- Email: [email protected]
Mismanagement of Chemical Agriculture in Malaysia from Legal Perspective
Available online at www.sciencedirect.com
ScienceDirect Procedia Economics and Finance 31 (2015) 640 – 650
/0 -0" /10"2"331)0 /04"05&)6/0 66310 - 03 7/"&3
, + (3! "+## ,% ( 2+ "8!"70##! 6!
! * ! # ( + ( ! +## ,% ( + ! #(# !%( #(#7 #7 ! ( ! + ! (87 # 7 ( #! ! ! $! ! 9# !! #! + ! ! * ! # 7 (#
#!%( ! (( 7 % ( *! %%#$%# +! (8 : $$9#*% ! !#+! !#%(! $#! 7! !!" (+! ! (( !# $ +7 +# 7 7 ( % ! # + , + ( +## ! %# # ! + + +! # ,% #! " ; <7 " ;7 " ;=>7 ?#% " ; <7 1# 6(% @!% " ;;<7 # + ( @%+ 3% " ;> % +# +# ! #% ! % ( * + ( * + + + ! ! +## +! (#
© 2015 Published by Elsevier B.V. This is an open access article under the CC BY-NC-ND license !"#! #$ !$% &' (http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-nc-nd/4.0/). # $%() * +,"-".! Peer-review under responsibility of Universiti Teknologi MARA Johor , + 73! "+##7&!7-+# 7"+##
" +6 "; <7 % #$ ! + % 7 :# ! % ( ! + ( # $# # ( 6 ( ";( % #$ ($% !( # (
2212-5671 © 2015 Published by Elsevier B.V. This is an open access article under the CC BY-NC-ND license (http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-nc-nd/4.0/).
Peer-review under responsibility of Universiti Teknologi MARA Johor doi:10.1016/S2212-5671(15)01152-1
Alizah Ali and Nurulhasni Shaari / Procedia Economics and Finance 31 (2015) 640 – 650
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
(!),& - .$ $//0 6 # 7 : ! # %7 ! $B ( +## ! ! !+! # (+ +# #! 7+ ! # (( ! % #! (8 7 ! 7 + !% % " ( % +! ! 9# !+9#%( #7 7 7 + + ( ! # + ( $ # !( %#+!( %! !# ( $# + 9# % 9#% " ! 7 ! % $ : + !# % (!(,& - & # $ /0 ! !% ( + ! + ! % + ! +! + ! + 7 # ( ( +! 7 #
641
642
Alizah Ali and Nurulhasni Shaari / Procedia Economics and Finance 31 (2015) 640 – 650
% :7 7 7 ( +""7 " !(+ * ( +! # %7 * # #% %$$( ! ! * 7 7 7 % ! # ( ( ! (%7 !!% ! # #% !!* " !(+ * ( ! # %7!%! #!!$# !% + ! (! !!* ( !( !*
(!1%
$ 2 # $ / ! ! +## # %! # #(( ( !# + $%+ 7$#! ((! # $C # #$B : 7 + # 5 #7 / (7 ! !(($%+ ( D= ! ; = ! ;; 4! 7 ;; ! +! (+ ( +! # (( ( *5(#$ 8# E/ (( !++ +!( D1+ ! ! 3 ! +! ( ++ ( !! +7 ( + ( + &#%7+! (2( (+ +7( + (# +"! +! !!# A# $(( !# : $% !!(( ! ( + # # !+ , (! +! # $%( ( # $# ! + ( # +# +# ! !! ( ! 8 ,#! 7 : ! % ( 7 < ( ! # ( &B2 -+ 7 6!$ *!! * % !
%+ ! # ! +##-$,7< / + # ! ! 7 7 % ! ! % B# * * (7 # %7 # + 7 + 7 $ % + 7 +# # $%(( + 7 ( *7!% ! !8 ( &%7 /( ! ! !+ 7 % * ! 9# # !7 + (!( ! #+!!( !$( !%7! ! %$ (!!# $ +,#! --7/( ! #$ # ! ( 7!! $! %((!9#%(! !
+!!% ! %# ! ( ! ! ! ( + # C! ! #
#! +7! ! # ! !: ! ! + *!!%$
1!) $$ 1!)!)2$$ / ! ! + + ! ,! ED 5 ! >=ED 3% ! ED 5 !
