Multilineage Cells from Apical Pulp of Human Tooth with Immature Apex

Multilineage Cells from Apical Pulp of Human Tooth with Immature Apex

0SBM4DJFODF*OUFSOBUJPOBM .BZ Q- $PQZSJHIUª +BQBOFTF4UPNBUPMPHZ4PDJFUZ"MM3JHIUT3FTFSWFE .VMUJMJOFBHF$FMMTGSPN"QJDBM1VM...
Download PDF
2MB Sizes 0 Downloads 62 Views
Report

0SBM4DJFODF*OUFSOBUJPOBM .BZ Q- $PQZSJHIUª +BQBOFTF4UPNBUPMPHZ4PDJFUZ"MM3JHIUT3FTFSWFE

.VMUJMJOFBHF$FMMTGSPN"QJDBM1VMQPG)VNBO5PPUI XJUI*NNBUVSF"QFY 4IJHFIJSP"CF 4BUPTIJ:BNBHVDIJBOE5FSVP"NBHBTB .BYJMMPGBDJBM4VSHFSZ .BYJMMPGBDJBM3FDPOTUSVDUJPOBOE'VODUJPO  %JWJTJPOPG.BYJMMPGBDJBMBOE/FDL3FDPOTUSVDUJPO  (SBEVBUF4DIPPM 5PLZP.FEJDBMBOE%FOUBM6OJWFSTJUZ

$IJFG 1SPGFTTPS5FSVP"NBHBTB

"CTUSBDU  5IF IVNBO UPPUI XJUI JNNBUVSF BQFY JT B EFWFMPQJOH PSHBO BWBJMBCMF GPS JOWFTUJHBUJPO  *O UIJT UPPUI FTQFDJBMMZJOUIFBQJDBMQVMQ UIFQSPMJGFSBUJPOBOEEJGGFSFOUJBUJPOPGWBSJPVTDFMMTBSFBDUJWBUFEUPNBLF BDPNQMFUFUPPUI8FJOWFTUJHBUFEUIFOPUJPOUIBUVOJRVFDFMMTBSFJODMVEFEJOUIFBQJDBMQVMQPGIVNBOUPPUI XJUI JNNBUVSF BQFY  )VNBO JNQBDUFE UIJSE NPMBST XJUI JNNBUVSF BQFY GSFTIMZ FYUSBDUFE GPS PSUIPEPOUJD SFBTPOT PS USFBUNFOU XFSF PCUBJOFE  )JTUPMPHJDBM BOBMZTFT SFWFBMFE UIBU #SE6JODPSQPSBUJOH DFMMT BOE DFMMT QPTJUJWFGPSUIFNFTFODIZNBMTUFNDFMMNBSLFST4)BOE4)XFSFMPDBUFEJOUIFTBNFSFHJPO5IFDFMMTGSPN UIFBQJDBMQVMQPGBIVNBOUPPUIXJUIJNNBUVSFBQFY EFTJHOBUFEIFSFBTBQJDBMQVMQEFSJWFEDFMMT "1%$T

 DBOCFDVMUVSFEFBTJMZJOWJUSPVOEFSPSEJOBSZTFSVNTVQQMFNFOUFEDVMUVSFDPOEJUJPO5IFFYQSFTTJPOPGTVS GBDFNBSLFSTPGFYQBOEFE"1%$TJTTJNJMBSUPUIBUPGCPOFNBSSPXNFTFODIZNBMTUFNDFMMT FYDFQUGPS$%E

αJOUFHSJO "1%$TEJGGFSFOUJBUFEJOUPNJOFSBMJ[FEDFMMT BEJQPDZUFT DIPOESPCMBTUTBOEOFVSBMDFMMTJOWJUSP "1%$T IBWF B IJHI DBQBDJUZ GPS QSPMJGFSBUJPO BOE NVMUJMJOFBHF QPUFOUJBM JO WJUSP  0VS SFTVMUT JOEJDBUF UIBU IVNBOUPPUIXJUIJNNBUVSFBQFYJTBQSFDJPVTUJTTVFTPVSDFGPSUIFSFTFBSDIPGIVNBOBEVMUTUFNDFMMTBOE GPSUIFBEWBODFNFOUPGEFOUBMBOESFHFOFSBUJWFNFEJDJOF ,FZXPSET BQJDBMQVMQ EFOUBMQVMQ EFWFMPQJOHUPPUI NVMUJMJOFBHFDFMMT

"CCSFWJBUJPO "1%$T BQJDBMQVMQEFSJWFEDFMMT $'; DFMMGSFF[POF %"+ EFOUJOBQJDBMQVMQKVODUJPO (MZ" HMZDPQIPMJO" 01/ PTUFPQPOUJO 5" UJQPGBQJDBMQVMQ

#41 CPOFTJBMPQSPUFJO $1 DFOUFSPGQVMQ %14$T EFOUBMQVMQTUFNDFMMT 0$/ PTUFPDBMDJO 15)S QBSBUIZSPJEIPSNPOFSFDFQUPS W8' WPO8JMMCSBOEGBDUPS

$" DFOUSBMBQJDBMQVMQ $3; DFMMSJDI[POF %411 EFOUJOTJBMPQIPTQIPQSPUFJO 0% PEPOUPCMBTUJD[POF 4)&%T TUFNDFMMTGSPNIVNBOFYGPMJBUFEEFDJEVPVTUFFUI

*OUSPEVDUJPO  4UFN DFMMT IBWF UIF VOJRVF DBQBDJUZ UP SFOFX UIFN  3FDFJWFE SFWJTFE BDDFQUFE  3FRVFTUT GPS SFQSJOUT  4BUPTIJ:BNBHVDIJ  .BYJMMPGBDJBM 4VS HFSZ .BYJMMPGBDJBM3FDPOTUSVDUJPOBOE'VODUJPO %JWJTJPOPG.BYJM MPGBDJBMBOE/FDL3FDPOTUSVDUJPO (SBEVBUF4DIPPM 5PLZP.FEJDBM BOE %FOUBM 6OJWFSTJUZ  oo :VTIJNB  #VOLZPLV  5PLZP o   +BQBO  1IPOF  ooo  'BY  ooo  &NBJMZBNBDIBONGT!UNEBDKQ

TFMWFTBOEUIFBCJMJUZUPGPSNTQFDJBMJ[FEDFMMUZQFT3F DFOUMZ  TUFN DFMMT IBWF SFDFJWFE NVDI BUUFOUJPO JO UIF mFMETPGEFWFMPQNFOUBMCJPMPHZ DFMMCJPMPHZBOEDMJOJDBM SFTFBSDI"OBEVMUTUFNDFMMJTBOVOEJGGFSFOUJBUFEDFMM UIBU DBO EJGGFSFOUJBUF JOUP UIF TQFDJBMJ[FE DFMM UZQF PG



0SBM4DJFODF*OUFSOBUJPOBM 7PM /P

UIFUJTTVFGSPNXIJDIJUPSJHJOBUFE5IFNPTUDPNNPOMZ

.BUFSJBMTBOE.FUIPET

TUVEJFEBEVMUTUFNDFMMUZQFJTUIBUGSPNCPOFNBSSPX   IFNBUPQPJFUJDTUFNDFMMTXIJDIGPSNCMPPEBOEJNNVOF

5PPUIBOEDFMMDVMUVSF

DFMMT BOENFTFODIZNBMTUFNDFMMTXIJDIOPSNBMMZGPSN

 5IFQSFTFOUTUVEZXBTBQQSPWFECZUIF&UIJDBM$PN

CPOF  DBSUJMBHF BOE GBU   .BOZ SFTFBSDIFST CFMJFWF

NJUUFFPG'BDVMUZPG%FOUJTUSZ 5PLZP.FEJDBMBOE%FO

UIBUBEVMUTUFNDFMMTBSFQSFTFOUJOGBSNPSFUJTTVFTPS

UBM 6OJWFSTJUZ  BOE BMM EPOPST HBWF JOGPSNFE DPOTFOU

HBOTUIBOPODFUIPVHIUBOEUIBUUIFTFDFMMTBSFDBQBCMF

)VNBO JNQBDUFE UIJSE NPMBST XJUI PQFO BQFY GSFTIMZ

PG EFWFMPQJOH JOUP NPSF LJOET PG DFMMT UIBO QSFWJPVTMZ

FYUSBDUFE GPS PSUIPEPOUJD SFBTPOT PS USFBUNFOU O 

UIPVHIU.VMUJMJOFBHFDFMMTIBWFCFFOJTPMBUFEGSPNBEJ

XFSF PCUBJOFE BU UIF 0SBM BOE .BYJMMPGBDJBM 4VSHFSZ

QPTFUJTTVF BSUFSJBMXBMM BOEVNCJMJDBMDPSECMPPE 

$MJOJDPG5PLZP.FEJDBMBOE%FOUBM6OJWFSTJUZ 'JH"

*OUFSFTUJOHMZ QMVSJQPUFOUNFTFODIZNBMTUFNDFMMTEFN

∼ $   'PS QSJNBSZ FYQMBOU DVMUVSF  BQJDBM QVMQ UJTTVF

POTUSBUFEUPCFDBQBCMFPGEJGGFSFOUJBUJOHJOWJUSPUPDFMMT

OPU GSBNFE JO CZ EFOUJO 'JH $  XBT TFQBSBUFE GSPN

PG UIF UISFF HFSN MBZFST XFSF TFMFDUFE GSPN BEVMU NV

UIFUJQPGSPPU BOEDVUJOUPBCPVU ×  × NNQJFDFT

 

 





SJOFCPOFNBSSPX 

"QJFDFPGUIFBQJDBMQVMQUJTTVFXBTQMBUFEPOBDVMUVSF

 %FOUBMQVMQ BTPGUUJTTVFPGNFTFODIZNBMPSJHJOGSPN

EJTIXJUI*TDPWFhT.PEJmFE%VMCFDDPhTNFEJVN *.%. 

