- Email: [email protected]
Mixed Linker Metal Organic Framework as an Efficient and Reusable Catalyst for Suzuki Miyaura Coupling Reaction
Available online at www.sciencedirect.com
ScienceDirect Procedia Chemistry 16 (2015) 8 – 14
"@F7D@3F;A@3>+K?BAE;G?A@BB>;76 :7?;EFDK "+
&;J76>;@=7D?7F3>AD93@;58D3?7IAD=3E3@788;5;7@F3@6D7GE34>7 53F3>KEF8AD+GLG=;&;K3GD35AGB>;@9D735F;A@ +;F;'GD:3L>;@#3>G66;@3$3D;?3:$3EE;?4/3@'3L;:3:/3@"4D3:;?3 "
"$4,38/'00,*&% $*&.$&2 .*5&12*3* &+./,/(* )"),"- ","82*" # .23*343&/' $*&.$&2 .*5&12*3* &+./,/(* )"),"- ","82*"
&'%' +7D;7E A8 ?7F3> AD93@;5 8D3?7IAD=E 8DA? @;FDA97@ 43E76 >;93@6 I7D7 EK@F:7E;L76 3E 788;5;7@F 3@6 D7GE34>7 53F3>KEF H;3 ?;J76 >;@=7D ?7F:A6E ,:7 F:7D?A9D3H;?7FD;5 EFG6K A8 F:7 ?;J76 >;@=7D ?7F3> AD93@;5 8D3?7IAD= &"0&( D7H73>E F:3F F:7 5A?B>7J7E 3D7 BAF7@F;3>F:7D?3>>KEF34>7?3F7D;3>E ,:7 B3>>36;G?EGBBADF76 53F3>KEFE 7J:;4;FE :;9: 53F3>KF;5 35F;H;FKFAI3D6F:7+GLG=;&;K3GD35DAEE 5AGB>;@9D735F;A@3@653@47D7GE76E7H7D3>F;?7EI;F:AGF3@KH;E;4>7>AEEA835F;H;FK7H7@38F7D8;H75A@E75GF;H7F;?7E © by Elsevier B.V. This is an open access article under the CC BY-NC-ND license N 2015
Published ,:7GF:ADE )G4>;E:764K >E7H;7D . (http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-nc-nd/4.0/). )77DD7H;7IG@67DD7EBA@E;4;>;FKA8*7E73D5: 7@F7D8AD :7?;EFDK"@6A@7E;3@"@EF;FGF7A8+5;7@57E Peer-review under responsibility of Research Center for Chemistry, Indonesian Institute of Sciences &86/1%2&;J76>;@=7D?7F3>AD93@;58D3?7IAD= :7F7DA97@7AGE53F3>KEF +GLG=;&;K3GD35AGB>;@9D735F;A@D7GE34>753F3>KEF
"'%#(' #" &7F3>AD93@;58D3?7IAD=E &( E 3D7 5DKEF3>>;@7BADAGEEA>;6F:3FD7EG>FE8DA?EFDA@9?7F3>>;93@65AAD6;@3F;A@ 3@6 :3H7BAF7@F;3>3BB>;53F;A@;@5>G6;@993EEFAD397 3@653F3>KEFE ,:7;?B>7?7@F3F;A@A8&( E;@53F3>KF;53BB>;53F;A@:3E D757@F>K 3FFD35F76 F:7 ;@F7D7EF A8 ?3@K 9DAGBE >F:AG9: ?AEF A8 F:7 5AGB>;@9 D735F;A@E :3H7 477@ 53DD;76 AGF 4K GE;@9 :A?A97@7AGEEKEF7?E:7F7DA97@7AGE53F3>KE;E:3E;@5D73E7;@67?3@66G7FAD75AH7DK3@6D7GE34;>;FKA8F:753F3>KEF ,:7 GE7A8&( E;@:7F7DA97@7AGE53F3>KE;E;E3H7DKBDA?;E;@94GFBDA434>KA@7A8F:7?AEF5:3>>7@9;@9 8;7>6EA83BB>;53F;A@ 8ADF:;E ;@F7D7EF;@95>3EEA8?3F7D;3>E ADF:;ED73EA@F:7D7:3E477@3@;@F7@E;H7D7E73D5:788ADF;@F:;E3D73
ADD7EBA@6;@93GF:AD -@;H7DE;F;,7=@A>A9;&* 35G>FKA8BB>;76+5;7@57E +:3:>3?&3>3KE;3 -"*,"%%1&22 =3D;?3:E3>3? G;F? 76G ?K$3D;?3:$3EE;? :3L>;@<3>G66;@9?3;> 5A? + 'GD:3L>;@ #3>G66;@
1876-6196 © 2015 Published by Elsevier B.V. This is an open access article under the CC BY-NC-ND license (http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-nc-nd/4.0/). Peer-review under responsibility of Research Center for Chemistry, Indonesian Institute of Sciences doi:10.1016/j.proche.2015.12.008
Siti Nurhazlin Jaluddin et al. / Procedia Chemistry 16 (2015) 8 – 14
G7 FA F:7 BD7E7@57 A8 35F;H7 3@6 E7>75F;H;FK A8 FD3@E;F;A@ ?7F3>E ;@ &( E F:7 :G97 BAF7@F;3> 53@ 47 7JB>A;F76 ;@ :7F7DA97@7AGE53F3>KE;E EF:7E7>75F;H;FK;EF:7?AEF;?BADF3@F873FGD7;@53F3>KE;E;F 53@47?3J;?;L76;8F:7E7>75F;H7 E;F7;E=@AI@3@6A@>KF:;EE;F7A853F3>KEF;EEK@F:7E;L76 '7H7DF:7>7EEF:74;997EFBDA4>7?;@EGBBADF7653F3>KE;EBDA57EE ;E ;@EF34;>;FKA8;@FDA6G5F;A@A85A?B>7J7EFAEGBBADF?3F7D;3>4753GE7A8BAD74>A5=3973@68D3?7IAD=5A>>3BE73EI7>>3E F:7;D F:7D?3> EF34;>;FK ,A AH7D5A?7 F:;E ;@EF34;>;FK ;EEG7 ;@FDA6G5F;A@ A8 ?;J76 >;@=7D ?7F3> AD93@;5 8D3?7IAD=E &"0&( E 3EB3>>36;G?EGBBADF7653F3>KEF :3H7477@F3=7@;@FA355AG@F ,:797@7D3>;673A8&"0&( E;E38AD?3F;A@ A8FIA;EAD75F;5G>3D>;@=7D?A>75G>7EF:3FD3@6A?>K5A?4;@76;@3?;J76EFDG5FGD7 "@F:;E3DF;5>7I7D7BADF36;D75F?;J;@9EK@F:7E;EEFD3F79KA8FIA6;887D7@F>;93@6E ; 7>;93@65A@F3;@;@9@;FDA97@ 9DAGBE 3@6F7D7BF:3>;535;6;@FA EA>GF;A@5A@F3;@;@9E3>F (GD;@F7D7EF>;7E;@EK@F:7E;L76&"0&( E5A@F3;@;@96;887D7@F@;FDA97@ >;93@63EB3>>36;G?EGBBADF7653F3>KEF "@F:;EEFG6KF:D77FKB7A8@;FDA97@9DAGBEG5:3E'!'( 3@6BKD;6;@7 I7D7 E7>75F76 3E 8G@5F;A@3>;L7 AD93@;5 >;93@6E 8AD &"0&( E ,:7 BD7B3D76 :7F7DA97@7AGE B3>>36;G? EGBBADF76 53F3>KEF )6 &"0&( '! & )6 &"0&( '( & 3@6)6 &"0&( BKD;6;@7 & I7D7 3BB>;76 ;@ F:7 +GLG=;&;K3GD3 5DAEE 5AGB>;@9D735F;A@
*$% !"'
