Accepted Manuscript Case report: Peritonitis, as a result of a retrograde postoperative incisional infection Christine T. Lopp, DVM, Cathleen A. Mochal-King, DVM, MS, DACVS
PII:
S0737-0806(15)00489-X
DOI:
10.1016/j.jevs.2015.07.017
Reference:
YJEVS 1921
To appear in:
Journal of Equine Veterinary Science
Received Date: 16 May 2015 Revised Date:
17 July 2015
Accepted Date: 24 July 2015
Please cite this article as: Lopp CT, Mochal-King CA, Case report: Peritonitis, as a result of a retrograde postoperative incisional infection, Journal of Equine Veterinary Science (2015), doi: 10.1016/ j.jevs.2015.07.017. This is a PDF file of an unedited manuscript that has been accepted for publication. As a service to our customers we are providing this early version of the manuscript. The manuscript will undergo copyediting, typesetting, and review of the resulting proof before it is published in its final form. Please note that during the production process errors may be discovered which could affect the content, and all legal disclaimers that apply to the journal pertain.
ACCEPTED MANUSCRIPT 1
Case report: Peritonitis, as a result of a retrograde postoperative incisional infection
2
C. T. Lopp, DVM and C. A. Mochal-King, DVM, MS, DACVS
3 Christine T. Lopp, DVM, Department of Clinical Sciences, College of Veterinary Medicine, Mississippi
5
State University, P.O. Box 6100, Mississippi State, MS 39762; Telephone: 336-944-1565; Fax: 662-
6
325-0243; Email:
[email protected]
7
Cathleen A. Mochal-King, DVM, MS, DACVS, Department of Clinical Sciences, College of Veterinary
8
Medicine, Mississippi State University, P.O. Box 6100, Mississippi State, MS 39762; Telephone: 662-
9
325-1400; Fax: 662-325-0243; Email:
[email protected]
SC
M AN U
10
key words: incisional infection, peritonitis, medical maggot, cecum
12
TE D
11
RI PT
4
Corresponding author:
14
Christine T. Lopp, DVM
15
Department of Clinical Sciences
16
College of Veterinary Medicine, Mississippi State University
17
P.O. Box 6100, Mississippi State, MS 39762
18
Telephone: 336-944-1565
19
Fax: 662-325-0243
20
Email:
[email protected]
AC C
EP
13
ACCEPTED MANUSCRIPT Abstract:
22
An eight-year-old Quarter horse x Walking horse cross mare was referred for treatment of septic
23
pedal osteitis and subsequently developed a cecal impaction which was resolved surgically. Post-
24
operative enteritis and incisional drainage developed in the short-term post-operative period.
25
One month post-operatively, the mare developed an acute septic peritonitis with Streptococcus
26
equi zooepidemicus that was likely a sequela to the incisional infection. Systemic antibiotic
27
therapy and peritoneal lavage was instituted, however, repeated culture and sensitivity of the
28
abdominal fluid revealed a multi-drug resistant Escherichia coli. In the face of antibiotic treatment
29
failure, medical grade Phaenicia sericata larvae were placed into the abdomen to be used as a
30
biological debriding agent. Clinical improvement was seen for 6 weeks, until the mare was
31
euthanized due to a small intestinal strangulating lesion. Additionally, this case report is a
32
description of the novel use of medical maggots in the treatment of a multi-drug resistant
33
peritonitis in a horse.
M AN U
SC
RI PT
21
37 38 39 40
EP
36
Case report: peritonitis, as a result of a retrograde postoperative incisional infection
1. Introduction: Septic peritonitis is a complication following abdominal surgery and
AC C
35
TE D
34
typhylotomy in horses and typically results in polymicrobial sepsis, predominantly with gram negative enteric bacteria 1,2,3. The overall prevalence of septic peritonitis following colic surgery is reported to be 3.1% 3 to 11% 4. Wound complication rates following a single initial
41
laparotomy vary from 7.4% 5 to as high as 37% 6, with higher rates of wound suppuration
42
reported in horses that had caecal or large colon obstruction, enterotomy6,7, or post-
43
operative peritonitis3. Abdominal contamination and peritonitis may lead to prolonged
44
incisional drainage, however little evidence exists in the literature that supports septic
ACCEPTED MANUSCRIPT peritonitis as a result of a retrograde postoperative incisional infection. Formation of
46
extraperitoneal incisional abscesses following colic surgery has been reported in 3 horses,
47
however in these cases the abscesses invaded the rectus abdominis muscle and did not
48
penetrate into the peritoneum8. This report describes the surgical and postsurgical
49
management of an 8-year-old Quarter Horse x Walking horse cross mare which developed a
50
septic peritonitis likely resulting from an ascending incisional infection. Additionally, this
51
case report describes the novel, off-label use of medical grade maggots as a biological
52
debriding agent in the treatment of a multidrug resistant peritonitis in a horse.
