- Email: [email protected]
Contents index to volume 13, 1990
INTERNATIONAL JOURNAL OF
LAW A N D PSYCHIATRY
Contents/Author Index Volume 13, 1990
Pergamon Press N e w York • O x f o r d • Beijing • F r a n k f u r t S~o P a u l o • S y d n e y • T o k y o • T o r o n t o
IN'rERNA'rION, t. JOURNALOF LAW
AND PSYCHIATRY
The Official Journal of The International Academy of L a w and Mental Health Editor-in-Chief David N. Weisstub Professor of Law and Psychiatry Institut Philippe Pinel de Montreal Universite de Montreal 10905 est Boul. Henri-Bourassa Montreal, Quebec HIC 1 H1 Canada
Editorial A d v i s o r y Board Paul S. Appelbaum Lionel Beliveau Bart DeSmit Leonard V. Kaplan Stephen J. Morse Vernon Quinsey Ronald Roesch Henry J. Steadman Laurence R. Tancredi Simon Verdun-Jones
Western European Editor Michael Zeegers Prof. of Forensic Psychiatry Leyden University Bertus Rimaweg 12 The Hague, The Netherlands
Research Associates Jeffrey Abrams Wendy Greenspoon
Eastern European Editor Stanislaw Dabrowski Director, Psychoneurological Institute AI. Sobieskiego 1/9 02-957 Warsaw, Poland
A I M S A N D SCOPE The International Journal of Law and Psychiatry is intended to provide a multidisciplinary forum for the exchange of ideas and information among professionals concerned with the interface of law and psychiatry. There is a growing awareness of the need for exploring the fundamental goals of both the legal and psychiatric systems and the social implications of their interaction. The journal seeks to enhance understanding and cooperation in the field through the varied approaches represented not only by law and psychiatry, but also by the social sciences and related disciplines. The Editors and Publisher wish to encourage a dialogue among the experts from different countries whose diverse legal cultures afford interesting and challenging alternatives to existing theories and practices. Priority will therefore be given to articles which are oriented to a comparative or international perspective. The journal will publish significant conceptual contributions on contemporary issues as well as serve in the rapid dissemination of important and relevant research findings. The International Journal of Law and Psychiatry is published quarterly in English; wherever possible, translated articles are accompanied by an abstract in the original language. The views expressed in this journal do not necessarily reflect those of the Editors.
Publishing and Advertising Offices: Pergamon Press, Inc., Maxwell House, Fairview Park, Elmsford, NY 10523 USA Pergamon Press plc, Headington Hill Hall, Oxford, OX3 0BW, England
Annual Subscription Rates 1990 Published Quarterly. Annual institutional subscription rate (1991): DM430.00; Two-year institutional subscription rate (1991/92): DM817.00. Professional subscription rate (1990): DM129.00. Prices are subject to change without notice. Notify 8 weeks in advance of address change with a copy of the subscription mailing label. Back Issues: Back issues of all previously published volumes, in both hard copy and on microform, are available direct from Pergamon Press offices. Ccq~n/r~ht Notice: it is s condition of publication that manuscripts submitted to this journal have not been published and will not be simultaneously submitted or published elsewhere. By submitting a manuscript, the authors agree that the copyright for the article is transferred to the publisher, if and when the article is accepted for publication. The copyright covers the e~clualve rights to reproduce and distdbuta the article, including reprints, phofographic reDroductions, microform or any o(her reproductions of similar nature and translations. No part of this publication may be reproduced, stored in a retrieval system or transmitted in any form or by any means, electronic, electrostatic, magnetic tape, mechanical, photocopying, recording or otherwise, without permission in writing from the copyright holder.