OFVSBM DSFTU DFMMT  PDDVQJFT UIF DFOUSBM DIBNCFS PG UIF

USBDFMMVMBS HMZDPTBNJOPHMZDBOT  OFSWFT BOE CMPPE WFT

4JHNB $IFNJDBM $P  4U -PVJT  64"  TVQQMFNFOUFE XJUI  GFUBM CPWJOF TFSVN '#4  .PSFHBUF '$4  #VDLJOHIBN  6,  BOE  N. -HMVUBNJOF 8BLP 1VSF $IFNJDBM $P -UE  0TBLB  +BQBO   5IF NFEJVN XBT

TFMT  *UT GVODUJPO JT QSPUFDUJWF BOE SFQBSBUJWF  5IF

DIBOHFE FWFSZ  EBZT  "GUFS  XFFLT PG QSJNBSZ PVU

UPPUISFTQPOETEFGFOTJWFMZUPTFWFSFFSPTJPO DBSJFTBOE

HSPXUIDVMUVSF BQJDBMQVMQEFSJWFEDFMMT "1%$T XFSF

SFTUPSBUJWF QSPDFEVSFT CZ TUJNVMBUJOH UIF TFDSFUPSZ BD

EFUBDIFE CZ FYQPTVSF UP  USZQTJO BOE 

UJWJUZPGPEPOUPCMBTUTUPGPSNSFQBSBUJWFEFOUJO8IFO

&%5"5IFDFMMTXFSFUIFOTFFEFEBUBEFOTJUZPG ×

PEPOUPCMBTUT BSF JSSFWFSTJCMZ EBNBHFE  UIFZ BSF SF

 DFMMT PO B NN DVMUVSF EJTI  BOE DVMUVSFE XJUI

QMBDFE CZ B TFDPOE HFOFSBUJPO PG OFXMZ EJGGFSFOUJBUFE

*.%.TVQQMFNFOUFEXJUI'#4BOEN.-HMVUB

PEPOUPCMBTUMJLFDFMMTUIBUHJWFSJTFUPBSFQBSBUJWFEFO

NJOF 8BLP 8IFOUIFDFMMTXFSFSFBDIJOHDPOnVFODF 

UJO NBUSJY 5IJT TVHHFTUT UIF QSFTFODF PG SFTUJOH QSP

UIFZ XFSF TVCDVMUVSFE BT BCPWF  5IF "1%$T BU UIJSE

HFOJUPSPSTUFNDFMMTJOEFOUBMQVMQ FWFOUIPVHIUIFFY

QBTTBHFXBTVTFEGPSFBDIFYQFSJNFOU

UPPUI4USVDUVSBMMZ UIFEFOUBMQVMQJTBMPPTFDPOOFDUJWF UJTTVFXJUImCSPCMBTUT PEPOUPCMBTUT DPMMBHFOmCFST FY

BDU PSJHJO PG UIF DFMMT SFTQPOTJCMF GPS TFDSFUJPO PG UIF SFQBSBUJWFEFOUJONBUSJYIBTOPUCFFODMFBSMZJEFOUJmFE

5PPUIPSHBODVMUVSFBOE#SE6MBCFMJOH

3FDFOUMZ BNVMUJMJOFBHFQPQVMBUJPOPGDFMMTXBTJTPMBUFE

 'PSMBCFMJOH#SE6 UIFFYUSBDUFEUFFUIXFSFJNNFEJ

GSPN UIF EFOUBM QVMQ PG B IVNBO NBUVSF QFSNBOFOU

BUFMZ DVMUVSFE JO *.%. 4JHNB  TVQQMFNFOUFE XJUI

 

UPPUI



BOEBIVNBOFYGPMJBUFEEFDJEVPVTUPPUI 5IF

 '#4 BOE  N. -HMVUBNJOF 8BLP  BOE  μ.

EFOUBMQVMQJTUIPVHIUUPCFTPVSDFPGBEVMUTUFNDFMMT

#SE6 4JHNB GPSI5IFUFFUIXFSFUIFOmYFEJO

 *OUIJTTUVEZ XFGPDVTBUUFOUJPOPOUIFBQJDBMQVMQPG

QBSBGPSNBMEFIZEFBU℃GPSIBOEEFOUBMQVMQTTFQ

BIVNBOUPPUIXJUIJNNBUVSFBQFY5IFIVNBOUPPUI

BSBUFE GSPN DSPXO BOE SPPU XFSF FNCFEEFE JO 5JTTVF

XJUI JNNBUVSF BQFY JT B EFWFMPQJOH PSHBO BOE B EZ

5&, 0$5 DPNQPVOE 4BLVSB 'JOFUFDIOJDBM $P -UE 

OBNJD CJPMPHJDBM SFBDUJPO JODMVEJOH QSPMJGFSBUJPO BOE

5PLZP  +BQBO   5IF  ∼ μN TFDUJPOT XFSF VTFE GPS

EJGGFSFOUJBUJPOPGTUFNDFMMTPDDVSTJOUIFBQJDBMQVMQUP

IFNBUPYZMJOFPTJOBOEJNNVOPIJTUPDIFNJDBMTUBJOJOH

DPNQMFUF SPPU GPSNBUJPO  5IF BQJDBM QVMQ PG B IVNBO UPPUIXJUIJNNBUVSFBQFY UIFSFGPSF DPVMEQPTTJCMZJO

(SPXUIPG"1%$T

DMVEF VOJRVF IVNBO BEVMU TUFN DFMMT  8F SFQPSU IFSF

 "U QSJNBSZ FYQMBOU DVMUVSF  XF NBSLFE UIF FEHF PG

UIF IJTUPMPHJDBM BOBMZTJT PG B IVNBO UPPUI XJUI JNNB

UIF DFMM TIFFU PO UIF CPUUPN PG UIF DVMUVSF EJTI 5IF

UVSFBQFY BOEUIFQSPMJGFSBUJPOBOEDIBSBDUFSJ[BUJPOPG

HSPXUIPG"1%$TXBTDBMDVMBUFECZNFBTVSJOHUIFBSFB

DFMMTEFSJWFEGSPNUIFBQJDBMQVMQ

PGDFMMTIFFUTVTJOH4DJPO*NBHFBUEBZT      BOE  .55BTTBZ 5IFUIJSEQBTTBHFPG"1%$TXBTTFFEFE

.BZ 

Multilineage Cells from Human Apical Pulp



'JH $IBSBDUFSJ[BUJPOPGBQJDBMQVMQUJTTVFPGUIFIVNBOUPPUIJNNBUVSFBQFY

"  1BOPSBNJD 91 PG UIF IVNBO JNQBDUFE UIJSE NPMBS XJUI JNNBUVSF BQFY BSSPX  #  4VSHJDBM UFDIOJRVF PG FYUSBDUJPO PG UIF JNQBDUFE MPXFS UIJSE NPMBS $  5IF FYUSBDUFE UPPUI XJUI JNNBUVSF BQFY"SSPXJOEJDBUFT BQJDBMQVMQ UJTTVFOPU GSBNFEJO CZ EFOUJO %  )FNBUPYZMJOFPTJOTUBJOJOHPG EFDBMDJmFEUPPUIhTDSPXOSFHJPO & *OUIFDSPXOBSFB EFOUBMQVMQXBTEJWJEFEJOUPGPVSMBZFST  PEPO UPCMBTUJD[POF 0%

DFMMGSFF[POF UIF[POFPG8FJM  $';

DFMMSJDI[POF $3; BOEDFOUFSPGQVMQ $1  ' )FNBUPYZMJOFPTJOTUBJOJOHPGBQJDBMQVMQXJUIJNNBUVSFBQFY0%  PEPOUCMBTUJDMBZFS ( )F NBUPYZMJOFPTJO TUBJOJOH PG UIF TFDUJPO PG BQJDBM QVMQ TFQBSBUFE GSPN UIF SPPU 5P DIBSBDUFSJ[F BQJDBM QVMQ XFEJWJEFEBQJDBMQVMQUJTTVFJOUPSFHJPOT  EFOUJOBQJDBMQVMQKVODUJPO %"+

DFOUFSPGBQJDBM QVMQ $" BOEUJQPGBQJDBMQVMQ 5" %  EFOUJO0SJHJOBMNBHOJmDBUJPO % (  ×& '  ×

BUBEFOTJUZPGDFMMTXFMMJOXFMMDVMUVSFQMBUFT

5IF NFEJVN XBT SFNPWFE  BOE UIF DFMMT XFSF SJOTFE

.55 BTTBZ XBT QFSGPSNFE FWFSZ  EBZT  #SJFnZ  UIF

UXJDF XJUI 1#4  mYFE XJUI NFUIBOPM BOE TUBJOFE XJUI

DFMMTXFSFJODVCBUFEJOBTPMVUJPODPOUBJOJOH  EJ NFUIZMUIJB[PMZM   EJQIFOZM UFUSB[PMJVN CSPNJEF

8SJHIU 4UBJO TPMVUJPO 8BLP  "GUFS TUBJOJOH  UIF DFMMT XFSF XBTIFE XJUI EJTUJMMFE XBUFS  BOE UIF OVNCFS PG

GPSIBU℃"GUFSUIFTPMVUJPOXBTSFNPWFE μM

DPMPOJFTXBTDPVOUFE

PG/)$MJTPQSPQBOPMXBTBEEFEBOEUIFQMBUFXBT TIBLFOGPST5IFQMBUFXBTUIFOTVCKFDUFEUPNFB

$ZUPLJOFT

TVSFBCTPSCBODFBUONUFTUXBWFMFOHUIBOEON

 3FDPNCJOBOU IVNBO SI  CPOF NPSQIPHFOFUJD QSP

SFGFSFODFXBWFMFOHUIVTJOHBNJDSPQMBUFSFBEFS #JP3BE .PEFM    5IF DBMJCSBUJPO DVSWF GPS UIF OVNCFST PG

UFJO #.1

SIOFSWFHSPXUIGBDUPS /('

SIUSBOT

DFMMT XBT QSFQBSFE CZ UIF TBNF .55 BTTBZ QSPDFEVSF

CMBTU HSPXUI GBDUPS C'('  XFSF QVSDIBTFE GSPN 3%

VTJOHUIFTBNFDFMMT

4ZTUFNT .JOOFBQPMJT ./ 

GPSNJOH HSPXUI GBDUPSβ 5('β  BOE SICBTJD mCSP

 $'6' BTTBZ  5IF "1%$T XBT QMBUFE BU          BOE  DFMMT PO NN DVMUVSF

"OUJCPEJFT

EJTIFT  BOE DVMUVSFE XJUI *.%. TVQQMFNFOUFE XJUI

 "OUJCPEJFT BHBJOTU IVNBO OFTUJO  5VK BOE 'ML

 '#4 BOE  N. -HMVUBNJOF 8BLP  GPS  EBZT

,%3XFSFQVSDIBTFEGSPN3%4ZTUFNT .JOOFBQPMJT 



0SBM4DJFODF*OUFSOBUJPOBM 7PM /P

./  "OUJCPEJFT BHBJOTU IVNBO UZQF ** DPMMBHFO XFSF

EJUJPO  NJOFSBMJ[FE NBUSJY XBT BMTP FWBMVBUFE CZ WPO

QVSDIBTFEGSPN4BOUB$SV[#JPUFDIOPMPHZ 4BOUB$SV[  $" "OUJCPEJFT BHBJOTU IVNBO BOUJHFOT $%  $% 

,PTTBTUBJOJOHVTJOHTJMWFSOJUSBUF 8BLP JOBEBSL

$%  $%  $%  $%  $%  $%C  $%E 

GPSNJO"MLBMJOFQIPTQIBUBTF "-1 BDUJWJUZXBTEF

$% $% $% $% HMZDPQIPMJO" (MZ"

