- Email: [email protected]
Hydrocarbon generation and storage mechanisms of deep-water shelf shales of Ordovician Wufeng Formation–Silurian Longmaxi Formation in Sichuan Basin, China
PETROLEUM EXPLORATION AND DEVELOPMENT Volume 47, Issue 1, February 2020 Online English edition of the Chinese language journal Cite this article as: PETROL. EXPLOR. DEVELOP., 2020, 47(1): 204–213.
RESEARCH PAPER
Hydrocarbon generation and storage mechanisms of deepwater shelf shales of Ordovician Wufeng Formation– Silurian Longmaxi Formation in Sichuan Basin, China GUO Xusheng1,*, LI Yuping1, BORJIGEN Tenger2, WANG Qiang1, YUAN Tao1, SHEN Baojian2, MA Zhongliang2, WEI Fubin1 1. Exploration Company, Sinopec, Chengdu 610041, China; 2. Wuxi Petroleum Geology Institute, Research Institute of Petroleum Exploration and Development, Sinopec, Wuxi 214126, China
Abstract: As the hydrocarbon generation and storage mechanisms of high quality shales of Upper Ordovician Wufeng Formation– Lower Silurian Longmaxi Formation remain unclear, based on geological conditions and experimental modelling of shale gas formation, the shale gas generation and accumulation mechanisms as well as their coupling relationships of deep-water shelf shales in Wufeng–Longmaxi Formation of Sichuan Basin were analyzed from petrology, mineralogy, and geochemistry. The high quality shales of Wufeng–Longmaxi Formation in Sichuan Basin are characterized by high thermal evolution, high hydrocarbon generation intensity, good material base, and good roof and floor conditions; the high quality deep-water shelf shale not only has high biogenic silicon content and organic carbon content, but also high porosity coupling. It is concluded that: (1) The shales had good preservation conditions and high retainment of crude oil in the early times, and the shale gas was mainly from cracking of crude oil. (2) The biogenic silicon (opal A) turned into crystal quartz in early times of burial diagenesis, lots of micro-size intergranular pores were produced in the same time; moreover, the biogenic silicon frame had high resistance to compaction, thus it provided the conditions not only for oil charge in the early stage, but also for formation and preservation of nanometer cellular-like pores, and was the key factor enabling the preservation of organic pores. (3) The high quality shale of Wufeng–Longmaxi Formation had high brittleness, strong homogeneity, siliceous intergranular micro-pores and nanometer organic pores, which were conducive to the formation of complicated fissure network connecting the siliceous intergranular nano-pores, and thus high and stable production of shale gas. Key words: hydrocarbon generation and storage mechanism; Upper Ordovician Wufeng Formation; Lower Silurian Longmaxi Formation; deep-water shelf; siliceous shale; Sichuan Basin; pore preservation
Introduction The Upper Ordovician Wufeng Formation–Lower Silurian Longmaxi Formation shales are the only shale formations in China from which shale gas has been developed commercially. Shale gas fields such as Fuling, Weirong, Weiyuan, Changling and Zhaotong have been discovered in this formation in Sichuan Basin and surrounding areas[15], and they have total proved geological reserves of 10 455×108 m3, shale gas productivity of 150×108 m3. Among them, the Fuling Shale Gas Field is the first commercially developed shale gas field, with the feature of overpressure[6]. In this gas field, the Wufeng Formation–Longmaxi Formation shale is about 90 m thick, in which the high quality shale reservoir sections (TOC≥2%) are about 3040 m thick, high in thermal evolution degree
with Ro of 2.0%3.5%, high in porosity (1.85% 8.32%, 5.22% on average). The shale reservoirs have mainly organic pores, total gas contents of 3.528.90 m3/t (5.96 m3/t on average), good fracturing effect, and high production. The average production of 313 wells during test was 24.2×104 m3/d. Some researchers have studied the depositional environment, reservoir features and main factors controlling gas accumulation and high production of the Wufeng FormationLongmaxi Formation deep-water shelf shale and got some achievements[714], and proposed the finding that two factors controlling the shale gas enrichment in marine shale of southern China[10]. Some researchers have also studied the hydrocarbon generation and storage mechanisms of deep-water shelf shale and got some understandings. But most of the studies haven’t examined the dynamic evolution and the relationship
Received date: 17 May 2019; Revised date: 26 Sep. 2019. * Corresponding author. E-mail: [email protected] Foundation item: Supported by the China National Science and Technology Major Project (2017ZX05036; 2017ZX05036001). https://doi.org/10.1016/S1876-3804(20)60019-2 Copyright © 2020, Research Institute of Petroleum Exploration & Development, PetroChina. Publishing Services provided by Elsevier B.V. on behalf of KeAi Communications Co., Ltd. This is an open access article under the CC BY-NC-ND license (http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-nc-nd/4.0/).
GUO Xusheng et al. / Petroleum Exploration and Development, 2020, 47(1): 204–213
between hydrocarbon generation mechanism and storage mechanism[6, 1011, 1516]. Therefore, in this study, starting from analysis of the features of shale gas reservoirs of Wufeng Formation–Longmaxi Formation, we investigated the hydrocarbon generation and accumulation mechanisms of the Wufeng FormationLongmaxi Formation shale and the relationship between them, and main factors affecting hydrocarbon generation and accumulation in shale formations of different depths of deep-water shelf facies through physical modeling, in the hope to find out the inner mechanism of shale gas accumulation, stable and high production of deep high quality shale (at the depth of 4 0005 000 m) with high thermal evolution degree.
1.
Introduction of the study area
The Sichuan Basin is located in south-western China, and can be divided into six structural belts, namely, low and steep structural belt in western Sichuan, low and gentle structural belt in northern Sichuan, gentle structural belt in central Sichuan, low and steep structural belt in south-western Sichuan, high and steep structural belt in eastern Sichuan, and low and steep structural belt in southern Sichuan. Shale gas fields such as Fuling, Weiyuan, Weirong, Changling and Zhaotong discovered in Sihuan Basin and its surrounding areas are mainly distributed in high and steep structural belt in eastern Sichuan, low and steep structural belt in southern Sichuan and low and steep structural belt in south-western Sichuan (Fig. 1). The Upper Ordovician–Lower Silurian organic-rich shale (TOC> 0.5%) mainly occurs in Wufeng Formation–1st member of Longmaxi Formation (hereinafter shortened as Long 1 Member) shelf sediments, while high quality shale (TOC>2%) is in
Fig. 1.
Wufeng Formation–Long1 Member, which is deep shelf sediment with a thickness of 2040 m, and is mainly distributed in south-western part, southern part and eastern part of Sichuan Basin. The shales include two types, calcium-bearing siliceous shale and siliceous shale, of which, the former is mainly distributed in southwestern Sichuan Basin and Weiyuan-Changning-Renhuai-Lintanchang in southern Sichuan Basin, while the latter in the areas north of Jiaoshiba in south-eastern Sichuan Basin and north-eastern Sichuan Basin.
2. Shale of deep shelf facies has high TOC and high silicon content The Wufeng–Longmaxi Formation shale deposited in deep-water shelf has high TOC and silicon content, with TOC of 1.04%5.89%, 3.50% on average, and silicon content of 31.00%70.60%, 44.57% on average (Fig. 2). The TOC and silicon content show obviously positive correlation, and the high quality shale sections have coupling of high TOC and high silicon content (Fig. 3). There are two reasons: one is that the high quality shale has abundant biological fossils such as grapholites, silicon radiolarians and sponge bone needles etc., and high organic productivity, suggesting the quiet, anoxic and strong reducing deep-water shelf environment is favorable to enrichment and preservation of organic matter, and thus has obvious control on the enrichment and preservation of organic matter; the other side is that the large amount of radiolarians and sponge bone needles can form endogenous high silicon-content minerals[1]. In shallow-water shelf, due to sufficient supply of terrestrial debris, the organic matter would be destructed or diluted, so the shale of this facies shows low TOC and silicon
Structural features and units division of Sichuan Basin and its periphery.