Alizah Ali and Nurulhasni Shaari / Procedia Economics and Finance 31 (2015) 640 – 650
( ! / (( @ " + 3! $D 3 ! , (D@ !$ +%# + (# D3 ! 3 D # 7"+ $D3 D62#7 3#+ !# D@" +C D,%8# 7 ! D #F% D@ ) D &% & 2( $#+ D '+ + !7 "+ &#+ $ " % ( + !# % 0 % ( % ! +$ 7!! +$((# % $##+ 7(
%! ! :%( % + !( # + # ! + + ! # ! * $#% # $# % # ! * 1!)!( &/$
# + % + + ! ,8$ = =ED !! ,!% ED & % ED 3 1:%! =E / (( # % ( (# + $ # + % + ( # $# % ( ! (# + ! * ! ( % (# &# ( % ! ! % $# ! #((! #! ( ! 1!)!1 34$ @$ * ! !+ + ! # ! + !# 7 ! % $#+ % (!$ ( * 9# 5 3! >ED ,6," ED 4#( " # >E & D4%! / % <E-# #@$ ($# ! ( 7<5 " <=ED 5# = =ED ,+ #(# ,!% E "% 0 % ( ! #(( $% B# ( + ( % + !$ " !!%# ( % + # $+!7! + * # $ ! (!%! #$( % +!$ % + +$# # + ! !# 7!$ % 1! ( !7 ! +# 7( * # + 7 %(!%# +(++ + ! 6 ( ! %!$ $# ! 7! +! ( % &#:% !% >E + D #:%% 0% ; E 6 ! % % : ! ! % ( + !$ % +! @$ (( 3+ # D #D +# # 3 + D ## !# D % + +D *# !D # B#+# D$(D ((
5!) / $/ 5!)!)6 / 6 6 ( "; < ! #(# !%!& (-+ (! !! #$ # #! (! ( ! 7 ! ( % ! + ( ! 7 :+ ( % + ( ! 7 !
643
644
Alizah Ali and Nurulhasni Shaari / Procedia Economics and Finance 31 (2015) 640 – 650
((% (%7! (!($# (! (!! ! +!! (( C! % + ( #(# + ! ! 7 ! + !#+! ! $ ! # 8 9# 6 =(!" !# ! 7 ! & # 9#% + # ! ! ! (#( ! > %7 ! & ! ( !! #$ #6 %7!$ *+ %!!+# %7!! #$((# (!# $ + (# ! +! # $ !#+! ( # *7 ! : $ #+! $% ! % + ( # + ! ! & % # % 9# ( ( /( ! & ( ! ! 7 ! & ! ( $% + + + # $ ! # ( ( + ! 1 ! ! ! 7 ! & ! + ! ! ( (! %(! 9# /( #(# (# + ! 7! + ! #$B# !$# !" +6 (!"7!# ! ( 7! #$B (!% ( ( !# ++ 7 #$ 9# 7 ( : % ( ( %!# ++$! 5!)!( / $/ / $"#
%7 ! ( ( + $
$% ! #(# # ! +##!# ! + 6 ( "; < ! ! #(# ! % ! & #(# ! &( + ! 7 ! & ! # ! ! % + # 6 (!" ! ! % #(#! ! # $(!:%(! ! * !# ! +!(@! # 9#!(( ( 8 + +! /(! 9# (7 %$+ !!% % ! % $ ( ! % % ( $ ( " % !! 6 (( $# 6 ! 6 ! ( 7! #$B (!% ( ( !# ++ 7 #$ 9# 7 ( : % ( ( %!# ++$! 5!)!12 64 #$ / $! 6 >(! "; < ! ! $ ! + # !" ! ! (( $7 ( 7 ((% ( (((%!# ++ 7 #$ 9# 7 ( % ( ( !# !# ++$! ! # 6 =( ";!! ! !! # ! " ! % %# ,% " % ! !! (( # !$# ! ! # 6 =>(!" ) ! +%7!(( # #(# #%! # #!8
Alizah Ali and Nurulhasni Shaari / Procedia Economics and Finance 31 (2015) 640 – 650
5!)!52 #$ % /$ 6 $ 6 < ( " ; < ! " + ( # !# + % !%! & ! $
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
645
646
Alizah Ali and Nurulhasni Shaari / Procedia Economics and Finance 31 (2015) 640 – 650
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
Alizah Ali and Nurulhasni Shaari / Procedia Economics and Finance 31 (2015) 640 – 650
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
647
648
Alizah Ali and Nurulhasni Shaari / Procedia Economics and Finance 31 (2015) 640 – 650
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
5!1!1!- , # 6 (!( # ! +! " 7!( ! ! * ( #! +!! !( !# *!
