- Email: [email protected]
Real-time observation of bacterial gene expression noise
Accepted Manuscript Real-time observation of bacterial gene expression noise Olga Anufrieva, Adrien Sala, Olli Yli-Harja, Meenakshisundaram Kandhavelu PII: DOI: Reference:
S1878-7789(16)00012-0 http://dx.doi.org/10.1016/j.nancom.2016.03.001 NANCOM 147
To appear in:
Nano Communication Networks
Received date: 18 September 2015 Revised date: 17 February 2016 Accepted date: 3 March 2016 Please cite this article as: O. Anufrieva, A. Sala, O. Yli-Harja, M. Kandhavelu, Real-time observation of bacterial gene expression noise, Nano Communication Networks (2016), http://dx.doi.org/10.1016/j.nancom.2016.03.001 This is a PDF file of an unedited manuscript that has been accepted for publication. As a service to our customers we are providing this early version of the manuscript. The manuscript will undergo copyediting, typesetting, and review of the resulting proof before it is published in its final form. Please note that during the production process errors may be discovered which could affect the content, and all legal disclaimers that apply to the journal pertain.
Real-time observation of bacterial gene expression noise +& -4%1($5 #1($- + ++( +( 1) -#$$- *2'(24-# 1 , -#' 5$+4
.+$"4+ 1 (&- +(-& !.,/43 3(.- + 823$,2(.+.&8$2$ 1"'1.4/ (&- +1."$22(-&$/ 13,$-3 ,/$1$ -(5$12(38.% $"'-.+.&8.7
,/$1$(-+ -# , (+ ,$$- *2'(24-# 1 ,* -#' 5$+4 343%(
ABSTRACT
'$, 5 1( !(+(38(-3'$2(-&+$"$++2 331(!43$23.1 -#.,/$1(.#2.%31 -2"1(/3(.-!41232 '$ "$++"8"+$/.22$22$2 &+.! +1.+$(- %%$"3(-&31 -2"1(/3(.- +.43/438$7/1$22(-&3'(2/1."$22 2 ".,,4-(" 3(.-2823$, 33'$- -.2" +$3'(231 -2"1(/3(.-.43/43.%3$- "".4-32%.13'$&$-$ $7/1$22(.--.(2$ -#3'(204 -3(%($23'$/1.,.3$1 "3(5(38.6$5$1"411$-323."' 23(",.#$+2 (&-.1$ 3'$ % "3 3' 3 &$-$ $7/1$22(.- -.(2$ (2 %%$"3$# -.3 .-+8 !8 3'$ "$++ "8"+$ -# /1.,.3$1 "3(5(38!43 +2.!83'$3(,$#41(-&6'("'-$6, 2 1$/1.#4"$#$1$6$2'.63' 3-.(2$ %1., 3'$ /1.,.3$1 (- (2 #.,(- 3$# !8 (-31(-2(" -# $731(-2(" -.(2$2 (- 2+.6 -# % 23 #(5(#(-& "$++2 1$2/$"3(5$+8 4"' #.,(- 3(.- .% 3'$ -.(2$ ".,/.-$-32 (- /' 2$2 6(3' #(%%$1$-3 &$-$1 3(.- 3(,$2 (2 "'($5$# 3'1.4&' #(23(-"3 -# ".,!(- 3.1( + (-3$1 "3(.-2 !$36$$- 3'$ 4/231$ ,#.6-231$ ,1$&4+ 3.18$+$,$-32 '$2$,$"' -(2,22$15$ 2 - # /3(5$231 3$&8%.1 (-"1$ 2(-&/./4+ 3(.-'.,.&$-$(384-#$1"' -&(-&$-5(1.-,$-32 Keywords: /1.,.3$1 &$-$ $7/1$22(.- -.(2$ ".,/.-$-32 "$++ "8"+$ !41238 , /1.#4"3(.-
Introduction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
2
)9,8<(:054 5- ;69:8,(3+5=49:8,(3 68535:,8 8,.054 3,+0(:,+ 9:5*/(9:0* .,4, ,>68,99054 04 :/, )(*:,80(2 *,229 5<,8 :/, :03, 04 +0--,8,4: *,22 .85=:/ 6/(9,9 09 45: =,22 ,9:()290/,+ #/,? (225=-5868,+0*:04./5=:/,*,22656;2(:0541,,69:/,9:()020:?)?35+;2(:04.2,<,295-:/,*,22 :5*,22 <(80()020:? (4+ )5:/ 4509, 5+;2(:054 5- :/, .,4, ,>68,99054 4509, +,9*80),+ 5<,8 :/, :03, 5- .85=:/ 5- :/, 6/(9,9 ,>6(4+9 5;8 ;4+,89:(4+04. ()5;: :/, )(*:,80(2 *,22;2(8 (*:0<0:? 4 6,896,*:0<, :/,9, 8,9;2:9 *5;2+ ), *536(8,+ =0:/ :/, 2,<,2 5- 9:5*/(9:0* .,4, ,>68,99054(::8(492(:0545<,8:03,:5+,9*80),/5=)(*:,80(),/(<,+;804.:/,*,22*?*2,;4+,8 <(805;9,>6,803,4:(2*54+0:0549 #! " # " Plasmids, Strains and media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nduction and determination of the cell phases #5 :8(*1 :/, )(*:,80(2 .,4, ,>68,99054 4509, 04 8,(2 :03, 5<,8 :/, 6/(9, =, +,<,256,+ :=5 9:8(049(9+,9*80),+()5<,58:/09 ( ! 9:8(0409.85=4;4+,856:03(2*54+0:054 -58:/,+,:,8304(:0545-:/,)(*:,80(2*,226/(9,9:09+54,)?*;2:0<(:04.*,2295<,840./:04(4 58)0:(29/(1,8 ()4,:(: B=0:/(,8(:054(:
! #/,4*,229(8,+02;:,+04-8,9/3,+0( (4+ 56:0*(2 +,490:? 09 3,(9;8,+ ;904. 96,*:856/5:53,:,8 $2:8(96,* 3,89/(3 059*0,4*,9(4+A 098,(*/,+)?+02;:054-:,8=(8+9*,229(8,.85=4(: B=0:/ (,8(:054(:
! (4+.85=:/5-:/,*,229093,(9;8,+,<,8? 304;:,9,4,8(:054:03,95- :/, )(*:,80(2 *,22 6/(9,9 (8, +,:,8304,+ ;904. 3,(9;8,3,4:9 & ' %/,4 145=04. :/,.,4,8(:054:03,5-,(*/6/(9,=,(8,()2,:55)9,8<,:/,*,22968058+;804.58033,+0(:,2? (-:,8*,22;2(8+0<090549:,49;8,9:/(:656;2(:0545-:/,*,2295)9,8<,+;4+,8:/,30*859*56,(8, 04+,,+-853(6(8:0*;2(86/(9,4+;*:054(*:0<(:0545-.,4,,>68,990549?9:,3(::/,68535:,8 8,.0545-:/,*,229(:(6(8:0*;2(86/(9,(225=9-589:;+?04.:/,.,4,,>68,990545- (4+ <(80(4:68535:,89,:,*:0545-(904.2,3! 352,*;2,09+54,)?(*:0<(:0545-8,658:,8.,4, =0:/ 4.325-(4/?+85:,:8(*?*204,(#*25:4;3),8 3),83(4?-58
304;:,904*;)(:054
3
=44 16,=+<176 7. 8:757<-: 1; ,76- *A )+<1>)<176 7. ,7?6;<:-)5 !" :-/176 ?1<0 5 # "1/5) 4,:1+0$" )6, =8;<:-)5 $!" :-/176 *A -6,7/-67=; + =44 16,=+<176 7. >):1)6< 8:757<-: 1; ,76- *A ):)*167;- .:75 =8;<:-)5 "1/5) 4,:1+0$" )6, *A 5 # .:75 <0-,7?6;<:-)56,-8-6,-6<16,=+<1767.>):1)6< 8:757<-:1;,76-,-8-6,16/76<0-)+<1>)<176+76,1<176;"8-+1.1+)44A<0-8:757<-:1;)+<1>)<-, -1<0-:.:75<0-=8;<:-)57:,7?6;<:-)5;1<-;=;16/+7::-;876,16/16,=+-:;1/=:-" 7:<15- <:)+--@8-:15-6<;+-44;):-16,=+-,?1<0)#+.7: 516.7447?16/<0-16,=+<176;+0-5-7.<0- <):/-<8:757<-:6<0-<15-;-:1-;-@8-:15-6<;+-44;):-<)3-68:17:<7<0-,1>1;176<15-)6,):- 7*;-:>-,=6,-:<0-51+:7;+78-,=:16/ 516=<-;"=884-5-6<):A 7>1-" Fluorescence microscopy of live cells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
