanes: 1. 5 pg re-mNC-t prior to aflinity purification; 2, 5 pg protein obtained from affinity column flow through; 3, 5 pg protein of pooled elution fractions; 4, 5 pg of re-mNC-t post concentration.
We have adapted these methods for purification of truncated HNCs. Briefly, inclusion bodies were recovered from lysed bacteria (Marcy et al., 1991). The pellet was solubilized in 6 M urea and after centrifugation the supernatant was loaded onto a MonoQ-Sepharose column. Pooled fractions were diluted tenfold and renaturation
was performed with refolding buffer containing Zn*+ and Ca2+ at 4°C. After the protein was concentrated, a final step of purification was carried out on a Sepharcyl S-100 HR column. Minor impu~ties detected on sepragels were attributed to the degradation of the re-protein based on aa sequencing. Whereas, this protocol yielded highly
300 purified
(3 I pg/ml ) suitable
re-mNC-t
studies of catalysis activation
and inhibition
of purified
romercuribenzoate (Mookhtiar
and VanWart,
analysis
of re-mNC-t
mature
HNCs
(approx.
IO-15%
presence
or absence
(see
section
Sepharose following
ligand
permitting products
aa sequence
then
rapid
an abundant
for biophysical
by
known
MMP
nant
nei-
communication),
coupled
with affinity purification
source
of pure, active re-mNC-t
characterization.
(5) This approach
The
resolves many of the difficulties
ciated with low yield (as has been observed
asso-
with recombi-
GST-proHNC;
activation
N. Berliner, personal and the need for enzyme processing and
(Schnierer
et al., 1993).
hydroxamate
and Spilburg, for further
1986) purifica-
coordinates
purification
re-mNC-t and other
is inhibited
(4) E. cdi expression provided
the Met).
activ-
activity
inhibitors.
Met
utilized
(Moore
to
This
initiator
Met influenced
of the re-protein,
to Fig. 1C). Full-length degradation
achieved
(see below) nor enzymatic We
tion. In this step, the metalloenzyme affinity
be
the
lacked
of the initiator
d).
not
or p-chlo-
that it corresponded
without
of the protein
chromatography refolding
could
1990). N-terminal
and
ther affinity purification ity
with trypsin
confirmed
with
enzyme.
(see section d). efficient
re-proNC-t (PCMB)
for mechanistic
to the
was separated contaminants
REFERENCES
(see legend from
(Fig. lC,
lane 3; 1%kDa band), yielding a pure, active, NC-t which could be concentrated without autodegradation (Fig. lC, lane 4). Small-peptide impurities (less than 10 kDa) appearing after affinity purification were removed during concentration. The identity of the protein was confirmed by N-terminal aa sequencing. The affinity-purified enzyme was successfully used for X-ray structure determination (Stams et al., 1994).
Birkedal-Hansen.
substrates as described previously (Stack et al., 1989; Knight et al., 1992). Using the pentapeptide benzoylPLALW-NH-(CH,),-N-(CH,), as a substrate in a fluorimetric assay in a microtiter plate (R.C.W., unpublished data), re-mNC-t had a specific activity of 1.58 + 0.08 pmol product/h/ug protein. The K, and k,,,/K, values obtained are 63.5 f 9.2 uM and 30.4 + 2.2 ).rM ’ h ‘, respectively. The activity of re-mNC-t was inhibited by ion chealators such as 5 mM EDTA and 10 mM I,10 phenanthroline. The inhibitor actinonin (hydroxamate functionality, Wahl et al., 1989) displayed a measured Ki of 160f 10 nM. The native NC isolated from human blood have comparable kinetic (Mallya et al., 1990; NetezelArnett et al., 1991) and Ki values (Wahl et al., 1989). (e) Conclusions (I ) The coding region for proNC-t and mNC-t was amplified by PCR, sub-cloned and expressed in E. co/i utilizing the inducible T7 polymerase PET system. (2) The catalytic domain of HNC (mNC-t) was produced at very high levels in E. coli, purified in a two-step procedure and successfully refolded. (3) The re-mNC-t protein is catalytically active and has kinetic parameters nearly equivalent to the native
W.G.I.,
of the enzyme,
and evidence
terminal end 6751-6758.
of the activated
Devarajan,
P.. Mookhtiar.
and expression ase. Blood 77 Docherty,
Taylor.
for clustering enlyme.
K.. VanWart,
R.E.. Bhown,
AS.
and
A.J.P.. O’Connell,
J., Crabbe,
K.A.,
Pourmotabbed,
in the NH:-
of epitopes Biochemistry
H. and Berliner,
of the cDNA encoding ( 1991) 2731 2738.
The matrix metalloproteinases pects for treating degenarative 10 ( 1992) 200 207. Hasty.
(d) Enzymatic characterization of re-mNC-t Enzyme activity and kinetic parameters were determined by assays based on the hydrolysis of small peptide
B.. Moore.
Birkedal-Hansen, H.: Monoclonal antibodies to human fibroblast procollagenase. Inhibition of enzymatic activity, ahinity purification
human
27 (1988) N.: Structure
neutrophil
collagen-
T.. Angal, S. and Murphy.
G.:
and their natural inhibitors: prostissue diseases. Trends Biotechnol.
T.F.,
Goldberg,
Spinella. D.G., Stevens. R.M. and Mainardi.
G.I.. Thompson. C.L.: Human
J.P..
neurophil
collagenase. J. Biol. Chem. 265 ( 1990) 1 I42 I I 1424. Henderson, B.. Docherty, A.J.P. and Beeley, N.R.A.: Design of inhibitors of articular (1990) 495-508.
cartilage
destruction.
