The Role of Case-study Research in Investigating Local-government Accountability Reporting: Evidence from Indonesia

Available online at www.sciencedirect.com

ScienceDirect Procedia Economics and Finance 35 (2016) 44 – 53

" -   . '$ 

/+  0)1 " . " 2% 

!" 3 ) 0 4$& 3 "  - ++ 5 6  #$%& 3+7  ) -  /$"  8$&19 0  4 :% 


  

  

   


 

   
! " 

#    
$% 



 # )  +"   ++  & "   && +;  < 1 "     "   $&  "  ))  +;% $     % +" !"  " )$ "   $&  "     $ ) " +  $%& +    +  <1     $   "    "   +  "   !"  

% $   +"  &+  "   " $ + ) 

$ " "" "  ) $%& : 



© 2016 The Authors. Published by Elsevier B.V. This is an open access article under the CC BY-NC-ND license  !" #$" 
$% " %&   '( (http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-nc-nd/4.0/).
 $   %& ) *  !+ ,  Peer-reviewed under responsibility of Universiti Tenaga Nasional & '(
0  $&= 3 " "+&= 5 + 


    !" $&   "  " "+&  &   ++ -  +  $%& + !" %> ) " $&  )7   $  "  ) $%&  <  %& -   +  )+ " ; ) =  %  $  "    $ " $%&  $%  %&  + 



9 0 + $" !7 ?@ABBCAC@= )<7  )* 
( "$&D+ 

2212-5671 © 2016 The Authors. Published by Elsevier B.V. This is an open access article under the CC BY-NC-ND license (http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-nc-nd/4.0/). Peer-reviewed under responsibility of Universiti Tenaga Nasional doi:10.1016/S2212-5671(16)00008-3

Muhammad Hudaya and Ciorstan Smark / Procedia Economics and Finance 35 (2016) 44 – 53

! + " $ +  %  :+1 " " " )$ ) "  " +&1   +&1 "+&1  " "$ %  "    %)" 6)):1 A1    &  + " )$ )$    

& ) ))  " 6)):1 A !" " " )$  &  " $&   )$ " &   +"   !"   + 

$  ) E$  "1 )  1   " "  "      " %> %+  " !" $&  +;  +"  7 " " %    =   $&  "   B=  

$&  "  +  C=  " E$    =  7 F$:+G " + ) 

  =  &  7 %+ $ "E$     " $    A 
   #+  6)): A  % :+1 )$ " " )$ "$ %  1  $   %    "  " %) $+  "7 +&1   +&1 "+&1  " 2+& )  " $ ) & 0  @@A= H;. 51 @@A= 6)):1 A= ' 1  2+&1 " $& 

$  " "  ) $%& +  &  $ %& "   !"  %$  "  ) $%& +  %    &   $ "  $ ) "$  1 &  & %   %&  '+ .5$: 1 @= '$ . /+ @@

  +&  " " 

) " :+   H;. 51 @@A= 6)):1 A= ' 1  '$  " $& $    $  "   + 

$ 1  E$ "    + 

$    + 

$  %$ E$  "     " " $&1 "" +$ "  ) $%& +   & $ & 6$%  5 @AA  " "   + 

$  ) E$  " E$  "  

 "   ) " %> %+ $   0 1 @@A1 "$ $+   $ /"+&  " " "  )$"   ) " " " )$ )  "  )E$&  $  6)):1 A1  ) $ &   && $ 6)):1 A /"+&  )  " ) : )   &  $+ " :+ H;. 51 @@A= ,$ 1 = 6)):1 A 6)): A1  1 )  1  " I "+&  +  $ " ) E$&  "$  "   ) :+I1 " " ) "  I" "E$ $   +" "   ) I !")1 " "  &  1  "$ %   "1  "+& - +1 "    " " 7 E$  E$  " J$ " )$  +  &;+ $   ) % %+ $ "$+"    + H;. 51 = " E$ "  " < +  )+   ) &  $ &1     $+  

% "  "  " %> %+ $ H;. 51  J$ "  