.0-!#"30#1&#!#**1 0#%0-5, 2
95'2& #0 2'-,-$ ,"5'2& !$-02�#.-02#0 !2'4 2'-,-',"3!#01 0#13..*'#"$-02 0%#2+.0-"3!2'-,0-+2'+#1#0'#1'+ %#1 5# $'," 2&# ..# 0 ,!# -$ $'012 $*3-0#1!#,2 1.-2 ', $'$27 0 ,"-+ !#**1 &#, 5# #620 !2 2&# $*3-0#1!#,!# ',2#,1'27 -$ # !& + 1.-2 &'1 ',$-0+ 2'-, '1 31#" 2- ! *!3* 2# +# , + ',2#,1'273..*#+#,2 07-4'## ,+',2#,1'27'1"#$',#" 12&#+# ,',2#,1'274 *3# -$ 1',%*#++-*#!3*# )',%',2- !!-3,2',$-0+ 2'-,$0-+2&#(3+."#2#!2'-,+#2&-" !#** !)%0-3,"!-00#!2#" 1.-2 ',2#,1'2'#1 ," 2&# +# , ',2#,1'27 -$ 1',%*# + +-*#!3*# 5# 0#$', **7 *#2-! *!3* 2#2&#,3+ #0-$++-*#!3*#1.0-"3!#"',# !&20 ,1!0'.2'-, * #4#,2 , 13!& 5 7 2 *# 12 -,# &3,"0#" !#**1 0# , *78#" ', # !& #6.#0'+#,2 * !-,"'2'-, *# ," Evaluation of bursty promoter behavior 2'1),-5,2& 2!#**1.0-"3!#+', 301215&'!& 0#.#0'-"1-$&'%&.0-+-2#0 !2'4'27 # 2&31 0# ',2#0#12#" 2- - 1#04#" 5� !#**1 !-,2 ',',% ," 4 0' ,2 .0-+-2#01 #6&' '2 30127 #& 4'-0-02&'1.30.-1#5#31#',$-0+ 2'-,-$2&#.0-"3!2'-,',2#04 *1 #25##, 2&# 30121! *!3* 2#"$0-+2&#',2#,1'27(3+.1,"##"- 1#04 2'-,-$ 1#/3#,!#-$,-,*',# 0 +.0-"3!2'-,#4#,21',2',%*#!#**1',"'! 2#12& 2 ," 4 0' ,2.0-+-2#01.-11#1 30127 #& 4'-0 2 !!-3,21 $-0 .0#1#,!# -$ 2&# %#,# #6.0#11'-, ,-'1# ', 2# #6.#0'+#,21 13 **7 2 !#**.-.3* 2'-,%#,##6.0#11'-,,-'1#'1#4 *3 2#" 72&# 3012',#11$ !2-0-0 ,- $ !2-0 - 5# !-,1'"#0 2& 2 2&# %#,# #6.0#11'-,,-'1#', !#**.-.3* 2'-,'1"#$',#" 1 !#**2-!#**4 0' '*'27 ,"'1#12'+ 2#" 7
-"#+-,120 2#2&#.0-"3!2'-,-$,#5+1'," 3%&2#0!#**1-4#02'+#5#!0# 2# +-4'# !-,1'12',%-$2'+#* .1#'+ %#12 )#,#4#07+',32#"30',% +',32#13..*#+#,2 07-4'# &#+-4'#1&-5125-!#**15&'!&.0-"3!#++-*#!3*#13,"#0 !2'4# .0-+-2#0-4#0 2'+#&#'+ %# ,"+-4'#3..*#+#,2 07-4'#1&-525-!#**"'4'1'-,1',#6.-,#,2' * .& 1#5�#2 0%#2++-*#!3*#1 0#.0-"3!#"3,"#0 !2'4# .0-+-2#0 Noise calculation ##12'+ 2#',20',1'! ,"#620',1'!!-+.-,#,21-$2&#,-'1# 220 ,1!0'.2'-, 731',%',$-0+ 2'-, -32 + $*3!23 2'-, ', " 3%&2#0 !#**1 - 2 ',#" $0-+ 2 %%',% +#2&-" -0 1.*'22',% -$ !#**2-!#** 4 0' '*'27 ',2- ',20',1'! ," #620',1'! !-+.-,#,21 *#2 ," "#,-2#2&#*#4#*1-$+1,3+ #0.#025-" 3%&2#0!#**1 2 %'4#2'+#
',2
#62
2-2
5
:). +89/2'9/43 4, -+3+ +=57+88/43 34/8+ <'8 ,/7891> +89'(1/8.+* (> 9.+ 14 5+)/,/)'11> <+ )438/*+7 9.'9 2 574*:)9/43 ,742 9<4 *':-.9+7 )+118 4(8+7;+* 4;+7 9.+ 9/2+ -/;+8 +88+39/'1 /3,472'9/43 ,47 )'1):1'9/3- /397/38/) '3* +=97/38/) 34/8+ )42543+398 84 9.'9(49.4,9.+22'0+'3479.4-43'1)4397/(:9/43949.+)+1194)+11;'7/'(/1/9>47949'134/8+
:).+;'1:'9/434,9.+-+3++=57+88/4334/8+'997'38)7/59/43<'8,/7891>+89'(1/8.+*(>9.+ '1' +9 '1 % & <.4 *+8)7/(+* 9.+ 1+;+18 4, 9.+ )+1194)+11 ;'7/'(/1/9> '3* /397/38/)+=97/38/) )42543+398 /3 9.+ )+118 4, =543+39/'1 5.'8+ 438+6:+391> <+ +=9+3* 9.+ 57+;/4:8 4(8+7;'9/438 (> *+8)7/(/3- *>3'2/)'1 ).'3-+8 4, -+3+ +=57+88/43 348/+ 4;+7 9.+ 9/2+ /3 */,,+7+39 (')9+7/'1 )+11 5.'8+8 :3*+7 ' 3:2(+7 4, +=5+7/2+39'1 )43*/9/438 !.+ '1-47/9.2 ,47 +89/2'9/43 4, -+3+ +=57+88/43 34/8+ /8 /251+2+39+* /3 '91'( ' 4124-474;@ 2/734; 9+89/8:8+*94*+9+72/3+89'9/89/)'11>8/-3/,/)'397+1'9/438./58 "! Presence of the noise in cells of different phases !.+*+9+)9/434,2 574*:)9/435+78/3-1+)+11.'8549+39/'194+3.'3)+4:7:3*+789'3*/3- 4,9.+ 894).'89/) -+3++=57+88/43'9 97'38)7/59/43 '3* (/4).+2/)'1 2+).'3/828 /3;41;+* :7 9441,47*+9+)9/3-2 83:2(+75+78/3-1+)+11/8 2+9.4*9/2+8+7/+8+=5+7/2+39 /-:7+ !.+ /-:7+ /11:897'9+8 )+11:1'7 */;/8/43 '3* )438+):9/;+ 2 574*:)9/43 +;+398,7429.+574249+7/39.+)+1181:)9:'9/434,9.+2 574*:)9/434;+79.+ 9/2+'))4:398,4757+8+3)+4,)+1194)+11;'7/'(/1/9>/3'545:1'9/43+1194)+11;'7/'(/1/9>/8 +89/2'9+* (> 9.+ '34 ,')947 47 (:789/3+88 ,')947 9.'9 /8 */;/*+* /394 9<4 34/8+ )42543+398 8:). '8 +=97/38/) '3* /397/38/) /-:7+ /89/3-:/8./3- (+9<++3 9<4 34/8+ )42543+398 /8 ('8+* 43 9.+ 2 8 ,1:)9:'9/43 5+7 8/3-1+ )+11 4;+7 9.+ 9/2+ '3* '243- 9.+ )+118 /3 ' 545:1'9/43 5+)/,/)'11> /397/38/) )42543+39 /8 9.+ ,1:)9:'9/43 4, 574*:)9/43 '3* *+-7'*'9/43 +;+398 4, 2 8 /3 8/3-1+ *':-.9+7 )+118 4;+7 9.+ 9/2+ <./1+ +=97/38/) )42543+39 /8 ' */,,+7+3)+ 4, 2 ,1:)9:'9/438 (+9<++3 9.+ *':-.9+7 )+118 4;+7 9.+ 9/2+ /-:7+ (8+7;'9/434,9.+*>3'2/)'1241+):1+574*:)9/4387+;+'1857+8+3)+4,(49.34/8+)42543+398 4;+7 (')9+7/'1 )+11 5.'8+8 /-:7+ 438+6:+391> *>3'2/)'1 ,1:)9:'9/438 4, /397/38/) '3* +=97/38/)34/8+)42543+398*+5+3*:543)+11)>)1+ Quantification of the noise components in cells of different phases #+ 97')0 9.+ *>3'2/)'1 ).'3-+8 4, /397/38/) '3* +=97/38/) 34/8+ 1+;+18 4;+7 9.+ 9/2+ 4;+7 (')9+7/'1 )+11 5.'8+8 +7+ <+ )438/*+7 9.'9 '- ))+1+7'9/43 =543+39/'1 +9'7*'9/43 '3* 9'9/43'7>'7+9.+5.'8+8/3)1:*+*/394(')9+7/'1)+11)>)1+% &3'3'1>8/87+;+'189.'9 (49.34/8+)42543+39847/-/3'9+*,742/-:7+ '3*;'7/'39/-:7+ 574249+78 ,1:)9:'9+/3'8/2/1'72'33+74;+79.+9/2+/3*/,,+7+39(')9+7/'1)+115.'8+8/-:7+ 92+'38 9.'9(+.';/474,;'7/'39574249+7*+8)7/(+8(+.';/474,574249+7'3*/8'551/)'(1+,47 9.+-+3+7'1/?'9/434,9.+7+8:198'8+*439.+5.'8+-+3+7'9/439/2+8<+*/;/*+(')9+7/'1)+11 5.'8+8 /394 9<4 )'9+-47/+8 8:). '8 814< '- +9'7*'9/43 '3* 9'9/43'7> 5.'8+8 '3* ,'89 ))+1+7'9/43'3*=543+39/'15.'8+8*/;/*/3-)+118% & (8+7;/3-).'3-+84,9.+34/8+ 1+;+18/3814<'3*,'89*/;/*/3-)+118'114<8,47*+8)7/(/3-9.+741+4,)+11:1'7*/;/8/43 49.+ 5;'1:+8 *+7/;+* ,742 4124-474;@ 2/734; 9+89 /3*/)'9+8 9.'9 /397/38/) 34/8+ *42/3'9+8 /3 814< */;/*/3- )+118 '3* +=97/38/) 34/8+ 7:1+8 ,'89 */;/*/3- )+118 !'(1+ $+9 +=97/38/) )42543+39/3814<'3*/397/38/))42543+39/3,'89*/;/*/3-)+118'7+3493+-1+)9+*'8(49.4, 9.+2 51'> ' 741+ /3 9.+ 1+;+18 4, )+1194)+11 ;'7/'(/1/9> %