SC
RI PT
45
2. Case Report
54
2.1 History: An 8-year-old Quarter Horse x Walking horse cross mare initially presented for
55
chronic septic pedal osteitis in the left forelimb and was treated with surgical debridement of
56
the distal phalanx under general anesthesia. Perioperative antibiotics with cefazolin (11mg/kg
57
bwt i.v, q8h)a and gentamicin (GentaFuse; 6.6 mg/kg bwt i.v.)b were given. Following recovery
58
from anesthesia, the mare was maintained on flunixin meglumine (Banamine; 1.1 mg/kg bwt,
59
i.v., q12h)c and lidocaine hydrochloride (Lidocaine 2% Inj; 0.05 mg/kg/min)d, and butorphanol
60
(Torbugesic; 0.01-0.02 mg/kg bwt i.v. or i.m.)e was given as needed for additional analgesia. An
61
intravenous regional limb perfusion was performed with cefazolin and morphine (Morphine
62
Sulfate Injection)f at the time of surgery and then repeated 2 days later.
63
Two days following her surgical debridement of P3, the mare was observed to show mild to
64
moderate colic signs (decreased appetite, reduced fecal output, increased recumbency,
65
inappetance, infrequent rolling) and was subsequently diagnosed with a cecal impaction on
66
rectal palpation. The mare was initially treated with intravenous and enteral fluids, however
67
due to unrelenting pain, surgical intervention was elected.
68
2.2 Surgical procedure: Antimicrobial therapy with cefazolin and gentamicin was maintained.
69
The patient was premedicated with xylazine (AnaSed; 1.1 mg/kg bwt i.v.)g and butorphanol.
AC C
EP
TE D
M AN U
53
ACCEPTED MANUSCRIPT General anesthesia was induced with ketamine (Ketaset; 2.2 mg/kg bwt i.v.)h and
71
diazepam(Diazepam injection; 0.05 mg/kg bwt i.v.)i, and maintained with isofluorane (Isoflurane;
72
1.5-3%)j and oxygen(5 L/min). A routine 30 cm ventral midline celiotomy was performed which
73
revealed a markedly enlarged cecum filled with hard ingesta. The cecal apex was exteriorized,
74
isolated with laparotomy sponges, and draped with a sterile plastic sheet. A routine typhlotomy
75
was performed. Ingesta was removed by lavaging the cecum with water administered using a
76
nasogastric tube and bilge pump inserted through the typhlotomy site. The typhlotomy was
77
closed with 2-0 Polydioxanone suture using a simple continuous pattern, which was oversewn
78
with 2-0 polydioxanone in a Cushing pattern. The cecum was lavaged with sterile 0.9% saline
79
solution, containing 500 mg Gentamicin/L and 5x10^6 IU potassium penicillin (PfizerPen) k, prior
80
to being replaced into the abdomen. The surgeons replaced gowns and gloves, re-draped the
81
surgical field, and lavaged the abdomen with 5 L sterile 0.9% saline solution which was removed
82
by suction. Gross contamination during or after the typhlotomy was not appreciated and
83
therefore abdominal drains were not deemed necessary. A final liter of sterile 0.9% saline
84
solution containing 500 mg gentamicin/L and 5x10^6 IU potassium penicillin was left in the
85
abdomen. The linea alba was sutured with No. 3 Polygalactin 910 in 3 segments using a simple
86
continuous pattern and the subcutaneous tissue was apposed with 2-0 Polydioxanone suture
87
using a simple continuous suture pattern. The skin was apposed with stainless steel staples. The
88
incision was protected during recovery by the placement of an adherent absorbent dressing
89
(Telfa pad). After recovery, a clean belly bandage, consisting of sterile cotton padding held in
90
place with adhesive bandage material (elastikon), was placed to protect the incision site from
91
external contamination.
92
2.3 Postoperative course: Recovery from anesthesia was uneventful and post-operative
93
antibiotic therapy was continued with cefazolin (11 mg/kg bwt i.v., q8h) and gentamicin (6.6
94
mg/kg bwt i.v., q24h) in the immediate post-operative period, however 48 hours after surgery,
95
the patient developed anterior enteritis, as evidenced by an elevated temperature (103.4°F),
AC C
EP
TE D
M AN U
SC
RI PT
70
ACCEPTED MANUSCRIPT moderate signs of endotoxemia, significant volumes of serosanguinous nasogastric reflux, and
97
segmental intramural edema and thickening of the small intestine (4.5-9 mm) (Image 1 and
98
Image 2). The horse was treated with continuous infusion i.v. of balanced polyionic fluids,
99
lidocaine hydrochloride (0.05 mg/kg/min), metoclopramide (Metoclopramide; 0.04 mg/kg/hr)l ,
100
and partial parenteral nutrition (lactated ringers solution containing 500mL of 50% dextrose, and
101
500 mL of aminosyn (Aminosyn II 10%) m) at 0.5-1 L/hr, for 4.5 days. Polymyxin B (Polymyxin B
102
for injection; 5000 u/kg bwt i.v., q8h) n and sodium heparin (Heparin; 40 u/kg bwt sub cut., q8h)o
103
were administered for 2 days. Enrofloxacin (Baytril 100; 7.5 mg/kg bwt i.v., q24h) p was
104
administered for 5 days for treatment of anterior enteritis. Nasogastric reflux ceased after 48
105
hours of enrofloxacin therapy.