   " + $"  " + $&1 "+"&  "   $& # $"1 E$  "   "  " &   " %&  & ) "   ,$ 1 = 4 1 C 4 C1 A ) %&  I" <  ""    ) "   $ + I1  &  K" <  "" "         L$L ) ) "  I - "  1 &  %&   " "  "  %"     4 1 C 81  E$  "1 $&   $&  "1 ) %&  &  

&  

% 4 1 C1  "&  " +    +  " 

 "   )  "G )   " %> %+ $ 4 1 C !"$ 1 " $&      & %&  & )    $++  %& 4 C !"  " +&  &  " $&    $&  "1 )  $ % )    M B  " $    "" "   $&    " +&7  " $&  

45

46

Muhammad Hudaya and Ciorstan Smark / Procedia Economics and Finance 35 (2016) 44 – 53

K"N  K"&N E$  = % "  + "  $"&  " =   " )$   "  & "  "   ) <   # " $&  "  1 "   $& "  %  !" <   %   $&  "    
 # +  ++ %& ) $ "  + "  ) $%& +   +  3:   A  8$  O        $&  "1 " '$"   @A@  '&  5 @@ $     ) "  $  +  /  ) " %  " 1 $+ 3&  1 1 4 C1 '   B1 O$ B= /:  3& = O  / = = /  5    #:%   1 $   $& " !")1 " " %   "  $%& +  $ +   $&  " !"    +& +  " ) ) "   $&   0 1 @@A= ,$ 1 = M1 B 0  @@A1  )    $&  I < )  F%$ &  G      $       "$+" 1 "   + $ $ ) )  "  <I -    1 ,$  1 C )   I " <  )  <   $ ) )  %$ & ) $    )    

$  )  I '" "  )

"   "  " E$   "  )  "$+" <   $  $ $ ) )  M B1 B ) "   $&  " +&  I   E$& "  +   & "  "  ) <1  & " " %$ % "   <   & I M B < " ) )   $& %& +  "+"+"+  %$1 " " %> %+ $    & "  !"$ 1 ML )       %$  $ + "  %+ <  $" 1 8$ "&  4 @@1 @C $ " $  ) "   $&  $+  "7 #
 "


% 



%  
4  


" 
  


  
'

 
% 
 
 
 


%   



 **
  5  
46  

% 
4  
 


% 

' 



 
4  
 6
'"
- ' 
"4
% 

% 
' 

4  


'



 % 
 
 
   


% 
!" + )    $&  "      $ ) $+      +

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

$ " "   + -     " " %> ) " $&1 ""   $   &; "  ) $%&  <  %& -   +  )+ ; ) 

Muhammad Hudaya and Ciorstan Smark / Procedia Economics and Finance 35 (2016) 44 – 53


   !"   "  "  + +&   +$ "   "  )$     $ )  "  " "& : )$   

+ "  " E$   #+  M B1 1 "  "  + )    $&  K)   7   $&G E$  1 %    1 ) &1   $  ) &  1  " + :+ "   "   1   "  ) + " )+ N /H  

 " F"  "&G  & E$  )   $&  "  " % ""  )  "  "+ "  "G %>  M B  $ "   1 ) %& ,$  1  A  I "   %$  " %     I1    $ & )    $& !" $ ) &   K" > & %+ &;  " $&N " .
:&:1 1  ABA -  %  $1  +$ ) $ ) <   ) &  )

 

1   +&  $"   

 +   +;  $ "  +; ,$   M B  " %" " + :+ "   "   1  "  ) + " )+    $ )$   + " + )  &     $&  "
 "+   ) &  $   +  &;+  H 1 
 "+  K "+  %     )  $ $  "  <   "&"    + "" "   "  $+   )  ) " "&"      "  $+    ) N 8:.H$1 1  B 0 + " $&     "&"    %>     " $1 " $&    &  "+=  1  $   & $ " %   "   Q  "+ 1  "+ 1  ": %$ "+ Q  :     )+ 41 @@A1  #  8  1   " "  %& &+ "7 $
 