& :(8+6:+391> */,,+7+39 6
%#+#/ 1',+ 1'*#0 ,$ !1#/' ) !#)) -& 0#0 -) 6 /,)# '+ 1&# $)2!12 1',+0 ,$ ,1& +,'0# !,*-,+#+10 11� *#1'*#1'*#- / *#1#/'+$)2#+!#$)2!12 1',+,$)#3#)0,$ ,1&+,'0# !,*-,+#+10,1'*#0! )#'0 +'*-,/1 +1- / *#1#/4&'!&& 01, #1 (#+'+1, !!,2+14&#+ !1'3'16 ,$ -/,*,1#/ '0 "#$'+#" + ""'1',+ 1, 1&# 1'*# - / *#1#/ '+"#-#+"#+1 2-01/# * +" ",4+01/# * -/,*,1#/ !1'3 1',+0 -) 6 "'01'+!1 /,)#0 '+ 1&# )#3#)0 ,$ ,1& +,'0# !,*-,+#+10 #1 +#'1&#/ ,$ 1&#* /#0#* )#0 1&# !& +%# ,$ ,1& +,'0# !,*-,+#+10 '+ $2))6 '+"2!#" !#))0 ,+0#.2#+1)6 '+1#/-) 6 #14##+ ",*'+ +1 +,'0# !,*-,+#+10 1 "'$$#/#+1 !1#/' )!#))-& 0#0* 6 ##5-) '+#" 61&#!,* '+ 1,/' )#$$#!1,$2-01/# * +"",4+01/# * %#+# !1'3 1',+!,+"'1',+0 Modulation of the noise components by independent gene activations # !1'3 1#'+"#-#+"#+1)63 /' +1-/,*,1#/$/,*2-01/# * +"",4+01/# *1,012"6&,4 02!&%#+# !1'3 1',+!,+"'1',+0 $$#!11&#%#+##5-/#00',++,'0#,$1&#$2))6'+"2!#"!#))0# $'+" 1& 1 2-01/# * '+"2!1',+ ,$ ) ! 3 /' +1 -/,*,1#/ /#02)10 '+ ",*'+ +1 '+1/'+0'! +,'0# '+
!!#)#/ 1',+ +" 1 1',+ /6 -& 0#0 '%2/# +" ",*'+ +1 #51/'+0'! +,'0# '+ % 5-,+#+1' ) +" #1 /" 1',+ -& 0#0 '%2/# �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evels of cell-to-cell variability in cells of different phases /#0#+!# ,$ ,1& '+1/'+0'! +" #51/'+0'! +,'0# !,*-,+#+10 !!,2+10 $,/ 1&# -,00' ')'16 1, .2 +1'$6 !#))1,!#)) 3 /' ')'16 ,/ 1,1 ) +,'0# 02 ))6 1 -,-2) 1',+ )#3#) !#))1,!#)) 3 /' ')'16'0#01'* 1#" 61&# +,$ !1,/,/ 2/01'+#00$ !1,/ &#+! )!2) 1'+% 2/01'+#00 $ !1,/ 4# , 0#/3# 1& 1 '1 "#!/# 0#0 $/,* % 1, #1 /" 1',+ -& 0#0 +" '+!/# 0#0 $/,*#1 /" 1',+1,1 1',+ /6-& 0#'+1&#$2))6'+"2!#"!#))0'%2/# 1'))201/ 1#01&#/,)# ,$"'01'+!1!#))-& 0#0,+1,1&#)#3#)0,$!#))1,!#))3 /' ')'16 + % +" #1 /" 1',+ -& 0# !#))0 2/01'+#00 $ !1,/ '0 2+#5-#!1#")6 &'%& 4&#+ 1 /# '+"2!#"$/,*1-01/# *'%2/#
1!,2)" #"2#1,0),4"'3'0',+/ 1# +"1&200),4 - /1'1',+'+% ,$ * *,)#!2)#0 #14##+ 1&# " 2%&1#/ !#))0 , 2-01/# * '+"2!1',+ $$#!10 01,!& 01'!'16,$%#+##5-/#00',+'+-& 0#04'1&0),4"'3'"'+%!#))01- /1)6 %/##04'1&/#!#+1 $'+"'+%0 ,$ ",*'+ +1 /,)# ,$ 2-01/# * '+"2!1',+ '+ 1&# # /)'#/ !#))2) / -& 0#0 #% % ,/
!!#)#/ 1',+ + $ 01 "'3'"'+% !#))0 2/01'+#00 $ !1,/ "#!/# 0#0 $/,* !!#)#/ 1',+ 1, 5-,+#+1' )-& 0#'+!#))0'+"2!#"$/,*1-01/# * +"",4+01/# *'%2/# 1 !!,2+10 $,/1&#/,)#,$$ 01!#))2) /"'3'0',+'+!,+1/' 21',+,$ ,1&+,'0#!,*-,+#+10,$1&#!#))1,!#)) 3 /' ')'16&#/#02)100&,41& 10),4 +"$ 01"'3'0',+/ 1#0"#1#/*'+#-/,*,1#/ !1'3'16 +" 1&20 !#))1,!#)) 3 /' ')'16 0 #5-#!1#" *# 02/'+% !#))1,!#)) 3 /' ')'16 '+ '+"#-#+"#+1)6 '+"2!#" !#))0 ",#0 +,1 /#3# ) 1&#'/ !,//#) 1',+0 4'1& 1&# !#))1,!#)) 3 /' ')'16 ,$ 1&# $2))6 7
%) 0 ! !''. *).!,0!)/'4*)'4/$!%- *( %) /*-% '!""! /+-* 0 !.* .!-1! +-*+ # /%*)*" /$!#!)!!3+-!..%*))*%.!/$-*0#$*0//$! !''+$ .!.
/* $ ./% %/4*" #!)!!3+-!..%*)%."0) (!)/ '"! /0-!/$ / !. -% !. !$ 1%*-*".%)#'! !'' %) $*(*#!)*0. +*+0' /%*) $! (* !-) -!.! - $ /$*0#$ ' &. /$! &)*2'! #! *0/ /$! "'0 /0 /%*) *" ./* $ ./% #!)! !3+-!..%*) %) /!-% ' !'' +$ .!. . 2!'' %/ %. '%(%/! /* !. -% %)#$*2./* $ ./% #!)!!3+-!..%*) $ )#!.*1!-/$!/%(! / + -/% 0' - !''0' -+$ .! $!.! "! /0-!. $*2!1!- -! !-/ %)'4 %(+*-/ )/ "*- /$! !/ %'! %)1!./%# /%*) *" #!)! !3+-!..%*))*%.! %/$ /$! %( *" 0) !-./ ) %)# $*2 /%(! " /*- ""! /. #!)! !3+-!..%*) )*%.! %) %""!-!)/ /!-% ' !''+$ .!.2!./0 %! +-*(*/!- /%1%/4 //- ). -%+/%*)%)/$! !''.! * .!-1! /$ / "0''4 %) 0 ! +-*(*/!- #!)!- /!. "'0 /0 /%)# *1!- /$! +$ .!. !''/* !'' 1 -% %'%/4/%. !/!-(%)! 4%)/-%).% *(+*)!)/%)/$!.'*2 %1% %)# !''. ) 4!3/-%).% *(+*)!)/ %) /$! " ./ %1% %)# !''. . 2!'' . %/ +*..!..!. %./%) / '!1!'. / )4 #%1!) /%(! +*%)/ *" /$! !3+!-%(!)/ $!.! * .!-1 /%*). !).0-! /$ / !'' 4 '! ) /%(! " /*- -! &!4 !/!-(%) )/. 2$!-! ) )*.%5! -!+-!..*- 1 -%!. *1!- /$! +$ .! ) -!#0' /! /$! #!)! !3+-!..%*))*%.! $*0#$ /$!.! + - (!/!-. -! %(+*-/ )/ "*- /$! #!)! !3+-!..%*) )*%.! +-*(*/!- %) 0 /%*) *) %/%*). '.* ""! / /$! '!1!'. *" ./* $ ./% %/4 +! %"% ''4 2$!) !''. -! %) !+!) !)/'4 %) 0 ! "-*(/$!0+./-! (*- *2)./-! ( !''.$ 1! %./%) /'!1!'. ) "'0 /0 /%*)(* !.*" /$! #!)! !3+-!..%*) )*%.! !%/$!- *" /$!( -!.!( '! *(+'!/!'4 /$! "'0 /0 /%*). *" #!)! !3+-!..%*))*%.!0) !- *)/-*'*""0''4%) 0 ! +-*(*/!-$%.(! )./$ //$! *( %) /*-% ' !""! / *" 0+./-! ( ) *2)./-! ( #!)! /%1 /%*). %) /$! "0''4 %) 0 ! !''. %. " - (*-! *(+'!3 /$ ) !""! /. *" %) !+!) !)/ %) 0 /%*). /* */$ )*%.! *(+*)!)/. ! "%) ''4 #!)!- '%5!* .!-1! ./* $ ./% #!)!!3+-!..%*)*" +-*(*/!- 40.%)#%/..4)/$!/% 1 -% )/ $!-!"*-!2! *)"%-(/$ /* .!-1! !$ 1%*-*"/$! +-*(*/!- !. -% !./$!2%' /4+! 0- * .!-1 /%*). +*..!.. )0( !- *" )*1!'/%!. %-./'4 2! +-*+*.! #!)!- ' ++-* $ "*- !1 '0 /%*) *" /$! #!)! !3+-!..%*) )*%.! /$ / *( %)!. !3+!-%(!)/ ' +-* ! 0-! (!/$* ) %( #! .%#) ' +-* !..%)# ) '4.%. $*0#$ /$%. (!/$* $ . !!) !. -% ! 4 ' !/ ' *0- / .!/. !3/!) +-!1%*0. * .!-1 /%*) 4 / &%)# %)/* *).% !- /%*) /%(! " /*- ) !''0' -+$ .!.! *) '42!+!-"*-( ) '4.%. %) -! '/%(!0 $ ) '4.%. +-*1% ! '! -*1!-1%!2*" /0 ' !$ 1%*-*"2%' /4+! +-*(*/!-%) ''42! -!.. ) %..0!-!' /! /*/$!-*'!*") )*(*'! 0'! *((0)% /%*) -!+-!..*-*)/*/$!'!1!'*"#!)! !3+-!..%*) )*%.! $!.! * .!-1 /%*). -! 0.!"0' +%! ! *" %)"*-( /%*) "*- /$! / .!. ./*-! #!)!/% ( .%#) '+-* !..%)#!1 '0 /%*).*"/$! /!-% ' !''. ACKNOWLEDGMENTS ! /$ )& -*" *' %)# "*- #!)!-*0. #%"/ *" ) 1 -!%)/ .4./!( - ) ) 1!' ) - $* % "*- $!'+"0' %. 0..%*) ) -%/% ' -! %)# $%. 2*-& 2 . .0++*-/! 4 !(4*"%)' ) )*)! ! ' -! 8