205
GUO Xusheng et al. / Petroleum Exploration and Development, 2020, 47(1): 204–213
Fig. 2.
Composite histogram of shale gas reservoir of Wufeng Formaiton–Long 1 Member in Fuling Shale Gas Field.
content on the whole (Fig. 2), and the silicon is dominated by terrestrial quartz debris, so the silicon content and TOC have poor correlation (Fig. 3).
3. Main source of shale gas of Wufeng–Longmaxi Formation is cracked gas from crude oil Kerogens of different geneses have different hydrocarbongeneration ability and degradation products[16]. The organic matter of Wufeng–Longmaxi Formation has mainly Ⅰ–Ⅱ1 type kerogens, and the shale has high TOC and high thermal evolution degree with Ro of 2.2%3.4%[1719]. According to the hydrocarbon-generation theory, simulation by using TOC, thickness and Ro of high quality shale, the Wufeng–Longmaxi Formation shale has high hydrocarbon-generating rate. Taking Well JY1 for example, the shale of shallow-water shelf facies is 51 m thick, and has a hydrocarbon-generation intensity of 25×108 m3/km2, while the high quality shale of deep-water
shelf, 38 m thick, has a hydrocarbon-generating intensity of 35×108 m3/km2 and huge hydrocarbon-generation potential[14]. Comparing δ13C of natural gas and kerogens of Wufeng Formation–Longmaxi Formation in Fuling Shale Gas Field with those of kerogens in other formations of Sichuan Basin shows that the natural gas in Wufeng Formation–Longmaxi Formation of Fuling Gas Field comes from in-situ source rock[13]. The gas of Fuling Gas Field has entire reversal of C isotope values, namely, δ13C1>δ13C2>δ13C3, suggesting that the natural gas is a mixture of gases generated by the same source rock in different geological times[20–23]. As Wufeng–Longmaxi Formation experienced three stages of evolution, early continuous burial and hydrocarbon-generation, cracking gas generation at maximum burial depth, and reservoir destruction and adjustment in the late stage (Fig. 4), Devonian shale samples from Luquan county, Yunnan province with TOC of 2.64%, Ⅱ1 kerogen and Ro of 0.48% similar to
206
GUO Xusheng et al. / Petroleum Exploration and Development, 2020, 47(1): 204–213
Fig. 3.
Correlations of TOC and silicon contents of shallow-water shelf shale (a) and deep-water shelf shale (b).
the Wufeng Formation–Longmaxi Formation deep-water shelf shale was taken to model hydrocarbon-generation course in the key oil & gas national laboratory of Wuxi Petroleum Geological Research Institute of Petroleum Exploration & Development Institute of SINOPEC. The principles and apparatus of the modeling experiment are elaborated in reference [24]. The modeling results show that cracking of kerogen to gas has three peaks at the Ro of 1.0%, 2.1% and 3.2% respectively. Ro 1.0% is the peak of oil generation (Fig. 5a), while organic matter is pyrolyzed into oil, part of little molecules with weak active energy fall off to generate gas. When Ro is 2.1%, due to high energy by pyrolysis, the organic matter has the strongest gas-generating capacity, then because of polycondensation of organic matter, solid bitumen is produced, and gas-generating capacity decreases. When Ro is more than
Fig. 4.
3.2%, due to the underground water, some hydrocarbon gas is generated, but from the trend of total hydrocarbon-generating rate (Fig. 5b), the amount of gas generated in the late stage is small. The total generating capacity of kerogen is 2 m3/t rock, residual oil makes great contribution to gas generated in high and over mature stage, the retained oil in shale with oil expulsion efficiency of 68% (original TOC 2.64%) during the oil generation peak has the highest gas generating capacity of 6 m3/t. Based on results from the experiments, the proportions of gas cracked by kerogen and gas cracked by residual oil in different evolution stages were calculated (Fig. 5b). After the stage of high- over-maturity, gas cracked by residual oil makes up 70%, and gas cracked by kerogens 30%. The roof and floor beds of shale gas reservoir feature
Hydrocarbon-generation evolution of Wufeng-Long 1 Member in Well JY1.
207
GUO Xusheng et al. / Petroleum Exploration and Development, 2020, 47(1): 204–213
Fig. 5.
Hydrocarbon-generation rate and total hydrocarbon-generation rate of kerogen.
great thickness, stable distribution, tight lithology, high breakthrough pressure and good sealing capacity [21]. The roof bed of shale gas reservoir is grey-dark grey medium-thick siltstone and muddy siltstone of 2nd member of Longmaxi Formation about 50 m thick; the floor bed is dark grey muddy nodular limestone and limestone etc. of Upper Ordovician Linxiang Formation about 3040 m thick in total, which is distributed stable regionally. The siltstone of 2nd member of Longmaxi Formation in Jiaoshiba area has an average porosity of 2.4% and average permeability of 0.001 6×103 μm2. Testing results by special petrophysical laboratory of national key laboratory of Chengdu University of Technology with TS-100 Breakthrough Pressure Instrument under the temperature 80 C show the breakthrough pressure of the roof bed is 69.871.2 MPa. The floor Linxiang Formation has an average porosity of 1.58%, average permeability of 0.001 7×103 μm2, and a breakthrough pressure of 64.570.4 MPa at the temperature of 80 C. High breakthrough pressure of roof and floor beds is crucial for the accumulation of shale gas[17]. The sealing of roof and floor beds is favorable for crude oil generated in early stage to be retained in great amount, and is also favorable for the retention and preservation of gas cracked in late stage. Based on many experiments on measuring isotopes of alkane gas such as methane and ethane etc. of mixed two kinds of end-element gases, the kerogen-cracking gas and oil-cracking gas, at various proportions in various evolution stages and theory calculation of C isotope of composition fractionation, a template to forecast values of C isotope of alkane gas of the mixed two kinds of end-element gases at any evolution stage[23] has been made. Conversely, the thermal maturity and mixture proportion can be forecasted by measuring the carbon isotope of methane and ethane in the two kinds of gas to judge whether there is cracked gas from crude oil or not. By putting current isotope compositions of methane and ethane of shale gas in Jiaoshiba Area in the quantitative identification template of kerogen-cracking gas and oil-cracking gas, it is found that the oil-cracking gas (residual oil) accounts for 60%80% (Fig. 6), which proves further the reliability of the modelling experiments.
Fig. 6. Quantitative identification by carbon isotope composition of kerogen-cracking gas and oil-cracking gas in shale gas from Wufeng–Longmaxi Formation in Jiaoshiba Area (The base map is from reference [23]).
4. Hydrocarbon generation and accumulation of high quality shale and main controlling factors 4.1.
Effect of biogenic silicon on pore formation
Generally, plankton with rich silicon mainly includes silicon algae, dinoflagellate, radiolarian, and sponge etc., their siliceous shells are made of opal A, which is a kind of noncrystalline mineral with amorphous structure[25]. During early diagenesis, the silicon filled inside the planktons would be dissolved ahead of siliceous shell to form multiple pore structure, while opal A of siliceous shell would transform into crystalline structure with high hardness. According to former studies, the biogenesis siliceous shale formations in current or ancient deposits in the oceans have pores of 510 nm in average diameter from sedimentation and diagenesis, and porosity of up to 35%50%[25]. High quality shale of Wufeng–Longmaxi Formation developing in deep-water shelf environment has a great number of biological fossils such as grapholites, foraminifera, radiolarians and spongy bone needles etc. and high silicon content. Moreover, its organic matter content and silicon content are in
208
GUO Xusheng et al. / Petroleum Exploration and Development, 2020, 47(1): 204–213
positive correlation, and on the triangle diagram of Al-Fe-Mn, most of the measured values fall in biogenesis area (Fig. 7a), so it is concluded that the siliceous minerals of high quality shale of Wufeng–Longmaxi Formation deposited in deepwater shelf are largely biogenesis silicons[1]. Analysis show that the porosity and content of siliceous minerals of Wufeng–Longmaxi shale samples from Well DYS1 have a positive correlation (Fig. 7b), so, it is inferred that biogenesis silicon content is an important factor controlling the development of pores in high quality shale. 4.2.