 

 
  
 
  
' 
 




% 
 
  
%%
%



4


 
4 


%

   "


%  
 


4
% 

 " %


 
'
4


 6
 

 
 
  

  
 

4 
!" "    " )+  %  %     "    &   -

"1 "  )  "  +    +$+  + "  "  

" $&G %> 
   !" $& "   " E$  7  "   +    $ $%&  R  % "     $  " $%& )$  $ " $ $%& 

$%  %&  + R #+  M B1 1 I"   $& +&    :&  %  ) F"G  F"&G E$  N !"$ 1  " E$     " $&  "  ) $ +    $& +& 0 + " $ ) E$  " ""        ,$ 1 1 " $&     <  "&"  1 "     $ + "  ) $%&    %& -   +     "  )     



+

$"   '& + 1 " $&  $    " + ) $"  " " $E$ < #.8 1  #+  /    "  " + )   $&  "7 <&1  1  <& S "&   " <&      $ &   &    ))  <   $%  ) )$+ " %> %+ $ -    1 #  8   +$ "   $&  "   &    ) 1 %$  $ % " "  &   &   !" $&1 ")1       <&     

$ 1 %$ "  " <&  )  "   -&1  & " $&  " <&   $& +&  & "++ -+  &;+ E$ 1 + " && %        &  : !" ))$ 

47

48

Muhammad Hudaya and Ciorstan Smark / Procedia Economics and Finance 35 (2016) 44 – 53

 %  +% " " " ) : ) " $&  !" ) :  " $"   "   "  "  &"+ :  " %) !"     " "  <

 %& 4 C "  $ " ) : $ ) $"  +       $&  " !" $ ) &  ) " $&    +   - 1 " "   " "  +  $ $& 56*4 ") %+      :& )   " < ) " +; %+ $!" "  $ %& $   $&  "1 $+ 4;:G @C@  "  ++ " !

 (& #$"&1  "" " $ ) &   " +;  )1  3 G @AC $& ) " '& G   !
"  #$%  & ' ( ')   $ %+1 " $" ) " $& "  %  

  

" 56*4 )) 4< " %) "   1  )) " " 56*4       " - + 1" $" 

$  "  

 $ % + &  &1  " 

 ) %&    81 &+ &  " ))   $+"1  " )) $ ))$&  <+ " $ ) " $& $ +   + "  1 "    

+ "   % "  "  " %> ) $&  "  $"& !"  $"& " " 56*4 $  :    ""  +  

   !"   )  "  $ %& -  6)): 1   " K++  

+   $  " $

) " >N 0 + " 

$1      :  

    ) "  )) # + " "  ))  " $ & 4 % A - " +1 " $ ) " $&  <  " ))  " " $ $   "%& +  

  

" 56*4 )) 8 " 

$  )  )&+ "  "  "  ) $%& +  " 56*4 )) $ % $) H % A  T$ @  " +1 " $"   % "" )  + $  " $ " " 56*4 !" ))  " " & " $"    $  "  & )) ) " ) $  "  !" )) )$" < " "    " "  &     )    "  "&  -  1 " $& E$ + ++   " )     %     ) " "  %+ $ - + 1 " $& $  )$

$ ) 7  1  %  1 $   "   $++  %& M B  H$  8: A !" < $%   % "  $ )     7
 " '(
8
"  

 

 
  % 

!" $& &   )   2    & $+ " )  "1  $++  %& M B !"    K & ) $&  " E$   ""    )  )) &   "&  "  " E$ N ,$ 1 1  A !"    "     K))+  $

N $+ "   $++  %& /  4$& B1   - $+ "    1 " $" %+ %& $ + " 

) +  +  $%&   %& " 56*4 * " 56*41 "  C : $ $+  %$$   % & 
9 4O
H #  : )  )  %& " 56*4  $%&  ) : $ 1 ""  "    " 56*4 $%&   !"  : )   )  E$   : $  $%  " $%&   " : $  " 5

H  5O
>  "  :)   " 56*4 '$$ ) 6 !"     