WPO

UFSNJOFE JO DFMM MZTBUFT PCUBJOFE CZ USFBUJOH DFMMT XJUI

8JMMCSBOE GBDUPS W8'

 HMJBM mCSJMMBSZ BDJEJD QSPUFJO ('"1

 OFSWF HSPXUI GBDUPS SFDFQUPSQ /('3Q /53 OFVSPUSPQIJD SFDFQUPS  BOE #SE6 XFSF QVSDIBTFE

$FM-ZUJD5.. NBNNBMJBO DFMM MZTJT &YUSBDUJPO SFBHFOU

GSPN#FDUPO%JDLJOTPO"OUJCPEJFTBHBJOTUIVNBOBOUJ

BSFFYQSFTTFEJOμNPMPGQOJUSPQIFOPMQSPEVDFEQFS

HFO4) BOE4)XFSFPCUBJOFEGSPN4)BOE4)

NJO BOE OPSNBMJ[FE UP QSPUFJO DPOUFOU  'PS RVBOUJUB

IZCSJEPNBDFMMMJOFT "NFSJDBO5ZQF$VMUVSF$PMMFDUJPO 

UJWF $B  EFUFSNJOBUJPO  DFMM MBZFST XFSF XBTIFE UISFF

3PDLWJMMF .% 

UJNFTXJUI1#4 BOEEFDBMDJmFEXJUI/)$MGPSI

CPYGPSNJO GPMMPXFECZTPEJVNDBSCPOBUF 8BLP 

4JHNB   5IF &-*4"CBTFE NFUIPE XBT QFSGPSNFE BD DPSEJOHUPUIFNBOVGBDUVSFShTQSPUPDPM 4JHNB 3FTVMUT

BU℃5IFDPODFOUSBUJPOPGDBMDJVNJO)$MTVQFSOB *NNVOPnVPSFTDFODF

UBOUT XBT NFBTVSFE CZ UIF PDSFTPMQIUIBMFJO DPNQMFY

 $FMMTXFSFmYFEPWFSOJHIUXJUIQBSBGPSNBMEFIZEF

POF NFUIPE VTJOH B $BMDJVN $5FTU ,JU 8BLP   5IF

BU ℃ BOE XBTIFE UXJDF XJUI 5#45  $FMMT XFSF JODV

QSPUFJODPOUFOUXBTNFBTVSFEVTJOHB#JP3BE1SPUFJO

CBUFEJO5#45TLJNNJMLTPMVUJPOGPSNJOUPQSF

"TTBZ ,JU #JP3BE -BCPSBUPSJFT  )FSDVMFT  $"  64" 

WFOUOPOTQFDJmDCJOEJOHPGBOUJCPEJFT5IFTMJEFTBOE

BDDPSEJOHUPUIFNBOVGBDUVSFShTJOTUSVDUJPOT

EJTIFT XFSF JODVCBUFE XJUI NPVTF QSJNBSZ BOUJCPEJFT

 "EJQPHFOJD EJGGFSFOUJBUJPO  8F GPMMPXFE UIF NFUIPE

BHBJOTU IVNBO OFTUJO 

 IVNBO 5VK 

 IV NBO ('"1 

 IVNBO UZQF Ⅱ DPMMBHFO 

 #SE6 

4)PS4)GPSI GPMMPXFECZnVPSFTDFJO JTPUIJPDZBOBUF '*5$  PS SIPEBNJOFDPVQMFE HPBU BOUJ

QSFWJPVTMZSFQPSUFEo5IFNFEJVNXBTDIBOHFEFWFSZ  EBZT GPS  XFFLT  'PS PJMSFE 0 TUBJOJOH  DFMMT XFSF mYFE XJUI  GPSNBMEFIZEF  TUBJOFE XJUI PJMSFE 0

NPVTF*H(TFDPOEBSZBOUJCPEJFTGPSI#FUXFFOJODV

8BLP GPSNJO UIFODPVOUFSTUBJOFEXJUI.BZFSIF NBUPYZMJO .VUP1VSF$IFNJDBMT$P 5PLZP +BQBO GPS

CBUJPOT UIFTMJEFTBOEEJTIFTXFSFXBTIFEXJUI1#4

NJO  $IPOESPHFOJDEJGGFSFOUJBUJPO 8FGPMMPXFEUIFNFUIPE

'MPXDZUPNFUSZ

QSFWJPVTMZSFQPSUFE5IFNFEJVNXBTDIBOHFEFWFSZ

 'PS DFMM TVSGBDF BOUJHFO QIFOPUZQJOH  UIF UIJSE QBT

EBZT GPS  XFFLT  $IPOESPHFOJD EJGGFSFOUJBUJPO XBT

TBHFDFMMTXFSFEFUBDIFEBOETUBJOFEXJUI'*5$DPVQMFE

FWBMVBUFE BGUFS QFMMFUT XFSF mYFE JO  QBSBGPSNBMEF

BOUJCPEJFT BOE BOBMZ[FE XJUI '"$4 $BMJCVS #FDUPO %JDLJOTPO 

IZEF BOE FNCFEEFE JO 0$5 DPNQPVOE #MPDLT XFSF DVUBOETFDUJPOTTUBJOFEXJUI5PMVJEJOCMVF .VUP1VSF $IFNJDBMT$P-UE 5PLZP+BQBO 

*OWJUSPEJGGFSFOUJBUJPO

 /FVSPHFOJD EJGGFSFOUJBUJPO  8F GPMMPXFE UIF NFUIPET

 .JOFSBMJ[FE DFMM EJGGFSFOUJBUJPO  "1%$T XFSF QMBUFE

QSFWJPVTMZ SFQPSUFE XJUI TPNF NPEJmDBUJPOT #SJFnZ 



BU  ×   DFMMT PO UIF NN DVMUVSF EJTI BOE DVM

"1%$T XFSF QMBUFE BU  ×  DFMMT PO UIF NN

UVSFEBUTVCDPOnVFODZ$FMMTXFSFUIFODVMUVSFEJOBM

DVMUVSF EJTI BOE DVMUVSFE BU TVCDPOnVFODZ  UIFO UIF

QIBNPEJmFE FTTFOUJBM NFEJVN α.&.  4JHNB  TVQ

DFMMT XFSF DVMUVSFE JO IJHIHMVDPTF %VMCFDDPhT .PEJmFE

QMFNFOUFEXJUI'#4 N.-HMVUBNJO 8BLP

 N. BTDPSCJD BDJE 8BLP

  N. βHMZDFSPQIPTQIBUF 4JHNB

  O. EFYBNFUBTPOF 4JHNB  BOE  OHNM SI#.1 3% 4ZTUFNT  GPS  EBZT  5IFO UIF DFMMT

&BHMFhT .FEJVN %.&.  4JHNB  TVQQMFNFOUFE XJUI  '#4   OHNM SI/(' 3% 4ZTUFNT

  OHNM SIC'(' (FOF[ZNF 5FDIOF

  N. EJCVUZSZM D".1

XFSF DVMUVSFE JO UIF TBNF NFEJVN XJUIPVU SI#.1

4JHNB  N.JTPCVUIZMNFUIZMYBOUIJOF *#.9  4JHNB

 BOE  μ. SFUJOPJD BDJE  5IF NFEJVN XBT

GPSVQUPXFFLT5IFNFEJVNXBTDIBOHFEFWFSZPS

DIBOHFEFWFSZEBZTGPSXFFLT

EBZTGPSXFFLT'PSFWBMVBUJPOPGNJOFSBMJ[FENB USJY  DFMMT XFSF mYFE XJUI NFUIBOPM GPS  NJO BOE

5PUBM3/"JTPMBUJPOBOE351$3

TUBJOFEXJUI"MJ[BSJOSFE4 8BLP TPMVUJPOJO

 5PUBM 3/"T XFSF FYUSBDUFE GSPN DFMMT CZ *40(&/

BNNPOJBXBUFSGPSNJOBUSPPNUFNQFSBUVSF*OBE

/JQQPO (FOF $P  5PZBNB  +BQBO  351$3 XBT QFS

.BZ 



Multilineage Cells from Human Apical Pulp 5BCMF 1SJNFSTVTFEGPS351$3 5BSHFUD%/"

1SJNFSTFRVFODF

SFGFSFODF

.JOFSBMJ[FEDFMMTQFDJmDHFOFT ' 3

hBHHDDBHDDBHDBUBBUHHBBh hDUDDDHUUDBDHBHUDUDBUh

<>

' 3

hDUHBDDUUDDUHDHDDUHBUHUDDh hHUDUHHHHDBDDBBDHUDDBBHHHh

<>

$CGB

' 3

hBUHDUUDBUUDHDDUDBDBBBDh hDDBBBBHBBHUUUUHDUHBDBUHHh

<>

0TUFPQPOUJO

' 3 3

hBHDDHUHHHBBHHBDBHUUBUHh hHHBHUUUDDBUHBBHDDBDBBBDh hDBBDDBHHBUBUDUUDBUHHDUHh

<>

' 3 3

hBUHHDDUHUHDUUUDUDBBUh hUUHUDHUBUUDBUUHBDHDDh hBDUHDDDUHBBDUHHBBBUDh

<>

' 3

hHHDBHUHBDUDBBBBHHBHDh hUHDUHUDBDUHUDBDUHDUHh

<>

0TUFSJY

' 3

hHDBHDUBHBBHHHBHUHHUHh hHDBHHDBHHUHBBDUUDUUDh

<>

0TUFPDBMDJO 0$/

' 3

hUDBDBDUDDUDHDDDUBUUHHh hHHHDBBHHHHBBHBHHBBBHBh

<>

/FTUJO

' 3

hHHDBHDHUUHHBBDBHBHHUUHHBh hDUDUBBBDUHHBHUHHUDBHHHDUh

<>

.VTBTIJ

' 3

hHBBUHHBDHDDUUDBUHDUHh hDHDUHBUHUBBDUHDUHBDDh

<>

5SL"

' 3

hDDBUDHUHBBHBHUHHDDUDh hDDBHDUDUHUHBHHBUDDBHh

<>

/FVSP%

' 3

hDDBBBBBHBBHBBHBUHBDUBBHHh hBHDUHUDDBUHHUBDDHUBBh

<>

βUVCVMJOⅢ

' 3

hHDDBBHUUDUHHHBBHUDBUh hHHDDUHBBHBHBUHUDDBBBh

<>

NJDSPUVCVMFBTTPDJBUFEQSPUFJO

' 3

hUHDDBUDUUHHUHDDHBh hDUUHBDBUUBDDBDDUDDBHHUh

<>

' 3

hBDBUDHBHBUDHDDBDDUBDh hBDBUDBDBUDDUUHUHDUDDh

<>

' 3

hUDDBDDBDDDUHUUHDUHUBh hBDDBDBHUDDBUHDDBUDBDh

<>

QBSBUIZSPJEIPSNPOFSFDFQUPS

15)S

DPMMBHFOUZQF

$PⅠ

01/

#POFTJBMPQSPUFJO

#41

EFOUJOTJBMPQIPTQIPQSPUFJO

%411

/FVSBMDFMMTQFDJmDHFOFT

."1

('"1 *OUFSOBMDPOUSPM HMZDFSBMEFIZEFQIPTQIBUF EFIZESPHFOBTF ("1%)

GPSNFE VTJOH 4VQFS4DSJQU5. 0OF4UFQ 351$3 XJUI B

T ℃GPST BOE℃GPSNJO5IFSNBMDZ

QMBUJOVN UBH *OWJUSPHFO   $PNQMFNFOUBSZ %/" TZO

DMJOHXBTDZDMFTJOB(FOF"NQ1$34ZTUFN

UIFTJT BOE QSFEFOBUVSBUJPO XBT QFSGPSNFE GPS  DZDMF

1&#JPTZTUFNT 1SJNFSTTFRVFODFTBSFTIPXOJO5BCMF

PG℃GPSNJOBOE℃GPSNJO"GUFSBOJOJUJBM



EFOBUVSBUJPO BNQMJmDBUJPOTXFSFQFSGPSNFEBU℃GPS



0SBM4DJFODF*OUFSOBUJPOBM 7PM /P

"RD5

3($!0)

3($!0)

$!*

#!