Alizah Ali and Nurulhasni Shaari / Procedia Economics and Finance 31 (2015) 640 – 650
# !! ! 5 $ %: !!$ (! 5!1!52 ! ( + ! ! % !% +! ( ! ! * + / +# ! *!! !$! (# * 5!1! $ 4 $$
! % $#% # $
+! (/ (% 3 "&* *, ! "8 D, 3 &- *2 # $
!$* < 6# " ! !% +(! !$ %
! " # + # +! " %$% 7 (# ! $ ( !# "% + (8 7(# + 7!$ 7 : 8 +9#% 9# %(# $ ! !! +## !# # ! ! + ! $@! #(# + ($ !# $ + + ! 7 7 !# + " $ ! ! # $ ! ( ( % # #! $* 7 7$ B# !!
% & " / # 7 # (!+! #(#7+! ! ( % ! ! + ! ! ! ! $ + ! + ! + ( ! ! !# $ # %! % % + # !! ( # ! + 7 #(#7 ! ( # $ $ + ! # ( + (+! / !!+ +## ! #+ + ! + (+##! !!8# (( !#$ ! 8 ! + !#$ %( #(# (!! $#! ! # $ ## # #( ! +# ! # ( !#$$(! !+ % ! ! #!+ % / ! ! # ( ! +! !# $ # 8 ! # $(( !+( # +!!! + %7 !! $76(%56!( +9# / ( + +# ! #% # + ( +!
649
650
Alizah Ali and Nurulhasni Shaari / Procedia Economics and Finance 31 (2015) 640 – 650
# ! ( !#$ : %& 7! #(#7 ! ( # $ ! ! #! + ! + ! +## #! ! %$ # %! # % !# + ! #$ &% ! $ ((7
# #! $ ' ( "
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
ScienceDirect Procedia Economics and Finance 31 (2015) 640 – 650
/0 -0" /10"2"331)0 /04"05&)6/0 66310 - 03 7/"&3
, + (3! "+## ,% ( 2+ "8!"70##! 6!
! * ! # ( + ( ! +## ,% ( + ! #(# !%( #(#7 #7 ! ( ! + ! (87 # 7 ( #! ! ! $! ! 9# !! #! + ! ! * ! # 7 (#
#!%( ! (( 7 % ( *! %%#$%# +! (8 : $$9#*% ! !#+! !#%(! $#! 7! !!" (+! ! (( !# $ +7 +# 7 7 ( % ! # + , + ( +## ! %# # ! + + +! # ,% #! " ; <7 " ;7 " ;=>7 ?#% " ; <7 1# 6(% @!% " ;;<7 # + ( @%+ 3% " ;> % +# +# ! #% ! % ( * + ( * + + + ! ! +## +! (#
© 2015 Published by Elsevier B.V. This is an open access article under the CC BY-NC-ND license !"#! #$ !$% &' (http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-nc-nd/4.0/). # $%() * +,"-".! Peer-review under responsibility of Universiti Teknologi MARA Johor , + 73! "+##7&!7-+# 7"+##
" +6 "; <7 % #$ ! + % 7 :# ! % ( ! + ( # $# # ( 6 ( ";( % #$ ($% !( # (
2212-5671 © 2015 Published by Elsevier B.V. This is an open access article under the CC BY-NC-ND license (http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-nc-nd/4.0/).