Effect of biogenesis silicon on pore preservation
As the depth increases, temperature, pressure and thermal maturity increase quickly, before hydrocarbons are generated at great scale (Ro<1.3), the opal would be transformed into quartz micro-crystals, and quartz microcrystalline grains would constitute a large number of hard framework pores. Organic matter with low hardness of 1.53.0 in general is easy to be compacted, whereas quartz with a hardness of up to 7.0 is difficult to be compacted, so the framework pores of quartz grains can be preserved easily. On one hand, unstable biogenesis silicon unstable in structure in the early stage (opal) in the deep-water shelf shale would be transformed into crystalline quartz in plaque and lump through continuous dehydration (Fig. 8), at the same time, a great number of hard quartz intergranular pores with strong anti-compaction capacity would be formed (Fig. 9a); whereas shale of shallow-water shelf facies has no rigid quartz intergranular pores and has
Fig. 7. Table 1.
Al-Fe-Mn triangle diagram (Left) and correlation between content of siliceous minerals and porosity (Right).
Variation characteristics of porosity and specific surface area of siliceous shale samples.
Sample type Diatomaceous earth Siliceous shale Siliceous shale Siliceous shale Siliceous shale Clay shale
weak anti-compaction capacity (Fig. 9b). On the other hand, the silicon released during the course of erosion of biogenesis silicon and clay minerals would recrystallize into authigenic quartz in shapes of flake, ovum and ellipsoid to form clay mineral intergranular pores with relatively high hardness (Fig. 9c, 9d). Therefore, the shale with biogenetic silicon has abundant pores in net structure and high original porosity (Fig. 9e, 9f and Table 1), providing space for crude oil charge, and growth and preservation of organic pores. Pores in quartz sandstone in many petroliferous basins are preserved well soundly prove the view too[2627]. Hence, it is considered that during the course of diagenesis, the transformation of structure of minerals in the inner part of siliceous living organisms such as radiolarians and spongy bone needles is an important reason for the high porosity of high quality shale, and is also the key for the preservation of massive intergranular pores and organic pores. When hard quartz intergranular pores are formed at the early stage of diagenesis, the thermal maturity of shale increases gradually, then when the shale enters into oil-generation stage, siliceous mineral framework has high resistance to compaction (Fig. 9a), the crude oil generated can be stored in the intergranular pores supported by siliceous framework; as the burial depth increases, thermal maturity of the shale increases further, the crude oil and kerogens remaining in the framework pores enter into the stage of cracking gas generation stage, nanometer scale organic pores begin to develop and be preserved. Clearly, the coupling relationship of hard
Specific surface area/(m2·g1) 19-65 92.81 74.23 68.69
Ro/%
Formation Quaternary Nenjiang Formation of Upper Cretaceous Nenjiang Formation of Upper Cretaceous Nenjiang Formation of Upper Cretaceous
Porosity/% 8090 51.43 46.36 31.20
Longmaxi Formation of Lower Silurian (Deep-water shelf)
6.34
25.30
2.63
Longmaxi Formation of Lower Silurian (Shallow-water shelf)
5.16
17.50
2.63
209
0.40 0.40 0.40
GUO Xusheng et al. / Petroleum Exploration and Development, 2020, 47(1): 204–213
Fig. 8.
Evolution stages from opal CT to quartz crystal.
Fig. 9. Scanning electron micrograph of argon ion polished shale samples. (a) Well DY5, 3 812.34 m, organic pores and intergranular pores, weak compaction, siliceous shale, deep-water shelf facies; (b) Well JY2, 2 526.41 m, strong compaction, clay shale, shallow-water shelf facies; (c) Well JY7, 3 419.43 m, intergranular pores in clay minerals, and organic pores in circular and oval shapes; (d) Well JY7, 3 419.43 m, intergranular pores in clay minerals, and organic pores in circular and oval shapes; (e) Baltic Sea, siliceous shale (radiolarians); (f) Sichuan Basin, siliceous shale (radiolarian).
quartz intergranular pore of deep-water shelf shale and the oil generating stage of organic matter results in high porosity and high specific area of the high quality shale of Wufeng–Longmaxi Formation (Fig. 10), which is favorable for shale gas accumulation and adsorption, thus the shale shows high gas content. In contrast, the clay shale of shallow-water shelf facies is
undeveloped in quartz intergranular pore and highly compacted later, all these are not conducive to crude oil charge and formation and preservation of organic pores (Fig. 9b). Consequently, the clay shale of shallow-water shelf facies has much lower porosity and specific surface area (Fig. 9), which aren’t favorable for shale gas accumulation and adsorption, so this kind of shales show much lower gas content.
210
GUO Xusheng et al. / Petroleum Exploration and Development, 2020, 47(1): 204–213
Fig. 10.
Vertical distribution of physical properties of Wufeng–Longmaxi Formation shale layers in Well DYS1.
Fig. 11. SEM photos of shale samples from Wufeng–Longmaxi Formation. (a) Well DYS1, 4 226.77 m, organic matter and siliceous minerals in scattered distribution, deep-water shelf facies; (b) Well DYS1, 4 164.04 m, laminar organic matter and siliceous minerals, shallow-water shelf facies; (c) Well JY4, 2 575.19 m, nanometer scale organic pores, oval shape; (d) Well JY2, 2 561.43 m, organic matter pores in intergranular pores, in circular and oval shapes, weak compaction.
Apparently, biogenesis silicon is the key for development and preservation of organic pores. 4.3. Coupling and coexistence of micrometer scale intergranular pore and nanometer scale organic pore Observations of thin sections and SEM pictures show the high quality Wufeng–Longmaxi shale of deep-water shelf facies has good homogeneity, has no obvious laminar heterogeneity like that in Wufeng–Longmaxi Formation shale layers of shallow-water shelf facies, Permian Longtan Formation and Jurassic, and has organic matter and siliceous minerals in scattered distribution (Fig. 11a, 11b). The high silicon content in the siliceous shale increases the brittleness of the rock (Table 2), so during fracturing, this shale is more likely to form complicated and net-like pore-fissure system. Furthermore, the organic matter pores in intergranular pores are mostly nanometer scale and in nearly circular, oval, pit, meniscus and narrow fissure etc. shapes under electronic microscope, more commonly in cell-like irregular oval shape with good connectivity between each other (Fig. 11c, 11d). Table 2.
In summary, siliceous mineral framework pores and organic pores coexist in Wufeng–Longmaxi shale of deep-water shelf facies. Siliceous minerals in shale have high elastic modulus, low Poisson’s ratio, and good brittleness, which are conducive to the formation of reticular fracture network. In contrast, clay minerals and organic matter have low elastic modulus, high Poisson’s ratio, poor brittleness, and thus poor fracability (Table 2). During fracturing, brittle siliceous mineral grains will be fractured open first to form net-like fissure connecting the scattered and isolated quartz intergranular pores, while the organic pores, clay mineral pores and siliceous mineral framework pores are paragenetic, and organic pores and clay mineral pores have good connectivity, thus the fractured net fissures can connect with organic pores and clay mineral pores that store shale gas, forming channels of organic pore-intergranular pore-micro-fissure (Fig. 12) favorable for high production of shale gas. Hence, though the high quality shale of Wufeng–Longmaxi
Rock mechanic parameters correlation of different minerals (Data of organic matter is from reference [28]).
Mineral Silicon (Quartz) Clay minerals (mudstone) Organic matter (coal)
Elastic modulus/ GPa 69.40 24.10 10.50
Possion’s ratio 0.12 0.34 0.39
Normalized elastic modulus/GPa 84.86 20.14 0.71
211
Normalized Possion’s ratio 112.00 24.00 4.00
Brittleness index/% 98.43 22.07 2.36
GUO Xusheng et al. / Petroleum Exploration and Development, 2020, 47(1): 204–213
[2]
[3]
[4]
Fig. 12. Sketch map of relationship between siliceous framework intergranular pores and nano-pores in high quality shale reservoir of Fuling Shale Gas Field.