106
Incisional drainage was noted 5 days after the celiotomy (Image 3) at which point the skin
107
staples around the points of suppuration were removed to facilitate drainage and a hernia belt
108
with sterile cotton padding adjacent to the incision was placed to allow for daily bandage
109
changes. Incisional ultrasound showed a hypoechoic area in the subcutaneous tissues at the
110
cranial aspect (2 cm caudal to the cranial extent of the incision) and at the middle aspect of the
111
incision (4 cm caudal to the caudal draining site). Palpation of the incision with sterile gloves
112
revealed no defect in the abdominal wall, however through palpation of the cranial half of the
113
incision purulent material could be expressed from the drainage sites. Enrofloxacin was
114
discontinued after 5 days of treatment. Chloramphenicol (Viceton)q, (Chloramphenicol
115
Palmitate oral suspension; 50 mg/kg bwt per os, q8h) r administration was initiated after
116
discontinuing enrofloxacin. Chloramphenicol was selected due to the culture and sensitivity
117
patterns of the Streptococcus uberis from her pedal osteitis with a sensitivity of less than 4
118
mcg/mL. Chloramphenicol treatment was continued for an additional 20 days to treat the
119
incisional drainage as well as the pedal osteitis.
AC C
EP
TE D
M AN U
SC
RI PT
96
ACCEPTED MANUSCRIPT For a period of 4 weeks, the horse showed clinical signs of improvement and could have been
121
discharged to the care of her owners, however, she remained at the hospital for boarding during
122
her period of post-operative stall confinement. The area of solar debridement over P3 showed
123
progression of healthy granulation tissue and solar cornification, and the patient’s lameness
124
(grade 3/5) was not noticeable at the walk. The abdominal incision site continued to drain a
125
moderate amount of slightly yellow-tinged purulent fluid until day 25 post celiotomy, at which
126
point the incisional drainage abruptly lessened until it was essentially 2 small spots seen on the
127
belly bandage over a 2-3 days period.
128
At 31 days post laparotomy, the patient acutely developed signs of severe septic peritonitis
129
(temperature 106, and HR 120 bpm), depression, had mild ataxia and muscle weakness, and was
130
hesitant to walk. Nasogastric intubation yielded 10 L net reflux, and abdominal ultrasound
131
revealed a mild amount of free peritoneal fluid. An abdominocentesis was aseptically
132
performed approximately 10 cm to the left of midline, using a (10 inch) bitch catheter, to avoid
133
potential contamination from the incision and to minimize the risk of enterocentesis in case the
134
cecum had formed an adhesion on midline. Grossly purulent fluid, with a nucleated cell count of
135
125,750 cells/uL, was obtained in a steady stream from a depth of approximately 8 inches and
136
cultured a pure growth of Streptococcus equi zooepidemicus.
137
The horse was administered 1000 mg prednisolone sodium succinate(Solu-Delt-Cortef)s i.v. and
138
7.2% saline solution (2 ml/kg bwt i.v.) followed by continuous infusion i.v. of balanced polyionic
139
fluids, lidocaine hydrochloride (0.05 mg/kg/min), metoclopramide (0.04 mg/kg/hr), and partial
140
parenteral nutrition (lactated ringers solution containing 500mL of 50% dextrose, and 500 mL of
141
aminosyn) at 0.5-1 L/hr, for 4 days. Polymyxin B (5000 u/kg bwt i.v., q8h) was administered for 2
142
days. Potassium penicillin (22000 u/kg bwt i.v., q6h) and gentamicin (6.6 mg/kg bwt i.v., q24h)
143
were administered for 14 days.
AC C
EP
TE D
M AN U
SC
RI PT
120
ACCEPTED MANUSCRIPT Inadequate clinical progress was made over the first 2 days of treating the peritonitis closed
145
(persistent fevers, elevated heart rate, and progressive abdominal distention), therefore a left
146
flank laparotomy was made and two ventral abdominal drains were placed to facilitate
147
peritoneal lavage. The abdomen was lavaged daily with 10 L balanced polyionic fluids containing
148
potassium penicillin and heparin. Abdominal fluid was sampled from the drains daily and
149
evaluated for clinical improvement until day 5 when the patient’s cell count improved at which
150
time the drains were removed. Following removal of the drains, the horse’s condition plateaued
151
and then started to decline steadily with increasing amounts of abdominal fluid distention and
152
development of cyclic fevers. Two days following drain removal, abdominocentesis was
153
repeated (Day 40) and submitted for culture. Culture revealed Escherichia coli, which showed
154
marked resistance to multiple antibiotics, with the exception of tetracycline. The antimicrobial
155
treatment of potassium penicillin and gentamicin was discontinued at this time and
156
oxytetracycline therapy was initiated due to the sensitivity results. A 6.6 mg/kg bwt i.v., q12h
157
dose of oxytetracycline was chosen initially to try to minimize the rapid die-off of gram-negative
158
bacteria and thus hope to reduce the amount of endotoxin released. The mare was pretreated
159
with polymyxin B (5000 u/kg bwt i.v., q8h) to help bind and inactivate endotoxins predicted to
160
be released following the initiation of oxytetracycline (Liquamycin, LA-200) t.