4!

'JH *NNVOPIJTUPDIFNJDBMBOBMZTJTPGBQJDBMQVMQPGIVNBOUPPUIXJUIJNNBUVSFBQFY 3FHJPOT PG  " ∼ $  EFOUJOBQJDBM QVMQ KVODUJPO %"+

 % ∼ '  DFOUSF PG BQJDBM QVMQ $"  BOE ( ∼ * UJQPGBQJDBMQVMQ 5"  " % ( #SE6JODPSQPSBUJOHDFMMT # & ) &YQSFTTJPO PG UIF NFTFODIZNBM TUFN DFMM NBSLFS 4) $  '  *  &YQSFTTJPO PG UIF NFTFODIZNBM TUFN DFMMNBSLFS4)4PNFTFDUJPOT # $ & ' )BOE* XFSFDPVOUFSTUBJOFEXJUI%"1*OVDMFBS TUBJOJOH0SJHJOBMNBHOJmDBUJPO # $ & ' ) *  ×" % (  ×

3FTVMUT

UIF NFTFODIZNBM TUFN DFMM NBSLFST 4)  4)   TIPXFEUIBUDFMMTJO%"+BOEUIFQFSJWBTDVMBSSFHJPOPG

)JTUPMPHJDBM GFBUVSFT PG BQJDBM QVMQ UJTTVF PG B UPPUIXJUIJNNBUVSFBQFY

$"FYQSFTTFECPUI4) 'JH# & BOE4) 'JH$  '   /FJUIFS #SE6JODPSQPSBUJOH DFMMT OPS FYQSFTTJPO PG

 5IFDPSPOBMQVMQPGZPVOHIVNBOUFFUIIBTGPVSMBZ

4)PS4)XBTGPVOEJO5" 'JH( ∼ * 

FST  UIFPEPOUPCMBTUJDMBZFS UIFDFMMGSFF[POF UIF[POF

$FMMDVMUVSF

PG8FJM

UIFDFMMSJDI[POFBUUIFQFSJQIFSZBOEUIFDFO UFS PG QVMQ 'JH %  &   5IF DFMMGSFF [POF TFQBSBUFT UIFDFMMSJDI[POFGSPNUIFPEPOUPCMBTUJDMBZFS 'JH%  & 5IFBQJDBMQVMQXJUIJNNBUVSFBQFYEPFTOPU IPX FWFS GPSNUIFTFMBZFSTUSVDUVSFT 'JH' 8FEJWJEFE

 5PPCUBJOBOEDIBSBDUFSJ[FDFMMTEFSJWFEGSPNUIFBQJ

BQJDBM QVMQ JOUP UISFF SFHJPOT   UIF EFOUJOBQJDBM QVMQ

DFOUSJDBMMZ NBJOUBJOJOHIBSNPOZPGEJWJTJPOBOENPWF

KVODUJPO %"+

UIFDFOUSBMBQJDBMQVMQ $" BOEUIFUJQ PGUIFBQJDBMQVMQ 5"  'JH( %"+JTBDFMMSJDISF

NFOU XIJMF DPNJOH JOUP DPOUBDU FBDI PUIFS 'JH " 

HJPO  CPSEFSFE CZ GPSNFE EFOUJO  UIBU JODMVEFT PEPOUP

UIF DFMM TIFFU VTJOH 4DJPO *NBHF  5IF BSFB PG UIF DFMM

CMBTUT  $" DPOUBJOT MBSHF CMPPE WFTTFMT BOE OFSWF

TIFFUBUEBZXBTOJOFGPME  ±  UIBUBUEBZ

USVOLT  5" JT B DFMMQPPS SFHJPO  MPDBUFE JO UIF BQFY PG

 'JH# 0OEBZ UIFUPUBMDFMMOVNCFSQSPQBHBU

UIFSPPUBOEOPUGSBNFEJOCZGPSNFEEFOUJO

FEGSPNBUJTTVFFYQMBOUPGBQJDBMQVMQXBTBCPVU ×

 5IFDFMMTJO%"+BOEUIFQFSJWBTDVMBSSFHJPOPG$"JO

  ±  XJUITPNFEJGGFSFODFTBNPOHJOEJWJEV

DPSQPSBUFE #SE6 'JH "  %   *NNVOPnVPSFTDFODF PG

BMT 'JH$ 5IF"1%$TFYIJCJUFETQJOEMFTIBQFEDFMMT

DBMQVMQPGJNNBUVSFBQFY QSJNBSZPVUHSPXUIDFMMDVM UVSF VTJOH 5" XBT QFSGPSNFE  5IF mCSPCMBTUMJLF DFMMT XFSFEFUFDUFEBSPVOEUJTTVFQMBUFEPOBDVMUVSFEJTIBU EBZPS5IFDFMMTGPSNFEBDFMMTIFFUBOEHSFXDPO

(SPXUI SBUF XBT DBMDVMBUFE CZ NFBTVSJOH UIF BSFB PG

.BZ 

Multilineage Cells from Human Apical Pulp



'JH .PSQIPMPHZBOEHSPXUIPG"1%$T

" "1%$TBSPVOEFYQMBOUFEUJTTVFJOQSJNBSZPVUHSPXUIDVMUVSF # (SPXUIPG"1%$TJOQSJNBSZFYQMBOUDVMUVSF NFBTVSFE CZBSFBPGDFMMTIFFUVTJOH4DJPO*NBHF /  $ 5PUBMDFMMOVNCFSGSPNPOFQJFDF BCPVU××NN PGBQJDBMQVMQUJTTVFBU EBZJOQSJNBSZPVUHSPXUIDFMMDVMUVSF % ∼ ' .PSQIPMPHZPGEFUBDIFEBOESFQMBUFE"1%$T ( $PMPOJFTPG"1%$TTUBJOFE XJUI8SJHIU4UBJOTPMVUJPO ) $FMMDMVTUFSTPG"1%$TGPSNFEBTJOHMFDPMPOZ * .55BTTBZJOUIJSEQBTTBHF / 3FTVMUTBSF FYQSFTTFEBTNFBOT±4% + $'6'BTTBZJOUIJSEQBTTBHF / 3FTVMUTBSFFYQSFTTFEBTNFBOT ± 4%0SJHJOBMNBHOJmDB UJPO (  × & ' )  × %  ×



0SBM4DJFODF*OUFSOBUJPOBM 7PM /P

'JH &YQSFTTJPOPGTVSGBDFNBSLFSTPG"1%$T $FMMTXFSFMBCFMFEXJUIUIFN"CTQFDJmDGPSUIFNPMFDVMFTJOEJDBUFE PQFOIJTUPHSBNT PSJTPUZQFDPOUSPMT mMMFE IJTUPHSBNT 

'JH % ∼ '

 BOE SBQJEMZ HSFX JO WJUSP 'JH *   5IF

351$3BOBMZTJTSFWFBMFEUIBUWBSJPVTNBSLFSQSPUFJOT

DFMMT IBE DPNF UP DPOnVFODF BCPVU BU  EBZT BOE

DIBSBDUFSJTUJDPGNJOFSBMJ[FEDFMMTTVDIBT15)S $CGB 

SFBDIFE IJHI DPOnVFODF BU  EBZT  UIFSFGPSF UIF

%411 BOE0$/XFSFVQSFHVMBUFEJOUSFBUFEDFMMT 'JH

HSPXUI SBUF GSPN EBZ  UP EBZ  EFDSFBTFE 'JH * 

(   5IFTF EBUB EFNPOTUSBUFE UIBU "1%$T QPTTFTTFE

5IF $'6 BTTBZ SFWFBMFE UIF OVNCFS PG DPMPOJFT XBT

UIFBCJMJUZUPEJGGFSFOUJBUFJOUPNJOFSBMJ[FEDFMMTTVDIBT

QSPQPSUJPOBM UP UIF TFFEFE DFMM OVNCFS 'JH (  )  + 

PTUFPCMBTUTBOEPEPOUPCMBTUT%411XBTSFHBSEFEBTB

5IFDPMPOJFTXFSFGPSNFEFWFOUIPVHI"1%$TXFSFSF

TQFDJmDNBSLFSGPSPEPOUPCMBTUT)PXFWFS SFDFOUTUVE

QMBUFEBUMPXEFOTJUZ DFMMTQFSNNEJTI5IFTF

JFTJOEJDBUFUIBU%411JTNPSFXJEFMZEJTUSJCVUFEUIBO

SFTVMUT JOEJDBUFE UIF IJHI QSPMJGFSBUJPO DBQBDJUZ PG"1

PSJHJOBMMZ UIPVHIU  BOE UIF QSFTFODF PG %411 JO PTUFP

%$T

CMBTUTXBTPCTFSWFEo*UJTOPUDMFBSXIFUIFSNJOFS BMJ[FEDFMMTEJGGFSFOUJBUFEGSPN"1%$TJOWJUSPXFSFPT

'MPXDZUFNFUSJDBOBMZTJTPG"1%$T

UFPCMBTUTPSPEPOUPCMBTUT

 'MPXDZUFNFUSJD BOBMZTJT XBT QFSGPSNFE UP FWBMVBUF

）"EJQPHFOJDEJGGFSFOUJBUJPOJOWJUSP

UIF FYQSFTTJPO PG TVSGBDF NBSLFST PG "1%$T  5IF FY

 5PEFUFSNJOFXIFUFIS"1%$TVOEFSHPBEJQPHFOJDEJG

QBOEFE "1%$T XFSF OFHBUJWF GPS $%  $%  $% 

GFSFOUJBUJPO UIFDFMMTXFSFDVMUVSFEJOBEJQPHFOJDNFEJ

(MZ" $% JOEJDBUJOHUIBUUIFTFDFMMTBSFOPUPGIF

VN  .VMUJQMF  JOUSBDFMMVMBS MJQJEmMMFE ESPQMFUT XFSF

NBUPQPJFUJD PSJHJO  5IF FYQBOEFE "1%$T XFSF BMTP

GPSNFE BOE WJTVBMJ[FE CZ TUBJOJOH XJUI PJMSFE 0  BOE

OFHBUJWF GPS FOEPUIFMJBM DFMMhT NBSLFS $%  'ML ,%3 W8' *ODPOUSBTU "1%$TXFSFGPVOEUPCFQPTJ UJWF GPS JOUFHSJOT $% βJOUFHSJO

 $%C α JOUFHSJO  $%E αJOUFHSJO  $% αWβ JOUFHSJO

 BOE QPTJUJWF GPS $%  $%  $%  $%  /('3Q /53  OFVSPUSPQIJO SFDFQUPS   *O BEEJUJPO  I.4$T NBSLFST  4) $%  BOE 4) $%  XFSF QPTJUJWF 'JH 