"3&1*",2 @3>KF;53> 9D367 D7397@FE 3@6 EA>H7@FE I7D7 GE76 F:DAG9:AGF F:7 7JB7D;?7@F ,:7 EA>H7@FE I7D7 6D;76 3@6 6;EF;>>76 GE;@93EF3@63D6BDA576GD7 ,7D7BF:3>;535;63@6E7D;7EA8@;FDA97@43E7653D4AJK>;535;6>;93@6E @3?;@93?;@AF7D7BF:3>;5 35;6 BKD;6;@76;53D4AJK>;535;63@6@;FDAF7D7BF:3>;535;6 I7D7 BGD5:3E76 8DA?+;9?3>6D;5: 6;?7F:K>8AD?3?;67 & 2;@5 357F3F7 :7J3:K6D3F7 2@(5 ! ( D7397@F 9D367 3@6 )3>>36;G? 357F3F7 )6(5 I7D7 BGD5:3E768DA?&7D5= >>F:75:7?;53>EI7D7GE763ED757;H76I;F:AGF8GDF:7DBGD;8;53F;A@
8.3)&2*2/'! &"0&( EI7D7 EK@F:7E;L768A>>AI;@9F:7>;F7D3FGD7BDA576GD7 ,7D7BF:3>;535;6 ??A> 3@6 3?;@AF7D7BF:3>;5 35;6 ??A> I7D7 6;EEA>H76 ;@ ?% A8 & 3F DAA? F7?B7D3FGD7 ,:7DAG@6 4AFFA? 8>3E= I;F: F:7 EA>GF;A@ I3E B>3576 ;@FA 3 BD7:73F76 A;>43F: 3F 3 D735F;A@ F7?B7D3FGD7 A 8AD : ,:7 D7EG>F;@9 BD75;B;F3F7 I3E 8;>F7D76 A88 38F7D 5AA>;@96AI@FADAA?F7?B7D3FGD73@6I3E:76E7H7D3>F;?7EI;F: ?%A8 & 735:F;?7 "@383E:;A@E;?;>3DFAF:7BD7B3D3F;A@A8 F7D7BF:3>;535;6 ??A>3@6@;FDA53D4AJK>;535;6 ??A>I7D7 ?;J76 FA97F:7D I;F: 2@(5 ;@ & ?% 3F A 8AD : FA 388AD6 I:;>7 F7D7BF:3>;5 35;6 3@6 BKD;6;@7 6;53D4AJK>;535;6I7D7GE76FA388AD6
8.3)&2*2/' %!2$"3",823 ,:7BD76D;76&"0&( EI7D753>5;@76;@3;D3F?AEB:7D73F A 8AD:FAD7?AH7F:7EA>H7@FE8DA?F:7BAD7EA8F:7 ?3F7D;3> 8F7DI3D6E ??A>A8&"0&( EI3EEGEB7@676;@ ?%A8 & 8D7E:EA>GF;A@A8)6(5 ?9;@ ?%A8 & I3EE>AI>K366766DABI;E7FAF:;EEA>GF;A@G@67DH;9ADAGEEF;DD;@9 ,:7D7EG>F;@9E>GDDKI3EEF;DD763FDAA? F7?B7D3FGD7 8AD : ,:7 EA>;6 I3E 8;>F7D76 A88 3@6 I3E:76 8;H7 F;?7E I;F: ?% A8 & 735: ,:7@ F:7 D7EG>F;@9 ?3F7D;3>I3EBD7FD73F76;@H35GG?3F A 8AD:
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
9
10
Siti Nurhazlin Jaluddin et al. / Procedia Chemistry 16 (2015) 8 – 14
&"$)*.(".%1&42"#*,*383&23 ,:7:AF8;>FD3F;A@F7EFI3E6A@7BGDBAE7>KFA7J3?;@7F:7BD7E7@57A853F3>KF;53>>K35F;H7EB75;7EF:3F>735:;@96GD;@9 D735F;A@F;?7 ,:7D735F;A@?;JFGD73F A ;@F:7BD7E7@57A8 ??A>)6&"0&( I3E8;>F7D76A8838F7D:D735F;A@ F;?7 ,:7EA>;6I3EI3E:76I;F:I3F7D?%3@67F:3@A>?% GDF:7DEA>H7@F3@643E7I3E36676FAF:78;>FD3F73@6 D735F;A@5A@F;@G76;@F:734E7@57A853F3>KEF8AD3: "@ AD67D FA F7EF F:7 D7GE34;>;FK A8 F:7 53F3>KEF F:7 D735F;A@ I3E B7D8AD?76 3E 67E5D;476 GD;@9 F:7 3BB>;53F;A@ 7JB7D;?7@F F:7 53F3>KEF I3E D75AH7D76 3F F:7 7@6 A8 53F3>KF;5 D735F;A@ ,:7 53F3>KEF I3E I3E:76 I;F: 357FA@;FD;>7 57@FD;8G9763@66D;76;@AH7@3F A 8AD : ,:76D;7653F3>KEFI3EF:7@D7GE76;@F:7@7JFDG@
&( '&" &(&& #" )&1-/(1"5*-&31*$".",82*2 ,:7 &"0&( E ?3F7D;3>E I7D7 EG4<75F76 FA F:7D?A9D3H;?7FD;5 3@3>KE;E , FA 7H3>G3F7 F:7 F:7D?3> EF34;>;FK A8 5A?BAG@6E ,:7, A@ F:7 &"0&( E 5A?BAG@6E I7D7 B7D8AD?76 G@67D 3 @;FDA97@ 3F?AEB:7D7 ;@ 8>AI;@9 ' I;F: :73F;@9 D3F7 A8 A ?;@ E 67B;5F76 ;@ ;9 ;F E:AIE F:3F 5A?B>7J7E 3D7 EF34>7 7@AG9: 3F DAA? F7?B7D3FGD7 3@6 67?A@EFD3F76F:7D?A6K@3?;5EF34;>;FKA85A?B>7J7E GBFA A >>F:75A?B>7J7E E:AI F:78;DEFI7;9:F>AEE;@D3@97A8 A FA A I;F:?;@;?3>I7;9:F>AEEGBFA 8AD& 3@6 8AD& 3@6& ,:;E;ED7>3F76FAF:7>AEEA8F:7 7?476676 I3F7D 3@6 EA>H7@F & ;@ F:7 5A?BAG@6 ,:7D7 ;E @A I7;9:F >AEE :36 A55GDD76 G@F;> F:7 F7?B7D3FGD7 34AH7 A ;E D735:76 ,:7 E75A@6 I7;9:F EF3DF;@9 3F M A ;@6;53F7E F:7 A@E7F A8 675A?BAE;F;A@ A8 5A?B>7J7E ,:7 F:;D6 I7;9:F>AEEI3EA55GDD76 47FI77@ A FA A 6G7FA675A?BAE;F;A@A83@AD93@;5EB75;7E