Peer-review under responsibility of Universiti Teknologi MARA Johor doi:10.1016/S2212-5671(15)01152-1
Alizah Ali and Nurulhasni Shaari / Procedia Economics and Finance 31 (2015) 640 – 650
2 # % 7 # 7 # 7 :# # #$ !! : # ( ! $ + ! 6 6!# ! *(+! !#+ ,% !! #!!! ( (+! # !( ! A ! ! # ( ! ! # ! + # !!# # #+!( +!(# +! !% ( !! +(( A(( + + ( + % ( ! #$ # " %7 !% % ! +## !$ # ! $ (+! % !+ *,% !$ 7 7(# + (8 "! ! %$ ! $%! %( %7 ! ) (# %7 ( 7 # ! ! # + ! +! ! #(# ! ! !# ! ! ! !# ! ( # ! 9# ( ( ! ! !% # + ! ( ! # ! $ + ! +## ! ( + + % ! % @ ! ! #$ !# ( + ! # : 8 #% ! ( 7 % ! ( %%! !## + 6 (!( !! % : 7! ! (# * +$ ! ! ,% #( ( % * % ** % # #!!( %! 8 !(7! ! 8 ! + $%! #(#7 !( ! #$ # +!+ ( / ,% 7 ! + + + ! # #! " ; <7 " ;7 " ;=>7 ?#% " ; <7 1# 6(% @!% " ;;<7 # + ( @%+ 3% " ;> % +# +# @ ! (# % " ; <7 " ;7 ?#%"; < 1# 6(% @!;;< ! "+#! 7 7 #(#7 # +7 +7 7 # (
(!),& - .$ $//0 6 # 7 : ! # %7 ! $B ( +## ! ! !+! # (+ +# #! 7+ ! # (( ! % #! (8 7 ! 7 + !% % " ( % +! ! 9# !+9#%( #7 7 7 + + ( ! # + ( $ # !( %#+!( %! !# ( $# + 9# % 9#% " ! 7 ! % $ : + !# % (!(,& - & # $ /0 ! !% ( + ! + ! % + ! +! + ! + 7 # ( ( +! 7 #
641
642
Alizah Ali and Nurulhasni Shaari / Procedia Economics and Finance 31 (2015) 640 – 650
% :7 7 7 ( +""7 " !(+ * ( +! # %7 * # #% %$$( ! ! * 7 7 7 % ! # ( ( ! (%7 !!% ! # #% !!* " !(+ * ( ! # %7!%! #!!$# !% + ! (! !!* ( !( !*
(!1%
$ 2 # $ / ! ! +## # %! # #(( ( !# + $%+ 7$#! ((! # $C # #$B : 7 + # 5 #7 / (7 ! !(($%+ ( D
%+ ! # ! +##-$,7< / + # ! ! 7 7 % ! ! % B# * * (7 # %7 # + 7 + 7 $ % + 7 +# # $%(( + 7 ( *7!% ! !8 ( &%7 /( ! ! !+ 7 % * ! 9# # !7 + (!( ! #+!!( !$( !%7! ! %$ (!!# $ +,#! --7/( ! #$ # ! ( 7!! $! %((!9#%(! !
+!!% ! %# ! ( ! ! ! ( + # C! ! #
#! +7! ! # ! !: ! ! + *!!%$
1!) $$ 1!)!)2$$ / ! ! + + ! ,! ED 5 ! >=ED 3% ! ED 5 !
Alizah Ali and Nurulhasni Shaari / Procedia Economics and Finance 31 (2015) 640 – 650
( ! / (( @ " + 3! $D 3 ! , (D@ !$ +%# + (# D3 ! 3 D # 7"+ $D3 D62#7 3#+ !# D@" +C D,%8# 7 ! D #F% D@ ) D &% & 2( $#+ D '+ + !7 "+ &#+ $ " % ( + !# % 0 % ( % ! +$ 7!! +$((# % $##+ 7(
%! ! :%( % + !( # + # ! + + ! # ! * $#% # $# % # ! * 1!)!( &/$
# + % + + ! ,8$ = =ED !! ,!% ED & % ED 3 1:%! =E / (( # % ( (# + $ # + % + ( # $# % ( ! (# + ! * ! ( % (# &# ( % ! ! % $# ! #((! #! ( ! 1!)!1 34$ @$ * ! !+ + ! # ! + !# 7 ! % $#+ % (!$ ( * 9# 5 3! >ED ,6," ED 4#( " # >E & D4%! / % <E-# #@$ ($# ! ( 7<5 " <=ED 5# = =ED ,+ #(# ,!% E "% 0 % ( ! #(( $% B# ( + ( % + !$ " !!%# ( % + # $+!7! + * # $ ! (!%! #$( % +!$ % + +$# # + ! !# 7!$ % 1! ( !7 ! +# 7( * # + 7 %(!%# +(++ + ! 6 ( ! %!$ $# ! 7! +! ( % &#:% !% >E + D #:%% 0% ; E 6 ! % % : ! ! % ( + !$ % +! @$ (( 3+ # D #D +# # 3 + D ## !# D % + +D *# !D # B#+# D$(D ((
5!) / $/ 5!)!)6 / 6 6 ( "; < ! #(# !%!& (-+ (! !! #$ # #! (! ( ! 7 ! ( % ! + ( ! 7 :+ ( % + ( ! 7 !