161
Despite the low dose oxytetracycline and pretreatment with polymyxin B, a 24-48 hours period
162
of endotoxemia was encountered which caused a transient period of ileus (lack of auscultable
163
gastrointestinal borborygmi and mild to moderate nasogastric reflux) and also resulted in
164
rotational deviation of P3 from the dorsal hoof wall on her left front foot (the same foot affected
165
with pedal osteitis). After 3 days of low dose oxytetracycline, the endotoxemia seemed to have
166
resolved, however the patient’s abdomen became further distended with peritoneal fluid and
167
the cyclic fevers were no longer regressing. The oxytetracycline dose was increased (10 mg/kg
168
bwt i.v., q12h) which resulted in initial improvement (reduction in fevers and less abdominal
169
fluid), however, after the second dose, the mare developed watery diarrhea, and the dose was
AC C
EP
TE D
M AN U
SC
RI PT
144
ACCEPTED MANUSCRIPT reduced back to the 6.6 mg/kg bwt i.v., q12h. Weight loss during this time period was estimated
171
to be about 80 kg, and bloodwork revealed an anemia of chronic disease.
172
The mare was moved into an isolation stall due to her multi-drug resistant infection, which
173
limited her progressive monitoring with the ultrasound. Ultrasound evaluation of the abdomen
174
during this time frame revealed the progression of a 4-7 mm thickness fibrin layer coating the
175
serosal surface of the abdominal organs diffusely (Image 4). Given the mare’s static response to
176
oxytetracycline, profound antimicrobial resistance of the E.coli, and the marked fibrin formation
177
visible on ultrasound, a novel form of treatment was sought to reduce bacterial load and reduce
178
fibrin adhesion formation.
179
On day 56 post-celiotomy, the most cranial and dependent abdominal drain was replaced and
180
the abdomen was lavaged with 5L LRS and allowed to empty by gravity. Approximately 3000
181
disinfected Phaenicia sericata larvae (Medical Maggots) u were introduced into the abdomen via
182
the abdominal drain and the drain was removed (Image 5). A belly bandage was placed over the
183
open drain site with porous materials to allow a vent for oxygen passage into the abdomen as
184
well as a portal for maggot self-extraction.
185
24 hours after the first application of medical maggots into the abdomen, the mare had her first
186
24 hour period without a fever since the initial onset of peritonitis. Incidentally, there was a
187
dramatic increase in the number of flies in the mare’s isolated/completely enclosed stall, and
188
when the abdominal lavage was repeated 4 days later, no maggots were recovered. Ultrasound
189
evaluation revealed marked reduction in the fibrin layer in a 10 cm radius from the site of
190
maggot introduction (Image 6), however, areas more remote to the drain portal continued to
191
show fibrinous adhesion formation. Cytology results indicated marked reduction in inflammatory
192
response, with a decrease in nucleated cell count from 186,000/uL to 1400/uL.
AC C
EP
TE D
M AN U
SC
RI PT
170
ACCEPTED MANUSCRIPT Serial abdominal ultrasonography revealed progression and consolidation of an abscess capsule
194
visible on the right ventral abdomen that extended caudodorsally toward the base of the cecum
195
and craniomedially toward the ventral midline incision (Image 7). A second application of
196
medical maggots was performed on day 87, through a new portal placed directly into the
197
abscess in the right ventral flank region. Repeated ultrasound indicated reduction in the size of
198
the abscess where the maggots had been inserted (Image 8).
199
The patient continued to improve clinically, with resolution of fevers, improved appetite, and
200
weight gain. After approximately 4 weeks on intravenous oxytetracycline, perivascular irritation
201
necessitated a switch from intravenous to oral medications thus oxytetracycline was
202
discontinued and doxycycline (Doxycycline powder; 10 mg/kg bwt per os, q12h)v was initiated.
203
The mare continued to do well for 2 weeks until she became acutely and severely colicky. Rectal
204
examination, in conjunction with ultrasonography was highly suggestive of a strangulating small
205
intestinal lesion. Repeat laparotomy was declined by the owner and the mare was euthanized
206
on day 98, due to unrelenting pain.
207
2.4 Post mortem findings: Necropsy revealed strangulation/incarceration of approximately 8
208
feet of distal jejunum by a fibrous band of adhesions in the left inguinal region. The necropsy
209
also revealed a very well defined fibrous capsule of the abdominal abscess tracking from the
210
cranial aspect of the ventral midline incision up into the abdomen and wrapping caudally
211
towards the body of the cecum (Image 9). Upon further evaluation of the abscess, no purulent
212
material was present. The typhlotomy site was not involved in the abscess and there was no
213
evidence of eosinophilic granulomatous inflammation or residual maggots within the abdomen
214
at necropsy.