;9 , B>AFEA8 &"0&( '! & &"0&( '( & 3@6&"0&( )KD;6;@7&
11
Siti Nurhazlin Jaluddin et al. / Procedia Chemistry 16 (2015) 8 – 14
"3",83*$"$3*5*38 ,34>7 +GLG=;&;K3GD35AGB>;@9D735F;A@A8 4DA?A47@L7@7 3@6B:7@K>4ADA@;535;6AH7D)6 &"0&( 53F3>KEF3
@FDK
4 4 4 5 6
0 & & & & & & & & & & &
)6 &"0&( 0 ,A>G7@7 :
3E7 $ ( F' '3 ( $ ( $ ( $ ( $ ( $ ( $ ( $ ( $ (
,7?BA
1;7>6
3
*735F;A@5A@6;F;A@E ??A>4DA?A47@L7@7 ??A>A8B:7@K>4ADA@;535;6 ??A>A843E7 ?A> A853F3>KEF : 3F :D735F;A@ 5 ?A>A8 )653F3>KEF 6 ?A>A8)653F3>KEF 4
"@AD67DFA;@FDA6G573 D7GE34>73@6788;5;7@F :7F7DA97@7AGE53F3>KEF8AD?;>6D735F;A@5A@6;F;A@EF:7EK@F:7E;L76)6 &"0&( I3E 7H3>G3F76 3E 3 53F3>KEF BD75GDEAD 8AD F:7 83?AGE +GLG=; &;K3GD3 5DAEE 5AGB>;@9 D735F;A@ ,:7 D735F;A@ 5A@6;F;A@EI7D7ABF;?;L764KGE;@94DA?A47@L7@73@6B:7@K>4ADA@;535;63EF:7?A67>EG4EFD3F7EFA7H3>G3F7F:778875FA8 6;887D7@FF7?B7D3FGD7 3@6 FKB7EA843E7E "@;F;3>>KFA>G7@7I3E5:AE7@3EF:7EA>H7@FFA BD7H7@F F:7>735:;@9A8)66GD;@9 53D4A@ 5AGB>;@9 D735F;A@ "F :3E 477@ D7BADF76 F:3F >735:;@9 A8 )6 A55GDE ;@ BA>3D EA>H7@FE B3DF;5G>3D>K ;@ & 3@6 ?7F:3@A> ,A7J3?;@7F:778875FA843E73E7D;7EA843E7EI7D7F3=7@;@FA5A@E;67D3F;A@ ,:7?AEF5A??A@43E7 8AD +GLG=;5AGB>;@9D735F;A@; 7$ ( I3E8AG@6FA47 ?AD7 78875F;H75A?B3D7FA F'3@6'3 ( 7@FD;7E ,:;E;E6G7 FA F:7 ;@F7D35F;A@ A8 ;@AD93@;5 43E7 F:3F ?AD7 78875F;H7 F:3@ AD93@;5 43E7E ;@ F:7 BD7E7@F EKEF7? 7EB;F7 A8 F:3F 3 E;9@;8;53@F78875FA8F:7D735F;A@F7?B7D3FGD7I3E8AG@6;@F:7D735F;A@7@FD;7E *3;E;@9F:7F7?B7D3FGD78DA? A FA A E;9@;8;53@F>KE:ADF7@76F:7D735F;A@F;?7 ,:7GE7A8 $ ( 3EF:743E73@6 ??A>)6 & 53F3>KEF;@ FA>G7@7 8ADD735F;A@3F A E:AI76F:7K;7>6 GBFA;@: "F;EE;9@;8;53@FFA355A?B>;E:9AA6K;7>6EGE;@9?;@;?G?3?AG@FEA853F3>KEF +;@57F:7 >A36;@93?AG@FA8)6;EF:7 ?AEF 5D;F;53> 835FAD I:;5: 38875FE F:7 53F3>KF;5 35F;H;FK I7 :3H7 7J3?;@76 F:7 78875F A8 53F3>KEF >A36;@9 47FI77@ 4DA?A47@L7@73@6B:7@K>4ADA@;535;63F A 75D73E;@9F:73?AG@FA853F3>KEF>A36;@993H73>AI7DK;7>6A8BDA6G5F 5A@H7DE;A@ 7@FD;7E (@F:743E;EA8F:7E7ABF;?;L3F;A@D7EG>FEI7D75AD676)6 & 53F3>KEFE:AIE:;9:7D788;5;7@5K A@+GLG=;&;K3GD35AGB>;@9D735F;A@5A?B3D76FA)6 & 3@6)6 &53F3>KEF ,:7BD7E7@57A83?;@A9DAGBA@F:7>;@=7D 5A?B>7J7EI3EBDAH76FA4747@78;5;3>8ADF:7EF34;>;L3F;A@A8)6EB75;7E4K7>75FDAEF3F;5;@F7D35F;A@
12
Siti Nurhazlin Jaluddin et al. / Procedia Chemistry 16 (2015) 8 – 14
,34>7 +GLG=;&;K3GD35AGB>;@9D735F;A@EA83DK>:3>;67E3@6B:7@K>4ADA@;535;6AH7D )6 & 53F3>KEF3
*
@FDK
3
* " " " D D D D > > >
)6 & $ ( ,A>G7@7 A
* ! (&7 ' ( ! (! (&7 !( ! !( D
*
,;?7:
1;7>6
*735F;A@5A@6;F;A@ DK>:3>;67E ??A>B:7@K>4ADA@;535;6 ??A>$ ( ??A> ?A>A8)6 & )6 &"0&( '!