Photocopying information for users in the U.S.A.: The item-Fee Code for this publication indicates that authorization to photocopy items for internal or personal use is granted by the copyright holder for libraries and ofher users registered with the Copyright Clearance Center (CCC) Transactional Reporting Service provided the stated fee for copying beyond that permitted by Section 107 or 108 of the United States Copyright Law is paid. The appropriate remittance of $3.00 per copy per article is paid directly to the Copyright Clearance Center Inc., 27 Congress Street, Salem, MA 01970. The copyright OWner's consent does not extend to copying for general distribution, for promo(io~, for creating new works, or for resale. Specific written parmisaio~ must be obtained from the publisher for such copying. In case of doubt please contact your nearest Pergamon office. The Item Fee Code for this publication is 0160-2527/90$3,00 + .00
Copyright © 1990 Pergamon Press plc ~t*~
Printed in the USA
The paper used in this publication meets the minimum requirements of American National Standard for Information Sciences--Permanence of Paper for Printed Library Materials, ANSI Z39.48-1984
Contents Index to Volume 13, 1990
Volume 13, Numbers 1/2, 1990
CONTENTS Special Issue: Intoxication and Criminal Responsibility
Articles
Chet Mitchell
1
Intoxication, Criminality, and Responsibility
Roger A. Shiner
9
Intoxication and Responsibility
R. D. Mackay
37
The Taint Intoxication
Lawrence P. Tiffany Mary Tiffany
49
Nosologic Objections to the Criminal Defense of Pathological Intoxication: What do the Doubters Doubt?
Herbert Fingarette
77
Alcoholism: Can Honest Mistake About One's Capacity for Self Control be an Excuse?
Stanton Peele
95
Does Addiction Excuse Thieves and Killers from Criminal Responsibility?
Warren Lehman
103
Alcoholism, Freedom, and Moral Responsibility
Herbert Fingarette
123
Response to Lehman's Article "Alcoholism, Freedom and Moral Responsibility"
Mimi Ajzenstadt Brian E. Burtch
127
Medicalization and Regulation of Alcohol and Alcoholism: The Professions and Disciplinary Measures
Irmgard Vogt
149
Governing Images of Alcoholism in Germany, 1870-1920
Naftali Fish Emi Shufman ]:air Barel
155
Ethical and Legal Dilemmas of Jerusalem Treatment Model for Drug Addiction
389
CONTENTS/AUTHOR INDEX
390
Volume 13, Number 3, 1990
CONTENTS Articles
UriAviram
163
Care or Convenience? On the Medical-Bureaucratic Model of Commitment of the Mentally I!1
Keith Soothill Pisamai Kupituksa Dinesh Badiani Fiona Macmillan
179
Compulsory Admissions to Mental Hospitals: A Replication Study
Peter Gottlieb Gorm Gabrielsen
191
The Future of Homicide Offenders: Results from a Homicide Project in Copenhagen
Nathan L. Pollock
207
Accounting for Predictions of Dangerousness
Marnie E. Rice Grant T. Harris
217
The Predictors of Insanity Acquittal
Richard Rogers R. Michael Bagby Marnie Crouch Brian Cutler
225
Effects of Ultimate Opinions on Juror Perceptions of Insanity
G. Andrew H. Benjamin Elaine J. Darling Bruce Sales
233
The Prevalence of Depression, Alcohol Abuse, and Cocaine Abuse Among United States Lawyers
CONTENTS/AUTHOR INDEX
391
Volume 13, Number 4, 1990
CONTENTS Special Issue: Ethical Issues in Forensic Theory and Practice Articles
William J. Winslade
247
Introduction
Paul S. Appelbaum
269
The Parable of the Forensic Psychiatrist: Ethics and the Problem of Doing Harm
C. Robert Showalter
261
Psychiatric Participation in Capital Sentencing Procedures: Ethical Considerations
Stephen L. Golding
281
Mental Health Professionals and the Courts: The Ethics of Expertise
Loretta M. Kopelman
309
On the Evaluative Nature of Competency and Capacity Judgments
Robert Justin Lipkin
331
Free Will, Responsibility and the Promise of Forensic Psychiatry
Donald H. J. Hermann
361
Autonomy, Self Determination, the Right of Involuntarily Committed Persons to Refuse Treatment, and the Use of Substituted Judgment in Medication Decisions Involving Incompetent Persons