UIF PJMSFE 0 DPOUBJOJOH DFMMT FYIJCJUFE BO FYQBOEFE NPSQIPMPHZ 'JH #   /P MJQJE ESPQMFUT XFSF PCTFSWFE JOVOEJGGFSFOUJBUFE"1%$TBTOFHBUJWFDPOUSPM 'JH"  5IFTF SFTVMUT JOEJDBUF UIBU"1%$T VOEFSHP BEJQPHFOJD EJGGFSFOUJBUJPO ）$IPOESPHFOJDEJGGFSFOUJBUJPOJOWJUSP  " QFMMFU DVMUVSF UFDIOJRVF XBT FNQMPZFE UP USJHHFS "1%$T UPXBSE UIF DIPOESPHFOJD MJOFBHF    5IF DFMMT JOUIFUSFBUFEHSPVQGPSNFEBQFMMFUUIBUIBEBTQIFSJ

.VMUJMJOFBHFQPUFOUJBMPG"1%$T

DBMBOEHMJTUFOJOHUSBOTQMBOUBQQFBSBODF 'JH$ 5IF

）%JGGFSFOUJBUJPOJOUPNJOFSBMJ[FEDFMMTJOWJUSP

EFWFMPQNFOUPGDBSUJMBHFNBUSJY TIPXOCZTUBJOJOHQSP

 5IFDFMMTDVMUVSFEJONJOFSBMJ[BUJPOQSPNPUJOHNFEJ

UFPHMJDBOT XJUI 5PMVJEJOF CMVF  SFWFBMFE UIF DIPOESP

VN GPSNFE OPEVMFT  BOE UIF OPEVMF TUBJOFE JOUFOTFMZ

HFOJD OBUVSF PG EJGGFSFOUJBUFE DFMMT GSPN "1%$T 'JH

XJUI"MJ[BSJOSFETUBJO 'JH" # BOEWPO,PTTBTUBJO 'JH$ % 5IFUSFBUFEDFMMTIBEBUPGPMEBMLB MJOF QIPTQIBUBTF BDUJWJUZ JO VOUSFBUFE DFMMT 'JH & 

% & 5IFDBSUJMBHFFYUSBDFMMVMBSQSPUFJO UZQF**DPM

5IF TFOTJUJWF DPMPSJNFUSJD RVBOUJUBUJWF DBMDJVN BTTBZ

）/FVSPHFOJDEJGGFSFOUJBUJPOJOWJUSP

TIPXFEDBMDJVNEFQPTJUJPOJOUIFUSFBUFEDFMMT 'JH' 

 /FVSPHFOJDJOEVDUJPOSFTVMUFEJOBDIBOHFJOUIFNPS

MBHFO XBTEFUFDUFEJOUIFNBUSJYPGUIFDFMMQFMMFUXJUI JNNVOPIJTUPDIFNJTUSZ 'JH' ( 

.BZ 



Multilineage Cells from Human Apical Pulp

!,0ACTIVITY μMOLMNGPROT

 

#/.4 $)&&

      





#ULTUREDAYS$AYS

#ADEPOSITIONMGMGPROT

#/.4  

$)&&

#/.4

04(R

$300

#OL)

/STERIX

#BFA 

/#.

/0.

'!0$(

$)&&

   

"30 $)&& 'JH %JGGFSFOUJBUJPOPG"1%$TJOUPNJOFSBMJ[FEDFMMT "1%$TXFSFDVMUVSFEJONBJOUFOBODFNFEJVN " $ PSNJOFSBMJ[FEDFMMEJGGFSFOUJBUJPONFEJVN # % GPSEBZT " # "SJ[B SJOSFETUBJOJOH $ % WPO,PTTBTUBJOJOH*OUIFEJGGFSFOUJBUJPOHSPVQ BDBMDJmFEFYUSBDFMMVMBSNBUSJYXBTQSFTFOUBOEQPTJUJWF GPSBMJ[BSJOSFEBOEWPO,PTTBTUBJOJOH # %  & "MLBMJOFQIPTQIBUBTF "-1 BTTBZ DPOUSPM XIJUFTRVBSF EJGGFSFOUJBUJPO CMBDL TRVBSF 3FTVMUTBSFFYQSFTTFEBTNFBOT±4% ' "NPVOUPGDBMDJVNEFQPTJUJPOBUEBZT DPOUSPM XIJUFTRVBSF EJGGFSFOUJB UJPO CMBDLTRVBSF  ( &YQSFTTJPOPGNJOFSBMJ[FEDFMMTQFDJmDHFOFT1BSBUIZSPJEIPSNPOFSFDFQUPS 15)S

UZQFⅠ$PMMBHFO $P Ⅰ

$CGB PTUFPQPOUJO 01/

CPOFTJBMPQSPUFJO #41  EFOUJOTJBMPQIPTQIPQSPUFJO %411

PTUFSJYBOEPTUFPDBMDJO 0$/ HFOF XFSFFYBNJOFECZ351$3BUEBZTBGUFSEJGGFSFOUJBUJPOJOEVDUJPO0SJHJOBMNBHOJmDBUJPO " ∼ %  × #/.4

'JH %JGGFSFOUJBUJPOPG"1%$TJOUPBEJQPHFOJDMJOFBHFBOEDIPOESPHFOJDMJOFBHF "EJQPHFOJDEJGGFSFOUJBUJPOPG"1%$T  JOUSBDFMMVMBSPJMESPQMFUTGPSNFEBOEXFSFTUBJOFESFECZPJM3FE0$POUSPMHSPVQ " XBT OPUTUBJOFECZPJM3FE0)PXFWFS JOEJGGFSFOUJBUJPOHSPVQ #

PJM3FE0TUBJOJOHPGUIFMJQJEWFTJDMFTQFSGPSNFEXFFLTBGUFS TUJNVMBUJPOEFNPOTUSBUFTPOHPJOHBEJQPHFOFTJT $IPOESPHFOJDEJGGFSFOUJBUJPOPG"1%$T   $ 3FQSFTFOUBUJWFNBDSPQJDUVSFPGDIPOESPTQIFSF % & 5JTTVFTFDUJPOTTUBJOFEXJUI 5PMVJEJOF#MVF ' ( *NNVOPIJTUPDIFNJTUSZGPSUZQF**DPMMBHFO*OUIFEJGGFSFOUJBUJPOHSPVQ &

UIFBDJEJDNVDPQPMZTBDDIBSJEF XBTTUBJOFEXJUI5PMVJEJOFCMVF5ZQF**DPMMBHFOUIBUJTBDIPOESPDZUFTQFDJmDQSPUFJOXBTTUBJOFEJOEJGGFSFOUJBUJPOHSPVQ ( % BOE'XFSFDPOUSPMHSPVQTGPSFBDIFYQFSJNFOU0SJHJOBMNBHOJmDBUJPO " # % &  ×' (  ×



0SBM4DJFODF*OUFSOBUJPOBM 7PM /P

'JH %JGGFSFOUJBUJPOPG"1%$TJOUPOFVSPHFOJDMJOFBHF

" $FMMNPSQIPMPHZPG"1%$TCFGPSFEJGGFSFOUJBUJPO # $ $FMMNPSQIPMPHZPG"1%$T BUEBZTBGUFSOFVSPHFOJDJOEVDUJPO%JGGFSFOUJBUFEDFMMTTIPXFEQPTJUJWFJNNVOPSFBD UJWJUZGPSUIF/FTUJO % (

5VK & ) BOEHMJBMmCSJMMBSZBDJEQSPUFJO ('"1  ' * BU EBZTBGUFSOFVSPHFOJDJOEVDUJPO4PNFTFDUJPOT % & ( ) XFSFDPVOUFSTUBJOFEXJUI %"1*OVDMFBSTUBJO + &YQSFTTJPOPGOFVSPHFOJDTQFDJmDHFOFTCFGPSF $0/5 BOEBG UFS OFVSPHFOJD JOEVDUJPO /FTUJO  .VTBTIJ  5SL "  /FVSP% βUVCVMJO ***  NJDSPUV CVMFBTTPDJBUFE QSPUFJO  ."1  BOE ('"1 HFOF XFSF FYBNJOFE CZ 351$3 BU  /.E BOE /.E EBZTBGUFSOFVSPHFOJDJOEVDUJPO0SJHJOBMNBHOJmDBUJPO " #  % & '  ×$ ( ) *  ×