$$ % , -
%.9.@B/?.:.;6.:" 6
, -
.1299 ).C62?%. 2C6; $<@A2?&522C<9BA6<;<3>B
, -
.@@92?B
, -
9
, -
<916;4 ".B9@@<;% +.D69@86
H 1<6 70299
,-
"%%D.6; 9
,-
%A<05.@A602;2E=?2@@6<;6;.%6;492299
,-
" 5<6)%)62%5.85;
H 1<6 77:/
,-
H 1<6 =;.@
, - ( 9.82 .2?;$.;A
H 1<6 ;.AB?2 , - $.@2? !I%52. <6@26;42;22E=?2@@6<;B2;02@.;10<;A?<9 %062;02 H 1<6 @062;02 , - $.7C.;!B12;..?12; .AB?2;B?AB?2B2;02@299 H 1<6 70299 , - B;@8F 2B2?AC.;!B12;..?12;'@6;42;2E=?2@@6<; <6@2A< ';12?@A.;12;2$24B9.A6<;%062;02 H 1<6 @062;02 , - +<=3 #B6;; +261:.; .52@5?6299F0922=2;12;02<3&?.;@0?6=A6<; <:6;.A2@ <6@26;2;2E=?2@@6<;" <%<:=BA6<9 1<6 7
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
J 0;5 6 D + , F775:1: -:04-B18A$->-?@;$#5.15>;?@59-@5;:;228A;>1?/1:/1 @-3310# :A9.1>?2>;9?<;@5:@1:?5@51?5;5:2;>9-@5/? J 0;5 .5;5:2;>9-@5/?.@@ +
, F718F 8;E0">5/1!)85->6-$#5.15>;$@;/4-?@5/?1=A1:/181B189;018 ;2/;A<810@>-:?/>5<@5;:-:0@>-:?8-@5;:5:<>;7->E;@1? 5;5:2;>9-@5/? 0;5 + , '-:;17";31C13%411221/@;2?@;/4-?@5/5@E;:@41 -/;<1>;:: 1B;8A@5;:->E<1>?<1/@5B1" ;$;9:-8-8<>;<1>@51? ;2@>-:?/>5<@5;:-8@591?1>51?5:?/41>5/45-/;85 -@1:1@
J 0;5 :3 +
, A4 "-A8??;:#-:0;9<->@5@5;:5:3;29;81/A81?-@/18805B5?5;:">;/ -@8 /-0$/5&$ J 0;5 <:-? + , $4;:341:1($(51 1/4-:5?9;2@>-:?/>5<@5;:-8.A>?@5:35:.-/@1>5- 188 J 0;5 6/188
;81/A8->/;99A:5/-@5;:$/419-@5/05-3>-9>1<>1?1:@?@4128A/@A-@5;:5:9# -:0 <>;@15::A9.1>?5:2-?@-:0?8;C05B505:3/188? Fig 2. :-8E@5/-8 <>;/10A>1 2;> <>;.5:3 5:@>5:?5/ -:0 1D@>5:?5/ /;9<;:1:@? ;2 /188@;/188 B->5-.585@E 5: 85B1 /188? ;2 05221>1:@ .-/@1>5-8 /188 <4-?1? 8A/@A-@5;: ;2 28A;>1?/1:@ 5:@1:?5@51? 5: 0-A34@1> /188? ;B1> @41 @591 :?1@ ?4;C? @41 0125:5@5;: ;2 5:@>5:?5/ 5:@ -:0 1D@>5:?5/ 1D@ /;9<;:1:@? 5: 0-A34@1> /188? ;B1> @591 $1=A1:/1 ;2 @5918-
$"%"# %#&'$& $!&&$ # %% ! &#$%!"#$"'& "! "!) % !' &$ %"($& & #% %$"& !) & !'& !&$( '$ ! !'&%$"' %$( % %%#"& !% & %$!&! ' &$ %$#" !&+ ' $!!#'$# $$")%$%#& ( + $%!""& !" %" #"!!&% ! %" $!&# %% Fig 3. '&'& "!" !&$ !% !*&$ !% " #"!!&% !!($ !&#$" "&$% ! ($ !& #$" "&$% * & % $ '&'& "!% " "& !" % " #"!!&% "($ & # %% !&$ !% " #"!!& " !&% ! &$& "! ! && "!$+ # %%
*&$ !% " #"!!&" !&% ! $& "!! *#"!!& # %% Fig 4. '&'& "!% " !&$ !% ! *&$ !% " #"!!&% "($ & & "($ & # %% ! !#!!& + !' ($ !& #$" "&$ % !' $" & '#%&$ ( !&$ !% " #"!!& ! $& "! ! && "!$+ # %% ) % !' $" & ")!%&$ !$& !&$ !% " #"!!&"! + !& # % ! % !'$" & '#%&$ *&$ !% " #"!!& % ! *#"!!& ! && "!$+ # %% % !'$" & ")!%&$ ( *&$ !% " #"!!& ! $& "!# % Fig. 5.( %"'$%& !%%#$ &$ ! %"($ "'% !'& "!%"($& &$ ' $ # %% ") ( ! % % ") $% ! '$%& !%% '!& "! "($ & & ! '!*#& + ( "'$%& !%%&"$ %$( ! % !'$" & '#%&$ %& ( ! %* & !$% ! ( %"'$%& !%%
11
Figure 1 Click here to download high resolution image
Figure 2 Click here to download high resolution image
Figure 3 Click here to download high resolution image
Figure 4 Click here to download high resolution image
Figure 5 Click here to download high resolution image
*Brief Biography Click here to download Brief Biography: Biography.docx
$ # % ""%$ " " $ " ) %"
" &"#$() 2002 #$"# $ ( " $ "$# &"#$() 2005*'# $" "#"" $#$ & ! $ ("#"" %!) #$$%$ ! ") 2004,2005*$"$$) 2006 #
" %$ # -"#" #! "() " %$ # # $ (." $ &"#$( " ) $ (-'$$ $("#" $("#"' " $ $ &"#$( .* %" 2007 ' " # #$ $ " "#"" * *"$ #$$%$ " % " #) * $")# 2010,2012 $ %#! #$, $ " "#" $!"$ $ # !" ## * 2013)# ' " # " ! &#$$ " - % " . # ###$ $ " ## "+% $ !" ## " $ # !"$ $*#%$ "308 $" $ ""!% $ *# $"%$ $ $ % " # !" ## * # "#" $"#$ $ &" $ " % " # !" ## $ " $#* # " $ ) !" &"#$( () !") )# 2013*# % ""%$#$% $$ !" &"#$( (' " $ '" #$" " % $,#! "( " !%$$ (#$ # (*
*Author Photo Click here to download high resolution image
*Author Photo Click here to download high resolution image
S1878-7789(16)00012-0 http://dx.doi.org/10.1016/j.nancom.2016.03.001 NANCOM 147
To appear in:
Nano Communication Networks
Received date: 18 September 2015 Revised date: 17 February 2016 Accepted date: 3 March 2016 Please cite this article as: O. Anufrieva, A. Sala, O. Yli-Harja, M. Kandhavelu, Real-time observation of bacterial gene expression noise, Nano Communication Networks (2016), http://dx.doi.org/10.1016/j.nancom.2016.03.001 This is a PDF file of an unedited manuscript that has been accepted for publication. As a service to our customers we are providing this early version of the manuscript. The manuscript will undergo copyediting, typesetting, and review of the resulting proof before it is published in its final form. Please note that during the production process errors may be discovered which could affect the content, and all legal disclaimers that apply to the journal pertain.
