89
Geoforum 19/74
CLARKE,
David L., ed. (1972):
Archaeology. London:
Models in
Methuen
vistas,
models to assist in the understanding matters
of
rural geographer
no fewer than 11 of
for his invested effort
for arresting classroom usage. As it is said
reading and thinking
about stereophonic
The adoption
sound systems that and taste,
methods
I. R. HODDER’s
the study of Romano-British
in geography
via the compendium and HAGGETT
Models in Geography
in 1967.
academic world concerned
assembled
Now the
with the study
of man’s past has been presented another,
monster-sized
volume
one can dip for information,
professional
“Settlement
has assembled the con-
of this well-produced
the pages
book, and the results
beckon one to look into any of the 26 chapters.
As an over-arching
field of contemporary compilation
as there are authors,
must always remember additional presented
such a
will provide almost as many
viewpoints
and one
that there are many
persuasions which are not rewithin
its pages. The editor has
taken upon himself the demanding doubt enjoyable
task of providing
mary statement
which is offered
chapter entitled contemporary
“Models
archaeology”
revolution explored
“The methodological rary archaeology:
in his in
The impact of
by f. N. HILL
in
For the
struggle within
these two
that discipline
know so well in our
own. When taken in context series of thoughtful Antiquity,
in the
one can come to a re-
asonably full appreciation developmental
with a current
essays appearing
of the notable
stresses and strains within a
sister discipline.
The rest of the chapters within are concerned archaeology
as illustrated
persuasion or by example hypothesis
this volume
with the usage of models in -
formulation,
-
by logic of to improve
research design,
ecological systems understanding, clarifications
typological
and analysis of excavation
results. The examples
a discipline
with although contact
used and the literature
Wirtschafts-
178 pp., 5 figs., 24 tables.
Arbeiten.
Friedrich-Alexander-Universitlt.
a
and of studies”.
of viewpoints
of the state, Aristotle
is reported
listed the weaver, the farmer, of economic
as well as the outsider
the constructor
Early writers on the location
activity,
E. M. HOOVER,
such as A. WEBER
used the leather
field.
and
industry
for their case studies. KLEEKAMPER
was
born into this classic branch of economic geography,
being a leather mer-
his father
chant. The best part of the book is the second half where among other things the author discusses the world market materials
from a technical
for leather raw point of view.
and Cattle
such as this volume cultivating
familiarity
one is himself not in daily
with the field of archaeology.
parallels of “new thought”
reflected
R. P. CHANEY
inquiry
“Scientific
models of sociosultural an epilogue”
The
attempting
and horses and pigs
each some 4 percent.
Raw hides are always
when animals are slaughtered. other things being
equal, provide the best hides. Slaughtering
to keep abreast of the con-
made by geographers to a sister can instill a sense of pride in what
our discipline
sheep
and goats 20 percent,
Large slaughterhou~s,
and
strike a resonant chord within
the geographer
more than two thirds of the
of the leather industry,
a by-product
in
data patterning:
of his own field. A recognition
provide
raw material
has been able to offer others,
is
here being done by experts who are under instructions
to handle the hide in a way that
is most profitable
to the company.
But the
value of the hide may have been lowered many other reasons even before slaughterhouse.
for
it enters the
Brands, insects, barbed wire,
and at the same time a type of reassurance
and other causes may be listed. The hump of
can arise out of a realization
the zebu cattle lowers the value of a hide
that parallel
occuring within
the preserve of a closely-
related field which also emphasizes In the words of Editor
regarding disciplinary uncomfortable
change is directionless
is an
and that the changes progress
are little
more than a succession of contemporary mythologies.
for histological
reasons would
have been of good quality.
human
change, “There
more exact knowledge
that otherwise
CLARKE
suspicion that much of this
we may wish to see as cumulative towards
are
If there is some justice in this
The survey of the distribution the world,
of animals in
mostly verbal and with some
simple maps, is less impressive. formation
sources, such as the Oxford of the World. The statement industry
Better
of Australia
Economic
is limited
to the coastal
areas of the east and the southeast
explicit
in point. Oxford
and testing of archaeo-
Atlas
that the cattle
view, then the cause is clear - only the construction
in-
can be had from easily available
is a case
shows a cattle distribution
logical models can provide the progressive
that makes sense of the large postwar
cycle by means of which fresh information
ments in cattle roads in the vast interior
is gained, theory
the north; KLEEKAMPER
cumulative
is accumulated
knowledge
within
and the
the discipline
thought
of the location
slaughterhouses.
of the Australian
make us suspicious of some economic
ing, academic
in the interior.
understand
our own of geography
have the wit to interpret offered us.
if we
In the north
M. NEWCOMB,
be cattle raising.
the reflections
Aarhus
G. ALEXANDERSSON,
activity
this turns out to
that Robert
of
The long rail lines should
expanded”. A mirroring of this search for constructive development within an adjoinfield may help us better to
invest-
may just have
an insight into curwork within
pillars
to have
cited in passing can give the archaeologist rent, non-traditional
13 of
und Sozialgeogr.
focused upon a growing edge
geography.
can set the scene regarding
which we geographers
within
England:
models“
searches for new concepts and methods
debate in contempogeographer,
An accessible collection examples
tributions discipline
and of the “new
a model”,
archaeology-orients contributions
journal
a sum-
upon the existing field of
study is further
the parallel
and no
and paradigms
archaeology”.
the quantitative
and J. HARRISS
in medieval
represents is well worth
view of the
archaeology,
model
type emerges from
study based on locational
of 28 colleagues within
Niirnberger
and the tanner.
and land use in the prehistory
E. M. JOPE “Models
tributions
models and settlement”,
and early history of southern
stimulation
der Welt mit Leder. Vol.
When asked about the most important
in
“A territorial
a reading of A. ELLlSON
with
into which
and refreshment. David CLARKE
geographical
“Locational
or in M. R. JARMAN’s
profitable,
und der
Versorgung
Niirnberg:
for archaeology: a behavioural and geographical approach”. Cross-fertilization of a
in their
Hauteund
ihrer Eneugung
in
for spatial analysis is evident
devices received relatively
early publicity
Heinz (1970):
Felle. Grundlagen
about their contents.
of recognized
so can it also be said about models. These
by CHORLEY
In the estima
the 26 chapters will repay the historical,
and models suitable
there is one for every pocketbook
in search of
borrowings?
tion of this reviewer,
KLEEKAMPER,
interest to the geo-
to the practitioner
interdisciplinary
in models
designed to provide comprehensive complicated
what is there in this collection
grapher,
& Co. Ltd. f 16,-.
One finds himself awash today
However,
which is of more direct
1055 pp. thus, Index.
Stockholm