215 216
AC C
EP
TE D
M AN U
SC
RI PT
193
ACCEPTED MANUSCRIPT 3. Discussion:
218
Cecal impactions are a serious and not infrequent complication of patients hospitalized with
219
musculoskeletal disease9,10,11, and can rapidly result in cecal rupture despite medical
220
management2,11,12. Surgical intervention has a reported short-term survival rate of 82%9 to
221
95%11, which is greater than or comparable to that of medical management9,11, however surgery
222
involving cecal disorders have been associated with increased incidence of peritonitis and
223
incisional suppuration6,13,14 likely due to direct trauma to the incisional tissue during
224
manipulation and the anatomic positioning of the cecum often results in the typhlotomy being
225
mere inches from the abdominal incision, making contamination highly likely.
226
Surgical site infection is a common and important complication that occurs in 7.4%5 to 37%6 of
227
horses undergoing abdominal surgery for acute gastrointestinal disease, with the two most
228
common sources of contamination being flora of the gastrointestinal tract or superficial
229
contamination of the wound from skin bacteria or environmental contaminants13. Suggested
230
risk factors include use of polyglactin 910 to close the linea alba, trauma to the incisional edges,
231
endotoxemia on admission, contamination with intestinal content during surgery, repeat
232
celiotomy, and poor anesthetic recovery. Reported sequelae to incisional drainage is herniation,
233
incisional dehiscence, and evisceration15,16.
234
Reported causes of postoperative peritonitis include intestinal infarction and necrosis of a
235
segment of the gastrointestinal tract before or after surgical intervention, contamination during
236
surgery, or leakage from the anastomosis or enterotomy site17,18. The most common reported
237
pathogens isolated from horses with peritonitis include E. coli, Staphylococcus, Streptococcus,
238
Rhodococcus, Bacteroides, Clostridium, and Fusobacterium spp18.
239
While many of the same risk factors and bacterial isolates seem to be shared between peritonitis
240
and incisional infection, there is lack of evidence in previous literature to support a causal
AC C
EP
TE D
M AN U
SC
RI PT
217
ACCEPTED MANUSCRIPT relationship between these two conditions15. In this case report, the acuteness and severity of
242
the onset of clinical signs of septic peritonitis combined with the pure growth of Streptococcus
243
equi zooepidemicus, a common commensal organism of the equine epidermis, led to suspicions
244
that this case of peritonitis had resulted from an ascending incisional infection and internal
245
abscess formation that had subsequently ruptured internally once the external drainage tracts
246
had sealed over with granulation tissue. This explanation seems supported by the post mortem
247
finding of the abscess track that was directly leading from the incision site. It is speculated that
248
the incisional drainage may have communicated with an extraperitoneal incisional abscess,
249
similar to the cases reported by Rubio Martinez et al,8 which, when the granulation tissue had
250
sealed the drainage spots, built up pressure enough to break through the peritoneum and
251
disseminate into the abdomen. To the authors’ knowledge this is the first reported case of an
252
ascending incisional infection documented as causing a septic peritonitis in a horse.
253
Serial ultrasound evaluation of the abdomen during the treatment of peritonitis in this horse
254
revealed the progression of a fibrin layer coating the serosal surface of the abdominal organs
255
diffusely. Given the patient’s static response to oxytetracycline, marked antimicrobial resistance
256
of the E.coli, and the marked fibrin on ultrasound, a novel form of treatment was sought to
257
reduce bacterial load and reduce fibrin adhesion formation.
258
Up until the 1940’s maggot therapy was used commonly by human surgeons for controlling soft
259
tissue infections and as an adjunct to surgical resection for osteomyelitis. The advent of modern
260
antibiotics and improved surgical techniques drastically reduced the use of these “tiny
261
surgeons”, but they are still FDA approved for the debridement of non-healing necrotic skin and
262
soft tissue wounds. Due to their seemingly distasteful nature of consuming necrotic tissue,
263
fibrin, and bacteria, medical maggots seem to have become reserved for treatment of wounds
264
that are not responsive to conventional treatment or that have multi-drug resistant bacterial
265
infections. As part of their role as debriding agents, maggots secrete potent proteolytic enzymes
AC C
EP
TE D
M AN U
SC
RI PT
241
ACCEPTED MANUSCRIPT that have significant anti-microbial activity against bacteria such as Staphylococcus,
267
Streptococcus, Pseudomonas, and Escherichia coli, causing breakdown of biofilm formation and
268
making the wound environment unsuitable for bacterial colonization19,20.