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
E 7JB75F76 D735F;A@ A8 EG4EF;FGF76 4DA?A47@L7@7 D7CG;D76 >A@97D F;?7 F:3@ ;A6A47@L7 D735F;H;FK /:7@ F:7 EG4EF;FG7@F A8 4DA?A47@L7@7 3D7 H3D;76 8DA? 7>75FDA@ 6A@3F;@9 FA 7>75FDA@ I;F:6D3I;@9 9DAGBEF:7BDA6G5F K;7>6E I7D7E;9@;8;53@F>K E:AIE3@78875FA@F:7D735F;A@E 7@FD;7E "@F:;EEFG6K I7 8AG@6F:3F )6 & 53F3>KEF I3E 53B34>7 FA 35F;H3F7 F:7 5:>ADA47@L7@7 7@FD;7E I:;5: @AD?3>>K D7?3;@E G@D735F;H7 ;@ 5AGB>;@9D735F;A@E !AI7H7DF:7D735F;H;F;7EA85:>ADA47@L7@7 3@6;FE67D;H3F;H7E I;F: B:7@K>4ADA@;535;6EI7D78AG@6FA 47>7EEF:3@4DA?A3@6;A6A47@L7@73@63>EA D7CG;D76>A@97DF;?7 &"$)*.( ".% &42"#*,*38/'3)&$"3",823 ,:753F3>KF;535F;H;FKA8)6 & 53F3>KEFI3E7J3?;@768AD>735:;@93@6D7GE34;>;FKF7EF !AF8;>FD3F;A@F7EFI3E6A@7FA ?73EGD7F:7>735:;@9A8F:753F3>KEF6GD;@9D735F;A@ ,:7>;CG;6B:3E7A8F:7D735F;A@?;JFGD7I3E5A>>75F764K8;>FD3F;A@3F F:7D735F;A@F7?B7D3FGD738F7D:D735F;A@F;?7>AI5A@H7DE;A@>7H7> "FE:AI76F:75A@H7DE;A@A84;B:7@K>;@5D73E7 38F7D:D735F;A@ !AI7H7D38F7D :D735F;A@EF:7D73D7@A5A@H7DE;A@A8BDA6G5FI3E67F75F76 ,:;E;@6;53F7E F:3F H7DK>AI)6>735:;@9I3EA55GDD76 ,:7E?3>>B7D57@F3975A@H7DE;A@A84;B:7@K>5A@FD;4GF764K)6 & 53@47@79>75F76
,:7>7H7>A8D7GE34;>;FK;E3@;?BADF3@F835FAD8ADBD35F;53>3BB>;53F;A@EA8:7F7DA97@7AGE53F3>KEFE ,:7D7GE34;>;FKA8 AGD 53F3>KEF I3E ;@H7EF;93F76 8AD F:7 +GLG=;&;K3GD3 D735F;A@E G@67D F:7 ABF;?3> D735F;A@ 5A@6;F;A@E ,:7 53F3>KEF I3E D75AH7D764KE;?B>78;>FD3F;A@F75:@;CG738F7D735:7JB7D;?7@F ,:7 D7EG>FE E:AIE F:7 EGBBADF76 )6 & 53F3>KEF 53@ 47 73E;>KD75AH7D763@6 D7GE76;@F:;E 53D4A@5DAEE 5AGB>;@9D735F;A@A84DA?A47@L7@73@6B:7@K>4ADA@;535;68AD8;H75K5>7E I;F:AGF3@KH;E;4>7>AEEA835F;H;FK ;9
Siti Nurhazlin Jaluddin et al. / Procedia Chemistry 16 (2015) 8 – 14
;9GD7 *7GE34;>;FK35F;H;FKA8)6 &"0&( '! & 53F3>KEFFAI3D6EF:7+GLG=;&;K3GD3D735F;A@A84DA?A47@L7@73@6B:7@K>4ADA@;535;63F A
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
%"&
&G7>>7D - +5:G47DF & ,7;5: )GFF7D ! D@6F +$ )3EFD7 # &7F3> AD93@;5 8D3?7IAD=BDAEB75F;H7 ;@6GEFD;3> 3BB>;53F;A@E "3&1 )&-
#;3@9 &3>>3F , $DG?7;5: 3;=7D ABB7D43E76 ?7F3> AD93@;5 8D3?7IAD= 8AD F:7 835;>7 D;@9AB7@;@9 A8 7BAJ;67E /41.", /' $"3",823
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
13
14
Siti Nurhazlin Jaluddin et al. / Procedia Chemistry 16 (2015) 8 –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
3A + 2:3A ' +:G & :7 + )3>>36;G? @3@AB3DF;5>7E EGBBADF76 A@ &( :;9:>K 35F;H7 53F3>KEF 8AD 3 >;93@6 5ABB7D 8D77 +3@A93E:;D3 5AGB>;@9D735F;A@ 00,*&%"3",82*2&.&1",
2:AG # GA 0 ,G %; 0 +G@ ! CG7AGE +GLG=; 5AGB>;@9 D735F;A@ 53F3>KL76 4K I3F7DEA>G4>7 6;;?;@7 B6"" EKEF7?E /41.", /' 1("./-&3",,*$)&-*2318
+3:3 +7@*&3;FK,$A@7D+ @5:AD;@9A8)3>>36;G?A@FAEGD8357A8BADAGE&7F3>AD93@;58D3?7IAD=F:DAG9:)AEFEK@F:7E;E &A6;8;53F;A@ 3@6EFG6;7EA@+GLG=;3@6+F;>>75AGB>;@9D735F;A@G@67D:7F7DA97@7AGE5A@6;F;A@ -&1*$".)&-*$", /$*&38
%7>A@6 * @6D7IE , +G@ 1 +AI3 #* 5F;H3F;A@ A8 3DK> 5:>AD;67E 8AD EGLG=; 5DAEE5AGB>;@9 4K >;93@6>7EE :7F7DA97@7AGE B3>>36;G? 1(".*$,&33&12
ScienceDirect Procedia Chemistry 16 (2015) 8 – 14
"@F7D@3F;A@3>+K?BAE;G?A@BB>;76 :7?;EFDK "+
&;J76>;@=7D?7F3>AD93@;58D3?7IAD=3E3@788;5;7@F3@6D7GE34>7 53F3>KEF8AD+GLG=;&;K3GD35AGB>;@9D735F;A@ +;F;'GD:3L>;@#3>G66;@3$3D;?3:$3EE;?4/3@'3L;:3:/3@"4D3:;?3 "
"$4,38/'00,*&% $*&.$&2 .*5&12*3* &+./,/(* )"),"- ","82*" # .23*343&/' $*&.$&2 .*5&12*3* &+./,/(* )"),"- ","82*"