Formation with large depth (more than 4000 m) in China has higher thermal maturity than shale in medium-shallow depth (They have undergone similar maximum depth in geological history, but structural uplifting and erosion in the later stage lead to the current differences of them in depth), due to the hard biogenesis siliceous framework, the high quality shale with larger depth can maintain high porosity and high gas content, which are favorable for shale gas accumulation. The deep shale gas of Wufeng–Longmaxi Formation (at the depth of 4 0005 000 m) has resources of over 7×1012 m3 and great exploration potential.
5.
[6]
[7]
[8]
Conclusions
High quality shale of Wufeng–Longmaxi Formation at high thermal maturity has high hydrocarbon generation intensity and good material base. Good roof and floor conditions kept a large amount of crude oil generated early retained in the shale, and the gas from cracking of crude oil provides sufficient gas source, laying solid material foundation for shale gas reservoir with high abundance. Biogenesis silicon (opal A) of Wufeng–Longmaxi Formation in deep-water shelf facies transformed into crystalline quartz with high hardness at the early stage of diagenesis, at the same time a lot of micro intergranular pores were formed. Furthermore, the biogenetic siliceous framework has strong resistance to compaction, which not only provides space for crude oil charge at the early stage but also conditions for development and preservation of cell organic pores, so it is the key for the preservation of organic pores. Wufeng–Longmaxi siliceous shale of deep-water shelf facies has high brittleness, strong homogeneity, paragenetic micron scale siliceous intergranular pores and nanometer scale organic pores, which are the keys to form complicated net fissures by fracturing to connect effectively micron scale siliceous intergranular pores and realize the connectivity of siliceous intergranular nanometer scale organic pores, and high and stable production of shale gas.
References [1]
[5]
[9]
[10]
[11]
[12]
[13]
[14]
[15]
[16]
GUO Xusheng. Enrichment mechanism and exploration
212
technology of Jiaoshiba area in Fuling shale gas field. Beijing: Science Press, 2014. GUO Xusheng, HU Dongfeng, WEI Zhihong, et al. Discovery and exploration of Fuling shale gas field. China Petroleum Exploration, 2016, 21(3): 24–37. MA Xinhua, XIE Jun. The progress and prospects of shale gas exploration and exploitation in southern Sichuan Basin, NW China. Petroleum Exploration and Development, 2018, 45(1): 161–169. LIANG Xing, WANG Gaocheng, ZHANG Jiehui, et al. Highefficiency integrated shale gas development model of Zhaotong National Demonstration Zone and its practical enlightenment. China Petroleum Exploration, 2017, 22(1): 29–37. LIU Naizhen, WANG Guoyong. Shale gas sweet spot identification and precise geo-steering drilling in Weiyuan Block of Sichuan Basin, SW China. Petroleum Exploration and Development, 2016, 43(16): 978985. WANG Qiang, WEI Xiangfeng, WEI Fubin, et al. Overpressure in shale gas reservoirs of Wufeng–Longmaxi formations, Fuling area, southeastern Sichuan Basin. Petroleum Geology & Experiment, 2019, 41(3): 333–340. GUO X, HU D, LI Y, et al. Geological features and reservoiring mode of shale gas reservoirs in Longmaxi Formation of the Jiaoshiba Area. Acta Geologica Sinica (English Edition), 2014, 88(6): 1811–1821. GUO X, HU D, LI Y, et al. Technologies in discovery and exploration of Fuling shale gas field, China. Natural Resources, 2016, 7(5): 271. ZHANG Jinchuan, NIE Haikuan, XU Bo, et al. Geological condition of shale gas accumulation in Sichuan Basin. Natural Gas Industry, 2008, 28(2): 151–156. NIE Haikuan, ZHANG Jinchuan. Types and characteristics of shale gas reservoir: A case study of Lower Paleozoic in and around Sichuan Basin. Petroleum Geology and Experiment, 2011, 33(3): 219–225. WU Liming, DING Wenlong, ZHANG Jinchuan, et al. Fracture prediction of organic-enriched shale reservoir in lower Silurian Longmaxi Formation of Southeastern Chongqiong Area. Journal of Oil and Gas Technology, 2011, 33(9): 43–46. WEI Zhihong. Late fugitive emission of shale gas from Wufeng–Longmaxi formation in Sichuan Basin and its periphery. Oil and Gas Geology, 2015, 36(4): 659–665. HUANG Renchun, WEI Xiangfeng, WANG Qiang. Key factors of shale gas accumulation in Dingshan area of southeastern Sichuan Basin. Marine Origin Petroleum Geology, 2017, 22(2): 25–30. GUO Xusheng. Rules of two-factor enrichiment for marine shale gas in southern China: Understanding from the Longmaxi Formation shale gas in Sichuan Basin and its surrounding area. Acta Geologica Sinica, 2014, 88(7): 1209–1218. GAO Zhanjing, ZHENG Herong, HUANG Tao. Attributes of sweet spots in the Devonian Woodford shales in Oklahoma, USA. Petroleum Geology & Experiment, 2016, 38(3): 340–345. HAO Fang, CHEN Jianyu. Relationship between hydrocarbon potential and biological types of kerogen. Geoscience, 1993(1): 57–65.
GUO Xusheng et al. / Petroleum Exploration and Development, 2020, 47(1): 204–213
[17] GUO Xusheng, HU Dongfeng, LI Yuping, et al. Geological factors controlling shale gas enrichment and high production in Fuling shale gas field. Petroleum Exploration and Development, 2017, 44(4): 481–491. [18] BORJIGIN Tenger, SHEN Baojian, YU Lingjie, et al. Mechanisms of shale gas generation and accumulation in the Ordovician Wufeng-Longmaxi Formation, Sichuan Basin, SW China. Petroleum Exploration and Development, 2017, 44(1): 69–78. [19] XIAO Xianming, WANG Maolin, WEI Qiang, et al. Evaluation of Lower Paleozoic shale with shale gas prospect in south China. Natural Gas Geoscience, 2015, 26(8): 1433–1445. [20] DAI Jinxing, NI Yunyan, HUANG Shipeng. Discussion on the carbon isotopic reversal of alkane gases from the Huanglong Formation in the Sichuan Basin, China. Acta Petrolei Sinica, 2010, 31(5): 710–717. [21] LIU Ruobing. Typical features of the first giant shale gas field in China. Natural Gas Geoscience, 2015, 26(8): 1488–1498. [22] FENG Ziqi, LIU Dan, HUANG Shipeng, et al. Carbon isotopic composition of shale gas in the Silurian Longmaxi Formation of the Changning area, Sichuan Basin. Petroleum Exploration and Development, 2016, 43(5): 705–713. [23] ZHANG S, HE K, HU G, et al. Unique chemical and isotopic
213
[24]
[25] [26]
[27]
[28]
characteristics and origins of natural gases in the Paleozoic marine formations in the Sichuan Basin, SW China: Isotope fractionation of deep and high mature carbonate reservoir gases. Marine and Petroleum Geology, 2018, 89(Part 1): 68–82. MA Zhongliang, ZHENG Lunju, LI Zhiming. The thermocompression simulation experiment of source rock hydrocarbon generation and expulsion in formation porosity. Acta Sedimentologica Sinica, 2012, 30(2): 955–963. QIN Yachao. Research progress in early diagenesis of biogenic silica. Geological Review, 2010, 56(1): 89–98. FANG Shaoxian, HOU Fanghao, SUN Fengyu, et al. Study of diagenesis and pore evolution of sandstone in tertiary in Tiandong Depression in Bose Basin. Nature Gas Industry, 1993, 13(1): 32–41. QIN Xiaoyan, LIN Jin, WU Fuli. Diagenesis and porosity evolution of tight quartz sandstones in Benxi Formation, Southeast Ordos Basin. Journal of Northwest University (Natural Science Edition), 2016, 46(4): 579–584. HOU Lianlang, LIU Xiangjun, LIANG Lixi, et al. Triaxial compression mechanical properties and energy evolution characteristics of soft coal and rock in eastern Yunnan and western Guizhou. Journal of Safety Science and Technology, 2019, 15(2): 105–110.