QIPMPHZ PG DFMMT /FVSPJOEVDFE "1%$T BDRVJSFE UIF

SBOHFEJOUPBOFVSBMOFUXPSLMJLFTUSVDUVSF 'JH" ∼

NPSQIPMPHZ FYIJCJUJOH B SFGSBDUJMF DFMM CPEZ XJUI FY

$   *NNVOPnVPSFTDFODF BOBMZTJT TIPXFE UIBU OFVSP

UFOEFE DFMMVMBS QSPDFTTFT  BOE EJGGFSFOUJBUFE DFMMT BS

JOEVDFE "1%$T XFSF TUBJOFE GPS /FTUJO  BO FBSMZ

.BZ 

Multilineage Cells from Human Apical Pulp



NBSLFS PG OFVSBM QSPHFOJUPS DFMMT 'JH %  (

 5VK  B

UIBUJTDPOTUBOUMZBWBJMBCMF

OFVSPOTQFDJmDβUVCVMJO*** 'JH& ) BOE('"1 B NBSLFSPGHMJBMDFMMT 'JH' *

"1%$TJOQSFJOEVDUJPO

 0VS IJTUPMPHJDBM BOBMZTJT TIPXFE UIBU #SE6JODPSQP

DVMUVSF  IPXFWFS  BMTP XFSF TUBJOFE GPS /FTUJO  5VK

FE JO UIF TBNF SFHJPO PG %"+ BOE UIF QFSJWBTDVMBS SF

BOE ('"1 EBUB OPU TIPXO   351$3 BOBMZTJT DPO

HJPO PG $"  5IFTF SFTVMUT TVHHFTU UIBU TUFN DFMMT PS

mSNFE UIF FYQSFTTJPO PG /FTUJO  βUVCVMJO *** BOE

QSPHFOJUPS DFMMT FYJTU BOE QSPMJGFSBUF JO UIFTF SFHJPOT

('"1 CVUUIFFYQSFTTJPOPG/FTUJOBOE('"1EFDSFBTFE

5IJT OPUJPO JT TVQQPSUFE CZ QSFWJPVT TUVEJFT TIPXJOH

EVSJOHOFVSPHFOJDJOEVDUJPO 'JH+ "EEJUJPOBMMZ "1

UIBU UIF QFSJWBTDVMBS SFHJPO XBT B OJDIF PG NFTFODIZ

%$T JO QSFJOEVDFE DVMUVSF FYQSFTTFE .VTBTIJ  BO

NBMTUFNDFMMTJOCPOFNBSSPXBOEEFOUBMQVMQ 5IF

3/"CJOEJOH QSPUFJO FYQSFTTFE JO OFVSBM QSFDVSTPS

QFSJWBTDVMBS QSPHFOJUPS PS TUFN DFMMT QSPMJGFSBUF JO SF

DFMMT 5SL" BIJHIBGmOJUZOFSWFHSPXUIGBDUPSSFDFQUPS 

TQPOTF UP EFOUBM QVMQ JOKVSZ  BOE UIFTF QSPMJGFSBUJOH

BOE."1 NJDSPUVCVMFBTTPDJBUFEQSPUFJO

BNBSLFS

DFMMT NJHSBUF UP QVMQBM JOKVSZ TJUFT  0O UIF PUIFS

GPSNBUVSFOFVSPO5IFFYQSFTTJPOPG/FTUJO .VTBTIJ

IBOE  5" XBT B DFMMQPPS SFHJPO  BOE UIFSF XFSF GFXFS

BOE 5SL" EFDSFBTFE EVSJOH OFVSPHFOJD JOEVDUJPO 'JH +  "GUFS  EBZT VOEFS EJGGFSFOUJBUJOH DPOEJUJPOT  UIF

#SE6JODPSQPSBUJOH DFMMT BOE NVDI XFBLFS FYQSFTTJPO

FYQSFTTJPO PG /FVSP%  B OFVSPHFOJD CBTJD IFMJYMPPQ

DPOTJEFSUIBUUIFTJHOBMGPSDFMMHSPXUIBOEEJGGFSFOUJB

IFMJYUSBOTDSJQUJPOGBDUPS XBTJOEVDFEBOEEFDSFBTFEBU

UJPOXBTBDUJWBUFEJO%"+PS$" CVUOPUJO5"5"NBZ

 EBZT 'JH +  *U JT LOPXO UIBU /FVSP% JOEVDFT

CFNPSFQSJNJUJWFUJTTVFUIBO%"+PS$"BUUIFUIPVHIU

OFVSPOBMEJGGFSFOUJBUJPOBOETVQQSFTTFTHMJBMEJGGFSFOUJ

PGUIFGBDUUIBUEFWFMPQNFOUPGSPPUBOEEFOUBMQVMQQSP

 

SBUJOHDFMMTBOE4)BOE4)QPTJUJWFDFMMTXFSFMPDBU

PG 4) BOE 4) DPNQBSFE UP %"+ BOE $"  8F UIVT

  $PODVSSFOU XJUI UIF JOEVDUJPO PG /FVSP%

DFFETUPXBSEBQJDBMTJUF5IFDFMMDVMUVSFJOWJUSPJTDPO

FYQSFTTJPO XFPCTFSWFEJODSFBTFEFYQSFTTJPOPGNBSLFS

TJEFSFEBGBDUPSJOUIFMPTTPGUIFNVMUJMJOFBHFQPUFOUJBM

GPSUIFNBUVSFOFVSPO ."1BOEEFDSFBTFEFYQSFTTJPO

PGTUFNDFMMT5IFQSJNJUJWFUJTTVFJTCFUUFSGPSDFMMDVM

PG UIF NBSLFS PG HMJBM DFMMT  ('"1 'JH +   5IFTF SF

UVSF JO WJUSP UP PCUBJO NVMUJMJOFBHF DFMMT  5" JT OPU

TVMUT JOEJDBUF UIBU "1%$T EJGGFSFOUJBUFE JOUP OFVSPOT 

GSBNFEJOCZIBSEUJTTVF UIFSFGPSFJUJTFBTZUFDIOJDBMMZ

OPUHMJBMDFMMTVOEFSOFVSPHFOJDJOEVDUJPO

UP UBLF UIF QVMQ UJTTVF GSPN 5"  "MUIPVHI JU JT OPU

BUJPO

LOPXOUIBUXIJDILJOEPGDFMMTHSPXBOEEJGGFSFOUJBUFJO %JTDVTTJPO

5" EVSJOH SPPU GPSNBUJPO  XF BUUFNQUFE DFMM DVMUVSF

 .BOZ BEVMU PSHBOT DPOUBJO QPQVMBUJPOT PG TUFN DFMMT

GSPN5"OPUGSBNFEJOCZEFOUJOUPPCUBJONVMUJMJOFBHF

UIBU IBWF UIF DBQBDJUZ GPS SFOFXBM BGUFS USBVNB  EJT

DFMMT

FBTF PSBHJOH5IFGSFRVFODZPGTUFNDFMMTJOBEVMUPS

 "1%$TDBOCFDVMUVSFEFBTJMZJOWJUSPVOEFSPSEJOBSZ

HBOT  IPXFWFS  JT MPX 'PS FYBNQMF  IVNBO NFTFODIZ

TFSVNTVQQMFNFOUFEDVMUVSFDPOEJUJPO BOEIBWFBIJHI

NBMTUFNDFMMTBSFQSFTFOUBTBSBSFQPQVMBUJPOPGDFMMT

DBQBDJUZGPSQSPMJGFSBUJPO"1%$TBSFDBQBCMFPGQSPWJE

JOCPOFNBSSPX SFQSFTFOUJOHQFSIBQTUP

JOHFOPVHIDFMMTGPSQPUFOUJBMDMJOJDBMBQQMJDBUJPO5IJT



PGOVDMFBUFEDFMMT 5IFGSFRVFODZPGTUFNDFMMTJOEFWFM

NBZ CF BUUSJCVUFE UP UIF FBSMZ EFWFMPQNFOUBM TUBUF PG

PQJOHPSHBOTNBZCFIJHIFSUIBOUIBUJONBUVSFPSHBOT 

BQJDBM QVMQ  5IF FYQSFTTJPO PG TPNF NBSLFST BMUFST

CVUIVNBOPSHBOTPOEFWFMPQNFOUJTVOBWBJMBCMF5IF

EVSJOH DFMM DVMUVSF JO WJUSP  5P UBLF PVS FYBNQMFT  UIF

JEFOUJmDBUJPO JTPMBUJPOBOEQVSJmDBUJPOPGIVNBOTUFN

FYQSFTTJPO PG 4) BOE 4) XBT WFSZ XFBL JO 5"  CVU

DFMMT BSF GSBVHIU XJUI EJGmDVMUZ EVF UP UIFJS MPX GSF

UIFTFFYQSFTTJPOPGDVMUVSFE"1%$TXFSFEFUFDUFEPCWJ

RVFODZ BOE FUIJDBM JTTVFT  5IF IVNBO UPPUI XJUI JN

PVTMZ  "OE UIF FYQSFTTJPO PG #41  XIJDI JT NBSLFS PG

NBUVSF BQFY JT EFWFMPQJOH PSHBO  BOE TFMGSFOFXBMBOE

NJOFSBMJ[FE DFMMT  XBT EFUFDUFE JO VOEJGGFSFOUJBUFE"1

EJGGFSFOUJBUJPO PG TUFN DFMMT UIFSFJO BSF BDUJWBUFE UP

%$T*UXBTSFQPSUFEUIBUEJGGFSFOUJTPMBUJPOPSDVMUVSF

NBLFBDPNQMFUFUPPUI*UJTDPODFJWBCMFUIBUTUFNDFMMT

NFUIPET HJWF SJTF UP EJGGFSFOU QPQVMBUJPOT PS MJOFBHF

PS QSPHFOJUPST PG WBSJPVT LJOET PG NBUVSF DFMMT BU BOZ

DFMMTEVSJOHDFMMDVMUVSFJOWJUSP$FMMDVMUVSFDPOEJUJPO

TUBHFEVSJOHEJGGFSFOUJBUJPOBSFQSFTFOUJOBUPPUIXJUI

JT UP CF OPUFE XIFO UIF DIBSBDUFS PG DVMUVSFE DFMM JT

JNNBUVSFBQFY5IJSENPMBSTXJUIJNNBUVSFBQFYBSF

FWBMVBUFE

GSFRVFOUMZ FYUSBDUFE JO PSUIPEPOUJD QSBDUJDF BOE BSF 

 'SPN UIF SFTVMUT PG nPXDZUPNFUSJD BOBMZTJT UIF QIF

UIFSFGPSF BWBMVBCMFBOESBSFEFWFMPQJOHIVNBOPSHBO

OPUZQF PG FYQBOEFE "1%$T JT TJNJMBS UP UIBU PG CPOF



0SBM4DJFODF*OUFSOBUJPOBM 7PM /P

NBSSPXNFTFODIZNBMTUFNDFMMT FYDFQUGPS$%E α

XIJDIJTSFMBUFEUPOFVSBMDSFTUTUFNDFMMT5IFTFEJGGFS

JOUFHSJO   "1%$T FYQSFTT /('3Q /53

 $%E αJOUFHSJO

 /FTUJO BOE .VTBTIJ /FVSBM DSFTU TUFN DFMMT BMTP FYQSFTT /('3Q /53    $%E α JOUFHSJO

 /FTUJO BOE .VTBTIJ  BOE HVU OFVSBM DSFTU

FODFT CFUXFFO "1%$T BOE PUIFS EFOUBM QVMQEFSJWFE



DFMMT BSF JNQPSUBOU QPJOUT GPS GVSUIFS TUVEZ  *U JT BMTP SFQPSUFE UIBU IVNBO QFSJPEPOUBM MJHBNFOU DPOUBJOT B QPQVMBUJPOPGNVMUJQPUFOUQPTUOBUBMTUFNDFMMTUIBUIBWF