&'%' +7D;7E A8 ?7F3> AD93@;5 8D3?7IAD=E 8DA? @;FDA97@ 43E76 >;93@6 I7D7 EK@F:7E;L76 3E 788;5;7@F 3@6 D7GE34>7 53F3>KEF H;3 ?;J76 >;@=7D ?7F:A6E ,:7 F:7D?A9D3H;?7FD;5 EFG6K A8 F:7 ?;J76 >;@=7D ?7F3> AD93@;5 8D3?7IAD= &"0&( D7H73>E F:3F F:7 5A?B>7J7E 3D7 BAF7@F;3>F:7D?3>>KEF34>7?3F7D;3>E ,:7 B3>>36;G?EGBBADF76 53F3>KEFE 7J:;4;FE :;9: 53F3>KF;5 35F;H;FKFAI3D6F:7+GLG=;&;K3GD35DAEE 5AGB>;@9D735F;A@3@653@47D7GE76E7H7D3>F;?7EI;F:AGF3@KH;E;4>7>AEEA835F;H;FK7H7@38F7D8;H75A@E75GF;H7F;?7E © by Elsevier B.V. This is an open access article under the CC BY-NC-ND license N 2015
Published ,:7GF:ADE )G4>;E:764K >E7H;7D . (http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-nc-nd/4.0/). )77DD7H;7IG@67DD7EBA@E;4;>;FKA8*7E73D5: 7@F7D8AD :7?;EFDK"@6A@7E;3@"@EF;FGF7A8+5;7@57E Peer-review under responsibility of Research Center for Chemistry, Indonesian Institute of Sciences &86/1%2&;J76>;@=7D?7F3>AD93@;58D3?7IAD= :7F7DA97@7AGE53F3>KEF +GLG=;&;K3GD35AGB>;@9D735F;A@D7GE34>753F3>KEF
"'%#(' #" &7F3>AD93@;58D3?7IAD=E &( E 3D7 5DKEF3>>;@7BADAGEEA>;6F:3FD7EG>FE8DA?EFDA@9?7F3>>;93@65AAD6;@3F;A@ 3@6 :3H7BAF7@F;3>3BB>;53F;A@;@5>G6;@993EEFAD397 3@653F3>KEFE ,:7;?B>7?7@F3F;A@A8&( E;@53F3>KF;53BB>;53F;A@:3E D757@F>K 3FFD35F76 F:7 ;@F7D7EF A8 ?3@K 9DAGBE >F:AG9: ?AEF A8 F:7 5AGB>;@9 D735F;A@E :3H7 477@ 53DD;76 AGF 4K GE;@9 :A?A97@7AGEEKEF7?E:7F7DA97@7AGE53F3>KE;E:3E;@5D73E7;@67?3@66G7FAD75AH7DK3@6D7GE34;>;FKA8F:753F3>KEF ,:7 GE7A8&( E;@:7F7DA97@7AGE53F3>KE;E;E3H7DKBDA?;E;@94GFBDA434>KA@7A8F:7?AEF5:3>>7@9;@9 8;7>6EA83BB>;53F;A@ 8ADF:;E ;@F7D7EF;@95>3EEA8?3F7D;3>E ADF:;ED73EA@F:7D7:3E477@3@;@F7@E;H7D7E73D5:788ADF;@F:;E3D73
ADD7EBA@6;@93GF:AD -@;H7DE;F;,7=@A>A9;&* 35G>FKA8BB>;76+5;7@57E +:3:>3?&3>3KE;3 -"*,"%%1&22 =3D;?3:E3>3? G;F? 76G ?K$3D;?3:$3EE;? :3L>;@<3>G66;@9?3;> 5A? + 'GD:3L>;@ #3>G66;@
1876-6196 © 2015 Published by Elsevier B.V. This is an open access article under the CC BY-NC-ND license (http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-nc-nd/4.0/). Peer-review under responsibility of Research Center for Chemistry, Indonesian Institute of Sciences doi:10.1016/j.proche.2015.12.008
Siti Nurhazlin Jaluddin et al. / Procedia Chemistry 16 (2015) 8 – 14
G7 FA F:7 BD7E7@57 A8 35F;H7 3@6 E7>75F;H;FK A8 FD3@E;F;A@ ?7F3>E ;@ &( E F:7 :G97 BAF7@F;3> 53@ 47 7JB>A;F76 ;@ :7F7DA97@7AGE53F3>KE;E EF:7E7>75F;H;FK;EF:7?AEF;?BADF3@F873FGD7;@53F3>KE;E;F 53@47?3J;?;L76;8F:7E7>75F;H7 E;F7;E=@AI@3@6A@>KF:;EE;F7A853F3>KEF;EEK@F:7E;L76 '7H7DF:7>7EEF:74;997EFBDA4>7?;@EGBBADF7653F3>KE;EBDA57EE ;E ;@EF34;>;FKA8;@FDA6G5F;A@A85A?B>7J7EFAEGBBADF?3F7D;3>4753GE7A8BAD74>A5=3973@68D3?7IAD=5A>>3BE73EI7>>3E F:7;D F:7D?3> EF34;>;FK ,A AH7D5A?7 F:;E ;@EF34;>;FK ;EEG7 ;@FDA6G5F;A@ A8 ?;J76 >;@=7D ?7F3> AD93@;5 8D3?7IAD=E &"0&( E 3EB3>>36;G?EGBBADF7653F3>KEF :3H7477@F3=7@;@FA355AG@F ,:797@7D3>;673A8&"0&( E;E38AD?3F;A@ A8FIA;EAD75F;5G>3D>;@=7D?A>75G>7EF:3FD3@6A?>K5A?4;@76;@3?;J76EFDG5FGD7 "@F:;E3DF;5>7I7D7BADF36;D75F?;J;@9EK@F:7E;EEFD3F79KA8FIA6;887D7@F>;93@6E ; 7>;93@65A@F3;@;@9@;FDA97@ 9DAGBE 3@6F7D7BF:3>;535;6;@FA EA>GF;A@5A@F3;@;@9E3>F (GD;@F7D7EF>;7E;@EK@F:7E;L76&"0&( E5A@F3;@;@96;887D7@F@;FDA97@ >;93@63EB3>>36;G?EGBBADF7653F3>KEF "@F:;EEFG6KF:D77FKB7A8@;FDA97@9DAGBEG5:3E'!'( 3@6BKD;6;@7 I7D7 E7>75F76 3E 8G@5F;A@3>;L7 AD93@;5 >;93@6E 8AD &"0&( E ,:7 BD7B3D76 :7F7DA97@7AGE B3>>36;G? EGBBADF76 53F3>KEF )6 &"0&( '! & )6 &"0&( '( & 3@6)6 &"0&( BKD;6;@7 & I7D7 3BB>;76 ;@ F:7 +GLG=;&;K3GD3 5DAEE 5AGB>;@9D735F;A@
*$% !"'