RESEARCH PAPER
Hydrocarbon generation and storage mechanisms of deepwater shelf shales of Ordovician Wufeng Formation– Silurian Longmaxi Formation in Sichuan Basin, China GUO Xusheng1,*, LI Yuping1, BORJIGEN Tenger2, WANG Qiang1, YUAN Tao1, SHEN Baojian2, MA Zhongliang2, WEI Fubin1 1. Exploration Company, Sinopec, Chengdu 610041, China; 2. Wuxi Petroleum Geology Institute, Research Institute of Petroleum Exploration and Development, Sinopec, Wuxi 214126, China
Abstract: As the hydrocarbon generation and storage mechanisms of high quality shales of Upper Ordovician Wufeng Formation– Lower Silurian Longmaxi Formation remain unclear, based on geological conditions and experimental modelling of shale gas formation, the shale gas generation and accumulation mechanisms as well as their coupling relationships of deep-water shelf shales in Wufeng–Longmaxi Formation of Sichuan Basin were analyzed from petrology, mineralogy, and geochemistry. The high quality shales of Wufeng–Longmaxi Formation in Sichuan Basin are characterized by high thermal evolution, high hydrocarbon generation intensity, good material base, and good roof and floor conditions; the high quality deep-water shelf shale not only has high biogenic silicon content and organic carbon content, but also high porosity coupling. It is concluded that: (1) The shales had good preservation conditions and high retainment of crude oil in the early times, and the shale gas was mainly from cracking of crude oil. (2) The biogenic silicon (opal A) turned into crystal quartz in early times of burial diagenesis, lots of micro-size intergranular pores were produced in the same time; moreover, the biogenic silicon frame had high resistance to compaction, thus it provided the conditions not only for oil charge in the early stage, but also for formation and preservation of nanometer cellular-like pores, and was the key factor enabling the preservation of organic pores. (3) The high quality shale of Wufeng–Longmaxi Formation had high brittleness, strong homogeneity, siliceous intergranular micro-pores and nanometer organic pores, which were conducive to the formation of complicated fissure network connecting the siliceous intergranular nano-pores, and thus high and stable production of shale gas. Key words: hydrocarbon generation and storage mechanism; Upper Ordovician Wufeng Formation; Lower Silurian Longmaxi Formation; deep-water shelf; siliceous shale; Sichuan Basin; pore preservation
Introduction The Upper Ordovician Wufeng Formation–Lower Silurian Longmaxi Formation shales are the only shale formations in China from which shale gas has been developed commercially. Shale gas fields such as Fuling, Weirong, Weiyuan, Changling and Zhaotong have been discovered in this formation in Sichuan Basin and surrounding areas[15], and they have total proved geological reserves of 10 455×108 m3, shale gas productivity of 150×108 m3. Among them, the Fuling Shale Gas Field is the first commercially developed shale gas field, with the feature of overpressure[6]. In this gas field, the Wufeng Formation–Longmaxi Formation shale is about 90 m thick, in which the high quality shale reservoir sections (TOC≥2%) are about 3040 m thick, high in thermal evolution degree
with Ro of 2.0%3.5%, high in porosity (1.85% 8.32%, 5.22% on average). The shale reservoirs have mainly organic pores, total gas contents of 3.528.90 m3/t (5.96 m3/t on average), good fracturing effect, and high production. The average production of 313 wells during test was 24.2×104 m3/d. Some researchers have studied the depositional environment, reservoir features and main factors controlling gas accumulation and high production of the Wufeng FormationLongmaxi Formation deep-water shelf shale and got some achievements[714], and proposed the finding that two factors controlling the shale gas enrichment in marine shale of southern China[10]. Some researchers have also studied the hydrocarbon generation and storage mechanisms of deep-water shelf shale and got some understandings. But most of the studies haven’t examined the dynamic evolution and the relationship
Received date: 17 May 2019; Revised date: 26 Sep. 2019. * Corresponding author. E-mail: [email protected] Foundation item: Supported by the China National Science and Technology Major Project (2017ZX05036; 2017ZX05036001). https://doi.org/10.1016/S1876-3804(20)60019-2 Copyright © 2020, Research Institute of Petroleum Exploration & Development, PetroChina. Publishing Services provided by Elsevier B.V. on behalf of KeAi Communications Co., Ltd. This is an open access article under the CC BY-NC-ND license (http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-nc-nd/4.0/).
GUO Xusheng et al. / Petroleum Exploration and Development, 2020, 47(1): 204–213
between hydrocarbon generation mechanism and storage mechanism[6, 1011, 1516]. Therefore, in this study, starting from analysis of the features of shale gas reservoirs of Wufeng Formation–Longmaxi Formation, we investigated the hydrocarbon generation and accumulation mechanisms of the Wufeng FormationLongmaxi Formation shale and the relationship between them, and main factors affecting hydrocarbon generation and accumulation in shale formations of different depths of deep-water shelf facies through physical modeling, in the hope to find out the inner mechanism of shale gas accumulation, stable and high production of deep high quality shale (at the depth of 4 0005 000 m) with high thermal evolution degree.
1.
Introduction of the study area
The Sichuan Basin is located in south-western China, and can be divided into six structural belts, namely, low and steep structural belt in western Sichuan, low and gentle structural belt in northern Sichuan, gentle structural belt in central Sichuan, low and steep structural belt in south-western Sichuan, high and steep structural belt in eastern Sichuan, and low and steep structural belt in southern Sichuan. Shale gas fields such as Fuling, Weiyuan, Weirong, Changling and Zhaotong discovered in Sihuan Basin and its surrounding areas are mainly distributed in high and steep structural belt in eastern Sichuan, low and steep structural belt in southern Sichuan and low and steep structural belt in south-western Sichuan (Fig. 1). The Upper Ordovician–Lower Silurian organic-rich shale (TOC> 0.5%) mainly occurs in Wufeng Formation–1st member of Longmaxi Formation (hereinafter shortened as Long 1 Member) shelf sediments, while high quality shale (TOC>2%) is in
Fig. 1.
Wufeng Formation–Long1 Member, which is deep shelf sediment with a thickness of 2040 m, and is mainly distributed in south-western part, southern part and eastern part of Sichuan Basin. The shales include two types, calcium-bearing siliceous shale and siliceous shale, of which, the former is mainly distributed in southwestern Sichuan Basin and Weiyuan-Changning-Renhuai-Lintanchang in southern Sichuan Basin, while the latter in the areas north of Jiaoshiba in south-eastern Sichuan Basin and north-eastern Sichuan Basin.
2. Shale of deep shelf facies has high TOC and high silicon content The Wufeng–Longmaxi Formation shale deposited in deep-water shelf has high TOC and silicon content, with TOC of 1.04%5.89%, 3.50% on average, and silicon content of 31.00%70.60%, 44.57% on average (Fig. 2). The TOC and silicon content show obviously positive correlation, and the high quality shale sections have coupling of high TOC and high silicon content (Fig. 3). There are two reasons: one is that the high quality shale has abundant biological fossils such as grapholites, silicon radiolarians and sponge bone needles etc., and high organic productivity, suggesting the quiet, anoxic and strong reducing deep-water shelf environment is favorable to enrichment and preservation of organic matter, and thus has obvious control on the enrichment and preservation of organic matter; the other side is that the large amount of radiolarians and sponge bone needles can form endogenous high silicon-content minerals[1]. In shallow-water shelf, due to sufficient supply of terrestrial debris, the organic matter would be destructed or diluted, so the shale of this facies shows low TOC and silicon
Structural features and units division of Sichuan Basin and its periphery.
205
GUO Xusheng et al. / Petroleum Exploration and Development, 2020, 47(1): 204–213
Fig. 2.