387
Contents/Author Index to Volume 13, 1990
LAW A N D PSYCHIATRY
Contents/Author Index Volume 13, 1990
Pergamon Press N e w York • O x f o r d • Beijing • F r a n k f u r t S~o P a u l o • S y d n e y • T o k y o • T o r o n t o
IN'rERNA'rION, t. JOURNALOF LAW
AND PSYCHIATRY
The Official Journal of The International Academy of L a w and Mental Health Editor-in-Chief David N. Weisstub Professor of Law and Psychiatry Institut Philippe Pinel de Montreal Universite de Montreal 10905 est Boul. Henri-Bourassa Montreal, Quebec HIC 1 H1 Canada
Editorial A d v i s o r y Board Paul S. Appelbaum Lionel Beliveau Bart DeSmit Leonard V. Kaplan Stephen J. Morse Vernon Quinsey Ronald Roesch Henry J. Steadman Laurence R. Tancredi Simon Verdun-Jones
Western European Editor Michael Zeegers Prof. of Forensic Psychiatry Leyden University Bertus Rimaweg 12 The Hague, The Netherlands
Research Associates Jeffrey Abrams Wendy Greenspoon
Eastern European Editor Stanislaw Dabrowski Director, Psychoneurological Institute AI. Sobieskiego 1/9 02-957 Warsaw, Poland
A I M S A N D SCOPE The International Journal of Law and Psychiatry is intended to provide a multidisciplinary forum for the exchange of ideas and information among professionals concerned with the interface of law and psychiatry. There is a growing awareness of the need for exploring the fundamental goals of both the legal and psychiatric systems and the social implications of their interaction. The journal seeks to enhance understanding and cooperation in the field through the varied approaches represented not only by law and psychiatry, but also by the social sciences and related disciplines. The Editors and Publisher wish to encourage a dialogue among the experts from different countries whose diverse legal cultures afford interesting and challenging alternatives to existing theories and practices. Priority will therefore be given to articles which are oriented to a comparative or international perspective. The journal will publish significant conceptual contributions on contemporary issues as well as serve in the rapid dissemination of important and relevant research findings. The International Journal of Law and Psychiatry is published quarterly in English; wherever possible, translated articles are accompanied by an abstract in the original language. The views expressed in this journal do not necessarily reflect those of the Editors.
Publishing and Advertising Offices: Pergamon Press, Inc., Maxwell House, Fairview Park, Elmsford, NY 10523 USA Pergamon Press plc, Headington Hill Hall, Oxford, OX3 0BW, England
Annual Subscription Rates 1990 Published Quarterly. Annual institutional subscription rate (1991): DM430.00; Two-year institutional subscription rate (1991/92): DM817.00. Professional subscription rate (1990): DM129.00. Prices are subject to change without notice. Notify 8 weeks in advance of address change with a copy of the subscription mailing label. Back Issues: Back issues of all previously published volumes, in both hard copy and on microform, are available direct from Pergamon Press offices. Ccq~n/r~ht Notice: it is s condition of publication that manuscripts submitted to this journal have not been published and will not be simultaneously submitted or published elsewhere. By submitting a manuscript, the authors agree that the copyright for the article is transferred to the publisher, if and when the article is accepted for publication. The copyright covers the e~clualve rights to reproduce and distdbuta the article, including reprints, phofographic reDroductions, microform or any o(her reproductions of similar nature and translations. No part of this publication may be reproduced, stored in a retrieval system or transmitted in any form or by any means, electronic, electrostatic, magnetic tape, mechanical, photocopying, recording or otherwise, without permission in writing from the copyright holder.