"3&1*",2 @3>KF;53> 9D367 D7397@FE 3@6 EA>H7@FE I7D7 GE76 F:DAG9:AGF F:7 7JB7D;?7@F ,:7 EA>H7@FE I7D7 6D;76 3@6 6;EF;>>76 GE;@93EF3@63D6BDA576GD7 ,7D7BF:3>;535;63@6E7D;7EA8@;FDA97@43E7653D4AJK>;535;6>;93@6E @3?;@93?;@AF7D7BF:3>;5 35;6 BKD;6;@76;53D4AJK>;535;63@6@;FDAF7D7BF:3>;535;6 I7D7 BGD5:3E76 8DA?+;9?3>6D;5: 6;?7F:K>8AD?3?;67 & 2;@5 357F3F7 :7J3:K6D3F7 2@(5 ! ( D7397@F 9D367 3@6 )3>>36;G? 357F3F7 )6(5 I7D7 BGD5:3E768DA?&7D5= >>F:75:7?;53>EI7D7GE763ED757;H76I;F:AGF8GDF:7DBGD;8;53F;A@
8.3)&2*2/'! &"0&( EI7D7 EK@F:7E;L768A>>AI;@9F:7>;F7D3FGD7BDA576GD7 ,7D7BF:3>;535;6 ??A> 3@6 3?;@AF7D7BF:3>;5 35;6 ??A> I7D7 6;EEA>H76 ;@ ?% A8 & 3F DAA? F7?B7D3FGD7 ,:7DAG@6 4AFFA? 8>3E= I;F: F:7 EA>GF;A@ I3E B>3576 ;@FA 3 BD7:73F76 A;>43F: 3F 3 D735F;A@ F7?B7D3FGD7 A 8AD : ,:7 D7EG>F;@9 BD75;B;F3F7 I3E 8;>F7D76 A88 38F7D 5AA>;@96AI@FADAA?F7?B7D3FGD73@6I3E:76E7H7D3>F;?7EI;F: ?%A8 & 735:F;?7 "@383E:;A@E;?;>3DFAF:7BD7B3D3F;A@A8 F7D7BF:3>;535;6 ??A>3@6@;FDA53D4AJK>;535;6 ??A>I7D7 ?;J76 FA97F:7D I;F: 2@(5 ;@ & ?% 3F A 8AD : FA 388AD6 I:;>7 F7D7BF:3>;5 35;6 3@6 BKD;6;@7 6;53D4AJK>;535;6I7D7GE76FA388AD6
8.3)&2*2/' %!2$"3",823 ,:7BD76D;76&"0&( EI7D753>5;@76;@3;D3F?AEB:7D73F A 8AD:FAD7?AH7F:7EA>H7@FE8DA?F:7BAD7EA8F:7 ?3F7D;3> 8F7DI3D6E ??A>A8&"0&( EI3EEGEB7@676;@ ?%A8 & 8D7E:EA>GF;A@A8)6(5 ?9;@ ?%A8 & I3EE>AI>K366766DABI;E7FAF:;EEA>GF;A@G@67DH;9ADAGEEF;DD;@9 ,:7D7EG>F;@9E>GDDKI3EEF;DD763FDAA? F7?B7D3FGD7 8AD : ,:7 EA>;6 I3E 8;>F7D76 A88 3@6 I3E:76 8;H7 F;?7E I;F: ?% A8 & 735: ,:7@ F:7 D7EG>F;@9 ?3F7D;3>I3EBD7FD73F76;@H35GG?3F A 8AD:
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
9
10
Siti Nurhazlin Jaluddin et al. / Procedia Chemistry 16 (2015) 8 – 14
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
&( '&" &(&& #" )&1-/(1"5*-&31*$".",82*2 ,:7 &"0&( E ?3F7D;3>E I7D7 EG4<75F76 FA F:7D?A9D3H;?7FD;5 3@3>KE;E , FA 7H3>G3F7 F:7 F:7D?3> EF34;>;FK A8 5A?BAG@6E ,:7, A@ F:7 &"0&( E 5A?BAG@6E I7D7 B7D8AD?76 G@67D 3 @;FDA97@ 3F?AEB:7D7 ;@ 8>AI;@9 ' I;F: :73F;@9 D3F7 A8 A ?;@ E 67B;5F76 ;@ ;9 ;F E:AIE F:3F 5A?B>7J7E 3D7 EF34>7 7@AG9: 3F DAA? F7?B7D3FGD7 3@6 67?A@EFD3F76F:7D?A6K@3?;5EF34;>;FKA85A?B>7J7E GBFA A >>F:75A?B>7J7E E:AI F:78;DEFI7;9:F>AEE;@D3@97A8 A FA A I;F:?;@;?3>I7;9:F>AEEGBFA 8AD& 3@6 8AD& 3@6& ,:;E;ED7>3F76FAF:7>AEEA8F:7 7?476676 I3F7D 3@6 EA>H7@F & ;@ F:7 5A?BAG@6 ,:7D7 ;E @A I7;9:F >AEE :36 A55GDD76 G@F;> F:7 F7?B7D3FGD7 34AH7 A ;E D735:76 ,:7 E75A@6 I7;9:F EF3DF;@9 3F M A ;@6;53F7E F:7 A@E7F A8 675A?BAE;F;A@ A8 5A?B>7J7E ,:7 F:;D6 I7;9:F>AEEI3EA55GDD76 47FI77@ A FA A 6G7FA675A?BAE;F;A@A83@AD93@;5EB75;7E