269
In human medicine, medical maggots are most commonly used on pressure sores, venous ulcers,
270
neuropathic foot ulcers, and non-healing traumatic or postsurgical wounds, however reported
271
off-label applications include the use of maggots to debride areas in the pleural and peritoneal
272
spaces21. In equine medicine, medical maggots are most often used in conjunction with surgical
273
debridement as a non-traumatic, minimally invasive means of removing necrotic tissue from an
274
extensive foot infection involving deeper structures of the foot such as the coffin bone, collateral
275
cartilages, distal interphalangeal joint, and navicular bursa20,22. Other more rare case reports of
276
their use include debridement of necrotic tissues in cases of supraspinus bursitis, abdominal
277
wound dehiscence, chronic infected leg wounds, soft tissue abscesses, and one case with a
278
MRSA infection over an internal fixation device used to stabilize a fracture20. To the authors’
279
knowledge, no literature exists documenting the use of medical maggots within a body cavity of
280
a horse. After consultation with Monarch Labs, it was decided to use a dose of 3000 maggots,
281
the same dose that had been used in the cases of human peritonitis and pleuritis. The usual
282
dose of disinfected larvae is 5-10 maggots per square cm of wound surface area; however
283
consultation with the laboratory revealed that doses of 16000 maggots had been reported to
284
cause myiasis and hepatic encephalopathy in sheep, and thus maximal doses of 6000 larvae per
285
application cycle were recommended.
286
The risks associated with use of medical maggots are not well reported due to limited use,
287
however, one must consider the potential risks of the treatment such as myiasis, eosinophilic
288
granulomatous reaction, failure of the maggots to survive and grow within the abdomen,
289
inadequate debridement of the fibrinous material dispersed throughout the abdomen, and
290
failure to recover all maggots from the abdominal cavity at the end of the treatment cycle. A
AC C
EP
TE D
M AN U
SC
RI PT
266
ACCEPTED MANUSCRIPT relatively conservative dose of Phaenicia sericata larvae was used to minimize the risk of myiasis
292
and degree of eosinophilic inflammation. At necropsy, no evidence of inappropriate tissue
293
consumption or eosinophilic response was seen. In this case report, no maggots were recovered
294
from the abdominal lavage 5 days after application, which raises concern about failure of the
295
maggots to survive within the abdominal cavity or loss of maggots within the abdomen. After
296
consultation with Monarch Labs, it was decided to leave the ventral drain portal open as a vent
297
to allow oxygen access for the Phaenicia sericata larvae and also to act as a portal for self-
298
extraction once the larvae were satiated, as is in accordance with their natural life cycle. This is
299
similar to how the medical maggot treatments were carried out in human thoracic and
300
peritoneal cavities and was thought to be appropriate for larvae placement within the equine
301
peritoneal cavity. It is possible that the larvae died upon instillation into the abdominal cavity
302
and their bodies were resorbed, however, the lack of eosinophilic granulomatous reaction at
303
necropsy does not suggest this. At the time of maggot implantation, the mare was being housed
304
in a completely confined concrete isolation building with controlled airflow into and out of the
305
stall. For the week following administration of the Phaenicia sericata larvae, there was an
306
exponential increase in the number of flies within the stall which could not be accounted for by
307
external migration alone. The other option for maggot administration is to apply the maggots
308
into the body cavity while still contained within a porous fabric bag (Biobag System). This allows
309
debridement via proteolytic enzyme secretion, but greatly limits the phagocytosis of fibrinous
310
material and the ability of the larvae to migrate to more confined areas of contamination. The
311
benefit of application of maggots within a porous bag would be that it assures that there will be
312
no loss of larvae within the cavity and might have also been a way to quantify larval survival
313
within the abdomen. However, larval bag placement was deemed less appropriate for this case
314
because it was felt that the bagged larvae would be less efficacious in debridement of the entire
315
abdomen, the bag might act as an irritant to cause more serosal adhesion formation, and would
316
also require a more invasive surgical procedure for retrieval. It is entirely plausible that the
AC C
EP
TE D
M AN U
SC
RI PT
291
ACCEPTED MANUSCRIPT improvement in the mare’s clinical status was due to the treatment with prolonged tetracycline
318
administration, however, the decision to add maggot therapy was made in response to a
319
suspected treatment failure at the low dose oxytetracycline (further peritoneal fluid distension
320
and cyclic fevers) and intolerance of the higher dose of oxytetracycline (diarrhea). The authors
321
feel confident in saying that the maggots caused no harm and likely contributed positively to the
322
treatment of the peritonitis if only by facilitating the continued treatment with low dose
323
oxytetracycline.
324
Subjectively, the authors feel that the use of medical maggots as a debriding agent was
325
efficacious in reducing fibrinous adhesions in the immediate area of application; however, the
326
maggots did not migrate as far from the site of administration as was hoped. It is speculated
327
that a greater surface area might have been able to be debrided by either using a larger dose
328
(6000 maggots) or by administering smaller doses of maggots at multiple sites around the
329
abdomen. It is also speculated that earlier administration of the medical maggots may have
330
improved their efficacy, as the fibrinous adhesions would have been less well established. No
331
deleterious effects were seen as a result of either maggot application, but further studies are
332
warranted to determine an appropriate dose and administration distribution, and expected
333
efficacy of intraperitoneal maggot debridement therapy.