TUFN DFMMT XFSF JTPMBUFE BT Q αJOUFHSJO DFMMT 

QPUFOUJBMUPHFOFSBUFBDFNFOUVNQFSJPEPOUBMMJHBNFOU

%FOUBMQVMQJTEFSJWFEGSPNOFVSBMDSFTUDFMMTBOEPUIFS

JO WJWP  5IFTF DFMMT GSPN UFFUI XJMM DPOUSJCVUF UP UIF

UZQFT PG DFMMT  BOE JU JT LOPXO UIBU OFVSBM DSFTU DFMMT

UJTTVFFOHJOFFSJOHPGUFFUI

DPOUSJCVUFUPPEPOUCMBTUT DFNFOUCMBTUT PTUFPCMBTUTBOE

 .PTUPGUIFCBTJDSFTFBSDIEJTDPWFSJFTDPODFSOJOHFN



DIPOESPDZUFTJOUIFDSBOJPGBDJBMSFHJPO *UJTOPUDMFBS

CSZPOJDBOEBEVMUIVNBOTUFNDFMMTDPNFGSPNBOJNBM 

UIBU"1%$T JODMVEF NFTFODIZNBM TUFN DFMMT PS OFVSBM

BOE QBSUJDVMBSMZ NPVTF NPEFMT  "MUIPVHI NPSF JT

DSFTUTUFNDFMMTGSPNPOMZUIFSFTVMUTPGNBSLFSFYQSFT

LOPXOBCPVUNPVTFDFMMT OPUBMMPGUIFJOGPSNBUJPODBO

TJPO5IFPSJHJOPG"1%$TJTWFSZJOUFSFTUJOHBOEJNQPS

CFUSBOTMBUFEUPUIFVOEFSTUBOEJOHPGIVNBODFMMT'PS

UBOUQPJOUGPSGVUVSFTUVEZ

SFHFOFSBUJWF NFEJDJOF  SFTFBSDI VTJOH QSJNBSZ IVNBO

 "1%$T FYIJCJUFE NVMUJMJOFBHF QPUFOUJBM JO WJUSP  EJG

DFMMTJTJOEJTQFOTBCMF'PSCBTJDPSDMJOJDBMSFTFBSDIVT

GFSFOUJBUJOH JOUP PEPOUHFOJDPTUFPHFOJD  BEJQPHFOJD 

JOHIVNBOQSJNBSZDFMMT XFNVTUPCUBJODFMMTGSPNBO

DIPOESPHFOJD BOE OFVSPHFOJD MJOFBHF XIFO DVMUVSFE JO

FBTJMZ BDDFTTJCMF UJTTVF SFTPVSDF XJUIPVU FUIJDBM QSPC

UIFQSFTFODFPGFTUBCMJTIFEMJOFBHFTQFDJmDGBDUPST5IJT

MFNT "T TIPXO JO UIF QSFTFOU SFQPSU  B IVNBO UPPUI

NVMUJMJOFBHF QPUFOUJBM PG "1%$T NBZ CF EFSJWFE GSPN

XJUI JNNBUVSF BQFY JT B WBMVBCMF BOE SBSF EFWFMPQJOH

UIF QSFTFODF PG   NVMUJQPUFOU TUFN DFMMT    TFWFSBM

PSHBO UIBU IBT DPOTUBOU BWBJMBCJMJUZ  BOE DFMMT EFSJWFE

MJOFBHFDPNNJUUFE QSFDVSTPS DFMMT  TVDI BT QSFPEPOU

GSPNUIFBQJDBMQVMQPGUIFUPPUIFYIJCJUFENVMUJMJOFBHF

CMBTUTQSFPTUFPCMBTUT  QSFBEJQPDZUFT  QSFDIPOESPCMBTUT

QPUFOUJBM)VNBOUPPUIXJUIJNNBUVSFBQFYXJMMCFBO

PS OFVSBM QSFDVSTPS DFMMT  PS   B DPNCJOBUJPO PG UIF

JNQPSUBOU DPOUSJCVUJPO UP UIF SFTFBSDI PG IVNBO BEVMU



BCPWF 8FDBOOPUDPODMVEFUIFQSFTFODFPGNVMUJQPUFOU

TUFNDFMMTBOEUPUIFBEWBODFNFOUPGEFOUBMBOESFHFO

TUFN DFMMT JO "1%$T CFDBVTF "1%$T BSF B IFUFSPHF

FSBUJWFNFEJDJOF

OFPVTDFMMQPQVMBUJPO4UFNDFMMTNBZCFSFTQPOTJCMFGPS UIF QIFOPNFOPO PG EFWFMPQJOH NVMUJQMF DFMM UZQFT "T EFOUBM QVMQ JODMVEFT PEPOUCMBTUT  OFSWFT BOE TDIXBOO DFMMT UIFSFJTBQPTTJCJMJUZUIBUQSFPEPOUCMBTUTBOEOFV SBMQSFDVSTPSDFMMTBSFJODMVEFEJO"1%$T*ODPOUSBTU  CPOF GBUPSDBSUJMBHFEPFTOPUPDDVSOBUVSBMMZJOEFOUBM QVMQ  *U JT VOMJLFMZ UIBU QSFPTUFPCMBTUT  QSFBEJQPDZUFT

3FGFSFODF  #BLTI %  4POH -  BOE 5VBO 34  "EVMU NFTFODIZNBM TUFN DFMMT  DIBSBDUFSJ[BUJPO  EJGGFSFOUJBUJPO  BOE BQQMJDB UJPOJODFMMBOEHFOFUIFSBQZ+$FMM.PM.FE o    1JUUFOHFS .'  .BDLBZ ".  #FDL 4$  +BJTXBM 3,  %PVHMBT 3  .PTDB +%  .PPSNBO ."  4JNPOFUUJ %8 

PSQSFDIPOESPCMBTUTBSFJODMVEFEJO"1%$T

$SBJH 4  BOE .BSTIBL %3  .VMUJMJOFBHF QPUFOUJBM PG

 3FDFOUMZ  QPQVMBUJPOT PG NVMUJMJOFBHF DFMMT  %14$T

BEVMUIVNBONFTFODIZNBMTUFNDFMMT4DJFODF o

%FOUBM 1VMQ 4UFN $FMMT  BOE 4)&% 4UFN DFMMT GSPN )VNBO &YGPMJBUFE %FDJEVPVT UFFUI

 XFSF GPVOE UP CF

   ;VL1" ;IV. "TIKJBO1 %F6HBSUF%" )VBOH+* 

EFSJWFE GSPN XIPMF QVMQ PG IVNBO QFSNBOFOU UFFUI 

.J[VOP) "MGPOTP;$ 'SBTFS+, #FOIBJN1 BOE)F

BOE SFNOBOU DPSPOBM QVMQ PG IVNBO FYGPMJBUFE EFDJEV

ESJDL.) )VNBOBEJQPTFUJTTVFJTBTPVSDFPGNVMUJQP



PVTUFFUI SFTQFDUJWFMZ #PUI%14$TBOE4)&%DPVME EJGGFSFOUJBUFJOUPNJOFSBMJ[FEDFMMT BEJQPDZUFTBOEOFV SBMDFMMTJOWJUSP5IFDFMMTEFSJWFEGSPNIVNBOEFOUBM QBQJMMB XFSF BMTP BCMF UP EJGGFSFOUJBUF JOUP NJOFSBMJ[FE DFMMT "1%$T XFSF BCMF UP EJGGFSFOUJBUF JOUP NJOFSBM J[FE DFMMT  BOE DFMMT PG BEJQPHFOJD  DIPOESPHFOJD BOE

UFOUTUFNDFMMT.PM#JPM$FMM o   ;VL1" ;IV. .J[VOP) )VBOH+ 'VUSFMM+8 ,BU[ "+  #FOIBJN 1  -PSFO[ )1  BOE )FESJDL .)  .VMUJ MJOFBHF DFMMT GSPN IVNBO BEJQPTF UJTTVF  JNQMJDBUJPOTGPS DFMMCBTFEUIFSBQJFT5JTTVF&OH o   5JOUVU :  "MGPOTP ;  4BJOJ 5  3BEDMJGG ,  8BUTPO ,  #PTUSPN ,  BOE %FNFS --  .VMUJMJOFBHF QPUFOUJBM PG

OFVSPHFOJD MJOFBHF JO WJUSP  1SFWJPVT SFQPSUT PO DFMMT

DFMMT GSPN UIF BSUFSZ XBMM $JSDVMBUJPO     o 

EFSJWFEGSPNEFOUBMQVMQIBWFOPEFTDSJQUJPOBCPVUUIF



FYQSFTTJPOPG/('3Q /53 PS$%E αJOUFHSJO



.BZ 

Multilineage Cells from Human Apical Pulp



 "CFEJO. 5JOUVU: BOE%FNFS-- .FTFODIZNBMTUFN

FT JO 3VOY$CGB FYQSFTTJPO BOE BDUJWJUZ EVSJOH PTUFP

DFMMTBOEUIFBSUFSZXBMM$JSD3FT o 

CMBTUJD EJGGFSFOUJBUJPO PG IVNBO CPOF NBSSPX TUSPNBM

 -FF0, ,VP5, $IFO8. -FF,% )TJFI4- BOE

DFMMT+#POF.JOFS3FT o 

$IFO 5)  *TPMBUJPO PG NVMUJQPUFOU NFTFODIZNBM TUFN

 ,MBTTFO )  ;JBFJBO #  ,JSPW **  :PVOH .+  BOE

DFMMT GSPN VNCJMJDBM DPSE CMPPE #MPPE     o 

4DIXBSU[ 1)  *TPMBUJPO PG SFUJOBM QSPHFOJUPS DFMMT GSPN



QPTUNPSUFN IVNBO UJTTVF BOE DPNQBSJTPO XJUI BVUPMP

 +JBOH: +BIBHJSEBS#/ 3FJOIBSEU3- 4DIXBSU[3& 

HPVTCSBJOQSPHFOJUPST+/FVSPTDJ3FT o 

,FFOF $%  0SUJ[(PO[BMF[ 93  3FZFT .  -FOWJL 5 

 4BLVSBHBXB /  ,BLJOVNB ,  ,JLVDIJ "  0LBOP ) 