;9 , B>AFEA8 &"0&( '! & &"0&( '( & 3@6&"0&( )KD;6;@7&
11
Siti Nurhazlin Jaluddin et al. / Procedia Chemistry 16 (2015) 8 – 14
"3",83*$"$3*5*38 ,34>7 +GLG=;&;K3GD35AGB>;@9D735F;A@A8 4DA?A47@L7@7 3@6B:7@K>4ADA@;535;6AH7D)6 &"0&( 53F3>KEF3
@FDK
4 4 4 5 6
0 & & & & & & & & & & &
)6 &"0&( 0 ,A>G7@7 :
3E7 $ ( F' '3 ( $ ( $ ( $ ( $ ( $ ( $ ( $ ( $ (
,7?BA
1;7>6
3
*735F;A@5A@6;F;A@E ??A>4DA?A47@L7@7 ??A>A8B:7@K>4ADA@;535;6 ??A>A843E7 ?A> A853F3>KEF : 3F :D735F;A@ 5 ?A>A8 )653F3>KEF 6 ?A>A8)653F3>KEF 4
"@AD67DFA;@FDA6G573 D7GE34>73@6788;5;7@F :7F7DA97@7AGE53F3>KEF8AD?;>6D735F;A@5A@6;F;A@EF:7EK@F:7E;L76)6 &"0&( I3E 7H3>G3F76 3E 3 53F3>KEF BD75GDEAD 8AD F:7 83?AGE +GLG=; &;K3GD3 5DAEE 5AGB>;@9 D735F;A@ ,:7 D735F;A@ 5A@6;F;A@EI7D7ABF;?;L764KGE;@94DA?A47@L7@73@6B:7@K>4ADA@;535;63EF:7?A67>EG4EFD3F7EFA7H3>G3F7F:778875FA8 6;887D7@FF7?B7D3FGD7 3@6 FKB7EA843E7E "@;F;3>>KFA>G7@7I3E5:AE7@3EF:7EA>H7@FFA BD7H7@F F:7>735:;@9A8)66GD;@9 53D4A@ 5AGB>;@9 D735F;A@ "F :3E 477@ D7BADF76 F:3F >735:;@9 A8 )6 A55GDE ;@ BA>3D EA>H7@FE B3DF;5G>3D>K ;@ & 3@6 ?7F:3@A> ,A7J3?;@7F:778875FA843E73E7D;7EA843E7EI7D7F3=7@;@FA5A@E;67D3F;A@ ,:7?AEF5A??A@43E7 8AD +GLG=;5AGB>;@9D735F;A@; 7$ ( I3E8AG@6FA47 ?AD7 78875F;H75A?B3D7FA F'3@6'3 ( 7@FD;7E ,:;E;E6G7 FA F:7 ;@F7D35F;A@ A8 ;@AD93@;5 43E7 F:3F ?AD7 78875F;H7 F:3@ AD93@;5 43E7E ;@ F:7 BD7E7@F EKEF7? 7EB;F7 A8 F:3F 3 E;9@;8;53@F78875FA8F:7D735F;A@F7?B7D3FGD7I3E8AG@6;@F:7D735F;A@7@FD;7E *3;E;@9F:7F7?B7D3FGD78DA? A FA A E;9@;8;53@F>KE:ADF7@76F:7D735F;A@F;?7 ,:7GE7A8 $ ( 3EF:743E73@6 ??A>)6 & 53F3>KEF;@ FA>G7@7 8ADD735F;A@3F A E:AI76F:7K;7>6 GBFA;@: "F;EE;9@;8;53@FFA355A?B>;E:9AA6K;7>6EGE;@9?;@;?G?3?AG@FEA853F3>KEF +;@57F:7 >A36;@93?AG@FA8)6;EF:7 ?AEF 5D;F;53> 835FAD I:;5: 38875FE F:7 53F3>KF;5 35F;H;FK I7 :3H7 7J3?;@76 F:7 78875F A8 53F3>KEF >A36;@9 47FI77@ 4DA?A47@L7@73@6B:7@K>4ADA@;535;63F A 75D73E;@9F:73?AG@FA853F3>KEF>A36;@993H73>AI7DK;7>6A8BDA6G5F 5A@H7DE;A@ 7@FD;7E (@F:743E;EA8F:7E7ABF;?;L3F;A@D7EG>FEI7D75AD676)6 & 53F3>KEFE:AIE:;9:7D788;5;7@5K A@+GLG=;&;K3GD35AGB>;@9D735F;A@5A?B3D76FA)6 & 3@6)6 &53F3>KEF ,:7BD7E7@57A83?;@A9DAGBA@F:7>;@=7D 5A?B>7J7EI3EBDAH76FA4747@78;5;3>8ADF:7EF34;>;L3F;A@A8)6EB75;7E4K7>75FDAEF3F;5;@F7D35F;A@
12
Siti Nurhazlin Jaluddin et al. / Procedia Chemistry 16 (2015) 8 – 14
,34>7 +GLG=;&;K3GD35AGB>;@9D735F;A@EA83DK>:3>;67E3@6B:7@K>4ADA@;535;6AH7D )6 & 53F3>KEF3
*
@FDK
3
* " " " D D D D > > >
)6 & $ ( ,A>G7@7 A
* ! (&7 ' ( ! (! (&7 !( ! !( D
*
,;?7:
1;7>6
*735F;A@5A@6;F;A@ DK>:3>;67E ??A>B:7@K>4ADA@;535;6 ??A>$ ( ??A> ?A>A8)6 & )6 &"0&( '!