$ ;1  " -5

H  + !" $%&   " "   " +  " " ) " 56*4 !"  1 $% E$&1  $%   " "  7 "  + 1 "     " $%

Muhammad Hudaya and Ciorstan Smark / Procedia Economics and Finance 35 (2016) 44 – 53

!" $ % )      " $&  1 $+   % ) "    H
3H 0  &  + "      "&  :+% %$  +  $%& += % "&  +  %   " $& $& !" )   +$ )  $+   " E$    " $     $&   :&  % )$ " " +1 ")  : 1   ) 1    %  ;= % " $  ) $   "   $%>    ) "    - $+ "    1 " $"   ++  +  " "  !" $" " )  +  " "      + %) " $&  $ "$+" "

"+ ) "$+"   $  $

 ! " $ + ) "  ) +  $%& +  " 56*41 " $"   $   "   % ) "    # +  " " "   +$& )  !" 

)  $   $%>  " "  )  "  %& 8$  3 " " 0  ++7  " "    " $&  $& % " "& & " "  ) " $&  &  =  "  )&  

$    % )  &  ) "  " !"  + )   B $ 1 $%>  "    %& ) "    -&1 " $"  "  $   +    "  = "1 "+  "    " 56*4 ))  $  : & ) "   1   :   !"      "   >$ ) %& " : ) 8&  /  C  / @ 8&  /  C1 B1 )  1  "7 $




% 
%

4

4

" '
'"
 
4* 

  
"


  

4*
4  
44

%
%

$



4" 




 
%
-
%
%

44

4

 
 
' 
4 
%
 



   
#"$+"   ) "    & <

" %>1 " $ $ %     ) " + $    1 " $"  $ ))$&  ++  ) / 01  )) " " '$$ ) 2+;  " )) "  : " $" $ & / 0 1 I " )) "  $%>     ) $  : " & ) " +;1 $+  +  $  1 $

  $  ) + $  I H+ " " $ $

)$&  %    ) "  " G :+ ) "  $$= %&  $  " +$+1 '>  * + " $$  +$  % 1 "  "  %   " )) " " $& $ % $   "    %   " "      " $&  $&  $ %   )$& &1 "   )  & !" < $++  " "+  " $$ " "    + 1 $&  ++ )$" )  !"    " " : ) 4 C "   " "   $&  " "$ " < +$+ : $+ :+ ) "  +$+   $+ " %" " $%> )  " $ ) "  " 7
9  
 "  (
44% 


:'

  

H %  &      +  ) 1    "+  +"  "  %+ $ M1 B= ! 1 @@ H %   " $"  "   $ + ) "  ) $%& +  " 56*4 H %  $ "$ 

  7  + $ "  " $&  & $  

) +$=  % ))+  +" %$ " & " $+ " $  ) +  $%&    $ ) " +  $%&  " %& " 
  !" )   & $+  %  7  $+   ) "  $"& ) "   + %+ % = % +   ; "   )   )  "  =  " $  ) $   "   $%>    ) "  $"    !"  : $+ " &    " +    :   +;  "  " $ )  " 

49

50

Muhammad Hudaya and Ciorstan Smark / Procedia Economics and Finance 35 (2016) 44 – 53

!" : ) $   " $"  )& "  "     "  ) $%&     1 +   " ) " 56*4  , AA1    

+   " $%&   81  %   " ) )$ " & )$   ++  "  !"$ 1  %   $"    "    " +$%   "  " & #" < 1 " $&  " )$  "" " " ) " 56*4  "+ $%& ) "    %) "  % ) "   =  %   " $"  + " K)N ) "  ++  7
9 %  
 
  "
 
H$   "  +"  "   )  " &  % % ) " $ M1 B= ! 1 @@7 /H1  M B1 A1 )  1  " I"     $  ) $    %  $+   ) " $ I M B1 A )$" < " $  $ I   $  1 )  $  $1    + I - " )1  "   "  & ) $ 1 $"  $%&  1 $+     + ) " +     !    % ) " 56*4 ))1 " $"   +"  ) < $ $"  " #$  4  ) " 56*4 

$ %& " 4$  #$ #+&  " -  '$$ ) 4  '
4 )
" #*  +    !" 