Real-time observation of bacterial gene expression noise +& -4%1($5 #1($- + ++( +( 1) -#$$- *2'(24-# 1 , -#' 5$+4
.+$"4+ 1 (&- +(-& !.,/43 3(.- + 823$,2(.+.&8$2$ 1"'1.4/ (&- +1."$22(-&$/ 13,$-3 ,/$1$ -(5$12(38.% $"'-.+.&8.7
,/$1$(-+ -# , (+ ,$$- *2'(24-# 1 ,* -#' 5$+4 343%(
ABSTRACT
'$, 5 1( !(+(38(-3'$2(-&+$"$++2 331(!43$23.1 -#.,/$1(.#2.%31 -2"1(/3(.-!41232 '$ "$++"8"+$/.22$22$2 &+.! +1.+$(- %%$"3(-&31 -2"1(/3(.- +.43/438$7/1$22(-&3'(2/1."$22 2 ".,,4-(" 3(.-2823$, 33'$- -.2" +$3'(231 -2"1(/3(.-.43/43.%3$- "".4-32%.13'$&$-$ $7/1$22(.--.(2$ -#3'(204 -3(%($23'$/1.,.3$1 "3(5(38.6$5$1"411$-323."' 23(",.#$+2 (&-.1$ 3'$ % "3 3' 3 &$-$ $7/1$22(.- -.(2$ (2 %%$"3$# -.3 .-+8 !8 3'$ "$++ "8"+$ -# /1.,.3$1 "3(5(38!43 +2.!83'$3(,$#41(-&6'("'-$6, 2 1$/1.#4"$#$1$6$2'.63' 3-.(2$ %1., 3'$ /1.,.3$1 (- (2 #.,(- 3$# !8 (-31(-2(" -# $731(-2(" -.(2$2 (- 2+.6 -# % 23 #(5(#(-& "$++2 1$2/$"3(5$+8 4"' #.,(- 3(.- .% 3'$ -.(2$ ".,/.-$-32 (- /' 2$2 6(3' #(%%$1$-3 &$-$1 3(.- 3(,$2 (2 "'($5$# 3'1.4&' #(23(-"3 -# ".,!(- 3.1( + (-3$1 "3(.-2 !$36$$- 3'$ 4/231$ ,#.6-231$ ,1$&4+ 3.18$+$,$-32 '$2$,$"' -(2,22$15$ 2 - # /3(5$231 3$&8%.1 (-"1$ 2(-&/./4+ 3(.-'.,.&$-$(384-#$1"' -&(-&$-5(1.-,$-32 Keywords: /1.,.3$1 &$-$ $7/1$22(.- -.(2$ ".,/.-$-32 "$++ "8"+$ !41238 , /1.#4"3(.-
Introduction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
2
)9,8<(:054 5- ;69:8,(3+5=49:8,(3 68535:,8 8,.054 3,+0(:,+ 9:5*/(9:0* .,4, ,>68,99054 04 :/, )(*:,80(2 *,229 5<,8 :/, :03, 04 +0--,8,4: *,22 .85=:/ 6/(9,9 09 45: =,22 ,9:()290/,+ #/,? (225=-5868,+0*:04./5=:/,*,22656;2(:0541,,69:/,9:()020:?)?35+;2(:04.2,<,295-:/,*,22 :5*,22 <(80()020:? (4+ )5:/ 4509, 5+;2(:054 5- :/, .,4, ,>68,99054 4509, +,9*80),+ 5<,8 :/, :03, 5- .85=:/ 5- :/, 6/(9,9 ,>6(4+9 5;8 ;4+,89:(4+04. ()5;: :/, )(*:,80(2 *,22;2(8 (*:0<0:? 4 6,896,*:0<, :/,9, 8,9;2:9 *5;2+ ), *536(8,+ =0:/ :/, 2,<,2 5- 9:5*/(9:0* .,4, ,>68,99054(::8(492(:0545<,8:03,:5+,9*80),/5=)(*:,80(),/(<,+;804.:/,*,22*?*2,;4+,8 <(805;9,>6,803,4:(2*54+0:0549 #! " # " Plasmids, Strains and media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nduction and determination of the cell phases #5 :8(*1 :/, )(*:,80(2 .,4, ,>68,99054 4509, 04 8,(2 :03, 5<,8 :/, 6/(9, =, +,<,256,+ :=5 9:8(049(9+,9*80),+()5<,58:/09 ( ! 9:8(0409.85=4;4+,856:03(2*54+0:054 -58:/,+,:,8304(:0545-:/,)(*:,80(2*,226/(9,9:09+54,)?*;2:0<(:04.*,2295<,840./:04(4 58)0:(29/(1,8 ()4,:(: B=0:/(,8(:054(:
! #/,4*,229(8,+02;:,+04-8,9/3,+0( (4+ 56:0*(2 +,490:? 09 3,(9;8,+ ;904. 96,*:856/5:53,:,8 $2:8(96,* 3,89/(3 059*0,4*,9(4+A 098,(*/,+)?+02;:054-:,8=(8+9*,229(8,.85=4(: B=0:/ (,8(:054(:
! (4+.85=:/5-:/,*,229093,(9;8,+,<,8? 304;:,9,4,8(:054:03,95- :/, )(*:,80(2 *,22 6/(9,9 (8, +,:,8304,+ ;904. 3,(9;8,3,4:9 & ' %/,4 145=04. :/,.,4,8(:054:03,5-,(*/6/(9,=,(8,()2,:55)9,8<,:/,*,22968058+;804.58033,+0(:,2? (-:,8*,22;2(8+0<090549:,49;8,9:/(:656;2(:0545-:/,*,2295)9,8<,+;4+,8:/,30*859*56,(8, 04+,,+-853(6(8:0*;2(86/(9,4+;*:054(*:0<(:0545-.,4,,>68,990549?9:,3(::/,68535:,8 8,.0545-:/,*,229(:(6(8:0*;2(86/(9,(225=9-589:;+?04.:/,.,4,,>68,990545- (4+ <(80(4:68535:,89,:,*:0545-(904.2,3! 352,*;2,09+54,)?(*:0<(:0545-8,658:,8.,4, =0:/ 4.325-(4/?+85:,:8(*?*204,(#*25:4;3),8 3),83(4?-58
304;:,904*;)(:054
3
=44 16,=+<176 7. 8:757<-: 1; ,76- *A )+<1>)<176 7. ,7?6;<:-)5 !" :-/176 ?1<0 5 # "1/5) 4,:1+0$" )6, =8;<:-)5 $!" :-/176 *A -6,7/-67=; + =44 16,=+<176 7. >):1)6< 8:757<-: 1; ,76- *A ):)*167;- .:75 =8;<:-)5 "1/5) 4,:1+0$" )6, *A 5 # .:75 <0-,7?6;<:-)56,-8-6,-6<16,=+<1767.>):1)6< 8:757<-:1;,76-,-8-6,16/76<0-)+<1>)<176+76,1<176;"8-+1.1+)44A<0-8:757<-:1;)+<1>)<-, -1<0-:.:75<0-=8;<:-)57:,7?6;<:-)5;1<-;=;16/+7::-;876,16/16,=+-:;1/=:-" 7:<15- <:)+--@8-:15-6<;+-44;):-16,=+-,?1<0)#+.7: 516.7447?16/<0-16,=+<176;+0-5-7.<0- <):/-<8:757<-:6<0-<15-;-:1-;-@8-:15-6<;+-44;):-<)3-68:17:<7<0-,1>1;176<15-)6,):- 7*;-:>-,=6,-:<0-51+:7;+78-,=:16/ 516=<-;"=884-5-6<):A 7>1-" Fluorescence microscopy of live cells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
.0-!#"30#1&#!#**1 0#%0-5, 2
95'2& #0 2'-,-$ ,"5'2& !$-02�#.-02#0 !2'4 2'-,-',"3!#01 0#13..*'#"$-02 0%#2+.0-"3!2'-,0-+2'+#1#0'#1'+ %#1 5# $'," 2&# ..# 0 ,!# -$ $'012 $*3-0#1!#,2 1.-2 ', $'$27 0 ,"-+ !#**1 &#, 5# #620 !2 2&# $*3-0#1!#,!# ',2#,1'27 -$ # !& + 1.-2 &'1 ',$-0+ 2'-, '1 31#" 2- ! *!3* 2# +# , + ',2#,1'273..*#+#,2 07-4'## ,+',2#,1'27'1"#$',#" 12&#+# ,',2#,1'274 *3# -$ 1',%*#++-*#!3*# )',%',2- !!-3,2',$-0+ 2'-,$0-+2&#(3+."#2#!2'-,+#2&-" !#** !)%0-3,"!-00#!2#" 1.-2 ',2#,1'2'#1 ," 2&# +# , ',2#,1'27 -$ 1',%*# + +-*#!3*# 5# 0#$', **7 *#2-! *!3* 2#2&#,3+ #0-$++-*#!3*#1.0-"3!#"',# !&20 ,1!0'.2'-, * #4#,2 , 13!& 5 7 2 *# 12 -,# &3,"0#" !#**1 0# , *78#" ', # !& #6.#0'+#,2 * !-,"'2'-, *# ," Evaluation of bursty promoter behavior 2'1),-5,2& 2!#**1.0-"3!#+', 301215&'!& 0#.#0'-"1-$&'%&.0-+-2#0 !2'4'27 # 2&31 0# ',2#0#12#" 2- - 1#04#" 5� !#**1 !-,2 ',',% ," 4 0' ,2 .0-+-2#01 #6&' '2 30127 #& 4'-0-02&'1.30.-1#5#31#',$-0+ 2'-,-$2&#.0-"3!2'-,',2#04 *1 #25##, 2&# 30121! *!3* 2#"$0-+2&#',2#,1'27(3+.1,"##"- 1#04 2'-,-$ 1#/3#,!#-$,-,*',# 0 +.0-"3!2'-,#4#,21',2',%*#!#**1',"'! 2#12& 2 ," 4 0' ,2.0-+-2#01.-11#1 30127 #& 4'-0 2 !!-3,21 $-0 .0#1#,!# -$ 2&# %#,# #6.0#11'-, ,-'1# ', 2# #6.#0'+#,21 13 **7 2 !#**.-.3* 2'-,%#,##6.0#11'-,,-'1#'1#4 *3 2#" 72&# 3012',#11$ !2-0-0 ,- $ !2-0 - 5# !-,1'"#0 2& 2 2&# %#,# #6.0#11'-,,-'1#', !#**.-.3* 2'-,'1"#$',#" 1 !#**2-!#**4 0' '*'27 ,"'1#12'+ 2#" 7