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
E 7JB75F76 D735F;A@ A8 EG4EF;FGF76 4DA?A47@L7@7 D7CG;D76 >A@97D F;?7 F:3@ ;A6A47@L7 D735F;H;FK /:7@ F:7 EG4EF;FG7@F A8 4DA?A47@L7@7 3D7 H3D;76 8DA? 7>75FDA@ 6A@3F;@9 FA 7>75FDA@ I;F:6D3I;@9 9DAGBEF:7BDA6G5F K;7>6E I7D7E;9@;8;53@F>K E:AIE3@78875FA@F:7D735F;A@E 7@FD;7E "@F:;EEFG6K I7 8AG@6F:3F )6 & 53F3>KEF I3E 53B34>7 FA 35F;H3F7 F:7 5:>ADA47@L7@7 7@FD;7E I:;5: @AD?3>>K D7?3;@E G@D735F;H7 ;@ 5AGB>;@9D735F;A@E !AI7H7DF:7D735F;H;F;7EA85:>ADA47@L7@7 3@6;FE67D;H3F;H7E I;F: B:7@K>4ADA@;535;6EI7D78AG@6FA 47>7EEF:3@4DA?A3@6;A6A47@L7@73@63>EA D7CG;D76>A@97DF;?7 &"$)*.( ".% &42"#*,*38/'3)&$"3",823 ,:753F3>KF;535F;H;FKA8)6 & 53F3>KEFI3E7J3?;@768AD>735:;@93@6D7GE34;>;FKF7EF !AF8;>FD3F;A@F7EFI3E6A@7FA ?73EGD7F:7>735:;@9A8F:753F3>KEF6GD;@9D735F;A@ ,:7>;CG;6B:3E7A8F:7D735F;A@?;JFGD7I3E5A>>75F764K8;>FD3F;A@3F F:7D735F;A@F7?B7D3FGD738F7D:D735F;A@F;?7>AI5A@H7DE;A@>7H7> "FE:AI76F:75A@H7DE;A@A84;B:7@K>;@5D73E7 38F7D:D735F;A@ !AI7H7D38F7D :D735F;A@EF:7D73D7@A5A@H7DE;A@A8BDA6G5FI3E67F75F76 ,:;E;@6;53F7E F:3F H7DK>AI)6>735:;@9I3EA55GDD76 ,:7E?3>>B7D57@F3975A@H7DE;A@A84;B:7@K>5A@FD;4GF764K)6 & 53@47@79>75F76
,:7>7H7>A8D7GE34;>;FK;E3@;?BADF3@F835FAD8ADBD35F;53>3BB>;53F;A@EA8:7F7DA97@7AGE53F3>KEFE ,:7D7GE34;>;FKA8 AGD 53F3>KEF I3E ;@H7EF;93F76 8AD F:7 +GLG=;&;K3GD3 D735F;A@E G@67D F:7 ABF;?3> D735F;A@ 5A@6;F;A@E ,:7 53F3>KEF I3E D75AH7D764KE;?B>78;>FD3F;A@F75:@;CG738F7D735:7JB7D;?7@F ,:7 D7EG>FE E:AIE F:7 EGBBADF76 )6 & 53F3>KEF 53@ 47 73E;>KD75AH7D763@6 D7GE76;@F:;E 53D4A@5DAEE 5AGB>;@9D735F;A@A84DA?A47@L7@73@6B:7@K>4ADA@;535;68AD8;H75K5>7E I;F:AGF3@KH;E;4>7>AEEA835F;H;FK ;9
Siti Nurhazlin Jaluddin et al. / Procedia Chemistry 16 (2015) 8 – 14
;9GD7 *7GE34;>;FK35F;H;FKA8)6 &"0&( '! & 53F3>KEFFAI3D6EF:7+GLG=;&;K3GD3D735F;A@A84DA?A47@L7@73@6B:7@K>4ADA@;535;63F A
#" (& #" "@ F:;E IAD= F:D77 @;FDA97@ 43E76 ?;J76 >;@=7D ?7F3> AD93@;5 8D3?7IAD= &"0&( I7D7 EK@F:7E;L76 3E B3>>36;G? EGBBADF7653F3>KEF ,:7F:7D?3>9D3H;?7FD;5EFG6KA85A?B>7J7E7J:;4;FE:;9:F:7D?3>EF34;>;FKI:;5:?77FEF:767?3@68AD GF;>;L3F;A@3E53F3>KEFEGBBADF "@F:;E5A@FD;4GF;A@I7:3H7E:AI@F:3F)6&"0&( E53F3>KEF7J:;4;FEFKB;53>47:3H;ADA8 :7F7DA97@7AGE 53F3>KEFE ,:7E7 B3>>36;G? EGBBADF76 53F3>KEF 67?A@EFD3F76 :;9: 53F3>KF;5 35F;H;F;7E ;@ +GLG=;&;K3GD3 5DAEE5AGB>;@9 D735F;A@3@653@47D7GE76E7H7D3>F;?7EI;F:AGF3@KH;E;4>7>AEEA835F;H;FK "#) !"'& ,:;E IAD= I3E EGBBADF76 4K &;@;EFDK A8 !;9:7D 6G53F;A@ &3>3KE;3 3@6 -@;H7DE;F; ,7=@A>A9; &* D3@F 'A *&" * +
%"&
&G7>>7D - +5:G47DF & ,7;5: )GFF7D ! D@6F +$ )3EFD7 # &7F3> AD93@;5 8D3?7IAD=BDAEB75F;H7 ;@6GEFD;3> 3BB>;53F;A@E "3&1 )&-
#;3@9 &3>>3F , $DG?7;5: 3;=7D ABB7D43E76 ?7F3> AD93@;5 8D3?7IAD= 8AD F:7 835;>7 D;@9AB7@;@9 A8 7BAJ;67E /41.", /' $"3",823
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
13
14
Siti Nurhazlin Jaluddin et al. / Procedia Chemistry 16 (2015) 8 –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
3A + 2:3A ' +:G & :7 + )3>>36;G? @3@AB3DF;5>7E EGBBADF76 A@ &( :;9:>K 35F;H7 53F3>KEF 8AD 3 >;93@6 5ABB7D 8D77 +3@A93E:;D3 5AGB>;@9D735F;A@ 00,*&%"3",82*2&.&1",
2:AG # GA 0 ,G %; 0 +G@ ! CG7AGE +GLG=; 5AGB>;@9 D735F;A@ 53F3>KL76 4K I3F7DEA>G4>7 6;;?;@7 B6"" EKEF7?E /41.", /' 1("./-&3",,*$)&-*2318
+3:3 +7@*&3;FK,$A@7D+ @5:AD;@9A8)3>>36;G?A@FAEGD8357A8BADAGE&7F3>AD93@;58D3?7IAD=F:DAG9:)AEFEK@F:7E;E &A6;8;53F;A@ 3@6EFG6;7EA@+GLG=;3@6+F;>>75AGB>;@9D735F;A@G@67D:7F7DA97@7AGE5A@6;F;A@ -&1*$".)&-*$", /$*&38
%7>A@6 * @6D7IE , +G@ 1 +AI3 #* 5F;H3F;A@ A8 3DK> 5:>AD;67E 8AD EGLG=; 5DAEE5AGB>;@9 4K >;93@6>7EE :7F7DA97@7AGE B3>>36;G? 1(".*$,&33&12