643
644
Alizah Ali and Nurulhasni Shaari / Procedia Economics and Finance 31 (2015) 640 – 650
((% (%7! (!($# (! (!! ! +!! (( C! % + ( #(# + ! ! 7 ! + !#+! ! $ ! # 8 9# 6 =(!" !# ! 7 ! & # 9#% + # ! ! ! (#( ! > %7 ! & ! ( !! #$ #6 %7!$ *+ %!!+# %7!! #$((# (!# $ + (# ! +! # $ !#+! ( # *7 ! : $ #+! $% ! % + ( # + ! ! & % # % 9# ( ( /( ! & ( ! ! 7 ! & ! ( $% + + + # $ ! # ( ( + ! 1 ! ! ! 7 ! & ! + ! ! ( (! %(! 9# /( #(# (# + ! 7! + ! #$B# !$# !" +6 (!"7!# ! ( 7! #$B (!% ( ( !# ++ 7 #$ 9# 7 ( : % ( ( %!# ++$! 5!)!( / $/ / $"#
%7 ! ( ( + $
$% ! #(# # ! +##!# ! + 6 ( "; < ! ! #(# ! % ! & #(# ! &( + ! 7 ! & ! # ! ! % + # 6 (!" ! ! % #(#! ! # $(!:%(! ! * !# ! +!(@! # 9#!(( ( 8 + +! /(! 9# (7 %$+ !!% % ! % $ ( ! % % ( $ ( " % !! 6 (( $# 6 ! 6 ! ( 7! #$B (!% ( ( !# ++ 7 #$ 9# 7 ( : % ( ( %!# ++$! 5!)!12 64 #$ / $! 6 >(! "; < ! ! $ ! + # !" ! ! (( $7 ( 7 ((% ( (((%!# ++ 7 #$ 9# 7 ( % ( ( !# !# ++$! ! # 6 =( ";!! ! !! # ! " ! % %# ,% " % ! !! (( # !$# ! ! # 6 =>(!" ) ! +%7!(( # #(# #%! # #!8
Alizah Ali and Nurulhasni Shaari / Procedia Economics and Finance 31 (2015) 640 – 650
5!)!52 #$ % /$ 6 $ 6 < ( " ; < ! " + ( # !# + % !%! & ! $
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
645
646
Alizah Ali and Nurulhasni Shaari / Procedia Economics and Finance 31 (2015) 640 – 650
! ( ! # ! !+ ( # !! $% # ( ! #7 7# : $ :# (( 7(!$# % (!7 # %7!# %(#$# +9# 9#! % 9# 9# $ ( #! 9# 6 > ( ! " ! % ! #$ ! $ +#% ( (( ! $ $ ( : + !# !# ++ ( : +(% $! (#!( : + !# ++%(%%!!(( #( $%!54 9# +! ! (! ! $ # ! - # 6 <( ?#%"; < $#!(( ( !+ + ! #(( % 6#$ : ! # !! !+ + ! ( ! % % ! % + % % !!9#7 + # / $#(! $ ! % (# 7+$+7 * 7 #+ 7 B ! # ( ! ( % ( 9# $$ :# (( !# $ + (!# +# $ %$ (# (! ! #((! 6 >(!" ! % ! #$ !$+#%( (( !$ $ ( : + !# !# ++ ( : +(% $! (#!( : + !# ++%( %%!!(( #( $%!54 9# +! ! (! ! $ # ! 6 ( ! " # $# ! # ( ! ! # !! # ( ! % % ! %+ % 7(! % !( 7 7 7 7 !7 $ *%(7 7 7$ !7$$ % 7 * +%!#+!! ++ 7!!% %7# % $ #! (!# ! #(! + $ $% ! ! $ 6#$ > ! % ! #$ !$+#%( (( !$$( : + !# !# ++ ( : +(% $! (#! ( : + !# ++ % ( % % ! ! (( #( $%!54 9# +! ! (! ! $ # ! 5!(6 " 5!(!)=4 $// .$ 2 $ " + ( " ;7 ! % $ $% ! ! ! ( ! / ( %7 ! $%! ( % ! # !! % $*$* ( #!# 7 ! $( 7 +! (!#! 7!( ! 7 ! 9# % ( ! ! # ( !! $% ! #! $9#D !#! ! ((:! + #! %! ( ! ( #! + $% ! #! + ! # 9#$ # ! #$ % #! !$ $%! ( !( !! #! !$ !$*