-"#+-,120 2#2&#.0-"3!2'-,-$,#5+1'," 3%&2#0!#**1-4#02'+#5#!0# 2# +-4'# !-,1'12',%-$2'+#* .1#'+ %#12 )#,#4#07+',32#"30',% +',32#13..*#+#,2 07-4'# &#+-4'#1&-5125-!#**15&'!&.0-"3!#++-*#!3*#13,"#0 !2'4# .0-+-2#0-4#0 2'+#&#'+ %# ,"+-4'#3..*#+#,2 07-4'#1&-525-!#**"'4'1'-,1',#6.-,#,2' * .& 1#5�#2 0%#2++-*#!3*#1 0#.0-"3!#"3,"#0 !2'4# .0-+-2#0 Noise calculation ##12'+ 2#',20',1'! ,"#620',1'!!-+.-,#,21-$2&#,-'1# 220 ,1!0'.2'-, 731',%',$-0+ 2'-, -32 + $*3!23 2'-, ', " 3%&2#0 !#**1 - 2 ',#" $0-+ 2 %%',% +#2&-" -0 1.*'22',% -$ !#**2-!#** 4 0' '*'27 ',2- ',20',1'! ," #620',1'! !-+.-,#,21 *#2 ," "#,-2#2&#*#4#*1-$+1,3+ #0.#025-" 3%&2#0!#**1 2 %'4#2'+#
',2
#62
2-2
5
:). +89/2'9/43 4, -+3+ +=57+88/43 34/8+ <'8 ,/7891> +89'(1/8.+* (> 9.+ 14 5+)/,/)'11> <+ )438/*+7 9.'9 2 574*:)9/43 ,742 9<4 *':-.9+7 )+118 4(8+7;+* 4;+7 9.+ 9/2+ -/;+8 +88+39/'1 /3,472'9/43 ,47 )'1):1'9/3- /397/38/) '3* +=97/38/) 34/8+ )42543+398 84 9.'9(49.4,9.+22'0+'3479.4-43'1)4397/(:9/43949.+)+1194)+11;'7/'(/1/9>47949'134/8+
:).+;'1:'9/434,9.+-+3++=57+88/4334/8+'997'38)7/59/43<'8,/7891>+89'(1/8.+*(>9.+ '1' +9 '1 % & <.4 *+8)7/(+* 9.+ 1+;+18 4, 9.+ )+1194)+11 ;'7/'(/1/9> '3* /397/38/)+=97/38/) )42543+398 /3 9.+ )+118 4, =543+39/'1 5.'8+ 438+6:+391> <+ +=9+3* 9.+ 57+;/4:8 4(8+7;'9/438 (> *+8)7/(/3- *>3'2/)'1 ).'3-+8 4, -+3+ +=57+88/43 348/+ 4;+7 9.+ 9/2+ /3 */,,+7+39 (')9+7/'1 )+11 5.'8+8 :3*+7 ' 3:2(+7 4, +=5+7/2+39'1 )43*/9/438 !.+ '1-47/9.2 ,47 +89/2'9/43 4, -+3+ +=57+88/43 34/8+ /8 /251+2+39+* /3 '91'( ' 4124-474;@ 2/734; 9+89/8:8+*94*+9+72/3+89'9/89/)'11>8/-3/,/)'397+1'9/438./58 "! Presence of the noise in cells of different phases !.+*+9+)9/434,2 574*:)9/435+78/3-1+)+11.'8549+39/'194+3.'3)+4:7:3*+789'3*/3- 4,9.+ 894).'89/) -+3++=57+88/43'9 97'38)7/59/43 '3* (/4).+2/)'1 2+).'3/828 /3;41;+* :7 9441,47*+9+)9/3-2 83:2(+75+78/3-1+)+11/8 2+9.4*9/2+8+7/+8+=5+7/2+39 /-:7+ !.+ /-:7+ /11:897'9+8 )+11:1'7 */;/8/43 '3* )438+):9/;+ 2 574*:)9/43 +;+398,7429.+574249+7/39.+)+1181:)9:'9/434,9.+2 574*:)9/434;+79.+ 9/2+'))4:398,4757+8+3)+4,)+1194)+11;'7/'(/1/9>/3'545:1'9/43+1194)+11;'7/'(/1/9>/8 +89/2'9+* (> 9.+ '34 ,')947 47 (:789/3+88 ,')947 9.'9 /8 */;/*+* /394 9<4 34/8+ )42543+398 8:). '8 +=97/38/) '3* /397/38/) /-:7+ /89/3-:/8./3- (+9<++3 9<4 34/8+ )42543+398 /8 ('8+* 43 9.+ 2 8 ,1:)9:'9/43 5+7 8/3-1+ )+11 4;+7 9.+ 9/2+ '3* '243- 9.+ )+118 /3 ' 545:1'9/43 5+)/,/)'11> /397/38/) )42543+39 /8 9.+ ,1:)9:'9/43 4, 574*:)9/43 '3* *+-7'*'9/43 +;+398 4, 2 8 /3 8/3-1+ *':-.9+7 )+118 4;+7 9.+ 9/2+ <./1+ +=97/38/) )42543+39 /8 ' */,,+7+3)+ 4, 2 ,1:)9:'9/438 (+9<++3 9.+ *':-.9+7 )+118 4;+7 9.+ 9/2+ /-:7+ (8+7;'9/434,9.+*>3'2/)'1241+):1+574*:)9/4387+;+'1857+8+3)+4,(49.34/8+)42543+398 4;+7 (')9+7/'1 )+11 5.'8+8 /-:7+ 438+6:+391> *>3'2/)'1 ,1:)9:'9/438 4, /397/38/) '3* +=97/38/)34/8+)42543+398*+5+3*:543)+11)>)1+ Quantification of the noise components in cells of different phases #+ 97')0 9.+ *>3'2/)'1 ).'3-+8 4, /397/38/) '3* +=97/38/) 34/8+ 1+;+18 4;+7 9.+ 9/2+ 4;+7 (')9+7/'1 )+11 5.'8+8 +7+ <+ )438/*+7 9.'9 '- ))+1+7'9/43 =543+39/'1 +9'7*'9/43 '3* 9'9/43'7>'7+9.+5.'8+8/3)1:*+*/394(')9+7/'1)+11)>)1+% &3'3'1>8/87+;+'189.'9 (49.34/8+)42543+39847/-/3'9+*,742/-:7+ '3*;'7/'39/-:7+ 574249+78 ,1:)9:'9+/3'8/2/1'72'33+74;+79.+9/2+/3*/,,+7+39(')9+7/'1)+115.'8+8/-:7+ 92+'38 9.'9(+.';/474,;'7/'39574249+7*+8)7/(+8(+.';/474,574249+7'3*/8'551/)'(1+,47 9.+-+3+7'1/?'9/434,9.+7+8:198'8+*439.+5.'8+-+3+7'9/439/2+8<+*/;/*+(')9+7/'1)+11 5.'8+8 /394 9<4 )'9+-47/+8 8:). '8 814< '- +9'7*'9/43 '3* 9'9/43'7> 5.'8+8 '3* ,'89 ))+1+7'9/43'3*=543+39/'15.'8+8*/;/*/3-)+118% & (8+7;/3-).'3-+84,9.+34/8+ 1+;+18/3814<'3*,'89*/;/*/3-)+118'114<8,47*+8)7/(/3-9.+741+4,)+11:1'7*/;/8/43 49.+ 5;'1:+8 *+7/;+* ,742 4124-474;@ 2/734; 9+89 /3*/)'9+8 9.'9 /397/38/) 34/8+ *42/3'9+8 /3 814< */;/*/3- )+118 '3* +=97/38/) 34/8+ 7:1+8 ,'89 */;/*/3- )+118 !'(1+ $+9 +=97/38/) )42543+39/3814<'3*/397/38/))42543+39/3,'89*/;/*/3-)+118'7+3493+-1+)9+*'8(49.4, 9.+2 51'> ' 741+ /3 9.+ 1+;+18 4, )+1194)+11 ;'7/'(/1/9> %
& :(8+6:+391> */,,+7+39 6