Hirose. T.. Patterson, C.. Pourmottabed, K.A.: Structure function releationship genase: identification
of regions
and general proteinase 2.56992573.
activity.
Drugs
of the
Future
15
T, Mainardi, C. and Hasty. of human neutrophil colla-
responsible
for substrate
specificity
Proc. Natl. Acad. Sci. USA 90 (1993)
Kmght, C.G.. Willenbrock. F. and Murphy. labelled peptide for sensitive continuous
G.: A novel coumarinassays of the matrix
metalloproteinases. FEBS Lett. 296 (1992) 2633266. Kraft. R.J.. Tardiff, J.. Krauter. KS. and Leinwand, L.A.: Using miniprep plasmid DNA for sequencing double stranded SequenaseR. BioTechniques 6 (1988) 544- 547.
template
with
Lowry, C.L., McGeehen, G. and Levine 111, H.: Metal ion stabilization of the conformation of a recombinant 19 kDa catalytic fragment of human
fibroblast
collagenase.
Proteins:
Struct.
Funct.
Genet.
I2
( 1992) 42248. Mallya.
SK.,
Mookhtiar,
K.A..
Gao.
Y., Brew.
K.. Dioszegi.
M..
Birkedal-Hansen, H. and VanWart, H.E.: Characterization of 5X-kilodalton human neutrophil collagenase: comparison with human libroblast collagenase. Biochemistry 29 ( 1990) 10628~10634. Marcy. A.I.. Eiberger, L.L.. Harrison. R., Chan. H.K.. Hutchinson. N.I.. Hagmann. W.K., Cameron, P.M.. Boulton. D.A. and Hermes. J.D.: Human fibroblast stromelysin catalytic domain: expression, purthcation. and characterization of a Biochemistry 30 ( 1991) 6476 6483. Mierendorf, R.C.. Percy. C. and Young. ing hgtll libraries with antibodies. 458 469. Mookhtiar. K.A. and VanWart. H.E.:
C-terminally
truncated
form.
R.A.: Gene isolation by screenMethods Enzymol. 152 ( 19X7) Puriticatton
to homogeneity
of
301 latent and active S&kilodalton ase. Biochemistry Moore,
forms of human
neutrophil
W.M. and Spilburg,
with a hydroxamic 518995195. Muller, D., Quantin,
M.W., Banks,
C.A.: Purification
acid affinity
of human
column.
collagenases
Biochemistry
B., Gesnel, M.C., Millon-Collard,
Sequence
S., Fields, G., Brikedal-Hansen, specificities
of human
R., Abecassis,
and neutrophil
J.
consist H.E.:
collagen-
Schnierer,
S., Kleine,
Tschesche,
T., Hillemann,A.,
H.: The recombinant
phi1 collagenase Biophys.
T., Gote,
lacks type
Res. Commun.
catalytic
domain
I collagen substrate
vitis
of rheumatoid
gelatinase
R.D.: Comparison
using a new fluorogenic
264(1989)427774281.
Semin.
and applications.
neutro-
cability
of vertebrate
collagenase
22 and
peptide. J. Biol. Chem.
Nature
Biol.
J.W.: Use
of cloned
J.: Electrophoretic
gels to nitrocellulose
neutrophil Struct.
genes.
transfer
of
sheets: procedure
Proc. Natl. Acad. Sci. USA 76 (1979) 4350-4354. of metalloproteinase
to the entire
matrix
H.: The cysteine
switch: a prin-
activity with potential
metalloproteinase
gene family.
appliProc.
Nat]. Acad. Sci. USA 87 (1990) 5578-5582. Wahl, R.C., Dunlap,
Rheumatism
T. and Gordon,
H.E. and Birkedal-Hansen,
of human
Biochm.
of human
pocket.
A.H., Dunn, J.J. and Dubendroff,
acrylamide
ciple of regulation
specificity.
Arthritis
substrate
from
V. and
191 (1993) 3199326.
arthritis.
H., Staehelin,
proteins
Knauper,
Sorsa, T., Konttinen, Y.T., Lindy, O., Ritchlin, C., Saari, H., Suomalainen, K., Eklund, K.and Santavirta, S.: Collagenase in syno(1992) 44-53. Stack, MS. and Gray,
reveals large Sl’ specificity
of T7 RNA polymerase to direct expression Methods Enzymol. 185 (1990) 60-89.
VanWart,
ase. J. Biol. Chem. 266 (1991) 6747-6755.
J.C., Smith, D.L., Wahl, R.C., Ho, T.F., Qoronfleh, T.M. and Rubin, B.: Structure
1 (1994) 119-123. Studier, F.W., Rosenberg,
Towbin,
H. and VanWart,
fibroblast
collagenase
25 (1986)
and Breathnach, R.: The collagenase gene family in humans of at least four members. Biochem. J. 253 (1988) 1877192. Netzel-Arnett,
Stams, T., Spurlino,
collagen-
29 (1990) 10620~10627.
R.P. and Morgan,
tion of collagenase (1989) 177-184. Ye, Q.-Z., Johnson,
and stromelysin.
L.L., Hupe,
B.A.: Biochemistry Annu.
D.J. and Baragi,
and inhibi-
Rep. Med. Chem. V.: Purification
25 and
charaterization of the human stromelysin catalytic domain expressed in Escherichia co/i. Biochemistry 3 1 ( 1992) 1 I23 l- I 1235.