) &;+    "$+  : %$  "  : $ ) 1 $"  %   1  1 +;   <  0 1 @@A / "  3

 @@@1  & " 

 I 

&1  %+$$ 1   $ +1 1  ) +I $"1 "   + "  &;+   E$  " 0 1 @@A= H&1 = 5 1  !"  %$  " "   $%>  )$ ) " "  #%$O"1 @1  1   1 "+ 1 " ) "$+" 5 1  1 " %> )  " H&1  - " )  + )  &  1 "    %& 4 @@A   +"  "  ++ " " 

) E$  &   4 @@A1   % " 

) E$  &    &  ) I+1 +1  ":+ )  + "+ I 4 @@A1  )$" "+"+" " IU " V    & 1 1  " ":1  "   I= " 

 1 +

1 $  "  1 + "  "  )& E$  )   "&  ":+  "+" "  1  "  "  "   $$ & +++  " "  !" " 1 $"  5+" 1 '

   #%$O" @1 + " 4 @AA $" 1 " 

)    "  $ )$"  41 @@A= '

1 = " 1  $1  " $&  &  $ $ ) 1  +$ ,$  1 C@ ) +$  I"  " :+   "+ ) $  )    $&I#  8    " " $  ) +$  "  "      ) $ $ 1 "$  + $& ,$ 1 1 C@1 %& #.8 1 1 1  ))+   "  :+ / . <1 C1 B $" +1 " : ) / "  3

 @@@  $   "     " 

$++  %& 4 @@A / "  3

 @@@1  $ ) < + "  )  &  7 I +;+ " = % ++ + 1 "  1  =  + " =   + "  + $ +=  "+ )  < =  ) + " I !"& )$" < "  $   $  " "  ) " 

 !" 

  " "  " % &   )  + "  $       + " <   "  " !"    " 5&T B      1 " +$ " "  )  E$  "  +)  "+  + "  "1  E$ "  "  ": )&  :   ) " %> %+ $

Muhammad Hudaya and Ciorstan Smark / Procedia Economics and Finance 35 (2016) 44 – 53

- " $&1 "   $& &; $ + "   $  %& 4 @@A  / "  3

 @@@ - " )  +1 4G @@A  +$ "  " %& + "  "  $  " 

)  +"+  E$  " - " )$" + 1 & $  %& / "  3

 @@@ + $ )$ +$  "  $    H $1  $++  %& / "  3

 @@@  

 " $ 7 +;+ " = ++ + 1 "    =  + " 1 " " " " $ "& )    & )   +    !%  !%  # ) " < "  ) / "  3

 @@@ #


" 



















2+;+ " 

H $

6+ + 1 "   



0+ " 

# : !"     %     + "1  &  & +;1 +" " %     $   "   !" +;  %   " "    " $&G %> 7  " 

) $%& =  " +; $$ ) " 56*4= B $%&   

& $ = C   +=  $+=  "  ) $%&  =  )   $ = A  $   " = @ $%& )$ =     L     "  $%  - )     %&     ) "

$&    $ + " ) )   $





























! + "  + $ +

- . + ) " 

4"+ )  < S+ " 

!"    &; $ +  "   "  +  ) " $& 5&T B  5    

 " E$  "   &   $  +7 IE$  " % " )$ $ + ) "     " <= "& $  "  & )    " "  "  I 5  1 1  !"     " %& :  H  "  " " "  " " $  ) " $ + ) "  " +)& )$ )$" + ) "  " 

 !")1 " $&   $  +  &;+ "   - " $&1  + $ +    1  " $&     "&"   3"1     ) "  +$ ) ++  "  :+  $++  %& /  < C + " $ 1   " $" ) "+  < ) " $&   1 " $& )$ " $%& )$ " %& "     +& $ 1  "&  & )$) "   "$ "+

+)    )  ) " 56*4  + $%

  S"&   "R # "    ) &    

" 

$

,
   !"  %> ) "    )  "   $& "+& $     "  $  "  ) $%& + " "  +  $ $& 56*4  -  $ )+ ) " $&  %   8$&1 4 :1 S  4  !"  %  "   $&  "       $+  + $"  "  $$ < - "  1 " +" $ ) "   $&1     %&    " + )  

$&  "1       +"  +  "    < !" 

