Accepted Manuscript The effect of banking supervision on central bank preferences: Evidence from panel data Georgios Chortareas, Vassileios Logothetis, Georgios Magkonis, Kalliopi-Maria Zekente PII: DOI: Reference:
S0165-1765(15)00538-8 http://dx.doi.org/10.1016/j.econlet.2015.12.021 ECOLET 7032
To appear in:
Economics Letters
Received date: 20 July 2015 Revised date: 17 November 2015 Accepted date: 27 December 2015 Please cite this article as: Chortareas, G., Logothetis, V., Magkonis, G., Zekente, K.-M., The effect of banking supervision on central bank preferences: Evidence from panel data. Economics Letters (2016), http://dx.doi.org/10.1016/j.econlet.2015.12.021 This is a PDF file of an unedited manuscript that has been accepted for publication. As a service to our customers we are providing this early version of the manuscript. The manuscript will undergo copyediting, typesetting, and review of the resulting proof before it is published in its final form. Please note that during the production process errors may be discovered which could affect the content, and all legal disclaimers that apply to the journal pertain.
?%? ?? &!#'$ ? ?%#?? ##$8?? '?# ? ?%?
# $? #%#$77?$$ $? %%$7? # $? $?=7? !>#? %? !#%%? ?%7? ;$? ? 7? ?
?
?
!#%%? ? $7?'#$%*? ?%$7?#?
?
? ?%7?'#$%*? ?# #7? ?
? )? %? %$? ? ? $&!#'$ #*? #%%? ? %#? ? !##$7? "&%? %# &? ? #%*? !# ! $? $? ? %#? ? $#'%$6? $? ? *? !? %? $!% ? (? &%? %%? %#? $? $#'? %? %#*? ! *? ? ? $&!#'$ ? &% $? #? $$? % ? $#'%'?%?% $?(%? *??!#?$%%*?%6? %#*? *7? ? &!#'$ 7 % ? $#'%$7? > %? ?03 # $? $7?
? ?%7?? 7?4?/ 7?# #7?
7?%8?5//9+:,-2/-.13+,7?8?6 $<# #66&
5 %5 $5 5 5 5 5 5 5 5 5 5 #5 5 %5 5 !5 5 # 5 5 5 %5 "51%55552.5 !5555 5 5 5 !5 5 5 #%5 ! 5 5 !"%5 ! 5 5 5 !5 5/5#551)'(+25! 5 5 5 5 55 55"5!55 5 55 555! 55!5 5! 5 .5 5 5 5 ! 5 $ 5 5 5 %5 %5 5 5 !"/5 5 5 5 55 5 5%555 5 5 "5# 55%5 ! 51 55 /5(--+2.55 %/5 55 51)'(*25#5#55$5 5 5 4 %5 .5 5 5 5 5 ! 5 5 5 5 ! 5 #5 5 5 5 5 ! 5 5 %5 %/5 %5 !5 5 /5 !5 5 5 35 5 5 5 !"%5 5 1 5 .5 (---2.5 ! 5 5 $ 5 5 5 5 $ %5 5 %5 5 5 %5 #/5 ../5 %5 $ 5 %5 %35 &5 5 5 55%51/5)'(*2.55 5 5 5 "5 5 5 5 5 5 !"5 5 %5 %5 "55 55!55%5! /5 5 5 5 5 5555! 5#5 5! 555 5 5 55 15 5 5 5 /5 (---05 " 5 5 /5 )'',2.5 %5 ! /5 #"/5 5 5 5 5 5 1../5 5 ! !5 5 5 %2.5 !/5 "! 5 "5 ! 5 5 %5 !5 5 %5 ! 5 1 /5 5 !5 25 5 5 5 5 #%5 5 5 #5 ! 55 "55/5!5 5%5! 55 5
# :":":" ::":' !:2 #!:: )(0:,**.3/: :"!: :%:&"':! :": ":"::! ":":#"!::: !# $!::" ':'::" :!8: !/::: : :
: &': ': !: %: #!: : !# : : ! $"!: !: ':
$#: : #"": 2,*+-30: %: !: : ": "9#"#": : $ "': " 90:!:"# :'::6' :# $7::!:#!" "::# :+/::":: ":# $: !"!:" :8!: !:%": !":":":%":"':: : ": $ "': 2 3: $ : #"#": : $ "': 2 3/: #!0: ": : : ": ' :# $: !!:":: :! $"$:" ::!: :":": /::":: :!# ::" :: !:$#::#"": 2,*+-3:#":":! $"!:!:"::$#:::"::":' :# $0: %:!:" " ':& !!:!1::
:
:
:::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::: :
:::::::::::::2+3:
% : : : : : ": $ !: : #"#": : :"0: !"$'/:!: 2+3::#":"::#"#"::$""!:':!"":: 2+0+3: : ::#" '::# :"!":%:":: !:!# ::! $"!: :":4*0+5: 0:%":":$#!:!:":+:":: :":! $"$: " :/+:: : : : : : 1
":#"!: :$:#: #!"/
" " " " "
" !" " !"