Photocopying information for users in the U.S.A.: The item-Fee Code for this publication indicates that authorization to photocopy items for internal or personal use is granted by the copyright holder for libraries and ofher users registered with the Copyright Clearance Center (CCC) Transactional Reporting Service provided the stated fee for copying beyond that permitted by Section 107 or 108 of the United States Copyright Law is paid. The appropriate remittance of $3.00 per copy per article is paid directly to the Copyright Clearance Center Inc., 27 Congress Street, Salem, MA 01970. The copyright OWner's consent does not extend to copying for general distribution, for promo(io~, for creating new works, or for resale. Specific written parmisaio~ must be obtained from the publisher for such copying. In case of doubt please contact your nearest Pergamon office. The Item Fee Code for this publication is 0160-2527/90$3,00 + .00
Copyright © 1990 Pergamon Press plc ~t*~
Printed in the USA
The paper used in this publication meets the minimum requirements of American National Standard for Information Sciences--Permanence of Paper for Printed Library Materials, ANSI Z39.48-1984
Contents Index to Volume 13, 1990
Volume 13, Numbers 1/2, 1990
CONTENTS Special Issue: Intoxication and Criminal Responsibility
Articles
Chet Mitchell
1
Intoxication, Criminality, and Responsibility
Roger A. Shiner
9
Intoxication and Responsibility
R. D. Mackay
37
The Taint Intoxication
Lawrence P. Tiffany Mary Tiffany
49
Nosologic Objections to the Criminal Defense of Pathological Intoxication: What do the Doubters Doubt?
Herbert Fingarette
77
Alcoholism: Can Honest Mistake About One's Capacity for Self Control be an Excuse?
Stanton Peele
95
Does Addiction Excuse Thieves and Killers from Criminal Responsibility?
Warren Lehman
103
Alcoholism, Freedom, and Moral Responsibility
Herbert Fingarette
123
Response to Lehman's Article "Alcoholism, Freedom and Moral Responsibility"
Mimi Ajzenstadt Brian E. Burtch
127
Medicalization and Regulation of Alcohol and Alcoholism: The Professions and Disciplinary Measures
Irmgard Vogt
149
Governing Images of Alcoholism in Germany, 1870-1920
Naftali Fish Emi Shufman ]:air Barel
155
Ethical and Legal Dilemmas of Jerusalem Treatment Model for Drug Addiction
389
CONTENTS/AUTHOR INDEX
390
Volume 13, Number 3, 1990
CONTENTS Articles
UriAviram
163
Care or Convenience? On the Medical-Bureaucratic Model of Commitment of the Mentally I!1
Keith Soothill Pisamai Kupituksa Dinesh Badiani Fiona Macmillan
179
Compulsory Admissions to Mental Hospitals: A Replication Study
Peter Gottlieb Gorm Gabrielsen
191
The Future of Homicide Offenders: Results from a Homicide Project in Copenhagen
Nathan L. Pollock
207
Accounting for Predictions of Dangerousness
Marnie E. Rice Grant T. Harris
217
The Predictors of Insanity Acquittal
Richard Rogers R. Michael Bagby Marnie Crouch Brian Cutler
225
Effects of Ultimate Opinions on Juror Perceptions of Insanity
G. Andrew H. Benjamin Elaine J. Darling Bruce Sales
233
The Prevalence of Depression, Alcohol Abuse, and Cocaine Abuse Among United States Lawyers
CONTENTS/AUTHOR INDEX
391
Volume 13, Number 4, 1990
CONTENTS Special Issue: Ethical Issues in Forensic Theory and Practice Articles
William J. Winslade
247
Introduction
Paul S. Appelbaum
269
The Parable of the Forensic Psychiatrist: Ethics and the Problem of Doing Harm
C. Robert Showalter
261
Psychiatric Participation in Capital Sentencing Procedures: Ethical Considerations
Stephen L. Golding
281
Mental Health Professionals and the Courts: The Ethics of Expertise
Loretta M. Kopelman
309
On the Evaluative Nature of Competency and Capacity Judgments
Robert Justin Lipkin
331
Free Will, Responsibility and the Promise of Forensic Psychiatry
Donald H. J. Hermann
361
Autonomy, Self Determination, the Right of Involuntarily Committed Persons to Refuse Treatment, and the Use of Substituted Judgment in Medication Decisions Involving Incompetent Persons
387
Contents/Author Index to Volume 13, 1990