EP
TE D
M AN U
SC
RI PT
317
Manufacturers’ addresses:
335
a SAGENT Pharmaceuticals, Inc., Schaumburg, Illinois, USA
336
b Sparhawk Laboratories, Inc., Lenexa, Kansas, USA
337
c Intervet Inc., Merck & Co. Inc. Whitehouse Station, New Jersey, USA
338
d Hospira, Inc, Lake Forest, Illinois, USA
339
e Fort Dodge Animal Health, a division of Wyeth, Pfizer Inc, New York, New York, USA
340
f West-Ward, Eatontown, New Jersey, USA
341
g Akorn, Inc., Decatur, Illinois, USA
AC C
334
ACCEPTED MANUSCRIPT h Boehringer Ingelheim Vetmedica, Inc., St. Joseph, MO, USA
343
i Hospira, Inc., Lake Forest, Illinois, USA
344
j Piramal Healthcare Limited, Digwal Village, Andhra Pradesh, India
345
k Roerig, division of Pfizer, Inc., New York, New York, USA,
346
l Teva Parenteral Medications, Inc, Irvine, California, USA
347
m Hospira, Inc, Lake Forest, Illinois, USA
348
n X-GEN Pharmaceuticals Inc., Big Flats, New York, USA
349
o SAGENT Pharmaceuticals, Inc, Schaumburg, Illinois, USA
350
p Bayer Healthcare LLC, Animal Health Division, Shawnee Mission, Kansas, USA
351
q Bimeda, Inc, Le sueur, Minnesota, USA
352
r Wedgewood Pharmacy, Swedesboro, New Jersey, USA
353
s Pharmacia & Upjohn Co., Division of Pfizer Inc, New York, New York, USA
354
t Zoetis Inc, Kalamazoo, Michigan, USA
355
u Monarch Labs, Irvine, California, USA
356
v Wedgewood Pharmacy, Swedesboro, New Jersey, USA
SC
M AN U
TE D
357
RI PT
342
Image Legend:
359
Image 1 and Image 2: (day 3 post-celiotomy) This longitudinal image of a small intestinal loop,
360
located in the left ventral flank region, demonstrates a wall that is thickened and edematous,
361
consistent with anterior enteritis. Note there is scant amount of free peritoneal fluid and the serosal
362
surfaces of the intestine appear smooth.
363
Image 3: (day 8) Copious drainage soaking through the belly bandage from draining sites at the
364
cranial (black arrow) and middle (blue arrow) aspects of the incision line. Digital pressure on the
365
incision line caudal to the draining sites resulted in expression of approximately 10 mL of purulent
366
material. The incision site was cleaned daily with 4% chlorhexidine and saline and the belly bandage
367
changed daily.
AC C
EP
358
ACCEPTED MANUSCRIPT Image 4: (day 47) Moderate amount of anechoic free peritoneal fluid and fibrin lining the serosal
369
surfaces of the small intestine and body wall in the left ventral abdomen.
370
Image 5: (day 56) Approximately 3000 medical grade maggots were instilled into the abdomen via
371
the left ventral abdominal drain portals.
372
Image 6: (day 81) Left ventral abdomen at the site of the cranial drain portal, 25 days after the first
373
medical maggot therapy. There is a mild amount of free peritoneal fluid, but the fibrin lining the
374
intestine is no longer identifiable.
375
Image 7: (day 87) Encapsulated abscess in the right ventral flank region between the body wall and
376
cecum. This window was used for the site of the second medical maggot application.
377
Image 8: (day 96) Right ventral flank portal site, 7 days after the second application of medical
378
maggots.
379
Image 9: Necropsy revealed a well-defined abdominal abscess that tracked from the cranial aspect of
380
the ventral midline incision (arrow) up into the abdomen and wrapped caudally towards the body of
381
the cecum. Note the body is in left lateral recumbency.
TE D
M AN U
SC
RI PT
368
EP
382 References:
384
[1] Hawkins JK, Bowman KF, Roberts M. Peritonitis in horses. J Am Vet Med Assoc 1993; 203:284
385
[2] Smith LCR, Payne RJ, Boys Smith SJ, Bathe AP, and Greet TRC. Outcome and long-term follow-up
386
of 20 horses undergoing surgery for caecal impaction: A retrospective study (2000-2008). Equine
387
Vet J. 2010; 42: 388-392.
388
[3] Mair TS1, Smith LJ. Survival and complication rates in 300 horses undergoing surgical treatment
389
of colic. Part 2: Short-term complications. Equine Vet J. 2005; 37(4):303-9.
AC C
383
ACCEPTED MANUSCRIPT [4] Driscoll, N., Baia, P., Fischer, A. T., Brauer, T. and Klohnen, A. Large colon resection and
391
anastomosis in horses: 52 cases (1996–2006). Equine Veterinary Journal 2008; 40: 342–347
392
[5] Freeman, D.E., Hammock, P., Baker, G.J., Foreman, J.H., Schaeffer, D.J., Richter, R.-A., Inoue, O.,
393
and Magid, J.H. Short- and long-term survival and prevalence of post operative ileus after small
394
intestinal surgery in the horse. Equine vet. J., Suppl. 2000; 32, 42-51
395
[6] Phillips, T.J. and Walmsley, J.P. Retrospective analysis of the results of 151 exploratory
396
laparotomies in horses with gastrointestinal disease. Equine vet. J. 1993; 25, 427-431
397
[7] Honnas, C.M. and Cohen, N.D. Risk factors for wound infection following celiotomy in horses. J.