Composite histogram of shale gas reservoir of Wufeng Formaiton–Long 1 Member in Fuling Shale Gas Field.
content on the whole (Fig. 2), and the silicon is dominated by terrestrial quartz debris, so the silicon content and TOC have poor correlation (Fig. 3).
3. Main source of shale gas of Wufeng–Longmaxi Formation is cracked gas from crude oil Kerogens of different geneses have different hydrocarbongeneration ability and degradation products[16]. The organic matter of Wufeng–Longmaxi Formation has mainly Ⅰ–Ⅱ1 type kerogens, and the shale has high TOC and high thermal evolution degree with Ro of 2.2%3.4%[1719]. According to the hydrocarbon-generation theory, simulation by using TOC, thickness and Ro of high quality shale, the Wufeng–Longmaxi Formation shale has high hydrocarbon-generating rate. Taking Well JY1 for example, the shale of shallow-water shelf facies is 51 m thick, and has a hydrocarbon-generation intensity of 25×108 m3/km2, while the high quality shale of deep-water
shelf, 38 m thick, has a hydrocarbon-generating intensity of 35×108 m3/km2 and huge hydrocarbon-generation potential[14]. Comparing δ13C of natural gas and kerogens of Wufeng Formation–Longmaxi Formation in Fuling Shale Gas Field with those of kerogens in other formations of Sichuan Basin shows that the natural gas in Wufeng Formation–Longmaxi Formation of Fuling Gas Field comes from in-situ source rock[13]. The gas of Fuling Gas Field has entire reversal of C isotope values, namely, δ13C1>δ13C2>δ13C3, suggesting that the natural gas is a mixture of gases generated by the same source rock in different geological times[20–23]. As Wufeng–Longmaxi Formation experienced three stages of evolution, early continuous burial and hydrocarbon-generation, cracking gas generation at maximum burial depth, and reservoir destruction and adjustment in the late stage (Fig. 4), Devonian shale samples from Luquan county, Yunnan province with TOC of 2.64%, Ⅱ1 kerogen and Ro of 0.48% similar to
206
GUO Xusheng et al. / Petroleum Exploration and Development, 2020, 47(1): 204–213
Fig. 3.
Correlations of TOC and silicon contents of shallow-water shelf shale (a) and deep-water shelf shale (b).
the Wufeng Formation–Longmaxi Formation deep-water shelf shale was taken to model hydrocarbon-generation course in the key oil & gas national laboratory of Wuxi Petroleum Geological Research Institute of Petroleum Exploration & Development Institute of SINOPEC. The principles and apparatus of the modeling experiment are elaborated in reference [24]. The modeling results show that cracking of kerogen to gas has three peaks at the Ro of 1.0%, 2.1% and 3.2% respectively. Ro 1.0% is the peak of oil generation (Fig. 5a), while organic matter is pyrolyzed into oil, part of little molecules with weak active energy fall off to generate gas. When Ro is 2.1%, due to high energy by pyrolysis, the organic matter has the strongest gas-generating capacity, then because of polycondensation of organic matter, solid bitumen is produced, and gas-generating capacity decreases. When Ro is more than
Fig. 4.
3.2%, due to the underground water, some hydrocarbon gas is generated, but from the trend of total hydrocarbon-generating rate (Fig. 5b), the amount of gas generated in the late stage is small. The total generating capacity of kerogen is 2 m3/t rock, residual oil makes great contribution to gas generated in high and over mature stage, the retained oil in shale with oil expulsion efficiency of 68% (original TOC 2.64%) during the oil generation peak has the highest gas generating capacity of 6 m3/t. Based on results from the experiments, the proportions of gas cracked by kerogen and gas cracked by residual oil in different evolution stages were calculated (Fig. 5b). After the stage of high- over-maturity, gas cracked by residual oil makes up 70%, and gas cracked by kerogens 30%. The roof and floor beds of shale gas reservoir feature
Hydrocarbon-generation evolution of Wufeng-Long 1 Member in Well JY1.
207
GUO Xusheng et al. / Petroleum Exploration and Development, 2020, 47(1): 204–213
Fig. 5.
Hydrocarbon-generation rate and total hydrocarbon-generation rate of kerogen.
great thickness, stable distribution, tight lithology, high breakthrough pressure and good sealing capacity [21]. The roof bed of shale gas reservoir is grey-dark grey medium-thick siltstone and muddy siltstone of 2nd member of Longmaxi Formation about 50 m thick; the floor bed is dark grey muddy nodular limestone and limestone etc. of Upper Ordovician Linxiang Formation about 3040 m thick in total, which is distributed stable regionally. The siltstone of 2nd member of Longmaxi Formation in Jiaoshiba area has an average porosity of 2.4% and average permeability of 0.001 6×103 μm2. Testing results by special petrophysical laboratory of national key laboratory of Chengdu University of Technology with TS-100 Breakthrough Pressure Instrument under the temperature 80 C show the breakthrough pressure of the roof bed is 69.871.2 MPa. The floor Linxiang Formation has an average porosity of 1.58%, average permeability of 0.001 7×103 μm2, and a breakthrough pressure of 64.570.4 MPa at the temperature of 80 C. High breakthrough pressure of roof and floor beds is crucial for the accumulation of shale gas[17]. The sealing of roof and floor beds is favorable for crude oil generated in early stage to be retained in great amount, and is also favorable for the retention and preservation of gas cracked in late stage. Based on many experiments on measuring isotopes of alkane gas such as methane and ethane etc. of mixed two kinds of end-element gases, the kerogen-cracking gas and oil-cracking gas, at various proportions in various evolution stages and theory calculation of C isotope of composition fractionation, a template to forecast values of C isotope of alkane gas of the mixed two kinds of end-element gases at any evolution stage[23] has been made. Conversely, the thermal maturity and mixture proportion can be forecasted by measuring the carbon isotope of methane and ethane in the two kinds of gas to judge whether there is cracked gas from crude oil or not. By putting current isotope compositions of methane and ethane of shale gas in Jiaoshiba Area in the quantitative identification template of kerogen-cracking gas and oil-cracking gas, it is found that the oil-cracking gas (residual oil) accounts for 60%80% (Fig. 6), which proves further the reliability of the modelling experiments.
Fig. 6. Quantitative identification by carbon isotope composition of kerogen-cracking gas and oil-cracking gas in shale gas from Wufeng–Longmaxi Formation in Jiaoshiba Area (The base map is from reference [23]).
4. Hydrocarbon generation and accumulation of high quality shale and main controlling factors 4.1.
Effect of biogenic silicon on pore formation
Generally, plankton with rich silicon mainly includes silicon algae, dinoflagellate, radiolarian, and sponge etc., their siliceous shells are made of opal A, which is a kind of noncrystalline mineral with amorphous structure[25]. During early diagenesis, the silicon filled inside the planktons would be dissolved ahead of siliceous shell to form multiple pore structure, while opal A of siliceous shell would transform into crystalline structure with high hardness. According to former studies, the biogenesis siliceous shale formations in current or ancient deposits in the oceans have pores of 510 nm in average diameter from sedimentation and diagenesis, and porosity of up to 35%50%[25]. High quality shale of Wufeng–Longmaxi Formation developing in deep-water shelf environment has a great number of biological fossils such as grapholites, foraminifera, radiolarians and spongy bone needles etc. and high silicon content. Moreover, its organic matter content and silicon content are in
208
GUO Xusheng et al. / Petroleum Exploration and Development, 2020, 47(1): 204–213
positive correlation, and on the triangle diagram of Al-Fe-Mn, most of the measured values fall in biogenesis area (Fig. 7a), so it is concluded that the siliceous minerals of high quality shale of Wufeng–Longmaxi Formation deposited in deepwater shelf are largely biogenesis silicons[1]. Analysis show that the porosity and content of siliceous minerals of Wufeng–Longmaxi shale samples from Well DYS1 have a positive correlation (Fig. 7b), so, it is inferred that biogenesis silicon content is an important factor controlling the development of pores in high quality shale. 4.2.