(
(
(
%( ( ( (&!$(#! '(
((((( " " " " " (
((( ( ( ( (
(% ( (
(
(((((
(
&'(
is our the t measuree of conservvatism, denotes
as deefined abovee, is a where vector of o k control variables, are unobbserved cou untry-speciffic effects, are time--specific effects and
is the error term. ( ( ( ( $(
( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( (
( ( ( ( #( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( &$( $( ""$( '( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( (
( (
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
!#9> '#)#9> *()'!9> $)(,#9> > #9> !9> $!$"9> '$)9> /> %*!9>> *#'.9> !#9> #9> #$#(9> ('!9> %#9> $'#9>$'9>> !.(9> *')*(9> -$9> ,> !#9> '9> $',.9> '*9> !%%#(9> $!#9> $"#9> #%$'9> $*)> '9> ,#9> !#9>*#(9>*' .9>9>8
5 !"5 5 #5 5 #5 %!5 5 $#!(5 "5 #"5 !!"5#5 5"##!5"55""##5!5 $#51,2/55!""5#"05 &5$"5#5 #&4"#5 ("#5
5"##!5!5(55#5 1$5 5 05+..-2/5!5!$"#""5$!""05&5"5!!#5#5'4#"5"##!/55
5+5!"#"5#5!"$#"5!5"##5!#5%!""55 $#51,2/5 !5 #5 !#(5 5 "##"05 5 5 !"5 "5 "#%5 5 "##"#(5 "#05"$"#5##5#!5"57!#5##5$""5(55#!(5 (5#5#55!5#5%!"5#5#"5&5!5"5""5#55 "$!%"/5 "5 !"$#"5 !5
$#5 !$"#5 &5 &5 "!5 !#5
"#"5 ##5 $"5 5 !#5 #!5 %!"/5 #(05 $!5 !"$#"5 "&5##5#5#!#!"5#5#5%55"#!!5!!5!5#5"##(/5 "5"$"#"5##5#!(5(5!&!"5(55$"5#5!!"/55 5 $!#!5 #"#5 #5 !$"#""5 5 $!5 !"$#"5 &5 "!5 5 $!5 5 #5#!"/5&5%55 !51,**-25&55#5")55#5 5 "#!5 1"#5 !#5 "5 !#5 5 205 5 #"5 #!#5  55"5"!5#5#!#55 5#"5#!#5/5 %5#$#5#5
5!"$#"5"$55$#$"(5!5"5#(55#5"#"(55 #5 ""!(5 !!#"05 #5 %5 "#5 "&"5 ##5 "!#5 #!(5 (5 55"$!%"5"5"#%(5""#5#!53"5"!%#"/55
&, , , ,( ), ,, , , , , , &, ,, ,!%, ,, ,,&, ,, ,, , , , ,, ,', , , , , , , , , , , , , , , ,, , ,, , %, , , , , , , , , , , , , ,
, , , , , , , ( , "+ )%, &, , , , ,
&, , , , , , , , , , %, , ,, ,
, , ,,, , + , , , , , ,,, + , %,,, ,,, # ,, $,
,
, , ,, , , , ,, ,, , , , , , , , , , ,
%, , , , , , , , , , , , , ,
, , *, %,, , ,, , , , ,,,, , , , , + , %,&,,, , , , , , &, , , , , , , , , , , , , , , %, &, , , , !
