Towards a new theory of distributive justice

319

TOWARDSA NEW THEORY OF DISTRIBUTIVE Amherst,

Massachusetts:

Pp. ix + 148, [Editor's book:

Note.

The editor

of a faculty

exceed

of

the

supply

of

author

considers

of distribution

six

have all

looks

fallen

short

The author

of

pretation which

used to

resolve model

which

He then

extreme

stayes. efficiency

He does this The less

need and merit

in

the

the

for

a

which

that

are

basic

they

distribution

in

the

four

related

the

three These

his

economics,

interstages

and and distri-

of goods

in each of the

the

the

greater

resulting

to

economics,

comfort,

and the greater the

is

economic

subsistence,

premise,

distribution

to formulate

the

are

analysis.

production,

production,

of

On that a just

used to form

sentences

an economy is,

language

language

tools to

availability

in production

of

of

this

each of

scarcity,

nature

problem

for

pertaining

by defining

to the

productive

and ability

and models

problems."

the

and these

uses these

he recognizes: relate

solve

are

are made up of words

as they

him.

because:

the

philosophical to

values

sentences

distribution

bution

into

The alphabet

product.

of a just

affluence.

from

whether

and concludes

interpretation

"insights

a language

and distribution.

theories

justice

adequate

that

aforementioned

sentences

Bowie's

their adherents do not understand the problem of distributive justice they are not sufficiently inclusive their adherents demand too much of them.

states

of an economy's six

other

to satisfy

in determining

different

distributive

2. 3.

word justice

and the

available

as primary

at several

with

often

Professor

Happiness Liberty Equality Merit Optimization or Efficiency Ability or Skill

1.

already

viewpoint

of

is just:

to deal

he develops

two reviews

student's

values

65: He then

for

goods and services

:: 3. 4u

the

asked

Towards a New Theory of Distributive Justice is an --ethical problems faced when man's wants and desi

the

system

attempt

1971.

member.1

Norman Bowie's examination

--Norman Bowie. of Massachusetts Press,

The University

&

$9.00.

one from a graduate

that

JUSTICE.

the

importance

product.

four

need for of

The more

320

affluent

an economy is,

liberty

and happiness

the in the

and services.

Therefore,

when it

to

yields

and liberty. services

the

However,

rather

than

consideration. of

social costs

justice.

It

political

science,

in

itself

etc.

book,

source

to provide

Although

this

to arrive

at a new theory justice

involved

in

develops

and how

of distributive

the

subjects

problems,

of

social

have its

own criticism

as an outside

a different

of of

sociology,

with

will

to

face

account

problem

urban

the

benefits.

of economics,

reading

perspective.

to the

of people."

in

the the

or according be produced

the outcome question

4)

Bowie

analysis

to what

principles justly?"

his

With

only

the limited

the question: 7)

goods

and

discussion

discuss

can these (p.

and

of benefits

limits

directly

raises

Ph.D.

justice Traditionally,

of burdens.

author's

and distributed

author's

distribution

and does not

distribution

the

justice.

just (p.

of

of distributive

of distributive

of benefits

and services,

services

the

"refers

among a group

basis

with

book,

investigate

distribution

goods what

to

of

is

problems

the

valuable

may bear becomes

take

the

the

human values.

But he fails

does not

and

University

The objective

to the

it

of

which

be affluent

to

relations,

student

potential

efficiency

when dealing

may find

research,

burdens

that

with

fields

goods

distribution

of more lofty

each discipline

instructors

John Grimes Western Illinois

distributive

to the

just

as a country

approach

minority

the

also along

and philosophy

insufficient

society. to

may arise

a novel

development,

of the

an affluent

goods

of happiness

some points

he maintains

be distributed

lends

philosophy,

covered

of

is most just

physical

maximization

can continue

which

of

actual

individual

amount

development,

The theory

costs

should

greatest

constraint

has not

system

The book presents

economic

the

upon the

production.

various

the

upon the

importance

how this

inefficient these

distribution

For example,

subordinate

consider

of

and distribution

of economic

theory

importance

production

given

must be based more firmly The author's

the

Bowie contends,

individual

in many stages

econany

greater

and

"On

321

To reach Chapter

his

objective,

1, covering

erations,

is

approaches being: all

three

In chapter

author

discusses

his

approach

iate

classified of

living,

discussing

followinq

6 values.

be attained

for

is used to applies sentence

are the

of distributive

the

three

and potential

principle

of

While find

the

limits

criticism,

distributive

this book to

his

principles

directly

discuss

though

he states

agrees

with

the

be somewhat narrow the

reflects

economic

above mentioned

work He then

words.

economic

each justice

priority

rankings different

of

productive

author

is able

of having

of

should

to arrive

at

that

make

principles capacity.

to avoid

the

a single

justice.

reviewer

discussion

the

providing

the

that word

while

comprising

levels

,

in the

arrangements

values

distribution

thus

different

Bowie con-

distribution

and their

systems,

for

two intermed-

and Distribution

those

the

of words

scarcity,

arranged

various

income,

and the

values

between varying

the

and

affluence.

Word,

from

to each of

kinds

same, the justice

of

production

sentence

the

use of

oroblem,

distribution

with to

words

Economic

process,

up each word differ Throuph,the

Word,

extreme

societies,

three

are constructed

production

justice

While

and classifying containing

the

connect

the

and comfort

word comprises

a just

systems.

either

The production in

values

words

under

justice,

capabilities.

or affluence,

Production

These three

He identifies

distributive

comfort,

sentence"

manner:

Word.

for

to comfort,

values

a "justice

into

to distributive

theory.

productive

as existing

subsistence

After structs

based on their

his

take justice.

optimization-efficiency,

as important

societies

stages:

to develop

equality,

and ability-skill)

minimum standard

the

liberty,

Bowie feels

and do not

5 the

(happiness,

are

and socialism.

restrictive

distributive

model

consid-

traditional

These approaches

for

6 values

Societies

justice.

essential

a language

5'chapters.

to the

values

using

classifies

too

into

the

justice, merit,

devoted

egalitarianism, are

work

and methodological

chapters

to distributive

approaches all

his

remarks

by three

and solutions

consideration

the

introductory

followed

utilitarianism,

that

Bowie divides

to the costs

in chapter

due to the

distribution

or burdens 1 that

author's of

of this

endeavor, fact

benefits

that

the

author

and does not

distribution,

his, conclusions

he does

apply

even to both

the

322

benefits tical

and the structure

burdens.

In addition,

and analysis

the work

necessary

lacks

the

to be considered

theore-

a major

work

in economics. Despite

its

stimulating

shortcomings,

Bowie's

material.

While

used as supplementary

reading

important prove

questions

very

economic

raised

useful

the

bution

toward

issues

and problems.

Michael Western

in

and urban book is well

much needed

T. Pledge Illinois University

designed

because

and the

in a course

development,

In general,

not

book offers of

a great

as a textbook,

deal it

could

the many interesting

insights

comparative

provided. economic

It

of be

and could

systems,

problems. written,

inter-disciplinary

stimulating, discussion

and a contriof major