Effect of biogenesis silicon on pore preservation
As the depth increases, temperature, pressure and thermal maturity increase quickly, before hydrocarbons are generated at great scale (Ro<1.3), the opal would be transformed into quartz micro-crystals, and quartz microcrystalline grains would constitute a large number of hard framework pores. Organic matter with low hardness of 1.53.0 in general is easy to be compacted, whereas quartz with a hardness of up to 7.0 is difficult to be compacted, so the framework pores of quartz grains can be preserved easily. On one hand, unstable biogenesis silicon unstable in structure in the early stage (opal) in the deep-water shelf shale would be transformed into crystalline quartz in plaque and lump through continuous dehydration (Fig. 8), at the same time, a great number of hard quartz intergranular pores with strong anti-compaction capacity would be formed (Fig. 9a); whereas shale of shallow-water shelf facies has no rigid quartz intergranular pores and has
Fig. 7. Table 1.
Al-Fe-Mn triangle diagram (Left) and correlation between content of siliceous minerals and porosity (Right).
Variation characteristics of porosity and specific surface area of siliceous shale samples.
Sample type Diatomaceous earth Siliceous shale Siliceous shale Siliceous shale Siliceous shale Clay shale
weak anti-compaction capacity (Fig. 9b). On the other hand, the silicon released during the course of erosion of biogenesis silicon and clay minerals would recrystallize into authigenic quartz in shapes of flake, ovum and ellipsoid to form clay mineral intergranular pores with relatively high hardness (Fig. 9c, 9d). Therefore, the shale with biogenetic silicon has abundant pores in net structure and high original porosity (Fig. 9e, 9f and Table 1), providing space for crude oil charge, and growth and preservation of organic pores. Pores in quartz sandstone in many petroliferous basins are preserved well soundly prove the view too[2627]. Hence, it is considered that during the course of diagenesis, the transformation of structure of minerals in the inner part of siliceous living organisms such as radiolarians and spongy bone needles is an important reason for the high porosity of high quality shale, and is also the key for the preservation of massive intergranular pores and organic pores. When hard quartz intergranular pores are formed at the early stage of diagenesis, the thermal maturity of shale increases gradually, then when the shale enters into oil-generation stage, siliceous mineral framework has high resistance to compaction (Fig. 9a), the crude oil generated can be stored in the intergranular pores supported by siliceous framework; as the burial depth increases, thermal maturity of the shale increases further, the crude oil and kerogens remaining in the framework pores enter into the stage of cracking gas generation stage, nanometer scale organic pores begin to develop and be preserved. Clearly, the coupling relationship of hard
Specific surface area/(m2·g1) 19-65 92.81 74.23 68.69
Ro/%
Formation Quaternary Nenjiang Formation of Upper Cretaceous Nenjiang Formation of Upper Cretaceous Nenjiang Formation of Upper Cretaceous
Porosity/% 8090 51.43 46.36 31.20
Longmaxi Formation of Lower Silurian (Deep-water shelf)
6.34
25.30
2.63
Longmaxi Formation of Lower Silurian (Shallow-water shelf)
5.16
17.50
2.63
209
0.40 0.40 0.40
GUO Xusheng et al. / Petroleum Exploration and Development, 2020, 47(1): 204–213
Fig. 8.
Evolution stages from opal CT to quartz crystal.
Fig. 9. Scanning electron micrograph of argon ion polished shale samples. (a) Well DY5, 3 812.34 m, organic pores and intergranular pores, weak compaction, siliceous shale, deep-water shelf facies; (b) Well JY2, 2 526.41 m, strong compaction, clay shale, shallow-water shelf facies; (c) Well JY7, 3 419.43 m, intergranular pores in clay minerals, and organic pores in circular and oval shapes; (d) Well JY7, 3 419.43 m, intergranular pores in clay minerals, and organic pores in circular and oval shapes; (e) Baltic Sea, siliceous shale (radiolarians); (f) Sichuan Basin, siliceous shale (radiolarian).
quartz intergranular pore of deep-water shelf shale and the oil generating stage of organic matter results in high porosity and high specific area of the high quality shale of Wufeng–Longmaxi Formation (Fig. 10), which is favorable for shale gas accumulation and adsorption, thus the shale shows high gas content. In contrast, the clay shale of shallow-water shelf facies is
undeveloped in quartz intergranular pore and highly compacted later, all these are not conducive to crude oil charge and formation and preservation of organic pores (Fig. 9b). Consequently, the clay shale of shallow-water shelf facies has much lower porosity and specific surface area (Fig. 9), which aren’t favorable for shale gas accumulation and adsorption, so this kind of shales show much lower gas content.
210
GUO Xusheng et al. / Petroleum Exploration and Development, 2020, 47(1): 204–213
Fig. 10.
Vertical distribution of physical properties of Wufeng–Longmaxi Formation shale layers in Well DYS1.
Fig. 11. SEM photos of shale samples from Wufeng–Longmaxi Formation. (a) Well DYS1, 4 226.77 m, organic matter and siliceous minerals in scattered distribution, deep-water shelf facies; (b) Well DYS1, 4 164.04 m, laminar organic matter and siliceous minerals, shallow-water shelf facies; (c) Well JY4, 2 575.19 m, nanometer scale organic pores, oval shape; (d) Well JY2, 2 561.43 m, organic matter pores in intergranular pores, in circular and oval shapes, weak compaction.
Apparently, biogenesis silicon is the key for development and preservation of organic pores. 4.3. Coupling and coexistence of micrometer scale intergranular pore and nanometer scale organic pore Observations of thin sections and SEM pictures show the high quality Wufeng–Longmaxi shale of deep-water shelf facies has good homogeneity, has no obvious laminar heterogeneity like that in Wufeng–Longmaxi Formation shale layers of shallow-water shelf facies, Permian Longtan Formation and Jurassic, and has organic matter and siliceous minerals in scattered distribution (Fig. 11a, 11b). The high silicon content in the siliceous shale increases the brittleness of the rock (Table 2), so during fracturing, this shale is more likely to form complicated and net-like pore-fissure system. Furthermore, the organic matter pores in intergranular pores are mostly nanometer scale and in nearly circular, oval, pit, meniscus and narrow fissure etc. shapes under electronic microscope, more commonly in cell-like irregular oval shape with good connectivity between each other (Fig. 11c, 11d). Table 2.
In summary, siliceous mineral framework pores and organic pores coexist in Wufeng–Longmaxi shale of deep-water shelf facies. Siliceous minerals in shale have high elastic modulus, low Poisson’s ratio, and good brittleness, which are conducive to the formation of reticular fracture network. In contrast, clay minerals and organic matter have low elastic modulus, high Poisson’s ratio, poor brittleness, and thus poor fracability (Table 2). During fracturing, brittle siliceous mineral grains will be fractured open first to form net-like fissure connecting the scattered and isolated quartz intergranular pores, while the organic pores, clay mineral pores and siliceous mineral framework pores are paragenetic, and organic pores and clay mineral pores have good connectivity, thus the fractured net fissures can connect with organic pores and clay mineral pores that store shale gas, forming channels of organic pore-intergranular pore-micro-fissure (Fig. 12) favorable for high production of shale gas. Hence, though the high quality shale of Wufeng–Longmaxi
Rock mechanic parameters correlation of different minerals (Data of organic matter is from reference [28]).
Mineral Silicon (Quartz) Clay minerals (mudstone) Organic matter (coal)
Elastic modulus/ GPa 69.40 24.10 10.50
Possion’s ratio 0.12 0.34 0.39
Normalized elastic modulus/GPa 84.86 20.14 0.71
211
Normalized Possion’s ratio 112.00 24.00 4.00
Brittleness index/% 98.43 22.07 2.36
GUO Xusheng et al. / Petroleum Exploration and Development, 2020, 47(1): 204–213
[2]
[3]
[4]
Fig. 12. Sketch map of relationship between siliceous framework intergranular pores and nano-pores in high quality shale reservoir of Fuling Shale Gas Field.