%#+#/ 1',+ 1'*#0 ,$ !1#/' ) !#)) -& 0#0 -) 6 /,)# '+ 1&# $)2!12 1',+0 ,$ ,1& +,'0# !,*-,+#+10 11� *#1'*#1'*#- / *#1#/'+$)2#+!#$)2!12 1',+,$)#3#)0,$ ,1&+,'0# !,*-,+#+10,1'*#0! )#'0 +'*-,/1 +1- / *#1#/4&'!&& 01, #1 (#+'+1, !!,2+14&#+ !1'3'16 ,$ -/,*,1#/ '0 "#$'+#" + ""'1',+ 1, 1&# 1'*# - / *#1#/ '+"#-#+"#+1 2-01/# * +" ",4+01/# * -/,*,1#/ !1'3 1',+0 -) 6 "'01'+!1 /,)#0 '+ 1&# )#3#)0 ,$ ,1& +,'0# !,*-,+#+10 #1 +#'1&#/ ,$ 1&#* /#0#* )#0 1&# !& +%# ,$ ,1& +,'0# !,*-,+#+10 '+ $2))6 '+"2!#" !#))0 ,+0#.2#+1)6 '+1#/-) 6 #14##+ ",*'+ +1 +,'0# !,*-,+#+10 1 "'$$#/#+1 !1#/' )!#))-& 0#0* 6 ##5-) '+#" 61&#!,* '+ 1,/' )#$$#!1,$2-01/# * +"",4+01/# * %#+# !1'3 1',+!,+"'1',+0 Modulation of the noise components by independent gene activations # !1'3 1#'+"#-#+"#+1)63 /' +1-/,*,1#/$/,*2-01/# * +"",4+01/# *1,012"6&,4 02!&%#+# !1'3 1',+!,+"'1',+0 $$#!11&#%#+##5-/#00',++,'0#,$1&#$2))6'+"2!#"!#))0# $'+" 1& 1 2-01/# * '+"2!1',+ ,$ ) ! 3 /' +1 -/,*,1#/ /#02)10 '+ ",*'+ +1 '+1/'+0'! +,'0# '+
!!#)#/ 1',+ +" 1 1',+ /6 -& 0#0 '%2/# +" ",*'+ +1 #51/'+0'! +,'0# '+ % 5-,+#+1' ) +" #1 /" 1',+ -& 0#0 '%2/# �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evels of cell-to-cell variability in cells of different phases /#0#+!# ,$ ,1& '+1/'+0'! +" #51/'+0'! +,'0# !,*-,+#+10 !!,2+10 $,/ 1&# -,00' ')'16 1, .2 +1'$6 !#))1,!#)) 3 /' ')'16 ,/ 1,1 ) +,'0# 02 ))6 1 -,-2) 1',+ )#3#) !#))1,!#)) 3 /' ')'16'0#01'* 1#" 61&# +,$ !1,/,/ 2/01'+#00$ !1,/ &#+! )!2) 1'+% 2/01'+#00 $ !1,/ 4# , 0#/3# 1& 1 '1 "#!/# 0#0 $/,* % 1, #1 /" 1',+ -& 0#0 +" '+!/# 0#0 $/,*#1 /" 1',+1,1 1',+ /6-& 0#'+1&#$2))6'+"2!#"!#))0'%2/# 1'))201/ 1#01&#/,)# ,$"'01'+!1!#))-& 0#0,+1,1&#)#3#)0,$!#))1,!#))3 /' ')'16 + % +" #1 /" 1',+ -& 0# !#))0 2/01'+#00 $ !1,/ '0 2+#5-#!1#")6 &'%& 4&#+ 1 /# '+"2!#"$/,*1-01/# *'%2/#
1!,2)" #"2#1,0),4"'3'0',+/ 1# +"1&200),4 - /1'1',+'+% ,$ * *,)#!2)#0 #14##+ 1&# " 2%&1#/ !#))0 , 2-01/# * '+"2!1',+ $$#!10 01,!& 01'!'16,$%#+##5-/#00',+'+-& 0#04'1&0),4"'3'"'+%!#))01- /1)6 %/##04'1&/#!#+1 $'+"'+%0 ,$ ",*'+ +1 /,)# ,$ 2-01/# * '+"2!1',+ '+ 1&# # /)'#/ !#))2) / -& 0#0 #% % ,/
!!#)#/ 1',+ + $ 01 "'3'"'+% !#))0 2/01'+#00 $ !1,/ "#!/# 0#0 $/,* !!#)#/ 1',+ 1, 5-,+#+1' )-& 0#'+!#))0'+"2!#"$/,*1-01/# * +"",4+01/# *'%2/# 1 !!,2+10 $,/1&#/,)#,$$ 01!#))2) /"'3'0',+'+!,+1/' 21',+,$ ,1&+,'0#!,*-,+#+10,$1&#!#))1,!#)) 3 /' ')'16&#/#02)100&,41& 10),4 +"$ 01"'3'0',+/ 1#0"#1#/*'+#-/,*,1#/ !1'3'16 +" 1&20 !#))1,!#)) 3 /' ')'16 0 #5-#!1#" *# 02/'+% !#))1,!#)) 3 /' ')'16 '+ '+"#-#+"#+1)6 '+"2!#" !#))0 ",#0 +,1 /#3# ) 1&#'/ !,//#) 1',+0 4'1& 1&# !#))1,!#)) 3 /' ')'16 ,$ 1&# $2))6 7
%) 0 ! !''. *).!,0!)/'4*)'4/$!%- *( %) /*-% '!""! /+-* 0 !.* .!-1! +-*+ # /%*)*" /$!#!)!!3+-!..%*))*%.!/$-*0#$*0//$! !''+$ .!.
/* $ ./% %/4*" #!)!!3+-!..%*)%."0) (!)/ '"! /0-!/$ / !. -% !. !$ 1%*-*".%)#'! !'' %) $*(*#!)*0. +*+0' /%*) $! (* !-) -!.! - $ /$*0#$ ' &. /$! &)*2'! #! *0/ /$! "'0 /0 /%*) *" ./* $ ./% #!)! !3+-!..%*) %) /!-% ' !'' +$ .!. . 2!'' %/ %. '%(%/! /* !. -% %)#$*2./* $ ./% #!)!!3+-!..%*) $ )#!.*1!-/$!/%(! / + -/% 0' - !''0' -+$ .! $!.! "! /0-!. $*2!1!- -! !-/ %)'4 %(+*-/ )/ "*- /$! !/ %'! %)1!./%# /%*) *" #!)! !3+-!..%*))*%.! %/$ /$! %( *" 0) !-./ ) %)# $*2 /%(! " /*- ""! /. #!)! !3+-!..%*) )*%.! %) %""!-!)/ /!-% ' !''+$ .!.2!./0 %! +-*(*/!- /%1%/4 //- ). -%+/%*)%)/$! !''.! * .!-1! /$ / "0''4 %) 0 ! +-*(*/!- #!)!- /!. "'0 /0 /%)# *1!- /$! +$ .!. !''/* !'' 1 -% %'%/4/%. !/!-(%)! 4%)/-%).% *(+*)!)/%)/$!.'*2 %1% %)# !''. ) 4!3/-%).% *(+*)!)/ %) /$! " ./ %1% %)# !''. . 2!'' . %/ +*..!..!. %./%) / '!1!'. / )4 #%1!) /%(! +*%)/ *" /$! !3+!-%(!)/ $!.! * .!-1 /%*). !).0-! /$ / !'' 4 '! ) /%(! " /*- -! &!4 !/!-(%) )/. 2$!-! ) )*.%5! -!+-!..*- 1 -%!. *1!- /$! +$ .! ) -!#0' /! /$! #!)! !3+-!..%*))*%.! $*0#$ /$!.! + - (!/!-. -! %(+*-/ )/ "*- /$! #!)! !3+-!..%*) )*%.! +-*(*/!- %) 0 /%*) *) %/%*). '.* ""! / /$! '!1!'. *" ./* $ ./% %/4 +! %"% ''4 2$!) !''. -! %) !+!) !)/'4 %) 0 ! "-*(/$!0+./-! (*- *2)./-! ( !''.$ 1! %./%) /'!1!'. ) "'0 /0 /%*)(* !.*" /$! #!)! !3+-!..%*) )*%.! !%/$!- *" /$!( -!.!( '! *(+'!/!'4 /$! "'0 /0 /%*). *" #!)! !3+-!..%*))*%.!0) !- *)/-*'*""0''4%) 0 ! +-*(*/!-$%.(! )./$ //$! *( %) /*-% ' !""! / *" 0+./-! ( ) *2)./-! ( #!)! /%1 /%*). %) /$! "0''4 %) 0 ! !''. %. " - (*-! *(+'!3 /$ ) !""! /. *" %) !+!) !)/ %) 0 /%*). /* */$ )*%.! *(+*)!)/. ! "%) ''4 #!)!- '%5!* .!-1! ./* $ ./% #!)!!3+-!..%*)*" +-*(*/!- 40.%)#%/..4)/$!/% 1 -% )/ $!-!"*-!2! *)"%-(/$ /* .!-1! !$ 1%*-*"/$! +-*(*/!- !. -% !./$!2%' /4+! 0- * .!-1 /%*). +*..!.. )0( !- *" )*1!'/%!. %-./'4 2! +-*+*.! #!)!- ' ++-* $ "*- !1 '0 /%*) *" /$! #!)! !3+-!..%*) )*%.! /$ / *( %)!. !3+!-%(!)/ ' +-* ! 0-! (!/$* ) %( #! .%#) ' +-* !..%)# ) '4.%. $*0#$ /$%. (!/$* $ . !!) !. -% ! 4 ' !/ ' *0- / .!/. !3/!) +-!1%*0. * .!-1 /%*) 4 / &%)# %)/* *).% !- /%*) /%(! " /*- ) !''0' -+$ .!.! *) '42!+!-"*-( ) '4.%. %) -! '/%(!0 $ ) '4.%. +-*1% ! '! -*1!-1%!2*" /0 ' !$ 1%*-*"2%' /4+! +-*(*/!-%) ''42! -!.. ) %..0!-!' /! /*/$!-*'!*") )*(*'! 0'! *((0)% /%*) -!+-!..*-*)/*/$!'!1!'*"#!)! !3+-!..%*) )*%.! $!.! * .!-1 /%*). -! 0.!"0' +%! ! *" %)"*-( /%*) "*- /$! / .!. ./*-! #!)!/% ( .%#) '+-* !..%)#!1 '0 /%*).*"/$! /!-% ' !''. ACKNOWLEDGMENTS ! /$ )& -*" *' %)# "*- #!)!-*0. #%"/ *" ) 1 -!%)/ .4./!( - ) ) 1!' ) - $* % "*- $!'+"0' %. 0..%*) ) -%/% ' -! %)# $%. 2*-& 2 . .0++*-/! 4 !(4*"%)' ) )*)! ! ' -! 8
$$ % , -
%.9.@B/?.:.;6.:" 6
, -
.1299 ).C62?%. 2C6; $<@A2?&522C<9BA6<;<3>B
, -
.@@92?