)   $&

51

52

Muhammad Hudaya and Ciorstan Smark / Procedia Economics and Finance 35 (2016) 44 – 53

 " $: ) " $& " " " $"  +   % +1 +1 )+1 &;+  $ +    $ < " "" " $%&  $ $&      " " 1 " $& $     $&  " +&  %$  " %& ) $  $%&  " $% 1 $&  "  ) $%& +   + $& !" >& ) $ +  $%& +  " $%  " % $   $ $ + $&  5: 1  $ " % " < )  "  $%& $ + "   $& " !"  E$    " +  $%& +  + $ 1 $&  -  -  ) +; $$ )  + 1 )  1 "  %  " "$+"  

$&  " !"  

% %$    $&  "   "  " " K$ + ) %" " && +;  < ) $"   "  )$ )     < N 8$ "& .4 1 @@1 @C !"$ 1 " $  ) "  " +& ) )$$  " $   $;    %  

( 



#1 -1 . 8 1
1  0  4$&   /"+ #" - # T / 1 6 H$ 1 .  S%   1 ) 4 

,
%
; 1  57 4#6
$% 5 #%$O"1 4 ,1 @ 4  :+  - /+  #$+ 3 "7 0 $+  0% #$     
% 

<%  "
+
=1 CB '

1 ' 3  - - # T / 1 6 H$ 1 .  S%   1 ) 4 

,
%
; 1 B 57 4#6
$% 5 ' 1 T1 
    #$+ 3 "7 # 
 
   0 3  $% 
$

%  
% 
 
/  
>C1 B 0 1 T S1 @@A <%  "
 ?% 
 
; 
9 
, 
 
/ "
8    57 4#6
$% 5 H 1 81  4  #&   - # T / 1 6 H$ 1 .  S%   1 ,
%


+ 
$44   AAAA@ 57 4#6
$% 5 H;1 , O1 . 51 M 41 @@A 8
@  4

<%  "
; (
8 
 
% !"$  2: 7 4#6
$% 1 - H;1 , O1 . 51 M 41  -$7 !" H  
 ) J$ 3 " - 8
 
  -

<%  "
; 1 B 57 4#6
$% 5 H&1 -1  <%  "
9
$   (
$
!
/  
A% 






   57 3$+ H$1 T1 . 8:1 !1 A ,
%
+

% 
;  2<)7   5 "1 /1 .
:&:1 1  4 + - # T / 1 6 H$ 1 .  S%   1 ,
%


+ 
$44 1 ABAC 57 4#6
$% 5 :1 3 /1 . H 1 O T1 4$& H +  J$ 3 "Q7 H+ J$   #



+ 3 $ ,  )%  


1   1 ,1 , 1 4/1 ': 61 '1

1 01 81 #1 /";"1 51  1 
$  J$ 3 "7 " -  ) H)) 3 "  J$ #"  " #&  ) J$ H <%  "
; 
C1  6)):1 /1 A $

%  
8
; 
; % 
 
$

%  
   "  1 ,4S7
  $ 8P++1 -1 . 8$1 61 @@ K0  4$ N - #$+ 3 " $

%   
B  5  
 


 
>1 BCB 8& 1 !1 . / 1 31 C ! !  ,  !7 3)  /" ) H 0 - 0 8$ "&1 . ' 5   1 8
;
@ 
A% 

$

%  
; (
$
 **  
C '