Formation with large depth (more than 4000 m) in China has higher thermal maturity than shale in medium-shallow depth (They have undergone similar maximum depth in geological history, but structural uplifting and erosion in the later stage lead to the current differences of them in depth), due to the hard biogenesis siliceous framework, the high quality shale with larger depth can maintain high porosity and high gas content, which are favorable for shale gas accumulation. The deep shale gas of Wufeng–Longmaxi Formation (at the depth of 4 0005 000 m) has resources of over 7×1012 m3 and great exploration potential.
5.
[6]
[7]
[8]
Conclusions
High quality shale of Wufeng–Longmaxi Formation at high thermal maturity has high hydrocarbon generation intensity and good material base. Good roof and floor conditions kept a large amount of crude oil generated early retained in the shale, and the gas from cracking of crude oil provides sufficient gas source, laying solid material foundation for shale gas reservoir with high abundance. Biogenesis silicon (opal A) of Wufeng–Longmaxi Formation in deep-water shelf facies transformed into crystalline quartz with high hardness at the early stage of diagenesis, at the same time a lot of micro intergranular pores were formed. Furthermore, the biogenetic siliceous framework has strong resistance to compaction, which not only provides space for crude oil charge at the early stage but also conditions for development and preservation of cell organic pores, so it is the key for the preservation of organic pores. Wufeng–Longmaxi siliceous shale of deep-water shelf facies has high brittleness, strong homogeneity, paragenetic micron scale siliceous intergranular pores and nanometer scale organic pores, which are the keys to form complicated net fissures by fracturing to connect effectively micron scale siliceous intergranular pores and realize the connectivity of siliceous intergranular nanometer scale organic pores, and high and stable production of shale gas.
References [1]
[5]
[9]
[10]
[11]
[12]
[13]
[14]
[15]
[16]
GUO Xusheng. Enrichment mechanism and exploration
212
technology of Jiaoshiba area in Fuling shale gas field. Beijing: Science Press, 2014. GUO Xusheng, HU Dongfeng, WEI Zhihong, et al. Discovery and exploration of Fuling shale gas field. China Petroleum Exploration, 2016, 21(3): 24–37. MA Xinhua, XIE Jun. The progress and prospects of shale gas exploration and exploitation in southern Sichuan Basin, NW China. Petroleum Exploration and Development, 2018, 45(1): 161–169. LIANG Xing, WANG Gaocheng, ZHANG Jiehui, et al. Highefficiency integrated shale gas development model of Zhaotong National Demonstration Zone and its practical enlightenment. China Petroleum Exploration, 2017, 22(1): 29–37. LIU Naizhen, WANG Guoyong. Shale gas sweet spot identification and precise geo-steering drilling in Weiyuan Block of Sichuan Basin, SW China. Petroleum Exploration and Development, 2016, 43(16): 978985. WANG Qiang, WEI Xiangfeng, WEI Fubin, et al. Overpressure in shale gas reservoirs of Wufeng–Longmaxi formations, Fuling area, southeastern Sichuan Basin. Petroleum Geology & Experiment, 2019, 41(3): 333–340. GUO X, HU D, LI Y, et al. Geological features and reservoiring mode of shale gas reservoirs in Longmaxi Formation of the Jiaoshiba Area. Acta Geologica Sinica (English Edition), 2014, 88(6): 1811–1821. GUO X, HU D, LI Y, et al. Technologies in discovery and exploration of Fuling shale gas field, China. Natural Resources, 2016, 7(5): 271. ZHANG Jinchuan, NIE Haikuan, XU Bo, et al. Geological condition of shale gas accumulation in Sichuan Basin. Natural Gas Industry, 2008, 28(2): 151–156. NIE Haikuan, ZHANG Jinchuan. Types and characteristics of shale gas reservoir: A case study of Lower Paleozoic in and around Sichuan Basin. Petroleum Geology and Experiment, 2011, 33(3): 219–225. WU Liming, DING Wenlong, ZHANG Jinchuan, et al. Fracture prediction of organic-enriched shale reservoir in lower Silurian Longmaxi Formation of Southeastern Chongqiong Area. Journal of Oil and Gas Technology, 2011, 33(9): 43–46. WEI Zhihong. Late fugitive emission of shale gas from Wufeng–Longmaxi formation in Sichuan Basin and its periphery. Oil and Gas Geology, 2015, 36(4): 659–665. HUANG Renchun, WEI Xiangfeng, WANG Qiang. Key factors of shale gas accumulation in Dingshan area of southeastern Sichuan Basin. Marine Origin Petroleum Geology, 2017, 22(2): 25–30. GUO Xusheng. Rules of two-factor enrichiment for marine shale gas in southern China: Understanding from the Longmaxi Formation shale gas in Sichuan Basin and its surrounding area. Acta Geologica Sinica, 2014, 88(7): 1209–1218. GAO Zhanjing, ZHENG Herong, HUANG Tao. Attributes of sweet spots in the Devonian Woodford shales in Oklahoma, USA. Petroleum Geology & Experiment, 2016, 38(3): 340–345. HAO Fang, CHEN Jianyu. Relationship between hydrocarbon potential and biological types of kerogen. Geoscience, 1993(1): 57–65.
GUO Xusheng et al. / Petroleum Exploration and Development, 2020, 47(1): 204–213
[17] GUO Xusheng, HU Dongfeng, LI Yuping, et al. Geological factors controlling shale gas enrichment and high production in Fuling shale gas field. Petroleum Exploration and Development, 2017, 44(4): 481–491. [18] BORJIGIN Tenger, SHEN Baojian, YU Lingjie, et al. Mechanisms of shale gas generation and accumulation in the Ordovician Wufeng-Longmaxi Formation, Sichuan Basin, SW China. Petroleum Exploration and Development, 2017, 44(1): 69–78. [19] XIAO Xianming, WANG Maolin, WEI Qiang, et al. Evaluation of Lower Paleozoic shale with shale gas prospect in south China. Natural Gas Geoscience, 2015, 26(8): 1433–1445. [20] DAI Jinxing, NI Yunyan, HUANG Shipeng. Discussion on the carbon isotopic reversal of alkane gases from the Huanglong Formation in the Sichuan Basin, China. Acta Petrolei Sinica, 2010, 31(5): 710–717. [21] LIU Ruobing. Typical features of the first giant shale gas field in China. Natural Gas Geoscience, 2015, 26(8): 1488–1498. [22] FENG Ziqi, LIU Dan, HUANG Shipeng, et al. Carbon isotopic composition of shale gas in the Silurian Longmaxi Formation of the Changning area, Sichuan Basin. Petroleum Exploration and Development, 2016, 43(5): 705–713. [23] ZHANG S, HE K, HU G, et al. Unique chemical and isotopic
213
[24]
[25] [26]
[27]
[28]
characteristics and origins of natural gases in the Paleozoic marine formations in the Sichuan Basin, SW China: Isotope fractionation of deep and high mature carbonate reservoir gases. Marine and Petroleum Geology, 2018, 89(Part 1): 68–82. MA Zhongliang, ZHENG Lunju, LI Zhiming. The thermocompression simulation experiment of source rock hydrocarbon generation and expulsion in formation porosity. Acta Sedimentologica Sinica, 2012, 30(2): 955–963. QIN Yachao. Research progress in early diagenesis of biogenic silica. Geological Review, 2010, 56(1): 89–98. FANG Shaoxian, HOU Fanghao, SUN Fengyu, et al. Study of diagenesis and pore evolution of sandstone in tertiary in Tiandong Depression in Bose Basin. Nature Gas Industry, 1993, 13(1): 32–41. QIN Xiaoyan, LIN Jin, WU Fuli. Diagenesis and porosity evolution of tight quartz sandstones in Benxi Formation, Southeast Ordos Basin. Journal of Northwest University (Natural Science Edition), 2016, 46(4): 579–584. HOU Lianlang, LIU Xiangjun, LIANG Lixi, et al. Triaxial compression mechanical properties and energy evolution characteristics of soft coal and rock in eastern Yunnan and western Guizhou. Journal of Safety Science and Technology, 2019, 15(2): 105–110.