398
am. vet. med. Ass. 1997; 2100, 78-81
399
[8] Rubio Martinez L.M., Cribb N.C., and Koenig J.B. Extraperitoneal incisional abscess formation
400
after colic surgery in 3 horses. Equine Vet. Educ. 2012; 24, 109-115
401
[9] Aitken, M.R., Southwood, L.L., Ross, B.M., and Ross, M.W. Outcome of surgical and medical
402
management of cecal impaction in 150 horses (1991-2011). Vet Surg. 2014; doi: 10.1111/j.1532-
403
950X.2014.12286.x
404
[10] Roberts, C.T., and Slone, D.E. Caecal impactions managed surgically by typhlotomy in 10 cases
405
(1988-1998). Equine vet. J., Suppl. 2000; (32) 74-76
406
[11] Plummer A.E., Rakestraw P.C., Hardy J., and Lee R.M. Outcome of medical and surgical
407
treatment of cecal impaction in horses: 114 cases (1994-2004). JAVMA. 2007; 231, 1378-1385
408
[12] Dart A.J., Dowling B.A., and Hudgson D.R. Cecal disease. Equine vet. Educ. 1999; 11, 182-188
409
[13] Ingle-Fehr J.E., Baxter G.M., Howard R.D., Trotter G.W., and Stashak T.S. Bacterial Culturing of
410
Ventral Median Celiotomies for Prediction of Postoperative Incisional complications in Horses. Vet.
411
Surg. 1997; 26, 7-13
AC C
EP
TE D
M AN U
SC
RI PT
390
ACCEPTED MANUSCRIPT [14] Kobluk CN, Ducharme NG, Lumsden JH, et al. Factors affecting incisional complication rates
413
associated with colic surgery in horses: 78 cases (1983-1985). J Am Vet Med Assoc 1989; 195:639-
414
642
415
[15] Freeman D.E., Rotting A.K., and Inoue O.J. Abdominal Closure and Complications. Clinical
416
Techniques in Equine Practice. 2002; 1, 174-187
417
[16] French N.P., Smith J., Edwards G.B., and Proudman C.J. Equine surgical colic: risk factors for
418
postoperative complications. Equine vet. J. 2002; 34, 444-449
419
[17] Hillyer M.H., Wright C.J. Peritonitis in the horse. Equine vet. Educ. 1997; 9, 136-142
420
[18] Hardy J., Rakestraw P.C. Postoperative Management for Colics. Clinical Techniques in Equine
421
Practice. 2002; 1, 188-197
422
[19] Jones G., Wall R. Maggot-therapy in veterinary medicine. Research in veterinary Science. 2008;
423
85, 394-398
424
[20] Lepage O.M., Doumbia A., Perron-Lepage M.F., and Gangl M. The use of maggot debridement
425
therapy in 41 equids. Equine vet. J. 2012; 44, 120-125
426
[21] Sherman R.A., Shapiro C.E., Yang R.M. Maggot Therapy for Problematic Wounds: Uncommon
427
and Off-label Applications. Advances in Skin & Wound Care. 2007; 20, 602-610
428
[22] Morrison S.E. How to Use Sterile Maggot Debridement Therapy for Foot Infections of the Horse.
429
Proc. Am. Ass. equine Practnrs. 2005; 51, 461-464
430
AC C
EP
TE D
M AN U
SC
RI PT
412
AC C
EP
TE D
M AN U
SC
RI PT
ACCEPTED MANUSCRIPT
AC C
EP
TE D
M AN U
SC
RI PT
ACCEPTED MANUSCRIPT
AC C
EP
TE D
M AN U
SC
RI PT
ACCEPTED MANUSCRIPT
AC C
EP
TE D
M AN U
SC
RI PT
ACCEPTED MANUSCRIPT
AC C
EP
TE D
M AN U
SC
RI PT
ACCEPTED MANUSCRIPT
AC C
EP
TE D
M AN U
SC
RI PT
ACCEPTED MANUSCRIPT
AC C
EP
TE D
M AN U
SC
RI PT
ACCEPTED MANUSCRIPT
AC C
EP
TE D
M AN U
SC
RI PT
ACCEPTED MANUSCRIPT
AC C
EP
TE D
M AN U
SC
RI PT
ACCEPTED MANUSCRIPT
ACCEPTED MANUSCRIPT
Highlights
RI PT
SC M AN U TE D
•
EP
•
We describe the potential progression of a ventral midline suppurative incisional wound into a septic peritonitis We describe the novel use of medical grade Phaenicia sericata larvae in the treatment of a multi-drug resistant peritonitis in a horse Medical grade Phaenicia sericata larvae caused no ill effects when placed into the peritoneal cavity
AC C
•