, ,,,, , , ,,%,,
) ',C #C "&''('#" C 'C '#C %&&C &(C &&(&C $#&C C "9C C ('(%C %&%C &'$C &C '#C ) #$C "C " ,-C !#%C ' C "&C #"C 'C %&C#C"'% C"&?C#(&:C"C'%#%C!#%C)%'#"C"C'C'9 C
"%:C 9:C 1/049C "C *,&C %#!C 'C ='""C %#C # ,9C %#%&&C #%C #"(&#"<>9C ''$;@@***9)#+(9#%@%' @%'""A!%#A$# ,A'"A '*,&C (" :C 9:C #":C 9:C 08879C "' C #"'#"&C "C #!"'C &'%'#"&C "C ,"!C" C'C # &9C #(%" C#C#"#!'%&C76:C004B0329C C #%#:C9:C1/039C #"'%,C$# ,C"C"" C&' ',;C'C# C"C%)"'#"C "C#)%,
9C #(%" C #C #!$%')C# ,C" ,&&:C0/:C2/8CBC2119CC C #$ #)':C 9C 9:C "C 99C "%9:C 1//79C "" C ( '#":C #"'%,C # ,:C"C " '#"C"C'C "(&'% -C#% 9CC #(%" C#C# '&9C6/:C552A57/9C C "%:C 99C "C 9C "%":C 1/039C "'% C "C %"&$%",C "C "$"";C $'&C "C *C &(%&9C "'%"'#" C #(%" C #C "'% C ""C0/:C078A14/9CC C C#%#:C9C"C9CC#:C08889C#( C""C($%)&#"C"C #"'%,C # ,C&&CC)"C'#C%"'C"&
# ,C"C""C($%)&#"CC$%'
%##"#!&C2/:C171B2/69C
+*:? 9? $? 9? *%)):? 1/039? ? #&"? #&'"? (*'? %? $)'"? $!(;?%$('+)(#9?%*)'$?%$%#? %*'$":?70:?3/8=3239? !:? 9:? %($'$? 9:? %%)"":? 9? 08889? < <:? :?'"?('+?$!?%?%()%$:?
((*?&:?10=219? %':? 9:? 1/0/9? $")%$? ')$? )*'$(? 1/9? $)'$)%$"? %$)'.? *$:? $$?$?+"%$)?36:?35=389? %%#$:? 9:? 1//89? ? %)? %$? )? #? %? %%? $.? $()'*#$)(9? -%'? *"")$?%?%$%#(?$?))()(?60:?024>0479? :? 9? $? 9? "$:? 1/039? $)'"? $!? $&$$? $? #'%= &'*$)"?'*")%$9?%$%#(?))'(:?014:?216=22/9? $# ':? 9:? 1//49? ? $)? #&"? %'')%$? %'? )? '$? %? $'? $)?,%=)&? ?()#)%'(9? %*'$"?%?%$%#)'(?015:?14>409? ? ? ? ? ? ? ? ? ? ? ? ? ? ?
7 7 7
77! $"!7 7 "7 7 7 7 7 %"7 7 7 7 7 !!7 7 7 7 $7#&7 7 $ "77 7 !"7 "7 7 !" "5 "77 7 5 "7 7 !""7 7 7 ! $"!7 3(47
3(47 2(7 7 6'1'.((7 3'1'0.(47 '1((0557 3'1'-''47 6'1(0*7 3'1)-,47 6'1''*/*7 3'1'),-47 '1(.+557 3'1'..047 '1''((07 3'1'')'/47 7 7 '1'*))7 3'1(*,47 6'1'(-+7 3'1'((,47 7 7 7 7 7 7 '1.*/557 3'1)0-47 7 */,7 '1'.)7
3*47 "2(7 7 '1'**/7 3'1(((47 '1'+(+7 3'1'/--47 6'1().7 3'1).(47 6'1''*-.7 3'1'(-(47 '1'),.7 3'1'.--47 6'1'''(+/7 3'1''(0+47 7 7 6'1'*'+7 3'1()047 '1'')+-7 3'1'('/47 7 7 7 7 7 7 '10).5557 3'1)*047 7 )-+7 '1(*.7
3+47 "2)7 7 6'1)',7 3'1)(,47 '1,0057 3'1*(.47 6'1,),557 3'1)(-47 6'1'+)/7 3'1','.47 '1+('557 3'1(.-47 6'1'''*-(7 3'1''(-+47 '1(/+57 3'1'00/47 6'1)).7 3'1(,+47 6'1'().7 3'1'(,047 '1'''-)*7 3'1'''///47 6'1''(,(7 3'1''('*47 6'1+*/557 3'1)()47 '10-05557 3'1)/+47 7 ),.7 '1(*,7