! 
<%  "
; 
+1 B@B #  7   5 8$&1 /1 4 :1 01 S 1 !1 . 41
1  !" *  ) #$%& 3  #$%& $ 7  )  -  5 6  $% 
$

%   
% 
 
/  
% 
DC1 )" + 8$ "&1 01 . 4 1 3 S1 @@ /"+ !"  7 !"  0  4$ ) 2+; #$+
 7 5   5%R $

%   
$%  
E
$

%   
% 
DC1 A -1 81 . 6)):1 /1  6+ 1 6+   6+ 2$7 3)   J$ 3 "
> $

%   
$%  
E
$

%   
% 
D1 C 5+"1 T
1  0+ '   - # T / 1 6 H$ 1 .  S%   1 ) 4 

,
%
; 1 A 57 4#6
$% 5 5 1 T1  #& + J$ 5+$ 3 "  $  



E


 
7C1 C 5&T 1 61 B H +  0 -

$  J$ 0  4$& 3 "     
% 

<%  "
+
 51 / 61 4$+1 H !1 . (+1 O 81 +

)%   
;  4  4  7 T

&'

 / "1 01 . 3

1 6 '1 @@@ 9  
<%  "
;  !"  !"$  2: 7 4#6
$% - /H1 ( 51  ')#) 0  4$& H + - # T / 1 6 H$ 1 .  S%   1 ) 4 

,
%
; 1 B 57 4#6
$% 5

Muhammad Hudaya and Ciorstan Smark / Procedia Economics and Finance 35 (2016) 44 – 53

/1 61 . <1 O T1 C !" '$+ '+7


%& ) #& H+$ % "+"&1 0  #&   $ - H 4   1 <%  "
; (
8 
+
 
  1 B 57 4#6
$% 5 / 1 # T1 H$ 1 61 . S%1 1  -$ - # T / 1 6 H$ 1 .  S%   1 ) 4 

,
%
; 1 <<<<<<1 57 4#6
$%  /1 /1 . 4$&1 S1 B
$% 4  /+  3) 7 # 0  4$& ) 5 6  #+  -  $% 
$

%  
% 
 
/  
% 
C1 @ /1 '1 @ 
 2%   2% 
 - 4 M% 1 H M1 8 S 1 .  O +   1 B  5  
)  4 (
% 
)" 
B  5  
@   B@ 57 4#6
$% 5 ,$ 1 S 51  


; 
+
<%  "
 
<%  "
$44 
 6
 ' 7
  $1 -
  :1 !1  0  4$& 3 "  / - # T / 1 6 $ 1 .  S%   1 ) 4 

,
%
;   A 57 4#6
$%  3 1
 @AC T$ T$   !" '& G  7 4$+  0$0
$ 0  1 @@@AC 


 
1  B 4 1 31 C H+ 0  4$& 3 " - 0 8$ "&1 . ' 5   1 8
;
@ 
A% 

$

%  
; (
$
 **   
C '

! 
<%  "
; 
+1 @ #  7   5 41 T (1 @@A <%  "
9
$    3 T$& B1 @1 ) "7E$  " EW" 4;:1
1 @C@ 8C$
 

A
;(
$
%






/
B  5   ':&7 * & ) 0)


 4 1 H1   4 
<%  "
9(
+

$  5 
8-
86
 
     57 4+ ! 1 S1 @@ -$  0  4$& 8
<%  "
;4
FB * 
 G
 ! 1 S1 @@% # )  0  4$& /"+& 8
<%  "
;4
FB * 
 G
B !" 1 S /1 1 2%  8
; 
+
& ' 

 
)    3 %$& 1 1 ) "7  " " :% ($+"1 H1 @@ !"& %7 " 8$  ) 0  #&   - 0 0 3+1 . 8 4 ':   1 #


,H
)64 

/%   




 ?%  1 B 0 %+7 0 %+ * &


 S "&1 T1  0$  0  4$&7 <& !"  - # T / 1 6 H$ 1 .  S%   1 ) 4 

,
%
; 1 BBA 57 4#6
$% 5 M1 3 O1 B ,
%
; (
9 
 
+ !"  57 4#6
$% 5

53