, -
9
, -
<916;4 ".B9@@<;% +.D69@86
H 1<6 70299
,-
"%%D.6; 9
,-
%A<05.@A602;2E=?2@@6<;6;.%6;492299
,-
" 5<6)%)62%5.85;
H 1<6 77:/
,-
H 1<6 =;.@
, - ( 9.82 .2?;$.;A
H 1<6 ;.AB?2 , - $.@2? !I%52. <6@26;42;22E=?2@@6<;B2;02@.;10<;A?<9 %062;02 H 1<6 @062;02 , - $.7C.;!B12;..?12; .AB?2;B?AB?2B2;02@299 H 1<6 70299 , - B;@8F 2B2?AC.;!B12;..?12;'@6;42;2E=?2@@6<; <6@2A< ';12?@A.;12;2$24B9.A6<;%062;02 H 1<6 @062;02 , - +<=3 #B6;; +261:.; .52@5?6299F0922=2;12;02<3&?.;@0?6=A6<; <:6;.A2@ <6@26;2;2E=?2@@6<;" <%<:=BA6<9 1<6 7
+ , %4-@@-5B-:!A01:-->01::@>5:?5/:;5?15:31:1>13A8-@;>E:1@C;>7?">;/ -@8 /-0$/5&$ J 0;5 <:-? + , %41>;C@4;2-/@1>5-8A8@A>1? + , $-8- $4;-5.!:A2>51B- A@4->-?A!)854->6- -:04-B18A!>535:? ;2%>-:?/>5<@5;:-8%>-:?5@5;: -8-:/1.1@C11:&1-9-:0;C:?@>1-91:1 #13A8-@;>E$1=A1:/1? 5; J0;5 95; 05@;> + , $4;C04A>E -:04-B18A!)85->6-$#5.15>;188?1391:@-@5;:.E9A8@5 >1?;8A@5;:-:-8E?5?-:09-D59A98571854;;01?@59-@5;: 5;5:2;>9-@5/? $A<<8 $0;5 $ $ + , $4;C04A>E -:04-B18A!)85->6-$#5.15>;:5:@1>-/@5:39A8@5<81 9;018258@1>.-?10-A@;2;/A??@>-@13E2;>/;:2;/-8@5918-;?/;
J 0;5 6 D + , F775:1: -:04-B18A$->-?@;$#5.15>;?@59-@5;:;228A;>1?/1:/1 @-3310# :A9.1>?2>;9?<;@5:@1:?5@51?5;5:2;>9-@5/? J 0;5 .5;5:2;>9-@5/?.@@ +
, F718F 8;E0">5/1!)85->6-$#5.15>;$@;/4-?@5/?1=A1:/181B189;018 ;2/;A<810@>-:?/>5<@5;:-:0@>-:?8-@5;:5:<>;7->E;@1? 5;5:2;>9-@5/? 0;5 + , '-:;17";31C13%411221/@;2?@;/4-?@5/5@E;:@41 -/;<1>;:: 1B;8A@5;:->E<1>?<1/@5B1" ;$;9
J 0;5 :3 +
, A4 "-A8??;:#-:0;9<->@5@5;:5:3;29;81/A81?-@/18805B5?5;:">;/ -@8 /-0$/5&$ J 0;5 <:-? + , $4;:341:1($(51 1/4-:5?9;2@>-:?/>5<@5;:-8.A>?@5:35:.-/@1>5- 188 J 0;5 6/188
;81/A8->/;99A:5/-@5;:$/419-@5/05-3>-9>1<>1?1:@?@4128A/@A-@5;:5:9# -:0 <>;@15::A9.1>?5:2-?@-:0?8;C05B505:3/188? Fig 2. :-8E@5/-8 <>;/10A>1 2;> <>;.5:3 5:@>5:?5/ -:0 1D@>5:?5/ /;9<;:1:@? ;2 /188@;/188 B->5-.585@E 5: 85B1 /188? ;2 05221>1:@ .-/@1>5-8 /188 <4-?1? 8A/@A-@5;: ;2 28A;>1?/1:@ 5:@1:?5@51? 5: 0-A34@1> /188? ;B1> @41 @591 :?1@ ?4;C? @41 0125:5@5;: ;2 5:@>5:?5/ 5:@ -:0 1D@>5:?5/ 1D@ /;9<;:1:@? 5: 0-A34@1> /188? ;B1> @591 $1=A1:/1 ;2 @5918-
$"%"# %#&'$& $!&&$ # %% ! &#$%!"#$"'& "! "!) % !' &$ %"($& & #% %$"& !) & !'& !&$( '$ ! !'&%$"' %$( % %%#"& !% & %$!&! ' &$ %$#" !&+ ' $!!#'$# $$")%$%#& ( + $%!""& !" %" #"!!&% ! %" $!&# %% Fig 3. '&'& "!" !&$ !% !*&$ !% " #"!!&% !!($ !&#$" "&$% ! ($ !& #$" "&$% * & % $ '&'& "!% " "& !" % " #"!!&% "($ & # %% !&$ !% " #"!!& " !&% ! &$& "! ! && "!$+ # %%
*&$ !% " #"!!&" !&% ! $& "!! *#"!!& # %% Fig 4. '&'& "!% " !&$ !% ! *&$ !% " #"!!&% "($ & & "($ & # %% ! !#!!& + !' ($ !& #$" "&$ % !' $" & '#%&$ ( !&$ !% " #"!!& ! $& "! ! && "!$+ # %% ) % !' $" & ")!%&$ !$& !&$ !% " #"!!&"! + !& # % ! % !'$" & '#%&$ *&$ !% " #"!!& % ! *#"!!& ! && "!$+ # %% % !'$" & ")!%&$ ( *&$ !% " #"!!& ! $& "!# % Fig. 5.( %"'$%& !%%#$ &$ ! %"($ "'% !'& "!%"($& &$ ' $ # %% ") ( ! % % ") $% ! '$%& !%% '!& "! "($ & & ! '!*#& + ( "'$%& !%%&"$ %$( ! % !'$" & '#%&$ %& ( ! %* & !$% ! ( %"'$%& !%%
11
Figure 1 Click here to download high resolution image
Figure 2 Click here to download high resolution image
Figure 3 Click here to download high resolution image
Figure 4 Click here to download high resolution image
Figure 5 Click here to download high resolution image
*Brief Biography Click here to download Brief Biography: Biography.docx
$ # % ""%$ " " $ " ) %"
" &"#$() 2002 #$"# $ ( " $ "$# &"#$() 2005*'# $" "#"" $#$ & ! $ ("#"" %!) #$$%$ ! ") 2004,2005*$"$$) 2006 #
" %$ # -"#" #! "() " %$ # # $ (." $ &"#$( " ) $ (-'$$ $("#" $("#"' " $ $ &"#$( .* %" 2007 ' " # #$ $ " "#"" * *"$ #$$%$ " % " #) * $")# 2010,2012 $ %#! #$, $ " "#" $!"$ $ # !" ## * 2013)# ' " # " ! &#$$ " - % " . # ###$ $ " ## "+% $ !" ## " $ # !"$ $*#%$ "308 $" $ ""!% $ *# $"%$ $ $ % " # !" ## * # "#" $"#$ $ &" $ " % " # !" ## $ " $#* # " $ ) !" &"#$( () !") )# 2013*# % ""%$#$% $$ !" &"#$( (' " $ '" #$" " % $,#! "( " !%$$ (#$ # (*
*Author Photo Click here to download high resolution image
*Author Photo Click here to download high resolution image