Alizah Ali and Nurulhasni Shaari / Procedia Economics and Finance 31 (2015) 640 – 650
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
647
648
Alizah Ali and Nurulhasni Shaari / Procedia Economics and Finance 31 (2015) 640 – 650
# ( ( !+ !! ! + !! ""7 6 >1# 6(%" @!3 ( 72$ +" 6(%56!1( @8# 3! -+# >(!9# #(# !6(%56! ! ( ( ! !8# ! # % ! :# + !8# #$ 6 > ! " 6(% 5 6! ! ! ( + !8# ! # ! :# + ! ( + ( D ( ( ! + ( ! !8# ! 7 ( # 7 ( (+! + # 7 # 7 ! + +7: # 7!% ! 7 $% %7 :+ ( 7 + ( 7 ( 7 ( 7+#% ( ! ( "! ( !! # 9# (6(%56! ( >(!/ # %3( !! # $ ! +#+ + ! +#+6 > ! # ! ! ! #$+# (( !7 7$$( : + !# ++ ( : + %$! 7 ! ( # +(( 7( : + !# ++ ( % % ( ! % # + !! ! (( # ( 5!(! 4/ 6 ( ";% ! % # +! % !$ #%! # (# (! / (( (! ! ! / !$ #(( ( %!+# ! ! ! !+! $# $!! ! #! $!+(+! % 5!1& 5!1!)- =4 .$ = ! # !6 ( "!$%!( $ ! ! ( #!! 5!1!(. /2%@$ ! : + ( ( ! % ! +! !# ( + ! #$ $%! !% # ! : ! * ! # ! : # 9# % ( (# ! : # ( ! ! % # $(( !# $ +7 7 7 !# + ! # % $ # ! (#
5!1!1!- , # 6 (!( # ! +! " 7!( ! ! * ( #! +!! !( !# *!
Alizah Ali and Nurulhasni Shaari / Procedia Economics and Finance 31 (2015) 640 – 650
# !! ! 5 $ %: !!$ (! 5!1!52 ! ( + ! ! % !% +! ( ! ! * + / +# ! *!! !$! (# * 5!1! $ 4 $$
! % $#% # $
+! (/ (% 3 "&* *, ! "8 D, 3 &- *2 # $
!$* < 6# " ! !% +(! !$ %
! " # + # +! " %$% 7 (# ! $ ( !# "% + (8 7(# + 7!$ 7 : 8 +9#% 9# %(# $ ! !! +## !# # ! ! + ! $@! #(# + ($ !# $ + + ! 7 7 !# + " $ ! ! # $ ! ( ( % # #! $* 7 7$ B# !!
% & " / # 7 # (!+! #(#7+! ! ( % ! ! + ! ! ! ! $ + ! + ! + ( ! ! !# $ # %! % % + # !! ( # ! + 7 #(#7 ! ( # $ $ + ! # ( + (+! / !!+ +## ! #+ + ! + (+##! !!8# (( !#$ ! 8 ! + !#$ %( #(# (!! $#! ! # $ ## # #( ! +# ! # ( !#$$(! !+ % ! ! #!+ % / ! ! # ( ! +! !# $ # 8 ! # $(( !+( # +!!! + %7 !! $76(%56!( +9# / ( + +# ! #% # + ( +!
649
650
Alizah Ali and Nurulhasni Shaari / Procedia Economics and Finance 31 (2015) 640 – 650
# ! ( !#$ : %& 7! #(#7 ! ( # $ ! ! #! + ! + ! +## #! ! %$ # %! # % !# + ! #$ &% ! $ ((7
# #! $ ' ( "
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