-VOE5 #MBDLTUBE. %V+ "MESJDI4 -JTCFSH" -PX

6DIJEB4 ,BNP* ,PCBZBTIJ. BOE:PLPZBNB: )V

8$ -BSHBFTQBEB%" BOE7FSGBJMMJF$. 1MVSJQPUFODZ

NBO BNOJPO NFTFODIZNF DFMMT FYQSFTT QIFOPUZQFT PG

PG NFTFODIZNBM TUFN DFMMT EFSJWFE GSPN BEVMU NBSSPX

OFVSPHMJBMQSPHFOJUPSDFMMT+/FVSPTDJ3FT o 

/BUVSF o 



 (SPOUIPT4 .BOLBOJ. #SBIJN+ 3PCFZ1( BOE4IJ

 +FPOH+" (BOH&+ )POH4) )XBOH4) ,JN48 

4 1PTUOBUBMIVNBOEFOUBMQVMQTUFNDFMMT %14$T JOWJ

:BOH*) "IO$ )BO) BOE,JN) 3BQJEOFVSBMEJG

USP BOE JO WJWP 1SPD /BUM "DBE 4DJ 64"     o

GFSFOUJBUJPO PG IVNBO DPSE CMPPEEFSJWFE NFTFODIZNBM

 

TUFNDFMMT/FVSPSFQPSU o 

 (SPOUIPT 4  #SBIJN +  -J 8  'JTIFS -8  $IFSNBO / 

 "MFTTBOESJ( 1BHBOP4 #F[" #FOFUUJ" 1P[[J4 *BO

#PZEF" %FO#FTUFO1 3PCFZ1( BOE4IJ4 4UFNDFMM

OPMP( #BSPOJP. *OWFSOJDJ( $BSVTP" .VOFSFUUP$ 

QSPQFSUJFT PG IVNBO EFOUBM QVMQ TUFN DFMMT + %FOU 3FT

#JTMFSJ( BOE1BSBUJ& *TPMBUJPOBOEDVMUVSFPGIVNBO

 o 

NVTDMFEFSJWFE TUFN DFMMT BCMF UP EJGGFSFOUJBUF JOUP NZP

 .JVSB .  (SPOUIPT 4  ;IBP .  -V #  'JTIFS -8  3PCFZ1( BOE4IJ4 4)&% TUFNDFMMTGSPNIVNBOFY GPMJBUFE EFDJEVPVT UFFUI 1SPD /BUM "DBE 4DJ 64"     o 

HFOJD BOE OFVSPHFOJD DFMM MJOFBHFT -BODFU     o    "WFSZ +,  0SBM EFWFMPQNFOU BOE IJTUPMPHZ 8JMMJBNT  8JMLJOT #BMUJNPSF  QQo

 5FDMFT0 -BVSFOU1 ;ZHPVSJUTBT4 #VSHFS"4 $BNQT

 #SVEFS41 )PSPXJU[.$ .PTDB+% BOE)BZOFTXPSUI

+ %FKPV+BOE"CPVU* "DUJWBUJPOPGIVNBOEFOUBMQVMQ

4&  .POPDMPOBM BOUJCPEJFT SFBDUJWF XJUI IVNBO PTUFP

QSPHFOJUPSTUFN DFMMT JO SFTQPOTF UP PEPOUPCMBTU JOKVSZ

HFOJDDFMMTVSGBDFBOUJHFOT#POF o 

"SDI0SBM#JPM o 

 $IFO4 3BOJ4 8V: 6OUFSCSJOL" (V55 (MVIBL

 /BLBP ,  *UPI .  5PNJUB :  5PNPPLB :  BOE 5TVKJ 5 

)FJOSJDI +  $IVBOH ))  BOE .BDEPVHBMM .  %JGGFSFO

'(' QPUFOUMZ JOEVDFT CPUI QSPMJGFSBUJPO BOE %41 FY

UJBM SFHVMBUJPO PG EFOUJO TJBMPQIPTQIPQSPUFJO FYQSFTTJPO

QSFTTJPOJODPMMBHFOUZQF*HFMDVMUVSFTPGBEVMUJODJTPSJN

CZ 3VOY EVSJOH PEPOUPCMBTU DZUPEJGGFSFOUJBUJPO + #JPM

NBUVSF QVMQ DFMMT #JPDIFN #JPQIZT 3FT $PNNVO     o 

$IFN o   #BCB0 2JO$ #SVOO+$ +POFT+& 8ZHBOU+/ .D

 ,PHMFS( 4FOTLFO 4 "JSFZ +"  5SBQQ 5  .VTDIFO . 

*OUZSF#8BOE#VUMFS 85 %FUFDUJPOPGEFOUJOTJBMPQSP

'FMEIBIO/ -JFEULF4 4PSH37 'JTDIFS+ 3PTFOCBVN

UFJO JO SBU QFSJPEPOUJVN &VS + 0SBM 4DJ     o 

$ (SFTDIBU4 ,OJQQFS" #FOEFS+ %FHJTUJSJDJ0 (BP



+  $BQMBO "*  $PMMFUUJ &+  "MNFJEB1PSBEB (  .VMMFS

 /BSBZBOBO, 3BNBDIBOESBO" 1FUFSTPO.$ )BP+ 

)8  ;BOKBOJ &  BOE 8FSOFU 1  " OFX IVNBO TPNBUJD

,PMTUP "#  'SJFENBO "% BOE (FPSHF "  5IF $$""5

TUFNDFMMGSPNQMBDFOUBMDPSECMPPEXJUIJOUSJOTJDQMVSJQP

FOIBODFSCJOEJOH QSPUFJO $ CFUB BOE /SG JOUFSBDU

UFOUEJGGFSFOUJBUJPO QPUFOUJBM + &YQ .FE    o 

UP SFHVMBUF EFOUJO TJBMPQIPTQIPQSPUFJO %411  HFOF FY



QSFTTJPO EVSJOH PEPOUPCMBTU EJGGFSFOUJBUJPO + #JPM $IFN

 :BNBNPUP/ *TPCF. /FHJTIJ" :PTIJNBTV) 4IJNP

 o 

LBXB) 0IZB, "NBHBTB 5 BOE,BTVHBJ4 &GGFDUTPG

 4BLBHVDIJ :  4FLJZB *  :BHJTIJUB ,  *DIJOPTF 4  4IJ

BVUPMPHPVTTFSVNPOPTUFPCMBTUJDEJGGFSFOUJBUJPOJOIVNBO

OPNJZB, BOE.VOFUB5 4VTQFOEFEDFMMTGSPNUSBCFDV

CPOFNBSSPXDFMMT+.FE%FOU4DJ o 

MBSCPOFCZDPMMBHFOBTFEJHFTUJPOCFDPNFWJSUVBMMZJEFOUJ

 ,VEP: )JSBPLB. ,JUBHBXB4 .JZBVDIJ. ,BLVP4  ;IBP .  *EF 5  BOE 5BLBUB 5  &TUBCMJTINFOU PG IVNBO

DBM UP NFTFODIZNBM TUFN DFMMT PCUBJOFE GSPN NBSSPX BTQJSBUFT#MPPE o 

DFNFOUJGZJOH mCSPNB DFMM MJOFT CZ USBOTGFDUJPO XJUI UFN

 .PSSPX &.  'VSVLBXB 5  -FF +&  BOE $FQLP $- 

QFSBUVSFTFOTJUJWF TJNJBO WJSVT 5BOUJHFO HFOF BOE

/FVSP% SFHVMBUFT NVMUJQMF GVODUJPOT JO UIF EFWFMPQJOH

I5&35HFOF#POF o   4IVJ$ 4QFMTCFSH5$ 3JHHT#- BOE,IPTMB4 $IBOH

OFVSBMSFUJOBJOSPEFOU%FWFMPQNFOU o   )BUBLFZBNB+ BOE,BHFZBNB3 3FUJOBMDFMMGBUFEFUFS



0SBM4DJFODF*OUFSOBUJPOBM 7PM /P NJOBUJPOBOEC)-)GBDUPST4FNJO$FMM%FW#JPM o

[BLJ 5  0HBXB 4  0TVNJ /  0LBOP )  BOE 'VLVEB , 

 

$BSEJBDOFVSBMDSFTUDFMMTDPOUSJCVUFUPUIFEPSNBOUNVM

 4IJ 4  BOE (SPOUIPT 4  1FSJWBTDVMBS OJDIF PG QPTUOBUBM NFTFODIZNBMTUFNDFMMTJOIVNBOCPOFNBSSPXBOEEFO UBMQVMQ+#POF.JOFS3FT o   )VBOH (5+  4POPZBNB 8  $IFO +  BOE 1BSL 4)  *O

UJQPUFOU TUFN DFMM JO UIF NBNNBMJBO IFBSU + $FMM #JPM  o   $IBJ :  +JBOH 9  *UP :  #SJOHBT +S 1  )BO +  3PXJUDI %) 4PSJBOP1 .D.BIPO"1BOE4VDPW). 'BUFPG

WJUSPDIBSBDUFSJ[BUJPOPGIVNBOEFOUBMQVMQDFMMT$FMM5JT

UIF NBNNBMJBO DSBOJBM OFVSBM DSFTU EVSJOH UPPUI BOE

TVF3FT o 

NBOEJCVMBSNPSQIPHFOFTJT%FWFMPQNFOU o 

 .PSSJTPO 4+  8IJUF 1.  ;PDL $  BOE "OEFSTPO %+ 



1SPTQFDUJWFJEFOUJmDBUJPO JTPMBUJPOCZnPXDZUPNFUSZ BOE

 *LFEB& )JSPTF. ,PUPCVLJ/ 4IJNBPLB) 5BEPLPSP

JO WJWP TFMGSFOFXBM PG NVMUJQPUFOU NBNNBMJBO OFVSBM

. .BFEB. )BZBTIJ: ,JSJUB5BOE0IHVTIJ) 0T

DSFTUTUFNDFMMT$FMM o 

UFPHFOJD EJGGFSFOUJBUJPO PG IVNBO EFOUBM QBQJMMB NFTFO

 #JYCZ 4  ,SVHFS (.  .PTIFS +5  +PTFQI /. BOE .PSSJTPO 4+  $FMMJOUSJOTJD EJGGFSFODFT CFUXFFO TUFN

DIZNBMDFMMT#JPDIFN#JPQIZT3FT$PNNVOo  

DFMMTGSPNEJGGFSFOUSFHJPOTPGUIFQFSJQIFSBMOFSWPVTTZT

 4FP#. .JVSB. (SPOUIPT4 #BSUPME1. #BUPVMJ4 

UFN SFHVMBUF UIF HFOFSBUJPO PG OFVSBM EJWFSTJUZ /FVSPO

#SBIJN+ :PVOH. 3PCFZ1( 8BOH$: BOE4IJ4 

 o 

*OWFTUJHBUJPOPGNVMUJQPUFOUQPTUOBUBMTUFNDFMMTGSPNIV

 5PNJUB :  .BUTVNVSB ,  8BLBNBUTV :  .BUTV[BLJ :  4IJCVZB* ,BXBHVDIJ) *FEB. ,BOBLVCP4 4IJNB

NBOQFSJPEPOUBMMJHBNFOU-BODFU o