3,47 2(7 7 67 67 '1'(-57 3'1''.47 '1(.*7 3'1',-47 '1'',7 3'1''*47 '1'+'557 3'1'(+47 6'1''')7 3'1''+47 7 7 67 67 6'1''0557 31''+47 7 7 7 7 7 7 '1/0/5557 3'1'+'47 7 +)'7 67
3-47 2)7 7 67 67 61'))7 31')*47 1)*(7 31'.+47 1''*7 31'')47 1'*-557 31'(+47 61''')7 31'''+47 1'+'57 3'1')'47 67 67 61'()57 31'',47 61''(557 31'''*47 1''(557 31'''+47 61'**7 31')+47 10.)5557 31'-*47 7 +)'7 67
3.47 3/47 "2(7 "2)7 7 7 67 67 67 67 1')(557 1'(.7 31''/47 31'+)47 1(,-5557 1)*'557 31'++47 31'./47 1''07 1''.7 31''-47 31''+47 1',05557 1',/557 31'(.47 31')(47 1''(57 1'''-57 31'''*47 31'''*47 7 1'+'7 7 31'),47 67 67 67 67 61'(+557 61')'57 3'1''+47 31''047 7 61''',7 7 31''(47 7 1''',7 7 31'''047 7 61'*07 7 31'*(47 '10(/5557 (1'(.5557 31'-.47 31'+-47 7 7 )/(7 )/(7 67 67
7 3)47 2)7 7 6'1(,'7 3'1(*(47 '1+/'557 3'1)*/47 '1'(()7 3'1,0'47 6'1'))(7 3'1')0/47 '1*',57 3'1(,-47 '1''()/7 3'1'')'/47 6'1'.((7 3'1((/47 '1)))7 3'1*'-47 6'1'(-(7 3'1'((/47 '1''',-*7 3'1''(*047 6'1''(*)7 3'1''().47 6'1*+-7 3'1)*+47 '1//'57 3'1+0047 7 *./7 '1(+*7
3047 2(7 7 67 67 6(1.+*57 31/'047 6.1**(557 3)1.-'47 61).,7 31)()47 6,1).,5557 3(1,(,47 1'-'5557 31'(+47 7 7 67 67 6(1'-+5557 31(,-47 7 7 7 7 7 7 (01)('5557 3)1+)+47 7 +)'7 67
3('47 2)7 7 67 67 6(1)()57 31--)47 6*100(557 3(1-/.47 61'0(7 31',(47 61-*,7 31*/(47 61''.57 31''+47 1'',7 31)'047 67 67 1((,7 31(')47 1'(*)7 31''/47 61'(+57 31''/47 (1..'557 31.,(47 +1(0)57 3)1(/(47 7 +)'7 67
3((47 "2(7 7 67 67 6(1.),557 31.*(47 1+-07 3*1.+)47 61+*07 31)0'47 6-1.'+5557 3(1/.,47 1'(07 31'(*47 7 7 67 67 6(1+))5557 31)0/47 7 7 7 7 7 7 )/1.)(5557 3,1(**47 7 )/(7 67
3()47 "2)7 7 67 67 6(1,,'57 31.(-47 6+1/(-557 3(1/++47 61'('7 31'*/47 61,+07 310)-47 61''05557 31'')47 61)((7 31)+.47 67 67 1')(7 31'/.47 1'()7 31'((47 61'(')7 361'('47 )1)-/5557 31-0.47 ,1..'5557 3(1))*47 7 )/(7 67
8
8
8
4(58 &1))+8 &1+)/8 &1/-'8 &1,,.8 78 78 78 78 78 78 78 8 8 &1-+)8 &1))/8 &1').8 &1*/)8 78 78 78 78 78 78 78
88 ! 8 ((8 (+8 ((8 (+8 78 78 78 78 78 78 78
88! 8 )+8 )+8 (*8 (*8 )+8 )+8 (*8 (*8 )+8 )+8 (*8
38 88 8 8 28#8 88 8$7 18'88(8 88 8!88 8$ 8"88! 84(528 "%18 8 28 ! 8 8 8 # 8 78 8 8 8 #7 8 "8 $8 8 "8 %8 8 4(&&+58 8 8 8 18 88!8 ! 88! 8%884(&&/58 8!8 8 188$7 287%8 888 88 186668286682868#8 888'028+088'&028 "%188
78 78 78 (*8